Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Benitez Full Blown Research Final
Benitez Full Blown Research Final
Department of Education
Region X
Division of Bukidnon
Don Carlos District III
OLD NONGNONGAN NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
SCHOOL ID: 303977
Proponent:
ROSEMARIE P. BENITEZ
Teacher -Researcher
2020-2021
2
Table of Contents
Page
I. Title Page 1
II. Abstract 3
Acknowledgment 4
III. Introduction
Reading Comprehension 7
IV. Methodology
c. Data Analysis 14
a. Summary of Findings 20
b. Conclusion 21
VII. References 22
Appendices
3
Abstract
The data showed from the posttest in PHIL-IRI Assessment conducted after
completing the weeks of the implementation of the Peer-Assisted Learning Strategy
(PALS) that the identified students who were in frustration reading level were able to
improve their reading comprehension to instructional and independent level.
Specifically, among the forty-six (46) student-participants, twenty-seven (27)
improved from frustration to instructional reading level, and nineteen (19)improved
from frustration to independent reading level. Therefore, the results of this study
attest that the Peer-Assisted Learning Strategy (PALS) was an effective intervention
in improving the reading comprehension skills in this group of students.
This result was supported by Fuchs, et al. (2000) statement that Peer-Assisted
Learning Strategies are potent methods of helping students comprehend reading and
strengthen other related skills. Reading can be learned even more quickly and
effectively with peer-assisted learning strategies, and students tend to enjoy these
interactive learning strategies. Moreover, Saenz et al. (2005) confirmed that Peer-
Assisted Learning Strategy had shown to improve academic achievement for the
recipient and the tutor. Teaching a concept or subject allows the tutor to gain a better
understanding of the subject as well while explaining it. A deep level of
comprehension is required to teach, and peer teachers will also develop excellent
communication and leadership skills.
Keywords: peer-assisted learning strategy, reading comprehension,
4
Acknowledgment
The author would like to take this opportunity to express her gratitude to
those people who shared their time and effort to make this action research possible.
encouragement and for believing that this research will be made possible.
To the parents of Junior High School Students, for this School S.Y. 2020-
To her family who gave love, moral, financial, spiritual support, and
inspiration.
Above all, to our Almighty God the creator of everything who has given her
INTRODUCTION
when they begin school. They learn the alphabet. They learn words. They string
these words together so that they can learn how to understand sentences and
paragraphs. Reading comprehension skills will help the child not only in English
class but in all areas of academic study. They translate into real-world abilities and
critical thinking, which are valuable skills a child needs to be successful in both
enables everyone to acquire knowledge and become a better person in some ways.
healthful way to attain when someone feels unhealthy because many believe reading
Some of the writers disclose the truth about reading. According to them, it
is necessary to ones' life because it will bring readers to the place where they could
not go or impossible for them to be there. The imagination built in the reader's mind
when reading will open up more opportunities for them to explore and find ways to
make sure what they built within them will become possible.
6
was often heard in school. The primary grade teachers always inculcate such skills to
child can read. It is an activity that a reader will demonstrate the meaning of what he
reads. It is the revelation of how they understand the text they are reading.
This would only happen when good adult readers think aloud as they read.
conscious processes before, during, and after reading (Pressley & Afflerbach, 1995).
Raising good readers is the ultimate goal of every teacher in their class.
However, this endeavor often gives the teachers difficulty because most of the
comprehension. This problem may not only be experienced by the students at the
primary level but even at the secondary level. In fact, some Junior High School
The researcher believes that English teachers play a vital role in improving
students’ comprehension skills. Thus, this action research was conducted to find
reading comprehension needs. This could be the best way to assist these students to
The words openly mentioned had great bearing in understanding the concept therein.
Reading Comprehension
track of what words are in the sentences (working memory), vocabulary meaning
(receptive language) (Berninger & Richards, 2002; Cutting, Materek, Cole, Levine,
& Mahone, 2009). It is the ability of readers to get meaning from the text being read.
This can be done by asking good readers to think aloud as they read. Researchers
processes before, during, and after reading (Pressley & Afflerbach, 1995).
Good readers are aware of how their reading is going and why. They know,
for example, when a text is difficult to read because it contains many new ideas or
when it is difficult to read because it is poorly written. They are adept at using their
prior knowledge as they read to make predictions about what might happen next and
to understand ideas as they encounter them (Paris, Wasik, & Turner, 1991).
2002) as they prepare to read, as they read, and after they read. Research has
clarifying, asking questions and finding answers, visualizing or imaging, and making
8
Reading Panel, 2000; Gambrell and Bales, 1986; Hansen & Pearson, 1983).
identify issues when comprehension breaks down. They are meta-cognitively aware
or in control of their own thinking throughout their reading. Luke (2006) compares
– all the parts of a project. When the project is moving along smoothly, there is no
need for intervention. Depending upon the problem, the foreman may need to stop
the project to take some action. In like manner, this is exactly what proficient readers
do. When reading comprehension is moving along smoothly, skilled readers do not
need to stop. However, when reading challenging or complex text, these same
like unfamiliar words or confusing referents, or inconsistent ideas, and use strategies
to clarify and resolve the problems. They usually use strategies that include
understanding.
Novice and struggling readers seem to lack awareness of thinking about what
is and is not making sense as they read. They are often unaware of when they do not
understand what they are reading. This is painfully evident when a struggling reader
turns two pages instead of one and continues on the wrong page even though it does
not make sense. They often are focused so much on reading the words that they
cannot think about how the words connect to create meaning. Good readers, on the
other hand, are aware of when their comprehension breaks down or if they are
confused by the text and have "fix-up" strategies to resolve their problems.
9
people use in order to achieve a goal (Roit, 2005) and are used deliberately to make
sense of the text (Afflerbach et al., 2008). Readers use strategies consciously to make
sense of the text, remember critical ideas, and integrate new learning into an existing
independently, recognize and solve problems, and delve deeper into the text to make
Reading strategies are not the same as instructional strategies. The goal of
Instructional strategies are the plans used by the teacher to teach comprehension.
They include but are not limited to explicit explanation, modeling, pre-teaching,
instructional strategies.
Often the terms comprehension strategies, skills, and activities are used
monitor and to check understanding, clarify confusion, and process text. Strategies
are situational and are used intentionally by readers. (McEwan, 2004). In contrast,
once skills are learned, they are used unconsciously, i.e., decoding words or breaking
words into syllables. Skills are also the tools readers use to organize the structure of
a text, e.g., main idea and supporting details, compare and contrast, and sequencing.
Activities such as charts like KWL (McEwan, 2004) or terms such as "click and
10
clunk" and "get the gist" is not comprehension strategies themselves but instructional
program. Teachers strategically pair a student with a peer. The pair works on various
activities that address the academic needs of both students. Pairs change over time.
PALS can be used across content areas. PALS does not require special reading
materials and consequently enables teachers to use the reading material of their
choice. This offers teachers flexibility for incorporating PALS into various content
areas.
class, observe students, and offer individual remediation. PALS, therefore, allows for
teacher-directed activities.
the year level by identifying which children require help on specific skills and the
most appropriate children to help other children learn those skills. Each member of
Teachers train students to use the PALS procedures. As the reader reads
aloud, the coach listens and provides corrective feedback. The PALS technique is
for effectiveness. Award may be given to students by giving additional points for
11
good reading and coaching. Peer-assisted learning, including peer tutoring, has many
benefits for all involved — the tutor, the recipient, and the teacher. According to
Saenz et. Al. (2005), Peer- Assisted Learning Strategy (PALS) has been shown to
improve academic achievement not only for the recipient but also for the tutor as
well. Teaching a concept or subject allows the tutor to gain a better understanding of
the subject as well while explaining it. A deep level of comprehension is required to
be able to teach, and tutors will also develop excellent communication and
leadership skills.
are a powerful method of helping students comprehend reading and take it to the
next level. These are just some of the elements and strategies that can be employed
in the classroom to make peer-assisted learning successful and fun. Reading can be
learned even more quickly and effectively with peer-assisted learning strategies, and
Since this school year was affected by the pandemic, and no student is
Learning Strategies (PALS) using an individual tool. Students nowadays have their
gadgets for communication and learning. The identified students with reading
comprehension challenges were paired by the independent reader. Both had given
the scheduled time for the reading activity. They will be provided with the reading
materials while the independent reader will stand as the tutor. They can maximize
their time using video calls while doing the reading activity. Further, attached to the
reading material received by the tutor is the instruction on how they could enhance
12
the reading activity, which the researcher believed will enhance the comprehension
skills.
2. How can Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies (PALS) help improve the reading
METHODOLOGY
Forty-six (46) grade eight students of Old Nongnongan National High School, Don
Carlos District III, for the School Year 2020-2021 belong to frustration level.
The data was gathered through the conduct of the assessment in pretest using
the PHIL-IRI Assessment Tool to establish the baseline data. Pretest was
administered among the 148 grade eight students, 46 of these students were in
frustration level, 53 in instructional level, and 49 were independent level. For the
first two weeks, was the conduct of pre-assessment, the orientation of participants in
PALS, teaching how to become acclimated to the roles of tutor and tutee, and they
were given sample scenarios to practice the roles. Subsequently, the participants
frustration level were paired with the independent level student and were assigned to
nine groups. Groups A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H had five pairs, and Group I had six
14
pairs. The participants were then given PALS reading activities such as Prediction
Relay, Partner Reading and Retell, and Paragraph Shrinking (IRIS | Page 3: PALS
Activities, 2021). The activities were done by pair. During Prediction Relay, the
reader has given time to finish to determine what he or she will learn. In Partner
Reading and Retell, the independent reader function as a coach by finding mistakes,
performing corrective methods, and giving scores for sentences read properly. The
participants would discuss what they had learned from the reading materials.
Paragraph Shrinking allowed participants to read one reading material at a time and
articulate the main idea statement. The researcher monitored each group alternately.
After the six weeks of PALS had been conducted, the post-assessment will still be
Analysis of Data
researcher used the percentage score of the pretest and posttest results.
15
This chapter discloses the result of the study and its respective discussion,
which would give a clear view of the benefits of the activities being conducted.
The table below presents the result of the PHIL-IRI pretest conducted to the
study participants, reflecting that 46 or 31% out of 148 students are in frustration
reading level.
52
50
48
53
46
49
44 46
42
Independent Instructional Frustration
16
The data in table 1 showed the Phil IRI Pretest results conducted last January
2021 to one hundred forty-eight (148) Grade 8 Junior High School students in
which forty-six (46)or 31% of them belong to frustration reading level, fifty-three
(53) or 36% of them belong to instructional level, and forty-nine (49) or 33% of the
students belong to independent reading level. After identifying their reading level,
Since the pandemic controls the situation and hinders the face-to-face classes,
the researcher maximizes resources for the following needs of student participants:
regular learning module and were retrieved by the advisers in their respective
classes.
prohibited, the researcher ensured that all student-participants had the gadgets
to be utilized for the purpose of the intervention. The researcher source out
mobile phone donations for the class and to be utilized by the participants
School Students had their different schedules for monitoring. As they were
paired with their peer, in this strategy, they (paired) had the same time, and
17
during the monitoring, the researcher utilized video calling. Each pair was
participants had important matter to attend to with regards to their learning modules
2. How can Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies (PALS) help improve the reading
Based on the result of the conduct of the intervention, the Peer-Assisted Learning
Strategies (PALS) help improve the reading level of the students by consistently
doing their reading tasks with their peers. This was proven by a study that when
18
students were able to develop self-confidence and reliance on their peers, they would
positively do their tasks. Since the participants were paired with their
the participants were catered according to their pace and willingness to do their
tasks. When students were not pressured to do something, they would have a
productive result.
weight to the accomplishment of their daily tasks and that was given a reward such
as an exemption for such learning area, or in such skills development. The result of
the post-assessment would attest to the effectiveness of the intervention or the Peer-
Development Theory, social interaction is crucial in the learning process that can be
Table 2 viewed the result of the posttest PHIL-IRI assessment after the conduct
Pretest Posttest
The data above showed the result of the posttest of PHIL-IRI Assessment
Learning Strategy (PALS). It was then reflected that 100% of the identified pupils
who are in the frustration reading level improved to instructional and to independent
reading level.
Among the forty-six (46) Junior High School students, (27) improved their
reading level from frustration to instructional reading level, and nineteen (19)
improved from frustration to independent reading level. The results imply that the
This result was supported by the statement of Fuchs et al. (2000). Peer-
comprehend reading and take it to the next level. These are just some of the elements
and strategies that can be employed in the classroom to make peer-assisted learning
20
successful and fun. Reading can be learned even more quickly and effectively with
peer-assisted learning strategies, and children tend to enjoy these interactive learning
strategies.
The researcher Saenz et. al. (2005) seconded the statement above that, Peer-
Assisted Learning Strategy has been shown to improve academic achievement not
only for the recipient but also for the tutor as well. Teaching a concept or subject
allows the tutor to gain a better understanding of the subject as well while explaining
it. A deep level of comprehension is required to be able to teach, and peer teachers
Summary of Findings
The result of the study clearly views that the intervention used was effective
in improving the reading comprehension skills of the students. It has been revealed
that during the Pretest PHIL- IRI assessment, 46 student-participants were on the
frustration reading level. The conduct of the Peer-Assisted Learning Strategy was
done. After the completion of the time frame and based on the PHIL-IRI Posttest
Assessment, all forty-six (46) student-participants were able to improve their reading
21
Conclusions
students. The positive result of the study was an indicator that they were able to
acquire the desired outcome. The implementation of the strategy and the proper
thereof. This result was supported by the statement of Wessel (2019), students can
develop practical skills in how to educate and give constructive criticism when they
participate in peer tutoring. Students learn how to engage in learning that is not
entirely teacher-led, and they are able to participate more fully in the discussion.
Furthermore, PALS can enable the development of children's innate abilities. Their
Students can bring in elements of their background and ideas when they are put into
groups where they can discuss freely, potentially leading to increased cooperation
among the members of the group. As a result, students learn how to deal with a
group of people with whom they may not normally work, and they can converse
the school and would be adopted in the school as one of their effective
2. there will be a school orientation on the conduct of the strategy for better
be done; and
References
Allington, R.L. (2013). What Really Matters when Working with Struggling
Baker, S., Lesaux, N., Jayanthi, M., Dimino, J., Protcor, C.P., Morris, J., Gersten, R.,
Balfe, T. (2008). Using the structured whole word reading programme Edmark to
help
Bear, D.R, Invernizzi, M., Templeton, S. and Johnton, F. (2008). Words their Way:
Bruner, Jerome (19990. In Eric Margolis & Stephen Laurence (eds.), Concepts: Core
Butler, A.C. (2010). Repeated testing produces superior transfer of learning relative
to
10.1037/a0019902.supp.
Callender, A.A., & McDaniel, M.A. (2009). The limited benefits of rereading
doi:10.1016/j. cedpsych.2008.07.001.
Fuchs, D., Fuchs, L. S., Mathes, P. G., & Simmons, D. C. (1997). Peer-Assisted
https://doi.org/10.2307/1163346
https://iris.peabody.vanderbilt.edu/module/palshs/cresource/q2/p03/
Karpicke, J., & Roediger, H. (2007). Repeated retrieval during learning is the key to
Scholar
25
Learning”.
Sáenz, L. M., Fuchs, L. S., & Fuchs, D. (2005). Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies
Schwartz, D. L., Varma, S., & Martin, L. W. (2008). Dynamic transfer and
innovation.
Thorne, Glenda (2018). How to Increase Higher Order Thinking · Higher Order
Wessel, A. (2015). Peer Learning Strategies in the Classroom. The Journal on Best
Teaching Practices.
http://teachingonpurpose.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Wessel-A.-2015.-
Peer-Learning-Strategies-in-the-Classroom.pdf
A. Research Information
Research Title:
Description:
Action Research to be conducted is to Improve the Reading Comprehension Using
the Peer Assisted Learning Strategy (PALS) of the Grade 8 Junior High School
Students of Old Nongnongan National High School
School o Governance
(Check only one) (Check up to one cross-cutting theme, if
applicable)
Action Research
o Basic Research o DRRM
o Gender and Development
o Inclusive Education
o Others (specify)
_______________
Fund Source (e.g. BERF, SEF, Personal
Others)
B. Proponent Information
LEAD PROPONENT
FEMALE
AUGUST 25, 1978 TEACHER
Signature of Proponent:
BSE NONE
I hereby endorse the attached completed Action Research. I certify that the
proponent implemented this research study without compromising her office
functions.
2. I hereby attest to the originality of this research proposal and has cited properly
all the references used. I further commit that all deliverables and the final research
study emanating from this proposal shall be of original content. We shall use
appropriate citations in referencing other works from various sources.
3. I understand that violation from this declaration and commitment shall be subject
to consequences and shall be dealt with accordingly by the Department of
Education.
2. I hereby declare that I do not have any personal conflict of interest that may arise
from my application and submission of my research proposal. I understand that
my research proposal may be returned to me if found out that there is a conflict of
interest during initial screening.
3. Further, in case of any form of conflict of interest (possible or actual) which may
inadvertently emerge during conduct of our research, I will duly report it to the
research committee for immediate action.
TIME LINE
Activities Person(s) Time Frame
Involve JANUARY 2021 FEBRUARY 2021 MARCH
2021
31
Financial Report
Total 5,080.00