Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sakai 2007
Sakai 2007
Review Article
Blackwell Publishing Asia
Abstract
The historical development of anatomical terminology from the ancient to the modern can be divided into five
stages. The initial stage is represented by the oldest extant anatomical treatises by Galen of Pergamon in the
Roman Empire. The anatomical descriptions by Galen utilized only a limited number of anatomical terms,
which were essentially colloquial words in the Greek of this period. In the second stage, Vesalius in the early
16th century described the anatomical structures in his Fabrica with the help of detailed magnificent
illustrations. He coined substantially no anatomical terms, but devised a system that distinguished anatomical
structures with ordinal numbers. The third stage of development in the late 16th century was marked by
innovation of a large number of specific anatomical terms especially for the muscles, vessels and nerves. The
main figures at this stage were Sylvius in Paris and Bauhin in Basel. In the fourth stage between Bauhin and
the international anatomical terminology, many anatomical textbooks were written mainly in Latin in the 17th
century, and in modern languages in the 18th and 19th centuries. Anatomical terms for the same structure
were differently expressed by different authors. The last stage began at the end of the 19th century, when the
first international anatomical terminology in Latin was published as Nomina anatomica. The anatomical
terminology was revised repeatedly until the current Terminologia anatomica both in Latin and English.
Key words: anatomy, history, medical illustration, terminology, textbooks.
Introduction nerves were coined in the 16th and early 17th centuries.
As founders of these anatomical terms, the names of
Anatomical terminology indicating the various parts and Sylvius in Paris and Bauhin in Basel have been frequently
organs of the human body is the most basic vocabulary mentioned. The current anatomical terms have been
in medicine and serves as the convenient tools in the defined officially in the international anatomical
anatomical sciences. The current international termi- terminology. The first international terminology was
nology, Terminologia anatomica, includes approximately titled Nomina anatomica in 1895 at the meeting of
7000 entries. The anatomical terms are specific and Anatomische Gesellschaft in Basel (His, 1895).
self-intelligible, namely, their meaning can be under- To clarify the evolution of the modern anatomical
stood from the terms themselves without referring to terms derived from the colloquial words in the ancient
the context. In everyday life we also use many colloquial anatomical treatises, I have surveyed a series of ana-
words to indicate parts and organs of the body. Most tomical works from Galen’s ancient treatises to the
of the anatomical terms are different from the colloquial modern anatomical textbooks either in my library or
words, and must have been invented intentionally in obtained as digital images. It became obvious from
certain periods in the history of anatomy since the time the survey that the anatomical descriptions in the
of the oldest known anatomists such as Herophilus historical literature were transformed significantly in
and Erasistratus in ancient Alexandria. parallel with the evolution of anatomical terms, as
A question naturally arises as to how and when well as that of anatomical illustrations, in history.
the anatomical terms were invented and developed. I have written the present review article in hopes
Concerning this question, the literature tells us that that the significance and usefulness of anatomical
many of the anatomical terms for muscles, vessels and terminology would be realized and appreciated not
only by anatomical experts, but also by general medical
doctors and students. The anatomical terms have greatly
Correspondence: Tatsuo Sakai, Department of Anatomy, School
of Medicine, Juntendo University, 2-1-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku,
facilitated communication in the medical disciplines
Tokyo, 113-8421, Japan. Email: tatsuo@med.juntendo.ac.jp and stimulated anatomical investigations in various
Received 1 September 2006; accepted 24 October 2006. dimensions from the macroscopic to the molecular
© 2007 The Author levels in humans as well as in the various other species
Journal compilation © 2007 Japanese Association of Anatomists on Earth.
66 T. Sakai
and arteries and On anatomy of nerves from the Greek in number, flex the whole wrist (*flexor carpi radialis/
texts with detailed annotations and discussions identify- ulnaris). The two oblique muscles (*pronator teres/
ing many of the anatomical structures described. During quadratus) turn the radius and with it the whole arm
these studies I noted that, in the anatomical texts, to the prone position. The seventh one (*palmaris
longus), the last and smallest of those extending the
Galen used only a small number of Greek colloquial
length of the forearm, in the opinion of anatomists
words to indicate structures of the body. An example
before my time also flexes the five fingers, but actually
of such a passage is cited below from On anatomy no movement of the fingers is entrusted to it and it
of nerves. has been formed for a certain marvellous purpose
The anterior cavities (*of the cranium) about the brain which I shall explain later in this book. Of the nine
[εγκεφαλος] themselves gradually narrow into the muscles on the outer side of the forearm, one (*extensor
shape similar to pine-cones as they proceed forward, digitorum) extends all the fingers except the thumb;
until they come to the origin of the nose [ρις], lying two others (*two of extensor digiti proprii) move the
side by side and touching altogether, that nothing same four fingers laterally. A fourth muscle (*extensor
exists between them except the thin membrane [µηνιγξ] pollicis longus) moves only the thumb, giving it the
(*of the cerebral falx). At each side of them, one in more oblique of its two external movements, the other
the right part, and one in the left, is a nerve [νευρον] being furnished by another muscle (*abductor pollicis
(*of the optic nerve) worth mentioning in thickness, and longus and extensor pollicis brevis) which also
almost the softest of all other nerves, growing out moderately extends the whole wrist; the vigorous
from the brain itself, and coming forward into the eyes extension of the wrist, however, is performed by two other
[οφθαλµος] (*in the orbit) out of the cranium [κρανιον] muscles (*extensor carpi ulnaris, extensor carpi radiales
through a hole (*of the optic canal) having exactly longus/brevis). The remaining two (*brachioradialis,
the same breadth as the thickness of the nerve. This supinator) supinate the radius and carry the whole
hole is located at the (*deepest) place where first the arm with it to the same position.
space of the eyes begins to grow, and when you observe (Adapted from May (1968); The parentheses with
(*from the front) those nerves they will appear like asterisks indicate the names of muscles identified by
some roots of the eyes. It does not break up into many the present author.)
fibers, like all other nerves spreading into the recipient The aforementioned text describes muscles in the
organs [οργανον], and there is something else remark- forearm, six on the flexor side and nine on the extensor
able, which is not easy to explain in words, or you side. Even without specific anatomical terms, we can
will not believe when you hear it, before you witness guess these 15 muscles as indicated by the notes in
with your own eyes.
the parentheses based on the positions and functions
(Adapted from Goss (1966) and Sakai et al. (2003);
of muscles. The flexor carpi radialis/ulnaris are identified
The parentheses with asterisks indicate notes by the
present author, and the square brackets show the
by the description ‘on the inner side of the forearm
original Greek anatomical words.) … the next largest, also two in number, flex the whole
wrist’, and the extensor carpi ulnaris, extensor carpi
The aforementioned text describes the anatomy radiales longus/brevis are judged from ‘on the outer
of the optic nerve, which emerges from the brain side of the forearm … vigorous extension of the wrist
through the optic canal to the eyeball, and explains … is performed by two other muscles’.
the difference from other nerves, using only seven The description is slightly inconsistent with the
colloquial words. The description represents vividly human anatomy because Galen dissected no human
and precisely the scene of anatomical dissection. The cadavers, only the bodies of monkeys and other animals,
modern anatomical experts with sufficient knowledge due to the social and cultural restrictions in the Roman
and experience of the human anatomy would well empire. The two extensor digiti proprii moving four
appreciate that Galen dissected and observed the fingers are actually the four extensor digiti proprii
body himself and made these observations during arising from the two origins in the monkey (Howell &
dissection with masterly clarity. Readers are required Straus, 1933), and not extensor indicis and extensor
to have certain knowledge of anatomy to understand digiti minimi in the human anatomy. The distinction
the text. Indeed Galen wrote the anatomical treatises between the extensor carpi radialis logus and brevis
and articles frequently for certain patrons who either as well as that between the abductor pollicis longus
loved anatomy deeply or had experience with Galen and extensor pollicis brevis are missing in Galen’s text.
dissecting animals. Otherwise the anatomical description by Galen fits
Another example of Galen’s anatomical texts is cited well the anatomy of human forearm muscles.
here, describing the anatomy of muscles moving the As Galen’s texts show, the anatomical descriptions
wrist, from Usefulness of the parts Book 2, Chapter 2. without specific terminology are perfectly possible, but
Two of the muscles on the inner side of the forearm, inevitably contain considerable weaknesses in trans-
and those the largest (*flexor digitorum superficialis/ mission of anatomical information to others. First, the
profundus), flex the fingers. The next largest, also two texts are intelligible only to anatomical experts with
sufficient knowledge of anatomy. Beginners cannot the muscle man in Book 2 are magnificent and most
access anatomical knowledge in the literature without outstanding among the numerous illustrations in Fabrica.
specific terminology, although Galen wrote several In Fabrica and the other works, Vesalius described
anatomical articles for beginners. Second, the anatomical individual anatomical structures with text and associated
texts permit various possibilities of interpretation so anatomical illustrations (wood engravings). Examples
that the accuracy of the information is difficult to verify. of the combination of verbal and pictorial presentations
Further development of anatomical sciences cannot are taken from Fabrica Book 2 on the muscles, Chapter
be expected on the basis of such ambiguous anatomical 44 on the muscles producing movements of the wrist
information. Third, the anatomical texts without specific (Fig. 2).
terminology require much time and effort to read, and
Along with the wrist the rest of the hand flexes and
in addition a masterly grasp of what Galen intends,
extends and moves to either side (the motion to which
to write down clear and intelligible descriptions. we apply the adjective obliquus). It does this by means
of four muscles. The first musclea draws from the inner
Anatomical terms with ordinal numbers tubercle of the humerusb a beginningc of mixed fleshy
by Vesalius and sinewy substance. From here it is attached to the
whole length of the ulna, from which it takes the strength
Andreas Vesalius (1514–1564) is frequently considered of its beginning as it proceeds; this is so especially
to be the founder of modern anatomy and medicine. at the top end of the ulna not far from the joint of the
His major work Fabrica (Vesalius, 1543a) in seven books forearm to the arm …
contains detailed description of the human anatomy a Σ in Table IV, Z in Table I, a in II, m in III,* in V, Ξ
in IX; b S in fig. 1 of Ch. 23 of Bk. I; c γ in Table IV.
as well as a number of artistic precise illustrations. Other
(Adapted from Richardson & Carman, 1999)
anatomical works by Vesalius include Tabulae sex
(Vesalius, 1538) consisting of six anatomical tables and The text describes the flexor carpi ulnaris in modern
explanations, and Epitome (Vesalius, 1543b) being an terminology. Vesalius named it as the ‘first muscle’
introductory treatise on anatomy. Translations of these among the four muscles which ‘flexes and extends and
works are available as follows: Tabulae sex, Singer and moves to either side’ the wrist. In Fabrica (Vesalius,
Rabin (1946) in English; Fabrica, Richardson and Car- 1543a) the muscles, blood vessels and peripheral
man (1998, 1999, 2002) for the Books 1–4, and Singer nerves were systematically distinguished with ordinal
(1952b) for a part of Book 7 in English; and Epitome, numbers. Vesalius’ anatomical description with ordinal
Lind (1949) in English, Nakahara (1994) in Japanese. numbers was obviously no more intelligible than that
Fabrica consists of seven books dealing with (i) of Galen, which lacked specific anatomical terms.
bones and cartilage; (ii) ligaments and muscles; (iii) However, the intelligibility of Vesalius’ anatomical texts
veins and arteries; (iv) nerves; (v) abdominal organs was improved by the addition of precise anatomical
of nutrition and generation; (vi) heart and associated illustrations.
organs in thorax; and (vii) brain. The anatomical The aforementioned text was accompanied by
illustrations of the skeletal man in Book 1 as well as side notes that indicated the structures depicted in the
Table 1. Muscles moving the fingers in Fabrica Book 2, and nerves in Fabrica, as in the case of texts by Galen.
Chapter 43 Indeed Vesalius improved the anatomical description
VESALIUS MODERN not by improvement of anatomical terminology, but
by utilizing the visual recognition of structures through
1st Flexor digitorum superficialis anatomical illustrations.
2nd Flexor digitorum profundus
The reaction against the published Fabrica was
3rd Flexor pollicis longus
sensational and diverse. Sylvius (1478–1555) criticized
4th to 11th 7 interossei and flexor digiti minimi
12th Flexor pollicis brevis
new anatomical findings in Fabrica and tried to justify
13th Opponens pollicis the incorrect anatomical descriptions by Galen. Geminus
14th to 16th Adductor pollicis (1510–1562) and Valverde (1520–1588) published
17th Adductor pollicis anatomical textbooks borrowing descriptions and
18th Extensor digiti minimi illustrations from Fabrica and Epitome. The influence
19th Extensor indicis of Vesalius’ Fabrica and Epitome is tremendous and
20th Abductor digiti minimi unparalleled in the history of anatomy. Colombo (1510–
21st Extensor pollicis longus 1559), Fallopio (1523–1562) and many other anatomists,
22nd Extensor pollicis brevis and part worked along the same lines with Vesalius to dissect
of abductor pollicis longus
human bodies, and corrected and augmented previous
23rd Part of abductor pollicis longus
anatomical descriptions including those by Vesalius.
24th Abductor pollicis brevis
25th First dorsal interosseous
26th to 29th Lumbricals Descriptive anatomical terms by Sylvius
and Bauhin
(adapted from Richardson & Carman, 1999)
After publication of Vesalius’ Fabrica, several anatomical
textbooks were published including De re anatomica
Bauhin Modern
74
Author Year Title and publisher Language
Laurentius A 1623 [1600] Historia anatomica, humani corporis partes singulas uberrimè enodans, novisque controversiis, & Latin
observationibus illustrata. Iacobi Cardon & Petri Cavellat, Lyon
Bauhin C 1605 Theatrum anatomical novis figuris aenis illustratum. Johan Theodor de Bry & Johan Israel Latin
de Bry, Frankfurt
Riolan J 1608 Schola anatomica novis et raris observationibus illustrata. Adrianum Perier, Paris Latin
Bartholin T 1651 [1641] Anatomia, ex Caspari Bartholini parentis institutionibus, omniumque recentiorum & propriis Latin
observationibus tertium ad sanguinis circulationem reformata. Franciscum Hackium, Lyon
Journal compilation © 2007 Japanese Association of Anatomists
Vesling J 1647 [1641] Syntagma anatomicum. Pauli Frambotti Bibliopolae, Padua Latin
Riolan J 1663 [1648] Encheiridium anatomicum et pathologicum, in quo, ex naturali constitutione partium, recessus a Latin
naturali statu demonstratur: ad usum theatri anatomici adornatum. Casparum Meturas, Paris
Vesling J, Culpeper N 1653 The anatomy of the body of man. Peter Cole, London English [Latin]
Bartholin T 1668 [1662] Bartholinus anatomy; made from the precepts of his father, and from the observations of all English [Latin]
modern anatomists, together with his own. Nich. Culpeper and Abdiah Cole, London
Diemerbroeck I 1679 [1672] Anatome corporis humani. Joan. Antonij Huguetan, Lyon Latin
Gibson T 1682 The anatomy of humane bodies epitomized. T. Flesher, London English
Bidloo G 1685 Anatomia humani corporis, centum & quinque Tabulis. Joannis à Someren, Amsterdam Latin
© 2007 The Author
Diemerbroeck I, Salmon W 1694 [1689] The anatomy of human bodies; comprehending the most modern discoveries and curiosities in English [Latin]
that art. W. Whitwood, London
T. Sakai
Dionis P 1698 [1690] L’anatomie de l’homme, suivant la circulation du sang, & les dernieres découvertes. 3rd edn, French
Laurend d’Houry, Paris
Blancardus S, Peucerum T 1691 Reformirte Anatomie/oder Zerlegung des menschlichen Leibes/Gebauet auff die wahrhafftigsten German [Latin]
und neuesten Erfindungen dieser Zeit. Moritz Georg Weidmann, Leipzig
Verheyen P 1708 [1693] Anatomie oder Zerlegung des menschlichen Leibes. Thomas Fritschen, Leipzig German [Latin]
Browne J 1697 Myographia nova: or, a graphical description of all the muscles in humane body, as they arise in Latin
dissection. London
Munnicks J 1697 De re anatomica liber. Antonium Schouten, Utrecht Latin
Keill J 1698 The anatomy of the humane body abridges; or a short and full view of all the parts of the body. English
(1st edn, William Keblewhite, London, 1698)
Tauvry D 1701 A new rational anatomy, containing an explication of the uses of the structure of the body of man English
and some other animals, according to the rules of mechanicks. D. Midwinter, London
Dionis P 1703 The anatomy of humane bodies improv’d, according to the circulation of the blood, and all the English [French]
modern discoveries. Translated from the third edition, corrected and enlarged by the author, with an
ample dissertation upon the nature of generation; and several new systems. H. Bonwicke, London
Cheselden W 1713 The anatomy of the humane body. N. Cliff, and D. Jackson, London English
Lancisi JM 1714 Tabulae anatomicae clarissimi viri Bartholomaei Eustachii. Francisci Gonzagae, Rome Latin
Heister L 1719 [1717] Compendium anatomicum totam rem anatomicam brevissime complectens. 2nd edn. Bibliopolio Latin
Kohlesiano et Adolphiano, Altdorf and Nurnberg
Heister L 1752 [1721] A compendium of anatomy. In which all the parts of the human body are succinctly and clearly English [Latin]
described; and their uses explained. W. Innys and J. Richardson, London
Kulmus JA 1759 [1722] Anatomische Tabellen, nebst dazu gehörigen Anmerkungen und Kupfern. Caspar Fritschischen German
Handlung, Leipzig
Table 4. Continued
Cowper W 1724 Myotomia reformata or an anaotmical treatise on the muscles of the human body. Robert Knaplok, Latin
and William and John Innys, London
Winslow JB, Douglas G 1734 [1732] An anatomical exposition of the structure of the human body. London English [French]
Cowper W 1739 Anatomia corporum humanorum centum et quatuordecim tabulis. Joannem Arnoldum Langerak, Latin
Leiden
Baccheton HL 1740 Anatomia medicinae theoreticae et practicae ministra, cautelisque in praxi observandis illustrata. Latin
Ioannis Iacobi Cremeri, Nurnberg
Journal compilation © 2007 Japanese Association of Anatomists
Petrioli G 1741 Tabulae anatomicae a celeberrimo pictore Petro Berrettino Cortonensi delineatae. Antonio de Latin
Rubeis, Rome
Albinus BS 1747 Tabulae sceleti et musculorum corporis humani. J. & H. Verbeek, Leiden Latin
Douglas J 1750 Myographiae comparatae specimen: or, a comparative description of all the muscles in a man, English
and in a quadruped. A. Kincaid and G. Crawfurd, Edinburgh
Leber F 1778 [1772] Praelectiones anatomicae. Editio nova, ex Germanico traducta, correcta et aucta. Rudolphum Latin
Graeffer, Vienna
Leveling HP 1783 Anatomische Erklärung der Original-Figuren von Andreas Vesal. Anton Attenthouer, Ingolstadt German
Mayer JCA 1783 –1784 Beschreibung des ganzen menschlichen Körpers, mit den wichtigsten neuren anatomische German
Entdeckungen bereichert, nebst physiologischen Erläuterungen. in 3 vols. Georg Jacob
Decker, Berlin
Chaussier F 1789 Exposition sommaire des muscles du corps humain. Dijon French
Hildebrandt F, Weber EH 1830 –1832 [1789] Handbuch der Anatomie des Menschen. 4th edn in 4 vols. Schulbuchhandlung, Braunschweig German
Soemmering ST 1796 –1800 [1791] Vom Baue des menschlichen Körpers. 2nd edn, in 5 vols., Barrentrapp und Wenner, Frankfurt German
am Main
Vaughan W 1791 An exposition of the principles of anatomy and physiology. In 2 vols., G. G. J and J. Robinson, English
London
Wiedemann CRW 1812 [1796] Handbuch der Anatomie. 3rd edn, Bandenhoeck und Ruprecht, Göttingen German
Bell J, Bell C 1809 [1797] The anatomy of the human body. In 4 vols. Collins and Perkins, New York English
Mayer AM 1820 [1799] Anatomische Beschreibung des ganzen menschlichen Körpers. 4th edn, Carl Ferdinand, Wien, German
Bichat X 1801–1803 Traité d’anatomie descriptive. In 5 vols., Carbon and Brosson, Paris French
Portal A 1804 Cours d’anatomie médicale, ou élémens de l’anatomie de l’homme. In 5 vols., Baudouin, Laporte, French
Arthus Bertrand, Paris
Monro A 1813 Outlines of the anatomy of the human body, in its sound and diseased state. In 3 vols., Archibald English
Constable and Longman, Edinburgh
Meckel JF 1815 –1820 Handbuch der menschlichen Anatomie. In 4 vols., Hallische Waisenhauses, Halle German
Wistar C 1817 A system of anatomy for the use of students of medicine. In 2 vols. Thomas Dobson, Philadelphia English
Bock C 1842–1843 [1820] Handbuch der Anatomie des Menschen mit Berücksichtigung der neueseten Physiologie und German
chirurgischen Anatomie. In 2 vols., 3rd edn, Friedrich Volckmar, Leipzig
Horner WE 1823 Lessons in practical anatomy, for the use of dissectors. Edward Parker, Philadelphia English
Cloquet JG 1998–1999 [1825] Manuel d’anatomie descriptive du corps humain. In 5 vols. Louis Pariente, Paris French
75
Horner WE 1830 [1826] A treatise on special and general anatomy. 2nd edn in 2 vols., Carey & Lea, Philadelphia English
Cloquet H, Knox R 1828 A system of human anatomy. MacLachlan and Stewart, Edinburgh English [French]
Table 4. Continued
76
Author Year Title and publisher Language
Quain J 1828 Elements of descriptive and practical anatomy: for the use of students. W. Simpkin and English
R. Marshall, London
Lauth EA 1837 [1829] Nouveau manuel de l’anatomiste. 2nd edn, Société Belge de Librairie, Brussels French
Römer A 1831 Handbuch der Anatomie des menschlichen Körpers. In 2 vols., J. G. Heubner, Wien German
Cruveilhier, J 1851–1852 [1834] Traité d’anatomie descriptive. 3rd edn, in 4 vols., Labé, Paris French
Meckel JF, Jourdan AJL, Breschet G 1839 Manual of descriptive and pathological anatomy. In 2 vols., G. Henderson, London English [German]
Krause CFT 1841–1843 Handbuch der menschlichen Anatomie. 2nd edn, Hahn’schen Hofbuchhandlung, Hannover Geran
Journal compilation © 2007 Japanese Association of Anatomists
Wilson E, Goddard PB 1844 A system of human anatomy, general and special. 2nd American edn, Lea and Blanchard, English
Philadelphia
Hyrtl J 1863 [1846] Lehrbuch der Anatomie des Menschen mit Rücksicht auf physiologische Begründung und German
praktische Anwendung. 8th edn, Wilhelm Braumüller, Wien
Hyrtl J 1847 Handbuch der topographischen Anatomie, und ihrer praktisch medizinisch = chirurgischen German
Anwendungen. J. B. Wallishausser, Wien
Bock C 1850 Hand-Atlas der Anatomie des Menschen. 3rd edn, Renger’schen Buchhandlung, Leipzig German
Froriep R 1852 Atlas anatomicus partium corporis humani per strata dispositarum imagines in tabulis XXX. 4th Latin
© 2007 The Author
T. Sakai
Henle J 1855 –1871 Handbuch der systematischen Anatomie des Menschen. In 3 vols. Friedrich Vieweg und Sohn, German
Braunschweig
Meyer, GH 1856 Lehrbuch der physiologischen Anatomie des Menschen. Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig German
Quain J, Sharpey W, Ellis GV 1856 Elements of anatomy. 6th edn, in 3 vols. Walton and Marberly English
Quain J, Wilson WJE 1856 A series of anatomical plates; with references and physiological comments, illustrating the English
structure of the different parts of the human body. 4th edn, Samuel and William Wood, New York
Gray H 1858 Anatomy descriptive and surgical, J. W. Parker and Son, London English
Hilles MW 1860 The pocket anatomist: being a complete description of the anatomy of the human body, for the use English
of students. Lindsay and Blakiston, Philadelphia
Leidy J 1861 An elementary treatise on human anatomy. Lippincott, Philadelphia, English
Heitzmann C 1870 –1875 Die descriptive und topographische Anatomie des Menschen. In 2 vols. Wilhelm Braumüller, Wien German
Hollstein L 1873 Lehrbuch der Anatomie des Menschen. 5th edn, E. H. Schroeder, Berlin German
Pansch A 1886 [1881] Grundriss der Anatomie des Menschen. 2nd edn, Robert Oppenheim, Berlin German
Gegenbaur C 1883 Lehrbuch der Anatomie des Menschen. Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig German
Henke W 1888 Handatlas und Anleitung zum Studium der Anatmoie des Menschen im Präpariersaale. In 2 vols. German
August Hirschwald, Berlin
Testut L 1899 –1901 Traité d’anatomie humaine. 4th edn, in 4 vols., Octave Doin, Paris French
Poirier P 1892 Traité d’anatomie humaine. In 5 vols., Battaille, Paris French
Rauber A 1892–1894 Lehrbuch der Anatomie des Menschen. 4th edn, in 2 vols. Eduard Besold, Leipzig German
Schäfer EA, Thane GD 1894 –1899 Quain’s elements of anatomy. 10th edn, in 3 vols. Longmans, Green, and Co., London English
Language, square brackets indicate the language of original publication; year, square brackets indicate the year of first edition.
History of anatomical terminology 77
Table 5. Various descriptive terms for the carpal muscles in the 17–19th centuries
Type 1 Flexor/Extensor
Type 1a Flexor/extensor; superior/inferior
Latin Laurentius, 1623 [1600], Bauhin, 1605; Whitteridge, 1964 [Harvey’s manuscript 1616]
Type 1b Flexor/extensor; externus/internus
Latin: Casserio, 1627; Vesling, 1647 [1641]; Browne, 1697
English: Vesling, Culpeper, 1653
German: (Bock, 1842 [1820])
Type 2 Radieus/cubiteus
Type 2a Radieus/cubiteus; internus/externus
Latin: Riolan, 1608; Bartholin, 1651 [1641]; Riolan, 1663 [1648]; Bartholin, 1668 [1662]; Diemerbroeck, 1679
[1672]; Gibson, 1682; Bidloo, 1685; Blancardus and Peucerum, 1691; Munnicks, 1697; Keill, 1698; Tauvry,
1701; Lancisi, 1714; Heister, 1719 [1717]; Heister, 1752 [1721]; Kulmus, 1759 [1722]; Baccheton, 1740;
Petrioli, 1741
French: Dionis, 1698 [1690]; Sabatier, 1791 [1775]; Portal, 1804; Sappey, 1876–1879 (1st edn 1853)
English: Diemerbroeck and Salmon, 1694 [1689]
Type 2a-1 Radieus/cubiteus; internus/externus; longus/brevis
Latin: Dionis, 1703; Verheyen, 1708 [1693]
Type 2a-2 Radieus/cubiteus; internus/externus; longior/brevior
Latin: (Leidy, 1861)
Type 3 Radialis/ulnaris
Type 3a Radialis/ulnaris; internus/externus
Latin: Winslow & Douglas, 1734 [1732]; (Meckel, Jourdan & Breschet, 1839)
German: Leveling, 1783; Mayer, 1783 –1874; Meckel, 1815 –1820; Mayer, 1820 [1799]; (Bock, 1842 [1820]); Römer,
1831; (Krause, 1841–1843); Hyrtl (1863) [1846]; (Heitzmann, 1870 –1875)
Type 3a-1 Radialis/ulnaris; internus/externus; longus/brevis
Latin: Verheyen, 1708 [1693]; Vaughan, 1791; (Meckel, 1815 –1820); (Bock, 1842 [1820]); (Römer, 1831); Krause,
1841–1843; (Hyrtl, 1863 [1846]); Hyrtl, 1847; (Bock, 1850); Henle, 1855 –1871; Heitzmann, 1870 –1875;
(Gegenbaur, 1883); (Poirier, 1892–1904)
Type 3a-2 Radialis/ulnaris; internus/externus; longior/brevior
Latin: Albinus (1747); Leber, 1778 [1772]; Soemmering, 1796 –1800 [1791–1796]; (Mayer, 1820 [1799]); (Cloquet
& Knox, 1828); (Quain, Sharpey & Ellis, 1856); (Leidy, 1861)
Type 3b Radial/ulnar; anterior/posterior
French: Bichat, 1801–1803; Cloquet, 1998–1999 [1825]; Lauth (1837) [1829]; Cruveilhier, 1851–1852 [1834];
Poirier, 1892–1904; Testut, 1899 –1901 [1889 –1892]
Type 5 Irregular
Latin: Monro, 1813; (Meckel, Jourdan & Breschet, 1839)
French: Chaussier, 1789; (Poirier, 1892–1904)
German: Soemmering, 1796–1800 [1791–1796]
English: Leidy, 1861
Nickname
‘bicornis’: Bauhin, 1605; Riolan, 1608; Whitteridge, 1964 [Harvey’s manuscript 1616]; Riolan, 1663 [1648]; Browne,
1697; Gibson, 1682; Keill, 1698; Dionis, 1703
‘grand palmaire’: Bichat, 1801–1803; Cloquet, 1998–1999 [1825]; (Lauth, 1837 [1829]); Sappey, 1876–1879 [1853]; Testut,
1899 –1901 [1889 –1892]; Poirier (1892–1904)
*Literature in parentheses indicates the terms that were presented as alternatives, and not as main terms.
The extensor carpi radialis muscles were not re- International anatomical terminology
cognized as two distinct muscles, but as a single muscle
with two terminations by early authors since Fabrica In the face of diverse terminology in numerous anatomical
(Vesalius, 1543a) in which the muscle was described books, anatomists in the late 19th century became aware
as ‘divided into two horns (bicornis)’. The nickname that anatomical terms should be logically consistent,
‘bicornis’ for the extensor carpi radialis muscles was intelligible by themselves, clear in meaning and
widely used by authors in the early 17th century and compact in form. Otherwise the diverse terminology
later by some English authors. In the 19th century the would be difficult to teach and cumbersome to use
two extensor carpi radialis muscles were distinguished in research. Several authors of influential anatomical
either by the longus/brevis pair or by its comparative books in the late 19th century, including Henle (1855–
form longior/brevior. The longus/brevis pair was used 1871) and Gegenbaur (1883) in Germany (1876–1879)
mainly by German authors and the longior/brevior and Testut (1899–1901) in France and Quain (1828)
pair was used by English authors. in England, tried to make the anatomical terms
A few authors in this period proposed quite different logically consistent, intelligible, and uniform in style.
types of terms for the muscles. Chaussier (1789) Through these efforts it became apparent that a
invented origin–termination terminology for all the systematic list of terminology should be produced
muscles in the body. The five carpal muscles were by the cooperation of anatomists rather than by
called ‘épitroklo-métacarpien’, ‘cubito-carpien’, ‘huméro- individual efforts. The sequence of events leading up
sus-métacarpien’, ‘épicondylo-sus-métacarpien’ and to the establishment of Nomina anatomica in 1895
‘cubito-sus-métacarpien’. Monro (1813) proposed was documented in detail in the preface of Die
English forms of this terminology. The proposals were anatomische Nomenclatur: Nomina anatomica (His,
not accepted by other authors surely because of the 1895).
heavy burden to memory. It was obvious that without The cooperative plan of the anatomical terminology
precise knowledge of the origin and termination of was first outlined by Anatomische Gesellschaft of
the individual muscles one could not determine the Germany at its first meeting in Leipzig in 1887. After
names of the muscles. preliminary work headed by His for 2 years, a Com-
Another adventure in the terminology of muscles mission was appointed for preparation of uniform
is found in Leidy (1861). This American author truncated anatomical terms with von Kölliker as chairman, and
the multiple epithets into one. The five carpal muscles Hertwig, His, Kollmann, Merkel, Schwalbe, Toldt, Waldyer
were written as ‘radio-carpal flexor’, ‘ulno-carpal and von Bardeleben as members. As editor of the
flexor’, ‘longer radio-carpal extensor’, ‘shorter radio- Commission, Krause worked diligently to compile the
carpal extensor’ and ‘ulno-carpal extensor’. This type manuscript, while taking into account the many demands
of truncated terminology was later proposed by that were placed on the Commission from many indi-
another American anatomist when the international viduals. The Commission estimated the necessary funds
anatomical terminology was being planned by the at 10 000 marks. The keiserische/königliche Akademie
commission of the Anatomische Gesellschaft in the der Wissenschaft in Berlin, München, Wien, Budapest,
1890s. and the königliche Gesellschaft der Wissenschaft in
It is sufficient here to provide a tiny example of the Leipzig assisted the project.
tremendously diverse terminology after Bauhin at the During the project, the Anatomische Gesellschaft
beginning of 17th century and before the international made contact with anatomical societies of other nations.
anatomical terminology at the end of the 19th century. The Anatomical Society of Great Britain appointed a
Another example of diverse terminology in this period special commission in 1893 for the purpose of adapting
may be given for the terms of pineal gland. Eycleshymer suggestions by German anatomists to English needs.
(1917) enumerated 16 synonyms of the organ including The Society of American Anatomists made another
pineal body, parietal eye, epiphysis cerebri and penis proposal to use mononymous terminology such as
cerebri, and estimated the total number at 50 including ‘Medipedunculus’ for Pedunculus cerebellaris medius.
the French and German synonyms. The German commission adopted a part of the pro-
From these examples it would be obvious that the posals, but rejected the principle of mononymous
confusing diversity of anatomical terminology was terminology. As the project advanced, international
immense at the end of the 19th century, when the cooperation became enhanced with English, Italian
international anatomical terminology was planned by and Belgian anatomists, but not so with French ana-
German anatomists in cooperation with anatomists in tomists. Then the German commission officially invited
other European countries. The actual extent of the Duval and Testut to cooperate on the terminology.
diversity of the anatomical terminology in these periods However, Duval did not reply, and Testut demanded
has yet to be systematically investigated, and is far official appointment and invitation by the French
beyond the scope of the present study. Minister of Public Instruction to take part in the work
of Japanese style until the 1980s. The first Korean by the different terms and to facilitate communication
anatomical terminology was published in 1978 in of anatomical information, the international anatomical
Japanese style. In 1987, the Korean Association of terminology was established in Latin at the end of the
Anatomists commenced transforming the terminology 19th century by German anatomists. The current edition
into native Korean words, and published a new edition of international anatomical terminology is written both
of the terminology in 1990. The newest edition published in Latin and English, and in addition national anatomical
in 2005 incorporated English and Latin terminology terminologies have been published in some countries
in accordance with Terminologia anatomica. including Japan, Korea and China.
Veterinary science also required an anatomical Anatomical terms are very convenient tools for
terminology that was in part incompatible with that describing and identifying anatomical structures but
in the human anatomy. In particular, the terms indicating they have several disadvantages. Medical students
directions such as superior/inferior and anterior/posterior frequently feel that anatomical terms are a heavy burden
have different meanings between human beings in to their memory. The imaginative power of researchers
an upright position and animals in quadruped postures. desiring to uncover new significance in anatomical
The first attempt to establish the Nomina anatomica structures may be restricted by the specific terms
veterinaria began at the seventh International Veterinary themselves. I hope that the current review will help
Congress at Baden Baden in 1899 just after publication readers to appreciate both the advantages and short-
of the BNA. In the JNA in 1936, the terms for directions comings of our anatomical terminology, which is the
were related to the parts of the body such as cranial/ product of continual efforts of previous generations
caudal and ventral/dorsal, and were therefore accept- of anatomists.
able to veterinary anatomists. However, since the
PNA in 1955 reintroduced the old terms of direction References
related to the human standing position, the veterinary
anatomists began to prepare a terminology of veterinary Albinus BS (1747) Tabulae Sceleti et Musculorum Corporis
anatomy. The International Committee on Veterinary Humani. J. & H. Verbeek, Leiden.
Anatomical Nomenclature (ICVAN) was established Bauhin C (1590) De Corporis Humani Fabrica: Libri IIII. Sebas-
tianum Henricpetri, Basel.
in 1957, and published the first edition of Nomina
Bauhin C (1605) Theatrum Anatomicum Novis Figuris Aenis
anatomica veterinaria in 1968. The current fifth edition
Illustratum. Johan Theodor de Bry & Johan Israel de Bry,
of Nomina anatomica veterinaria is offered through
Frankfurt.
the home page of the World Association of Veterinary Brock AJ (1916) Galen on the Natural Faculties. Harvard
Anatomists (WAVA). University Press, Cambridge.
Chaussier F (1789) Exposition Sommaire des Muscles du Corps
Conclusion Humain. Chaussier, Dijon.
Cheselden W (1713) The Anatomy of the Humane Body. N. Cliff,
Anatomical terms are invaluable tools for dealing with D. Jackson and W. Innys, London.
structures of the human body, in the medical sciences. Colombo R (1559) De re Anatomica Libri XV. Nicolai Bevilacquae,
The usefulness of the anatomical terms is obvious when Venice.
Daremberg C (1854 –1856) Oeuvres Anatomiques, Physiologiques
one reads the anatomical texts by Galen (129–216)
et Médicales de Galien, in 2 Vols. Baillière, Paris.
in the Roman Empire. Galen wrote logically consistent
Duckworth WLH (1962) Galen: On Anatomical Procedures, the
and precise descriptions of the anatomical structures
Later Books. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
without specific terminology, and therefore his anatomical Eycleshymer AC (1917) Anatomical Names Especially the Basle
texts required sufficient anatomical knowledge on the Nomina Anatomica. William Wood, New York.
part of the readers and much effort to identify the Fallopio G (1561) Observationes Anatomicae. M. A. Ulmum, Venice.
anatomical structures and relations. Garofalo I (1991) Galeno Procedimenti Anatomici, in 3 Vols.
Anatomical illustrations greatly improved the re- Biblioteca Unversale Rizzoli, Milano.
cognition of anatomical structures. The precise artistic Garofalo I, Vegetti M (eds) (1978) Opere scelte di Galeno.
illustrations in Fabrica (1543) by Vesalius of Brussels Unione Tipografico-Editrice Torinese, Torino.
(1514–1564) stimulated investigations on the human Gegenbaur C (1883) Lehrbuch der Anatomie Des Menschen.
Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig.
body. In contrast, it soon became obvious that the
Goss CM (1961) On anatomy of veins and arteries by Galen of
ordinal terminology by Vesalius was insufficient, and
Pergamon. Anat Rec 141, 355 – 66.
Sylvius in Paris (1478–1555) and Bauhin in Basel (1560–
Goss CM (1962) On the anatomy of the uterus. Anat Rec 144,
1624) developed the descriptive terminology for the 77–83.
muscles, blood vessels and peripheral nerves. In the Goss CM (1963) On the anatomy of muscles for beginners by
17th, 18th and 19th centuries, many anatomists wrote Galen of Pergamon. Anat Rec 145, 477–501.
anatomical texts using different terms in Latin as well Goss CM (1966) On anatomy of nerves by Galen of Pergamon.
as in modern languages. To prevent confusion caused Am J Anat 118, 327–36.
Henle J (1855–1871) Handbuch der Knochenlehre des Menschen, Sakai T, Ikeda R, Sawai T (2006) Galen’s ‘On the anatomy of veins
in 3 Vols. Friedrich Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig. and arteries’ – translation from the Greek text and discussion.
His W (1895) Die Anatomische Nomenclature. Nomina Anatomica, Nihon Ishigaku Zasshi 52, 211–72 (in Japanese).
Verzeichnis der von der Anatomischen Gesellschaft auf Ihrer Sakai T, Ikeda R, Tsukisawa M (2003) Galen’s ‘On the anatomy
IX. Versammlung in Basel Angenommenen Namen. von Veit, of nerves’ – translation from the Greek text and discussion.
Leipzig. Nihon Ishigaku Zasshi 49, 403–54 (in Japanese).
Howell AB, Straus WL (1933) The muscular system. In: The Sappey PC (1876 –1879) Traité D’anatomie Descriptive Avec
Anatomy of the Rhesus Monkey (Macaca Mulatta) (Hartman Figures Intercalées Dans le Texte, 3rd edn, in 3 Vols. Adrien
CG, Straus WL, eds). Hafner Publishing, New York, 89 –175. Delahaye, Paris.
Huang Y (1989) Nomina anatomica. Cina Esperanto-Eldonejo, Sawai T, Sakai T (2005) Laurentius on anatomy. Nihon Ishigaku
Pekino (in Latin, English, French, Spanish and Chinese). Zasshi 51, 3–24 (in Japanese).
Kühn CG (1821–1833) Clavdii Galeni Opera Omnia, 20 Vols. Sawai T, Sakai T (2006) Gaspard Bauhin and nomenclature of
Cnobloch, Leipzig. muscles. Nihon Ishigaku Zasshi 52, 601–630 (in Japanese).
Kusayama Y (1998) Galen: On Natural Faculties. Kyoto University Simon M (1906) Sieben Bücher Anatomie des Galen: Zum
Press, Kyoto (in Japanese). ersten Male veröffentlicht nach den Handschriften einer
Laurentius A (1593) Opera Anatomica in Quinque Libros Divuisa. arabischen Übersetzung des 9. Jahrh. n. Chr. in 2 Vols. J. C.
Ioannis Baptistae, Lyon. Hinrichs’sche, Leipzig.
Laurentius A (1600) Historia Anatomica, Humani Corporis Singer C (1952a) Galen’s elementary course on bones. Proc
Partes Singulas Uverrime Enodans, Nobisquie Controversiis Roy Soc Med 45, 767–76.
& Observationibus Illustrata. Marcum Orry, Paris. Singer C (1952b) Vesalius on the Human Brain. Oxford University
Leidy J (1861) An Elementary Treatise on Human Anatomy. Press, London.
Lippincott, Philadelphia. Singer C (1956) Galen: On Anatomical Procedures. Oxford
Leveling HP (1783) Anatomische Erklärung der Original-Figuren University Press, London.
Von Andreas Vesal. Anton Attenthouer, Ingolstadt. Singer PN (1997) Galen Selected Works. Oxford University
Lind LR (1949) The Epitome of Andreas Vesalius. Macmillan, Press, Oxford.
New York. Singer C, Rabin C (1946) A Prelude to Modern Science Being a
May MT (1968) Galen: On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Discussion of the History, Sources and Circumstances of the
Body, in 2 Vols. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, USA. Tabulae Anatomicae Sex of Vesalius. Cambridge University
Mayer JCA (1783–1794) Beschreibung des Ganzen Menschlichen Press, Cambridge.
Körpers, Mit Den Wichtigsten Neueren Anatomischen Entdeck- Suzuki B (1895) Anatomical Vocabulary. Maruzen, Tokyo (in
ungen Bereichert, Nebst Physiologischen Erläuterungen, in Japanese).
8 Vols. Georg Jacob Decker, Leipzig. Sylvius J (1555) In Hippocratis et Galeni Physiologiae Partem
Monro A (1813) Outlines of the Anatomy of the Human Body, in Anatomicam Isagoge. Ioannem Hulpeau, Paris.
its Sound and Diseased State, in 3 Vols. Archibald Constable, Testut L (1899 –1901) Traité D’anatomie Humaine, 4th edn, in 4
Edinburgh. Vols. Octave Doin, Paris.
Nakahara S (1994) The Epitome of Vesalius. Nankodo, Tokyo (in Töply RR (1903) Geschichte der Anatomie. In: Handbuch der
Japanese). Geschichte der Medizin, 2nd Vol (Puschmann TH, ed.).
Ninomiya R (1998) Galen: Natural Vital Forces. Hirakawa Publishing, Gustav Fischer, Jena, 155 –326.
Tokyo (in Japanese). Tsuchiya M (1997) Galen’s own bibliographical introduction ‘My
Persaud TVN (1997) A History of Anatomy: The Post-Vesalian own books’ – introduction, translation and annotations. Bull Meiji
era. Charles C Thomas, Springfield, USA. Pharmaceutical University [Humanities and Social Sciences]
Platter F (1583) De Corporis Humani Structura et Usu Libri III. 28, 31– 60 (in Japanese).
Froben, Basel. Valverde del Amusco J (1556) Historia de la Composicion del
Quain J (1828) Elements of Descriptive and Practical Anatomy: Cuerpo Humano. Antonio Salamanca and Antonio Lafrerij,
for the Use of Students. W. Simpkin and R. Marshall, London. Rome.
Richardson WF, Carman JB (1998) On the fabric of the human Vesalius A (1538) Tabulae Anatomicae Sex. J. S. Calcarensis,
body. Book I, the Bones and Cartilages. Norman Publishing, Venetia.
San Francisco. Vesalius A (1543a) de Humani Corporis Fabrica Libri Septem.
Richardson WF, Carman JB (1999) On the fabric of the human Ioannes Oporinus, Basel.
body. Book II, the Ligaments and Muscles. Norman Publish- Vesalius A (1543b) Suorum de Humani Corporis Fabrica Librorum
ing, San Francisco. Epitome. Ioannes Oporinus, Basel.
Richardson WF, Carman JB (2002) On the fabric of the human Whitteridge G (1980). Bauhin, Gaspart. In: Dictionary of Scientific
body. Book III, the Veins and Arteries; Book IV, the Nerves. Biography (Gillispie CG ed.). Scribner, New York.
Norman Publishing, Novato. Wright J (1924) Galen on the organ of smell. Laryngoscope 34,
Riolan J (1608) Schola Anatomica Novis et Raris Observationibus 1–11.
Illustrata. Adrianum Perier, Paris.