Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1549385878URP 4243 L-02 Disaster Management Plans (Counter Plan)
1549385878URP 4243 L-02 Disaster Management Plans (Counter Plan)
1549385878URP 4243 L-02 Disaster Management Plans (Counter Plan)
Lecture-02:
Disaster Management Plans
(Counter Plan)
62
Course Teacher:
Md. Esraz-Ul-Zannat
Assistant Professor
1
2
Topics to be Covered by this Presentation
Purpose of the Disaster Management Plan
The Need for Plans
Pitfalls in Planning
Levels of Planning
Format of Plans
5
THE NEED FOR PLANS
International experience shows that proper and adequate
planning can reduce the impact of disasters
6
PITFALLS IN PLANNING
Plans must be kept under review.
Plans must be effective with the necessary mechanism to
implement it
Plans become ineffective because of
Lack of clear national policy
Inadequate funding
Limited expertise, or
Other similar reasons
7
PLANNING AND DM CYCLE
Prevention
Mitigation
Structural (Technocratic View)
Non-Structural (Development Planners’ View)
Preparedness/Response
Recovery
8
LEVELS OF PLANNING
National Level
Policy matters to detailed actions
Local Level
Detailed counter measures
Coordination
9
FORMAT OF PLANS
No fixed format
Some Common Rules
Clarity of aim
Realism
Flexibility
Coordination
Definition of responsibility
Ease of use
Plans should be
Written
Simple
Disseminated
Tested
Revised 10
CRITICAL AREAS IN PLANNING
Crisis Pressure
Loss of or major disruption to communications
Destruction of resources
Disruption of disaster management system
Octopus Effect
Information Management
11
PLANNING PROCESS
The basic issues of disaster management planning are:
1. Necessity of linking different phases of disaster, such as:
Phase I: Prevention/Mitigation (Pre-disaster phase);
Phase II: Preparedness/Fighting (Just before disaster);
Phase III: Emergency response (During disaster);
Phase IV: Rehabilitation (Post-disaster).
2. Disaster relevant differences between the developed and
developing countries;
3. Difference in rural and urban ways of life;
4. Criteria for assessment of disaster management planning;
12
PLANNING PROCESS
The basic issues of disaster management planning are:
5. Possible links between disaster management planning
and development planning;
6. Participation of local citizens and communities;
7. Concerns over future disasters;
8. Institutional framework for disaster management.
13
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Phase I: Prevention and Mitigation Phase
This includes a pre-disaster long term pre-impact activities such as:
A. Structural measures;
B. Non-structural measures.
A. Structural Measures
i) Construction of dykes (sea)/embankments (river) for control of
flood and storm surge (due to cyclone);
ii) Raising of homesteads and other structures above flood level;
iii) Construction of strong buildings and retrofitting of existing
buildings to withstand strong earthquakes and windstorms;
iv) Construction of water retention reservoirs and tubewells for use of
ground water to combat drought;
v) Construction of disaster shelter for temporary accommodation of
disaster affected people. 14
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
B. Non-structural Measures
i) Preparation of hazard map and land use management by
prohibiting construction of buildings and other facilities in
hazardous areas, such as flood plains, low lying coastal areas,
probable landslide locations etc.;
ii) National legislation requiring all communities to have a certain level
of disaster management planning;
iii) Development of forecasting and warning system;
iv) Training of administrators, volunteers and local people on disaster
management and occasional drills.
15
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Phase II: Disaster Preparedness/Fighting
This phase has to do with pre-impact measures immediately
before the outset of the impending disaster and aimed at
improving emergency preparedness and time if a disaster
were to occur. Preparedness measures are:
Forecasting and warning to caution people likely to be affected
and administration for taking necessary preparedness;
Mobilization of trained volunteers and people for safeguarding
vital installations and disaster fighting;
Stockpiling of food, water and medical supplies to enhance
preparedness disaster fighting at emergency times;
Setting up of temporary shelters.
16
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Phase III: Emergency Response
This phase has to do with those emergency actions that
immediately follow disaster impact. They generally include
the following emergency activities:
Undertaking Search and rescue:
Taking helpless people to temporary shelters;
Emergency relief such as food, water, clothing, medical supports
etc.
Setting up emergency operation center for coordination of
emergency response activities undertaken by multiple
organizations;
17
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Phase III: Emergency Response
Actions for reducing secondary damages;
Systematic damage assessment for rehabilitation;
Shutting down electric supply thereby preventing people from
electrocution;
Putting road blocks on endangered and damaged roads for
preventing road accident;
Providing healthcare, social care and epidemic control services.
18
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Phase IV: Rehabilitation/Recovery
This phase has to do with activities as are undertaken after
the emergency period/phase is over in an attempt to return
to normal functions.
Major rehabilitation and recovery activities are:
Financial assistance by charity and by credit/loan;
Restoration of major services such as electricity, water, gas,
telephone, transportation such as roads, railways etc.
Rebuilding of damaged and destroyed buildings and facilities;
Restoration of agricultural farm lands;
Supply of agricultural inputs such as seeds, fertilizers,
insecticides, irrigation water etc.
Formulating measures and recommendations for preventing and
mitigating future disasters.
19
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
It is important to know that while all these four phases of
disaster can be analytically separated, in reality they are
closely related to one another. The disaster related activities
of one phase can have consequences on other phases, for
example:
Failure to enact regulations to prevent people from living in the
hazardous areas will necessitate developing preparedness in
respect of warning system, evacuation plan, search and rescues,
temporary shelter, relief etc.
Construction of embankment for preventing flood disaster will
shift attention of disaster management from prevention to
preparedness of safeguarding the embankments.
20
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Prevention Is Better Than Cure
The major factors in disaster management process are:
Human vulnerability resulting from poverty, inequality and
injustice;
Environmental degradation due to poor land use;
Rapid population growth, especially among the poorer section of
the community;
The root cause of increasing frequency, severity and adverse affects of
flood and drought are not to be found in climatic change but in
environmental degradation caused by human activities such as:
Deforestation;
Habitations in hazardous areas;
Inappropriate cultivation;
Weak structures etc. expose more and more people to disaster.
21
ISSUE 1: NECESSITY OF LINKING DIFFERENT PHASES OF DISASTER
Prevention Is Better Than Cure
Following adequate and appropriate steps are therefore necessary for
prevention of disaster from ecological and socio-economic points of
view:
Preservation and development of natural environment;
Poverty alleviation and self-reliance;
Population control through family planning and education.
22
ISSUE 2: DISASTER RELEVANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
From organizational point of view, developed and developing
countries differ along the following lines:
Although most of the disasters take place in the developing
countries, but most of the disaster research works have been
carried out in the developed countries. As such application of
disaster research results of the developed countries may not be
appropriate for the developing countries.
Developing countries do not have as complex an advanced
organizational structure as do developed countries. There is
much weaker and inadequate disaster management
infrastructures in developing countries.
Organizational structures in the developed countries are both
proactive and reactive and functions smoothly from top down.
But organizational structures in the developing countries are
mainly reactive with a strong tendency of initiatives only at the
top level of government.
23
ISSUE 2: DISASTER RELEVANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
From organizational point of view, developed and developing
countries differ along the following lines:
In the developing countries most of the top disaster
management planners obtain education and training in the
developed countries on problems not related to their own
developing countries as such, such planners are not fully aware
on local disaster situations.
In the developing countries, the disaster management
organizations give more emphasis on forming committees and
doing paper works rather than actual functions and tasks.
24
ISSUE 2: DISASTER RELEVANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
The elaborate and linked groups existing in many developed
countries for emergency services do not exist in the
developing countries.
Emergency services are:
25
ISSUE 3: DIFFERENCE IN RURAL AND URBAN WAYS OF LIFE
There exist some differences in socio-economic aspects
between urban and rural areas. These differences should be
recognized while formulating disaster management planning.
In developing countries urban areas are characterized by
High population density;
Over-loaded public services such as transportation system;
Over-loaded civic amenities;
Traffic jam and pollution;
Unplanned slums and squatters;
Drainage congestion problems;
Garbage disposal problems and similar other problems.
26
ISSUE 3: DIFFERENCE IN RURAL AND URBAN WAYS OF LIFE
In the developed countries most of the populations live in
the urban areas while in the developing countries majority
of the population live in rural areas. For example, in Japan
93% of the total population live in the cities and the rest
7% live in the urbanized rural areas.
Moreover the urban area economy is mainly based on trade,
commerce and industries while the rural economy is mainly
based on agriculture, livestock and fisheries. All the above
differences between the rural and urban ways of life should
be recognized for disaster management planning and care
should be taken so that the disaster management planning
procedures and methodology developed for urban areas are
not directly applied in the rural areas and vice versa.
27
ISSUE 4: CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING
28
ISSUE 4: CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING
4.1 General Criteria For Assessment Of Disasrter Management
Planning
4.1.2 Disaster management planning should primarily be generic
(general in nature) rather than hazard specific and should deal with
problems which are common across all hazards.
Example: house constructed on high land may be safe against flood but
should be sufficiently strong against windstorm and earthquake.
29
ISSUE 4: CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING
4.1 General Criteria For Assessment Of Disasrter Management
Planning
Vertical Integration
4.1.3 National level
↓
Regional/Provincial level
↓
District level
↓
Upazila level
↓
Union level
↓
Field
Horizontal Integration
Government → NGOs → Political parties → Armed forces → Religious groups →
Donors → Community groups.
30
ISSUE 4: CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING
4.2 Disaster-specific Criteria For Assessment Of Disasrter
Management Planning
4.2.1 Specific criteria on disaster prevention:
Planning of Prevention Phase (Phase I) should be
As close as possible to everyday expectations;
Politically reactive;
Economically viable.
32
ISSUE 4: CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING
4.2 Disaster-specific Criteria For Assessment Of Disasrter
Management Planning
4.2.4 Specific criteria for rehabilitation and reconstruction (Phase IV):
Rehabilitation and reconstruction management planning will be most
acceptable if this is
Preplanned and integrated as apart of development planning;
Not too ambitious and grandiose;
Involve as many sections of the community in the decision
making as possible;
Urgent rehabilitation of electricity, roads, agriculture, places of
economic activities and other development infrastructures should
be given priority.
33
ISSUE 5: POSSIBLE LINKS BETWEEN DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING
Following possible links between Disaster Management Planning and
Development Planning have long been recognized:
5.1 The prevention phase of Disaster Management Planning is
concerned with such matters as
Land use;
Building code;
Zoning regulation etc. which are also the requirements for Development
Planning.
5.2 During recovery period of a disaster some of the restoration
activities may be integrated with development activities.
Example: Dhaka-Tangail highway was reconstructed after damage by
several floods and the height of the highway was increased above the
highest flood level keeping adequate free board. The highway had also
been widened and strengthen in order to
Make it an all-weather road;
Keep movement of men and materials unhindered;
Ensure dispatch of relief goods and workers; 34
People may take shelter.
ISSUE 5: POSSIBLE LINKS BETWEEN DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING
5.3 During recovery period some of the schools which are under
development plan of expansion and which are affected by flood may
be made two or three storied that is expanded vertically. These schools
may be utilized during next disasters as
Evacuation sites or shelters;
Relief operation centers;
Disaster management coordination centers etc.
5.4 The flood protection embankment may be planned in such a way
that it forms a part of the road network.
Example: 4000 km of coastal embankment have been paved and
integrated with the general road network system thereby
tremendously increasing the mobility and access of the vast mass
of people living in the coastal areas.
5.5 Poverty alleviation and self-reliance projects under development
planning increase income and employment thereby increasing disaster
resiliency and hence contribute towards disaster mitigation. 35
ISSUE 6: PARTICIPATION OF LOCAL CITIZENS AND COMMUNITIES
Following participation of local citizens and communities are
envisaged:
6.1 Reduction in the vulnerability of the citizens and communities is
better done with people’s participation. As such any national, regional
or local disaster management planning calls for people’s participation
and involvement.
36
ISSUE 6: PARTICIPATION OF LOCAL CITIZENS AND COMMUNITIES
6.4 Disaster rehabilitation planning should be undertaken for targeted
groups rather than in large masses of individual citizens, because
different groups may have different order of priority.
For example:
Agricultural farmers need seeds, fertilizers, irrigation water and
other inputs;
Fishermen need fishing net, fishing boat, marketing facilities,
transport etc.
Livestock farmers need good variety of livestock, feed and
veterinary services;
Traders need bank loan, transport, growth center etc.
6.5 Awareness about disaster management planning is vital in
mitigating disaster and participation by individual citizen as well as
different communities in generating awareness is essential.
37
ISSUE 6: PARTICIPATION OF LOCAL CITIZENS AND COMMUNITIES
6.6 Where disaster have been increasing both in frequency and
intensity on account of environmental degradation due to human
interference, massive participation by all concerned people in reversing
the degradation process is a of utmost importance.
42
ISSUE 8: INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER MANAGEMENT
8.3 Specialist facilities and systems
A disaster management organization system is a dynamic entity and all
phases of disaster management planning must involve action as such
following specialist facilities and systems are required:
Direction and coordination of disaster related actions;
Emergency operation centers;
Altering and activating disaster management system as and when
required;
Communication network for disaster management;
Warning and its dissemination system;
Survey and assessment of damage for future disaster
management planning;
Information management;
Emergency logistics.
43
ISSUE 8: INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER MANAGEMENT
8.4 Coordination of non-government resources
Non-government resources can be easily coordinated into the disaster
management system. This can easily be done through
National Disaster Management Council (headed by the PM);
Prime Minister’s Disaster Relief Fund;
District Disaster Management Committee;
Upazila Disaster Management Committee;
Union Disaster Management Committee.
44
ISSUE 8: INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER MANAGEMENT
8.6 Shape and size of the organizational system
The fundamental considerations which basically determines the shape
and size of the organizational system is the disaster threat in respect of
a. The nature of threat such as
Natural hazards;
Man-made hazards;
Civic unrest etc.
b. The degree of threats such as
Severe;
Moderate;
Minor.
c. The pattern of threats such as
Frequency;
State/Extent.
45
ISSUE 8: INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER MANAGEMENT
8.7 Psychology For Coping With Disaster
The disaster can have wide ranging effects on a country, its
government and its people. Therefore the primary responsibility of
coping with disaster must rest with the government institutions at
various levels. Government departments and agencies dealing with
disaster have to accept additional work flow and work under pressure
during emergency. However, donor agencies, NGOs, CBOs and other
groups are generally at hand to cooperate for disaster management
planning.
46
TASKS OF DISASTER PLANNING
Develop
a working relationship with parent organization
and community, i.e., university disaster team, city disaster
management, fire department
Risk Assessment: Identify, assess and mitigate potential
risks and hazards
Identify insurance policies, spending authority and
emergency funds
47
DISASTER PREPAREDNESS INVOLVES THESE ACTIVITIES…
Assess collections and assign priorities for salvage
Identify disaster recovery resources, including institutional
assistance, vendors, consultants, conservators
Secure a budget for supplies and training activities
48
DISASTER PREPAREDNESS INVOLVES THESE ACTIVITIES…
Review policies and procedures for disasters and/or
emergencies
Write the disaster plan, distribute, or better, put on the
website
Secure offsite backups
Trainstaff
Conduct pre-planned tests of the plan
49
RISK ASSESSMENT
Identify and assess risks
Risk Assessment
1- Survey Building
Site of building
Landscape
Building materials and structure
Fire Protection (sprinklers, type)
Utilities (water, electrical, etc)
Custodial
Security
Communication Systems 50
RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk Assessment
51
ELEMENTS OF A DISASTER PLAN
1- Quick Reference Guide
Procedures for immediate response to most common disasters
Done with Security and Building personnel
2- Basic information
Emergency phone numbers
Building officer/personnel
Post evacuation meeting locations
Location of disaster supplies
List of vendors
Floor plans with fire alarms, exits, etc.
52
ELEMENTS OF A DISASTER PLAN
3- Disaster Team
The disaster management team will depend on individual
institution size, resources and staffing patterns
Staff selected should have experience with :
Administration activities, i.e., public relations, finance, & personnel
The physical building
The collection and materials
Preservation practices
Library services, including reference, circulation
Computer services
53
ELEMENTS OF A DISASTER PLAN
4- Collection priorities
54
ELEMENTS OF A DISASTER PLAN
5- Disaster scale and recovery operations
Level 1: Emergency
Handled by minimal staffing in less than 4 hours
Any damaged materials are handled in-house
Level 2: Small disaster
Limited to isolated area
Damages of less than 100 items
Requires 1-3 staff members
Disruptions resume within a day
Supplies available in-house
Damaged materials treated in-house
55
ELEMENTS OF A DISASTER PLAN
5- Disaster scale and recovery operations
Level 3: Medium disaster
Damages of less than 500 items
Service operations resumed within 48 hours
Outside vendors may be needed
Level 4: Major/large scale disaster or wide-area disaster
6- Procedures for disaster recovery
General Guidelines
Recovery of mold materials
Freezing of materials
Vacuum freeze drying
Vacuum drying or thermal vacuum drying
Freezer drying
Dehumidification
Air drying of materials
56
Guidelines for paper-based materials
What We have Covered Today
Purpose of the Disaster Management Plan
The Need for Plans
Pitfalls in Planning
Levels of Planning
Format of Plans
59
60
61
What Next?
Lecture 3:
Disaster and National Development
62
Sample Questions
1. What are the purposes of disaster management plan? Put down the
rationales of the counter disaster management plan.
2. Pitfalls of the counter disaster management plan.
3. Briefly explain the basic issues while preparing disaster management
planning.
4. How does psychology affect in coping with disaster?
5. What activities will be involved in disaster preparedness while
preparing disaster management planning?
6. What activities will be involved in disaster risk assessment while
preparing disaster management planning?
7. Briefly explain the elements of a Disaster Plan.
63