Page 58-65

Title: "The Painting of Modern Life: Capitalism, Revolution, and Utopian Thought in Second
Empire Paris"

I. Introduction
- The book "The Painting of Modern Life" by T.J. Clark explores the impact of Baron
Haussmann's urban transformation of Second Empire Paris.
- Clark argues that this transformation was rooted in a capitalistic reimagining of the city's
purpose and form.
- Capital aimed to replace existing city images with its own, devoid of accessible imagination,
readings, or con icts.

II. The Missing City Images

- Clark's argument focuses on commodi cation and spectacle, but he neglects to discuss the
images of the city that were displaced.

III. Repression and Shift in Sensibility after 1848

- The revolution of 1848 repressed romanticism and socialist utopianism in France.
- Many revolutionaries were lost due to death, exile, or discouragement.
- A shift in sensibility occurred, leading to scienti c socialism and bourgeois positivism.

IV. Pre-1848 Views of the City and Society

- Examining how people, especially progressives, perceived and imagined the city and society
before 1848.
- Exploring possibilities and what the Empire had to counteract.

V. The Republic and the City as a Body Politic

- Flora Tristan's monument dedication in Bordeaux in 1848 symbolizes the representation of
Liberty as a woman.
- How the woman symbol was portrayed and its signi cance.
- The nurturing social republic represented by Daumier in 1848.

VI. Imagery of the Ideal Republic and City

- The connection between thinking about the republic and the city.
- Historical examples of socialist and utopian thinkers considering urban development and
planning as a form of political and social organization.

VII. Turbulent Currents of Thought

- The complexities of di erent schools of thought in the 1830s and 1840s.
- Mixing rational Enlightenment principles with romanticism, Christian mysticism, science, and
utopianism.
- Fragmentation and adaptation of ideas as political-economic conditions changed.

VIII. Turning the World Right Side Up

- Saint-Simon's desire to "turn the world right side up" through rational and paci c change.
- The legacy of the French Revolution, disillusionment, and revival of republican alternatives.
- The emergence of socialist ideas as a response to social inequality and industrialization.

IX. Legacy of Revolutionary-Period Thinkers

- François Babeuf's economic and political socialism.
- August Blanqui's conspiratorial schemes and belief in a dictatorship for the proletariat.
- Saint-Simon and Fourier's contributions to socialist and reformist thought, despite their
complex and open-to-interpretation legacies.

The text explores the multifaceted history of Second Empire Paris, shedding light on the socio-
political, ideological, and artistic shifts that took place during this transformative period.
fl
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
Here are the key points from the provided text:

**Introduction:**
- T.J. Clark, an art historian, discusses the impact of Haussmann's restructuring of Second Empire
Paris, linking it to capitalism.
- Capital is argued to prefer the city not to have a de ned image, so it can produce its own.

**Changes After 1848:**

- 1848 marked a shift in French sensibility, rede ning political struggle for both left and right.
- Socialism became more scienti c, while bourgeois thought became more positivist and
managerial.
- This shift is considered a part of the transition to modernity and modernism.

**Representation of Liberty:**
- Since 1789, the Republic, the Revolution, and Liberty were often depicted as women.
- This countered the monarchical theory of the state embodied by the king.
- In the French Revolution, the King's image was satirically portrayed with the Phrygian cap of
liberty.

**Variations in Liberty Representation:**

- The way Liberty was represented had signi cance.
- Opponents of republicanism portrayed her negatively, while respectable bourgeois republicans
preferred digni ed depictions.
- Revolutionaries preferred a more ery representation.

**Daumier's Unique Depiction:**

- Daumier's representation of the Republic in 1848 is notable for its maternal aspect.
- It emphasizes a nurturing social republic over political or revolutionary symbolism.
- This aligns with Danton's declaration that education is a primary need.

**Ideal Republic and City Connection:**

- The imagery of the ideal republic was closely tied to that of the ideal city.
- The government of a large state like France was thought to be akin to governing a city.

**Socialist Interest in Urban Planning:**

- Various groups, including the Saint-Simonians, were dedicated to creating new social and
spatial forms in cities.
- The symbolic dimension of urban development was also considered.

**Confusion in Political Thought:**

- From the 1820s onward, various groups of thinkers formed, bonded, and fractured, resulting in
confusion in political thought.
- Enlightenment principles mixed with romanticism, science, materialism, empiricism, and
utopianism.

**Legacy of Revolutionary Thinkers:**

- François Babeuf and Buonarotti promoted economic and political socialism as the next step in
the French Revolution.
- August Blanqui revived this tradition in the 1830s with conspiratorial schemes.
- Blanqui advocated for a transition program involving dictatorship in the name of the proletariat.

**Saint-Simon and Fourier's In uence:**

- Saint-Simon and Fourier provided di erent perspectives on socialist and reformist thought.
- They left legacies aspiring to universality but were often confusing and open to multiple
interpretations.

The text primarily explores the impact of political and social changes in France during the 19th
century, with a focus on the representation of Liberty, the connection between the ideal republic
and city, and the in uence of various thinkers on socialist thought.
fi
fl
fl
fi
fi
ff
fi
fi
fi
 Certainly, I can summarize the main points from the provided text:

1. T.J. Clark, in "The Painting of Modern Life," argues that Haussmann's transformation of Second
Empire Paris was rooted in a capitalistic vision of the city, emphasizing the importance of capital
in reshaping the urban landscape.

2. Capital, according to Clark, did not require a physical representation but rather sought to erase
the city's existing image and replace it with one of its own making.

3. Clark discusses the mechanisms of commodi cation and spectacle in the new urban
landscape but doesn't delve into the details of the displaced city images.

4. The text highlights the suppression of romanticism and socialist utopianism during the
counterrevolution of 1848–1851 in France.

5. Many participants in the social movements of 1848 were lost due to death, exile, or
discouragement, leading to a signi cant shift in sensibility in France after 1848.

6. After 1848, socialism became more "scienti c" while bourgeois thought became more
positivist, managerial, and tough-minded.

7. The transition to modernity and modernism is discussed as a result of these shifts.

8. The text raises questions about what was repressed, destroyed, or co-opted during the
counterrevolution of 1848–1851.

9. Before 1848, the Republic, the Revolution, and Liberty were often depicted as feminine gures,
challenging the traditional monarchical idea of the state embodied by the king.

10. The text mentions the use of satirical imagery, such as placing the cap of liberty on the king's
head, to symbolize the king's impotence during the French Revolution.

11. There's a discussion of di erent representations of Liberty and Revolution, with varying levels
of re and symbolism.

12. Flora Tristan, a pioneering gure in socialist feminism, is mentioned, and her signi cance in
1848 is explained.

13. The ideal republic's imagery is linked to the ideal city, with the government thinking of its
territory as a large city.

14. Socialists, communists, feminists, and reformers of the 1840s paid attention to the city as a
fundamental part of the body politic and a vision for a future good society.

15. César Daly is noted as an imposing gure who translated ideas into architectural forms and
practical projects in urban administration during the 1840s.

16. The text acknowledges that while there was a general connection between thinking about the
republic and the city, the details were often lost in confusion regarding how the body politic
should be constituted and governed.

17. From the 1820s onward, various groups of thinkers formed, bonded, imploded, or fractured,
resulting in an array of ideas that were recombined into di erent modes of thought.

18. Con icting ideologies, including rational Enlightenment principles, romanticism, Christian
mysticism, science, materialism, empiricism, and utopianism, in uenced the turbulent currents of
thought during this period.
fi
fl
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
ff
fl
fi
fi
 19. The text discusses the legacy of Revolutionary-period thinkers, such as François Babeuf and
August Blanqui, who advocated for economic and political socialism.

20. Blanqui's transition program involved assuming state power to establish a dictatorship in the
name of the proletariat to educate the masses and instill capacities for self-governance.

21. Claude-Henri de Saint-Simon and Fourier provided di erent perspectives on reforming society
but left behind incomplete and often confusing legacies open to multiple interpretations.

These are the main points extracted from the text.

PAGE 65-72
**Summary of the Text:**

**1. Introduction: Saint-Simon and His In uence**

- Saint-Simon is considered the founder of positivist social science.
- His approach involved studying society's actual condition and proposing changes for its
betterment.
- He often communicated his ideas through open letters, tracts, and memoranda to in uential
gures.

**2. Historical Context and Evolution of Saint-Simon's Ideas**

- Saint-Simon believed that societies had previously achieved harmonious states (e.g., feudalism)
but later dissolved into contradictions.
- He saw the crisis in his time as a transition from a feudal ecclesiastical system to an industrial
and scienti c one.
- The French Revolution addressed hereditary privileges but failed in its approach.

**3. Transition to an Industrial and Scienti c Society**

- Saint-Simon proposed transferring spiritual power from priests to scientists and artists and
temporal power to industrial leaders.
- He advocated minimizing government intervention and promoting e cient administration to
facilitate productive activities.
- He emphasized Europe-wide cooperation for peaceful economic development.

**4. Organization of Production and Useful Work**

- Saint-Simon stressed the proper organization of production and useful work as a remedy for
societal problems.
- He promoted individual initiative, liberty, and sometimes echoed laissez-faire ideals.

**5. Political Institutions for Maximizing Individual Liberty**

- Saint-Simon proposed a system with three chambers of governance: Chamber of Invention,
Chamber of Execution, and Chamber of Examination.
- He believed that natural leaders should be determined by technical ability and merit.
- He emphasized the need for moral incentives alongside self-interest.

**6. In uence and Spread of Saint-Simon's Ideas**

- Saint-Simon's followers published accounts of his ideas after his death, leading to increased
interest.
- Meetings in the early 1830s garnered support from reform-minded bourgeois and workers.
- Saint-Simonian feminists played a role in issues like divorce and women's work.
- Some followers, like Pierre Leroux, turned to Christian socialism.

**7. Louis Napoleon's Engagement with Saint-Simonian Ideas**

fi
fl
fi
fl
fi
ff
ffi
fl
 - Louis Napoleon engaged with Saint-Simonian ideas, particularly regarding large-scale public
works and the right to work.
- He proposed state legislation to create workingmen's associations for land cultivation and
employment.
- His proposals were met with both support and mockery.

**8. Introduction of Charles Fourier and His Ideas**

- Fourier published "The Theory of the Four Movements" in 1808, proposing a transition from
social chaos to universal harmony.
- His ideas involved agricultural association and passionate attraction.
- Fourier's work was considered di use and enigmatic, with some unconventional arguments.

**9. Fourier's Critique of Civilization and Poverty**

- Fourier criticized civilization as organized repression of healthy instincts.
- He attributed poverty to the ine cient organization of production, distribution, and consumption.
- Commerce was seen as destructive to human well-being.

**10. Fourier's Vision of Phalanstères**

- Fourier proposed the creation of communities called "Phalanstères" to organize production and
consumption collectively.
- These communities aimed to provide happiness, variety of work, and social and sexual
engagements.
- Detailed principles were developed for matching individuals based on passionate attractions.

**11. Proliferation of Alternative Thought (1840)**

- The year 1840 witnessed the publication of various in uential works, including Proudhon's
"What Is Property" and Cabet's "Voyage in Icaria."
- Romantic writers supported radical reform, and worker protests and strikes occurred.

**12. Diverse Diagnoses and Proposed Remedies**

- Di erent thinkers had various diagnoses of societal problems, including issues with civilization,
inequality, individualism, patriarchy, and capitalism.
- Proposed remedies ranged from dictatorship of the proletariat to social equality and worker
empowerment.

**13. Equality as a Central Theme**

- Equality was a common concern, but interpretations varied.
- Debate revolved around equality of life chances, empowerment, gender equality, and the role of
women in the workforce.

**14. Women's Emancipation and Role in Equality**

- Women's emancipation was considered essential for overall societal liberation.
- Issues of gender equality, the right to work, and women's autonomy were discussed.
- Concerns arose about the limited career opportunities for women and wage disparities.

**15. Conclusion: The Diversity of Radical Arguments**

- The text highlights the intense diversity and creativity of radical arguments during this period.
- There was widespread agreement about the existence of societal problems but di ering views
on diagnosis and solutions.

This summary breaks down the text into key subheadings and provides detailed points within
each section for clarity.

Certainly, I can break down the provided text into key points covering each detail:

1. **Saint-Simon as the Founder of Positivist Social Science**:

- Saint-Simon is considered the founder of positivist social science.
ff
ffi
ff
fl
ff
 - He emphasized the need to study the actual condition of society to bring about harmony and
productivity.
- Many of his works were open letters, tracts, or memoranda to in uential people, addressing
societal issues.

2. **Evolution of Saint-Simon's Ideas**:

- Saint-Simon's ideas evolved from 1802 until his nal, un nished work on the new Christianity,
published posthumously in 1826–1827.

3. **Historicist View of Human Evolution**:

- Saint-Simon believed that the body politic had taken harmonious forms in the past and should
evolve to a new harmonious state.
- This view in uenced subsequent thinkers, including Marx.

4. **Crisis in the Body Politic**:

- Saint-Simon saw the crisis in his time as a transition from a feudal ecclesiastical system to an
industrial and scienti c one.
- The French Revolution addressed hereditary privileges but failed due to centralized state
power and violence.

5. **Role of the Industrial Class**:

- Saint-Simon advocated transferring power from aristocrats and priests to industrials, including
workers, scientists, and thinkers.
- He called for minimizing government intervention and e cient administration to facilitate
productive activities.

6. **Government's Role**:
- Government should ensure that "useful work is not hindered" and shift from command to
e ective administration.
- Saint-Simon proposed a Europe-wide system for peaceful and progressive economic
development.

7. **Emphasis on Production and Useful Work**:

- Saint-Simon stressed the importance of organizing production and useful work to address
societal issues.
- He supported individual initiative and liberty, echoing laissez-faire ideals.

8. **Political Institutions**:
- Saint-Simon focused on designing political institutions to maximize individual liberty and
promote collective projects.
- He proposed three chambers of governance, including one for invention, execution, and
examination.

9. **Diversity Among Industrials**:

- Saint-Simon recognized diversity among industrials but believed in the common interest of
educated elites making decisions.

10. **Moral Incentives**:

- Saint-Simon emphasized the need for moral incentives beyond self-interest and egotism.
- He called for a new form of Christianity based on moral principles.

11. **Spread of Saint-Simon's Ideas**:

- Saint-Simon's followers published his ideas after his death, and interest grew after the July
Revolution.
- Meetings and educational e orts gained support from reform-minded bourgeois and workers.

12. **Role of Saint-Simonian Feminists**:

- Saint-Simonian feminists evolved their ideas on divorce and women's work, playing a role in
1848.
ff
fl
fi
ff
fi
ffi
fi
fl
 13. **Shifts Toward Christian Socialism**:
- Pierre Leroux embraced associationist Christian socialism, identifying individualism as a moral
disease.
- Socialism aimed to restore unity among societal parts.

14. **Louis Napoleon's Engagement**:

- Louis Napoleon engaged with Saint-Simonian ideas, promoting large-scale public works and
the right to work.

15. **Fourier's Vision**:

- Fourier published "The Theory of the Four Movements" in 1808, seeking to transition from
social chaos to universal harmony.
- His ideas included agricultural association and passionate attraction.

16. **Complexity of Fourier's Ideas**:

- Fourier's work was considered di use and enigmatic, with bizarre and outlandish arguments.
- His ideas in uenced social democratic movements.

17. **1840 and the Proliferation of Ideas**:

- 1840 saw the publication of various in uential works, including Proudhon's "What Is Property"
and Louis Blanc's "The Organization of Work."

18. **Commonalities in Radical Arguments**:

- There was widespread agreement on the existence of poverty and su ering among the
working class.
- Diagnoses and remedies for societal ills varied widely among thinkers.

19. **Diverse Diagnoses**:

- Di erent thinkers attributed societal problems to factors such as civilization, commerce,
aristocrats, priests, individualism, and more.

20. **Di ering Goals**:

- Transformative social movements had varying goals, from radical revolution to seeking
equality, liberty, and fair remuneration for workers.
- The emancipation of women was a crucial issue.

21. **Challenges in De ning Equality**:

- Equality was seen as important, but its de nition and means of achievement varied.
- Debate surrounded political, social, and economic equality.

22. **Inequality of Women**:

- The subordination of women was recognized as a form of inequality.
- Feminists advocated for women's emancipation, including the right to work and divorce.

23. **Complex Views on Equality**:

- Views on equality di ered, including radical calls for social equality and more moderate
demands for equal treatment.

24. **Struggles for Women's Rights**:

- Women faced challenges in securing equal work opportunities and wages compared to men.

25. **Proudhon's Views on Women**:

- Proudhon held conservative views on women, emphasizing the family and male control.

These points cover the major details and themes discussed in the provided text.
ff
ff
fl
fi
ff
ff
fl
fi
ff
PAGE 72 - 79
The provided text discusses several key points and themes related to social and political ideas in
the 1840s. Here is a breakdown of the main points covered in the text:

1. **Material and Moral Egalitarianism**: The text explores the dialogue between material and
moral egalitarianism, emphasizing the right to a living wage, security, and dignity for individuals
regardless of their class or gender. Various reformers and authors, including Proudhon, Tristan,
Saint-Simon, Cabet, and others, engaged with these ideas. Some even saw a radicalized form of
Christianity as part of the solution.

2. **Association**: The concept of association is a recurring theme in the text. It highlights the
importance of organizing collectives to address material needs and create environments
conducive to education and personal ful llment. Di erent thinkers had various interpretations of
association, including Fourier's focus on agricultural production and Saint-Simonians' belief in a
universal association encompassing various interests.

3. **Worker Associations**: The text discusses the idea of independent associations formed by
workers themselves, advocating for bottom-up approaches to address labor issues. This idea
gained popularity among workers, and it became a major topic of discussion in worker-based
publications. The movement for worker associations led to the proposed Union of Associations in
1849.

4. **Community and Communism**: The text explores di erent views on community and
communism. Proudhon opposed the idea of community, emphasizing individual liberty. Some
thinkers, like Cabet, advocated for paci c methods and alternative forms of community
organization, while others, like Dézamy, developed elaborate codes of community.

5. **Organization of Work and Labor**: The text delves into the fundamental importance of work
and labor in social critique and proposed solutions. Various thinkers, such as Fourier, Saint-
Simonians, Proudhon, and Cabet, had di erent visions of how labor could be organized. The text
also discusses Proudhon's ideas on labor value and competition.

6. **Worker Self-Management**: The text mentions competing models of worker self-management

or autogestion proposed by Proudhon, Cabet, and Leroux. It highlights the debate over the role of
competition and capital ownership in organizing labor.

7. **Urban Question and Modernity**: In the year 1840, the text introduces the launch of the
Revue Générale de l’Architecture et des Travaux Publics, a journal that played a central role in
discussing architectural, urban design, and urbanization questions. This re ects the growing
interest in urbanization and modernity in the mid-19th century.

8. **Engineering and Architecture**: The text emphasizes the role of engineers and architects in
shaping the physical environment, including cities, factories, and infrastructure. It highlights the
importance of architectural and engineering advancements during this period.

9. **Industrialization and Urbanization**: There is an underlying theme of industrialization and

urbanization throughout the text, as various thinkers and movements grappled with the social and
economic changes brought about by industrialization.

Overall, the text provides insights into the intellectual and social debates of the 1840s, touching
on topics such as social equality, labor organization, urban development, and the role of
engineers and architects in shaping society.
fi
fi
ff
ff
ff
fl
 **Summary of the Text: "The Dialogue Between Material and Moral Egalitarianism in 1840s
France"**

**Introduction:**
- The text explores the complex dialogue between material and moral egalitarianism in 1840s
France.
- It discusses the right to a living wage, dignity, and respect regardless of class or gender.

**Association:**
- The principle of association plays a signi cant role in political institutions and actions during this
period.
- Di erent authors and reformers had varying de nitions and interpretations of association.
- Association aimed to organize the collectivity to ful ll material needs while promoting education
and personal ful llment.
- Fourier's vision focused on agricultural production and lacked adaptation to industrial settings.
- Saint-Simonians emphasized association among industrials, including scientists and artists,
within a universal association for the common good.
- Many believed that a grand association of interests and class alliance could bridge bourgeois
and worker interests.

**Community/Communism:**
- Proudhon strongly opposed the concept of community, viewing it as oppressive.
- Dézamy proposed a detailed Code of Community in 1842, emphasizing unity and fraternity.
- Cabet's Icarian communism aimed to suppress egoism, privilege, and domination, transforming
personal property into common property.
- Proudhon and Cabet advocated traditional family life.
- Cabet's movement gained support mainly from the working classes.
- Cabet shifted towards Christianity and emigration to the United States in 1847.

**The Organization of Work and Labor:**

- Work and labor were central to social critique and proposed solutions during this era.
- Fourier envisioned work as equivalent to play and aimed to eliminate the social division of labor.
- Saint-Simonians proposed reorganizing labor on larger scales with greater e ciency.
- Proudhon's mutualism focused on remunerating laborers based on the value they produced.
- Proudhon accepted competition as a coordinating device in the labor market.
- Models of worker self-management or autogestion emerged, including Proudhon's mutualism,
Cabet's communism, and Leroux's Christian communitarianism.
- Piore and Sable's argument suggested that the mid-19th century missed an opportunity for
small-scale worker-controlled rms.

**The Urban Question: Modernity Before Haussmann?:**

- In 1840, César Daly launched the Revue Générale de l’Architecture et des Travaux Publics,
focusing on architectural and urban design, and urbanization.
- Engineers and architects played essential roles in construction, urbanization, and infrastructure
development.
- Daly emphasized the importance of their work in housing, industrial establishments, cities,
transportation, and agriculture.
- The text highlights the signi cance of progress in architectural and urban science during this
period.

**Conclusion:**
- The text explores various aspects of 1840s France, including association, communism, labor
organization, and urban development, shedding light on historical lessons and key issues of the
time.
ff
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
ffi
 PAGE 79-86
**Summary of the Text: "The City as a Body Politic: The Politics of Planning in Post-Revolutionary
Paris (1848-1852)"**

**Introduction: Setting the Context**

- The text discusses the political and urban planning developments in post-revolutionary Paris
between 1848 and 1852.
- It explores how di erent thinkers and leaders approached the city's issues, drawing in uences
from Saint-Simonian and Fourierist ideologies.

**Saint-Simonian and Fourierist In uence**

- The tone of the planning e orts in this period is Saint-Simonian, which is intriguing because of
Daly's earlier in uence by Fourier.
- The Revue (a publication) combined Saint-Simonian and Fourierist principles, favoring large-
scale public projects and a harmonious approach guided by scienti c principles.
- Considérant and Perreymond, in uenced by Fourier, contributed articles on reorganizing Paris's
interior space.

**Urban Issues and Key Figures**

- Various administrators, thinkers, and writers of the time engaged with urban issues due to their
signi cance and urgency.
- Adolphe Thiers, as Minister of Commerce and Public Works in 1833, initiated monumental
projects and secured funding for canals, roadworks, and railways.
- Rambuteau, the prefect of Paris, worked on improving communication and hygiene after the
cholera epidemic of 1832.
- Architect Jacques Hittor played a role in redesigning the city center.
- Lanquetin, a businessman, commissioned an ambitious plan for Paris's revitalization.

**Utopian Plans for Restructuring**

- "The utopians of 1840" proposed concrete plans to reorganize city streets, some of which were
implemented.
- These plans di ered from Haussmann's e orts in terms of scale and cautious execution.
- Rambuteau adhered to scal conservatism and prioritized staying within the city's budget.

**Ideas from In uential Thinkers**

- Many in uential thinkers addressed urban questions during this period.
- Fourier envisioned an ideal city based on unitary architecture, aimed at preventing res and
improving urban living.
- Fourier's designs were more suitable for agrarian societies than the industrialized Paris of the
time.
- Proudhon and Cabet proposed small-scale experiments with communities but didn't think on a
larger urban scale.
- Dézamy's urban code emphasized collective property rights and territorial organization of
communes.
- Considérant and Perreymond criticized the railroad's irrational implementation and proposed
nationalization based on Fourierist principles.

**Perreymond's Ambitious Plan**

- Perreymond detailed a plan for Paris's revitalization, focusing on congestion, lack of harmony,
and north-westward drift of activity.
- He proposed covering the left branch of the Seine, better rail access, and a complete
reconstruction of the city center.
- Engineering speci cations and nancial calculations supported the feasibility of his project.
- Perreymond was open to debt nancing and critical of Rambuteau's scal conservatism.

**Meynadier's Proposals**
fi
fl
fl
fl
ff
ff
fi
fi
ff
ff
fi
fi
fl
fl
ff
fi
fi
fi
fl
 - Meynadier, in "Paris Pittoresque et Monumentale" (1843), advocated revitalizing the city center
through clearances and rational road systems.
- He prioritized health, hygiene, and a park system for Paris, along with suburban access to
nature.

**Shift in Representation and Modernity**

- The Revolution of 1848 marked a shift in the representation of the city.
- Balzac portrayed the city as a dynamic and discoverable entity, while Flaubert's approach
reduced it to a static backdrop, devoid of social and political meaning.
- After 1848, Haussmann and developers began to shape the city according to commercial
interests, dispossessing the masses.
- The idea of the city as a nurturing state was lost, replaced by the idea of a capitalist city.

**Conclusion: The Impact of 1848**

- The failed socialist revolution of 1848 changed the course of urban planning and representation.
- The ferment of ideas and possibilities before 1848 gave way to a more materialist transformation
of Paris.
- The Second Empire, in uenced by capitalist interests, eventually succumbed to economic
liberalization and declined in power.

**Impact on Representation**
- The Revolution of 1848 resulted in a loss of open questions of representation and rede ned the
city's role as a materialist entity.
- Paris's transformation after 1851 was driven by material interests, distancing it from the idea of a
nurturing state or a sentient being.

**Legacy of Imaginative Exercises**

- The period from 1830 to 1848 paved the way for subsequent urban developments, even though
the sources of inspiration were often denied by those who implemented the changes.

Certainly, I can break down the provided text into key points covering every small detail:

1. **Tone and In uence**:

- The text's tone is described as Saint-Simonian, which is unexpected because the author, Daly,
was in uenced by Fourier.
- The Revue (a publication) often merged Saint-Simonian ideas with Fourierist principles,
emphasizing large-scale public projects with scienti c and harmonic planning.

2. **Urban Question**:
- Many administrators, thinkers, and writers during this period discussed the urban question,
which was a pressing issue that couldn't be ignored.
- Adolphe Thiers, who took over the Ministry of Commerce and Public Works in 1833, invested
in monumental projects and infrastructure like canals, roadworks, and railways.
- The prefect of Paris, Rambuteau, worked on improving communications and hygiene in
response to the 1832 cholera epidemic.
- Architect Jacques Hittor played a role in shaping the city's expansion toward the north and
west.
- Lanquetin, a businessman, commissioned an ambitious plan for revitalizing Paris.

3. **Utopian Plans**:
- The "utopians of 1840" proposed concrete plans for reordering the city streets, some of which
were implemented.
- These plans di ered from Haussmann's approach in terms of scale and vision. They were
cautious and scally conservative.

4. **Ideas of Grand Thinkers**:

- Many in uential thinkers of the time had ideas about urban living and restructuring.
fl
fl
fi
fl
ff
fl
ff
fi
fi
 - Fourier had ideas about a new type of architecture but was more suited for agrarian societies.
- Various thinkers like Proudhon, Leroux, and Cabet had small-scale community-based ideas.
- Communists like Dézamy proposed extensive plans for communal living arrangements and
public projects.

5. **In uence of Fourier**:

- Fourier's ideas were initially inspired by Paris but were better suited for agrarian societies.
- His Phalanstère concept in uenced experiments in collective living but did not provide a city-
wide restructuring plan.

6. **Exceptions**:
- Saint-Simon appealed to industrialists, scientists, engineers, and architects to rethink the city
on a larger scale.
- Saint-Simonian ideas continued to in uence a technical elite despite the movement's decline
in the 1830s.

7. **Railroad Critique**:
- Considérant and Perreymond critiqued the railroad system for promoting centralization and
irrational development.
- They proposed nationalizing the rail network and building it based on rational, harmonic
principles.

8. **Practical Plans**:
- Considérant, Perreymond, Meynadier, and Lanquetin proposed practical plans to ameliorate
Paris's problems.
- Perreymond suggested a radical restructuring of internal communications and the city center,
with engineering speci cations and nancing plans.
- These plans were ambitious but received little discussion or consideration.

9. **Impact of 1848**:
- The failure of the socialist revolution in 1848 led to the repression of social republic ideas.
- Two contrasting conceptions of modernity clashed in the June 1848 events.
- Adolphe Thiers represented a bourgeois vision, while the social republic sought to address
poverty and inequality.

10. **Loss of Representation**:

- The Revolution of 1848 led to a crisis of representation, and the city lost its status as a body
politic.
- Louis Napoleon's rule under the Second Empire emphasized imperial power over the city's
representation.
- Economic liberalization undermined imperial power, eventually leading to the downfall of the
Empire in 1870-71.

11. **Ferment of Debate**:

- The period from 1830 to 1848 saw rich debates and the emergence of socialist and
communist ideas.
- Many alternative visions and plans were proposed in response to urban and social problems.
- The Revolution of 1848 disrupted these debates but did not entirely eliminate the ideas.

12. **Impact on Representation**:

- Balzac's writing presented the city as a dynamic and ever-changing entity.
- Flaubert's style reduced the city to an aesthetic object, devoid of social and political meaning.
- The Revolution of 1848 reshaped the representation of the city, making it more static.

13. **Imperial Power and Capitalism**:

- The Second Empire attempted to reconstitute the body politic but eventually succumbed to
economic forces.
- The Empire's fall was in uenced by economic liberalization and pressures from both
capitalism and republicanism.
fl
fi
fl
fl
fi
fl
14. **Legacy of Ideas**:
- The imaginative exercises undertaken from 1830 to 1848 prepared the ground for future urban
developments, even if the original sources of inspiration were denied.

This summary captures the main points and details from the provided text.