Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4996-Article Text-115609-1-10-20230726
4996-Article Text-115609-1-10-20230726
ABSTRACT
Objective. As part of the evaluation of control programs recommended by WHO, this study describes the local
implementation of schistosomiasis (SCH) and soil-transmitted helminthiasis (STH) morbidity control as well as
water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions post calamity. It likewise determines the challenges, areas for
improvement, and good practices in SCH and STH morbidity control strategies in Haiyan-stricken areas in Eastern
and Western Samar, the Philippines.
Methods. Twenty key informant interviews and eight focus group discussions documented the implementation of
SCH and STH control strategies in Eastern Visayas. Data analysis was done manually by a multi-disciplinary team.
Results. Mass drug administration (MDA) in schools and communities was conducted for morbidity control. MDA
for STH for pre-school-age children was integrated into the Garantisadong Pambata program, while a school-
based teacher-assisted approach was used for school-age children. WASH facilities, such as sanitary toilets, were
constructed through the initiatives of the local government units (LGUs) and other private sectors. Partnerships with
Plan International Philippines helped in the implementation of WASH through the conduct of Community-led Total
Sanitation. Health advocacies helped instill behavioral change in the community. SCH surveillance was conducted
annually while STH surveillance was irregularly implemented. Data on MDA coverage were validated through Rapid
Coverage Assessment before final reporting. Discrepancies were observed due to typographical errors and the
inclusion of teachers and transient migrants in the reports submitted. Challenges in the implementation of MDA
include delays in drug delivery, lack of human resources, non-compliance of participants, and drug unpalatability.
Challenges in WASH included the lack of hand washing facilities, inaccessibility to safe water, as well as non-utility of
sanitary toilets. Strengthening health advocacy and education may help address these challenges.
Corresponding author: Mary Ann J. Ladia, PhD Keywords: schistosomiasis, soil-transmitted helminthiasis,
Institute of Clinical Epidemiology Haiyan, Philippines
National Institutes of Health
University of the Philippines Manila
Room 103 Paz Mendoza Building
547 Pedro Gil Street, Ermita, Manila 1000, Philippines
Email: mjladia1@up.edu.ph
ORCiD: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4757-8072
In general, the extent and nature of the analysis ultimately In partnership with the LGUs, Plan International
depended on the goals of the study. Topics for analysis were Philippines was conducting CLTS activities in their covered
generally dictated by those included in the guide questions. areas. The importance of having and using a toilet and its
Analysis was broken down into more manageable subsets of impact on the health of the community was advocated.
topics such as the local implementation and monitoring of LGUs in Oras provide low-cost construction materials for
SCH and STH control as well as the challenges, areas for toilets and septic tanks to lessen the financial burden on the
improvement, and good practices without being selective in household owners. In addition, orientation on hygiene, proper
the use of data from different sources. Rather, all categories hand washing, and proper use of toilets were also conducted
of opinions were taken into account. Lastly, quotes from by rural sanitary inspectors (RSIs) in barangays and schools.
interviewees were included to emphasize an important An unannounced quarterly evaluation of toilets and
point of view. water was conducted and the top 10 barangays were awarded
monetary compensations. Lastly, local chief executives
Ethical Considerations provided support to these programs and advocate for the
The study protocol was reviewed and approved by the achievement of ZOD status.
University of the Philippines Manila Research Ethics Board
(UPMREB-2017-088-01). Individual informed consent was Local implementation of SCH and STH control in
obtained before the conduct of KIIs and FGDs. Western Samar
Local health workers from the DOH and RHU
RESULTS administered PZQ in schools. Social mobilization conducted
by teachers was highlighted:
Local implementation of SCH and STH control “If the parents have not anticipated the dewor-
ming activity (through social mobilization), they
Local implementation of SCH and STH control in usually don’t let their children take the medication.
Eastern Samar The children don’t usually take the medicine… we have
Only known SCH-endemic barangays were provided good deworming in school because the children trust
with PZQ. The rural health unit (RHU) staff visited schools the teachers. However, in the community, the children
to administer PZQ to SAC depending on their weight. don’t trust the health workers that give the medicine,
A master list of students with their respective weights so the social mobilization is very vital.”
and corresponding PZQ dose was prepared by the public – Infectious Disease Cluster Head, DOH-EVCHD
health nurse before the scheduled MDA, making drug
administration easier. For PSAC, selective treatment was Health workers from the RHU and school nurses
provided for SCH diagnosed only. brought and administered the anthelmintics. In Daram, the
For purposes of health education, RHU staff distributed purok system was utilized wherein each BHW handles 50 or
flyers about SCH. According to parents, flyers were their fewer households. BHWs, oriented by the nurses or RHMs,
primary source of information. Neither seminars nor distributed anthelmintics and ensured that the members of
orientations have been conducted. There were still parents her purok will receive PZQ.
who refuse to deworm their children. Furthermore, some Parents were well aware of the advantages of deworming
children do not take PZQ because of the tablet’s big size for their children and supported the GP program in their
and bitter taste, and parents did not force them to do so. community. They agreed with a CDC-based MDA scheme.
According to the key informants, MDA for STH in RHMs of Gandara agreed that CDWs can assist in the
PSAC was conducted by RHU staff twice a year as part of administration of anthelmintics to PSAC. The MHO and
the Garantisadong Pambata (GP) program. The schedule of some RHMs in Daram expressed doubts about the implemen-
MDA in SAC has been harmonized with the implementation tation of CDC-based MDA due to the low enrolment rate
of National School-based Deworming Month every January in CDCs which could lessen the coverage.
and July. The Municipal Social Welfare and Development The LGU’s main WASH intervention was the provision
Officer of Oras claimed that RHU staff was already of toilets as well as the construction of a water system. It
conducting deworming in some CDCs, assisted by child provided materials for toilet construction and low-cost septic
development workers (CDWs) before the start of classes, tanks while Plan International Philippines provided support
while others were asked to go to the barangay health centers. for the construction of tap stands and water tanks. The LGU
SAC parents preferred the conduct of MDA in schools. prioritized the barangay with low sanitary toilet coverage but
Health workers from the RHU and school nurses, trained with a strong commitment to the utilization and maintenance
by the DOH, administer anthelmintics. For absentee of the sanitary facility. Another WASH intervention was
children, the school nurses administered it when they the conduct of CLTS activities in selected barangays. Plan
report. Teachers’ role was focused on MDA advocacy and International Philippines staff together with the LGU
dissemination of information to both students and parents. provided information on the importance of ownership and
utilization of a toilet, as well as usage’s effects on community so. Moreover, according to some teachers including parents,
health. Orientations on good hygiene, proper hand washing, the deworming drugs provided by the government were
and proper use of toilets were likewise conducted by RSIs. ineffective and caused side effects. Parents who can afford
preferred to buy commercially available anthelmintics.
Monitoring and evaluation of SCH and STH control Teachers said that some parents initially refused, but were
implementation in Eastern and Western Samar later convinced to submit their children for deworming after
For monitoring and evaluation, a focal survey was receiving an orientation.
conducted yearly for SCH while surveillance for STH was Teachers were involved when the school nurse could
irregularly implemented. Data on deworming coverage not attend to all schools. In such cases, the school nurse
submitted by provincial coordinators from the PHO to brought deworming drugs and oriented the teachers on how
DOH were validated through Rapid Coverage Assessment to administer anthelmintics to the children. Some teachers
before final reporting. The DOH-EVCHD IHCP/SCEP did not participate for fear that pupils might suffer from
Coordinator mentioned discrepancies between reported and adverse events, while other teachers refused to cooperate
validated data due to typographical errors and the inclusion during MDA without the presence of a physician even if a
of teachers as well as transient migrants in the reports nurse was present.
submitted by RHUs and/or schools. “We encountered problems in a certain school. We
pity the nurse. Nurses stated that teachers refused to
Challenges, areas for improvement, and good deworm the children. The nurse seemed insulted because
practices in the implementation of SCH and STH of additional conditions. They were requesting for their
control in Eastern and Western Samar own physician.”
Challenges in the implementation of SCH and STH – Medical Officer, DepEd
control strategies included prioritization as well as conflicts
in schedule with other programs of DOH together with Areas for improvement included the provision of
LGUs. As suggested by DepEd Medical Officer, programs additional anthelmintics as a backup supply for walk-in
should be based on children’s needs thus making the program untreated patients. Intensified social mobilization combined
successful and sustainable. The delay in supply of PZQ and with health promotion and education is needed to increase
lack of human resources slackens program implementation participation as well as an understanding of the community
compromising MDA coverage. Deworming services to far- on deworming. Regular monitoring of infection rates
flung communities likewise required additional time and may be done by DOH to track the outcomes of the mass
transportation expenses as described below: treatment. Training of local chief executives together with
“…drug supplies don't arrive on time, so people the MHOs on health governance through the Municipal
don't start the deworming on time as well… schedules Leadership Governance Program, provided an in-depth
for the deworming are within a month and it's understanding of the health problems and intervention
allocated by the respective LGUs, so, we at the technical programs to address the situation.
services don't have any control… But even the other According to the key informants, good practices included
LGUs don't do it within the prescribed month because the conduct of training or capacity building for local health
of some local factors. For example, if they have far- workers although priority is given to those assigned in
flung barangays… they have to ask funding from the known SCH-endemic areas. Health workers deployed by
LGU, and sometimes the LGU doesn't grant it on time, the DOH provided valuable support in the promotion and
so that's a delaying factor as well… There are even implementation of deworming, however, not all local health
times when the local health workers have to abandon workers were well-trained, especially the new graduates.
(deworming)… because they don't have their travel Barangays also had different initiatives, such as feeding
expenses covered by the local municipalities… some of before the administration of anthelmintics. Some barangay
the far-flung barangays may be about 3, 4, 5 hours away captains demonstrated the safety of deworming by taking the
from where the RHUs are located… that's probably anthelminthic themselves. Community participation, such as
around PhP4,000 to PhP5,000 [transportation cost] those of parents and BHWs, was also beneficial. High MDA
which the health worker cannot actually shoulder and coverage for SCH was awarded a monetary prize by DOH.
they're not actually expected to shoulder it anyway.” Challenges in WASH included the lack of hand washing
– Technical Services Division Head of PHO facilities, access to safe water in CDCs and schools, as well as
non-functional sanitary facilities. For example, in Vallesbello
Some parents refused due to fear of “worms passing out ES, toilets and sinks were provided in every classroom.
of the mouth, nose, or ears of the child,” and other adverse However, the pupils did not use them due to lack of water.
events such as abdominal pain. As mentioned earlier, some The pupils needed to fetch water and brought it to the facility.
children did not take PZQ because of the tablet’s big size Even with the availability of toilets, some HH owners
as well as bitter taste, and parents did not force them to do still did not utilize them because they were made of plastic.
In some cases, the people did not build their own toilet deworming contributed to continuing challenges. Deworming
facilities because they did not own the land where their alone, however, will not break the transmission of SCH and
houses were built. In Llorente, only five out of 33 barangays STH. Transmission is dependent on ending OD through
had been declared ZOD status. In Oras, 14 out of the 42 improving access to WASH in endemic communities.6,7 The
barangays had ZOD status. OD could still be observed in WHO and DOH-IHCP recommend complementing PC
some barangays situated near rivers. There were people who, with improvements in WASH as well as health promotion
despite being provided with sanitary toilets, still practiced and education.8,9,17, 18 Poor WASH conditions may contribute
OD, including elders who had been doing it for a long time. to STH reinfection due to continuous exposure. Reinfection,
LGUs also provided water disinfectants, however, some which occurs rapidly for Ascaris and Trichuris infections,
residents rejected them as they caused them abdominal pain. may contribute to high STH infection prevalence despite
They preferred boiling the water before consumption. high MDA coverage.19 People with safe water and adequate
In Daram, only one out of 58 barangays had been sanitation had significantly lower odds of having SCH.20
declared ZOD status with two having a status of near ZOD. Improvements in sanitation by increasing access to sanitary
In Gandara, no barangay had been declared ZOD status. toilets and safe water as well as efforts toward influencing
Informants unanimously agreed that OD can still be observed health behaviors including proper personal hygiene can
in some barangays; in Daram, especially those living near the address most, if not all, these helminths altogether.21
coasts of the island. In this regard, access to WASH facilities and targeted
The lack of human resources for WASH activities environmental management have to be strengthened
resulted in difficulties in the delivery of materials and especially after a typhoon. WASH interventions in Eastern
monitoring of all barangays. RSIs requested HH owners to and Western Samar are focused on the provision of
provide pictures of areas where the toilets will be constructed materials for the construction of sanitary facilities and the
and photographs after they have been constructed. Lastly, conduct of CLTS activities. However, adopting the use of
there was a lack of surveillance of water sources, such as improved sanitation facilities requires behavioral change
water refilling stations. not merely the provision of toilets. SCH and STH control
Good practices in the implementation of WASH require eliminating OD achieved by ensuring the utilization
interventions included the conduct of health promotion of sanitary toilets. To sustain effective control of STH,
and education activities such as orientation on proper community interventions such as CLTS may be intensified
hand washing as well as tooth brushing for children, and so that the WASH sector would improve parasitologic status
on CLTS for health workers and parents. School teachers in high-risk groups, as well as sustain behavior change. LGUs
specifically mentioned that DOH and other non-government working with WASH organizations should formulate clear
organizations (NGOs) also provided grooming kits for policies toward a sustainable system for monitoring and
children containing toothbrushes, toothpaste, soap, comb, evaluation of ZOD outcome indicators.
including towels. The areas for improvement include the increase of
The major WASH interventions were the provision of human resources, intensified health education to parents, as
toilets to selected HHs, as well as the construction of water well as additional sanitary including hand washing facilities
systems by the LGU with the help of NGOs; however, not in schools and CDCs. The advantages and disadvantages of
all HHs were provided toilets due to insufficient funds. maintaining good hygiene as well as sanitation in HHs should
The LGU prioritized the barangay with low sanitary toilet be advocated to parents by the LGUs. Social mobilization
coverage and those who committed to using and maintaining is also vital in achieving high deworming coverage as it
them. Non-government and international organizations builds trust between the people in the community and the
(i.e., Kabit Bisig Laban sa Kahirapan-Comprehensive and health workers.
Integrated Development of Social Services, Plan International The most important cross-cutting strategy in the success
Philippines), as well as political entities, assisted with the of SCH and STH control programs is the multi-sectoral
purchase of toilets and construction of water systems. HHs collaboration of different agencies. Japan and China have
provided counterpart support by providing manual labor. successfully eliminated SCH through integrated approaches
After the provision of toilets, LGUs conducted monitoring involving preventive chemotherapy, snail control, health
to ensure that the toilets were constructed and utilized. education, provision of sanitary facilities, environmental
modification, and improved farming methods.22,23 In China,
DISCUSSION cattle were removed from grasslands where snail inhabits
for 80% of all snail infections originate from cattle. Also,
Post-Haiyan, the implementation of SCH and STH sanitation was improved to decrease the amount of human
control in Eastern and Western Samar was still focused excreta discharged into the lake and grasslands, thereby
mainly on MDA despite the evidence of a high burden of reducing the human source of snail infection.24
infections. Insufficient or delayed delivery of anthelminthic Following a model of effective SCH and STH control,
supply, lack of human resources, and misconceptions about the above-mentioned challenges can be addressed through
13. Watson JT, Gayer M, Connolly MA. Epidemics after natural disasters. 20. Jia TW, Melville S, Utzinger J, King CH, Zhou XN. Soil-transmitted
Emerg Infect Dis. 2007 Jan; 13(1):1-5. doi: 10.3201/eid1301.060779. helminth reinfection after drug treatment: a systematic review and
14. World Health Organization & League of Red Cross Societies. meta-analysis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2012; 6(5):e1621. doi: 10.1371/
Coping with natural disasters: the role of local health personnel and journal.pntd.0001621.
the community. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 21. Grimes JE, Croll D, Harrison WE, Utzinger J, Freeman MC,
1989. 97p. Templeton MR. The roles of water, sanitation and hygiene in reducing
15. Salazar MA, Law R, Pesigan A, Winkler V. Health consequences of schistosomiasis: a review. Parasit Vectors. 2015 Mar 13; 8:156. doi:
typhoon Haiyan in the Eastern Visayas Region using a syndromic 10.1186/s13071-015-0766-9.
surveillance database. PLOS Currents Disasters; 2017 Feb 6: 9(1). doi: 22. Belizario VY Jr, Totañes FI, de Leon WU, Ciro RN, Lumampao YF.
10.1371/currents.dis.4a3d3b4474847b2599aa5c5eefe3a621. Sentinel surveillance of soil-transmitted helminthiasis in preschool-
16. Belizario VY, Delos Trinos JP, Sison OT, Miranda E, Molina aged and school-aged children in selected local government units in
VB, Cuayzon A, Isiderio ME, & Delgado R. High burden of soil- the Philippines: follow-up assessment. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2015
transmitted helminth infections, schistosomiasis, undernutrition, and Mar; 27(2):NP1604-15. doi: 10.1177/1010539513483825.
poor sanitation in two Typhoon Haiyan-stricken provinces in Eastern 23. Parker M, Allen T. Does mass drug administration for the integrated
Philippines. Pathogens and Global Health; 2021 May 6: 115(6):412-2. treatment of neglected tropical diseases really work? Assessing evidence
doi:10.1080/20477724.2021.1920777 for the control of schistosomiasis and soil-transmitted helminths in
17. World Health Organization Evaluation Office. Evaluation of the WHO Uganda. Health Res Policy Syst. 2011 Jan 6; 9:3. doi: 10.1186/1478-
neglected tropical diseases programme. World Health Organization 4505-9-3.
[Internet]. 2019 [cited 2021 Nov]. Available from: https://www. 24. Rollinson D, Knopp S, Levitz S, Stothard JR, Tchuem Tchuenté
who.int/docs/default-source/documents/evaluation/evaluation-ntd- LA, Garba A, et al. Time to set the agenda for schistosomiasis
report.pdf ?sfvrsn=351a363f_2 elimination. Acta Trop. 2013 Nov; 128(2):423-40. doi: 10.1016/j.
18. World Health Organization. Accelerating work to overcome the global actatropica.2012.04.013.
impact of neglected tropical diseases: a roadmap for implementation: 25. World Health Organization. Schistosomiasis progress report 2001–
executive summary. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2011 and strategic plan 2012-2020. Geneva, Switzerland: World
2012. 22 p. Health Organization; 2013. 74 p.
19. Philippine Department of Education. DepEd Order 10 s.2016:
Policy and guidelines for the comprehensive water, sanitation and
hygiene in schools (WINS) program. Manila, Philippines: Philippine
Department of Education; 2016.