Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PCOSBF EndOncMet2017
PCOSBF EndOncMet2017
net/publication/319165460
Polycystic ovarian syndrome and low milk supply: Is insulin resistance the
missing link?
CITATIONS READS
0 82
All content following this page was uploaded by Lora Kirigin Bilos on 18 August 2017.
REVIEW
/:+<>7/8>908.9-<389691CN3+,/>/=+8./>+,963-3=/+=/=d6+./8#/5=9eN%83@/<=3>C9=:3>+6/8>/<d#/=></369=<.83-/eN%83@/<=3>C90*+1</,/.3-+6
#-2996N&3891<+.=5+/=>+ N*+1</,N<9+>3+
9<</=:98.381+?>29<O ,=><+->
9<+#>+85+3<3138369įN/:+<>7/8>90 /=:3>/>2/589A87+>/<8+6+8.380+8>,/8/F>=90,</+=>0//.381N986C
8.9-<389691CN3+,/>/=+8./>+,963-
+,9?>>A9\FL2=90380+8>=+<//B-6?=3@/6C,</+=>0/.09<>2/F<=> 798>2=
3=/+=/=d6+./8#/5=9eN%83@/<=3>C
90630/NA3>269A7365=?::6C+7981>2/79=>-977986C-3>/.</+=98=
9=:3>+6/8>/<d#/=></369=<.83-/eN
%83@/<=3>C90*+1</,/.3-+6#-2996N
09<,</+=>0//.381-/==+>398M6>29?12+8/-.9>+6</:9<>=0<976+->+>398
*+1</,N<9+>3+N 298/Oƅ\ N -98=?6>+8>=38.3-+>/>2+>:96C-C=>3-9@+<3+8=C8.<97/V #W38>/<0/</=
/\7+36O69<+M=M53<3138ž17+36M-97 A3>26+->+>398N@/<C0/A=>?.3/=2+@//B+738/.>23=</6+>398=23:N+8.>2/
+==9-3+>398,/>A//8 #+8.6+->+>398.C=0?8->398</7+38=:99<6C
OM m/97m M M M ?8./<=>99.M9</9@/<N=>?.3/=2+@/</:9<>/.-98G3->381</=?6>=A2/8
/B+738381,</+=>0//.381=?--/==38A97/8A3>2 #N+8..3@/<1/8-/
"/-/3@/.O+C >2 90 >2/ # :2/89>C:/ 7+C ,/ </=:98=3,6/ 09< >2/ 2/>/<91/8/9?=
--/:>/.O?8/ >2 </=?6>=>9.+>/M#:/-3F-+66CN38=?638</=3=>+8-/7+C2+@/+8+11<+@+>381
?,63=2/.O?8/ >2
9</@/8/==/8>3+6<96/38>2/:+>291/8/=3=9069A7365=?::6CM"/-/8>6CN
9:C<312>OƁ9:C<312>,C==9-3+>398 :<9>/38>C<9=38/:29=:2+>+=/N</-/:>9<>C:/N2+=,//83./8>3F/.+=+
09<8.9-<38/8-9691C+8./>+,963=7M :9>/8>3+6,397+<5/<638538138=?638</=3=>+8-/A3>238=?I-3/8>7365=?::6CM
$23=3=+8:/8--/==+<>3-6/.3=><3,?>/. --9<.3816CN38>/<@/8>398=>+<1/>38138=?638+->3982+@/,//8</-9183D/.
?8./<>2/>/<7=90>2/</+>3@/ +=:9>/8>3+66C:<973=381=><+>/13/=>9A+<.>2/></+>7/8>906+->+>398
97798=>><3,?>39898\977/<-3+6 .C=0?8->398M$23=</@3/AA36623126312>=>?.3/=6385381 #A3>269A7365
3-/8=/V2>>:Omm-</+>3@/-97798=M9<1m =?::6C+8./B:69</:9>/8>3+67/-2+83=7=>2+>-98><3,?>/>96+->+>398
63-/8=/=m,C\8-m MmWA23-2:/<73>=
?8</=><3->/.898\-977/<-3+6?=/N
.C=0?8->39838>2/=/A97/8M
.3=><3,?>398N+8.</:<9.?->39838+8C /CA9<.=O8=?638</=3=>+8-/P6+->+>398P69A7365=?::6CP:96C-C=>3-9@+<3+8
7/.3?7N:<9@3./.>2/9<3138+6A9<53= =C8.<97/
:<9:/<6C-3>/.M
?8.381O98/M
98G3->9038>/</=>=>+>/7/8>O$2/
+?>29<./-6+</=>2+>=2/2+=89-98G3->
9038>/</=>M
+>+@+36+,363>C#>+>/7/8>O66
</6/@+8>.+>++</A3>238>2/:+:/<M
Breastfeeding involves a complex interplay of several Estrogen and progesterone stimulate breast development
hormones, many of which are disordered in women with throughout puberty and pregnancy [17]. During puberty, a
PCOS, and these hormonal alterations may interfere rise in circulating estrogen stimulates ductal growth. Early
with mammogenesis, lactogenesis, or galactopoiesis [8]. in pregnancy, progesterone and prolactin facilitate alveolar
Anecdotal reports from lactation consultants indicate growth. Secretory differentiation or lactogenesis I occurs
that PCOS interferes with lactation; however, very few during midpregnancy and results in mammary epithelial
cell differentiation. Later, the fall in progesterone after
studies have examined this relationship. This is surprising
parturition results in secretory activation or lactogenesis
considering the high prevalence of PCOS among women
II, stimulating milk secretion [8,17].
of childbearing age [9] and the known benefits of
breastfeeding [10]. Furthermore, due to advances in
Women with PCOS have decreased levels of progesterone,
reproductive technology, more and more women with
which could potentially interfere with alveolar growth during
PCOS have successful pregnancies, with little known
pregnancy [8]. Furthermore, despite high circulating levels
about the effect, it will have on lactation. of estrogen in women with PCOS, hyperandrogenism may
downregulate estrogen and prolactin receptors [8]. Insulin
Studies have reported conflicting results when
and glucocorticoids are also essential for lactogenesis to
examining breastfeeding success in women with PCOS
occur, but their signaling pathways and downstream targets
(Table 1) [11,12], and the contribution of PCOS to
are not completely understood [17].
lactation difficulties remains poorly understood. The
first study to suggest a potential link between PCOS and 3. Low Milk Supply and the Hyperinsulinemia-
low milk supply was a case report that described three Androgen Connection
women with PCOS who failed to breastfeed [8]. Later,
in a case-control study, Vanky et al. reported somewhat Androgens inhibit lactation [18] and are elevated in pregnant
reduced breastfeeding rates in women with PCOS in the women with PCOS [19]. The first study to report an association
early postpartum period [11]. between androgens and breastfeeding outcomes in women
Table 1: Main findings published in the literature concerning the relationship between PCOS and
breastfeeding success
Study title Year Reference # Study design Study description Main results and
published conclusions
Pregnancy outcome 2006 [12] Single-center To analyze pregnancy Breastfeeding success was
in infertile patients retrospective case health parameters and not affected by PCOS or
with polycystic ovary analysis outcomes (including metformin use
syndrome who were breastfeeding success) Of the women that
treated with metformin in patients with PCOS attempted breastfeeding,
treated with metformin 78% (97/124) were
successful and 22% failed
Only four women attributed
poor milk production as
a reason for stopping
breastfeeding
with PCOS was a case-control study that included 36 women placebo in women with PCOS (the PregMet study [20]),
with PCOS and 99 controls [11]. The researches found that DHEAS, testosterone, and free testosterone index had no
third-trimester dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEAS) levels impact on breastfeeding [21].
were negatively correlated with breastfeeding rates at 1- and
3-month postpartum. However, in a later follow-up study of Insulin resistance, followed by compensatory
a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of metformin versus hyperinsulinemia, is frequently found in patients with
PCOS and is in part responsible for the increased suggest that interventions targeting insulin action may be
levels of androgens in these women [22]. This so-called a promising and novel strategy toward improving milk
“hyperinsulinemia-androgen connection” is a vicious supply in susceptible mothers [13].
cycle, whereby insulin directly induces excess androgen
production by theca cells [23] and decreases sex hormone- Metformin could improve lactation through its favorable
binding globulin (SHBG) production by the liver [24]. effect on insulin resistance. However, in a retrospective
This leads to more free androgens, which in turn interferes case analysis of pregnancy outcomes in 188 PCOS
with removal of insulin by the liver. patients treated with metformin, breastfeeding success
was not affected by PCOS or metformin use. Of the 124
Approximately 30-40% of women with PCOS have women that attempted breastfeeding, 78% (97/124) were
impaired glucose tolerance, and 10% develop Type 2 successful, and 22% (27/124) failed [12]. Only four women
diabetes mellitus by the age of 40 [6,16]. The previous attributed poor milk production as a reason for stopping
studies have shown diabetes to be negatively associated breastfeeding. Furthermore, in a follow-up study of an
with lactation [13]. One study found that mothers with RCT of metformin versus placebo in pregnant women
gestational diabetes, especially mothers with insulin- with PCOS (the PregMet study [20]), metformin had no
dependent gestational diabetes, and obese mothers impact on breastfeeding [21].
breastfed their children significantly less and for a
Recently, a small-scale phase I/II RCT of metformin
shorter duration than healthy mothers [25]. Gestational
versus placebo has been conducted, with results pending,
diabetes has also been associated with delayed onset
to test whether metformin is safe and potentially effective
of lactogenesis [26]. In a case-control analysis, women
in treating low milk supply in insulin resistant and pre-
diagnosed with low milk supply were significantly more
diabetic mothers [28]. Primary outcome measures will
likely to have had diabetes in pregnancy compared with
include milk output (at baseline and weeks 2 and 4
women with latch or nipple problems. An independent
post-intervention), and secondary outcome measures
effect of PCOS on the risk of low milk supply was
will include safety, mammary gene expression (using
not observed in a model that included diabetes, and
mammary epithelial cell mRNA and RNA-sequencing),
the authors concluded that “PCOS as a risk factor for
sensitivity and specificity of maternal fasting plasma
insufficient lactation may be limited to the subset of
glucose (FPG) in predicting low milk supply, and change
women with postpartum glucose intolerance” [13].
in milk output among completers. The results of this
The association between low milk supply and insulin study will inform a future larger double-masked RCT of
adjuvant metformin treatment versus placebo for early
dysregulation was elegantly demonstrated in a recent
postpartum low milk supply in women with insulin
study that compared gene expression in the milk fat
resistance based on the presence of at least one of the
globule transcriptome of women with or without low
followings: Elevated FPG (defined as >95 g/dL), history
milk supply [27]. Milk fat globules are a rich source
of PCOS or gestational diabetes, or current abdominal
of mammary epithelial cell messenger RNA (mRNA),
obesity. Thus, results of this pilot study are eagerly awaited
and using RNA-sequencing technology, the researchers
and will have a major impact on treatment strategies for
found that protein tyrosine phosphatase, receptor type,
women with gestational diabetes, pre-diabetes, or PCOS
F (PTPRF), which blocks the action of insulin to stimulate
that present with low milk supply.
milk production, is overexpressed in the mammary gland
of women with low milk supply. Therefore, PTPRF may 4. Metabolic Disturbances, Obesity, and
serve as a biomarker linking insulin resistance with Breastfeeding
insufficient milk supply. Women with decreased insulin
sensitivity might have a more sluggish increase in milk Animal models have demonstrated that obesity is
output in response to infant demand as a result of PTPRF associated with marked abnormalities in mammary
overexpression in the mammary gland [27]. These findings alveolar development [29]. Mammary adipose tissue
may produce locally effective concentrations of estrogen and postprandial blood glucose [39,40], and greater
that could alter mammary gland development and insulin sensitivity [39], few studies have measured these
lactation [17]. biochemical parameters longitudinally [37]. Moreover, as
previously mentioned, it is difficult to ascertain whether
Approximately one-half of women with PCOS are non-lactating women are at the start “metabolically
obese [30], and women with pre-gravid obesity, irrespective inferior” compared to lactating women [21]. Therefore,
of the presence of PCOS are less likely to initiate and while breastfeeding may prevent the development of the
sustain breastfeeding [31,32]. Maternal obesity is also metabolic syndrome, pre-existing metabolic dysregulation
associated with delayed onset of lactogenesis [33] and may hinder attempts at breastfeeding [41]. Women with
a lower prolactin response to suckling [34]. Therefore, PCOS are at an increased risk of developing the metabolic
women with PCOS may be at an increased risk for syndrome [42], and these characteristics may make them
insufficient milk supply due to their underlying obesity.
more susceptible to lactation difficulties. One study
examined the effect of lactation on insulin resistance,
In the first case-control study of breastfeeding in women
glucose and insulin metabolism, and biological markers
with PCOS, Vanky et al. reported reduced breastfeeding
rates in the early postpartum period in women with of insulin resistance (SHBG and insulin-like growth
PCOS; however, the controls were not matched for body factor binding protein-1 [IGFBP]) in fully breastfeeding
mass index (BMI). In the follow-up study of an RCT women with PCOS and normal lactating women during
of metformin versus placebo in pregnant women with the postpartum period as well as after weaning [43].
PCOS (the PregMet study [20]), the significance of breast 12 lactating women with PCOS and six normal lactating
growth in pregnancy, indexed by a change in bra size, on women were matched for BMI, and during the study,
breastfeeding outcomes was assessed [21]. The duration BMI remained unchanged was comparable between the
of both exclusive and partial breastfeeding correlated groups. Lactation had no significant effect on peripheral
positively with breast size increment and the increase insulin resistance (measured by the insulin tolerance test)
in breast size was unrelated to maternal BMI or change in women with PCOS, but fasting insulin concentrations
in BMI. Indeed, increased BMI was related to a shorter were lower after weaning in the lactating PCOS group
duration of partial breastfeeding. Furthermore, those than in the same patients before pregnancy. Therefore,
with no breast growth were more metabolically disturbed although lactation may improve metabolic control in these
(obese had higher blood pressure, serum triglycerides, patients shortly after weaning, the long-term benefits
and fasting insulin levels). The authors suggested a new remain uncertain and should be investigated in future
way of interpreting past epidemiological studies that prospective studies.
have shown breast milk to protect offspring from obesity
and diabetes [14,35,36]. Namely, because mothers with 5. Conclusion
decreased breastfeeding rates were more obese and had
Studies, albeit scare, have reported conflicting results
higher insulin levels, their offspring may be more prone to
develop obesity, independent of breast milk. Simply put, when examining breastfeeding success in women with
women who are not able to breastfeed are metabolically PCOS [11,12], and the divergence of the PCOS phenotype
inferior compared with those who breastfeed easily [21]. may be responsible for the heterogeneous results to
date. Specifically, insulin resistance as a feature of PCOS
Similarly, studies examining the long-term benefits of may have a contributing or even essential role in the
breastfeeding on maternal metabolic risk factors have development of lactation dysfunction and may be the
yielded mixed results, and very few studies provide direct missing link. Considering the high prevalence of PCOS
evidence for lactation’s lasting effects on the development among women of childbearing age and the known
of cardiometabolic diseases [37]. Although lactating benefits of breastfeeding for both mother and child, it is
compared with non-lactating women have better metabolic evident that more research in this area is needed. Future
parameters, including lower lipid levels [38], lower fasting research should focus on the underlying mechanisms