Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analysis Miller
Analysis Miller
net/publication/3270407
CITATIONS READS
12 4,861
5 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mircea Popescu on 23 November 2012.
http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/archive/00002833/
Abstract—The motor presented employs multiple independent winding so that the motor can be optimally designed using
windings for operation with two very different pole numbers. The single-phase motor engineering knowledge and practices.
18-pole field is produced with a symmetrical three-phase winding Starting from the commonly employed theory of symmet-
connected in a Steinmetz arrangement to a single-phase supply. A
unified analysis method has been developed and used to demon- rical components and after further mathematical transforma-
strate the equivalence of a Steinmetz delta or star connection with tions, new equations and single-phase motor equivalent circuits
a main and auxiliary winding of a single-phase motor. The method have been developed in this respect. Also as new contributions,
has been experimentally validated and also included are some spe- the mathematical relations between the actual measurable volt-
cific motor design considerations. ages and currents in the motor real windings, on one hand, and
Index Terms—Asynchronous rotating machines, design method- the values in the equivalent auxiliary and main winding, on the
ology, machine windings, phase conversion, single-phase induction other hand, have been established for both the delta and the wye
motors, squirrel cage motors. Steinmetz connection. A design procedure based on the new
analysis method has been implemented using a motor design
I. INTRODUCTION software and the theory has been experimentally validated.
The optimal design of the 2 and 18-pole motor, which is ex-
Fig. 5. Equivalent main and auxiliary winding for Steinmetz wye connection.
Fig. 1. Electrical connections for the high speed 2-pole configuration and
for the low speed 18-pole configuration. The 18-pole field is produced with a
Steinmetz delta connection. where and are the positive sequence and negative se-
quence impedance respectively and the positive sequence and
negative sequence current components are
(4)
(5)
with
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
Fig. 3. Electrical circuit for Steinmetz wye connection.
In terms of an equivalent single-phase motor circuit, we can
consider (7) and (9) respectively, as the voltage equation for
the main winding, and (8) and (10) respectively, as a voltage
equation from which a mathematical expression of the voltage
on an equivalent auxiliary phase winding can be determined, as
it will be demonstrated in the following.
Because the neutral point of the 3-phase symmetrical winding
is not connected, the phase currents can be expressed as a func-
tion of two currents, one fictitious and one equal to
(11)
Fig. 4. Equivalent main and auxiliary winding for Steinmetz delta connection. (12)
64 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENERGY CONVERSION, VOL. 20, NO. 1, MARCH 2005
(13) tained for the equivalent circuit of the single-phase motor with
Steinmetz wye connection
The flow of the two currents and through the motor wind-
ings would produce two orthogonal magnetomotive forces.
By substituting (11) in (4) and (5)
(23)
(14) (24)
(25)
(15)
(26)
Fig. 6. Torque speed curve for steady state operation in 18 pole configuration. Fig. 9. Current vs. speed for steady state operation in 2 pole configuration.
TABLE I
CALCULATED AND TEST DATA FOR STEADY-STATE OPERATION IN
18-POLE CONFIGURATION
TABLE II
CALCULATED AND TEST DATA FOR STEADY-STATE OPERATION IN
2-POLE CONFIGURATION
Fig. 7. Current vs. speed for steady state operation in 18 pole configuration.
Fig. 8. Torque speed curve for steady state operation in 2 pole configuration.
Fig. 10. Transients for starting against rated load in 18 pole configuration.
In the 18-pole configuration the motor is operated as a per-
manent-split capacitor (PSC) type, with the same capacitor con- Because of the very high load inertia the torque ripple does
nected both at start and run operation. In the 2-pole configura- not cause speed oscillations in the example motor drive. Such a
tion a solid-state switch is employed to change in between the torque ripple is specific to a single-phase induction motor [9],
start and run capacitor at 90% of the synchronous speed. The ef- being caused by the presence of a forward and a backward ro-
fect of the switch is noticeable in both the steady-state and tran- tating magnetic field.
sient performance curves. The transient torque contains a rela- Means of balancing the motor operation and reducing the pul-
tively large pulsating torque of twice the line supply frequency. sating torque are further discussed in the next section.
66 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENERGY CONVERSION, VOL. 20, NO. 1, MARCH 2005
Fig. 11. Transients for starting against rated load in 2 pole configuration.
Fig. 13. Flux lines and flux density in the cross-section of the motor operating
on load in the 2 pole configuration.
capacitance and the turns ratio of the auxiliary and main winding
(27)
where and are the line supply voltage and frequency re-
spectively, the referred rotor resistance, and the
locked rotor main and auxiliary winding impedance, respec-
tively and is the capacitive impedance con-
nected in series with the auxiliary winding. The real and imagi-
nary components of the complex impedances are denoted by
Fig. 12. Flux lines and flux density in the cross-section of the motor operating and , respectively.
on load in the 18 pole configuration. The starting torque can also be evaluated using the main and
auxiliary starting currents
IV. MOTOR DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
(28)
The motor magnetic circuit has to be designed for optimal where is a proportionality constant and is the electrical
operation with 18-pole and 2-pole field, respectively. The finite phase angle between the main and auxiliary current phasors at
element analysis (FEA) magnetic field plots, which are printed locked rotor conditions.
on the same flux density scale in Figs. 12 and 13, illustrate some Based on (27), it can be demonstrated that the maximum the-
of the design challenges due to the magnetic circuit being shared oretically achievable starting torque is only dependent of the
by two largely different stator winding polarities. In the low motor parameters, i.e., is independent of the starting capacitor,
speed 18-pole configuration, the saturation level is significant and can be calculated as
only in the teeth. In the high-speed 2-pole configuration, the
stator yoke has an increased magnetic loading.
For a capacitor-start single-phase induction motor, which has (29)
the magnetization reactance much higher than the referred rotor
resistance and leakage reactance and based on the equations This equation can serve for an initial design choice of the turns
from [1], the starting torque can be computed as a function of the ratio. In order for the motor to achieve the maximum starting
POPESCU et al.: ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF A TWO-SPEED SINGLE-PHASE INDUCTION MOTOR WITH 2 AND 18 POLE SPECIAL WINDINGS 67
(30)
(31) Fig. 14. Starting and rated load torque as a function of capacitance in the 18
pole motor configuration.
Fig. 17. The starting torque as a function of starting capacitance and turns ratio
Fig. 15. Starting torque per amp as a function of capacitance in the 18 pole in the 2 pole motor configuration.
motor configuration.
Fig. 18. Average torque at rated load as a function of run capacitance and turns
ratio in the 2 pole motor configuration.
Fig. 16. The starting torque per amp as a function of starting capacitance and
turns ratio in the 2 pole motor configuration.
where the starting torque and the average torque at rated load
reach a maximum, and the amplitude of the pulsating torque at
rated load has a minimum. Also, within this capacitance range,
the ratio of the starting torque and starting current achieves a
maximum.
It is interesting to note that for the considered motor example
a phase angle of 60 degree, which would ensure fully balanced
operation, cannot be achieved at a relatively large load of 5.5
lbft at 335 rpm. In order to completely eliminate the torque pul-
sations not only the capacitance (see Fig. 14) but also the turns
ratio of the equivalent auxiliary and main winding should be Fig. 19. Amplitude of the pulsating torque at rated load as a function of run
modified, which is clearly not feasible with a Steinmetz connec- capacitance and turns ratio in the 2 pole motor configuration.
tion. However, by optimal choice of the capacitor the pulsating
torque is minimized at a level, which is totally satisfactory for this requirement being determined by the typical direct drive
typical applications, while the starting and rated torque require- application.
ments are met. More design freedom is available for the 2-pole configuration
The 2-pole configuration is of the conventional single-phase also because a solid-state switch is employed to change from a
type and the parametric design study has been extended to start capacitor to a run capacitor. The run capacitance and the
include not only the capacitance but also the turns ratio (see turns ratio are selected in order to minimize the pulsating torque
Figs. 16–19). For a set value of the starting capacitance, the and the same time match the rated load requirements. It is inter-
turns ratio has a relatively reduced influence on the starting esting to note that fully balanced operation, with virtually zero
torque per amp value. The value of the starting capacitance pulsating torque, would be possible at rated speed; however, in
is selected in order to ensure the same starting torque for the this case the motor would not be able to develop the required
2-pole motor configuration as for the 18-pole configuration, rated torque.
POPESCU et al.: ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF A TWO-SPEED SINGLE-PHASE INDUCTION MOTOR WITH 2 AND 18 POLE SPECIAL WINDINGS 69
Stephen J. Dellinger received the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in electrical engi- Malcolm McGilp was born in Helensburgh, U.K. He received the B.Eng. de-
neering from the University of Dayton, Dayton, OH. gree (Hons.) in electronic systems and microcomputer engineering, University
Currently, he is Director of Engineering with the AO Smith Corp., Electric of Glasgow, Glasgow, U.K.
Products Company, Tipp City, OH. His responsibilities include the development Currently, he is a Research Associate in the SPEED Laboratory, University of
and introduction to manufacturing of new motor technologies. He has been with Glasgow, where he was a Research Assistant from 1987 to 1996. He is respon-
AO Smith Corp. for more than 35 years and, during this time, held various po- sible for the software architecture of the SPEED motor design software and has
sitions in manufacturing, engineering, and management. developed the interface and user facilities which allow it to be easy to learn and
integrate with other PC-based software.