Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reading Sesion
Reading Sesion
Reading Sesion
DOI 10.22146/jcef.3458
Available Online at: https://jurnal.ugm.ac.id/v3/JCEF/issue/archive
ABSTRACT Several CPT-SPT correlations have been reported worldwide to allow for the estimate of soil physical properties from one set
of accessible data to another. Although most correlations are for silty and sandy soils, there is insufficient information on whether these
correlations correspond to the silty clay soil conditions in Indonesia. Therefore, this study aims is to validate and enhance the generalized
CPT-SPT correlation, with emphasis on Indonesian soil conditions to increase its prediction accuracy. The soil under examination is silty
clay layers that cover most of Northern parts of West Java – Indonesia. Known with its expansive clay characteristics, these type of soils
are sensitive to volume change as a result of seasonal variations in water content. For this study, data is collected from 8 (eight) locations
in Cikarang Area. Each location consists of dedicated SPT and CPT pairs tests at 2 (two) m distance between each other. After analyzed
with various statistical regression analysis of data relevant to this type of soil, a simple linear empirical CPT-SPT correlation with a fairly
high correlation has been established allowing test findings to be translated and predicted for the relevant soils type. The simple CPT and
SPT correlation is in form of n = qc/NSPT = 0.225 (Mpa), with data distribution of n ranges from 0.15 (Mpa) to 0.33 (Mpa). This results shows
much lower n values compared to various correlation have been published worldwide. With respect to the clay soil formation, the low of
n-value also reflect a lower density and cohesion bonding clay properties.
245
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
Table 1. CPT – SPT correlations from some literature (Shahri et al., 2014)
246
Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022)
247
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
Robert Hall (2009) stated that most Java Island coastal plains. This indicates sedimentation
were considered part of the Woyla Terranes in continues to be considered in the basins of Sunda
the early Tertiary, approximately 65.5 million and Asri, located in North West Java. These
years ago. In the mid-Eocene, about 40 million sediments started to fold and rise due to renewed
years ago, there was lifting, subsidence, and subductive activity towards the end of the
sedimentation along the edge of the larger Miocene. This led to the elevation of a former
Sundaland due to the subduction of the India- coastal sedimentation region, approximately 50
Australia and Eurasia plates. Correspondingly, m above sea level. These bending and lifting
this subduction action resulted in forming a actions, along with tropical rains and erosion,
depressed complex band of hills, volcanoes, and resulted in wavy low undulating hills.
mountainous terrain in the Bogor and Bandung
zones of West Java. Clement and Hall (2008) In accordance with the aforementioned analyses,
reported that rows of mountains and volcanoes the outcome of 100-meter-deep drilling shows
were actively created about 14 million years ago that the study area is structured from alluvial
from the mid-Eocene to the Middle Miocene. sediment materials. According to Geology Map
These activities ceased in the mid-Miocene by Ratman and Gafoer (1998), this sediment was
epoch but resumed towards the end formed during the quaternary periods (>2.5 ma)
approximately five million years ago and were as deposition of volcanic lava and mud flows of
relocated 50 km north. hinterland mountains such as Mount Salak,
Gede, and Pangrango, including the coastal
Extensive weathering usually occurs in the plain. These soft-grained sediments
central belt zone, under a severe tropical accumulated into shale in the Java Sea basins for
environment, consisting of a series of mountains thousands to millions of years.
and volcanoes known as the Bandung and Bogor
zones. Tropical rain degraded the cones of Occasionally, volcanic ash tends to settle and is
volcanoes, mountains, plateaus, and any other deposited on these sediments. Leaching is
remnants of subduction zones. This also resulted restricted in areas with poor drainage conditions,
in residual soils transported by rainwater and thereby triggering the accumulation of
rivers. In addition, these sedimentary sediments magnesium, calcium, sodium, and iron cations in
tend to gravitate toward northern Java's low the system. A combination of volcanic ash and
248
Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022)
shale progressively changes into clay shale SNI 4153:2008 to consider the effective vertical
containing montmorillonite. One of the clay stress (N1) and energy efficiency (N60). However,
mineral concentrations in soils contributes to its the correction factor applied is shown in Table 2.
expansive feature and is a reason for worry due Laboratory analyses on undisturbed samples
to its engineering challenges that must be show that soil's unit weight varies from 1.66 to
addressed in modern days. 1.89 tons/m3, with an average value of 1.775
tons/m3. Generally, no groundwater table was
4 DATA COLLECTION AND PROCESS
found except a small quantity traped in the sandy
This study was carried out using existing SPT- soil lenses. Figure 4 shows the results of the
CPT pairs collected in Cibatu Village, Cikarang, calculated NSPT corrections.
West Java, Indonesia, which is known for having
expansive soil difficulties. Data used consisted of Figure 4(a) shows the distribution of NSPT
37 pairs of CPT-SPT with a 2 m distance between within the five drill points studied. Although the
each. degree of proliferation was not clearly defined,
the graph shows that it tends to increase with
4.1 Standard Penetration Test (SPT) depth. This is related to the vertical overburden
stress and the density of the soil, which tends to
SPT is a commonly performed in-situ approach,
be denser at the bottom. It also depends on
which used to determine the density and
variations in soil type, such as the content of
consistency of sandy and clay or silt layers,
sand, silt, and clay, mineralogy, presence or
respectively. This test is generally carried out
absence of cementation, chemical bonding etc.
simultaneously with drilling and soil sampling.
Figure 4(b) shows that the value of the corrected
In this study, SPT was executed based on a depth
NSPT, (N1)60, ranges from 7 to 27 with an average
interval of 2 m in accordance with the ASTM D
of 15.7 strokes. This implies that its equivalence
1586. Visual identification was carried out as
to the vertical stress of 1 kg/cm2 and the hammer
soon as the sample was removed from the split
energy efficiency, the N value does not diverge
poon sampler as an interpretation of SPT data is
significantly. This minute N value is closely
strictly achievable for suitable soil types.
related to the soil type dominated by clay
In total, 37 drilling and SPT tests were carried deposits. Meanwhile, the almost uniform value
out, and based on the acquired data, the of (N1)60 versus depth reflects the uniformity of
interpretation of the approximate soil layering or soil stratigraphy.
stratigraphy is shown in Figure 3. Generally, the
4.2 Cone Penetration Test (CPT)
SPT results show that soil consistency becomes
harder with depth. The hard layers (SPT > 50) CPT is widely used in a more simple soil
were detected at various depths from 8 m (BH 36) investigation programme. The test is conducted
to 32 m (BH 44). However, the SPT value tends to by penetrating a cone through the soil layer to
decrease with depth. This results in a value of 30 determine the ground resistance toward it, QC
~ 40, which means the soil is firmly consistent. (endpoint resistance), and the blanket friction, fs
Virtually every test point displayed similar (blanket resistance). With the measurements
behavior. It is also notable that some of them above, it is possible to determine the shear
failed to acquire SPT > 50 consistently down to a strength and layering of soils, as well as design
depth of 60 m (BH 42) or 90 m (BH 39). These parameters. In this study, the CPT test was
results are closely related to the process of soil carried out using a Begemann type cone and rigs
formation in previous studies. The settlement of with 2.5 tons capacity. The reading was taken at
various sediment materials with different an interval of 20 cm, even though the naming of
thickness and period also triggered the test points was similar to its drilling, it was
consistency of the soil with depth.For analysis carried out within 2 m of the SPT, as shown in
purposes, NSPT data were corrected according to Figures 5a and b.
249
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
250
Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022)
(a) (b)
(a)
(b)
Figure 5. NSPT and CPT BH #7 OC (a) and NSPT and CPT BH #13 OC (b)
251
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
5 DATA ANALYSIS AND RESULTS ~ 4.0, except at some points where the n value was
6.36.
The magnitude and the variation of (n) = qc/NSPT
with respect to depth are illustrated Three statistical analyses were performed: (i)
simultaneously with the test results shown in Least-squares linear correlation with an intercept
Figures 5a and b. At BH 7 OC, for depth d = 0.0 ~ at the origin, qc = a + b.NSPT (ii) Least-squares
2.5 m, n slowly increases from 0 to 2. linear correlation qc = n.NSPT and (iii) Least
Furthermore, at d = 2.5 ~ 12.4 m, n is within the square power correlation, qc = c.NSPT d. Figure 6
range of 1.5 ~ 2.7, these are similar to the study shows the plotting of CPT against the SPT at a
carried out by Barata et al. (1979) on sandy, silty similar depth where both tests were carried out as
clay, and clayey silty sand. well as the linear regression trendline and
coefficient of determination, R2 = 0.65.
At BH 13, for d = 0.0 ~ 3.0 m, n gradually increases n = qc/NSPT = 0.225 (Mpa) (1)
from 0 to 2, while at d = 3.0 ~ 7.0 m, the variation with:
of n is slightly wider between 2.0 ~ 3.8, and at d = upper limit : n = qc/NSPT = 0.33 (Mpa) (2)
7.0 ~ 12.4 m, the variation of n is between 1.2 ~ lower limit : n = qc/NSPT = 0.15 (Mpa) (3)
2.4. For BH 26, at d = 0.0 ~ 4.0 m, the range of n
variations seems to be between 2.0 ~ 4.0, which This trend was generated by ignoring 4 (four) data
narrows down to d = 4.0 ~ 7.4 m where n is within situated far from the general trend. These were
the range of 1.0 ~ 2.18. At BH 26, the CPT test only obtained from BH 2A, BH 4, BH6 taken at Cicau
reaches a depth of 3.0 m, as it encounters a Village. The excessive value of CPT at this
sandstone layer lens, thereby making it difficult location reflects the sturdiness of the unexposed
to analyze. However, for depths of 0.5 to 3 m, the or unweathered clay shale. However, assuming
value of n is stretched between 1.2 to 5.8. the analysis was only made using data from
Cibatu, a higher confidence level of R2= 0.79 tends
At Cibatu, n = qc/NSPT varied at a certain value,
to be achieved.
and different characteristics were observed. In BH
2A, the n values consistently increase and 6 DISCUSSION
correspond to its depth, which was obtained as 10
at the end of the CPT test, d = 13.5 m. A similar The results are consistent with Robin (2012),
incident occurred at BH 6, and it is closely related which was carried out within 6 km of the study
to the degree of clay shale weathering at the locations. Robin stated that the data distribution
active zone, possibly reflected by QC. of qc/NSPT (Mpa) ranges from 0.14 to 0.34.
Although the result of the upper boundary differs
This indicates the higher the QC value, the lower slightly, n = 0.38, this analysis was made by
the weathering rate of the clay shale. At BH 2A, disregarding 2 data, namely BH 7, d = 12 m and BH
the weathering is estimated to have occurred at a 13, d = 16 m. At those depths, the cone
depth of 7 m, while at BH 6A, it only reached 6 m. penetration almost reaches its final reading,
For BH 4, the bore log shows a layer of clayed sand resulting in a high QC value of 12 MPa and 16.4
soil at 10 m depth, with n values varying from 1.58 MPa.
252
Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022)
253
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
phenomenon is evident in BH 7, BH 13, BH 2A, and Soil data will increase the accuracy of the
and BH 6A, except in BH 40, where the soil type proposed correlations.
encountered at a depth of 3 m is sandstone.
REFERENCES
This led to an important finding because almost
every commercial and industrial building, such as Akca, N. 2003. Correlation of SPT–CPT data from
housing, factories, and low-rise offices in the the United Arab Emirates, Engineering Geology,
Cikarang area, is always designed based on CPT 67,: 219 –231.
test data. It is also important to note that the
American Society for Testing and Material, ASTM
depth acknowledged through this analysis is most
Designation D : 1586 – 99. 1999. Standard Test
likely from the active zone acquired. The soils
Method for Penetration Test and Split-Barrel
undergo swelling and shrinkage at this depth as
Sampling of Soils.
the water content increases or decreases. The
piles' designed length must be elongated Badan Standarisasi Nasional, Standar Nasional
underneath the active zone to avoid its Indonesia, SNI 4153 : 2008, Cara Uji Penetrasi
detrimental effects. This is even more crucial to Lapangan dengan SPT.
developing areas preceded by land grading. The
CPT test was carried out at shallow depths Chin, C.T., Duann, S.W. and Kao, T.C. 1988. SPT-
because the active zone had not reached a stable CPT Correlations For Granular S oils, Proceedings
depth. But over time, it tends to increase due to of International Symposium on Penetration
weathering. This factor must be considered in the Testing, ISOPT-1, Orlando, USA, Balkema,
future CPT test basis foundation design. Rotterdam, Vol. 1, pp. 335-339.
The proposed correlation can radily be used to Hall, Robert, 2009. Indonesia, Geology.
estimate and predict the NSPT soil parameter of Encyclopedia of Islands. University of California
known CPT’s cone resistance, QC parameter or Press; pp. 454-460.
vice versa for correspond soils types and
characteristics. Addition of more future SPT, CPT
254
Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022)
Hore, R., Al-Mamun, S. and Ansary, M. A. 2018. Robertson, P. K. 2009. Interpretation of Cone
SPT-CPT Correlation for Reclaimed Areas of Dhaka, Penetration Tests - A Unified Approach, Canadian
Journal of Engineering Science 09(1), pp. 35-46. Geotechnical Journal, 46 (11),: 1337– 1355.
Ismael, N.F., Jeragh, A.M. 1986. Static Cone Tests Schmertmann, J. H. 1970. Static Cone to Compute
and Settlement of Calcareous Desert Sands, Static Settlement Over Sand, Journal of the Soil
Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 23 (3), pp. 297– Mechanics and Foundations Division, ASCE, 96
303. (3),: 1011-1043.
Jefferies, M.G. and Davies, M.P. 1993. Use of CPTU Schmertmann, J. H. 1976. Predicting the qc/N ratio
To Estimate Equivalent SPT N60. Journal of Interpreting the Dynamics of the Standard
Geotechnical Testing ;16(4): 458–68. Penetration Test, University of Florida Report to
the Department of Transportation, Florida
Kullhawy, F.H. and Mayne, P.H. 1990. Manual on
Estimating Soil Properties For Foundation Design. Shahri, A.A, Juhlin, C. and Malemir A. 2014. A
EPRI Report. Reliable Correlation of SPT-CPT Data for Southwest
of Sweden, Electronic Journal of Geotechnical
Luanne, T., Robertson, P. K., and Powell, J. J. M. Engineering, 19,: 1013-1032
1997. Cone Penetration Testing In Geotechnical
Practice, Blackie Academic, EF Spon/Routledge Stark, T. D., and Olson, S. M. (1995). Liquefaction
Publications, New York. Resistance Using CPT and Field Case Histories.
Journal of Geotechnical Engineering. ASCE,
Rahman, S.Z. and Harris, R.W. 1984. The Nature 121(12), 856-869.
and Characteristics Of The Soils in The Regions of
Dubai and Abu Dhabi, Symposium on the nature Suherman. 2005. Penanganan Tanah Expansif
and characteristics of oils in the UAE and untuk Konstruksi Jalan. Pedoman Konstruksi dan
Foundation Engineering, Dubai. No. 1,: 7– 17. Bangunan, Departemen Pekerjaan Umum.
Ratman N, and Gafoer, S. 1998, Peta Geologi Bemmelen, R. W., 1949. The Geology of Indonesia
Lembar Jawa Bagian Barat (Skala 1:500,000), Vol. IA, General Geology and Adjacent
Badan Geologi, Pusat Vulkanologi dan Mitigasi Archipelagos, Government Printing Office, The
Bencana Geologi. Hague, Netherlands.
Robertson, P. K., Campanella, R. G. and A. Winata, Robin. 2012. Studi Karakteristik Tanah
Wightman. 1983. SPT-CPT Correlations, Journal Ekspansif di Daerah Cikarang dan Surabaya
of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, ASCE, menggunakan Analisis Regresi Berganda dan Uji
109(11),: 1449-1459. Lapangan, Master’s Thesis. Program Pasca
Sarjana Magister Teknik Sipil Fakultas Teknik,
Universitas Katolik Parahyangan, Bandung.
255
Vol. 8 No. 3 (September 2022) Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum
256