Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jones 2000
Jones 2000
Jones 2000
Introduction
Summary
Streptococcus agalactiae [group B streptococci (GBS)] is
Group B streptococcal (GBS) infections are the most the leading cause of neonatal sepsis and meningitis in the
common cause of bacterial sepsis in the immediate United States and western Europe, and is an emerging
newborn period. Apart from the capsule, the factors pathogen in immunocompromised adults (Schuchat,
required for survival of GBS in the host are not well 1998). The early-onset form of GBS disease typically
defined. In this study, signature-tagged transposon presents in the first 24 h of life as fulminant pneumonia
mutagenesis (STM) was used to identify genes and septicaemia, with high mortality (10±15%) despite
required for growth and survival of GBS in a neonatal intensive supportive therapy (Nizet et al., 2000). The less
rat sepsis infection model. Approximately 1600 trans- common, late-onset (. 7 days of age) form of infection
poson mutants were screened in pools of 80 mutants, presents as meningitis, bacteraemia or osteoarthritis.
and approximately 120 mutants defective for survival Prematurity and maternal obstetric complications are
in the animal host were identified. We successfully important risk factors for early-onset disease, whereas
cloned and sequenced DNA flanking the transposon late-onset infections most commonly affect term new-
insertions from 92 of the mutants. Fifty per cent of the borns with unremarkable perinatal histories (Nizet et al.,
mutants had transposon insertions in genes with 2000). GBS associated with human disease are almost
homologues in the public databases, whereas the invariably encapsulated, belonging to one of the nine
remaining 50% had transposon insertions in genes recognized capsular serotypes: Ia, Ib or II±VIII. GBS
with unknown function. A significant proportion of isolates from neonates with early-onset infection are well
the avirulent mutants had transposon insertions in distributed among the capsular serotypes, whereas most
genes encoding transport-associated or regulatory isolates from infants with late-onset disease (and infants
proteins or in genes involved in cell surface metabol- with meningitis regardless of age of onset) are of serotype
ism, emphasizing the significance of these functions III (Nizet et al., 2000). The type-specific capsule of GBS
for in vivo survival of GBS. Overall, STM analysis has been studied extensively and is an important
revealed GBS genomic loci that encode a wide variety virulence determinant for both virulence and immunity
of functional gene classes, underscoring the diver- (Rubens et al., 1987; Wessels et al., 1989). Studies of
sity of bacterial processes required for the infection GBS virulence have examined adherence to and invasion
process. Currently, the function of the genes identi- of epithelial and endothelial barriers, interactions with host
fied during the screening can only be inferred by immune pathways, using or focusing on a few specific
homology to previously described genes. However, a factors, such as haemolysin, alpha and beta proteins and
number of the genes identified in this study have the capsular polysaccharide (for a review, see Nizet et al.,
been shown to correlate with virulence in other 2000). The role of basic biosynthetic, metabolic and
pathogens. Avirulence of a subset of mutants identi- transport pathways in infection has not been well
fied during the screening was confirmed by perform- characterized.
ing competitive index assays and lethal dose assays. Recognition of the prevalence and severity of human
This represents the first report of a genome-wide neonatal and adult disease underscores the importance of
Accepted 10 July, 2000. *For correspondence. E-mail cruben@chmc. investigating the mechanisms important to the pathogen-
org; Tel. (11) 206 526 2073; Fax (11) 206 527 3890. esis of GBS infections. Large-scale screening to identify
Percentage amino
acid identity
a b
Classification Mutant Homology Hypothesized function (homology)/spanc
component
Regulatory KK12B8 Member of two-component regulatory system 40 (62)/161
AJ4C4 33 (54)/162
AJ9G5 Putative response regulator 54 (70)/53
AJ9B11 (Lactobacillus sakei) 40 (62)/121
AJ20C8 54 (70)/53
AJ6B1 YvoA (B. subtilis) Transcriptional regulator (GntR family) 37 (58)/74
AJ1E8 LytS (S. aureus) Autolysis sensor, member of two-component 53 (73)/207
regulatory system
Cell envelope AJ4F8 murF (S. pneumoniae) D-alanyl-D-alanine adding enzyme 69 (84)/106
AJ4F10 LrgB (S. aureus) Murein hydrolase 38 (61)/55
AJ3F6 PBP1a (S. pneumoniae) Peptidoglycan transglycosylase-transpeptidase 61 (80)179
Adherence AJ5D1 Lmb (S. agalactiae) Laminin-binding protein 78 (78)/41
Metabolic KK15A2 ScrB (Streptococcus sobrinus) Sucrose hydrolase 70 (81)/153
AJ2F5 LyxK (E. coli) Cryptic l-xylulose kinase 38 (61)/125
AJ10F10 PepX (L. lactis) Dipeptidyl peptidase 44 (61)/210
AJ1A4
AJ2D12 ] PepN (L. lactis)
Amimopeptidase 54 (72)/146
73 (86)/200
AJ18G6
AJ18E7 ] Xylanase (Mycoplasma genitalium)
Putative xylananse, xylose metabolism 28 (51)/176
46 (82)/157
Pyrimidine biosynthesis AJ2F8 CarB (Lactobacillus plantarum) Carbamoyl phosphate synthase 88 (93)/36
Purine biosynthesis AJ20C4 GuaA (L. lactis) GMP synthase 59 (73)/166
Amino acid biosynthesis AJ7B7 Hdh (L. lactis) Homoserine dehydrogenase 54 (70)/165
Cellular processes AJ8D3 RopA (S. pyogenes) Chaperone/regulator of secreted proteins 77 (87)/165
AJ16E7 LepA (B. subtilis) Membrane-associated GTP-binding protein 75 (92)/168
AJ5F7 Clp-like ATP-dependent Chaperone, proteolysis mediator 65 (75)/20
protease-binding subunit
]
KK14G4 Unknown 40 (64)/124
AJ20B5 DNA processing chain A 43 (64)/216
AJ7A3 (Thermatoga maritima) 40 (53)/134
AJ9F12
AJ9D9 ] Nisin resistance protein (L. lactis) Nisin resistance
31
27
(59)/214
(58)/137
Adaptations KK12G2
AJ9D8 ] Carbon starvation protein
homologue (E. coli)
Putative CstA family 40
40
(55)/77
(55)/77
Transcription factors KK13B10 plaC (S. aureus) DNA-directed RNA polymerase sigma factor 47 (68)/87
Translation AJ6E12 Amino group acetyl transferase Protein modification 33 (53)/72
(Chlamydia trachomatis)
Unknown AJ18D3 Membrane protein (B. subtilis) Putative integral membrane protein 72 (90)/48
Plasmid functions AJ10B3 RepJ (S. aureus) Plasmid replication initiation protein 34 (54)/146
Transposon-related
functions
KK15C4
KK13B4
AJ9C3
] ISL2 protein (L. lactis)
61
61
61
(78)/108
(78)/108
(78)/118
19 Unknown/putative (significant homology)
7 Unknown/putative (low homology)
20d No homology in public databases Unknown
a. Homology scores with a sum probability , e210 were considered significant. Mutants with lower homology (e204 to e209) were classified
separately. Homology scores . e203 were classified as having no significant database match. Only individual mutants of particular interest with low
homology are listed separately.
b. Hypothesized function inferred by analogy to other known proteins or gene sequences in the public databases.
c. Span describes the length of the region in amino acids to which percentage similarity and identity refers.
d. Sequence obtained from the flanking DNA of these mutants showed no significant homology to any sequence in the public databases or to any
unfinished genome sequences.
LD50a
Strain Mutation (homology) CI (no. of pups)b (cfu/animal)
a. LD50 values were calculated using the methods of Reed and Muench (1938) as described in Experimental procedures. LD50 for the parent strain
A909 was 3.2 104 cfu/animal.
b. Competitive indices (CI) are calculated relative to the wild-type strain A909 as described in Experimental procedures. The competitive index is
defined as the output ratio (mutant/wild type) divided by the input ratio (mutant/wild type). CI is the average determined from the number of rat pups
shown in parentheses. In some cases, no mutant bacteria were recovered from one or more rats. In this case, CI was calculated assuming that one
mutant bacterium had been recovered, and the CI is expressed as less than (,) this number.
during infection in a murine renal abscess model. A is approaching saturation or, alternatively, that these are
mutant was constructed in the orfA1 homologue and insertion hot-spots. Although Tn917 is reported to integrate
found to be significantly attenuated in virulence compared more randomly than other Gram-positive transposons, it
with the parent strain (Lowe et al., 1998). Mutant KK13B10 is thought that all transposons exhibit some sequence
has an attenuated phenotype in the competitive index bias for transposition (Coulter et al., 1998). Although we
assay; however, it also exhibits a growth defect when did obtain multiple transposon insertions in a number of
grown in vitro in complex media (Table 2). genes, we did not observe exact duplication of transposon
Mutant AJ5F7 had a transposon insertion in a region of insertion sites, suggesting that hot-spots for Tn917
the GBS chromosome with homology to a region of a Clp insertion are less likely.
protease regulatory subunit (65% identity over a 20- We were surprised that mutations in the capsule
amino-acid span). Clp proteases are a family of highly polysaccharide locus were not recovered, particularly as
conserved proteins involved in ATP-dependent proteo- the animals invariably cleared the asialo capsule mutant
lysis (Gottesman et al., 1990). The Clp protease is included in our study as a control strain. Similarly, Polissi
involved in degradation of denatured proteins and con- et al. (1998) did not identify any capsule mutants of S.
trolling the half-life of unstable proteins to modulate gene pneumoniae during STM screening. Using STM screening
expression (Porankiewicz et al., 1999). The Clp stress of S. aureus, Coulter et al. (1998) found only a small
response system for intracellular protein degradation is proportion of transposon insertions in classical virulence
widely conserved in bacteria, and the Clp proteases have genes, such as proteases, toxins or adhesins, that are
been implicated in virulence in an increasing number of involved in bacterial colonization. This was attributed to
organisms. STM of S. aureus identified an avirulent the required use of high-titre inocula to ensure non-biased
mutant with a transposon insertion in a ClpX homologue STM sampling of the surviving mutants. Additionally,
(Mei et al., 1997). Components of the Clp system are virulence factors are not constitutively expressed and are
also important for the virulence of L. monocytogenes often transcriptionally activated in response to the growth
(Rouquette et al., 1996) and Salmonella typhimurium phase of a culture. A variety of hypotheses has been
(Hensel et al., 1995). This mutant was severely attenu- proposed to explain the bias in the genes identified during
ated in the competitive index assay (Table 2). STM screening. Coulter et al. (1998) hypothesized that
the absence of many of these products may reflect the in
vivo growth state achieved at the time of mutant recovery.
Conclusions
STM screening may be biased against the identification of
To understand the mechanisms by which pathogens genes such as secreted toxins, adhesins and binding
cause disease, it is necessary to identify the microbial proteins involved in colonization because of its inherent
genes that are specifically required for the establishment limitations. Conversely, it may favour the identification of
and maintenance of an infection. STM has been applied genes impacting longer term in vivo growth and persis-
successfully to other Gram-positive organisms such as tence. (Coulter et al., 1998). Additionally, the model
S. pneumoniae (Polissi et al., 1998) and S. aureus (Mei system used for screening mutants may significantly
et al., 1997). We sought to apply STM to GBS in a influence or bias the genes that are identified.
neonatal rat sepsis model. Neonatal rats have been DNA sequence analysis of regions flanking transposon
shown to possess the same age-related susceptibility to insertions in the GBS mutants revealed that approxi-
GBS infections as human neonates and have been used mately 50% of them represent genes with unknown
widely as a model system for GBS infection (Zeligs et al., function. Our results are in agreement with those obtained
1982; Rubens et al., 1987; Wessels et al., 1989). In the by Mei et al. (1997), who reported similar results in S.
sepsis model, the ability of the bacteria to disseminate aureus. Insertions in genes lacking homology to known
systemically and survive significant exposure to host genes in the databases suggest that several genes
defence mechanisms is evaluated. However, this model encode novel factors that are potentially important during
bypasses the early stages of the infection process the infection process. The identification of the entire ORF
including adherence to and colonization of epithelial and searches for specific motifs or domains may give
surfaces, followed by subsequent invasion of host cells; an indication of the function of these genes. Additional
hence, some bacterial factors important to these stages in studies are under way to characterize the role of these
pathogenesis will not be identified using this model. unknown genes in GBS infection.
Given the estimated 2.2 Mb genome size of GBS, an The successful application of STM to GBS establishes
assumption of a 1 kb average gene size suggests that a basis for the application of this technique to other animal
complete coverage by transposon mutagenesis would models of infection, such as the pulmonary colonization
require in excess of 2200 transposon mutants. Despite model (Martin et al., 1988). Presumably, the lung colon-
this fact, duplication of mutants indicates that the system ization model will identify mutants that fail to survive