ENGLISH த ழ் বাংলা മലയാളം िहं दी मराठी

Follow Us:

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Home India Cities Opinion IPL 2020 Entertainment Lifestyle Tech Videos Explained Audio
SUBSCRIBE
Epaper Sign in
Home / Opinion / Aarogya Setu and patient tracking tools: A serious infringement of digital privacy

Aarogya Setu and patient

tracking tools: A serious
infringement of digital privacy
BECIL tender wants bidding companies to offer surveillance instruments that
eye suspects, not just patients. We have no information on where this data is
being stored, the period of storage, and whether the data will be deleted after
the COVID-19 crisis passes.

Written by Vrinda Bhandari | May 28, 2020 6:46:03 pm

Aarogya Setu is a contact-tracing app developed by the National Informatics Centre (NIC) under the
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology. (File/Express photo: Sneha Saha)

The COVID-19 crisis has seen a gradual erosion of privacy through the proliferation
of apps and measures undertaken by governments and companies. Some of these
measures, such as the introduction and deployment of Arogya Setu, have received a
lot of attention, while others have slipped under the radar.

One such instance is the request for expression of interest floated by the Broadcast
Engineering Consultants India Ltd. (BECIL) last month for the empanelment of an
agency “for the supply of healthcare equipments”. As part of the scope of work,
BECIL, which comes under the Information and Broadcasting Ministry, has
provided a list of 22 items that have to be delivered by the bidders, including a
sanitisation/disinfectant chamber, COVID-19 test kits, rescue team GPS location
monitoring system, and N95 face masks. BECIL then issued a corrigendum and
added a hand-held thermal imaging system, optical thermal fever sensing system,
and a COVID-19 patient tracking tool, as part of the products to be delivered.

Through these innocuous additions, the building blocks of a perfect surveillance

tool have been smuggled in. Consider the specifications of the “COVID-19 patient
tracking tool”, presumably meant to be deployed to reduce health risks. The very
first specification, however, is for the tool to be useful as an “intelligence
investigation platform and tactical tool to detect, prevent and investigate threats to
national security using CDR, IPDR, tower, mobile phone forensics data”.

The law enforcement aspect of this “patient tracking” tool is further made evident
in other parts of the corrigendum, such as for its use as an “intelligence
investigation platform and tactical tool to detect, prevent and investigate threats to
national security…”; for location-based analysis to “geo-fence an area of interest”
such as “airport, mosque, railway station” to identify “all the people” present there
at the time of the event; to identify a “suspect’s behaviour”, including where they
“order food from”, where they go for regular walks, where they “work during the
day” and “sleep at night”. These are just some examples that illustrate the vast
swathes of personal data being collected. For all practical purposes, therefore, the
government will have intimate knowledge of our every movement and be able to
monitor every aspect of our daily routine.

Interestingly, the specifications for this patient tracking tool use the word “infected
person” and “suspect” separately, further establishing its surveillance and national
security imperative. Under the guise of supplying healthcare equipment during a
national epidemic, the government (through BECIL) is using COVID-19 as an
opportunity to shore up its surveillance infrastructure. This is concerning both for
practical and philosophical reasons.

The practical concern stems from the fact that India still does not have a data
protection law, and there are no established norms that regulate the collection,
storage, and use of such data. The patient tracking tool is collecting far more data
than required for the task of contact tracing. We have no information on where this
data is being stored, the period of storage, and whether the data will be deleted
after the COVID-19 crisis passes.

There is no restriction on the sharing of such personal data with law enforcement
agencies, which will greatly enhance – and result in the likely misuse of – their
surveillance capabilities. Despite the extraordinary amount of data being collected,
we have no way of knowing the security measures being deployed to prevent a
hack or an unauthorised data breach. The Aadhaar experience, and the multiple
cases of leaks, over the last couple of years should make us wary about government
claims of security of data. Finally, there is no accountability or oversight built into
the system. Citizens have no way of knowing how their data will be processed nor
is there any data protection authority who can handle any complaints about the
misuse of data.

The philosophical concern stems from the fact that privacy is increasingly viewed
as a “luxury”, that has no place in times of a public health crisis. Such a view,
however, simplifies the debate to a “privacy vs health” heuristic. Most academics or
privacy activists are not opposed to the idea of contact tracing per se. Their fear,
instead, is that exceptional measures taken during the COVID-19 crisis will be
normalised; and that the surveillance architecture being built as a reaction to the
pandemic will become a part of our bureaucratic infrastructure, justified on the
ground that it will be necessary to “fight” the next pandemic. Mass surveillance
may very well become the new norm in these exceptional times.

Over the years, technology has removed the traditional constraints of surveillance,
namely limited police resources. However, technology today has empowered law
enforcement agencies with far greater ability to monitor the daily activities of a
large number of people. Many people question the focus on state surveillance,
particularly when we seemingly have no problems giving Google and Facebook all
our personal data. “Surveillance capitalism” is undoubtedly a cause of concern.
However, the power imbalance between citizens and the state, in terms of the
concentration of powers in the hands of the state, their monopoly over the law and
violence, and the possibilities of misuse, means that we should be even more
concerned when the state tries to arrogate greater powers to itself. The BECIL
expression of interest represents just that, and unless we sit up and take notice, we
are unwittingly sacrificing our hard-fought civil liberties in the name of public
health protection.

The writer is a Delhi-based lawyer specialising in digital rights and privacy

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel
(@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App.
TAGS: Aarogya Setu Coronavirus Data Privacy

0 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by indianexpress.com.

EXPRESS OPINION
Opinion
Fifty-eight years later,
India-China relationship
has changed. Inequality
has grown

Opinion
Isher Ahluwalia and
Devaki Jain fashioned
feminism out of lived
experience

Opinion
The economic rise of
Bangladesh is also an
opportunity for India

Opinion
Policy needs to address
— and help — those who
have seen the greatest
distress during
lockdown

BEST OF EXPRESS
What impact will ban on
visitors at Durga Puja
pandals in Bengal have?

Live Updates
PM Modi to address
nation at 6 pm

Entertainment
The iconic DDLJ turns 25, but how does it hold
up today?
 Entertainment
Prithviraj tests positive
for coronavirus

Trending
UK residents tweets 'I
am not OK', netizens
from around the world
try to cheer him up

Trending
Patients and healthcare
workers perform garba
at COVID-19 facility, get
praise on social media

Sports
To bring IPL stands
alive in UAE, Mumbai
engineers cut-paste
audio

Sports
RELIVE | Virender
Sehwag's ve ODI
centuries on his 42nd
birthday

Opinion
Fifty-eight years later,
India-China relationship
has changed. Inequality
has grown

Quixplained: As schools
reopen, a look at the
guidelines for students
and staff

Lifestyle
Covid-19: Simple
precautionary
measures and
immunity-bosting tips
for pregnant women
 Technology
Here are the cheapest
and most expensive
places to buy iPhone 12

MUST READ
Sports
To bring IPL stands
alive in UAE, Mumbai
engineers cut-paste
audio

Sports
RELIVE | Virender
Sehwag's ve ODI
centuries on his 42nd
birthday

Sports
A season too far: CSK’s
chances seem all but
over after tepid loss

Technology
Here are the cheapest
and most expensive
places to buy iPhone 12

Technology
These WhatsApp
features are coming
soon for Android,
iPhone users

Technology
When will PlayStation 5
release in India, what is
the price?

Lifestyle
Covid-19: Simple
precautionary
measures and
immunity-bosting tips
for pregnant women

MORE EXPLAINED
 Quixplained: As schools
reopen, a look at the
guidelines for students
and staff

What impact will ban on

visitors at Durga Puja
pandals in Bengal have?

Why scientists are

trying to cultivate heeng
in the Indian Himalayas

Five main strategic

implications of
Bangladesh's economic
rise

OCT 20: LATEST NEWS

SRK on 25 years of
DDLJ: I’m shy with
ladies, didn’t know how
I’d say romantic bits

Donald Trump to remove Sudan from US terror

blacklist

Death toll climbs as

Nigeria protests spiral

Morales party claims

win as Bolivia seems to
shift back left
 Happy to play wherever
team requires me: Jos
Buttler

Taiwan, China trade

accusations after
staffers ght in Fiji

iPhone 12, iPhone 12

Pro screen repairing
cost revealed: Check
how much it will cost
you

HUL Q2 net up 8.6% at

Rs 1,974 crore; net
sales up 15.9% at Rs
11,510 crore

US diplomats and spies

battle Trump
administration over
suspected attacks

UK residents tweets ‘I
am not OK’, netizens
from around the world
try to cheer him up

TRENDING NEWS

Covid-19 Vaccine Horoscope Today Coronavirus India News RCB Team 2020 Players
List

CSK Team 2020 Players MI Team 2020 Players List SRH Team 2020 Players DC Team 2020 Players List
List List

KXIP Team 2020 Players KKR Team 2020 Players IPL 2020 Points Table Maharashtra Coronavirus
List List News

US Elections 2020 Karnataka Coronavirus

News
FOLLOW US

DOWNLOAD APPS

EXPRESS GROUP

The Indian Express The Financial Express

Loksatta Jansatta

IE Tamil IE Bangla

IE Malayalam inUth

The ExpressGroup Ramnath Goenka Awards

IE-26/11 MyInsuranceClub
QUICK LINKS

T&C Privacy Policy

Advertise with Us Contact Us

Subscribe Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses)

Code of ethics for digital news websites

Copyright © 2020 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved