Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Exam Om
Final Exam Om
BLEMBA 65
INSTITUT TEKNOLOGI BANDUNG
TAHUN 2021
1
Table of content
Chapter 1
BUSINESS ISSUE ................................................................................................3
1.1 Introduction .....................................................................................................3
1.2 Business Issue ............................................................................................... 4
Chapter 2
BUSSINES ISSUE EXPLORATION .....................................................................5
2.1 Literature Review ............................................................................................6
2.1.1 Objectives Of Material Requirements Planning......................................6
2.1.2 Elements of Material Requirements Planning ........................................7
2.1.3 Production Planning ..............................................................................10
2.2 Root Cause Analyze .......................................................................................13
Chapter 3
ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION...................................................................................15
3.1 Analysis of Requirement Materials..................................................................15
3.2 Master Production Schedule ..........................................................................16
Chapter 4
CONCLUTION.......................................................................................................22
Reference..............................................................................................................23
2
Chapter 1
Business Issue
1.1 Introduction
Jasa Sarana has an asset in the form of a 19.45 Ha of sand and stone mine
located in Paseh Kaler Village, Paseh District, Sumedang Regency, West Java
Province. Based on the results of a study conducted by the Company through a
consultant, the potential reserves of sand, as well as andesite, is + 2,284,278
BCM, and ± 274,442 BCM respectively.
In order to manage the sand and stone mine, the Company has acquired
several permits:
•Environmental Permit (Decree of the Sumedang Regent Number:
660.1/2523/BLH/2009, (June 29, 2009)
•Production and Operation of Mining Business Permit (IUP OP), December 23,
2019, consisting of sand commodities (Number
540/26/29.1.07.2/DPMPTSP/2019) and andesite commodities (Number
540/27/29.1.07.2/DPMPTSP/2019 ).
3
2021 Plans
The problem that often occurs is the problem of ineffective and efficient work
productivity. Production costs that are carried out are often not proportional to
the imposition of the selling price. So that production costs often swell, due to
several factors:
1. Geological Factor
4
Geological factors are often an obstacle, although, in mine planning and
exploration study has been made, this is only an estimate whose approach is
only 65%-70%. For example, in terms of thickness of topsoil and
overburden, it is estimated that the thickness is 5-6 meters and then the
desired material content is found, but in reality, it is often more, so that the
waste that must be peeled takes longer, of course after conversion it will cost
more than what is expected. planned. Or at the time of entering the
production stage, the material obtained after stripping the waste, is not the
released material that is obtained but instead is dominated by bolder stone
blocks, which in stripping require heavy equipment such as breakers, which
of course also increases costs.
2. Weather Factor
The weather factor is of course an issue because it can't be predicted. So
that it slows down productivity, especially if we are getting orders that require
speed in fulfilling volumes.
3. Worker Factor
The worker factor is one of the determinants of productivity, especially for
heavy equipment operators. The reliability and experience of heavy
equipment operators determine the level of productivity, especially in the
Mining Pit. It takes foresight and experience in making excavation methods
effective, breaking down materials, separate types of materials, and carrying
out the process of loading materials into transport vehicles.
5
Chapter 2
Business Issue Exploration
The specificity of mining production results in the fact that most of the
materials used do not come into the content of the product manufactured
(Michalak, 2016). The materials are necessary to conduct the process of
mining production, and also for the maintenance of the machines and
appliances and for keeping them running (Drebenstedt and Singhal,
2014). Despite this character of materials, they play a very important role
6
in the process of mining production. Their lack may cause a disturbance
in the course of mining works and the continuation of the production
process. The mining plant, or the mines included in the plant to be
precise, use a variety of materials. Their type depends on the character
of the works conducted. The significance of the particular types of
materials used in the mines is not the same, though. Some of them have
a decisive impact on the course of the production process, and their lack
may lead to a production halt. The significance of some materials is not
as great, however, their shortage results in an impediment in conducting
the mining works and may cause a disturbance in regular production. In
order to provide the continuance of mining works, in particular the
adequate mining conditions, it is necessary to develop the material and
technical supply plan. The purpose of this plan is to grant access for
every mine department to the proper material quantity so that all the
work posts may receive the materials in the required amount and type.
Nevertheless, one must not forget about the rule of inventory
minimization, because excessive inventory is, on one hand, a comfort for
the people responsible for supply guarantee and on the other hand, is an
additional, redundant cost increase (Dolgui and Prodhon, 2007; Jonek-
Kowalska and Turek, 2013). In practice, it happens that the reserves of
some materials are too large and at the same time it happens that the
materials shortage causes disturbance in the course of production, what
is more, this forces an inadequate substitution.
7
cadangan beberapa bahan terlalu besar dan pada saat yang sama terjadi bahwa
kekurangan bahan menyebabkan gangguan dalam proses produksi, terlebih lagi,
ini memaksa substitusi yang tidak memadai
The method that will be carried out in this analysis is the Lot Sizing
Strategy based on the stages and schedule of the Bill of Materials that
have been determined based on the Feasibility Study Document for
Sand and Andesite Mining PT. Facilities Services.
Metode yang akan dilakukan dalam analisis ini adalah Strategi Lot Sizing
berdasarkan tahapan dan jadwal Bill of Materials yang telah ditetapkan
berdasarkan Dokumen Studi Kelayakan Untuk Pertambangan Pasir dan Andesit
PT.
Lot Sizing
Strategies
The stages and data analysis can be seen in Figure 1 with the following
details:
a. Demand forecast
Demand forecasting is the main stage that needs to be done in raw
material planning. Demand forecasting is done based on past
production data owned by the company to forecast demand from
January 2022 to December 2022..
Peramalan permintaan merupakan tahap utama yang perlu dilakukan dalam
perencanaan bahan baku. Peramalan permintaan dilakukan berdasarkan data
produksi sebelumnya yang dimiliki perusahaan untuk memperkirakan
permintaan dari Januari 2022 hingga Desember 2022. Data peramalan
permintaan yang digunakan berada dalam kisaran Januari 2021 hingga
Desember 2021
8
to company data regarding product production from June 2021 to
June 2022. This production master schedule will calculate the
number of products to be produced and when these products will be
produced.
ketika bahan baku dibutuhkan dan menentukan jadwal pemesanan dan
menentukan berapa banyak bahan baku yang akan dipesan. Jadwal master
production diperoleh dari hasil peramalan dengan mengacu pada data
perusahaan terkait produksi produk dari Juni 2021 hingga Juni 2022. Jadwal
master produksi ini akan menghitung jumlah produk yang akan diproduksi
dan kapan produk tersebut akan diproduksi.
Forecasting
Production
production master
scheduling
production Structure
9
The total of all raw materials or components needed in a period.
2) Scheduled Receipts
Is the number of items that will be received in a certain period
based on the order made.
3) Project on Hand
State the amount of inventory available at a certain time period.
On-hand at the beginning of the next period is determined using
the formula 1:
𝑂𝐻𝑡 = (𝑂𝐻𝑡−1 + 𝑆𝑅𝑡−1 − 𝐺𝑅𝑡−1 )…….(1)
𝑂𝐻𝑡 = Initial Period Inventory 𝑡
𝑂𝐻𝑡−1 = Initial Period Inventory 𝑡 − 1
𝑆𝑅𝑡−1 = Schedule Receive Period 𝑡 − 1
𝐺𝑅𝑡−1 = Gross Requirement period 𝑡 – 1
4) Net Requirements
State the actual number of requirements needed in each time
period to meet the needs of the item. To get the net requirements
can be used formula 2:
𝑁𝑅𝑡 = (𝐺𝑅𝑡 − ( 𝑂𝐻𝑡 + 𝑆𝑅𝑡 )……………(2)
e. Lotting Determination
Is a process to determine the optimal order quantity for each item
individually based on the results of the calculation of net
requirements. In this study, the determination of the lot size used is
lot for lot and economic order quantity.
1) Lot size lot for lot method
It is the simplest and easiest to understand the lot-sizing
technique. Orders are made with the consideration of minimizing
storage costs. In this technique, the fulfillment of net needs is
carried out in each period that needs it, while the size of the order
quantity (lot size) is the same as the number of net needs that
must be met in the period concerned.
10
[f] There is no shortage of materials.
Calculation of economic order quantity based on formula 3:
TH = 𝑃𝐴𝑉. ℎ.........................................................(4)
TC = 𝐷. 𝑐 + 𝑓. 𝑘 + 𝑇𝐻..................................................(5)
11
TOTAL 260.124,67 222.000,00 978.000,00 1.200.000,00
Overall, the stages of mining activities planned by PT Jasa Sarana are from the
process of dismantling cover material, mining of minerals, processing of
minerals to the final stage, namely reclamation of ex-mining land.
As for the mining sequence, starting with unloading and moving topsoil material
to the nursery area and overburdening to the disposal area, the next step is to
unload the excavated materials in the form of sand and andesite to be loaded
and transported to the mineral processing site for further reduction. size and
sieving, so that in the end, you will get several types of products based on their
respective specifications
The following is the acquisition of processed products for the realization in 2021
and the plan for 2022:
Tabel 2
Sand Realization Production 2021 and Production Planning 2022
BULAN
Rencana dan
Blok
Realisasi Jan Feb Mar Apr Mei Jun Jul Agu Sep Okt Nov Des Total (BCM)
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 73404
2021
Realisasi Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2021
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 8156 73404
2022
Tabel 3
Andesite Realization Production 2021 and Production Planning 2022
BULAN
Rencana dan
Blok
Realisasi Jan Feb Mar Apr Mei Jun Jul Agu Sep Okt Nov Des Total (BCM)
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 76599
2021
Realisasi Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2021
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 8511 76599
2022
12
Table 4
Over Burden and Soil Realization in 2021 and Production Plan in 2022
BULAN
Rencana dan
Blok
Realisasi Jan Feb Mar Apr Mei Jun Jul Agu Sep Okt Nov Des Total (BCM)
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 23301
2021
Realisasi Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2021
Rencana Tahun
Nagrak 0 0 0 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 2589 23301
2022
Table 5
Sand Production Plan in 2022
Rencana Tahun 2022 (Pasir)
No Deskripsi Total (LCM)
Jan Feb Mar Apr Mei Jun Jul Agu Sep Okt Nov Des
1 Produksi (LCM) - - - 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 10.602 95.418
2 Komoditas yang diolah (LCM) - - - 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 10.496 94.464
3 Recovery 99%
4 Rencana Terjual (LCM) - - - 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 10.391 93.519
5 Recovery 99%
Table 6
Andesite Production Plan in 2022
Rencana Tahun 2022 (Andesit)
No Deskripsi Total (LCM)
Jan Feb Mar Apr Mei Jun Jul Agu Sep Okt Nov Des
1 Produksi (LCM) - - - 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 12.446 112.014
2 Komoditas yang diolah (LCM) - - - 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 12.322 110.898
3 Recovery 99%
4 Rencana Terjual (LCM) - - - 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 12.199 109.791
5 Recovery 99%
The processing procedures carried out by PT Jasa Sarana are basically carried
out according to the plan, that rocks that have a size greater than 30 cm will be
inserted into the hopper for later size reduction using a jaw crusher. The
material that comes out of the jaw crusher is then transported using a belt
conveyor to the secondary crusher using a hammer mill. The results of the size
reduction process on the hammer mill tool are then transported to a vibrating
screen to separate the processed material into several types of products based
on the size of the material.
The final result of the processing carried out is in the form of products that have
different sizes, while the products produced include stone ash (0-5 mm),
screening (5-10 mm), split 10-20 mm, split 20-30 mm and splits 30-50 mm. The
following is a list of processing equipment, can be seen in Table 7.
Table 7
Equipment of PT Jasa Sarana
No Tipe Capacity Unit
Processing Equipment
1 Hooper 1
2 Jaw Crusher 1
3 Banker 1
4 Hammer Mill 100 - 150 tph 1
5 Sand Sievers 1
6 Belt Conveyor 7
7 Control Panel 1
Conveyance Equipment
1 Wheel Loader Bucket 2 m3 1
2 Excavator Bucket 0.93 m3 1
13
2.2 Root Cause Analysis
The development of material balance should always start from determining the
disposal planned and the final level of reserves planned because these are the
elements determining the requirements. The process of material requirements
planning in the mining enterprises, as it was mentioned before, consists of
planning cycles including a calendar year and months, in connection with the
technical and economic plan, but not only. From the planning point of view, the
problem of material security should be analysed in the contexts: strategic,
tactical, operational.
As the plans have a strictly defined structure, that should correspond to the
organizational structure of the mining enterprise, and an objective arrangement
based on the distinguished spheres of the main activity, their content should
refer to all these levels. Then the question arises, to what extent the material
requirements planning is strategic planning, to what extent is tactical, and to
what extent is it operational planning? The individual levels of planning are
described by several attributes, in which the aforementioned stock is included.
These are:
• Time horizon, which encompasses the supply plan, the longest for the
strategic plan, medium-term for the tactical plan, and the shortest for the
operational one,
• Range of material requirements planning, which involves the whole
enterprise, the individual mines,
• Participation, competence extent, including the responsibility of the
particular management levels in the mining enterprise, both during plan
development and execution,
• Plan range in the mining enterprise, whether the whole plant or
distinguished areas or individual undertaking
• Type of measures included in the supply plan, that is, synthetic, indirect
and analytical.
In this case, it will be analysed how the mechanism for scheduling and fulfilling
material production is in accordance with the targets that have been set in
2022. The expect target are :
Table 7
Realization of Processing Costs in 2021 and Plans in 2022
Kegiatan
14
Table 8
Realization of Mining Costs in 2021 and Plans in 2022
Deskripsi
Realisasi dan Lokasi /
No Deskripsi
Rencana Blok / Pit Pengupasan OB Penambangan
Reconturing (Ha)
(LCM) Komoditas
Kuantitas - 3.263 -
1 Realisasi Tahun 2021 Blok 1 Satuan Biaya - 23.288 -
Total - 75.980.040 75.980.040
Kuantitas 32.624 207.438
2 Rencana Tahun 2022 Blok 1 Satuan Biaya Rp 23.288 Rp 23.288
Total Rp 759.740.208 Rp 4.830.768.433 5.590.508.642
15
Chapter 3
Alternative Solution
Table 9
Equipment Used of Overburden and Soil Mining
Excavator Times Effective per day Dump Truck Time Effective per Day
Day Duration Unit Day Duration Unit
Monday-Thursday 6,87 H/D Monday-Thursday 6,87 H/D
Excavator works efficiency per Day Dump Truck works efficiency per Day
Day % Unit Day % Unit
Mean 83,2323 %/Day Mean 83,2323 %/Day
Table 10
Equipment Used of Andesite and Sand Mining
ROCK BREAKER EXCAVATOR DUMP TRUCK
Rock Breaker Times Effective per day Excavator Times Effective per day Dump Truck Time Effective per Day
Rock Breaker works efficiency per Day Excavator works efficiency per Day Dump Truck works efficiency per Day
Table 11
Forecasting Requirement, The Materials in 2022
DAY OF PRODUCT (BCM)
MONTH PRODUCTIVITY
WORKS/MONTH OB/SOIL SANDS ANDESITE
16
1 26 33,77% 7.867,87
2 24 31,17% 7.262,65
3 27 35,06% 8.170,48
4 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
5 23 10,00% 9.352,30 10.979,10
6 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
7 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
8 25 10,87% 10.165,54 11.933,80
9 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
10 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
11 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
12 26 11,30% 10.572,17 12.411,16
TOTAL 230 100,00% 23.301,00 93.523,00 109.791,00
After getting the forecasting results for the next six months, the forecasting
results are used to create a Master Production Schedule which is then divided
into 4 week periods, so there are 32 periods in weeks.
Table 12
Master Production Schedule of Materials
17
e
Month Mar-22 Apr-22
Period 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
OB/Soil 2.042,62 2.042,62 2.042,62 2.042,62 - - - -
Sand - - - - 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.114,43
Andesit
- - - - 3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23
e
Month May-22 Jun-22
Period 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
OB/Soil - - - - - - - -
Sand 2.805,69 2.805,69 2.805,69 935,23 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24
Andesit
3.293,73 3.293,73 3.293,73 1.097,91 3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23
e
Month Jul-22 Aug-22
Period 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
OB/Soil - - - - - - - -
Sand 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24 1.524,83 2.880,24 2.880,24 2.880,24
Andesit
3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482 1.790,07 3.381,24 3.381,24 3.381,24
e
Month Sep-22 Oct-22
Period 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
OB/Soil - - - - - - - -
Sand 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24
Andesit
3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23 3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23
e
Month Nov-22 Dec-22
Period 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
OB/Soil - - - - - - - -
Sand 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.114,43 2.819,24 2.819,24 2.819,24
Andesit
3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23 3.309,64 3.309,64 3.309,64 2.482,23
e
Table 13
Lot for Lot Analysis for OB/Soil
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
1 1966,97 1966,97 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp18.345.906
2 1966,97 1966,97 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp36.691.812
3 1966,97 1966,97 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp55.037.719
4 1966,97 1966,97 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp73.383.625
5 1815,66 1815,66 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp90.318.307
6 1815,66 1815,66 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp107.252.990
7 1815,66 1815,66 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp124.187.673
8 1815,66 1815,66 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp141.122.355
9 2042,62 2042,62 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp160.173.873
10 2042,62 2042,62 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp179.225.391
11 2042,62 2042,62 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp198.276.909
12 2042,62 2042,62 0,00 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp217.328.427
18
Table 14
EOQ Analysis for OB/Soil
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
1 1966,97 5000,00 3033,03 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp46.635.000,00
2 1966,97 0,00 1066,06 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp47.914.277,92
3 1966,97 5000,00 4099,10 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp94.549.277,92
4 1966,97 0,00 2132,13 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp97.107.833,77
5 1815,66 0,00 316,47 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp97.487.594,81
6 1815,66 5000,00 3500,81 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp144.122.594,81
7 1815,66 0,00 1685,14 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp146.144.766,23
8 1815,66 3000,00 2869,48 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp174.125.766,23
9 2042,62 0,00 826,86 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp175.117.998,70
10 2042,62 3000,00 1784,24 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp203.098.998,70
11 2042,62 2301,00 2042,62 Rp8.127 Rp1.200 Rp224.560.425,70
12 2042,62 0,00 0,00 Rp0 Rp1.200 Rp224.560.425,70
Table 15
Lot for Lot Analysis for Sand
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
13 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp77.166.939
14 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp154.333.877
15 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp231.500.816
16 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp289.376.020
17 2805,69 2805,69 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp366.171.964
18 2805,69 2805,69 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp442.967.908
19 2805,69 2805,69 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp519.763.852
20 935,23 935,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp545.362.500
21 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp603.237.704
22 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp680.404.642
23 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp757.571.581
24 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp834.738.520
25 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp892.613.724
26 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp969.780.663
27 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.046.947.601
28 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.124.114.540
29 1524,83 1524,83 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.165.851.466
30 2880,24 2880,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.244.687.882
31 2880,24 2880,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.323.524.298
32 2880,24 2880,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.402.360.714
33 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.460.235.918
34 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.537.402.856
35 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.614.569.795
36 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.691.736.734
37 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.749.611.938
38 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.826.778.877
19
39 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.903.945.815
40 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.981.112.754
41 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.038.987.958
42 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.116.154.897
43 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.193.321.836
44 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.270.488.774
45 2114,43 2114,43 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.328.363.978
46 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.405.530.917
47 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.482.697.856
48 2819,24 2819,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.559.864.795
Table 16
EOQ Analysis for Sand
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
13 2819,24 6500,00 3680,76 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp177.914.750,00
14 2819,24 0,00 861,51 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp181.432.733,78
15 2819,24 6500,00 4542,27 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp359.347.483,78
16 2114,43 0,00 2427,83 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp369.261.547,11
17 2805,69 6500,00 6122,14 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp547.176.297,11
18 2805,69 0,00 3316,45 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp560.719.040,22
19 2805,69 0,00 510,76 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp562.804.748,21
20 935,23 6500,00 6075,53 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp740.719.498,21
21 2114,43 0,00 3961,10 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp756.894.657,16
22 2819,24 0,00 1141,86 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp761.557.433,00
23 2819,24 6500,00 4822,61 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp939.472.183,00
24 2819,24 0,00 2003,37 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp947.652.942,62
25 2114,43 6500,00 6388,94 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.125.567.692,62
26 2819,24 0,00 3569,69 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.140.144.531,80
27 2819,24 0,00 750,45 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.143.208.987,86
28 2819,24 6500,00 4431,20 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.321.123.737,86
29 1524,83 0,00 2906,37 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.332.991.911,30
30 2880,24 0,00 26,14 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.333.098.635,64
31 2880,24 6500,00 3645,90 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.511.013.385,64
32 2880,24 0,00 765,66 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.514.139.961,80
33 2114,43 6500,00 5151,23 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.692.054.711,80
34 2819,24 0,00 2331,98 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.701.577.367,52
35 2819,24 6500,00 6012,74 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.879.492.117,52
36 2819,24 0,00 3193,50 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.892.532.757,01
37 2114,43 0,00 1079,06 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp1.896.939.109,18
38 2819,24 6500,00 4759,82 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.074.853.859,18
39 2819,24 0,00 1940,57 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.082.778.195,12
40 2819,24 6500,00 5621,33 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.260.692.945,12
41 2114,43 0,00 3506,90 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.275.013.360,62
42 2819,24 0,00 687,65 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.277.821.393,00
43 2819,24 6500,00 4368,41 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.455.736.143,00
44 2819,24 0,00 1549,17 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.462.062.159,17
20
45 2114,43 6500,00 5934,73 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.639.976.909,17
46 2819,24 0,00 3115,49 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.652.699.004,89
47 2819,24 0,00 296,24 Rp0 Rp4.084 Rp2.653.908.717,50
48 2819,24 2523,00 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.722.967.012,00
Table 17
Lot for Lot Analysis for Andesite
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
13 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp90.589.859
14 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp181.179.718
15 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp271.769.577
16 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp339.711.971
17 3293,73 3293,73 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp429.866.301
18 3293,73 3293,73 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp520.020.632
19 3293,73 3293,73 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp610.174.963
20 1097,91 1097,91 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp640.226.406
21 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp730.816.265
22 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp821.406.124
23 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp911.995.983
24 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp979.938.377
25 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.070.528.236
26 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.161.118.095
27 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.251.707.954
28 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.319.650.348
29 1790,07 1790,07 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.368.647.267
30 3381,24 3381,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.461.197.002
31 3381,24 3381,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.553.746.738
32 3381,24 3381,24 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.646.296.474
33 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.736.886.332
34 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.827.476.191
35 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.918.066.050
36 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.986.008.444
37 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.076.598.303
38 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.167.188.162
39 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.257.778.021
40 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.325.720.415
41 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.416.310.274
42 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.506.900.133
43 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.597.489.992
44 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.665.432.386
45 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.756.022.245
46 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.846.612.103
47 3309,64 3309,64 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.937.201.962
48 2482,23 2482,23 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp3.005.144.357
21
Table 17
EOQ Analysis for Andesite
Net Production Ending Mining Processing
Week Total Cost
Requirement Quantity Inventory Cost/LCM Cost/LCM
13 3309,64 7000,00 3690,36 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp191.600.500,00
14 3309,64 0,00 380,72 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp193.155.155,92
15 3309,64 7000,00 4071,07 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp384.755.655,92
16 2482,23 0,00 1588,84 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp391.243.698,26
17 3293,73 7000,00 5295,11 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp582.844.198,26
18 3293,73 0,00 2001,38 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp591.016.847,69
19 3293,73 7000,00 5707,65 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp782.617.347,69
20 1097,91 0,00 4609,74 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp801.441.235,19
21 3309,64 0,00 1300,10 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp806.750.200,64
22 3309,64 7000,00 4990,46 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp998.350.700,64
23 3309,64 0,00 1680,82 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.005.214.322,01
24 2482,23 7000,00 6198,59 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.196.814.822,01
25 3309,64 0,00 2888,95 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.208.611.829,80
26 3309,64 7000,00 6579,30 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.400.212.329,80
27 3309,64 0,00 3269,66 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.413.563.993,51
28 2482,23 0,00 787,43 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.416.779.465,69
29 1790,07 7000,00 5997,36 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.608.379.965,69
30 3381,24 0,00 2616,12 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.619.062.872,18
31 3381,24 7000,00 6234,87 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.810.663.372,18
32 3381,24 0,00 2853,63 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp1.822.316.154,31
33 3309,64 7000,00 6543,98 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.013.916.654,31
34 3309,64 0,00 3234,34 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.027.124.092,35
35 3309,64 7000,00 6924,70 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.218.724.592,35
36 2482,23 0,00 4442,47 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.236.865.416,82
37 3309,64 0,00 1132,83 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.241.491.319,25
38 3309,64 7000,00 4823,19 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.433.091.819,25
39 3309,64 0,00 1513,54 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.439.272.377,60
40 2482,23 7000,00 6031,31 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.630.872.877,60
41 3309,64 0,00 2721,67 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.641.986.822,37
42 3309,64 7000,00 6412,03 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.833.587.322,37
43 3309,64 0,00 3102,39 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.846.255.923,05
44 2482,23 0,00 620,16 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp2.848.788.332,21
45 3309,64 7000,00 4310,51 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp3.040.388.832,21
46 3309,64 0,00 1000,87 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp3.044.475.897,28
47 3309,64 4791,00 2482,23 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp3.175.612.753,78
48 2482,23 0,00 0,00 Rp23.288 Rp4.084 Rp3.175.612.753,78
22
Chapter 4
Conclusion
From the two methods above, it can be concluded that the best method used by the
company is the Lot For Lot (L4L) method because from the calculation of the Lot For
Lot (L4L) method, the smallest total cost is Rp. 5,782,337,578, - when compared
with the calculation of the Lot Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) is Rp. 6,123,140,191,
because the Lot For Lot method can minimize processing costs so that the total
costs incurred are small.
Table 18
Comparison of Total Cost with The Best Lot
Lot for Lot Lot Economic Order Quantity
Product
Mining Cost Processing Cost Total Cost Mining Cost Processing Cost Total Cost
OB/Soil Rp189.367.227 Rp27.961.200 Rp217.328.427 Rp189.367.227 Rp35.193.199 Rp224.560.426
Rp2.177.963.62
Sand Rp2.177.963.624 Rp381.901.171 Rp2.559.864.795 4 Rp545.003.388 Rp2.722.967.012
Rp2.556.812.80
Andesite Rp2.556.812.808 Rp448.331.549 Rp3.005.144.357 8 Rp618.799.946 Rp3.175.612.754
TOTAL Rp5.782.337.578 Total Rp6.123.140.191
From the results of the analysis, it can be concluded that the Material Requirement
Planning (MRP) method can be applied to PT. Jasa Sarana by paying attention to
several things, namely forecasting based on sales data, and scheduling production.
Some suggestions in this study are the company can consider the Material
Requirement Planning (MRP) method with the Lot For Lot (L4L) technique as a
model in determining the order size that is adjusted to company policy to minimize
the total cost of inventory and can plan raw material orders in a timely manner.
optimal. In addition, research can be continued by using the MRP II method and
making a computerized raw material planning system.
23
Reference
[1] A. Desrianty, H. Prasetyo dan D. Irawan, “Model Optimasi Ukuran Lot Produksi untuk Single Item dan Single Stage pada Sistem
Pro-duksi yang Mengalami Deteriorasi dan Kesalahan Pemeriksaan den-gan Kriteria Minimasi Ongkos Total,” dalam Proc.
SENTI-UGM, 2015, hal. 133-143.
[2] A. H. Nasution dan Y. Prasetyawan,”Perencanaan dan pengendalian Produksi,”Graha Ilmu, 2008, hal. 245-305.
[3] A. Wahyuni dan A. Syaichu. (Oktober 2015). Perencanaan Persediaan Bahan Baku dengan Menggunakan Metode Material
Requirement Planning (MRP) Produk Kacang Shanghai Pada Perusahaan Gangsar Ngunut-Tulungagung. Spektrum Industri.
Volume 13 Nomor 2, hal. 141-156.
[4] D. T. Jons dan H. A. Harding,”Operations Management To Achieve Competitive Advantage”, PPM, 1996, hal. 71-96.
[5] I. R. Sari dan A. Sudiarso, “Perencanaan Produksi Agregat Berdasar-kan Peramalan Permintaan dengan Menggunakan Jaringan
Syaraf Ti-ruan pada IKM X,” Proc. SENTI-UGM, 2015, hal. 436-444.
[6] R. Amaranti, C. R. Muhamad dan R. Rusniani,”Perencanaan Produksi Untuk Mereduksi Lead Time dengan Strategi Make To
Stock (MTO) dan Make To Order (MTO),”dalam Proc. IDEC-UNS, 2014, hal. 26-35.
[7] S. Assauri,”Manajemen Produksi dan Operasi, Edisi revisi,”FEUI, 2008, hal. 47-52.
[8] S. Sinulingga, “Pengantar Teknik Industri,”Graha Ilmu, 2008, hal. 87-128.
[9] PT. Jasa Sarana, “Dokumen Laporan Hasil Eksplorasi”, 2021
[10] PT. Jasa Sarana, “Dokumen Studi Kelayakan”, 2021
[11] PT. Jasa Sarana, “Dokumen Laporan RKAB Tahun 2022”, 2021
24