Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aa 425 Ca 5
Aa 425 Ca 5
Aa 425 Ca 5
DESIGN
AWARDS RECOGNIZING DESIGN EXCELLENCE
AND CONSTRUCTION QUALITY WITH PRECAST CONCRETE
2021
SPECIAL
PCI DESIGN AWARDS
2
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
SPECIAL
PCI DESIGN AWARDS
JURY
Marvin Hartsfield
PRESIDENT, HARTSFIELD & ASSOCIATES, SPRINGBORO, OHIO
Marvin Hartfield formed Hartsfield & Associates in 2005, where he provides consulting services
to building owners, architectural design and construction professionals, and precast concrete
producers/manufacturers. His firm has consulted on numerous architectural precast concrete
cladding projects throughout the United States.
Prior to opening his own firm, Hartsfield began his career in architectural precast concrete in 1978
as a design engineer for Concrete Technologies Inc. Over the years he worked on hundreds of
projects, moving steadily up the ladder. He was eventually elected president and chief operating
officer of the company.
Hartsfield has been an active member of PCI for more than 40 years. He has a bachelor’s degree
in civil engineering and a master’s degree in civil/structural engineering from the University of
Cincinnati.
He assists project stakeholders in the visioning of project goals and expectations, and helps build
consensus in finding solutions that best fit client needs and budgets. A collaborative leader, Knop
has demonstrated a successful history in coordinating project design and engineering teams
while actively managing budgets and work plans on $200,000 to $75 million projects.
Knop is a member of the American Institute of Architects. He has a bachelor’s degree from the
University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee and is a LEED-accredited professional.
Bob Konoske
RETIRED VICE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL MANAGER, CORESLAB STRUCTURES LA, PERRIS, CALIF.
Bob Konoske worked for 46 years in the precast concrete industry. He started his industry work
with Rockwin Corporation, where he held many positions and ultimately became vice president
and part owner. Rockwin was acquired by Coreslab Structures in 1995, and Konoske stayed on as
vice president and general manager of Coreslab Structures LA until his retirement.
During his career, he served on many PCI committees. He spent six years on PCI’s Board of Direc-
tors and was chair in 2007. He is also a PCI Fellow.
Konoske has a bachelor’s degree from California State University–Long Beach and a graduate
degree from the University of Southern California. After graduation, he joined the Army National
Guard and served for six years.
2021
2021 ESCONDIDO VILLAGE
GRADUATE RESIDENCES
PALO ALTO, CALIFORNIA
ALL-PRECAST CONCRETE
SOLUTION AWARD Stanford University is a world-class institution that requires world-class
housing for its students. But in 2017, the campus was facing a housing shortage
AND MULTI-FAMILY that strongly affected its 9000 graduate students. Only 55% of postgrads were
able to secure on-campus housing, and more than 1000 were living in off-campus
BUILDING COWINNER accommodations subsidized by the school. The high cost and rapidly rising rents in
the area were creating financial stress for many students that the university want-
ed to solve.
The solution was to build four graduate housing buildings with 665 two-bed-
room apartments, 517 premium studios, and 292 junior studio apartments. The
structures would increase the university’s on-campus graduate housing rate to ap-
proximately 75%, while also providing computer labs, activity spaces, and laundry
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES facilities for students.
To meet the owner’s goals, the designers had to align their vision with several
❚ More than 6700 windows aesthetic and structural requirements. The new buildings had to conform to campus
were installed in the precast
concrete plant.
standards for unit size, dimensions, and layout, and they had to mimic the tradition-
al architecture of the campus. But they also had to use durable, cost-effective, and
❚ Choosing precast concrete helped
designers cut six months from easy-to-maintain materials, and be built while school was in session, to accommo-
the schedule. date the next round of graduate students arriving in 2020. The architect chose pre-
❚ Off-site fabrication resulted in cast concrete to address all of these requirements and worked closely with the pre-
65,000 fewer worker-days on cast concrete producer to accelerate results.
the jobsite, reducing dust,
pollution, and safety hazards.
“To complete the project on time, the entire design and construction team need-
ed to begin detailed coordination efforts very early in the design process,” says Ted
PROJECT AND PRECAST Korth, design principal for KSH Architects. His team notes that many complex de-
CONCRETE SCOPE cisions had to be made early on—“most sooner than a conventional project.”
❚ Build four campus housing For example, every penetration through the precast concrete floor system (over
structures totaling 1,835,000 ft². 14,000 in total) needed to be sized and located at a very early stage of design so the
❚ The project used more than precast concrete producer could begin production. All window openings and sizes
14,000 precast concrete panels
as well as detailed profiles for the exterior structural wall system also needed to be
produced at three local plants.
determined very early on. “All of these early decisions enabled manufacturing and
❚ All four buildings were
completed in 11 months. erection of the building to proceed at a very rapid pace, with extremely high quality
control,” Korth says.
in the design process.” ARCHITECT: Korth Sunseri Hagey Architects (KSH), San Francisco, Calif.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: John A. Martin & Associates, Los Angeles, Calif.
— Ted Korth, KSH Architects GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Vance Brown, Palo Alto, Calif.
PROJECT SIZE: 1,835,000 ft²
4
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Bernard Andre.
EDWARDS INDUSTRY beautiful, durable, and highly energy-efficient precast concrete package.
“The customer was initially skeptical that a beautiful building could be designed
ADVANCEMENT AWARD and built with precast concrete,” says Allen Finfrock, chief executive officer of Fin-
frock, the designer, precast concrete producer, and contractor for the project. The
owner also wanted to lower financial risk on the project while accelerating con-
struction to meet a tight timeline. “Getting the building design right—and within a
specified time frame—was critical to their strategic plan,” Finfrock says.
The design team used building information modeling (BIM) software and Fin-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES frock’s proprietary precast concrete products to prove that precast concrete could
deliver the beautiful structure they envisioned, and so much more.
❚ The use of BIM software reduced The project team started by creating a virtual plan using BIM. “By designing the
errors and accelerated progress.
project virtually in 3-D [three-dimensional] software, we answered questions and
❚ Subsystems were produced and instilled confidence that the customer would get the building he wanted within the
installed using laser-guided
technology to enhance budget he required,” Finfrock says.
precision. The team showed the owner how using a precast concrete building system
❚ Rapid erection gave would allow rapid erection of the structure, giving subcontractors early access to
subcontractors early access safely begin their work. Precast concrete also suited the minimal staging area of
to safely begin work.
the extremely tight jobsite and made it easier to integrate all of the subsystems,
Finfrock says.
PROJECT AND PRECAST As an added benefit, the nearly soundproof nature of precast concrete construc-
CONCRETE SCOPE tion not only blocks the steady stream of noise from nearby traffic and road con-
❚ Build a seven-story, 268-unit, struction but also provides a more resilient solution than other material options.
multi-family housing project. “Resiliency is always a concern for developers in central Florida,” Finfrock says.
❚ The project featured
a total–precast
concrete solution.
BIM-DRIVEN INNOVATION
Once the client was convinced and the project was official, Finfrock’s team created
❚ The complex opened 11 months
after breaking ground. every precast concrete component using 3-D modeling software, allowing design-
ers to eliminate manufacturing and construction conflicts by integrating the struc-
tural and subsystems into one common model. “Conflicts were noted and solved
in the model by project designers rather than in the field,” he says. This approach
eliminated errors and change orders in the design phase and considerably reduced
6
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
the on-site construction time as well as disruptions to sur-
rounding properties.
The design team coordinated with subtrades so the elec-
trical, plumbing, and heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning
could be manufactured in the plant within Finfrock’s pro-
prietary DualDeck Building System. The designers used 3-D
modeling software to combine design files into one space
for clash detection and to locate all penetration locations
required though the elements. As the structure was mod-
eled, the information was fed into the product manage-
ment software, PieceTracker, to manage and oversee pieces
Photos: Finfrock.
and erection plans.
During production, lasers were used to locate partition
layouts, and the product shipped to the site with lines for
field-installed partitions already indicated on the product.
This sped up construction and reduced on-site labor, Fin-
frock says. Biweekly meetings with all subtrades kept every-
one’s plans aligned.
2021
2021 COUNTY ADMINISTRATION
SOUTH – BUILDING 16
SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA
SUSTAINABLE
When Orange County decided to build a new building as part of the OC Civic
DESIGN AWARD Center in Santa Ana, Calif., they wanted it to be more than just another office
center. The owner saw the building as an opportunity to enhance the community,
says Deryl Robinson, vice president, senior program and construction manager, for
Griffin Structures. It was the first building Orange County had built in 40 years, and
they wanted it to reflect the elegant local architecture, which was dominated by a
120-year-old historic courthouse clad in natural sandstone.
“Our team’s challenge was to design and construct a building that combined
high quality, durability, and a long life with minimal maintenance,” Robinson says.
From the outset, the primary design objective was to create a beautiful and resil-
ient building that would be efficient and operational for generations to come. The
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES designers chose precast concrete because they knew it would deliver the desired
durability and timeless appearance that the client was seeking—while staying
❚ Integral colored precast concrete within their budget.
emulates the rich red color of
historic sandstone.
The final $162 million design features a six-story office building on top of two
levels of underground parking, with a freestanding 7200 ft² conference center. The
❚ Spray foam insulation applied to
thin shell precast concrete at the owner originally wanted the feature walls to be made of sandstone to match the
plant enhances energy efficiency. courthouse; however, that wasn’t a cost-effective option, says the project’s archi-
❚ The project was completed five tect, Melody Tang of LPA Design Studios. Instead, the design team elected to con-
months ahead of schedule. struct the feature walls out of colored precast concrete that was designed to ex-
actly match the color of the sandstone while also meeting other project goals.
“The ability to seamlessly blend freestanding architectural precast concrete walls
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE around the site and ground floor with an efficient, lightweight, thin precast con-
❚ Build a six-story office crete shell was critical in achieving the overall design aesthetic,” Tang says.
building and freestanding
conference center above a
two-level underground
INSULATED SKIN
parking structure. The design team reviewed many material samples with the precast concrete fabri-
❚ The project features
cator before finding the right match for the project. The final solution features an
306 precast concrete panels. integral colored precast concrete to emulate the rich red color of the historic sand-
❚ The project was completed stone, and thoughtful detailing of mitered corners and full returns of the panels
in two years. gives the precast concrete the appearance of natural stone.
8
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: LPA Inc. and RMA Photography.
2021 BUILDING
RETAIL BUILDING
16 Texas Health Frisco – New Bed Tower 44 Churchill Downs Colonnade and
HEALTHCARE/MEDICAL BUILDING AND
SUSTAINABLE DESIGN AWARD HONORABLE MENTION Infield Gate
CUSTOM SOLUTION
18 Boston College Recreation Center 60–69 Honorable Mentions
HIGHER EDUCATION/UNIVERSITY BUILDING
22 Clybourn 1200
MULTI-FAMILY BUILDING COWINNER
10
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
BUILDING
PCI DESIGN AWARDS
JURY
Timothy Cullen
VICE PRESIDENT, BLUE RIDGE DESIGN , INC., WINCHESTER, VA.
Timothy Cullen is vice president at Blue Ridge Design, where he is responsible for leading the de-
sign of precast concrete structures from inception to completion. Cullen has more than 13 years
of experience in the design, detailing, construction, maintenance, and renovation of precast con-
crete structures. He has worked on the structural design of a wide variety of structures, including
parking structures, bridges, food processing plants, dormitories, data centers, and architectural
cladding for multistory buildings.
Cullen is an active member of PCI, and currently serves on the Joint and Connection Design and
Industry Handbook committees. He attended Lehigh University, where he earned a bachelor of
science degree in civil engineering and a master of science degree in structural engineering.
Monty Overstreet
VICE PRESIDENT AND CO-OWNER, FDG, INC., BRIGHTON, COLO.
Monty Overstreet is vice president and co-owner of FDG, which provides planning and conceptual
design of precast concrete structures, and provides design, detailing and project-management ser-
vices to owners, developers, architects, and precast concrete producers. Overstreet has 30 years of
experience in precast concrete construction and has been a major contributor to some of the larg-
est precast concrete construction projects throughout the United States.
For the past 21 years he’s served in a variety of roles with FDG, and has worked on a several high-pro-
file projects, including the Maricopa County Courthouse in Phoenix, and the Burns & McDonnell
Corporate Campus parking structure in Kansas City. Most recently, he managed the precast con-
crete design for the $1.5 billion PennFIRST Patient Pavilion in Philadelphia, slated to open in 2021.
Overstreet earned a bachelor of science degree in architectural engineering technology from the
University of Southern Mississippi. He has served on several nonprofit boards and has been selected
to the board of trustees for the PCI Foundation starting in 2021.
Cheryl L. Rishcoff
PROJECT ENGINEER, TRC WORLDWIDE ENGINEERING, INC., ALLENTOWN, PA.
Cheryl L. Rishcoff has had a long career in the precast concrete industry. As a consultant and en-
gineer with TRC, she oversees a staff of design engineers in Allentown, as well as in Bangalore and
Mysore, India, to ensure every project is completed correctly, within budget, and on schedule. Her
responsibilities also include periodic visits to jobsites to observe construction, prepare cost esti-
mates, and oversee preparation of design packages. On many projects she is the engineer of re-
cord for the precast concrete elements, signing off on all drawings and calculations.
Rishcoff is a long-time member of PCI, and has served on a number of committees, including the
Professional Members Committee, Building Codes, Parking Structures, and the Fire Committee.
She is currently serving on PCI’s Board of Directors as a professional member director.
Rishcoff has a bachelor’s degree in civil and environmental engineering from Lafayette College,
where she graduated magna cum laude.
2021
2021 DC BLOX
BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA
DC Blox’s bold purple accent walls are just a small part of what makes this
precast concrete building special. The 31,000-ft² structure will become the cen-
DATA CENTER terpiece for the DC Blox technology and innovation campus, giving employees a
state-of-the-art center to do their work.
The new building includes 18,000 ft² of “white space,” allocated for servers and
other information technology equipment, and another 13,000 ft² of office space,
conference rooms, workstations, and common areas. It features a fully protected
private network and 5 MW of customer capacity—all in a building designed to with-
stand 150-mph winds.
The decision to use precast concrete was central to achieving the project’s many
aesthetic and structural goals. “With security and reliability being of the utmost
importance, precast concrete was the clear first choice for both the building enclo-
sure and structure,” says Charles J. O’Brien III, president of Pieper O’Brien Herr Ar-
chitects.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES From the start, the designers knew they wanted to create a building that would
convey a sense of strength and security, while also meeting considerable structural
❚ The precast concrete shell requirements.
provides blast security ratings and Both goals were accomplished with precast concrete serving as the primary
the ability to withstand
150-mph winds. structure and focal building component. “Satisfying blast-rating and wind-load re-
❚ A light brush blast provided a
quirements are inherently right in precast concrete construction’s sweet spot,”
paintable surface for bold colors. O’Brien says. “The ability to combine the architectural fenestration, the necessary
❚ Ready-to-erect panels sped blast and storm resistance, the insulation, and the fire resistance into a single
completion. manufactured, ready-to-erect wall panel, was a clear demonstration of the effi-
ciency of precast concrete construction in this project.”
PROJECT TEAM:
“With security and reliability
being of the utmost importance, OWNER: DC Blox, Atlanta, Ga.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Gate Precast Company, Monroeville, Ala.
precast was the clear first choice
PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Midwest Structure Engineering, West Allis, Wis.
for both the building enclosure ARCHITECT: Pieper O’Brien Herr Architects, Alpharetta, Ga.
and structure.” ENGINEER OF RECORD: LBYD, Birmingham, Ala.
— Charles J. O’Brien III, GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Brasfield & Gorrie, Birmingham, Ala.
Pieper O’Brien Herr Architects PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: Precision Stone Setting Company, Hiram, Ga.
PROJECT COST: $10 million
PROJECT SIZE: 31,000 ft²
12
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: DC Blox.
PUBLIC BUILDING would use the building to simulate a wide range of emergency conditions, which
often requires creating or using voids in the structure to release heat and smoke
and find means of escape.
This meant designers would have to be extremely thoughtful in how they could
create an adaptable three-story structure within a safe, highly resilient envelope.
The architect conducted an early study of the tools used by emergency workers,
which informed the design from the beginning and helped the architect imagine
the structure as a training tool. Through that analysis, the team determined that a
total–precast concrete solution was the best choice because it provided robust and
durable material that would be ideal to withstand the wear and tear of the training
scenarios.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES “In addition, being fire-resistant was critical in the use for training of the compa-
ny that is utilizing the building,” says Sean Dixon, vice president of construction for
❚ Precast concrete provides a High Concrete Group.
fire-resistant structure to run
complex rescue simulations.
The precast concrete producer’s early involvement in the planning process
helped the designers achieve the right mixture proportions and alignment of hol-
❚ Insulated sandwich panels have
an R-value of R-16, which improves low-core, double tees, and single tees for the flooring, which was key to ensuring
the thermal efficiency of the the right distance of the stem of the tees throughout the building. It also helped
building envelope. them align where and how much terracotta could be placed as accent elements to
❚ Building information modeling the precast concrete.
was used to coordinate
trades on the busy jobsite
to meet the tight schedule. SAFE HAVEN
The three-story building is organized around two large interior voids and enclosed
by precast concrete insulated sandwich wall panels that are strategically punc-
PROJECT AND PRECAST tured by windows and openings. The interior voids and façade openings enable the
CONCRETE SCOPE
rescue teams to practice common urban emergency situations, like high angle bal-
❚ Build a three-story fire rescue
facility in a busy Brooklyn cony rescues and entering a smoke-filled manhole, while boldly highlighting the
neighborhood. building’s function as a crucial piece of civic infrastructure.
❚ The project included 95 “Custom precast concrete panels provided a modern look while achieving en-
precast concrete elements. hanced durability,” Dixon says. “And with an R-value of R-16, the insulated sandwich
❚ Precast concrete erection was
completed over two months.
PROJECT TEAM:
“Being fire-resistant was critical
in the use for training of the OWNER: Fire Department of New York Facilities Management, Long Island City, N.Y.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: High Concrete Group, Denver, Pa.
company that is
ARCHITECT: Studio Gang, New York, N.Y.
utilizing the building.”
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Thorton Tomasetti, Chicago, Ill.
— Sean Dixon, GENERAL CONTRACTOR: ZHL Group, Brooklyn, N.Y.
High Concrete Group PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: JEMCO Erectors, Inc., Shamong, N.J.
PROJECT COST: $32 million
PROJECT SIZE: 22,000 ft²
14
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: High Concrete Group.
2021
2021 TEXAS HEALTH FRISCO –
NEW BED TOWER
FRISCO, TEXAS
HEALTHCARE/
MEDICAL BUILDING AND Most people think of hospitals as the place you go when you are sick or in-
jured. But what if these healthcare centers became destinations for wellness,
SUSTAINABLE DESIGN where the community could go to learn practices that would help them lead health-
AWARD HONORABLE ier lives? And if so, what would that structure look like? These were the questions
that inspired the design of Texas Health Frisco’s New Bed Tower in Frisco, Tex.
MENTION The owners wanted to create a center that could act as a “health facilitator” for
the community, providing better outcomes by connecting healthcare staff, fami-
lies, patients, and the model of care to the surrounding natural environment. That
vision was part of every decision made in the design of the new eight-story hospi-
tal, four-story medical building, and attached parking structure—including the use
of precast concrete to bring it to life.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES “With respect to degree of difficulty, this project certainly ranks as one of the top
ten most challenging for Gate Precast Texas,” says Norm Presello, senior project
❚ Panels feature three different manager for Gate Precast Company.
colored concrete mixture designs
along with four different finishes.
The City’s planning and development guidelines required an exterior natural ma-
sonry material for the project, and several systems were considered, including
❚ A “file-to-fabrication” workflow
enabled team members to push brick, natural cut stone, ceramic panels and, precast concrete.
ideas forward and manage The designers thought precast concrete was the best choice; however, building
budgetary parameters in officials had concerns that a precast concrete design would be perceived as a
the digital file.
cheap-looking material. To convince them, the designers had detailed mock-up
❚ The design-assist process cut 2%
of the precast concrete budget, and
samples created to show how the natural concept and biophilia aesthetic could be
a month from the construction manifested in the surface treatments, aggregates, mixture coloring, and patterns
schedule compared with a of the precast concrete.
traditional design-bid-build
project.
After demonstrating how precast concrete could deliver the sophisticated look
and feel that the city was requesting, along with considerable time and cost sav-
ings, precast concrete was accepted for the project.
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE CUES FROM NATURE
❚ Create a nature-inspired façade The designers wanted the façade to feature natural patterns of biophilic design.
for this healthcare facility.
The exterior skin of the building played a crucial role in telling that overall story,
❚ The project included 902
precast concrete elements.
says Presello. “Precast concrete was selected as the best material to represent the
design narrative at the pedestrian and building scale, and reinforced the overall
❚ Precast concrete installation
began in May 2018 and finished concept.”
in October 2018.
the design required adjustment of member dimensions or To ensure successful erection, designers worked with the
anchorage configurations and the analysis was repeated. erection crew to review plans for bracing and stability, as
“This unique situation resulted in pre- and post-tension- well as the sequencing of all grouted and welded connec-
ing not typically seen in a precast product and a complex tions. Large shoring towers were put in place to support
reinforcement design that had to fit in a relatively small bents and the double-tee roof while welding and post-ten-
footprint of the precast columns and bents,” Haley says. sioning of members were completed. The towers were not
The decision to use precast concrete also aided in con- removed until the concrete topping slab was installed on
struction through the winter months, explains Scott Long top of the double-tee framing.
of Prime Steel Erection. “Forming, pouring, and win- “It was a very challenging project where we had to think
ter-heating for cast-in-place construction versus precast outside the box,” Long says. “But the final product came
erection would have had negative impacts on schedule and out great, which is very rewarding.”
appearance.”
2021
2021 THE PEYTON HOUSE AND
OCEAN HOUSE, PONTE VEDRA
HOTEL/MOTEL INN & CLUB
PONTE VEDRA BEACH, FLORIDA
BUILDING
The Ponte Vedra Inn & Club has been a landmark destination on Ponte Vedra
Beach for nearly 100 years. But the owners wanted to update the setting with a
modern-day addition to the AAA Five Diamond–rated resort.
The plan was to add two new three-story structures with 41 beachfront guest
rooms and suites, each of which would have a sweeping view of the ocean. The
owners wanted a façade that matched the resort’s historic brick, as community
expectations and acceptance of the finished product were critical to the project’s
success.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES The challenge: the designers had to complete both structures before the next
tourist season, while keeping nearby facilities operational throughout construction.
❚ The choice of precast concrete Those demands caused the architect to replace their original plan to use a com-
saved the owner $700,000 and the
project was completed four
bination of cast-in-place, concrete masonry, brick, and precast concrete with an
months early. all–precast concrete solution. “Precast concrete was the only material that ad-
❚ The precast concrete system can dressed all of the challenges of this project,” says Michael Ramsey, president of
withstand storm surges, high Architectural Design & Planning Group.
winds, and salty sea air. Along with helping to meet the aggressive schedule, using precast concrete
❚ Use of precast concrete allowed made it easier to erect the buildings on the constricted beachfront site, which had
thinner walls and floors systems,
maximizing ocean frontage.
limited access for materials and labor. And it provided a resilient structure that
exceeded all wind-load requirements and could withstand the salt, humidity,
storm surges, and high winds that buffet these oceanside properties.
PROJECT AND PRECAST “Precast concrete gave us a material that would provide superior acoustical,
CONCRETE SCOPE thermal, moisture, and fire-protection benefits,” Ramsey says. “And it allowed for
❚ Build two three-story structures precision construction in a very challenging and competitive construction labor
with 41 beachfront guest rooms
and suites. market.”
❚ The project included 43,713 ft² of
hollow-core and solid slabs and NINE WEEKS VERSUS ONE YEAR
72,434 ft² of spandrels and Construction of the buildings began in January 2019, and erection went quickly.
wall panels.
Precast concrete work on the north building was completed in five weeks and on
❚ Total–precast concrete erection the south building in six weeks. By overlapping the two projects, the entire precast
was completed in just nine weeks.
concrete erection time took nine weeks total, compared with the estimated
20
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Gate Precast Company.
12 months that would have been required for traditional and the owners’ desire for a brick exterior matching the rest
masonry construction. “These compressed construction of the resort. But he was wrong, he says. “Precast concrete
schedules allowed earlier access for follow-along trades, proved to be the perfect material and satisfied all of the
and ultimately earlier owner occupancy,” says Tom New- design criteria without significant compromise in our aes-
ton, vice president of operations for Gate Precast Company. thetic intent.”
There were challenges along the way, but the precast con- “Total–precast concrete is a viable and potentially
crete producer proved the material’s resilience through an cost-saving option for any large residential project,” New-
innovative, collaborate approach to the design. That includ- ton adds. “Total–precast concrete construction reduces the
ed matching the new precast concrete buildings with the overall construction duration, resulting in earlier owner oc-
brick on the existing cast-in-place structures in the complex, cupancy, and dramatically reduces the number of on-site
while simultaneously reducing cost and erection times. trades and personnel.”
Ramsey admits that originally he didn’t think precast
concrete was a viable solution due to the complex layout
2021
2021 CLYBOURN 1200
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
Chicago’s Near North Side was once home to Cabrini Green, a vast housing
project that was notorious for violence and neglect. In 2000, the Chicago
MULTI-FAMILY Housing Authority began demolishing those towers and replacing them with more
BUILDING COWINNER modern, durable, and family-friendly homes.
The latest addition to this transformation is Clybourn 1200, a 157,000-ft² mixed-
use, mixed-income redevelopment project that leverages precast concrete to pro-
vide a resilient, sustainable living and working space for the entire community.
The project includes a combination of retail, parking, and residential options
within a tight triangular site located in a busy section of the city. The building exte-
rior material also had to be cost-effective, durable, and low-maintenance.
The designers had originally considered a brick and metal design, but precast
concrete quickly emerged as the better choice. “The use of precast concrete start-
ed as a cost-savings strategy,” says Michael Henning, associate with Pappageorge
Haymes Partners.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES Once the decision was made to use precast concrete, his team reimagined the
original design. “As part of the adaptation, ownership expressed an interest in us-
❚ The decision to build an entirely ing the material honestly and not disguising it,” Henning says. That led to the evo-
precast concrete solution resulted lution of the aesthetic.
in vibrant revitalization on a
restricted budget.
❚ The project earned two Green LIKE AN OPEN BOOK
Globe awards for exemplary The new design uses precast concrete to create a book-shaped massing for the
sustainable design. seven-story building featuring an acute angle to fit the nontraditional infill site.
❚ Using a single precast concrete The “spine” of the book, which is located at the narrowest point on the lot, includes
system and provider for the full-height glazing with a steel and glass canopy providing a backdrop.
structure and enclosure led to
cost and time savings. The exterior panels and columns use different planes of relief with features that
are either light acid-washed or sandblasted and, with the exception of selected
accent areas that are stained dark, the surface is untreated. Window units punctu-
PROJECT AND PRECAST ated with bright contrasting color and alternating orientation from floor to floor
CONCRETE SCOPE play up movement in the elevation and reduce the building mass. The glassy, open
❚ Build a cost-efficient, mixed-use,
seven-story building on Chicago’s base, accented by contrasting colored precast concrete piers and banding accents,
Near North Side. provides an active and engaging street presence.
❚ The project included 1600 precast
concrete pieces.
❚ Erection was completed
in 16 weeks.
PROJECT TEAM:
OWNER: Brinshore Development, Northbrook, Ill., and
the Michaels Organization, Chicago, Ill.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: ATMI Precast, Aurora, Ill.
“As part of the adaptation,
PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Precast Engineering Company, Brookfield, Wis.
ownership expressed an interest in ARCHITECT: Pappageorge Haymes Partners, Chicago, Ill.
using the material honestly ENGINEER OF RECORD: Matrix Engineering Corporation, Chicago, Ill.
and not disguising it.” GENERAL CONTRACTOR: McShane Construction Company, Rosemont, Ill.
— Michael Henning, PROJECT COST: $35 million
Pappageorge Haymes Partners PROJECT SIZE: 157,000 ft²
22
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Henning’s team chose a single precast concrete system
and provider for the structure and enclosure to achieve cost
and time efficiencies with a durable and attractive solution.
They gained many benefits by combining structural and ar-
chitectural elements, adds Mike Walsh of ATMI. “We were
able to fabricate architectural components that act as the
exterior load-bearing frame for the building.”
Because the building footprint is pushed to the lot lines
along two sides, the project team faced significant staging
and erection constraints, and they had to come up with an
innovative access system for parking. To accommodate ac-
cess to the parking structure, the precast concrete produc-
er designed a precast concrete ramping system that ex-
tends beyond the footprint, allowing the architect to
maintain the parking stall count. Photos: Pappageorge Haymes Partners.
To minimize traffic disruption during construction, they
positioned a single large crane inside the V-shaped site to
set the entire building. “On-site, the simultaneous assem-
bly of structure and enclosure kept costs down with a tight,
controlled schedule,” Henning says.
“It does not look like a precast concrete structure at the
first glance,” Walsh adds. “The colors are very vibrant and
accented with depth of structure, and you have to look hard
to see the subtle differences.”
2021
2021 ONE SOUTH FIRST
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK
One South First in Brooklyn, N.Y., is a new mixed-use building that promises
to redefine waterfront living. Overlooking the East River, the 42-story residential
MIXED-USE BUILDING tower and 22-story commercial tower have transformed the property, which was
AND HARRY H. EDWARDS once home to an old sugar factory. The new owners saw the potential for luxury liv-
ing on the site, and they wanted a façade that would maximize the waterfront views.
INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT The architect envisioned a contemporary façade that was inspired by sugar’s
AWARD HONORABLE crystalline structure as a way to connect the new building with the industrial histo-
ry of the site.
MENTION “That brought us to the idea of dealing with sugar,” says Pam Campbell, partner
at CookFox and designer of the project. “We were interested in creating a façade
that would really be animated, but reminiscent of the reflection and form of sugar
crystals.”
They used precast concrete to bring that idea to life.
The precast concrete façade features repetition of angled white precast concrete
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES using interlocking panels with deep facets to create a play of light and shadow that
animates the rigorous forms. Designed to self-shade, each elevation is formed to
❚ Use of 3-D printed molds and respond to its specific solar orientation and optimized to reduce energy use for
Revit software expedited cooling. “It offers a unique opportunity to prioritize energy efficiency through the
panel production.
complementary energy profiles of different uses,” says Steve Schweitzer, vice pres-
❚ Nearly 2500 windows were
installed at the precast concrete ident of operations for Gate Precast Company.
plant, cutting eight months from The window openings were deep-set and the sides were faceted back at different
the schedule. angles to catch the light and show the sparkle of the glitter sand used in the
❚ The molds could support acid-etched white concrete. The front faces of the panels were polished to give a
more than 200 pours smooth, reflective surface to complement the acid-washed surface. The layout of
without reconditioning.
the molds in the panel were varied throughout the building to give an appearance
of randomness.
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE TWO HUNDRED POURS PER MOLD
❚ Create a façade with maximum Along with helping designers achieve their aesthetic goals, using precast concrete
waterfront views for a 42-story
residential building and 22-story for this façade delivered considerable time and cost savings.
commercial tower. To create the façade, the precast concrete producer used three-dimensional (3-D)
❚ The project included 1593 precast printed molds in a process known as additive manufacturing. The 3-D printed
concrete panels. forms made it possible to rapidly produce a large number of panels with window
❚ Erection occurred from August openings.
2018 through February 2020.
PROJECT TEAM:
“It offers a unique opportunity to OWNER AND GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Two Trees Management Co. LLC, Brooklyn, N.Y.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCERS: Gate Precast Company, Winchester, Ky., and
prioritize energy efficiency through Gate Precast Company, Oxford, N.C.
the complementary energy PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Gate Precast Company, Jacksonville, Ark.
profiles of different uses.” ARCHITECT: CookFox, New York, N.Y.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Rosenwasser/Grossman Consulting Engineers, New York, N.Y.
— Steve Schweitzer,
PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: E. E. Marr Erectors, Baltimore, Md.
Gate Precast Company
PROJECT SIZE: 462,000 ft²
24
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Gate Precast Company and Kumar.
2021
2021 PEABODY PLAZA
NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE
On a sunny day, Peabody Plaza looks more like a painting than a structure.
The 290,000-ft² office building’s façade uses an artistic combination of patterned
OFFICE BUILDING precast concrete panels, brick, and glass, to create an ever-changing reflection of
the surrounding city.
The new building and adjoining park replaced a 250-space parking lot on a bluff
overlooking the Cumberland River, giving the community greater access to the
views and nature surrounding the site.
Initially, designers planned to use a glass curtainwall system for the project, but
instead shifted to a window wall supported by a precast concrete framework. “We
chose precast concrete as the spandrel panel primarily to allow the design team
the opportunity to mold the panels to the desired shape and for the flexibility in
color and finish,” explains Chuck Gannaway, principal at Hastings.
Precast concrete also brought “affordability, durability, and interesting finish col-
ors and textures,” notes Chris Cruze, project manager for Gate Precast Company.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
A GOOD RIBBING
❚ Coordination of shared cranes The façade design is a nod to the adjacent historic trolley barns. The concept re-
ensured multiple subcontractors quired precast concrete spandrels and columns covered with a 6-in. trapezoidal
could sequence their work.
projection that runs the length of each piece and aligns to the adjacent spandrels,
❚ Six-inch rib extrusions on
spandrels created depth in column covers, or both. The shapes extend to all-glass corners at both the south-
the façade pattern. east and northwest corners to denote major entry locations. The main floor of the
❚ 75% of the precast concrete building on the southeast corner has structural columns wrapped in polished pre-
was polished. cast concrete.
The depth of the projections was accentuated by lightly acid-etching the rib
component, leaving its finish lighter and homogenous, while deeply polishing the
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE larger adjacent back body faces. The polishing reveals a Tennessee black granite
❚ Replace an aging steel office aggregate to create a darker, more reflective contrasting face.
space and parking lot with a The tight jobsite resulted in limited staging areas, causing alternating loads to
vibrant 10-story building, buried be stored in different locations. “Our shipping departments excelled in overcoming
parking structure, and pocket park.
these challenges, which allowed for a continuous flow of product to the project
❚ The project included 483 precast site, allowing the installer to complete the installation in an expeditious manner,”
concrete elements.
Cruze says. To add further efficiencies, the precast concrete producer produced the
❚ Precast concrete production and
erection was completed in architectural precast concrete panels at two of its prefabrication facilities, which
10 months. involved very detailed communication and timing between both facilities’ shipping
departments and the erector.
2021
2021 PENN STATE HERSHEY MEDICAL
CENTER PARKING GARAGE
HERSHEY, PENNSYLVANIA
ALL–PRECAST CONCRETE
PARKING STRUCTURE When owners of the Penn State Hershey Medical Center decided to add a
four-story, 1235-space parking structure to their rapidly expanding medical
center campus, they wanted it to be eye-catching. “It would be set within the
context of an architecturally significant campus, so it had to complement and en-
hance the materiality already established,” says Amy Luchun, principal at Lamar
Johnson Collaborative.
But at the same time, it had to fit within the cost, schedule, and technical re-
quirements of the project. The architects used precast concrete to tackle all of
these goals.
“Precast concrete was our best option among the materials we proposed for the
façade of this project,” says Dohyoung Kim, associate at Lamar Johnson Collabora-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES tive. “It was the most economical solution that provided flexibility to meet the
various design challenges we would face.”
❚ Three-dimensional curved Finding inspiration in the landscape, the designers took advantage of the fluidity
spandrels reflect Pennsylvania’s and versatility of precast concrete to create a three-dimensional (3-D) design that
rolling hills.
mimics the rolling hills and flowing rivers of Pennsylvania’s topography. The total–
❚ Designers used Rhino and
Tekla tools to meet exact precast concrete design features a series of 3-D wave spandrels that flow across
weight requirements. the sides of the parking structure in four levels. On each level, the panels merge
❚ The 8-ft overhang cantilever together at central points, then cascade away to create a natural flow in both the
entrance was created in two pours design and the way light and air moves throughout the building.
to accommodate its massive depth. Three 8-ft cantilevered concrete overhangs at the stair tower entrances were
incorporated to allow more light to fill the structure, creating a safe and pleasant
PROJECT AND PRECAST user experience. The overhangs offer a canopy to protect patrons from rain and
CONCRETE SCOPE snow, while adhering to the flowing design aesthetic.
❚ Build a 1235-space, four-story,
all–precast concrete parking
structure with room for expansion.
NO FINS REQUIRED
To achieve the waved design while staying within budget goals, the design team
❚ The project included 771 total found ways to maximize forms, while keeping engineering stability in check and
pieces of precast concrete.
minimizing design changes. Significant cost savings were achieved by reducing the
❚ Erection was completed
in four months. number of unique molds from 72 to 8, and by increasing the bay size using larger
double tees.
28
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: High Concrete Group.
However, these changes resulted in concerns about the Luchun notes that the designers initially thought they
weight of the massive panels. The precast concrete produc- would have to adhere metal panels and fins to the façade to
er had to stay within a 100,000-lb limit, which they did by bring the design to life, but found that precast concrete al-
using a Grasshopper script in Rhino and Tekla tools to con- lowed them to meet all of their design goals while provid-
stantly monitor the weight of the panels. In some cases, ing the structural purpose of a parking structure. “The
they hollowed out certain panels to reduce weight and to eye-catching waving spandrels are now the first element to
make space for internal systems. greet visitors who drive onto the health campus,” she says.
“The natural features of precast concrete allowed us to The project was completed in January 2020, and, as an
control size, weight, and center of gravity to meet challeng- unexpected benefit, the parking structure was used as a
ing requirements for transportation and for lifting and drive-through COVID-19 testing site, she adds. “With the
swinging the pieces into place,” Kim says. Within the park- larger bays and well-lit area, it was a perfect location that
ing structure, glass-wall stairwells reflect light through the also provided a safe space to tend to their community.”
space, casting shadows off the spandrels that complement
the landscape seen through the open spaces. The addition
of wood soffits built into the precast concrete canopy en-
trance further reflects nature in the surroundings.
2021
2021 UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA
PARKING DECK
TUSCALOOSA, ALABAMA
FAÇADE-ONLY
PARKING STRUCTURE The new seven-story parking structure at the University of Alabama looks
more like a state-of-the-art library than a place to park your car. The neoclas-
sical architecture and brick-and-limestone design were specifically chosen to mimic
the century-old buildings that cover the university’s campus, and to give the struc-
ture a feeling of strength and permanence.
“The University of Alabama prides itself on the architectural beauty and history
of its largely neoclassical campus,” says Neil King, president and chief operating
officer of Evan Terry Associates.
From the outset, designers wanted the building to blend with that neoclassical
style but knew it wouldn’t be easy. King notes that this architectural style features
many ornate elements, including balustrades, cornices, parapets, and entabla-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES tures, which require strict adherence to proportion and scale. In the past, these
architectural elements were hand-carved from limestone and similar materials,
❚ Precast concrete helped designers but that approach would be unaffordable in today’s world.
deliver intricate details with a “To that end, we were able to take advantage of the precision, consistency, and
cost-effective and resilient
material. economy of precast to exactly replicate classical details rendered to proper classi-
❚ Rapid installation met the cal proportions,” King says. Choosing precast concrete allowed them to achieve
owner’s strict construction the strict design goals with a cost-effective, extremely durable, and low-mainte-
deadlines. nance product.
❚ The precast concrete producer
was able to exactly replicate the
neoclassical design that is common
EXCEEDING EXPECTATIONS
across the campus. The structural frame of the parking structure is cast-in-place concrete. That frame
was then hung with precast concrete panels to form the highly detailed building
envelope. The precast concrete producer used thin-brick veneer to exactly replicate
PROJECT AND PRECAST the brick appearance on the upper floors, and sandblasted panels with limestone
CONCRETE SCOPE accents on the lower levels.
❚ Create a detailed neoclassical
façade for this seven-story Each mold was designed to replicate the classical details, while adhering to
parking structure. proper classical proportions. Both the brick wall panel molds and sandblasted pan-
❚ The project included 517 pieces of el molds included multiple window spacings, which required additional molds and
precast concrete. modifications.
❚ Erection of the precast concrete
façade was completed in
four months.
PROJECT TEAM:
“The University of Alabama prides OWNER: MBA, Inc., Birmingham, Ala.
itself on the architectural beauty PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Gate Precast Company, Monroeville, Ala.
and history of its largely PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Gate Precast Company, Springboro, Ohio
ARCHITECT: Evan Terry Associates, Birmingham, Ala.
neoclassical campus.”
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Bailey Harris Construction, Auburn, Ala.
— Neil King, PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: SE Precast Erectors, Roswell, Ga.
Evan Terry Associates PROJECT SIZE: 511,800 ft²
30
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Along with meeting the design goals, using precast con-
crete helped the project team meet the strict delivery sched-
ule, which was built around the school’s academic calendar.
“The inherent efficiency and rapid installation of precast
concrete was vital in helping us to meet, or even exceed, the
university’s expectations,” King says. The precast concrete
erection process was completed in four months, ending in July
before the start of the school year. It marks the completion of
phase one of this multiphase project to provide on-campus
living space, food service, and parking for university students,
King says. “The owner loved the rapid and timely completion Photos: Gate Precast Company.
of the project, and how well this new parking deck blends
seamlessly with the university’s design aesthetic.”
2021
2021 ASSEMBLY ROW BLOCK 6
PARKING GARAGE
SOMERVILLE, MASSACHUSETTS
HYBRID PARKING
STRUCTURE The new seven-story Assembly Row parking structure in Somerville does
more than offer weary shoppers a place to leave their cars. The building replac-
es a formerly contaminated industrial site, providing an anchor structure that will
play a key role in transforming the city center into an urban destination, connecting
community, commerce, and mass transit.
The structure was part of a larger project to build the city’s tallest building and
connect it to adjoining residential structures. While the complete structure took
three years to construct, the project owners wanted to fast-track the precast con-
crete parking structure, and they needed an experienced precast concrete design
and construction team to help make it happen.
They partnered with Unistress, whose team worked closely with the project
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES owner to streamline the design process and rein in costs. “Partnering with the pre-
cast concrete producer upfront through real-time design and BIM [building infor-
❚ Fast-track erection of the parking mation modeling] resulted in the elimination of redundancies and the reduction of
structure concurrent with other conflicts in drawings and change orders,” says Steve Callahan Jr., vice president of
site activities shortened the
project schedule. business development for Callahan Construction.
❚ The use of precast concrete Through the close collaboration, the teams identified value-engineering oppor-
helped the project earn LEED tunities worth roughly $8 million during the preconstruction phase alone. “We
gold certification. were able to resolve many complex engineering and façade issues early in the de-
❚ Value engineering delivered sign phase, generating significant cost and schedule savings,” says Perri Petricca,
roughly $8 million in savings. chief executive office of Unistress Corporation.
34
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: www.toddlandryphotography.com
and Milton J. Womack, Inc.
36
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Gate Precast Company.
2021
2021 SMITHFIELD MIDDLE SCHOOL –
GYMNASIUM ADDITION
NORTH RICHLAND HILLS, TEXAS
SCHOOL BUILDING (K-12)
In Texas, hurricanes and dangerous storms are a constant threat. To mitigate
these risks and keep the community’s most vulnerable citizens safe, Smithfield Mid-
dle School in North Richland Hills wanted to build a larger storm shelter that would
provide a safe space for students, faculty, and the community.
Thanks to a bond package passed in 2018, all independent school district campus-
es in the area received funding to build shelters, and the designers of this shelter
knew early on that precast concrete was the best choice.
“Immense wind and debris loads associated with storm shelters create unique
structural design challenges,” notes Nick Heinlen, project engineer for Dunaway As-
sociates. “Selecting a structural system requires a balance of many factors, espe-
cially for a gymnasium where uninterrupted clear space is critical.” Precast concrete
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES would give them the highly resilient structure they needed within the prescribed
budget, and it would create minimal site disruption while the school was occupied.
❚ Twelve-inch wall panels and
48-in.-deep double tees can
withstand an EF5 tornado.
ONE HUNDRED-FOOT ROOF SPANS
To meet wind and debris load requirements, the designers used long-span (103 ft
❚ Lightweight precast concrete
double tees allowed roof spans 9 in.) roof double tees to support superimposed live loads of 100 lb/ft² for debris
greater than 100 ft. loading. They also added a 260 lb/ft live load for a roll-up dividing curtain located
❚ It is now one of the largest storm at midspan of the double tee. Dead and collateral loads consisting of 4-in. topping
shelters in North Texas. at 150 lb/ft³ were spread throughout the roof.
The combination of 12-in.-thick wall panels and 48-in.-deep double tees makes
this storm shelter capable of withstand an EF5 tornado (the highest rating on the
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE Enhanced Fujita scale of tornado intensity). “Lightweight precast concrete double
❚ Build a 23,000-ft2 storm tees provided a solution that allowed for greater than 100-foot roof spans, mini-
shelter to hold 1000 people. mized structure depth, and provided space for the installation of mechanical
❚ The project included 70 equipment,” Heinlen says.
precast concrete elements.
❚ Erection was completed
in just five days.
38
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Eric Childs, Key Construction.
2021
2021 GLOBE LIFE FIELD, HOME
OF THE TEXAS RANGERS
ARLINGTON, TEXAS
STADIUM AND
ARENA STRUCTURE The Texas Rangers are a 60-year-old Major League Baseball team that needed
a new home. In 2016, the team announced they would build a brand new stadium
through a public/private partnership between the City of Arlington and the Rang-
ers. The new 1.7 million-ft² 41,000-seat ballpark would provide a permanent site
for home games, as well as a multipurpose sports and entertainment venue for the
community.
Designers originally wanted to use hand-laid brick for the north façade. Howev-
er, the contractor emphasized early on that 100% hand-laid brick would not be
possible with the construction schedule.
As an alternative, they split up the brickwork, using precast concrete on the ex-
terior of the façade and hand-laid on the interior. They selected a thin-brick version
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES of the same full brick that was being used throughout the ballpark and cast them
into the precast concrete column wrap units, which were eventually lifted into
❚ Thin-brick inlays mimic the place and hung from the steel structure.
appearance of hand-laid brick “From the start of design, Fred Ortiz [of HKS] challenged us to ‘think outside the
at a fraction of the cost.
box’ on the finishes for the exterior of the non-brick-clad areas,” says John Arehart,
❚ A distressed travertine look was
achieved by incorporating three vice president of the architectural division for Enterprise Precast Concrete.
finishes in 1-in. increments The design team ultimately selected a distressed finish that simulates aged
within the panels. travertine by incorporating three finishes at varying widths and depths within a
❚ The retractable roof rolls onto a 15 × 30 ft panel. “The level of exterior texture gave the façade a travertine look, but
steel frame with decorative in more monolithic, large, random blocks,” says Fred Ortiz, director of sports and
thin-brick precast concrete arches.
principal at HKS. “Instead of being consistent, it was consistently inconsistent, and
that worked for the betterment of the project.”
PROJECT AND PRECAST Because the masonry in the north arcade was part of the same arch element,
CONCRETE SCOPE the precast concrete producer had to work closely with the masonry company
❚ Build a 1.7 million-ft² baseball and the contractor to ensure that similar masonry color and coursing comple-
field for the Texas Rangers.
mented the hand-laid brick on the interior face of the arches for a cohesive aes-
❚ The project included approxi- thetic. “The precast concrete brick-clad columns and arches now read as one
mately 114,000 ft² of finished
precast concrete. singular element, thanks to the collaborative efforts of the design and construc-
❚ Precast concrete erection was tion teams,” Arehart says.
completed from October 2018
through April 2019.
40
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Enterprise Precast Concrete and Jacia Phillips | Arch Photo KC.
RETRACTABLE ROOF
One of the most important features in the design is a mas-
sive retractable roof that can be opened and closed based
on the weather. In the old stadium, extreme heat or rain
were often cited as reasons why attendance was lower than
in other baseball stadiums. The retractable roof, which rolls
onto a steel frame with decorative thin-brick precast con-
crete arches, solved this issue, Arehart says. “The roof in-
troduces a fully climate-controlled atmosphere, a first of
its kind in a Major League Baseball facility.”
To meet the tight schedule, which was set to accommo-
date the 2020 baseball season, the project team was able
to speed erection through the shared use of cranes and hav-
ing the precast concrete set overnight to avoid conflicts
with other trades. A second PCI-certified producer was
brought in to provide 1650 structural components in the
stadium, including risers, raker beams, columns, beams,
and interior structural walls. Cooperation and collabora-
tion between the two different precast concrete producers,
who are typically competitors in this market, was essential
to the project’s success.
As a result, the project was delivered on time, and was
tapped to host the 2020 World Series, but because of the
pandemic, the fans haven’t yet had a chance to experience
the beauty of this new ballpark. “Sitting in the empty stands
… is a strange experience,” Ortiz says. “You hear so many
more nuances of the game, like voices, and the clear crack
of the bat. But we are all ready for baseball to be back.”
2021
2021 ACADEMY MUSEUM
OF MOTION PICTURES
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA
THEATER STRUCTURE
The new Academy Museum of Motion Pictures in Los Angeles was created to
celebrate the art and science of movies—past, present, and future. And what
better way to do that than to create a structure that looks like it could have rolled
off the set of a Star Wars movie?
The project involved the exterior restoration and interior gut renovation of a
230,000-ft² historic landmark structure, with the addition of a 60,000-ft² spheri-
cal glass and concrete structure to house the 1000-seat David Geffen theater. The
150-ft-diameter precast concrete sphere appears to float above ground, offering a
whimsical counterbalance to the more sedate renovated historic structure.
The sphere was originally conceived as a cast-in-place concrete shell, but as the
design evolved, it became clear that cast-in-place was not the right solution.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES “Spherical formwork would have been prohibitively expensive for carpenters to
fabricate and assemble on-site,” says Daniel Hammerman, architect for Renzo Pia-
❚ Precast concrete panels were no Building Workshop. “Precast concrete allowed for better and more cost-effec-
used as permanent formwork to tive finish quality and tighter tolerances and geometry control to ensure a perfect
support structural concrete during
installation. sphere.”
❚ Countless unique connection Because the sphere features a consistent radius, the project required only 30
brackets allowed installers to base molds, which could be reused many times with only minor adjustments of
adjust each panel from behind to edge forms and blockouts. The use of precast concrete also allowed the large,
correct global positioning.
column-free space, providing unobstructed sightlines for the theater in the round,
❚ A consistent radius allowed as well as providing the physical mass necessary for acoustic isolation of the
molds to be reused many times
with only minor adjustment of high-performance theater.
edge forms and blockouts. Initially, designers were concerned that precast concrete would not be able to
deliver the desired variation in the finish. “Precast concrete tends to prize a consis-
tent, uniform look of factory-made cladding panels,” says Hammerman. However,
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE the precast concrete producer generated multiple samples and mock-ups to ulti-
❚ Renovate a historic museum and mately define the best technique to achieve the intended finish appearance. The
add a massive spherical precast final design used a standard gray cement and a single aggregate to produce all of
concrete addition. the panels.
❚ The project included 727 total Rather than using a typical sandblasted finish, which erases all the flaws but also
panels cast on 30 base molds. the character, they opted for an “as-cast” finish to impart a luminous surface qual-
❚ Precast concrete erection ity. “The gentle sheen on the soffit panels above the plaza brings fantastic daylight
took 26 months.
and reflections underneath the mass of the sphere, helping create a wonderfully
welcoming public plaza,” Hammerman says.
42
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Willis Construction Inc.
2021
2021 CHURCHILL DOWNS
COLONNADE AND INFIELD GATE
LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY
CUSTOM SOLUTION
Churchill Downs is one of the most iconic sports venues in the country. Thou-
sands of guests pour through its gates every year to watch the Kentucky Derby and
other world-famous horse races.
In 2017, the owners decided they wanted to add a colonnade wall to the famous
park, to increase security and create better pedestrian flow in and out of the race-
track. The new colonnade and gate would have to match the signature architecture
of the site, with its historic details and grand scale.
“The biggest challenge we faced was creating an authentic design for such an
iconic racetrack and historical grounds that would include complex classical de-
tailing in a cost-effective, feasible installation,” says Kelly Kerns, senior principal at
Populous.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES He notes that while the primary facility is dominated by white brick, the site has
incorporated many materials and detailing in later additions, including an exterior
❚ The finishes combine embedded
thin brick and white concrete with
insulation and finish system, wood, and brick. “The variety of materials presented
an acid-etched finish to match the a challenge to our design team, and we quickly realized that precast concrete with
historic look of the racetrack. inlaid brick provided the optimum solution,” Kerns says.
❚ Back-to-back precast concrete Choosing precast concrete also accommodated the project’s tight time frame,
spandrels were cast separately and says Steve Schweitzer, vice president of operations for Gate Precast. “The schedule
welded together in the plant to
achieve a unified, two-sided for this project revolved around million-dollar horses and the racetrack’s meet
appearance. schedules,” he says. “Since this racetrack is only open for racing 75 days out of the
❚ Crane work couldn’t begin until year, all on-site construction had to be completed between the meets.”
after 10:00 a.m. to avoid spooking The construction crews also had to abide by strict sound requirements while
the horses, requiring a just-in-time
approach to panel delivery.
they were on-site. “During construction, noise had to be controlled while the hors-
es were training, which meant no loud cranes until after 10:00 a.m.,” Schweitzer
notes. To accommodate that restriction, his team scheduled a small crew to pro-
PROJECT AND PRECAST vide just-in-time delivery and installation of the pieces to meet the tight deadline.
CONCRETE SCOPE
❚ Build a colonnade and gate at the
historic Churchill Downs Racetrack.
TWO-FACED
The project was completed in two phases to ensure all construction could be com-
❚ The project included 950 precast
pleted in the winter and early spring months. Design and bidding for each phase
concrete elements.
was completed before the Fall Meet at the racetrack so that construction could
❚ Both phases of construction were
completed in winter and early begin promptly at the end of November.
spring around meet events.
44
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Gate Precast Company.
Prior to joining the FHWA, Holt was a senior project manager with T.Y. Lin International. He is a
registered professional engineer and has a bachelor’s and master’s degrees in civil engineering
from the University of Maryland.
Bijan Khaleghi
STATE BRIDGE DESIGN ENGINEER, WASHINGTON STATE
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION OLYMPIA, WASH.
Bijan Khaleghi is a state bridge design engineer with the Washington State Department of Trans-
portation and adjunct faculty member at Saint Martin’s University, where he is a lecturer on
civil engineering.
Khaleghi is a member of AASHTO Technical Committees T-8 Movable Bridges, T-10 Concrete,
and T-20 Roadway Tunnels. He is a member of the PCI and ASBI bridge committees and chairs
the PCI Seismic Design subcommittee. His committee work also includes the Transportation
Research Board (AFF30 Concrete and AFF50 Seismic) and the World Road Association, PIARC.
He is the recipient of IBC, PCI, ASCE, SEI, and T.Y. Lin awards.
Khaleghi received his master’s degree and doctorat in engineering from the National Institute of
Applied Sciences in France.
Myers’s unique blend of experience in structures and architecture, combined with his knowledge
of the construction industry, has resulted in the design of award-winning structures recognized
for their aesthetic value, constructability, and economy. He is a registered professional engineer
and a former Florida-certified general contractor.
Myers chaired the PCI Committee on Bridges and the Girder Stability sub committee, and is a
member of the Transportation Activities Council. He has a bachelor of science degree in architec-
tural engineering and a master of science degree in civil engineering from the University of Miami.
2021
2021 REPLACEMENT OLD EASTON
ROAD BRIDGE OVER PINE RUN
PLUMSTEAD TOWNSHIP, PENNSYLVANIA
BRIDGE WITH A MAIN SPAN
UP TO 75 FEET (23 M) In 2019, Old Easton Road Bridge in Plumstead Township had to be replaced.
Its past several inspections showed increasing scour issues and deterioration of the
main load-carrying members, indicating it was becoming structurally deficient.
The township wanted to replace the original two-lane bridge with a more robust
design, but they were limited by permit requirements and other restrictions that
prevented widening the roadway. The township also had a limited budget, which
further constrained the design team, says William Castle, founder and president of
W.J. Castle, P.E. & Associates.
“The biggest challenge was to design the bridge within the township’s limited
budget and timeframe,” Castle says. “This included construction considerations,
such as maintaining the existing under-clearance, and saving what we could on the
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES old bridge, while ensuring the design was able to handle the required load ratings.”
The original bridge was a single-span concrete T-beam structure founded on
❚ Seven precast concrete box
beams were installed in two days.
stone masonry abutments. The age, foundation type, and bottom of footing ele-
vations were unknown, and no original drawings or records of the bridge were
❚ New bridge abutments were
installed behind existing ones to available.
avoid extra permits. It left many questions unanswered, but Castle had worked with precast concrete
❚ The original stone abutments and on many previous projects and he knew it would help his team to address all of
wingwalls now function as scour these challenges.
protection.
48
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: Richard Parisi.
2021
2021 CR 661/BLACKHALL
ROAD OVER RUM CREEK
HENRY COUNTY, GEORGIA
BRIDGE WITH A MAIN
SPAN FROM 76-149 FEET Like many bridges built in the 1960s, the original Blackhall Road bridge over
Rum Creek in Georgia didn’t meet modern design standards. It was narrow,
(23 TO 45 M) with a substandard vertical curve, and showing signs of wear. The Georgia Depart-
ment of Transportation (GDOT) wanted a bigger and better bridge that would
meet the community’s needs with minimal disruption to the flow of traffic.
That’s where problems arose. The original plan was to close the road for nine
months while a replacement was built. However, that generated a local uproar in
the community, causing the project team to rethink their design and reduce the
closure time to just two months. They came up with a hybrid precast concrete
solution using accelerated bridge construction (ABC) techniques to create the new
195-ft two-lane bridge with 2-ft travel lanes and 8-ft shoulders.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
HYBRID DESIGN SOLUTION TO SITE CONSTRAINT ISSUES
❚ ABC construction cut road closure
time from 9 months to 60 days.
Because the jobsite is tight due to a nearby dam and homes, the design team came
up with a plan to use American Association of State Highway and Transportation
❚ The bridge deck was cast on-site
over AASHTO precast concrete Officials (AASHTO) precast concrete bulb-tee beams as the base of the bridge,
bulb-tee beams. then to cast the bridge deck on top of them at designated staging areas on-site.
❚ Casting the deck on-site “It was the first project in Georgia to use a hybrid concept of using precast con-
eliminated profile management crete beams and precasting the deck in an on-site lay-down area while maintaining
issues due to differential cambers
in decked bulb tees.
the traffic on the existing bridge,” says Dexter Whaley, bridge design ABC liaison for
GDOT.
By casting the deck in place at the project site, the common problem of profile
PROJECT AND PRECAST management created by differential cambers in precast concrete decked bulb tees
CONCRETE SCOPE was eliminated. False bents that matched the vertical profile and cross slope of the
❚ Build a 195-ft bridge over proposed bridge superstructure were fabricated to make construction work.
Rum Creek in Georgia.
This method allowed the bridge superstructure to be constructed before closing
❚ The project included 15 AASHTO
the road. “It was an innovative use of precast concrete that allowed us to reduce
precast concrete bulb-tee beams.
the duration of the road closure and impact to the public from months to weeks,”
❚ The project was completed
in two months. says Kevin Kahle of CHA Consulting.
Once the roadway was closed, the existing bridge was demolished and the new
permanent bridge foundations and substructures were constructed. After the sub-
structure was completed, the deck girders were transported and erected on the
permanent bridge substructures using an 800-ton-capacity crane. Steel dia-
phragms were used as both temporary bracing for the initial deck pour in the stag-
50
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
ing yard, then they were reinstalled and the bridge edge
beams and end-walls were formed and cast with 24-hour
concrete. Wood formwork and foam were used to create
block outs for the 9-in. closure pour between the precast
concrete decked beam unit.
When the deck was fully cured, the skim pour was
chipped out and the foam and wood forms were removed.
The skim pour created cross-slope continuity across the
deck that would not require additional grinding to achieve a
consistent deck surface between each decked beam unit.
In the final phase of construction, 9-in. closure strips
were poured using ultra-high-performance concrete, and
the deck was ground to remove minor undulations. After
grooving and completion of the roadway approaches, the
road was reopened to traffic on schedule, after a closure of
only 60 days.
“The use of precast concrete for this project demonstrat- Photos: CHA Consulting Inc. and CW Matthews Contracting Co.
ed how it is possible to use the standard AASHTO precast
concrete beams that were readily available from the Geor-
gia fabricators to develop an accelerated bridge construc-
tion solution that allowed the bridge to be completed in
under 60 days,” says Jim Aitken of CHA. “This solution did
not require any specialty contractors or equipment, and
other than the use of a few special details and the ul-
tra-high-performance concrete closure pours, it was con-
structed like any other bridge in the GDOT inventory with
the same durability and maintenance expectations.”
2021
2021 ROCKINGHAM I-91 BRIDGES
24N AND 24S – IM 091-1(66)
ROCKINGHAM, VERMONT
BRIDGE WITH A MAIN
SPAN MORE THAN In Rockingham, Vt., there were two bridges over the Williams River that were
falling into disrepair. They were built in the 1960s and were not designed to with-
150 FEET (46 M) stand the increasing flow of traffic in the region. An engineering study around 2015
determined that the most cost-effective solution was to replace both bridges.
When the owners put out a call to engineers for proposals, HDR’s team consider
five possible design options, laying out the benefits and challenges of each. They
ultimately chose an innovative precast concrete design using pretensioned bulb-
tee beam segments that are post-tensioned together.
“A high-level cost analysis of each option showed that the four-span, spliced
precast concrete girder alternative was the least costly, and best met their means
and methods,” says Thomas French, senior project manager and office leader for
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES HDR. He notes that the girders are designed for a 100-year life span, exceeding the
typical 75-year standard service life for bridges in the area. The design includes us-
❚ Precast concrete girders
weigh up to 186,920 lb.
ing high-performance 9000-psi concrete, and stainless steel for any projecting
steel.
❚ The girders have a lifecycle of
more than 100 years—25 years The project owner agreed that precast concrete was the best choice. “Precast,
more than the standard service life prestressed concrete provides great long-term durability as well as reduced main-
of bridges in this region. tenance efforts over its lifetime versus a steel superstructure,” says Carolyn Cota,
❚ The PCI-certified producer used project manager for the Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans). The spliced
specialized trucks with steerable
trailers to transport the massive
precast concrete girder option brought many ancillary benefits to the project. It
girders on Vermont’s allowed a reduction in superstructure depth and weight, will require minimal
winding roads. maintenance, and has a smaller “coefficient of expansion,” reducing the need for
multiple large bridge joints.
This is a major issue for bridges in the region, says project engineer David Peter-
PROJECT AND PRECAST
CONCRETE SCOPE son. “VTrans has found that failing bridge joints are one of the largest factors in
❚ Build two 863-ft precast concrete reducing the life of a bridge and increasing the need to perform maintenance and
bridges over the Williams repairs, especially in colder climates where road salt is heavily used during the win-
River in Vermont. ter,” he says.
❚ The project included 70 precast
concrete girder segments ranging
from 96 to 147.5 ft.
A LONG AND WINDING ROAD
The winning design features two distinct bridges with individual substructures and
❚ Girder installation was completed
in six weeks for the northbound continuous girders. The new bridges are wider than the existing structure, with two
bridge, and 10 weeks for the 12-ft travel lanes, a 4-ft left side shoulder, and a 10-ft breakdown lane. Both bridges
southbound bridge. 24N and 24S have abutments and pier substructures supported by footings on
piles, with the exception of one pier on the southbound bridge bearing on bedrock.
52
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: J. P. Carrara & Sons Inc.
The main prestressed concrete beam segments range in Due to the large size of the girders, cranes with 440-ton
weight from 144,920 lb to as much as 186,920 lb. “The final capacity were required to install them. The contractor built
design was based on J. P. Carrara’s capacity to fabricate and a temporary trestle across the river that had enough capac-
ship the elements to the jobsite,” French says. The girders ity to hold the weight of the cranes as well as the picks.
maxed out the lifting capacity at the Middlebury, Vt., plant, The resulting bridges were completed on schedule in the
and Carrara used professional drivers and trucks with steer- fall of 2020, and the owners are thrilled with the results.
able trailers to safely transport the girders along the wind- “The continuity between the superstructure and sub-
ing roads that led to the jobsite. structure provides an aesthetically pleasing bridge,” Peter-
Once demolition was complete, the bridges were con- son says. “Vermont is a small state, so when we are giving
structed in two phases with one bridge built at a time. the opportunity to provide a unique bridge for the public,
Highway crossovers were used so that one lane of traffic in we take pride in making that happen.”
each direction was maintained on the existing bridge while
the new bridge was constructed adjacently, preventing the
need for total road closure.
2021
2021 LAKE PONTCHARTRAIN
CAUSEWAY SAFETY BAY
REHABILITATED BRIDGE IMPROVEMENTS
NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA
The Lake Pontchartrain Causeway features two bridges that span nearly 24
miles over water. The bridges, which were built in 1956 and 1969, are among the
longest overwater bridges built in their time. And because they don’t have shoul-
ders, when accidents occur, traffic on the bridges comes to a halt. As traffic in the
region grew, the bridges were seeing 8 to 12 breakdowns daily, and 180 crashes per
year, many of them rear-end collisions, says Christopher White, senior bridge engi-
neer for Volkert. To improve safety and traffic flow, the owners wanted to add safe-
ty bay shoulders up and down both bridges to support stranded vehicles.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES The use of precast concrete and accelerated bridge construction (ABC) was key
to the safe and successful delivery of this project.
❚ Thirty pullover lanes were
assembled and installed on two
“The original causeway bridge was built entirely out of precast components and
overwater bridges with almost was the first project ever to employ mass production and assembly-line techniques
no lane closures. in fabricating and assembling a bridge,” White says. “Its use of prefabricated bridge
❚ Assembly-line construction on elements and systems and ABC was decades ahead of its time.”
the jobsite accelerated progress. In 2018, the owners embarked upon the upgrade to add 1008-ft pullover lanes at
❚ Self-propelled modular trans- multiple locations in both directions. “The goal from the get-go was to add the
porters were used for deck
span installation.
most emergency stopping area for the least cost and with the least impacts to
commuters,” says Carlton Dufrechou, general manager of the Greater New Orle-
ans Expressway Commission.
PROJECT AND PRECAST The bridges support 40,000 vehicle crossings every day, which meant lane clo-
CONCRETE SCOPE sures during construction were not feasible. So the project team chose an all–
❚ Build 30 safety bays on two precast concrete solution, which included precast concrete cylinder piles, pile
bridges over Lake Pontchartrain.
caps, and composite girder/slab deck units with barrier rails. “Using prefabricated
❚ The project included more than
components allowed for all major elements to be constructed off-site in a con-
900 precast concrete elements.
trolled setting and then transported and assembled on the bridge,” Dufrechou
❚ Precast concrete erection
began in February 2019 and was says. “This saved time, money, and almost entirely eliminated delays to our 40,000
completed in April 2020. daily commuters.”
ASSEMBLY-LINE CONSTRUCTION
To speed construction, the contractor set up long-line fabrication beds along the
waterfront. Each line could accommodate components for one complete 1008-ft
“Using prefabricated components safety bay, consisting of 12 spans for the northbound structure and 18 spans for the
allowed for all major elements southbound structure.
to be constructed off-site in a
controlled setting and then PROJECT TEAM:
transported and assembled OWNER: Greater New Orleans Expressway Commission, Metairie, La.
on the bridge.” PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Gulf Coast Prestress Partners, Ltd.,
Pass Christian, Miss.
— Carlton Dufrechou,
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Volkert, Inc., Houston, Tex.
Greater New Orleans
Expressway Commission GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Boh Bros. Construction Co. LLC, New Orleans, La.
PROJECT COST: $57.5 million
PROJECT SIZE: 175,894 ft²
54
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: BOH Bros. Construction Co. LLC.
2021
2021 SOUND TRANSIT E360
GUIDEWAY BRIDGE
BELLEVUE, WASHINGTON
NON-HIGHWAY BRIDGE
The city of Bellevue is making significant investments in public transporta-
tion to make it easier for citizens to traverse the region. That includes extend-
ing its local light-rail system to connect two major metropolitan city centers. This
process included the design-build of the E360 guideway bridge, a 0.86-mile struc-
ture adjacent to the highly-traveled Washington State Department of Transporta-
tion State Route 520.
“With a design-build delivery, construction cost and schedule are always top prior-
ity, or else we would not have won the original bid,” says Catherine Hovell, of T. Y. Lin
International. Her team’s winning design also had to ensure the design was com-
patible with future expansion goals to accommodate the adjacent roadways.
They chose a precast concrete design early in the process to address these con-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES straints. “Using precast simplified designs sped up project delivery, increased qual-
ity of materials, and reduced the impact of construction on the neighborhood,” she
❚ Two 182-ft girders were made
continuous to allow the removal of
says. “For a project like this, located next to a major freeway and employment hub,
a post-tensioned straddle bent. these benefits were significant towards positive public opinions on the project.”
❚ Optimized design eliminated the
need for five 9-ft shafts. CONTINUOUS SPANS
❚ Prestressed concrete stay-in- The final design features 31 spans ranging from 125 to 182 ft, and four parallel wide-
place deck forms were used on the flange girders, ranging in depth from 74 to 100 in. Typical spans are 95-in. girders
guideway structure to increase
construction speed.
spanning 140 ft.
During the design phase, the plan was optimized to minimize the number of
foundations required, which allowed the design team to eliminate five 9-ft shafts
PROJECT AND PRECAST from the original design. A 65-ft post-tensioned straddle bent was also eliminated
CONCRETE SCOPE by using the two 182-ft spans made continuous over a fixed pier. “This adjustment
❚ Build a 4569-ft bridge to opened space under the guideway for a new highway off-ramp to be constructed in
support light-rail extension.
the future,” Hovell says.
❚ The project included 128
Of the 128 prestressed concrete girders fabricated, 80 were the same size and
precast concrete pieces.
length, with only minor changes in prestressing strand design, which helped accel-
❚ The project was completed
in August 2020. erate delivery and minimize trades on-site. Consistent girder and pier designs were
used to increase fabrication quality and further expedite construction.
That speed, quality, and efficiency was seen as a major benefit to the project,
according to Eza Agoes, deputy project director for Downtown Redmond Link Ex-
tension (R200). “E360 ’s use of precast bridge concrete panels eliminated the use
of time-consuming, labor-intensive formwork that would otherwise be needed to
deliver a cast-in-place concrete deck for the bridge superstructure construction,”
“Using precast simplified designs
sped up project delivery, increased
quality of materials, and reduced PROJECT TEAM:
the impact of construction OWNER: Sound Transit, Seattle, Wash.
on the neighborhood.” PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Concrete Technology Corporation,
Tacoma, Wash.
— Catherine Hovell, ENGINEER OF RECORD: T. Y. Lin International, Olympia, Wash.
T. Y. Lin International GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Kiewit-Hoffman East Link Constructors, Federal Way, Wash.
PROJECT COST: $225 million
PROJECT LENGTH: 4569 ft
56
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photos: T.Y. Lin International.
2021
2021 PORT OF CORPUS CHRISTI
NORTH BANK CARGO DOCK 16
CORPUS CHRISTI, TEXAS
TRANSPORTATION
SPECIAL SOLUTION In 2018 the Port of Corpus Christi Authority put out a request for proposals to
design and build a new 40,500-ft² cargo dock and ramp for the port’s North
Bank. The dock had to be durable enough to support a steady stream of cargo from
the Handymax and Panamax vessels arriving in the port.
“One of the challenges on this project was to develop the most cost-effective
solution,” says Louis Klusmeyer, the port’s chief of design for engineering services
at the time of the project.
The design they chose featured a precast, prestressed concrete pile-supported
ship dock, consisting of precast concrete beams, precast, prestressed concrete
slabs, and a cast-in-place topping slab.
The use of precast concrete piles, pile caps, and deck panels met the financial
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES goals, with added financial benefits achieved through rapid erection of the struc-
ture. That reduced the need for costly floating cranes and associated labor costs,
❚ The choice of a precast concrete
design accelerated construction
Klusmeyer says. “Precast concrete construction also minimized the need for ex-
and reduced costs. pensive overwater formwork, which would have been required for cast-in-place
❚ It will require less maintenance construction.”
than a steel structure.
❚ Tight quality control procedures FLEXIBILITY FOR THE FUTURE
at the plant enabled the team to Once the design was approved, the biggest challenge for the precast concrete pro-
meet strict mixture design
specifications.
ducer was meeting stringent concrete mixture design specifications, which would
have been very difficult to accomplish without the use of plant-cast precast con-
crete. It required tight quality control procedures, which the precast concrete pro-
PROJECT AND PRECAST ducer was able to meet by following close specification requirements set by the
CONCRETE SCOPE design team.
❚ Build a 40,500-ft² cargo Once on-site, the precast concrete elements were erected in just five months.
dock and ramp.
The precast concrete slabs delivered the necessary strength and functionality,
❚ The project included nearly 400
while serving as an in-place forming system over water, which enhanced the proj-
precast concrete elements.
ect schedule while improving worker safety.
❚ Precast concrete erection was
completed in five months. “The precast concrete deck concept not only simplified the installation of top-
sides, including the ship unloader rails, but also provided enough flexibility for fu-
ture liquid bulk operations,” says Carlos E. Ospina, former vice president of Berger-
ABAM and current vice president of WSP USA. “Innovative design ideas and close
communication with the design-builder owner and suppliers were paramount for
the success of the project.”
“Precast concrete construction also
minimized the need for expensive
overwater formwork, which would PROJECT TEAM:
have been required for OWNER: Port of Corpus Christi, Corpus Christi, Tex.
cast-in-place construction.” PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Heldenfels Enterprises, Inc., San Marcos, Tex.
— Louis Klusmeyer, PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Eriksson Technologies, Temple Terrace, Fla.
Port of Corpus Christi Authority ENGINEER OF RECORD: BergerABAM, Houston, Tex.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Orion Construction, Deer Park, Tex.
PROJECT COST: $17.5 million
PROJECT SIZE: 40,140 ft²
58
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
The final design now provides a highly efficient structure
that will meet the needs of the port and its clients for years
to come. With ample space, lots of storage, and a highly
durable, extremely low-maintenance structure, the termi-
nal is now open for business, accommodating cargo ships
coming from around the globe.
Photos: Orion Construction LP.
“The additional benefits of precast beyond the cost sav-
ings is the greater durability and longer time until first re-
pair that precast concrete exhibits over a steel structure,”
Klusmeyer says. “This was important to reduce the long-
term maintenance costs of the facility to the owner.”
2021
HONORABLE MENTIONS
The new seven-story Nathan Deal Judicial Center in Atlanta, Ga., was
designed to reflect its status as a state government building and to com-
plement the classical architecture of the nearby Capitol Hill district.
Early design ideas included cladding the building in marble to match oth-
er state government buildings in the district, or using limestone cladding to
correspond with the Georgia State Capitol. However, the design team ulti-
mately chose to use precast concrete because it could deliver the desired
stone look in a durable, cost effective, and energy-efficient package. Addi-
tionally, a precast concrete structure would also be faster and easier than
the alternatives to erect on the tight jobsite.
NATHAN DEAL
the building perimeter provided excellent R-values (R-30) for wall assem-
bly, significantly exceeding code minimums. Working in tandem with
high-performance glazing, the exterior envelope contributes to lower ener-
JUDICIAL CENTER
ATLANTA, GEORGIA
gy costs and greater occupant comfort, while eliminating road noises from
adjacent highways.
To mimic the limestone on the adjacent Capitol Building, the precast
concrete producer developed a perfect color match using a blend of local
materials combined with a quality cement and dye combination. The faces
of the panels are acid etched to look like Indiana limestone, which is nor-
mally cut from large blocks.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES During construction, the siting of the building and adjacent interstate re-
❚ Use of precast concrete delivered a limestone taining walls restricted crane access; therefore, all panels had to be sized below
aesthetic in a cost-effective, energy-efficient
package. crane capacity to achieve an extended reach. The panel sizes were coordinated
with the panel articulation desired by the design team and are indiscernible.
❚ Panels had to be sized to accommodate
long-span crane placement on a tight jobsite. Because the entryway panels are granite clad, they had to be broken up
❚ Spray foam insulation on precast concrete panels several times to stay under crane load capacity. At the colonnade, the col-
helped deliver R-values exceeding code minimums. umn surrounds had to be installed first, and then the spandrels were in-
stalled at the back side. The erector shimmed these spandrels off the col-
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE umn surrounds to keep the tube beams from rotating; after this was done,
❚ Deliver a precast concrete façade to mimic workers were able to install the front spandrel panels to be balanced.
limestone architecture for a state government The result is a stunning companion building to the State Capitol, rein-
building. forcing this new building’s status as a central home for state government.
❚ The project included 972 precast concrete pieces.
❚ Precast concrete erection was completed in less
than one year.
PROJECT TEAM:
Photo: © Brian C. Robbins. OWNER: Georgia Building Authority, Atlanta, Ga.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Gate Precast Company, Monroeville, Ala.
PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: Gate Precast Company, Lexington, Ky.
ARCHITECT AND ENGINEER OF RECORD: Stevens & Wilkinson, Atlanta, Ga.
DESIGN ARCHITECT: Robert A.M. Stern Architects, New York, N.Y.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Gilbane Building Company, Atlanta, Ga.
PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: Precision Stone Setting Company, Hiram, Ga.
PROJECT COST: $130 million
PROJECT SIZE: 235,225 ft²
60
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
When the Moss and Johns Residence Halls at Longwood University
were erected in 1969 and 1970, they were built out of concrete ma-
sonry with uninsulated brick cavity walls. Fifty years later, when the
10-story residence halls needed repair, the university considered demol-
ishing them but opted instead to renovate the buildings with an insu-
lated precast concrete, brick-faced panel system that could mimic the
traditional aesthetic of the historic college campus. The precast con-
crete solution saved time and money, while retaining the welcoming
appearance of these structures.
MOSS JOHNS
tailing of the building envelope. This allowed smooth development and
approval of shop drawings, so that the production of the panels could
be accelerated to meet the project schedule.
The primary design challenges for the project were achieving consis-
tent architectural details and giving the monotonous layout some ar-
ticulation and architectural interest. The designers were able to achieve
RESIDENCE HALLS
FARMVILLE, VIRGINIA
the intricate detailing while staying within the budget through the use
repetitive forms, which included thin brick embedded in precast con-
crete with limestone accents with an acid-etched finish. Off-site pre-
casting also sped up construction and reduced the number of trades on
site at the busy campus. This helped the team meet the strict goal of KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
❚ Architectural precast concrete panels deliver
renovating each building within one academic year.
historic architectural detail in a cost-effective
The designers used highly repetitive forms for the precast concrete package.
façade panels to achieve consistent architectural details and align- ❚ The panel system is supported on separate
ments. Then, they placed the panels in different configurations to add foundations that do not add load to the
variety to the design. Durability and precision were achieved through existing steel frame.
factory-controlled production, which delivered the panels to the jobsite ❚ Each renovation was delivered within
one academic year.
precisely when they were needed.
The self-supporting precast concrete cladding system brought beau-
ty, structural capability, and excellent thermal performance to the PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE
campus on a demanding schedule. Each building, from demolition to ❚ Completely renovate two 10-story
residence halls.
occupancy by students, was completed within one year.
❚ The project included 740 precast
concrete architectural wall panels.
❚ The first tower was delivered in
PROJECT TEAM: August 2019, the second in August 2020.
1550 MISSION
ening seam supports a series of residential balconies and is framed by two
luminously white precast concrete veils.
A variegated grid of narrow white precast concrete has been used to
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA form three sides of each window, with the fourth side created from a dark-
er, polished material that blends into the look and proportion of the win-
dows. In this way, both lightness and mass are achieved at once.
To achieve the design, cast panels had be exposed from both sides, and
the precast concrete producer had to incorporate two colors into one pan-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES el with a polished concrete finish for one of the colors. Additionally, the
❚ Precast concrete panels are exposed on both
precast concrete producer had to minimize vibration during the pour pro-
sides, so strict vibration control was required
during pouring. cess or hand-seed the exposed poured side with additional aggregate to
❚ Two-color design features sharp lines between achieve a consistent sandblasted finish on both sides of the panels. The
contrasting design elements. timing to pour the two colors was also crucial to ensure both parts of the
❚ Reinforcing steel inserts add structural strength design would cure together as one bonded piece without bleeding. This re-
for panels with large windows. quired extra quality control for the duration of casting. Once cast, hand-
held polishing equipment was used to achieve the polished black look.
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE To accommodate the large windows with minimal concrete around
❚ Create a precast concrete façade for a them, each panel had to work as one solid, cured concrete beam. There-
40-story residential tower. fore, the precast concrete producer developed a specific pour procedure for
❚ The project included 845 precast careful placement of concrete and inserted reinforcing steel to add struc-
concrete panels.
tural strength. The new building provides a beautiful, energy-efficient hav-
❚ Precast concrete erection was completed en for residents, proving once again that precast concrete can be an ideal,
in one year.
cost-efficient solution for projects with high envelope performance and
aesthetic value.
Photo: © SOM/Mark Schwettmann.
PROJECT TEAM:
OWNER: Related California, San Francisco, Calif.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Willis Construction Co., Inc.,
San Juan Batista, Calif.
ARCHITECT: Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, San Francisco, Calif.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: DCI Engineers, Seattle, Wash.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Build Group, San Francisco, Calif.
PROJECT SIZE: 760,000 ft²
62
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Immersed in the grand beauty of the Rocky Mountains, this project
combines mountain charm and luxurious living in a highly sought-after
vacation destination. This project added five additional mixed-use struc-
tures to service the current residents and the ski base area.
Erected at a challenging mountain jobsite, the buildings had strict seis-
mic design requirements and had to be delivered in tight time frames
despite unpredictable winter weather. The designer chose a total–precast
concrete solution using emulative design techniques to meet all of these
challenges. The emulative design cut 24 months from the original cast-
in-place construction timeline, while netting the owner extensive cost
savings. The design also met all seismic requirements and allowed the archi-
tect to incorporate higher ceilings without making the building taller.
FAST-TRACK ERECTION
Extensive coordination among the design, engineering, general contractor,
and precast concrete producer teams was necessary to meet the rigorous
project requirements with minimal disruption to residents and visitors
throughout the design, delivery, and construction of the buildings. The Mixed-Use Building
YELLOWSTONE
team also had to work out extremely complex framing geometry and shal-
low floor plates in the residential units to ensure stringent height require-
ments were met.
The project’s precast concrete scope had 4613 premanufactured compo-
nents, including retaining walls, hollow-core flat slabs, double tees, span-
drels, uninsulated monolithic shear/shaft walls, columns, shallow beams,
CLUB
BIG SKY, MONTANA
a short V-shaped wall, soffit beams, and bidirectional balcony slabs. In to-
tal, 16,900 yd³ of concrete were shipped in 1342 truckloads from Colorado
Springs, Colo., to the ski resort, and erected over a 12-month period. The
largest piece weighed 86,000 lb.
Precast concrete was used for 96 unique balcony elements, many with KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
❚ Emulative design shortened the original
drastically different geometries. The balconies required bidirectional pre-
cast-in-place construction timeline by 24 months.
stressing of many members, followed by post-tensioning of the cantile-
❚ Almost 17,000 yd³ of concrete were shipped in
vered slab to resolve negative moments. 1342 truckloads from Colorado Springs, Colo.,
To meet the aggressive timeline, the project team facilitated a fast-track to Big Sky, Mont.
schedule over four seasons, battling extreme temperatures and several se- ❚ All structures met or exceeded International
vere freeze/thaw cycles. The off-site production of precast concrete com- Energy Conservation Code guidelines.
ponents limited the negative impact of weather on the construction cycle.
The end result of the project is a beautiful and durable solution that PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE
meets extreme seismic activity requirements. Additionally, all the struc- ❚ Build five total–precast concrete
tures met or exceeded International Energy Conservation Code guidelines, mountain-side buildings.
ensuring the community and its residents will be able to meet stringent ❚ The project included 4565 precast
concrete components.
energy-efficiency requirements.
❚ The project was completed in just 12 months.
PARKING DECK
The new structure was designed and detailed to meet the requirements of
the applicable building code as if it were to be constructed of monolithic
cast-in-place reinforced concrete. However, the structure was divided into
PHILADELPHIA, structural elements of sizes and shapes that could be plant fabricated, trans-
PENNSYLVANIA ported, and safely and efficiently erected on site. This method is consistent
with American Concrete Institute (ACI) 550.1R-09, Guide to Emulating Cast-
in-Place Detailing for Seismic Design of Precast Concrete Structures, and is
judged by ACI to be applicable to any structural system where monolithic
structural concrete would also be appropriate.
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
The above-grade patient tower is supported primarily on below-grade pre-
❚ Designers used emulative detailing to achieve
structural performance with precast concrete cast concrete framing. To support the massive pavilion, many of the typical
equivalent to a cast-in-place design. columns had to be designed for loads in excess of 6 million lb. Typical precast
❚ The use of precast concrete significantly concrete columns were 33 × 66 in. using 9000-psi concrete.
accelerated the construction schedule. The pavilion’s lateral force–resisting system is primarily composed of steel-
❚ Many of the typical columns were designed braced frames around the stair and elevator core. At the transition from above-
for loads in excess of 6 million lb. grade steel framing to below-grade precast concrete framing, the steel-braced
frames distribute loading to precast concrete shear walls beneath. Lateral
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE loads from the pavilion are also distributed into the below-grade floor dia-
❚ Build a five-level underground parking structure phragms to the below-grade columns and perimeter walls.
that partially supports a 17-story patient pavilion. This innovative use of precast concrete significantly accelerated the con-
❚ The project included 1138 pieces of struction schedule and allowed work on the massive steel patient pavilion to
precast concrete.
begin sooner than would have been possible with cast-in-place concrete con-
❚ Precast concrete construction was struction.
completed in 14 months.
PROJECT TEAM:
Photo: Hover Solutions, LLC.
OWNER: University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pa.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Shockey Precast, a Metromont Company, Winchester, Va.
PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER: FDG, Arvada, Colo.
ARCHITECT: HDR, Charlotte, N.C.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: HDR, Washington, D.C.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: LF Driscoll/Balfour Beatty Joint Venture, Bala Cynwyd, Pa.
64
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
PCI-CERTIFIED ERECTOR: Jonasz Precast, Inc., Westville, N.J.
PROJECT SIZE: 1.5 million ft²
Madison, Wis., is the state capital and a bucolic college town, famous for
its architectural history, beautiful lakeside settings, and the active cam-
pus of the University of Wisconsin. One of the latest additions to the univer-
sity is the Mead Witter School of Music’s Hamel Music Center. The new center,
which includes a 650-seat concert hall, a 330-seat recital hall, and a large re-
hearsal room, is a significant component of the university’s east campus devel-
opment plan.
When planning for the new center, the designers had to take into account
the many challenges of building a world-class music center in the heart of a
busy and crowded urban setting. Those challenges led them to a precast con-
crete design solution.
Precast concrete appealed to designers because it is durable and flexible,
and because it provides unique opportunities to create a dramatic exterior ef-
fect. The precast concrete design helped maximize the footprint of the site Theater Structure
MEAD WITTER
while minimizing concerns about traffic noise and vibrations that could com-
promise the precise acoustic needs of the building’s multiple performance
SCHOOL OF MUSIC–
spaces.
BOX IN A BOX
The building design, both inside and out, was driven by the acoustic goals at the HAMEL MUSIC CENTER
heart of the project. The most striking exterior feature of the new music center MADISON, WISCONSIN
is the folded precast concrete façade of the exterior walls. The accordion de-
sign mimics a curtain frozen in time and provides the mass and form needed
for ideal acoustic isolation of the building’s interior from the noise of the busy
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
streets outside.
❚ Precast concrete panels create an acoustic
The deep folds of the “curtain” were achieved by rotating panels horizontal- shell, eliminating outside noise.
ly and tilting them forward and backward vertically. This allowed the panels to ❚ Box-in-a-box precast concrete design further
be staggered, each with one end in front of the previous panel and the other minimizes sound and vibration.
end behind the next. As a result, traditional sealant joints were concealed be- ❚ Staggered precast concrete panels emulate
tween panels. The texture was created using a combination of exposed aggre- a folded curtain in the façade.
gate material and a custom fluted profile on every other panel face.
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE
Double-wall construction ensured no traffic noise would affect performanc-
❚ Build a two-story music and performance
es, while also allowing for opportunities to strategically incorporate natural center on a busy university campus.
daylighting at the top of the recital hall volume. Using this strategy, the design- ❚ The project included 152 precast concrete panels.
ers were able to locate the Collins Recital Hall prominently at the front of the ❚ Precast concrete erection was
facility, rather than burying it at the core. completed in four months.
The recital and rehearsal halls were designed as a box-within-a-box concept,
using 8-in.-thick precast concrete panels to minimize the impact of outside Photo: Mike Rebholz.
sounds and vibrations. The panels were strategically shaped and sloped in dif-
ferent directions, leaning in or out by 2 degrees to further deflect sound.
PROJECT TEAM:
To ease assembly, the supplier created computer-aided-design layout points
that provided the bottom profile and top corner points of the panels. This OWNER:
State of Wisconsin, University of Wisconsin-Madison
saved time by eliminating layout from the piece drawings. Lasers and 2-in.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER:
shims were used to rapidly set the panels in place. International Concrete Products, Germantown, Wis.
Along with meeting acoustic and aesthetic goals, the use of precast con- PRECAST CONCRETE SPECIALTY ENGINEER:
crete brought practical advantages to the busy jobsite. The new center is locat- CSD Structural Engineers, Milwaukee, Wis.
ed at the eastern gateway to the university, one of the most publicly visible ARCHITECT: Strang, Inc. in association with Holzman
corners of the campus. This gateway is active with traffic for most of the day, Moss Bottino, Madison, Wis.
and the use of precast concrete was essential to ensuring rapid construction ENGINEER OF RECORD: Strang, Inc., Madison, Wis.
with minimal disruption to the community. GENERAL CONTRACTOR: JP Cullen, Madison, Wis.
The project is currently pursuing LEED certification, and most of the points PROJECT COST: $55.8 million
supporting this effort reflect the project’s integration into the dense campus PROJECT SIZE: 7500 ft²
and downtown surroundings.
2021
HONORABLE MENTIONS
STORMWATER
In the initial phase of the project, the old drainage systems were replaced
with new piping, overflow junction boxes, and box-culvert systems to the
edge of the sand template, which encompasses the area located 230 ft
OUTFALLS
BILOXI, MISSISSIPPI
south of the existing seawall. Three architectural and structural precast
concrete wave outfalls were then constructed, combining nine existing
and future round pipes into three public walkway structures where visi-
THREE LOCATIONS tors can view the beauty of the Sound.
The precast concrete producer assisted in the design of gray-and-tan
wave patterns in the panels to blend with the beach color palette. The
color patterns flow with spontaneity, like the rolling waves of the Sound.
To prevent graffiti from tarnishing the design, the architect chose a facto-
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES ry-applied coating that will prevent any permanent graffiti damage and
❚ Replace aging rainwater outfall infrastructure keep the maintenance costs as low as possible.
with precast concrete wave-shaped walkways.
The new outfalls now provide increased capacity for the existing storm
❚ Precast concrete was the only material that could sewer system, with new oversized box-culvert drainage outlets. They also
withstand the 597-lb/ft² wave pressures.
can be used as a secondary safety measure for Highway 90 drainage
❚ Factory-applied coating prevents permanent
graffiti damage. through the installation of overflow boxes that allow for constant drain-
age if primary systems fail.
The innovative precast concrete solution will help to enhance, con-
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE
serve, and upgrade waterfront areas while improving public amenities
❚ Build three precast concrete wave outfall
structures to replace pipes on coastal beaches. and the aesthetics of the beach environment for years to come.
❚ The project included 90 precast concrete pieces.
❚ The first two walls were erected in one week; the
third was completed two months later.
66
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
The original Clarks Mills County Route 113 Bridge connecting Green-
wich, N.Y., and Easton, N.Y., was built more than 100 years ago, and
was in dire need of replacement. The structure spanning the Batten Kill
River was in poor condition, and the community needed an overpass with
wider lanes to support increased truck traffic. However, local residents
didn’t want to lose the historic charm of the original arched bridge.
To meet the community’s needs and aesthetic goals, the designers
used precast concrete to replicate the look and feel of the original bridge
in a more durable replacement bridge. The decision to use precast con-
crete also eliminated need for significant formwork over the river. This
reduced construction time significantly, minimizing the project’s impact
on travelers.
Bridge with a Main
HOMETOWN PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER Span From 76-149 Feet
CLARKS MILLS
The new three-span arch bridge features 84 precast concrete units, with
the heaviest piece weighing 54,000 lb. The pieces were manufactured just
PROJECT TEAM:
Photo: Brian Haynes.
OWNER: Washington County, Fort Edward, N.Y.
PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Fort Miller Co., Inc., Greenwich, N.Y.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Greenman-Pedersen, Inc., Albany, N.Y.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Kubricky Construction Corp., Wilton, N.Y.
PROJECT COST: $4.3 million
PROJECT LENGTH: 282 ft
2021
HONORABLE MENTIONS
MENTION
For years, a highway interchange in Jacksonville, Fla., created con-
stant traffic delays. Because the southbound Interstate 95 (I-95) traffic
exited to eastbound State Route 202 (SR-202) at a stoplight, vehicles would
back up for a mile or more during rush hour. City leaders finally decided the
problem had to be fixed.
In 2014, the owner awarded a design-build contract for the redesign and
construction of the interchange to eliminate the congestion. The winning
design featured four bridge structures, new ramp configurations, new high-
way alignments, and roadway widening of both highways.
The signature piece of the design is a curved, post-tensioned, precast
concrete U-girder flyover ramp bridge to carry southbound I-95 traffic to
eastbound SR-202 lanes, eliminating the traffic backup problem. The sev-
en-span, 1342-ft-long structure is curved on an 1100-ft horizontal radius
and features a superstructure composed of curved, spliced precast con-
crete U-girders that are post-tensioned for continuity.
SB I-95 TO EB
to six eight-hour windows for erection in traffic areas. To accommodate the
constant flow of traffic through the jobsite, the designers incorporated
SR-202
several innovative features into the design and construction staging, in-
cluding precast concrete hammerhead pier caps for interior piers adjacent
to traffic. These pier caps also served to support the pier girders during con-
FLYOVER BRIDGE
JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA
struction, eliminating the need for falsework towers within the traffic zone.
To minimize form changes, both the left and right girders were designed
to be cast at the same radius. This casting method did not significantly af-
fect the design, but it allowed for vastly increased efficiency in girder pro-
duction. Once stripped from the formwork and stored at the precast con-
crete producer’s yard, the girders were mildly reinforced, and
post-tensioning tendons were installed and grouted to control concrete
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES stresses during shipping and erection. These tendons are also part of the
❚ Curved post-tensioned, precast concrete U-girder final structure design.
flyover ramp solves traffic congestion issue.
Before erecting the drop-in girders, all other girders in the superstructure
❚ Precast concrete hammerhead pier caps unit had to be erected with splices cast, lid slabs poured, and partial-length
eliminated the need for falsework towers in
traffic zones. continuity tendons stressed. This required a detailed erection sequence and
❚ The project was the first implementation of a coordination among the contractor, precast concrete producer, and
spliced, curved, post-tensioned U-girder post-tensioning subcontractor to minimize schedule impacts.
superstructure by the Florida Department of The successful rapid construction of this flyover bridge proves that
Transportation.
spliced post-tensioned, precast concrete designs can provide innovative
solutions for many bridge design challenges. The new structure will fulfill
PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE local traffic needs for years to come.
❚ Build a curved, post-tensioned, precast concrete
U-girder flyover ramp bridge.
❚ The project included 28 precast concrete
U-girders and four precast concrete PROJECT TEAM:
hammerhead pier caps.
OWNER: Florida Department of Transportation, Jacksonville, Fla.
❚ The bid was won in August 2014, and the
bridge was open to traffic September 2017. PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER: Dura-Stress, Inc., Leesburg, Fla.
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Modjeski and Masters, Littleton, Colo.
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: SEMA Construction, Orlando, Fla.
Photo: Modjeski and Masters.
PROJECT COST: $66.7 million
PROJECT LENGTH: 1342 ft
68
2021 PCI DESIGN AWARDS
Photo: H&K Group.
The new State Route 191 bridge replacement project in Stroudsburg,
Pa., faced many obstacles in design and construction. The project in-
volved replacing a steel through-girder bridge that passed through one bar-
rel of an existing concrete railroad tunnel. This tunnel, which supports rail-
road tracks that could not be disturbed, needed rehabilitation, and the
bridge structure carrying the roadway over the overflow channel in one cell
of the tunnel needed to be fully replaced.
The original tunnel rehabilitation and reconstruction plan included cre-
ating a 345-ft-long reinforced concrete culvert structure inside the tunnel
and two new post-tensioned reinforced concrete approach spans. Howev-
er, the winning contractor teamed with an engineer to develop a better
plan using a precast concrete design that brought innovation to the ap-
proach structures and helped coordinate the timing and scheduling of the
multiple site activities required for the complex project.
To facilitate delivery and erection using readily available cranes and de- Transportation Special Solution
livery trucks, the new plan used segmental bridge design features and de-
tails normally reserved for long-span structures. Segmental bridge design SR 191 BRIDGE
and structural post-tensioning are not normally used by this owner; how-
ever, they recognized that an innovative solution was required to provide a REPLACEMENT INSIDE
“side opening,” and saw that using a precast concrete edge girder with
post-tensioning would address that need. The new design also used similar STITES TUNNEL
load paths to the cast-in-place model with modifications to use precast EAST STROUDSBURG,
concrete to reduce field work and accommodate the time schedule. PENNSYLVANIA
MONOLITHIC EDGE GIRDER
The design of the approach span structures had to account for the unique
KEY PROJECT ATTRIBUTES
arrangement of the overflow channel of the creek, which takes two
❚ The precast concrete deck was designed transverse to
90-degree bends under the spans. To accommodate this layout, the design the roadway to accommodate 90-degree turns in the
involves a precast concrete deck transverse to the roadway and supported tunnel.
by new integral abutments under the outside shoulder. Because the box ❚ The precast concrete edge girder was cast monolithi-
culverts were designed with the top slab spanning perpendicular to the di- cally with the deck slab to keep unit weights within
acceptable limits.
rection of traffic, standard design software could not be used; instead, a
more rigorous analysis using finite element software was used to develop ❚ Replacing cast-in-place concrete with precast
concrete reduced on-site work and shortened the
the live-load forces. schedule.
The project team wanted to take advantage of the efficiency of fabricat-
ing multiple precast concrete segments with the same forms, so each seg- PROJECT AND PRECAST CONCRETE SCOPE
ment was made a common length. Once the 78 precast concrete sections ❚ Replace a girder through one barrel of an existing
concrete railroad tunnel.
were on site, the team used two Taylor “Big Red” industrial lift trucks work-
ing side by side to move the individual box-culvert segments through the ❚ The project included 101 precast concrete elements.
tunnel and into their final position on a new abutment foundation. The re- ❚ The project began in January 2019 and was completed
in July 2020.
sulting structure will be more durable than the original plan to use existing
abutments.
The precast concrete edge girder was cast monolithically with the pre-
cast concrete deck slab to keep precast concrete unit weights within ac- PROJECT TEAM:
ceptable limits for handling and erection. The 11-to-12 girder segments were OWNER: Pennsylvania Department of
post-tensioned in the field after erection on temporary supports. The joints Transportation District 5-0, Allentown, Pa.
in the precast concrete segments and edge girder were designed to use PCI-CERTIFIED PRECAST CONCRETE PRODUCER:
Northeast Prestressed Products, LLC, Cressona, Pa.
8000-psi grout, which was readily available in the state and thereby avoid-
ENGINEER OF RECORD: Larson Design Group, Lititz, Pa.
ed the need for less readily available solutions.
Eliminating the cast-in place concrete formwork and temporary false- GENERAL CONTRACTOR: H&K Group, Douglassville, Pa.
work reduced the duration of the on-site work, which extended into cold PROJECT COST: $8.2 million
weather months, and helped with the overall project schedule. PROJECT LENGTH: 532 ft
2021
CALL FOR ENTRIES
Entries open on May 10, 2021. Join us in our
search for excellence and submit your projects
electronically by August 10, 2021.
The improved PCI Design Awards program will
showcase the winning projects in multiple ways:
The PCI Design Awards is not just looking for design excellence,
but also for projects with outstanding use of precast concrete.
PCI looks for projects that push the envelope and advance the
precast concrete industry.