Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article Salmonella
Article Salmonella
net/publication/6991744
CITATIONS READS
10 865
5 authors, including:
Montserrat Agut
Universitat Ramon Llull
104 PUBLICATIONS 2,206 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Montserrat Agut on 23 October 2017.
www.elsevier.de/micres
KEYWORDS Summary
Salmonella;
The survivability of Salmonella cells in popcorn preparation was determined for two
Corn kernels;
distinct cooking methods. The first method used a standard microwave oven. The
Popcorn;
second method used conventional cooking in a pan. Prior to thermal processing in
Thermal treatment;
independent experiments, 12 suspensions in a range between 1 103 and 8 106
Microwave
colony-forming units (CFU) per gram of Salmonella cells were inoculated in both raw
microwave popcorn and conventional corn kernels. The influence of the initial
concentration of Salmonella cells in the raw products and the lethal effects on
Salmonella by thermal treatments for cooking were studied. Survival of Salmonella
cells was determined in the thermally processed material by pre-enrichment and
enrichment in selective medium, in accordance with the legislation for expanded
cereals and cereals in flakes. Viable experimental contaminants were recovered
from the conventionally cooked popcorn with initial inoculation concentrations of
9 104 cells/g or greater. Salmonella cell viability was significantly reduced after
microwave oven treatment, with recoveries only from initial concentrations of
2 106 cells/g or superior.
& 2006 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
0944-5013/$ - see front matter & 2006 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.micres.2006.03.010
ARTICLE IN PRESS
74 I. Anaya et al.
microwave or conventional cooking is capable of density equivalent to 2 on the McFarland scale. This
eliminating pathogens such as Salmonella in order suspension was used to prepare serial standard
to guarantee the safety of such processed food. decimal dilutions in sterile salt solution (0.85%
It is known that each popcorn kernel contains a NaCl).
drop of water inside a mass of soft starch Subsequently, absorbance readings of the serial
surrounded by a hard outer surface. As the kernel dilutions were taken using a spectrophotometer
heats up, the water begins to expand, and pressure (Helios Alpha, Unicam, UK) at 390 nm, with sterile
builds against the hard starch. Eventually, this hard saline solution (0.85% NaCl) as the blank.
surface fractures, and the soft starch inside inflates Viable counts of Salmonella cells present in these
and bursts, turning the kernel inside out. The drop serial dilutions were determined by superficial
of water is vaporized and released, as the corn inoculation on Hektoen enteric agar (Oxoid).
kernel pops, causing Salmonella cell death under Exactly 0.1 ml of each serial dilution was placed
the best-case scenario. and spread onto an agar plate using a glass
The thermal treatment, to reduce the presence spreader. The plates rested for some minutes in
of Salmonella and other microorganisms in differ- the same position before they were incubated at
ent foods including pork, turkey, poultry meat, eggs 37 1C for 24 h. Colonies, which developed on
and corn flour, by use of water bath and dry heat Hektoen enteric agar, were recognized and
treatments is described in the literature by counted. The total colony-forming unit (CFU) per
(VanCauwenberge et al., 1981; Juneja et al., gram was obtained by multiplying the number of
2001; Bemrah et al., 2003; Grijspeerdt and Her- colonies by ten.
man, 2003; Marcy et al., 2004). Also, the use of
microwave radiation for the reduction of Salmo-
nella and others microorganisms in various foods:
Thermal treatment
chicken, turkey, beef, corn-soy-milk, eggs, frozen
food, poultry feed, poultry meat and rice salad is
described in the literature by (Craven and Lillard, Corn samples
1974; Blanco and Dawson, 1974; Crespo et al.,
Samples of corn kernels were purchased from a
1977; Cunningham, 1978; Bookwalter et al., 1982;
local supermarket. The raw microwave popcorn is
Burdick et al., 1983; Aleixo et al., 1985; Evans
manufactured using corn suitable for microwave
et al., 1995; Levre and Valentini, 1998).
popping which is specially prepared with stable
Reports of Salmonella survivability in popcorn
vegetable fats, salt, flavourings and antioxidants.
processed from raw microwave popcorn or conven-
This product is packed in a 100 g specially designed
tional corn kernel products are not available in the
published literature and this work could complete paper bag, which can be placed in the microwave
oven.
this lack of information regarding these products.
On the other hand, the conventional corn kernels
We report the survival characteristics of Salmonella
for popcorn production were purchased as raw
enterica in inoculated raw popcorn kernels that
products supplied in containers with selected
were conventionally stove cooked in a pan and
kernels that had been packed in a modified atmo-
cooked in a microwave oven to final internal
sphere packaging.
temperatures of 130.0 and 110.0 1C, respectively.
Prior to the thermal treatment, the corn kernel
samples were screened by standard methods
(Pascual-Anderson and Calderón-Pascual, 1999) to
Materials and methods determine the presence of naturally occurring
Salmonella. Only samples free of Salmonella were
considered suitable for the assay.
Preparation of the standard calibration curve
with 0.1 ml of the pre-enrichment medium. The tube For the initial inoculation of the samples, the
was then incubated at 42 1C for 18–24 h. equation described above is useful to calculate the
Additionally, 100 ml of selenite–cystine enrich- concentration of the Salmonella suspensions
ment broth (Merck) was placed in a 250 ml S1–S12. Results are shown in Table 1.
Erlenmeyer flask and inoculated with 10 ml of the We have found no reports in the literature
pre-enrichment medium. The flask was incubated indicating Salmonella contamination levels in raw
at 37 1C for 18–24 h. corn material for microwave or conventional cook-
ing. The range of Salmonella contaminations
Isolation normally present on raw material would have an
important bearing on establishing safe cooking
Each microbiological loop sample was inoculated procedures.
into a separate polyethylene plate, which had been There is no exact infective dose of Salmonella,
made previously to contain 25 ml of brilliant green but as few as 100 cells per 100 g of food have been
agar (Merck) or Hektoen enteric agar (Oxoid). The reported to make people sick (Jay, 1996).
plates were subsequently incubated at 37 1C for The risk of infection is dependent upon age and
24–48 h. health of the host, and it also depends on the
bacterial strain. For safety reasons, European
regulation concerning the quasi-totality of food
Identification of presumptive salmonella
colonies
0.07 y = 5.9E-06x + 1.2E-05
Bacterial colonies which developed on the selective
0.06 R2 = 0.9992
agar cultures, brilliant green agar and Hektoen enteric
0.05
Absorbance
Absorbance ¼ 5:9 106 ½CFU=g þ 1:2 105 . (+): positive recovery; (): negative recovery.
a
Total time: 3 min, Final temp: 130 1C.
(1) b
Total time: 4 min, Final temp: 110 1C.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Survivability of Salmonella cells in popcorn after microwave oven and conventional cooking 77
products stipulate a Salmonella contamination rate strated that Salmonella can survive after being
of less than 1 bacteria per 25 g (Axelsson and Sorin, subjected to the thermal treatments typically
1997). executed by end consumers. Likewise, it must be
In this study, Salmonella suspensions ranging taken into account that the time-temperature
from 1 103 to 8 106 cells per gram, were used relation is different in both cases, as with the
to contaminate the corn kernel samples. These intensity and conditions of heating (microwave
values were chosen to simulate high-contaminated oven: 3 min/130 1C; conventional cooking: 4 min/
samples levels that would be able to produce illness 110 1C).
after the consumption of popcorn. The experimental data presented in Table 1 show
Due to the different types of domestic micro- the differences in the Salmonella survivability
waves ovens, the popcorn makers recommend in according to cooking type. The viability or
the instructions, that using a 700 W unit, the positive recovery of Salmonella was greater when
time required in order to explode the corn the raw popcorn was prepared by conventional
grains is 3 min at full power (high). Under these cooking. Although microwave heating was applied
conditions, the centre of the bag reached for 1 min less, it resulted in a more intense heat
temperature values of 130.070.5 1C and was impact on Salmonella due to a higher end tem-
favoured mainly by the packing type, which perature in the centre of the finished popcorn.
concentrate a high quantity of water vapour, Thus, the lethal effects on Salmonella by micro-
and by the high content of vegetable fats. Follow- wave cooking are greater compared with the
ing microwave cooking for each of the 12 initial conventional cooking, and therefore Salmonella
suspensions, our experimental data showed survival is lower.
that Salmonella cells were recovered and detected It is common knowledge that heat kills bacteria.
only when corn kernels were inoculated However, when evaluating process lethality, it is
with concentrations of Salmonella higher than essential to understand both the wide range of
2 106 cells/g. The experiments in which Salmo- product and process parameters, beyond just
nella cells were recovered and detected temperature, that affect the process outcome.
are marked as positive (+) in Table 1, whereas the Thermal inactivation or heat resistance of micro-
experiments in which no Salmonella was detected organisms is influenced by numerous intrinsic
are marked as negative (). factors. Kirby and Davies (1990), and Burns et al.
The conventional heating process for raw corn (2001) conclude that samples with low water
material does not have an established procedure activity confer a higher thermal resistance to
and the homemade form has many variations. After Salmonella cells. In fact, the water activity (aw)
different laboratory tests, it was demonstrated values of raw microwave popcorn and conventional
that 4 min are necessary to completely explode corn kernels for popcorn production are between
25 g of raw corn kernels in the pan. After the 0.86 and 0.89. Additionally, as Fain et al. (1991)
4 min had elapsed, the temperature in the centre had previously reported, the thermal resistance of
of the finished product was 110.070.5 1C. To bacteria in food appears to increase with fat
achieve repetitive results during the conventional content. However, the microwave bag is a sealed
thermal treatment, the raw corn kernels for package, allowing the high-temperature water
popcorn production were always cooked for 4 min. vapour and vegetable fats to remain in its interior
Using this conditions, Salmonella cells were for more time, with increasing elimination of the
recovered and detected only when corn kernels Salmonella cells.
were inoculated whit concentrations of Salmonella The non-thermal effects of microwave processes
higher than 9 104 cells/g. In Table 1, samples on microbial inactivation have not been confirmed
marked as positive (+) are those in which Salmo- in the literature and appear insufficient in magni-
nella was detected, whereas the experiments in tude to be considered during development of
which no Salmonella was detected are marked as preparation procedure. Nevertheless, the food
negative (). ingredients such as ionized salts, vegetable fats,
In this study, results demonstrate that the flavourings and antioxidants interact with the
microwave cooking procedure is useful to achieve microwave oven electric field, increasing the
a 6-fold reduction of this pathogen. On the other temperature in the bag and favouring Salmonella
hand, conventional cooking is less efficient than the cells death.
microwave cooking process reaching only a 4-fold On the other hand, the conventional corn kernels
reduction of Salmonella cells. for popcorn production are exempt of preservatives
With considerations to the Salmonella concen- and the increment of temperature is only attained
tration in the raw material, it has been demon- by contact with the metallic material, which allows
ARTICLE IN PRESS
78 I. Anaya et al.
Salmonella cell to survive the sub-lethal thermal product in collective catering establishment. Int. J.
treatment. Food Microbiol. 80, 17–30.
Blanco, J.F., Dawson, L.E., 1974. Survival of Clostridium
perfringens on chicken cooked with microwave en-
ergy. Poultry Sci. 53, 1823–1830.
Conclusions Bookwalter, G.N., Shukla, T.P., Kwolek, W.F., 1982.
Microwave processing to destroy Salmonellae in
We do not have knowledge of any reported cases corn-soy-milk blends and effect on product quality.
of salmonellosis due to the consumption of popcorn J. Food Sci. 47, 1683–1686.
from raw microwave or conventional corn kernels. Burdick, D., Cox, N.A., Thomson, J.E., Bailey, J.S., 1983.
Heating by microwave, hot air, and flowing steam to
However, the ability of Salmonella cells to survive
eliminate inoculated Salmonella from poultry feed.
the popcorn preparation, shows that the consump-
Poultry Sci. 62, 1780–1785.
tion of products produced from contaminated Burns, T.R., Marks, B.P., Harris, K.L., Orta-Ramirez, A.,
raw material may represent a risk if the initial Ryser, E.T., 2001. Effect of meat moisture content on
count of Salmonella cells is relatively high (approx. thermal inactivation of bacteria. In: IFT Abstract 84-9,
104–106 cells/g). Paper presented at the Institute of Food Technologists
Lower inoculums levels might yield a safe Annual Meeting, New Orleans, LA.
product with the cooking procedures employed in Craven, S.E., Lillard, H.S., 1974. Effect of microwave
this study, either with microwave oven or with heating of pre-cooked chicken on Clostridium perfrin-
conventional cooking. However, if levels of con- gens. J. Food Sci. 39, 211–217.
tamination similar to those used in this study occur Crespo, F.L., Ockermann, H.W., Irvin, K.M., 1977. Effect
in the commercial raw kernels (4104 cells/g), of microorganisms in meat by microwave and conven-
popcorn cooking at home may represent a potential tional cooking. J. Food Prot. 40, 588–593.
food safety problem. Cunningham, F.E., 1978. The effect of brief microwave
treatment on numbers of bacteria in fresh chicken
Due to the ability of Salmonella cells to survive
patties. Poultry Sci. 57, 296–297.
popcorn preparation by microwave and conven-
Evans, M.R., Parry, S.M., Ribeiro, C.D., 1995. Salmonella
tional cooking, the data presented in this paper outbreak from microwave cooked food. Epidemiol.
may be interesting for popcorn producing enter- Infect. 115, 227–230.
prises when creating hazard analysis and critical Fain Jr., A.R., Line, J.E., Moran, A.B., Martin, L.M.,
control point (HACCP) plans. Lechowich, R.V., Carosella, J.M., Brown, W.L., 1991.
Lethality of heat to Listeria monocytogenes Scott A:
D-value and z-value determinations in ground beef
and Turkey. J. Food Prot. 54, 756–761.
Acknowledgements Grijspeerdt, K., Herman, L., 2003. Inactivation of
Salmonella enteritidis during boiling of eggs. Int. J.
We acknowledge the support of Selecta S.A. for Food Microbiol. 82, 13–24.
the materials with which this study was under- Jay, J.M., 1996. Modern Food Microbiology: Foodborne
taken. Gastroenteritis Caused by Salmonella and Shigella,
fifth ed. Chapman & Hall, New York, pp. 507–526.
Juneja, V.K., Eblen, B.S., Marks, H.M., 2001. Modeling
non-linear survival curves to calculate thermal in-
References activation of Salmonella in poultry of different fat
levels. Int. J. Food Microbiol. 70, 37–51.
Aleixo, J.A., Swaminathan, G.B., Jamesen, K.S., Pratt, Kirby, R.M., Davies, R., 1990. Survival of dehydrated cells
D.E., 1985. Destruction of pathogenic bacteria in of Salmonella typhimurium LT2 at high temperatures.
turkeys roasted in microwave ovens. J. Food Sci. 50, J. Appl. Bacteriol. 68, 241–246.
873–880. Levre, E., Valentini, P., 1998. Inactivation of Salmonella
Anaya, I., Ventura, M., Comellas, L., Agut, M., 2004. during microwave cooking. Zbl. Hyg. Umweltmed.
Microbiological survey of 40 samples of corn (Zea 201, 431–436.
mays) and derived products obtained in local markets Marcy, J.A., Murphy, R.Y., Beard, B.L., Martin, E.M.,
of Barcelona, Spain. Alimentaria 354, 73–79. Duncan, L.K., 2004. Comparative study of thermal
Axelsson, F., Sorin, M.L., 1997. Transia Salmonella. inactivation of Escherichia coli O157:H7, Salmonella,
Technical Handbook 1997. Diffchamb AB, Hisings Listeria monocytogenes in ground pork. J. Food Sci.
Backa, pp. 8–15. 69, 97–101.
Bemrah, N., Bergis, H., Colmin, C., Beaufort, A., Pascual-Anderson, M.R., Calderón-Pascual, V., 1999.
Millemann, Y., Dufour, B., Benet, J.J., Cerf, O., Food Microbiology: Analytical Methodology for Foods
Sanaa, M., 2003. Quantitative risk assessment of and Drinks, second ed. Dı́az de Santos S.A., Madrid,
human salmonellosis from the consumption of a turkey pp. 41–62.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Survivability of Salmonella cells in popcorn after microwave oven and conventional cooking 79
Uyttendaele, M.R., Debevere, J.M., Lips, R.M., Neyts, otypes on dry corn flour. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 42,
K.D., 1998. Prevalence of Salmonella in poultry 688–691.
carcasses and their products in Belgium. Int. J. Food Vela, G.R., Wu, J.F., 1979. Mechanism of lethal action of
Microbiol. 40, 1–8. 2450 MHz microwave radiation on microorganisms.
VanCauwenberge, J.E., Bothast, R.J., Kwolek, W.F., Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 37, 550–553.
1981. Thermal inactivation of eight Salmonella ser-