The Efficiency of The Tram Network in Al

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 58

!

"#

! "

" ) * +%&'( # $ ! "


! , # - ./ . 01 +. # ./ , " / 2
34 5 6 = 7 8 / ,9 : ;/ < 7
$ : ,9 : 6 5 1 3 ? 5>
< ! > A 2 "# # > ? 9 : ;! >2 + ! @/
$: + D ! E (B%& +(B%& (B%C #
F 4 ;> ! +D 5" 2 - 4 + " ! @/
0 >-2 IE - 2 G H2 ? "#
I 1 4" > ? @ # + ) / +
@ # ,9 : 6 5 2 G 5# ,9 : G H: J
? 5 : 4 5)
! " ) 0. @ 7 8 ;/ * J
. : 5 7 4# ! :" K + 5 @ 4
? ! < 7 5 . L: 0
? ) / 8 ! M' 1F ! 4 J

? ! @/ $ : +A + +. ! +

4 2 ; / 5 2
I 8 ?< 7 N O . " H: 0
PPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPP
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

# ) J 2 5 5 5 5 D 44
Q:7 ! 2 H7 L +; 5 < J 2
? > 1 !
! = " 2 5 5
8$ S 0 ;> + D 2 R %&'B # .
6 > "# " @ ! # > + !O A# / " >
" .:L <G )0 5 ? ! > + T/
T 6 " 5 5 E J $ !
5 %&UV # "# 5 E , 5 ) 5
S% R
Q 7 , 2 , 5 , 2 ) +A: 4 T
J W F " + ) ! , 2
, : 2 $ +. ! ! 1 2 4 2 3
? ,)
4> > A! !7 5 , # "# , I ,# ! A "
/ T ) X + @ :" H : + 9 : # +
" . Y # + Q A! # + @ A!
" 5 7 S%Z& K +(BB& +F/ ) R L
? > 5

[ ! J L !J< 7 J
[. 9 : ;/ * ) > 2 , )5 >-# 8 J
[ 4 >0 6 7 O < J
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
" + #+ "$, -# . /0 # & ' # 1 23 4 ) ' * # "$#$%# & ' # ( !"
B2 C D # 5+0# 67 " 4 89+ :$.$.+ #+ + ;# < => ?8 + ) @A+
IJKL M0" IG3 H$ # 4%/ 0)8'B# # 5+0B# + 5+0# E;F 4 ) ' *
:YZP : 0NO P$B B# Q R BS :T ' #+ & ' # U BV WX # U G "$#$%#
Y^ Y]^ \ \ :Y[ Y : H
!"#

" #
? ,9 : 6 5 J
? 4 >0 >2 ;/ 5 7 J
? Q! ,9 : ;! >2 - J

I $
"2 6 7 4 , L ! 2 $ # 2
2 > 4 D"* 3" +
(B%( # D A / 5 + L! D
5 < (B%C # ! > $ ? ! "
9 2 5 / -! ; / 4 (B%& #
"# ; / 4 ! +A 2>
< ! "# 4 6 + "# Q
F 4 ? "# ;> 4: 5 N
4 8$ ? 4 A! #X 5 "# 4
, 2 4 - 3- ? 5 / " 2
S% Q " R "# 5 Y$ Q + A 5 G ;
4 V&V Y$ 'BB ; ) > +, # 5 K 0
4 +. - 4 T9 : 5# 5 < E 4 * %%'
? H2 !

! / D" 7 " 5" :4 \ / >


I ]> 3 ?
? ,O ^
? A ;) ^
? D ^
? ! @/ T$ : 9 ,9 : ^
? " G - ^

!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

% & '( & # $


Q 2 2 ; " 9/
! + "4 " - 5 9 4< 5 "!
/ 5" 7 A! D #7 H2 1 O , ! , @4
9 5 + "X *7 N 5# S , L! R, /9
8" 4 # +5 5 "> 2 _" _ , @4 > 5 8"
+ " 5 K 5$` 01 ! 0 " @ )/ 0A 2 Q 5
, 3 <> / "# Q" " >D /
S%R
? > ,

0 ; " / 7 / ) 5 #, );
" : 2 A 5 D /7 H2 8" > + " A 2
aBB 5# ) 5 #5 / 5 2 5 > ? /
> S%aa K +%Za& + # A 4 R %&'B # A!
I S" R -
A! 5 > 2 5 %&'( # ! ' ( &
5# + " S R " "
?E W 8$ +b / Q
S< R\ 5 )* &
# : 4 1 A! 7 2 :
@ :> +S% RS 4 W R /<
Y ) > ?%Z(' # 2" . #1 . "# D" 8 5 "! c
#5 3> +%&ZC # A" 5
4 Sd !R 5 A 57
%ZBZ # /" 4 5 +A A " E #
? 0
PPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPP
) 0N% A a) 9 4 b c-d : ) 0N% # e<f I ; R$'_ 0# ` G H$ # 4%/ 0)8'B#
Y[[l :& # :ghB# &0 # R :G+ ;<# :i)0L W # U j >L+ k ' #

%
!"#

?(B%& # . -,
0 A/ 0 JD J(B%& D 2 J $
?(B%&J(B%C + JY J 3 4 +(BU(

+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

@ /" = %&ZC # A! * * &


9)/7 , L5 # > _ _
8$ 2 + 5 5
+5 4 4 A! 8" ? 2
5 5 _ < @4 5 1 4 + - N: 6
. N: + 5 5 N 5 6 +E 1A +_d
?Sd 5 E A :7R 8 / 1;
6 +d d %ZBV # A! 0 &
" /" ) %Z%( # ! +
e ) 0 Q f" -@ A! 5#
?S% K +%ZZ( + 0 L! D 2 R 2 7
" " g 5 8 " "
? O 2 %Za( #

! 5 >-2 L 5 > 34 < "#


5 A 2 4 0 A! G A <
5 , # < 1 +Q
" L ; 8 $ 5 ) > ?Q T$ A 7 2 ;: A + D"> 3
/: 0 , 8 "# Q" A 5 5
4 + 5 2 / "# +S%% K +(BBC +T # 2 R
? Q E
34 #; 5 $ S(R F
2 5 >-2 / +5 2 5 5
Y ) ; 5 ) 5 2 5 %&ZC # ! +Q
.> 4 Q 0 L - ! %Z%C # 5 2 @ : T
1 5 2 "! S > 1 @ D / 5R ; .!
@ D / 5 J # $/ 5 + 7 h A! D /
H2 ) 5 , 4 ! 5 2 J > 1
? # 4

/
!"#

?5 2 5 A! . -,
?3 4 +%'U K +%Za& + I # 4 $

1 3 40 5 2 Q 5# \
:4 . 5 1 :4 T "# $ 5 E ) 5 2
? E ! , )/ 4>7 @ 3 Q ! . > <$ 5 E 4
:4 " " >j # ?5 " 3 4 Q i @ 3 7 :7
/ 5# - ! , -2 5 #7 H2 9 #7 , 7 ! H2
"4 > %&CUZ %&ZC 2 A! 5 # => $ + 7 4 /7
?S%Z% K +%Za& + # 4 R5 A /1 5 M(' 1 . D /7
+ %('VVB 1 5 # 4 %ZVC 2 ! 5 > 34 2
Q 5 9 0 5 5 - 5 7 34 ! 8 $ "# #
K F " > %ZUV # 8$ 5 E T) 5 ]
5 2 5! 4 # ) 5 5 7 ! 5 # , ) 8 7
+ < "/ " 5 >1 ! + ! D /7 "# 4 " k
" D / T 5 + 3 4 ) Q : >
? 2 , ) 9/ 5 " " 2 5 "2 T # i 5 )"
1
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

+ H2 9 @ ` 8 $ @ >
S%R
$ ? (B%& %Z&' # $ " / 6 5 ? 3-
"# 2 5 #8 5 %Z'Z # @
5 2 )/ # / 2 2" 4 ; 5
5 # > # S%R / - 5 ? - 1 > +5 G
%Z&' 2 2 > VU 1 4 (B%& # A #5 /
T$ L +5 G ! #7 # 4 "*
? > 2 0

?(B%&W%Z'Z # $ 5 # . -,

5 5 3 4 3 4 3 33
. - ) 6 3 ) 33 , 33 )
^( %VU Z& aa %ZC(J%Z'Z
^^ (l' %aZ %%U V' %Z&VJ%Z&(
(lZ %C% %(& VU %Z&'
UlU %C% %(& VU %ZZ'
V %C% %(& VU (BB'
al( %'( %%Z VU (B%'
$
?(B%& + *5 + N O 5 + 4 , 1+ 8 J%
5 2 + / A /1 + 2 2" \ +9 4 i 2 2" ) ) / J(
?(B%'J%ZC'
?%Z&' C' < 2 ^^ +%ZC'J'' < 2 ^
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
E # <_ r E' B# " .+ 4 - %C b < # 4 R0, 1 m nB, 0F # o p" G3 & mA 0q
& mA ) 4# 4%#+ Y[ u tW N b <F ^ 5$d+ DF$ C 4 + : 2 # s$<f . $" - T +
&02+ g02 0)0 Ph# 0 )+ Y[ Z P , ic;# b 1 3 v-F$9 i 2 0# U '= #3
D; 9 P z"+ v"h"3 0{ R+8 + :tF$ # + w # %c # B', x &$< C $#$N% B# y 0X
}-f T ~9+ % &R+8 Ph# bK•, T '. : , # |h $B . ^l G3 p , EW9+ :GPS
.Q) cB# €• ‚"3 P z" 4, K>
y :QB28 #+ t28# DNƒ "+h%#3 &8= + :w # 1 N„ 1 …$>#
2
!"#

Z - 1 2 J > %%Z 1 4! (B%' # # A /1


# 4 +%Z&' 2 %ZC(J%Z'Z 5 , : 1 > ;/ J >
S%R
- 5 3 ;4 / 5 * "# +S% , 4R +O
# 5 0 >-2 @ 02 0 D 5 Q /
# 8 $ SUR F ! 7 - 2" 8$ 5
5 @ 5 >-2 5 5 +(B%' # A! : %Z&' # 2
+ # A! . 4 5 # A! ! BlZ& f" $1 / >
5 # 5 / (B%' %Z&' 2 5 2 G 2 D
? , ) ; D > (UC (B' %&( 1 4 5 D/

5 # 5 0 >-2 0 .!- ,
?(B%&J%Z'Z 5
PPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPP
Š # ˆ #+ W b 2 < 9 ‰ ulZ P , M WC † ' DNW ‡ o
, >;# M$ # 0 #$9 • .# =,$"7 )0)0L ‹% # b , , Nd 5 S x Œ ) +
U DNWC Ph# b , } Ž .h P$ ) DNWC T . € # + Ph#+ +hC b , 4, yK>
G3 •1 "3 ‚N p NWC Ph# b , R0, •B + : " W# b+R+ # D<F w $9 ‹#‚.+ :? f
P , D NW B# # ’ O b .m+ D" W ,$'S G3 p'… o :& # Ph# =;B@ , ]‘[
P # H< # D" W WXW` 4'… p ) ˆ+ Y[[]
7
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

& +, - . / 0 & ) *
2 R Z'lV ! %U 1 4 A
S%R
U'lC 1 S(B%& + I L! D
Z N) +M'( aZlC + V 2 MU&
7 9 7 Q ; / "# N) ?SV R
2 D2 Y +A /2 T) 9 9 !+ ! )
?9 7 A>

, 9 33 .
5 5 Q: V 1 # 4
+ 4 W +E W ! :" 5 +Q !
" , # #5 ! 4> 5 5 " ! +S% ;/ R
I S(R Q " N) + : 5
. " T > ) E S%R > $ 32 ; : , 9 3 &
5 ! # 7 ! 7 2 + - . # # Q )7
$ "# +U% # A /X %BlaV' 2 ! !+2 7
! Q 7 ) A / Q . )
2 L ! "/ )@" # 4 O > O E
?5
%Bl%&B 1. ! f" +S(R > 32 .9 - $) : , 9 3 &<
$ O S\ R< 2 : 7 ; d: +(Z . #
! " 2 : E: : 4 5 " A /
?A $ O S(R A / $ O S%R > ! 5
PP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPP
1 #3 o 'N 2+ : . []”] •B;) ) 0N% A Ph# s$<` 5$( € “3 T G3 & mA 0q
b C . u‘”] s$<f 5$( •;d . Z 5$< 4) 9 . v" 8N# [ e`
s$<` u = B, H$ ) –#+ N)0C b 5$( •B; s$<f ‹B9 = B, w 9 –# )0)0L
: ;) 9 . Y”l 5$< 4) 9 . –2 EW;# N 4 [ e` 4 18 tF$9 0 . Y[
s$<` ] R0 . [”Y + [”l 'O$( •B; E # P 9 j
!8
!
!"#

?(B%& # L! .%- ,
+(BU( A/ 0 JD J?(B%U + aB > airbus # 4 5 ! J $
?(B%& (B%C 2 JY ? 2 " 2
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

# H2 9 , #1 . ) : 9# @ - >? 9 &=
8 4 ] # 5 5 # ) / A
.! > - 5 F " 44 2
5 5 > > S VR . ! 2 ? + S( , 4 R
5 5 T 0 +> ) 0 < . " ) 5 #
.7 )" 6 1; / "
8$ ! 8 5 3: 0 . , 2 5 -! ,
5 #. 4 J $ D $ " ! + 1
J $ , 2 # +< 5 ! :
J 4 W "# : 4 : 5 5 E
? 1 (U $ (( 1. # 4 + 1; /
32 . ) : 9# @ - 5 3 &
?, # $Q E: $ + 7 . " > ) 0 7
> S UR # . "# 2 +SU , 4 R . ! 5 . ) / A! > 2
+. @ 1 <$ U' -d $ 2 ? ! 5 # 5 5 >
# !+ @" (a - .! 2
8$ @ ! / O 5 / < 5
S% R
? (B%&

< $ 5 "# 2 /
N + E:
"# Q" + 5# L 5 > A!
T$ Gridiron system 9 Chequrboard \ 2>
8 $ ?SU( K +(BBC +T # 2 R > ) 2 ; ; # 5O
? #, 2 Q 5 4
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
:E # Ph E 9+ ;F ~ - :— ;, 3 D ) $ % <c˜ 1 #+ " 0 C 0#
Y[ Z|^| ^
!
!"#

) 9 33 .
Z C UR 9@1 6 ! Z 1 # 4
D* 8 / 9 O D* N # N) +S(% %B
5 ?D 2 > ! 2 +E A /2 > 3 7
I # 6- 8 5 / SVR

+ S'R # N: #2 , 2 $ 3
, # ? 4 ; < +S'R # I8 , #
0 +4 ! , 2 ! ?5 # 6 5 E
! 8$ ? / " 9 #: 2 )
/2 5 ;/ ! $ , # / A! 2
IA N) ?D * 8 / A Q >) N
%Bl& ! 6 2 I; : #) . - 3 &
+ UC . # f" + ! ! 7
) . 4 A: L < / # 4 A Q
5 ) A! T # 5 Q T$ D 5 ! , Q :
! ? / A 8 - / 4 # 4 /
8 ! + A 5 : 5 2
! S8 N R / A $8 N O
? 5 !5 5 " 4
Q E: &lV : #) . - 3 &<
f" +) . S< 4 R < #5 g $ ) #
?! > . Q K 4 E: ) + U( . #
%U 2 VlV ! 4> 5 ) : A 9 .%- 3 &=
? < / Q .
Y 7 .:4 ! + (a C ! ; :A 9 ./- 3 &
5 "4 <$ + W 5 E " , 2 5
?
E: ) + (U 2 al& ! $ 3 : #) . - 3 &B
?S%R K 4
!!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

5 ; / +%U 2 Vl% ! ; :, 3 . +- 3 &


5 4 <$ 2 + / A# 4
?8 5 E 5 6
/ Ul& ! 4> 2 : ) . /- 3 &
?%B . # f" 5)
+ (& 2 & ! ) : # ) . 2- 3 &C
# 4 Q >O T T "# ! ) + #
+8 # 4 :L 5 4 Q # 4) 6 +5 " 8
7 E 5 2 8 VBB # 4 5 # 5 "
?SUVV K +(B%U +< 4 5 /R
. H: + (% 2 ClV . f" ; & $ 3 . 7- 3 &D
/ D 5" 2 "# d g E ! 3 O 4 /
5 5 5 2 > + 5! 5 5 5 "/
! H: (B%% 2 A 7 -: 0 , ! 4 "# - 0
- 5 " # 4 # 4 ) E
5# - ! ? ! / "2 / 2 9/ ! + A 7 , / H: A
S%R
? " . ! $ T "# " / 7 " 2 > #1

2" " 3& 1 *


* " 5 H@ D # 6 5 5 5
(B%( # 5 D SaR S(R / - 5 ?8 $
S(R
I A 5 (B%& # 1
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
u e` : N)0C Ph Q™ 0 'L 0;, b8, I D i)02+ Y[ Z $ #$) U " 0 C 0#
E• 9 .L 4%9 B r#+š C R '.+ Y[ Y E;F .L nB, 5$WL ‚ 9 p" & mA 0q Y
4 ) 0 0)0 P z" E -9 o+ F $# b -BC } b0 + Y[ g 02 E;F k+h%#3 E%
.cB# b 1 W23 } nB, $› # o ’ O ; %˜ œ$-V b -BC } ;# H$ # 4%#+ Y[ Y
r#+š C } ;# WX # bK C 4 + :P # x ;. T$ B [ v B –#+ b N " '›#
P # x Ž. T$ B ][ G3 EW9 v" . G L T # 4 5+ 0 # x .L T7 +R
&1 -%#+ R0 # ‰ -•* .L v>-• N • ; + b < # ‹# = # 4%#
!%
!"#

!+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

?(B%&J(B%( # 5 D A /X D # .+- ,

4 (B%U (B%( A # 5 MU'J , H: F J


8- 7 > ! D 5 9 Q 5 #8 8$
" 8 $ < O! +(B%% 6 2 A 7 -: - " > $@
S (% Z C UR H2 :> ,9 :
5 / D- # H: 8$ / ? / # 5 #8
. 2 / E 1
2 @ ! 5 # 7 ; N: - # J
?M%B 5 D (B%a # " , )F + 4
? 2 # " JA W L J
D ! # * 5# D , 5 J
! " 8$ M(U MCC 1 4 (B%&J(B%( # 5
? A "2 2
+< 7 - 1 @ ! H2 D$ $ A O J
>! 4 2 @ ! 5 # (B%' 5 , )
O! 7 3 L" A - + 2 !D 5 " %U 5
"# E ; " R 4 #K 2 3> + 3 3>

!/
!"#

aZlC 5 5 * "# ?S(B%& + + 4


! > / : 5 01 A /1 5 M'(
8$ ; UB "/ ` Nottingham / !< 5
5 34 5 5 MUB D 2 A! D " 5 " %U
?SHarvey, 2012, p. 18R
0 5 M%' 8 ! A /1 5# > 7 2 0 J
, $ ;! 5 , :2 , ! 3- ? M(B 1 4 +
5G +d 4 5 > 2 4 A! : 4 5>2 ! 4 !
5 M%a M%B 5" 9 5 # /0
? D 5 - *D 5 MUB 8 5 < ?D "#
D- M'a D 5 5 F J
A! 5 5 A! + * 5" 2 5 3 L " MUa
?< 7 3 L 5 " Maa D- " MVa 1 4
# , ) 8 $ ;/ (B%& (B%C # A! , ) F J
! > 2 , ) < 7 2 : 2 N: + 4
?9 * . : 2 > H : 0 < > E!
# 5 " al( 1 4 <$ 5 # ; D 0 J
3 %(B # f" Osijek 8 "2! +(B%'
5 " Cl( D # 4 8$ ; UB 2 E:
5 2 ! 8$ "# SDimter, et al., 2016, pp. 72-76)
? 5 " UBB "# 5 H : !

?*
, ) 5 / - 5
! ! ; 1 S'R SUR / 5 + 2> 7
: ) + U& # f" + !
" + ! : 5 M%&la /
#: / < 7 -4 5 4
?E Q 7 / Q " ) + : 4 : 5

!1
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

?(B%& # D < .!- ,

E 0 3 <
%&la C / :
UVl( %U :
(% &
('lU %B :
88 !2 5 6
? (B%& " $

A /1 5 MUVl( %U : # f" J
5 / ; +;> 7 ! 5 +
. "# ) 6 @ D / ) : D"*
"# 2 A 4 "2 G ) 5 # ! T$ A!
) T$ 7 7 " # ! 2
;/ + 4 " +_ _ 7 Y-# ) +D " 5 G
?\ < +8 5 + 0 < +e- < + "" L
A /1 5 M(% & 1 ! # 4 J
8$ " #: 2 5 5 ; T$ 5 L - +
A 7 # 1 : D * "2 m / *!
4 E 5 #E +" / 5 : " + #) " +
! 5 2 ! 4 / 01 +E E
, 4> ! "# 5 +5 "# D >
? 2 5
! : ) < @4 1 ; / 9 J
"# O ) T$ @ ! > D /
-4 Q : : 5 / , 4> !
5 / D 4 2 " "> ! +< 7
? -

!2
!"#

0 A/ 0 JD J(B%& D 2 J $
?(B%&J(B%C JY J 3 4 +(BU(
?(B%& # ! ./- ,

!7
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

F ? G H? $ 3 , ? ) 3 3 '?
, $ 3 33 I ;H )
+ 4 # D ) : ) 8$
) ! SV (Q "RE 2 5 %a
5# - ! + "2 G / Q 5 L 8 N Q
> ! + * 5" / # / " ! $ 4
Q ! 4 : ! ! $ Q Y
? ! H: 0 E E 3 7
) H: 0 5# D- H: 5`! #
! ) ! +%Z ! 4 H2 "# "2 G
: 2 > H: 0 A : T$ 5 " < H: 0 <
5 5" / # 2 H2 5 " 2 ) +" 9 ;
?SV , 4R . 2 5 " : 5$ 4
0S >R > > 5 / 5# !
2 0 :2 ! 8 ! +H2 5# 2 !
! ) S E W RE 4 5
! # <$ > 3 7 !
,L 8 J ! E: < 7 ! ; J > A 7
4 5" / # ) . A 5 "
5 / 4 E Q O / ; b : , A L! 5 5
E $ " 5 7 / H: 5 3 3- ?, : Q
? 7 8 + " , K4 2 4. )-

JJJ .
5 5 (B%&J(B%( 5 D SVR SUR " - 5
3 4: ) , $ 5 + ; / D 8
E # "# <+ A /1 5 D "# M(Cl( M('la
"2 "2 " ! 57 M(UlU " > 34 ! ;>
?5 ! 4 .! 5

%8
!"#

S%R
, : E >5 2 SCR SaR Q " 5
!- / 5 " , ! @ 5 2 $ # : 6 (B%&J(B%( 5
@ N / f" + N , L L # 5# / >9
E > + T$ K ) 3 L 5 +%BB 5 2 %(BB
I 2 - 5

) 9 3 K 9 3

5 : 7 5 > / . 5
M%%Bla "# + JE 5 2 < 7 + J
4: ?M%BlV < M%BBl% E
?5 ! 4 " " T$ H: 2 34 4: L 0 + " "

? (B%&J(B%( # 5 D 2 .1- ,

Q: 2 < 34 2 , > L
2 f" ?3 4 0 7 4: ;
5 5 L 0 M%BUlZ !. > M%%C !. >
?
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
Y^ \ :Y[ Z :Ž)0# 0Ÿ M0Ÿ IG3 H$ # 4%/ ž$C E H$" 4 0)8'B#
%
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

5 3" N 7 O 5 SVR / 5 F ! 7 < "#


S%R
+ " 5" 2 ) O ) 7 N 7 34 ! ,) /
,) /1 6 MZ D " 7 > 2 ;> E # "# 2 / ! 8$
$ # 7 ,) / ! )/ ! + 2 / E " N 7
. 2/ 5 /! ?MaB 5 D , $ #
: 2/ Q Q ,# ) ! ,) 4
,) / 9 ? 4 Q + $ !E ,
] @ ,) /1 7 9 D ! N 7 > + :4
/ 5 7 5 * 4 # H2 / G 5
?,) / 5# ) H: ! *

5 - N 0 7 .%- ,
?S(B%&J(B%CR 2 "#

) 9 , 9 9 33
M ( M (
E . $- E .L - E . $- E .L - 9
%% %( %' %B
%( %( %( %C 7
%a %' %( %C 5 7
%' %a %( %' 9 -
%a %a %a %a 92 7
%' %' %Z %' E
%a %V %V Z 2/
88 88 88 88 5 6
?(B%&J(B%C < #- $
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
$' & A+ 0# $ e rž$ G3 ,$; .L 9 o p" G3 & mA 0q
u • ;, + q+ $ "$) tW N G3 ¡' ; tW N 4 0 / M‚#+ .L &+ $ 0#
) ¢ G $ #$) 4 0 /+ t W# $ $= b A $ :$ "$) –2 $ . 4 $=m
Œ 0# P # & 3+ † <d* .2 4 E' ) ˜ ¡' ;
%
!"#

6 < ) .
5 5 / , "# 2 A 5 5 *
A 5 5# ;/ ! 5 01 < 5 AO *
9@ X 8 5 $ D n +(B%( 2 , 7 #7 ! );
! <$ 4 >0 O A )X
1 (B%( # 5 / S&R SaR / F ? 6 " , #1
I F + (B%&
4 (B%U # ! 2 5 D , H: A "/ J
- 7 - 2 2> MUCJ M U'J 1
H2 3> < - 2 + # To = < - 5 4
?< , :G @4 "# 5 3 2 / E
A 7 - MZ @ MZlC (B%a # < , N: - # J
2: A + >5 / #, ) A
2 ;/ X !D # , ) 5 M&V 1 4 <$ N: 0 $ 5
?. / 34 5 . / 34 1 ; 5 ! 32 1 : 2 5 ;!

@ A D A /1 .+- ,
?(B%&J(B%( # 5

N ) 6 N ) < 5
E E .> ) - E E 9 33 )
J J (''aZ&&( J J CZZCZ'V& (B%(
aZlV UCJ %'C(CBaC a'la U'J a%B&Z&ZV (B%U
(l' (l'J %'(ZC''& % %J aBa(BCaC (B%V
Val' &V (ZZCBVa& Z ZlC aaVUV%%B (B%a
%& ((la U'C%'%UB % %lU a'%CZ'Z' (B%'
%a %& VU(aU%Ua Cl& &la 'BZUZ(a& (B%C
( ( VVBZ&((' U U '(&ZaC%' (B%&
&& && !8+! 2!1 && && +7+118 O) J9
"2 , 1+ $ # Q "2 ) + L! D 2 $
? " D / +(B%&J(B%( # 5 D #O 5 +9 4

%!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

"/ (B%& # ! D 5 " 'U 5 D "4 ! / 2: J


! X +32 " : 2 2 N : 0 2 E: . / 5 " VV 5
8$ + / . : 2 .! +. / . :" A
? "2 2" . / :" K 4

?(B%&J(B%( 5 , : - D A /1 .2- ,

5 ! 6$ ! " & 4&


N: 1 2 "# ) 5 1 , /
$ ? 2 9 ; / A! 5 * A! )0 1< +4
5# ) D " : 2 2 4
"# > O + > > 8- ,9 : +,9 : 6 5 4 ,
5 Q A! 2 0 ?SŠojat, et al., 2017, p. 17R
0 4 5 0 "# D ;/ - 5 $/ 5 5
,9 : G - 5 ,9 : 3 ? 2
"# D + 4 5 : ,9 : 5# - ! + 5)
? # 5)

%%
!"#

P .
2 5 0 ! :4 D " 2 ) S'R / F
S%R
F ? \ G D Q ! 2 ) / 8$ + "
I F + 2 N SZR
Q " / 5 *! A! " ) 2 < J
? 2 9 Q " 0 01 Q S(R 1 4 , #
2 D "# S 4 R !
2! + / , # 4 ! +D ! 5 /
?5 $ O ! $ +5 E " + / , #
5 " 2 : 9 2 /! " 2 ) / < J
5 * "# ?5 5# / #: "# ; 0 8 $ +E 2 4"
<) 2> 01 2 3 4 5 / < Y
? %a 3> 8 Y <
6 " 2 S9 R 4 2! J
) L2 ) + ,# N: "
+K # -/1R D* 1 -! 4 / -
A! E 5 < * ? / " Sa'% K +(BBU
3> 3 7 5 ; E ! 5 5 01 )
? 3 L
5 - , @ 3 L" 5 G $ E ; ) < J
5 5 A! 8 ! , ) , # ,2 ) !
?E !, ) , # 5 Q ,# , # 0E
PPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPP
WF ¡, ` &0 , 0 )RšC bKd$# R0 0 # )8. 0# !"$. mš w )
P0X 3+ : )8. ›. &0 B# d R0 # w ) ‹#‚ + %; # s$<` 5$( nB, 4%£
0 , n< 9 i 2 B` 0# 0 # )8. R nB, 5$WL 4%/ %, F 9 ) < mšC
'F ¡. R0 # w ) i ¤ E` 0# •$d j0, W # Fh# ' ) ¥ F %; # † (
: G3 H$ # 4%/ 0)8'B# )8. ›. &0 B#
l[l l[] \ \ : uu[ :‰ ) # :a) C R :U ic;# :w` ‡$-d
%+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

%/
%1
!"#

? 2 N .7- ,
? S 'R / "# 9 $
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

3 ML P .
D A / # - 5 " 9 7 ,9 : G
"# 5 2 : ; ! e-40 4 8$ + 5
? 2: " 2 # -40 T$
+ 8 < %Z&' # $ / 5 / S%R / 2/
A /1 5 > ZU 2 6 > 34 2 5 SCR / 5 F
5 ! L +Ma& 2 + ! MaC > %'(
5 1 ! + "2: A /1 5 M'a 1 4 " 2 > !
D # , )D 5 8$ 2 5 ! # 6- >
? A /1 5 M('la 1 4 5 ; 5#
? > 5 Maa 2 5 MCUla "# $

?(B%& # 34 ! ,9 : < .1- ,

3 ) E 0 4 E 3 4 0 3
M 0 0 0 3 33
('la 'a &V %(Z 'a (& VU
CUla aa %UB (U& aa 'a %%Z
88 +2 % !/1 +1 7! / ' 6
+ 8 "# 9 #1 5 D / $
+ "# 2 # # A /` 5 + 4 , 1+ : 4
?(B%& + *5

; ! 5 1$ 9@1 "!
+, < 7 )" 0 > 0 ;
9@ / ! ?5 "# 2 N 2
: 9: ,) /O : ; 5 ! 0 ? ,9 : "# 8 $ O!
2 A! S3 R 8 ;4 5 * "# + 4
] 2 + ,9 : " A! : , 2 K 5 ?.
? ! # 7 3 7 / ! 2 5 ! 4 2

%2
!"#

2 5 # 4 ! 5 2 ! ,9 : G
3 UB 5 D4 5 8 $ ! S&R / F + a%'UCaB 1 (B%'
8$ ?D "# " 2 2: , / A / >5 5 3 aa
"# " 2 , / 5 >D 5 3 'C 3 U& 5 D4
D # , ) "# @ 2 02 5 > 8 $ +D
? "#

?(B%& 5 D / ,9 : G .2- ,

U&&(Va A /1 U%&Ca /1
D 5 3 5 5 3
'C'(Z& ! " 2 aaa(V ! " 2
D 5 3 5 5 3
?(B%' + L! A 2 SaR S(R S%R / "# 9 $

Q 3 $ P .!
# / 7 4 >0 / " # A! E 5 G $ 2
/ 1 H: . / + A! T$ 5 : D 4 ;: !
I D + L2 A! /
)K9 S 4RQ 3 , 3
5 5 3 %BB %l&' q a%'UCaB p Z'lV <

,N 4 Headway 3 .%
Q 2 , "# 5 5 ) # .O 5) G 32
A , $ > K G $ L SHenry, 1950, p. 487R 5 2
5 5 5) , ) 5 SZR /5 F !3 40
* ) W5 S%'R 5 E W S%aR I
Q O 5 5 6 5 # > ! 6 5 5 4>
? )

%7
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

?(B%& # 5) ! .7- ,

9 ? 9 4
T 9 3 ? 9T
3 9
, 3 , . T - .9 - 3
3
, 9 33 U

UlZ BlUV U% %(B %Bla 4 JE W %

Ul& BlUa (Z %%B %Bl( 4 J "/ J (

Ula BlUa ((la &B & .! J

Ula BlUa ((la &B & A J

) 9 33 )*

Ul( BlUB UC %(B %Bl& E W ) %

UlU BlUB UB %BB &lV ) J ) (

Ul& BlUV %U aB VlV 5 J8 V

U Bl(C (' &B C 5 E J8 '

(l' Bl(' U% &B & S RA J ) %B

(l& Bl(& (% 'B al& 4 W ) %%

Vl( BlUV %( aB Vl% 5 E J %a

Vla BlU& %B Va Ul& ) J5 %'

U BlU (' &B & 5 J ) %&

U BlU( (U CB ClV E J 4 %Z

!V+ 8V! && 28 7/V% 3 &5 6


I "# 9 " ! ) D / $
.(B%& + + I L! D 2 J
# ;) 5 + @ , 1+ 8 JD
?(B%& + *5 +

+8
!"#

5 )! 5 " - O 5 5 9 "/ >


Q <$ S%aR 4 / 9/ # ) 5 5
/ D"> / Q " 5 2 3);!+ )
. ) / !@ N Q T$ 18 / 5
5 8 5 # / G 5 2
?. # 9 . > #1 A! # + 2" / 5 , 7 ;/
, $ 4 ) N 5 5 . 5 S%'R 5
; / , D 3 N < 7 ; T 9 > #X )0
E ) S%R + .! O )0 +Sa , 4R < 2
?. 5) 5 " #
"# + > 5 > Ul& UlZ 5 ) 5 "/ 8$ 2 AO
5 ; UC 8 5 A! < 7 ; 5 0 5 *
?S' , 4R 9 A! 5 ! "# #N ; 1-
"/ @ # ! 5 S%BR 5 5 ! @ #
A! $ G 5 +# r ' +# r 'lU E J 9
! : i @ 3 7 . L2 ; E 5 #0
5 5 * ! + H: 0 # )! )0 A
, ! 5 8$ " ! ) * D 5 * ! )
# > 5 E W / ?# "# G 3>
34 / 2 " T$ L A! / 2 8$ # r VlZ
# ?# "# 8 $ G! 5 4 / ) Q T
A! + # r ala 1 A! 4 ! ; / @ # H:
# r (BJC 5 " ; # f" 5
?SFraser, et al., 2015, p. 21R
S%%R F Y$ " "# 4 ""! S @ ! R "@ ,
/ 0 H2 4 5 0 +SŠojat, 2017, p. 219R
:> # + , > + D # 2
4 2 +8 $ * > -! -4 5 , # +
4 9 " "# 9 "# #0 Y$ )" "

+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

L - S% Q " R 5 0 Y$ "# 9 + "# 5 " 2 ;


S%R
I - H2 D SZR / "# #0 8 $ ? 4

?(B%& # @ # . 8- ,
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
‹#‚.+ bh $B %# s$<f 5 $( nB, 5$WL 4% ] E% <) f+ u 5+0 4
E # , + :E # b F+ e $ + :Q™ F0# - # vF+ e $ + bKd$# 5$(
IŒB) nB, 5$WcB# " 0 C 0# b " ; " * o
Q™ F0# - # vF$# nWF 0L
4 b +0# 4 8# § 8# E B # j Q™ F0# vF$# e;… 5+0 + ¦ w`7 # E R
- # vF$# nWF 0L+ - # vF+ e $
? $'N# Ž2 d ‚¨ –# b ) # nB, N R ' ,* o Q™ F0# F <# 2h vF+
- # vF+ e $ 4 | n +
: F <# 2h DF$ + : <# ) =N# 0N 4 Q Q™ F0# b ;.C Ž 9 9 &R ,3 vF+
"0C 0# b " 4 + :‹# G3 + : <V G3 Œ' N9 ©# & mA b b ( #+
FR G3 EW9 ¢ G3 0# vBd$9
FR YY $ + : b ;.C Ž 9 9 &R ,3 E' ) &w` <V tF$ # vF+
&w` <V tF$ # &0 n + ) =N# vF++ - # vF+ e $ H$'S Q™ F0# Œ™8 &+R vF+
2h * &w` <V tF$ # vF+ ª &R$, ª • - # vF+ Q™ F0# =B. & +0# vF+
b ;.C Ž 9 9 &R ,3+ F <#
+
!"#

? " "@ , "# 4 " - "# Šojat . -,

! / 7 @ , >5 F Y$ \ S%(R - 5
3 Bl& . ! / +# rD 3 %lZ 1 .! 4 5 5 6 "@ , >
J ) / ?. H: 5 * "# "# @ # T) +# rD
# ?D "# # rD 3 % %l% 1 4 @ , >5 E J E
6 5 5# K 4 5 8$ + 5 "@ , > "# !
?, > A /X O 2 : > 4>7 #

?Šojat Y$ (B%& # @ , > . -,


+!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

9 33 '? N 5 ) G ) .+
5 5 N > ! @ 5 / Q H2 5
-! , 57 5 +A 0 $ ) 5 2
+ # 2 $ : H: S R D" 5# 2 " $:
4 9 " "# # ? ! > " S%UR 5 F
: 4 /< ! O D
D 5 5 ! 2 " 5 F ? 5 4 4
? ! 4 . "# > H:

" D ) 6 + " " $: S%BR / F


2 5 5 > 5 ! " Q 4 MZB T 5 Q
5$ 5 *D 8$ + (BB 1 5 7 H2 ! ! 4! /
? /< 5 5

?(B%& " $: . 8- ,

) 9 , 9
E< 9 ? E< 9 ?
&& 34 ZB 34 5 >
'( % Ca % 1 34 5
aa %la 'V %la J% 5
UB ( V( ( J%la 5
%B (5 %& (5
?(B%&J(B%C 3 4 ! > #- 0 "# 9 #1 5 / $

H: %la ! 2 D / 4 5# ! 2 " J
"# , 5 5 8 5 ? D n ! M%& 1 4
5 / ; 4- < : 5
?< 7 5 " :! # 2 5 4

+%
!"#

? 5# 2 D D S R " $: . !- ,
?S%R Q " 5 0 Y$ Q (B%&J(B%C "# # $

++
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

> J 9 5 * "# W < 5" : D H: J


D H: 8$ ?. - 5 , / 4 5
, Q < " D" ! 2! " T) 5
<) 5 4 + " 2 2 5 " : ! +, ! 42
- 5 , / 4 5 S > ] N R ]/
?5 5$
2 # 4 : , ! 5 5 * "# J
: < 7 < 2 + H2 ! 5) 5
! 2 " " 5 2 Q ! 4 :"
+M'( "# 5 " 4 % 2 /! J J 5#
E: , # / ! #: 57
( 5 +< D > "# /0
! D @" / 4 5 2 5# , 2 3 7 Q !
?2 , < 5 : M%B 1
/ " "> ! " A ;/ ! .! / * J
T$ @ ! +F H@ 5 < )5 " 5 M' 5 D
5 , ) " 5 ! < 7 + "
# ! , ) : 5 Q F " 8$ ! MV
?S3 2 #7 ! 3" R<

4 : + 2 H2 -4 "2 0 5 8
! Y " L ! ? "# < 2 2
?

)9 :07- ; <= (- & 78


Q! 5" 2 D N- - 5
9/ 54 : L / 5 ) - 5 # 4 "4
IA S%VR

+/
!"#

?(B%& " - ;) . %- ,

0 < F) W .
2 - A /1 5 MV' "# 9 " $ I L3 &
) A! < ! #,#8 6 + 5" 2 D
H: 0 <G " : ) / / 2! + @ # H:
< 7 < ; 8 +# ,9 :
; 3> 5 " 8 $ +. > #1 "# # ! 7
5 ; S2 )2 J 4 R )- * 3> !
1 5# , # ; UC ; ; ,
# ] ! 5# - ! ?S' a , 4R 9 "# 2! # N
?E 5 D + > 5" /
4 / # 5 D 5 M%' < I 3 9 4 &<
+ 2 H2 $! # 6 2 L! +
1 7 4 A! 8 $ D ! $! Q-*1 2 9 D "# G
?D " 4 7 H2 A! : $! " 34 2 G 8$ #
# H: ;/ + > 5 , ! ) 3 4 X ) &=
E ! 2 1 @ ; >K 5 : 2 K 4 # - i
O 4 2 5 2 > 5 # T$ 57
V ! " .! , !5 # 5 MVU < + O
?, : 5 MaC # 5 5 T$ >

+1
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

5 M%B + 5# #7 - ) I , 34( &


8 D O" , 5 H2 6 -
! 9 ; +5 " 4 F 1 T D A 4 34
< 2 H: 0 5" 2 "# " T$ G ? 3> <G "
?D # N: "# 2 <$
5 M& 6 " 5 A! D 5 " 2 5 - Q: Y &B
, 5 < 5" 2 , 5# Y ! - ;/ -
8$ H2 ! ! / 0 . 5 H2 ! > +5 5 "#
5 > 2: # 5# - ! +6 N> 4: k : 4D 2
6 5 ; ? 4 $ N
A! > # 5 A! 4 < 5 A! , , L
5# > 5 , :: 5 41 D 5 5 +" > L2
8$ 5 2 9)/ 4 A! @ Q
3> ! 3> D )" 0 ?SKovandová and Válka, 2014R
9 5 ): D : 7 H2 +. 3> 5 5 <O
5 A! 8 $ D ! Q-* A! !D 2 Q"@ 0 D"* 57 T
?6
T L! 4 - 5 M' 9 I LZ Z &
D ! +Q H2 A! ) Q 5# - ! "2 G D /
D"*O! + 4 %J' 5 2 5 4 2 9 " A!
/ < "! , / " ) ! X / Q T
?. <
A! O : " 5" 2 D H2 ) 9 &
G D / ) + ! MU 7 D
+ ! T$ A! Q 7 E L +E W E 5 ! :"
4 W ) 5 ! 4 " >: !
D : Q 2 )2 + Q ,
8$ < G ! " , ! < 2" > 5 2 F 62 A!
? 2 D

+2
!"#

: # 5# / .! D - 8 " 2 - A!
A! ; / 8 2 8 $ ;/ .! K 4 5 N >
I 5 "2! + :" #
5 +$! Q"* 3 ! X + 5) 4 0 .! # 5 , )
? ! 5 2 !
.! 9@` 5 5 * L A! + , 5
5 0 5) " ) 3: < # . , : - # ."
?5 > E N , : 0 ) 0 #, )
D ! " 2 .! > 57 3 D F"4 0 .
aaB 1 > ) 5 03 @ + ! /- @ ! ((B
5 0 ? ! > ! 2 8$ # ; 8 $ F"4 0 !
0 5 )" ! , $ # 5 .7 : .! "
? T$ " 5 -! : 5 5 : 5 /
+4 , /7 4 < 7 5 :" > g " / 5 G
?< 2 5 "# !L /

9 JJJ .
+ # E 2 4 / "" 5 2 Y 9 0) J
D*D / 5 A 2 5 M%Z 5`! SWEP, 2011R
/ ! -! # 8 $ +A" 5 AO "/
2 8$ 2 $ 5 "# ! 2 < Q :
? " ,)
" : 2! + S " / aR . ! 9 !I * X ) -<
S R 2 ,) 2" 8 $ . / % > 6" ] > aB
] > aB : 2 ! + + Q #
" > 5 2 7 ! ? @ . / %
?(B%& # " 4 5 5X L! #
+ > - :" 5 g . M&C < +4 -4 5 ! ) [ &=
? 4 5 7E D 7 Q"* 2 5 7 #D 5 M%U

+7
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

" R BRT -! ; L 5 5 * "# I , N " X ) &


@ 3 5 01 @ A! K 5 >S 7 2
? 4 @ 3L 3 D" BRT L 57 D" # >
L 1 L= > + 3 5# L 34 I ' 3 9 9 4 &B
# 5 6 ,L 1 L d *A -! 5 $/ "#
A# /0 - ! ?SFraser, et al., 2015, p. 21R / 5 "
? 4 D ; A

33 9 33 .!
< 7 < 5 , ! J 8 J ./
2 " " "# , 2 $ Q Q Q < 5
2/ / # , ) , 4 5 ! " ! S ) R
,#8 $ S(a& K +(BBa +5 )# Q !R " !
I < # + O , #` ,9 : ;!

, 9 , #\ M 4 I , J
3 + O "# " : 4 D / 5 Q:0
?S(B%& + , / RI 1
"# 9 5 )1 Q 5# 8 $ I < 4 J
, : 0 Q H2 \ ! + 5 !
4: ! (C / + 5 # ! 5 <4
? a%B !
"# 5 < 4: 5 H : 5 I< 4: J
' !< Q! ;! N < ; ! +Q
?, ; . 5 " 8$ V / f" ;>
S >R # 5 - 9 - 5 2 ; / / I 2 / J
? g $ # #X / + 'a
/ 8$ + 2 5 2 5 7 J
4 S !J /< W R -
?, /7 7 "
/8
!"#

8$ ; UC # 2 8 : 8$
! : 5 ! ; > " "# Q:7 "
S%R
? " .> @ <$ 5 ) ; ! > UB
! ! H > 5 " %BB 5 " U'U N " / :" f"
Y # # 5# - ! + 7 " ! >
? <$@ > 9 1 /
? -41 "# 2 ; !

IM 9 33 4 &<
A + 5 , / # 5 5
9 1N +(B%Cr(B%' 0 5 ./ 1 2 J !
N + / 3> 8 N +. / T) J !
? Q 2 4 N (% " E
>1 9 ! ." 2: 5 , ! / 5 Q N 5 <
?S O , #1R Q 7 N
2 . # (BU( i A/ 0 5 < # 8
Y 9 X A /2 E 5 2 "
R 4 5 #) Q " <) 5# - ! D 2
?S%a

) 6 Q ) I &=
Q A! > 5 A ">1 ,#$
< W + Va D @ A! e r Q (% " 1
8$ " #1 ? /2 J " W E J 4 W /
+(BB& +F/ ) R 4 > 5 7 " $: )-
?S(BB K
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
z c˜ • .# E N# # ’ O .L P , )0 : d nB, —0N=C D WXm B
Y[ Z :$ #$) : ) 0N% A

/
! $ , - *+ )
$
/

$
% &' ('
? L! ; E 7 . +- ,
A/ 0 JD J?(B%U + aB > airbus # 4 5 ! J $
? 2 " 2 +(BU(
!"#

:L 2 " Q:0 5 ?(B%& $: ! 9


L /< / 3> 3 O F/ 5 5
8$ Q D24 5 5 ! D" 3 7 @ 0 #)
! # Q 4 # F 4 2 2
?b " N) N 4 + #3

. -
.Q 0 3 -, ) I &
, A"# +Q : A# / " Monorail 2
2 f" ?d D 5 " 16 " <4 2 f" + "2
; ! L! > ?T / 0 r # rD 3 V& " 4
N # " ; )7 "#
9 1 1 2 5 2 " , : e <$ _ _ N 8$
>9 1 1 ./ +N $ F"4 0 2 L L! Q:
, Q"2 N , !e / +(B%% 6 7 L N 3> > +Q"2
:" D 3> N 5 + 4 < 1 ; : , $ ;> <
? > 8$ ! ,) G d! L
; >: , " G D 2 2> >
(a " %(& PPP _Q"2 >_ N $: + 4 CYD
S(R
? BOT L + & "# +
R ! 5 7 + Q"2 " U 9 1 e 5
+ / < W / 3> J ! + W S< 4
1 3 /7 " ; ! +5 E W T) 6
?D 2 Y 1 Q"2
+# !D 3 %a 1 30g %B 5 # Q"2 F 5 ;> 5
0 5 ! +Q " 2 0 > >! Q #5 6 + T/0
? L! L " " 5
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
T0C E` R T ;> # jR 2 j0)02 e` nB, w 9 ©# b < # s$<`
1 N;# + Transfer E)$¬+ Operate E 9+ Build 1 N b cB<WC W ` «BOT« P z" Y
%BC E "+ E #+
/!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

" 5 $ : A! 9 (B%Z (B%&


? ! 5 #

>+
]H ) .
F: / > i A 2 ; ! < J
- 5 * ; )/ ? # 4 #
?
8 L 5 > ,9 : > 2 2 * J
? H2 9 @ X 7
H2 9)/7 3> -" 7 " (B%% 2 D : J
# 5 # Q +E 3 7
! ! 2 5# :7 ! D 2/
5 ! J 94 1 D W D 5 " %(B
?D 5 " 'B
@ ! " ) 05 / # ;/ * J
? "# 5 . :" K 5
J ) W 9 W ! J R 0 2 2 J
? # A /1 5 M%&la ! ) S8
5 01 i , 5 * "# D J
+ " 9 ) 6 ; 5# :4 D
? M%' M%Z # 7 , $E
5) ) + > rD 3 'C 1 4 6 ,9 : G H: J
H: ? ! UlZ X ! Vla Vl( 1
2 5 5 ! ; / # r ala 1 @ #
?# r (BJC 5 e
5 M ZB ! >1 . ! , ) "# 5 > J
) $1 5 !+ 34 5 > 5 ! 2 " 5

/%
!"#

5 " M%B M%& 1 5 H: ( 5# !


?D "#
! M' 1 4 ! " 01 0 J
? @"
" L 5 # H: / # 9 - 2 * J
5 . L: 0 . : ; /" :" >7 7 c
?< 7
9)/ ! ; , N X 5 < 2 L ! J
? Bla ! 2 4 5# D 2 A" T$ : 5

$ .
+ O 5 . H2 9 @ X 9 @ 1 5O J e
I
9 ! : 4 < \ 2 : 5 E 5 9)/ 9 @ 1 J
5 / " 5 ! "# 2 / < "#
? %a
"4 "# 9 : 5 " 5 4 5 9)/ 9 @ 1 J
T$ Y E ) < / 57 E J
? ) - 5 3: ; L N
; E +< ; L: +5 ) : 4 ; 5 " 5 \ J
? ! 4 +S\ R< ; < @4 \ :4
9@ X , < 5 / F O J
? / ! D 1; /
2 < "# ) 2 A! . L : 0 <$ ;! J
?N
) 0 ! 5 n e : 3 J
? !
4 :" I 4 ! J
D * $ 5 5" 2 2 6 ) 5 " , : 9 7 A!

/+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

; / < , " J : * J . / % : 2 ;!
$ +32 1 : 2 ) (B%Z 2 " 5 4 +
? H:
A! ) N Q / 24 ; J
J ! 5 01 2: 0 J 2: 5 5 2 N
5 5 2 6 < 7 5 4 6 5 " "
# ! A! "# > 2 8$ 9 / 9
? @ ; > !
D" 5 + " 4 >0 3 L" L ! "# , / / - 1 J
" : 2 + @ ; > ! ! #1 8 $
?
)1 6 O , #1 K4 ; / 8 15 0 J
"# 5 #0 "2 Q H2 , / 8$ O m
? 2 / E D- 4 "

//
!"#

) , 9 3 3 '4 < . -Q

T ^ 3

S R 2 S R :L S R > &
S R 1S R 5 A D " J(
S R O! Va S R Va JUB 5 S R UB J%a 5 S R > %a 5 > r " 5 ) JU
! L , J%
S R O! > UB S R UB J(B 5 S R (B J%B 5 S R Q > %B 5 >
?S R 0 S R 2 J *< " : Ja
[ $ S R ! 2 / 51
S R0S R 2 *< " D 5 , 8 / 4 J'
S R0S R 2 D :" 2 JC
S R >- 1 S R S R I # ! J&
S R0S R 2 8 >1 5 5 , JZ
?S R 0S R 2 < " . 4
D 8" : D J%B
S R< S R5 7 S R, 8 / 4 S R :" H:
8 9 8/ - D J%%
S R " 5) S R )0 S R #7 S R 9
S R< S R6 S R , 4 #
5# 8 >1 2 J%(
S R J 34 5 S R 34 5 >
S R (5 S R %laJ% 5
I. ! / !8 J%V
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

/1
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

I. ! ) J%a
S R< S R # S R ) / S R !L S R 44
D $ 9 D ??? . ! D # J%'
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
?????????????????

S R 2 5 7 S RF S R ! 2" ! J%C
- ) D $ 0 2 Q J%&
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????S
???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????SD
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????SY
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????S
S R0 S R 2 W. " > > : J%Z
# .! 5 8 J(B
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????S
???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????SD
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????SY
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????S
S R0S R 2 [ O , #1 " # 5# , ! 8 J(%
8 $ 5# .! 2 <$ ! 2 / 51
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

/2
!"#

?(B%& # # . -Q
4
3 9 9T
M 4 #G
0 3 3
,0
%a J 5 J 1 ; / W %
, # $ 2 / J J5 " 5 J 5) : 4 W
W < @4 J J ) D J JE
J " J < @4 " J !
JL: J : 4 Jb /<
J :4 JE J \ "! J , ) J " J<
J5 W J : 5 J E" / J E
!J3 J < J
%U J 5 J 1 ; / W (
, # $ J 2 / J J5 " 5 J 5) : 4 J
J W < @4 J J ) D J "/
J : 4 J /< J< ) " 4
W J J " J< J L:
J J : 5 J :4 4> J "L J "/
!J 3 J < J J5
U S, 2 # *R J 5) : 4 J 5 J 1 ; / J
J E J E" / J : 5 ) D J 2 / J W 5 " 5
J ,) J \ "! J E W :4 " W W < @4 J J
J L: J < J " J : 4 J / < J < )
/< J : 4 J J " J< JL:
J J< ) " J : 5 – :4 4> J "L W "/ J
) D J J < @4
5 J J 2 / J
J 5) : 4 J 5 "
1; /J 5
V , # $ *R J 5) : 4 J 5 J 1 ; / J
J E J E" / J : 5 ) D J 2 / J W 5 " 5 .!
J ,) J \ "! J E W :4 " W W < @4 J J
J L: J < J " J : 4 J / < J < )
/< J : 4 J J " J< JL:
W J< ) " : 5 J :4 4> J "L J "/ J
) D J J < @4
5 J J 2 / J
J 5) : 4 J 5 "
1; /J 5

/7
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

. -Q @
4
3 9 9T
M 4 3 #G 3
0 3 3
,0
%( J @ W, Q J / J%N W 2 )# J ) W ) %
, # $ J 5 W W E W , W " Y / E
, > < J S< 2 , >R < 24 @ J
W 5 2 5) J ! 4 W 8 J S "" R E
D J S9 R 4 J JS R5 /J
J 2 J S, D R # J < 2 ; /J #
GR, Jb < J 4 J 4 J #
J / : W S- R 9-/ J 9 W J< JS s
?E J S< RQ
a J @ J, Q J / J%N W 2 )# J ) J ) (
, # $ J 5 W W E J , W " Y / )
, > < J S< 2 , >R < 24 @ J
J 5 2 5) J ! 4 J 8 J S "" R E
D J S9 R 4 J JS R5 /J
#J # J S, D R # J< 2 ; /J #
?) J ) J) < J ! WS R<
& 5 /J W5 2 5) W ! 4 J5 4 W8 8 V
, # $ J # D S9 5 R 4 W S R J
?5 J < W57 J< 2 ; / 5
a 5 /J W5 2 5) W ! 4 J5 4 W8 8 '
, # $ D J S9 5 R 4 W S R E J
W # J 2 W, D J< 2 ; /J # 5
D J Y / –%VD J < J 2/ Q J 4
JD 5 ! J < 2 J % D J S8 / >R ' D J %B
5 E J
C * J @ J, Q J / J % N W 2 )# J ) J ) %B
, # $ J 5 W W E W , W " Y /
T$ 0 , > < J S< 2 , >R < 24 @ J S< R
< W 5 2 5) J ! 4 J 8 J S "" R E
S% ;/ R D J S9 R 4 J JS R5 /J
J 2 W S, D R # J< 2 ; /J #
" b J J 5 " J -@ Q J #
?5 J

18
!"#

. -Q @
4
3 9 9T
M 4 3 #G 3
0 3 3
,0
' @ J, Q J / J%N W 2 )# J ) 9 %%
, # $ J5 J JE W, W " Y /J ) J
, > < J S< 2 , >R < 24 @ J
W5 2 5) J ! 4 J8 J S "" RE
S9 R 4 J JS R5 /J
V %a
JQ ! , > J< J ! S R W
, # $ J
< / J S8 " 2" R :0 J JE 2
E
5 E J5 E 4> J S5 RF , >J
5
U D R # J < 2 ; / W 5 7 J <
, # $ ) < J ! WS R< #J # W S, J5 %'
) J ) J )
V J @ J, Q J / J%N W 2 )# J ) J ) %&
, # $ J 5 W W E W , W " Y /
, > < J S< 2 , >R < 24 @ J 5
W5 2 5) J ! 4 J8 J S "" RE
J S9 R 4 J J S R 5 /J
J < J 5 7 J < 2 ; /J #D
?5
V J < 2 ; / J # D J S9 R 4 5 %Z
, # $ W 4 J # J 2 J S, D R # 9
< W S s GR, Jb < J 4 J
J S< RQ W / : W S- R 9-/ W 9 W W E
W " 4 J5 2 W J < JE
?E W E/
7! & & ' 6
$
?(B%& + + I L! D 2 J
5 + # ;) 5 + @ , 1+ 8 JD
?(B%& + *
? 4 - ; / 4 (B%& < JY

1
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

1
!"#

1!
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

9 8 2&(BB%( # 5 D 2 .+- Q

) 9 , 9
, 0 5 , 0 '
< 4 < 4
%BVl& %V%BBV' ZVl& UVUBaUC
ZZlC %UVBCaU ZUl( UUC('(U !
%%%l' %aB%V(U %BBl% U'((Ua' E
%%C %aCV%ZV %BUl% UCUB&aU
%%%l( %VZ'BVZ %BBl' U'VU'CV
%BUlZ %UZ&B%Z ZUl( UUCV'Z%
ZUl( %(aUC%U ZVl' UV(a&&a
Z%lZ %(U'U%U Z'la UVZaB%a E *
ZVl& %(CaV%V %BBlZ U'aVBa'
Zala %(&aUZV %%Bla UZZZB(C
ZBlZ %(((CUa %B'lV U&a(Ba' !
&ala %%VZZa( %B'l( U&V'a&B
88 / %%88+ 88 %!%%1!+! ' U
& !%+!!% & !/ 8/ ! 3
? 2 D +SVR SUR " "# 9 #1 5 Q " $

1%
!"#

? ! * : 4 ./- Q

?. ! ) / . -M $ ?8 # . -M $

5" / # 2 .%- M $ .!- M $


?, : " 5" : S V R

2 ./- M $ ; 2 ; .+- M $
? "# ?, D < 2 ; / < 7

1+
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

.? - 6 @-

A! 4 H 5 # A! 4 +A "/ + 4 5 2 IF/ ) J%
+ 7 2 +(B(B # " . N- 5 2 5
?(BB& + 7
W R " "# : IK # 1 -/1 J(
2 + 4 ! @/ 2/ + 2 ! @/ "/ + ! @/ A! S >
?(BBU + 9)/ +VU
+ O , #1 N 5 I 4 ; > , / JU
?(B%& (C +SVR 2
5 5 " 2 2" \ I9 4 2 2" ) ) / JV
?(B%C +N " 5 4 5 #+ m
? 2 " 2 I(BU( A/ 0 Ja
5# +Q "2 ) I L! D 2 J'
?%ZZ( + * +
I L! D 2 JC
?(B%& +
+ $ # Q "2 ) I L! D 2 &
?(B%&J(B%( # 5 D #O 5 +9 4 "2 , 1
+ $ # Q "2 ) I L! D 2 JZ
?(B%&J(B%( # 5 ` 5 +9 4 "2 , 1
?(B%& +3 ; 4 +A L I; 4" 2 J%B
https://www.aoi.org.eg/index.php?lang=ar
+ 9 6" L H2 A! @/ " I< 4 5 / J%%
?(B%U + 7 9)/ +'% 2 + 4 ! @/ 2/ + 2 ! @/ "/
"/ 0 +% + ! @/ / 2 + - > ID < J%(
?(B%& +, + 4
A! A 2 b 5 :4 + I J%U
?(BBa +6 " , 2 + 7 2 +6 42
SU(%R ! @/ + / + + : +< ! @/ IT # 2 J%V
?(BBC + 2 / + ! @/ >

1/
!"#

?%ZZB +H +b + ! @/ 6 I e :4 J%a
+ D 2 + b 5# I5 g 4 2 # "# J%'
?(BBB
?%Za& + 4 + I # 4 J%C
?(B%U + aB > airbus # 4 5 I ! J%&
?(B%& + *5 + N O 5 + 4 , 1I 8 J%Z
# ;) 5 + @ , 1 I 8 J(B
.(B%& + *5 +
?(B%& + *5 + N O 5 + 4 , 1I : 4 J(%
Q 2 / "/ +5 2 , 2 A! " 4 A! IQ- < J((
?(C%J(VC K K +(B%( +% N +(& + "2"
"/ 7 + 2 + \ E I 5 )# Q ! J(U
?(BBa +, + 4
24- Dimter, S, Tanasi , Z, Zagvozda, M, Ruška, F (2016)Development of tram
traffic in the city of Osijek, Elektroni ki asopisgra evinskogfakulteta
Osijek, pp. 71-79.
25- El-Bushra, E; Urbaniztion, Urban Growth and Change in The Middel East,
Bulletin of The Egyptian Geographical Society, Vol. 79, 2006. (El-Bushra,
E; 2006, p. 1).
26- Fraser, H, A. Christopher, P. Kennedy, C. Webster, T. Vardanega, P, J.
Johansson, A (2015) A new tram network for Bristol a possible scenario,
Municipal Engineer; Volume 169; Issue ME1, ICE Publishing, pp. 19-30.
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/25d9/d12125c699ea9960872aaa24dde9e3a
d750d.pdf
27- Harvey, G (2012): City of Nottingham Expands Tram System; IEEE
Vehicular Technology Magazine 1 June, pp. 18-22.
28- Kovandová H. and Válka R. (2014): Experimental Study of Non-
Compatible Collision of Rail and Road Vehicle, Promet – Traffic &
Transportation, Vol. 26, 2014, No. 6, 459-466 459.
29- Henry, K (1950): Traffic Engineering Handbook, Second Edition, institute
of Traffic Engineering, NewHaven, Connecticut.
30- Šojat, D, Br i , D, Slavulj, M (2017): Analysis of public transport service
improvements on tram network in the City of Zagreb,Technical gazette,
Vol. 24 No. 1, pp. 217-223. https://doi.org/10.17559/TV-20151123143049
31- West of England Partnership, WEP (2010): West of England Joint Local
Transport Plan 3, 2011-2026, Engagement Draft, July 2010.

11
! $ , - *+ ) $ $ % &' ('

This study examines one of the most significant and popular urban
electrical transport lines in Alexandria, represented in the tram network, which
started since 1862. Despite the environmental benefits of tram transport due to
the absence of ecological harmful pollutants, it faces, nevertheless, several
complications to compete against other means of land transport due to their
progress and decline of its efficiency; as a result of the destruction of
infrastructure, which was not updated almost half a century. The study aims to
compare the tram-lines in Alexandria in terms of movement, efficiency and
geographical influence. Furthermore, to evaluate the obstacles which hampered
efficiency.
This study is a field work search, conducted in June and July of both years
2017 and 2018, and January 2018 to measure the density of Passenger traffic in
stations, the geographical influence of tram lines, and identify the difficulties
facing both workers and passengers; as well as drawing tracks properly on maps.
This paper utilized indicators and coefficients to measure correlations,
seasonality, network centralization, and operating capacity.

The study concluded:


- The tram efficiency index is lower than the global indicators in terms of
efficiency, operational capacity, headway and per capita lines.
- Despite the decline of activity and the deterioration of the infrastructure of
the majority of tram lines, nevertheless, it is still the chief means of
transport, especially for the majority of residents of the suburb of Raml,
because of the cheapness and availability of safety element, which allowed
it to maintain its place among other competitor means of transport.
- Trams contribute only a small percentage in the recreation movement up to
6% for decline of trains and their equipment.

12

You might also like