Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ethyl Alcohol As A Fuel For Contemporary Internal Combustion Engines
Ethyl Alcohol As A Fuel For Contemporary Internal Combustion Engines
Kozak M. Ethyl alcohol as a fuel for contemporary internal combustion engines. Diagnostyka. 2019;20(2):27-32.
https://doi.org/10.29354/diag/109173
ISSN 1641-6414
DIAGNOSTYKA, 2019, Vol. 20, No. 2 e-ISSN 2449-5220
DOI: 10.29354/diag/109173
Abstract
The article presents the conditions for the use of ethyl alcohol as a component and a sole fuel for internal
combustion engines. Methods of ethanol production, its properties and the benefits and risks associated with
using it as engine fuel have been described. The variants of commercial ethanol fuels allowed by law have
also been presented. Ecological aspects of the use of ethanol fuels for modern internal combustion engines
were presented. The opinion was expressed that although ethanol is used in bulk as a component of gasolines,
its use as a self-contained fuel is and probably will continue to be small in the near future.
Streszczenie
W artykule przedstawiono uwarunkowania stosowania alkoholu etylowego jako składnika oraz
samodzielnego paliwa do silników spalinowych. Opisano metody produkcji etanolu, jego właściwości oraz
korzyści i zagrożenia związane ze stosowaniem go jako paliwa silnikowego. Zaprezentowano dopuszczalne
prawem warianty handlowych paliw etanolowych. Przedstawiono ekologiczne aspekty stosowania paliw
etanolowych do współczesnych silników spalinowych. Wyrażono opinię, iż mimo, że etanol stosowany jest
masowo jako komponent benzyn silnikowych, to jego zastosowanie jako samodzielnego paliwa jest i
prawdopodobnie w najbliższej przyszłości będzie niewielkie.
2. ETHYL ALCOHOL PRODUCTION Bioethanol from the raw materials of the last group
is a 2nd generation biofuel.
Industrial production of ethanol by fermentation
is a multi-stage process and includes: initial raw 3. PROPERTIES OF ETHANOL AS FUEL
material preparation, hydrolysis and saccha-
rification, detoxification (in the case of The physicochemical properties of ethanol
lignocellulosic biomass), fermentation, distillation (Table 1), in particular the high octane number, low
and rectification, ethanol dehydration/drying, as viscosity and low boiling point, predispose it
well as the management of by-products and waste primarily as fuel for SI engines. The use of ethanol
(Figure 1). as a fuel brings both benefits and risks (Table 2),
The enzymes produced by yeast in the process the latter being largely related to its impact on some
of alcoholic fermentation facilitate the construction materials of vehicles not adapted to be
decomposition of carbohydrates into ethyl alcohol powered by ethanol. It is assumed that the
and carbon dioxide. For example, the alcoholic maximum safe ethanol content in gasoline intended
fermentation of glucose proceeds according to the for conventional automotive SI engines is 10-15%.
reaction: The latest edition of the Worldwide Fuel Charter
C6H12O6 → 2 C2H5OH + 2 CO2. (2013) [20] recommends not exceeding the level of
A mash with alcohol concentration of up to 18% 10%. Fuels with higher ethanol content can be used
is obtained in the fermentation process (the yeast for the so-called FFV (Flexible Fuel Vehicles), i.e.
perishes at higher concentration). The concentration vehicles that are factory-adapted for the use of this
of alcohol is modified by distillation, the product of type of fuel. These vehicles are equipped with a
which is 90% ethanol is referred to as raw spirit, fuel composition sensor and can be fuelled with an
which is then rectified to obtain an azeotropic ethanol-gasoline mixture with any range of changes
mixture of water and ethanol, with about 96% between the content of these two components.
ethanol concentration. Ethanol used as a fuel Several European car manufacturers offer FFV
component should not contain more than 0.3% of versions of their passenger cars (Table 3).
water, however, due to the formation of an
azeotropic mixture, it is not possible to obtain Table 1. Properties of ethanol as engine fuel [5]
anhydrous alcohol by conventional distillation. Gasoline
Parameter Ethanol
Removal of water from the azeotropic mixture is 95
carried out using adsorption methods on molecular Density at 20C kg/m3 789 750
sieves and by pervaporation. The water content in Research
dehydrated ethanol is 50 to 2000 ppm, depending – 109 > 95
octane number
on the process conditions. Motor octane
– 90 > 85
In domestic conditions, ethanol is the most often number
produced from grains and potatoes. In the USA, Heat of
kJ/kg 841 330
Canada and China, the primary raw material is evaporation
corn. The largest amount of ethanol production in MJ/kg 26.8 43.5
Heating value
the world (about 60%) comes, however, from the MJ/dm3 21.2 31.8
processing of sugar cane. This raw material is used Stoichiometric
for example in Brazil. Raw materials for the kgair/kgfuel 9,0 14,3
air-fuel mixture
production of bioethanol can generally be divided Distillation C 78 40 – 215
into three groups [1]: Flash-point C 13 – 43
- containing sucrose: sugar cane, beetroots and Kinematic
mm2/s 1.2 0.5
sugar sorghum and certain fruits, viscosity at 40oC
- containing starch: wheat, rye, barley, potatoes, Elementary
maize, rice, cassava, composition % m/m
- lignocellulosic biomass: energy crops, by- C 52.2 84.8
products from agriculture and the wood H 13.0 13.3
industry, paper and cardboard being a fraction O 34.8 2.4
of municipal waste.
Table. 2. Technical and operational advantages and risks Table. 3. Selected FFV models commercially available
associated with the use of ethanol as motor fuel [9] on the European market [11]
Advantages Risks
FFV Vehicle Brand Country
high octane number high emission through
allowing the increase evaporation, Audi A3 1.6e e-power (E85)
Sweden
of compression ratio smaller particle sizes Audi A4 2.0 TFSI
engine efficiency created in the combu- Citroën C3 Flex
Sweden, Benelux,
increase, stion process (more Citroën C4 1.6/2.0 BioFlex
France, Switzerland
CO, HC and PM harmful particles), Citroën C5 2.0 BioFlex
emissions reduced or lower calorific value Dacia Duster 1.6 16v (E85)
maintained at the increased fuel consu- Dacia Logan MCV 1.6 16v Hi-
current level, mption, Flex (E85) Sweden
reduction of CO2 difficult engine start at Dacia Sandero 1.6 16v Hi-Flex
emissions (partial or (E85)
low temperatures, due to
complete closure of Ford Focus Austria, Denmark,
low vapor pressure and
the CO2 cycle chain), high latent heat of Ford C-Max France, Germany,
Ford Mondeo Ireland, Holland,
reduction of benzene ethanol evaporation,
Ford S-Max Poland, Spain,
and other aromatics acetaldehyde formation
Ford Galaxy Sweden,
emissions, in the combustion Switzerland, UK
lower ozone process, which is
Peugeot 307 1.6/2.0 BioFlex
formation potential suspected of having Sweden, Benelux,
Peugeot 308 1.6/2.0 BioFlex
than for pure carcinogenic properties, France, Switzerland
Peugeot 407 2.0 BioFlex
gasoline, low lubricity reduced Renault Clio III 1.2 16v Eco2
lower toxicity than durability of fuel inje- Renault Mégane 1.6 16v Eco2
Sweden, Benelux,
pure gasoline, ction elements, France, Switzerland
Renault Kangoo 1.6 16v 105
better flammability corrosive effects on SEAT Leon MultiFuel 1.6 MPI
than pure gasoline, metals: zinc, lead, (E85)
allowing the alcohol- aluminum, brass and SEAT Altea MultiFuel 1.6 MPI
steel without coatings; European market
air mixtures to be (E85)
leaner, which may stainless steel and SEAT Altea XL MultiFuel 1.6
result in a slightly bronze are sufficiently MPI (E85)
higher overall engine resistant, Škoda Octavia MultiFuel 1.6 Sweden, Benelux,
efficiency, damaging impact on MPI (E85) France, Switzerland
higher flame propa- some elastomers Volvo C30 1.8F
gation speed (by (gaskets, fuel lines, etc.) Volvo S40 1.8F
about 20-30%), and plastics (e.g. Volvo V50 1.8F
which has the same polyamide, PVC, etc.), Volvo V70 2.0F European market
effect as above and mixture instability, it Volvo V70 2.5FT
gives the possibility stratifies under the Volvo S80 2.0F
of obtaining incre- influence of even small Volvo S80 2.5FT
ased engine speed, amounts of water or Volkswagen Golf and Golf Plus Germany, Sweden,
high heat of moisture from the air, it Volkswagen Jetta Benelux and
evaporation is necessary to use Switzerland
"internal" cooling of stabilizers or emu-
the engine. lsifiers, Ethanol is also considered as fuel for future
ethanol does not burn high-performance engines [5, 16]. Its parameters,
visibly, which increases such as high octane number and a large evaporation
the fire hazard,
heat, which contribute to the effective cooling of
unburned ethanol reacts
the cylinder fuel mixture, are particularly desirable
in the catalytic reactor,
causing an unpleasant,
in high-performance engines. An engine designed
acetic smell of exhaust for ethanol fuel may have a higher compression
gas, ratio, thus significantly improving the overall
the mixture is electri- efficiency under low and medium load, a similar
cally conductive effect relates to the accelerated ignition.
electrochemical corro-
sion, fire hazard, 4. VARIANTS OF USING ETHANOL AS
some detergent additives FUEL IN POLAND
for gasolines do not
work in the presence of In Poland, it is legally permissible to produce
ethanol or even show the and sell ethanol fuel in three variants:
reverse effect – increase (a) as a biocomponent of gasoline in an amount up
in the amount of
to 5% (v/v),
deposits.
(b) as a biocomponent of gasoline in an amount up
to 10% (v/v),
30 DIAGNOSTYKA, Vol. 20, No. 2 (2019)
Kozak M.: Ethyl alcohol as a fuel for contemporary internal combustion engines
energy consumption is very similar when using Vehicle) class bus fuelled with ED95 fuel has
both fuels, and CO2 emissions is even lower for admittedly exhaust emissions similar to the
E85 (Figure 3) due to the more favorable hydrogen- conventional EEV bus fuelled with diesel fuel but
carbon ratio in the ethanol molecule. also about 7% higher energy consumption.
Extensive tests of FFVs' fuel consumption were
carried out by the United States Environmental Table 5. Emissions of aromatic compounds
Protection Agency (EPA). The test results of these over the FTP-75 cycle for vehicles fuelled
vehicles are the most comprehensive data available with fuels containing ethanol [15]
for the comparison of gasoline and E85 fuel Nissan passenger car emissions [mg/km]
efficiency. For the 2007 year, 24 different models Total
Benzene Toluene Xylenes
from 5 manufacturers were designated FFVs. aromatics
Within these 24 models, there were 76 different Gasoline 4.08 5.23 5.30 18.96
E10 4.35 4.75 5.21 19.43
drivetrain/body-style variants tested for gasoline
E45 1.14 1.20 1.44 5.05
and E85 fuel economy. Table 6 presents these
E85 0.31 0.31 0.53 1.68
results. The mean fuel economy of E85 in city
driving was 73.42% that of gasoline. In highway GM pick-up emissions [mg/km]
driving, the mean fuel economy was 73.4% that of
Total
gasoline. The EPA also produces a mean fuel Benzene Toluene Xylenes
aromatics
economy by averaging city and highway fuel Gasoline 1.40 3.45 3.34 11.00
economy, with a 55% city/45% highway weighting. E10 1.17 3.01 3.70 11.38
By this measure, the ratio of E85 to gasoline fuel E45 0.51 1.40 0.99 4.08
economy was also 73.4% [14]. E85 0.37 1.23 0.77 3.15
As the ethanol content in fuel increases, the
content of harmful aromatic hydrocarbons in fuel
decreases. Hence, decreases also emissions of 6. CONCLUSIONS
aromatics in exhaust gas. According to [15] the
total aromatic hydrocarbon emission is several Ethyl alcohol has been used for many years as a
times lower for an E85 powered vehicle than for a few percent additive to regular gasoline. Its
gasoline-powered vehicle (table 5). valuable feature, both in the past and today, is
Ethanol in its pure form is used very rarely as increasing the octane number of fuel. In the era of
fuel for compression-ignition (CI) engines. There is using advanced catalytic exhaust aftertreatment
in principle only one manufacturer on the systems, the effect of ethanol on toxic exhaust
automotive market that offers ethanol-powered CI emissions is less important. At present, the main
engines, namely Scania. These engines have a high advantage of ethanol in the environmental aspect is
compression ratio (28) and require a special ED95 the fact that it is a renewable fuel that leads to a
fuel. It is a mixture of 95% ethanol and a 5% reduction in CO2 emissions and lower dependence
package of additives improving, among others the on fossil fuel resources. It is also definitely less
ability of the fuel to self-ignite and its lubricity. The toxic and more readily biodegradable than gasoline.
high compression ratio alone does not ensure Despite the legal and technical possibilities, in
proper ignition of the ethanol [10]. Scania’s Poland and most other countries the market of
ethanol-powered CI engines are mainly used in city vehicles powered with neat ethanol or mixtures
buses. Although this solution has been present on with a high ethanol content is not developed. FFVs
the market for over 20 years, less than one thousand have a significant market share in only a few
ED95 buses have been manufactured so far, mainly countries around the world. At the same time, work
for the Swedish market. In Poland, several buses is being carried out on fuels for future engines,
powered by ED95 were operated at MZK Słupsk. including HCCI engines, for which ethanol is also
After a few years, the carrier withdrew from this considered as potential fuel component. The
solution, due to high operating costs among other production of ethanol is still mainly based on the
reasons. As shown by the data published in [10], use of raw materials from edible plants containing
the EEV (Enhanced Environmental Friendly
Table 6. Summary statistics of EPA FFV fuel economy tests [14]
City Highway Average
Gasoline E85 Ratio Gasoline E85 Ratio Gasoline E85 Ratio
Mean 14.9 10.9 73.4% 19.8 14.6 73.4% 17.1 12.6 73.4%
Minimum 13.1 9.1 66.9% 16.7 12.4 67.6% 14.7 10.8 68.3%
Maximum 21.8 15.8 81.3% 31.2 23.4 81.5% 25.8 19.2 81.4%
Notes: Nominal values are EPA estimated miles travelled per gallon consumed. ‘Ratio’ is the ratio of E85 fuel economy to
gasoline fuel economy. ‘Average’ is the average of ‘City’ and ‘Highway’ weighted 55% ‘City’ and 45% ‘Highway’. N = 76
total vehicles tested.
32 DIAGNOSTYKA, Vol. 20, No. 2 (2019)
Kozak M.: Ethyl alcohol as a fuel for contemporary internal combustion engines
sucrose or starch. The technologies of ethanol 13. Regulation of the Polish Minister of Economy of 17
production from non-food raw materials, mainly December 2010 on quality requirements for
from lignocellulosic complexes, developed for biocomponents, methods for testing the quality of
about last 20 years, have still not had a significant biocomponents and the method of sampling
biocomponents. Polish. Dz.U. 2010 nr 249 poz. 1668.
share in this fuel production market. Although
14. Roberts MC. E85 and fuel efficiency: An empirical
ethanol remains a very important component of
analysis of 2007 EPA test data. Energy Policy 2008;
fuels for SI engines, the scale of its use as an 36: 1233–1235.
independent motor fuel is growing slowly. It also https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2007.11.006.
seems that the coming years will not bring a 15. Schifter I. et al. From actual ethanol contents in
significant change in this field. gasoline to mid-blends and E-85 in conventional
technology vehicles. Emission control issues and
REFERENCES consequences. Fuel 2018; 219: 239-247.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2018.01.118.
1. Balat M, Balat H. Recent trends in global production and 16. Schwaderlapp M, Adomeit P, Kolbeck A, Thewes M.
utilization of bio-ethanol fuel. Applied Energy 2009; 86: Ethanol and its potential for downsizing engine
2273–2282. concepts. MTZ - Motortechnische Zeitschrift 2012;
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2009.03.015. 73(2): 120-125. German.
2. Bielaczyc P, Woodburn J, Gandyk M, Szczotka A. https://doi.org/10.1365/s35146-012-0246-0.
Ethanol as an automotive fuel – a review. 17. Smith TW, Axon CJ, Darton RC. The impact on
Combustion 2016; 166(3): 39-45. human health of car-related air pollution in the UK,
https://doi.org/10.19206/CE-2016-338. 1995–2005. Atmospheric Environment 2013; 77:
3. Dardiotis C, Fontaras G, Marotta A, Martini G, 260-266.
Manfredi U. Emissions of modern light duty ethanol https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosenv.2013.05.016.
flex-fuel vehicles over different operating and 18. Suarez-Bertoa R, Zardini A, Keuken H, Astorga C.
environmental conditions. Fuel 2015; 140: 531-540. Impact of ethanol containing gasoline blends on
doi: 10.1016/j.fuel.2014.09.085. emissions from a flex-fuel vehicle tested over the
4. Jakóbiec J, Marchut A, Jaskólski J. Exhaust Worldwide Harmonized Light Duty Test Cycle
emissions of engines fuelled with gasoline with (WLTC). Fuel 2015; 143: 173-182.
bioethanol. Journal of KONES 2000: 146-153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2014.10.076.
Polish. 19. Wender I, Friedel R, Orchin M. Ethanol from
5. Kałużny J. et al. An innovative system for piston Methanol. Science 1951; 113: 206-207.
engine combustion with laser-induced ignition of the https://doi.org/10.1126/science.113.2930.206.
hydrocarbon fuel consisting carbon nanotubes. 20. Worldwide Fuel Charter 2013.
Combustion Engines 2017; 168(1): 3-14,
https://doi.org/10.19206/CE-2017-101. Received 2019-01-08
6. Klimiuk E, Pawłowska M, Pokój T. Biofuels – Accepted 2019-05-06
technologies for sustainable development. PWN Available online 2019-05-07
Warszawa; 2012. Polish.
Miłosław Kozak, DSc, DEng,
7. Leja K, Lewandowicz G, Grajek W. Production of
graduated with honors at the
bioethanol from cellulose raw materials.
Faculty of Mechanical
Biotechnologia, 2009; 4(87): 88–101. Polish.
Engineering of the Lublin
8. Liu Y, Murata K, Inaba M, Takahara I. Synthesis of University of Technology in
ethanol from methanol and syngas through an indirect 1998, he obtained further
route containing methanol dehydrogenation, DME academic degrees at the
carbonylation, and methyl acetate hydrogenolysis. Faculty of Transport at the
Fuel Processing Technology 2013; 110: 206-213. Poznan University of
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fuproc.2012.12.016. Technology. Main areas of his
9. Merkisz J, Kozak M, Teodorczyk A. Benefits and scientific activity include:
risks associated with the use of biofuels in internal conventional and alternative motor fuels, automotive
combustion engines. Archiwum Spalania, 2003, 3(1). pollution of the environment, on-board emission
Polish. measurement systems (PEMS), environmental macro and
10. Nylund N, Koponen K. Fuel and Technology microsimulation of road traffic and the use of
Alternatives for Buses. VTT Technical Research thermogravimetric methods, chromatography and mass
Centre of Finland; 2012. spectrometry in the study of ecological properties of
11. Pałuchowska M, Stępień Z, Żak G. The prospects for means of transport.
the use of ethanol as a fuel component and its
potential in the reduction of exhaust emissions.
Combustion Engines 2014; 158(3): 80-92.
12. Regulation of the Minister of Economy of 14 May
2015 amending the regulation on quality
requirements for biocomponents, methods for testing
the quality of biocomponents and the method of
sampling biocomponents. Polish. Dz.U. 2015 poz.
780.