Anthony-Giddens-Interaction in Time and Space

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Social Interaction and Everyday Life 271

Interaction in time and bedrooms. So, too, in American middle-


class neighbourhoods, on afternoons the
space line between children's playground and
home may be defined as backstage by
Understanding how activities are distrib- moth ers, who pass along it wearing jeans.
uted in time and space is fundamental to loafers, and a minimum of make-up . ...
analysing encounters, and also to under- And , of course, a region that is thoroughly
standing socia l life in general. All established as a front region for the regular
interaction is situated - it occurs in a partic- performance of a particular routine often
functions as a back region before and after
ular place and has a specific duration in
each performance, for at these times the
time. Our actions over the course of a day permanent fixtures may undergo repairs,
tend to be 'zoned' in time as well as in space. restoration, and rearrangement, or the
Thus, for example, most people spend a performers may hold dress rehearsals. To
zone - say, from 9.00 a.m. to 5.00 p.m. - of see this we need only glance into a
their daily time working. Their weekly time restaurant, or store, or home, a few
is also zoned: they are likely to work on minutes before these establishments are
weekdays and spend weekends at home, opened to us for the day. (1959: 128)
altering the pattern of their activities on the
weekend days. As we move through the Clock time
temporal zones of the day, we are also often
moving across space as well: to get to work, In modern societies, the zoning of our activ-
we may take a bus from one area of a city to ities is strongly influenced by clock time.
another, or perhaps commute in from the Without clocks and the precise timing of
suburbs. When we analyse the contexts of activities, and thereby their coordination
social interaction, therefore, it is often across space, industrialized societies could
useful to look at people's movements across not exist (Mumford 1973). The measuring of
time-space. time by clocks is today standardized across
The concept ofregionalization will help the globe, making possible the complex
us understand how social life is zoned in internat ional transport systems and
time-space. Take the example of a private communications we now depend on. World
house. A modern house is regionalized into standard time was first introduced in 1884
rooms, hallways and floors if there is more at a conference of nations held in Washing-
than one storey. These spaces are not just ton. The globe was then partitioned into 24
physically separate areas, but are zoned in time zones, each one hour apart, and an
time as well. The living rooms and kitchen exact beginning of the universal day was
are used most in the daylight hours, the fixed.
bedrooms at night. The interaction that Fourteenth-century monasteries were
occurs in these regions is bound by both the first organizations to try to schedule the
spatial and temporal divisions. Some areas activities of their inmates precisely across
of the house form back regions, with 'perfor- the day and week. Today, there is virtually no
mances' taking place in the others. At times, group or organization that does not do so -
the whole house can become a back region. the greater the number of people and
Once again, this idea is beautifully captured resources involved, the more precise the
by Goffman: scheduling must be. Eviatar Zerubavel
(1979, 1982) demonstrated this in his study
Of a Sunday morning, a whole household
of the temporal structure of a large modern
can use the wall around its domestic
establishment to conceal a relaxing hospital. A hospital must operate on a 24-
slovenliness in dress and civil endeavour, hour basis, and coordinating the staff and
exte nding to all rooms the informality that resources is a highly complex matter. For
is usuaUy restricted to kitchen and instance, the nurses work for one time
272 SOCIAL INTERACTION AND EVERYDAY LI FE

period in ward A, another time period in which more than a handful of people are
ward B, and so on, and are also called on to together at anyone time?
alternate between day- and night-shift To see some of the contrasts between
work. Nurses, doctors and other staff, plus social interaction in modern and traditional
the resources they need, must be integrated societies, let's take as an example one of the
together both in time and in space. least developed cultures in terms of tech-
nology remaining in the world: the !Kung
The ordering of space and time (sometimes known as the Bushmen), who
live in the Kalahari Desert area of Botswana
The Internet is another examp le of how and Namibia, in southern Africa (Lee 1968,
closely forms of social life are bound up with 1969; the exclamation mark refers to a click
our control of space and time. The Internet sound one makes before pronouncing the
makes it possible for us to interact with name). Although their way of life is chang-
people we never see or meet, in any corner ing because of outside influences, their
of the world. Such technological change traditional patterns of social life are still
'rearranges' space - we can interact with evident.
anyone without moving from our chair. It The !Kung live in groups of some 30 or 40
also alters our experience of time, because people, in temporary settlements near
communication on the electronic highway water-ho les. Food is scarce in their environ-
is almost immediate. Until about 50 years ment, and they must walk far and wide to
ago, most communication across space find it. Such roaming takes up most of the
required a duration of time. If you sent a average day. Women and children often stay
letter to someone abroad, there was a time back in the camp, but equally often the
gap while the letter was carried by ship, who le group spends the day walking.
train, truck or plane to the person to whom Members of the community will sometimes
it was written. fan out over an area of up to a 100 square
People still write letters by hand today, of miles in the course of a day, returning to the
course, but instantaneous communication camp at night to eat and sleep. The men may
has become basic to our social world. Our be alone or in groups of two or three for
lives would be almost unimaginable with- much of the day. There is one period of the
out it. We are so used to being able to switch year, however, when the routines of their
on the TV and watch the news or make a daily activities change: the winter rainy
phone call or send an email to a friend in season, when water is abundant and food
another part of the world that it is hard for much easier to come by. The everyday life of
us to imagine what life would be like other- the !Kung during this period is centred on
wise. ritual and ceremonial activities, the prepa-
ration for and enactment of which is very
Everyday life in cultural and time-consuming.
historical perspective The members of most !Kung groups never
see anyone they do not know reasonably
Some of the mechanisms of social interac- well. Until contacts with the outside became
tion analysed by Goffman, Garfinkel and more common in recent years, they had no
others seem to be universal. But much of word for 'stranger'. While the !Kung, particu-
Goffman's discussion of civil inattention larly the males, may spend long periods of
and other kinds of interaction primarily the day out of contact with others, in the
concerns societies in which contact with community itself there is little opportunity
strangers is commonplace. What about for privacy. Families sleep in flimsy, open
small-scale traditional societies, where dwellings, with virtually all activities open to
there are no strangers and few settings in public view. No one has studied the !Kung
Social Interaction and Everyday Life

with Goffman's observations on everyday life logical thought known as social construc-
in mind, but it is easy to see that some aspects tionism.
of his work have limited application to !Kung Social constructivists believe that what
social life. There are few opportunities, for individuals and society perceive and under-
example, to create front and back regions. stand as reality is itself a construction, a
The closing off of different gatherings and creation of the social interaction of individ-
encounters by the walls of rooms, separate uals and groups. Trying to 'explain' social
buildings and the various neighbourhoods of reality is to overlook and to reify (regard as a
cities common in modern societies are given truth) the processes through which
remote from the activities of the !Kung. such reality is constructed. Therefore, social
The form of social interaction of the !Kung constructivists argue that sociologists need
is very different from the interaction that to document and analyse these processes
takes place in the modern city. City life and not simply be concerned with the
forces us to interact almost constantly with concept of social reality they give rise to.
strangers. Social constructionism has been seen as an
important influence on the postmodern
THINIUNG CRITICALLY school of thought in sociology (see chapter
Think about your recent holidays and I, 'What is Sociology?').
note the reasons why you chose those In their 1966 classic study, The Social
locations. Did you ever consider the Construction of Reality, sociologists Peter
impact your visit would have on: Berger and Thomas Luckrnann examined
common-sense knowledge - those things
the society and people you were that individuals take for granted as real.
visiting - what resources are needed?
They emphasized that these 'obvious' facts
what kind of jobs are required to
of social reality may differ among people
service the tourist's needs?
from different cultures, and even among
the natural environment - in terms of
different people within the same culture.
travel, infrastructure needed, damage
The task becomes an analysis of the
to ecosystems.
processes by which individuals come to
Do the benefits of global tourism perceive what is 'real' to them as real.
outweigh the damage it causes? What Social constructivists apply the ideas of
are those benefits? Berger and Luckmann to the investigation of
social phenomena, to illuminate the ways in
A famous account of urban social
which members of society come to know and
interaction is that of Georg Simmel, simultaneously create what is real. While
whose work is discussed in chapter 6, social constructivists have examined such
'Cities and Urban Life'. diverse topics as medicine and medical
treatment, gender relations and emotions,
The social construction of reality: much of their work has focused on social
the sociological debate problems, such as the crime 'problem'.
The work of Aaron Cicourel (1968)
Within sociology, many different theoreti- provides an example of social construction-
cal frameworks are used to explain social ist research in the area of youth crime.
reality. These theories differ in their expla- Sometimes, data regarding rates and cases
nations of social phenomena, yet they of youth crime are taken as given (that is, as
share the assumption that social reality real), and theories are created to explain the
exists independently of people's talking patterns observed in the data. For example,
about it or living in it. This assumption has at first glance arrest and court data would
been challenged by a broad body of socio- seem to indicate that young people from
Global Society 7. I International tourist interactions
Have you ever had a face-to-face conversation with the physical environment are supposed to
someone from another country? Or connected to an proceed.
overseas website? Have you ever travelled to Britons travelling in the United States, for example,
another part ofthe world? If you answered 'yes' to may delight in the fact that the Americans drive on the
any of these questions, you have witnessed the right-hand side of the road. At the same time, such
effects of globalization on social interaction. behaviour is disconcerting to drivers from the UK. Our
Globalization - a relatively recent phenomenon - rules of the road are so ingrained that we experience
has changed both the frequency and the nature of systematic violations of those rules as strange, weird
interactions between people of different nations. The and exotic. Yet, as tourists, we take pleasure in this
historical sociologist Charles Tilly, in fact, defines strangeness. In a sense, it is what we have paid money
globalization in terms of these changes. According to see when we go abroad - along with the Empire
to Tilly, 'globalization means an increase in the State Bwlding or the Eiffel Tower. Imagine how
geographic range of locally consequential social disappointed you would be if you were to travel to a
interactions' (Tilly 1995: 1-2). In other words, with different country only to find that it was almost exactly
globalization, a greater proportion of our the same as the city or town in which you grew up.
interactions come to involve. directly or indirectly, Yet most tourists do not want their experiences
people from other countries. to be too exotic. A popular destination for young,
What are the characteristics of social interactions particularly US, travellers in Paris, for example, is a
that take place between individuals of different McDonald's restaurant. Some go to see if there is
nations? Important contributions to the study of this any truth to the line from Quentin Tarantino's movie
problem have been made by those working in the Pulp Fiction that, because the French use the metric
area of the sociology of tourism. Sociologists of system, McDonald's 'quarter pounder with cheese'
tourism note that globalization has greatly hamburgers are called 'Royales with cheese' (it is
expanded the possibilities for international travel, true, by the way) . Britons travelling abroad often
both by encouraging an interest in other countries cannot resist eating and drinking in British- and
and by facilitating the movement of tourists across Irish-style pubs. Sometimes such diversions are the
international borders. Between 1982 and 2002, the result of curiosity. but often people enjoy the
number of visits to the UK made by overseas comfort of eating familiar food in a familiar setting.
residents doubled, and spending on these visits The contradictory demands for the exotic and the
more than tripled. These visitors now pump almost familiar are at the heart of the tourist gaze.
£12 billion a year into the UK economy Britons are The tourist gaze may put strains on face-to-face
also travelling the world in record numbers (ONS interactions between tourists and locals. Locals
2004b). who are part of the tourist industry may appreciate
High levels of international tourism, of course, overseas travellers for the economic benefits they
translate into an increase in the number offace-to- bring to the places they visit. Other locals may
face interactions between people of different resent tourists for their demanding attitudes or for
countries. The sociologist John Urry (1990) argues the overdevelopment that often occurs in popular
that the 'tourist gaze' - the expectation on the part tourist destinations. Tourists may interrogate locals
of the tourist that he or she will have 'exotic' about aspects of their everyday lives, such as their
experiences while travelling abroad - shapes food, work and recreational habits; they may do this
many of these interactions. Urry compares the either to enhance their understanding of other
tourist gaze to Foucault's conception of the medical cultures or to judge negatively those who are
gaze (see chapter 10, 'Health, illness and different from themselves.
Disability'). Urry argues that the tourist gaze is just As tourism increases with the march of
as socially organized by professional experts, globalization, sociologists will have to watch
systematic in its application and as detached as the carefully to see what dominant patterns of
medical gaze, but this time it is organized in its interaction emerge between tourists and locals,
search for 'exotic' experiences. These are and to determine, among other things, whether
experiences that violate our everyday expectations these interactions tend to be friendly or
about how social interaction and interaction with antagonistic.
Social Interaction and Everyday Life 275
single-parent families are more likely to analyses examining which young people
commit delinquent acts than those from become labelled as delinquent, social
two-parent homes. Some sociologists have constructivists often argue that the initial
therefore developed explanations for this behaviours reported for the young people
observed relationship: perhaps children are identical; therefore, any differences
from Single-parent homes have less super- between those labelled as criminals and
vision, or perhaps they lack appropriate role those avoiding such a label must be due to
models. the construction of the label itself. Critics
By contrast, Cicourel observed the argue that social constructionism inconsis-
processes involved in the arrest and classifi- tently presents the initial behaviours as
cation of youths suspected of committing objective, while arguing that the labelling
crimes; that is, he observed the creation of process is subjective (ibid.).
the 'official' crime data. He discovered that Other sociologists have criticized social
police procedures in the handling of young constructionism for its unwillingness to
offenders rely on common-sense under- accept broader social forces as powerful
standings of what young offenders are influences on observable social outcomes.
'really like'. For example, some critics have argued that
For example, when youths from lower- while reality may be a constructed perpetu-
class families were arrested, police were ation of common-sense beliefs, these
more likely to view their offences as results beliefs themselves may be caused by exist-
of poor supervision or a lack of proper role ing social factors such as capitalism or
models, and would retain the young people patriarchy.
in custody. Offenders from upper-class Ultimately, social constructionism offers
homes, however, were more likely to be a theoretical approach to understanding
released to their parents' care, where police social reality that radically differs from most
and parents believed the young person other sociological approaches. Rather than
could receive proper discipline. Thus, the assuming that social reality objectively
practices of police serve formally to assign exists, social constructivists work to docu-
the label of 'young offender' more often to ment and analyse the processes through
those from lower-class homes than to those which social reality is constructed, such that
from upper-class homes - even when the the construction then serves to confirm its
youths have committed similar offences. own status as social reality.
This assignment produces the very data,
which in turn confirm the relationships held Social interaction in cyberspace
by the common-sense views; for example,
that young people from poor families are In modern societies, in complete contrast to
more likely to engage in crime. Cicourel's the !Kung, we constantly interact with
study shows that, through interacting with others whom we may never see or meet.
other people in society, we transform our Almost all of our everyday transactions,
common -sense notions of reality into such as buying groceries or making a bank
independent, 'objective' proof of their own deposit, bring us into contact - but indirect
validity. contact - with people who may live thou-
Social constructionjsm is not without its sands of miles away.
critics. Sociologists Steve Woolgar and Now that email, instant mess aging,
Dorothy Pawluch (1985) argue that social online communities and chat rooms have
constructivists aim to show the subjective become facts of life for many people in
creation of social reality, yet in doing so industrialized countries, what is the nature
selectively view certain features as objective of these interactions, and what new
and others as constructed. For example, in complexities are emerging from them?
276 SOCIAL INTERACTION AND EVERYDAY LIFE

Sceptics argue that indirect communication often presented as liberating and empower-
through email and the Internet contains a ing, since people can create their own online
wealth of problems not found in face-to - identities and speak more freely than they
face social interaction. As Katz et al. put it: would elsewhere.
'To type is not to be human, to be in cyber- Internet sceptics have also argued that
space is not to be real; all is pretence and indirect, online communication encourages
alienation, a poor substitute for the real isolation and prevents real friendships from
thing' (2001: 407). In particular, supporters forming, but this does not seem to reflect the
of this view argue that computer-mediated realiry. A survey of Internet users carried out
communication technology is too limited to between 1995 and 2000 showed that, far from
prevent users hiding behind false identities. increasing social isolation, Internet usage is
This also allows trickery, lechery, manipula- associated with Significant and increased
tion, emotional swindles and so on: online and offline social interactions. The
survey found that Internet users tend to
The problem lies in the nature of human
communicate with others through other
communication. We think of it as a
product of the mind, but it's done by media - especially by the telephone - more
bodies: faces move, voices intone, bodies than non-users do, meet face-to -face with
sway, hands gesture .. ,. On the Internet, friends more than non-users and interact
the mind is present but the body is gone. with others more in general (Katz et al. 2001).
Recipients get few clues to the personality
and mood of the person , can only guess
why messages are sent, what they mean, THINllING CRITICALLY
what responses to make. Trust is virtually From your own experience, can the
out the window. It's a risky business. online environment ever match the trust
(Locke and Pascoe 2000) established by relationships in face-to
face relationships? Could the wider use
Yet defenders of new technology argue that
of personal webcams increase the trust
there are ways in which good or bad reputa-
we have in Internet communications?
tions can be built and trust can be estab-
What can we learn about online trust
lished, thereby reducing the risks of online
from the eBay system and experience
communication. described in 'Global Society 7.2'?
Furthermore, Internet enthusiasts argue
that online communication has many inher-
ent advantages that cannot be claimed by
more traditional forms of interaction such as Conclusion: the
the telephone and face-to -face meetings. compulsion of proximity?
The human voice, for example, may be far
superior in terms of expressing emotion and Despite the rise in indirect communication,
subtleties of meaning, but it can also convey however, it seems that humans still value
information about the speaker's age, gender, direct contact. People in business, for
ethnicity or social position - information instance, continue to attend meetings,
that could be used to the speaker's disadvan- sometimes flying halfway around the world
tage. Electronic communication, it is noted, to do so, when it would seem much cheaper
masks all these identifying markers and and more efficient to transact business
ensures that attention focuses strictly on the through a conference call or video link.
content of the message. This can be a great Family members could arrange 'virtual'
advantage for women or other traditionally reunions or holiday gatherings using elec-
disadvantaged groups whose opinions are tronic real-time communications, butwe all
sometimes devalued in other settings (Locke recognize that they would lack the warmth
and Pascoe 2000). Electronic interaction is and intimacy of face-to -face celebrations.
Social Interaction and Everyday Life 277
Global Society 7.2 Building trust in cyberspace?
Public debate on Internet security has tended to allowed to post positive, negative or neutral
focus on issues of online banking fraud, the use of comments about users with whom they have
false identities and the problems associated with traded. Each positive comment is given a score of
children using chatrooms that may be monitored + 1, each negative comment is given a score of -1 ,
by predatory paedophiles. Such worries make with neuh-al comments not affecting one's score in
many people wary and erode trust in the online either clirection. At certain levels, market
environment. Sociologists have been interested in participants are also awarded a colour star which
the auction website. eBay, which has become a marks the number of net positive comments they
global phenomenon; some 165,000 Americans have received.
alone are estimated to be making a living purely One is able t
from selling via eBay (Epley et al. 2006). Below is a o contact the person via email by clicking on the
short extract which discusses how eBay has sought name; clicking on the number following someone's
to increase levels of trust for buyers and sellers in name leads to their full feedback profile. There one
its services. finds the full list of comments, with emaillinks and
ratings numbers for every evaluator as well (thus,
The 'eBay' feedback system one can explore the reputation of the evaluators just
Currently the largest. and one of the oldest person- as one can for the evaluated). A typical positive
to-person Internet auction houses is eBay comment might be 'Well packaged, fast delivery
Launched in 1995, eBay soon attracted more than Highly recommended. AI.' .
100 million people around the world who buy and A high feedback rating is an extremely valuable
sell products on the eBay websites. Remarkably, asset. Many participants report that they are more
eBay offers no warrantles or guarantees for any of willing to trade with someone with a high rating, or
the goods that are auctioned off - buyers and even that they will only trade with inclividuals with
sellers assume all risks for the transaction, with high ratings. In that sense, some traders are able to
eBay serving as a listing agency It would seem to create a brand identity that increases their volume
be a market ripe with the possibility of large-scale of sales or even the price at which they are able to
fraud and deceit. and yet the default rate for trades sell items .... Even a few negative ratings can
conducted through eBay is remarkably small. Both seriously damage a reputation, and so frequent
eBay and the participants in its market creclit an traders are very careful about nurturing their rating
institutionalized reputation system at the slte - by provicling swift execution of honest trades. The
known as the Feedback Forum - for the very hlgh potential damage of a negative comment is a
rate of successful trades. subject of great concern among frequent
After every seller's or bidder's name is a participants .... One can choose to make one's
number in parenthesis. In the case of a seller, the entire feedback profile private, but this is a huge
information is displayed as follows: clisadvantage in a market which relies on these
reputations.
Seller name (265)
The number is a summary measure of a person's Source: Adapted from Kollock (1999)
reputation in the eBay market. Registered users are

An explanation for this phenomenon attend meetings, Boden and Molot ch


comes from Deirdre Boden and Harvey suggest, because situations of co-presence,
Molotch (l994), who have studied what they for reasons documented by Goffman in his
call the compulsion of proximity: the need studies of interaction, supply much richer
of individuals to meet with one another in information about how other people think
situations of co-presence, or face- ta-face and feel, and about their sincerity, than any
interaction. People put themselves out to form of electronic communication. Only by
~78 SO C IAL I NTE RACT IO N AN D EVERYD AY LIFE

actually being in the presence of peo ple body pa rt that "never lies", the eyes - the
who make decisions affecting us in impor- "windows on the soul". Eye contact itself
tant ways do we feel able to learn what is signals a degree of intim acy and trust; co -
going on and feel co nfident that we can present interactants continuously monitor
impress them with o ur own views and OUI the subtle m ovem e nts of th is most subtle
own sinceri ty. 'Co-prese nce', Bod en an d body pa rt.'
Molotch (! 994) say, 'affects access to th e

Summary points divided up into distinct encounters, or


episode s of inte raction, is when two or more
I. Many apparently trivial aspects of our day-to - individuals are directly attending to what the
day behaviour turn out on close examination other or others are saying and doing.
to be both complex and important aspects of 6. Social interaction can often be illuminatingly
social interaction. An example is the gaze - studie d by applying the dramaturgical model
looking at other people. In most interactions, - studying social interaction as if those
eye contact is fairly fleeting. To stare at involved were actors on a stage, having a set
another person could be taken as a sign of and props. As in the the atre, in the various
hostility - or on some occasions, of love. The contexts of social life there tend to be clear
study of social interaction is a fundamental distinctions between front regions (the stage
area in sociology, illuminating many aspects of itself) and back regions , where the actors
social life . prepare themselves for the performance and
2. Many different expressions are conveyed by relax afterwards.
the human face. It is widely held that basic 7. All social interaction is situated in time and
aspects of the facial expre ssions of emotion space. We can analyse how our daily lives are
are innate. Cross-cultural studies demonstrate 'zoned' in both time and space combined by
quite close similarities b e tween members of looking at how activities occur during definite
different cultures both in facial expression and durations and at the same time involve spatial
in the interpretation of emotions re gistere d on move me nt.
the human face. 8. Some mechanisms of s ocial interaction may
3. The study of ordinary talk and conversation be universal, but many are not. The !Kung of
has come to be called 'ethnomethodology', a southe rn Africa, for exarnple, live in small
term first coined by Harold Garfinkel. mobile bands, where there is little privacy and
Ethnomethodology is the analysis of the ways thus little opportunity to create front and back
in which we actively - although usually in a regions.
taken-for-granted w ay - make sense of what 9. Modern socie ties are characterized largely by
others mean by what they say and do. indirect interpersonal transactions (such as
4. We can learn a great deal about the nature of making bank deposits) , which lack any co-
talk by studying re sponse cr ies presence. This leads to what has be en called
(exclamations) . the compulsion of proximity, the te ndency to
S. Unfocuse d interaction is the mutual awareness want to meet in person whenever possible,
individuals have of one another in large p erhaps because this makes it e asier to gather
gatherings when not directly in conversation information about how others think and feel ,
toge ther. Focused interaction, which can be and to accomplish impre ssion management.

You might also like