Professional Documents
Culture Documents
USEOFVORTEXTUBEAIRCOOLING - JMERD 127 131 - Aug2019
USEOFVORTEXTUBEAIRCOOLING - JMERD 127 131 - Aug2019
net/publication/335494046
CITATIONS READS
0 286
4 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Bhaskara P Achar on 08 September 2020.
RESEARCH ARTICLE
USE OF VORTEX TUBE AIR COOLING DURING MACHINING OF INCONEL 718:
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION AND MODELING STUDIES
Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P*, Mr. Gururaj K.
Dept. of Mechanical Engg., NMAM Institute of Technology, Nitte-574 110, Karnataka State, India
*Corresponding Author Email: srinivasapai@nitte.edu.in
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in
any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Article History: Among Nickel based super alloys, Inconel 718 is a most widely used alloy, due to its superior properties like high
temperature resistance, corrosion resistance, creep resistance, good mechanical properties etc. But, machining this
Received 15 July 2019 alloy is a challenge even today because of its high temperature strength, hot hardness, wear resistance and work
Accepted 21 August 2019 hardening and is considered as a ‘difficult-to-machine’ material. To overcome these problems, lubrication and
Available online 29 August 2019 cooling is an effective method and there have been several research studies aimed to reduce the machinability
problems considering different cooling methods. But these methods have their own disadvantages and to overcome
these and to support ‘sustainability’, air cooling is being adopted in a big way by machining industries. Thus, this
research work focusses to experimentally investigate the effect of air cooling during turning of Inconel 718 using
uncoated carbide inserts. The machinability is being evaluated in terms of cutting tool temperature, tool wear,
surface roughness and cutting tool vibrations. Experiments are conducted at different speeds and feeds and results
have been compared with dry machining. Further Random forest regression, a statistical technique is used to model
surface roughness using data collected from air cooled experiments. It is found to be effective in modeling surface
roughness, with a prediction accuracy of more than 89 % for Ra.
KEYWORDS
Inconel-718, vortex tube air cooling, dry machining, cutting tool temperature, surface roughness.
1. INTRODUCTION use of cutting fluids in flood lubrication, is the most common cooling and
lubrication technique used by industries. But due to stringent
Super alloys of Nickel are having a vast usage in aerospace industry and environmental laws, there is a need felt to replace this cooling method
more than 75 % by weight of aircraft and more than 50 % by weight of jet with other alternatives. Cutting fluids constitute a major cost component
engine parts are made of these alloys. Inconel 718 is widely used in a in the total machining cost, it is a source of health problems like irritation
variety of applications due to their desirable properties like high corrosion to skin, lung, eyes, nose and throat and cause of dermatitis, acne,
resistance, strength to weight ratio, creep strength, etc. [1]. These alloys hypersensitivity, pneumonitis, asthma, irritation of the upper respiratory
are mainly used in airplane engine parts (e.g. turbine discs, compressor tract and various type of cancers. They also cause problems of disposal.
discs, shafts, rings, casings and blades), biomedical implants (joints), Hence other methods of coolant use like MQL, solid lubricants, better
reciprocating engines, metal processing, steam turbines, chemical and design of nozzles, cryogenic cooling etc. are being investigated [6]. Further
petrochemical industries, space vehicles, heat treating equipment, gas use of dry machining can reduce all these problems and have advantages
turbines, coal gasification and liquefaction plants and marine engine parts like no environmental pollution, reduced disposal and cleaning costs and
[2]. no health hazard to workers. But can cause increase in the cutting tool
temperature and thereby increase tool wear and damage the surface
The machinability of Nickel based alloys is poor due to its metallurgical
finish. The other sustainable cooling strategies include use of air cooling,
condition. Due to its austenitic structure, work hardening occurs rapidly
which can support sustainable initiatives in a big way, as air is readily
while machining. This affects the machinability further during machining
available. Further efforts are on in using hybrid cooling strategies like MQL
operations and can damage the work piece surface. The presence of phases
and compressed cold air, which can complement each other overcoming
like carbides, nitrides, oxides, silicates etc., has a tendency to cause tool
the limitations of each [7].
wear and large amount of heat is generated during machining. This is
because they have low thermal conductivity and thermal diffusivity [3]. Studied the heat transfer mechanism in MQL technique during grinding of
They also have a tendency to promote formation of built-up edge (BUE), CK45 soft steel using simulation [8]. To further improve the cooling ability
which can also reduce tool life and lead to poor surface finish [1]. A of MQL, a simple and inexpensive vortex tube was used. The results
previous study discussed the machinability of Ni based alloys considering revealed that 95 % heat is removed by compressed air. Also, air pressure
different techniques of cooling including cryogenic cooling, cryogenic is important than temperature in cooling process. There is a significant
treatment of tool and a hybrid technique of cryogenic cooling of tool with reduction in tangential grinding force and friction coefficient. But surface
heating of work piece. There was an improvement in tool life and surface finish is poor at optimum condition, which has the highest heat transfer
quality [1]. To reduce the problem of tool wear, tool temperature, and coefficient [8]. A study made an effort to compare specific energy
reduction in surface roughness etc., researchers are exploring different consumption during turning of Inconel 718 using dry, vortex-tube chilled
alternatives like development of better tool materials and cutting air and nanolubricants enhanced MQL using coated carbide tool at
geometries, more resistant tool coating and use of new lubrication different speed, feeds and constant depth of cut [9]. There was a marginal
strategies [4]. Among these strategies, the focus is more on use of alternate difference in the specific energy consumption between the three methods.
lubrication strategies and include flood cooling, cryogenic cooling, The best results were obtained for MQL [9]. Developed mathematical
minimum quantity lubrication (MQL), use of solid lubricants etc. [5]. The models for analyzing the effects of air-cooling during machining of Ti-6Al-
Cite The Article: Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P, Mr. Gururaj K. (2019). Use of vortex tube air cooling during machining
of Inconel 718: Experimental Investigation and Modeling studies. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 42(5) : 127-131.
Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments (JMERD) 42(5) (2019) 127-131
4V alloy during hard turning [10]. The use of air cooling, has better instrument (Talysurf, make TAYLOR & HOBSON). Figure 1 shows the
penetration to the cutting zone, reduces the cutting temperature, tool experimental setup.
wear and improves surface roughness. The cutting parameters have
similar effect on the machining of the alloy for both dry and air cooling
[10]. Compared variety of cooling methods in turning of Inconel 718 [4].
Use of cold air produced better results, when compared to dry cutting, but
underperformed compared to use of oils. Cryogenic cooling resulted in
less tool wear, when compared to use of emulsion, cold air and dry
machining [4]. An investigated the effect of air cooling on turning of steel
St 40 [11]. It was found that overhead jet cooling was more effective in
reducing tool temperature than interface jet cooling. There was a
significant reduction in nose wear. It resulted in better chip formation
control and lower temperatures leading to better surface finish [11]. A
studied the effect of chilled air coolant during machining of 2205 duplex
stainless steel on surface roughness and tool wear [5]. The study was
carried out on a turning machine using coated carbide tools at constant
speed, feed and depth of cut. Further comparison was done between
conventional cooling and air cooling. Surface roughness was lower in case Figure 1: Experimental set up
of air cooling, whereas tool wear was lower in case of conventional cooling
[5]. Kadam and Pawde (2017) studied surface quality in high speed 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
turning of Inconel 718 using coated carbide tools at constant cutting
In this section the influence of vortex tube cooling technique on surface
speed, feed and depth of cut under dry condition, use of water vapor and
roughness, cutting tool temperature, flank wear, and cutting tool
chilled air. Use of water vapor resulted in better surface finish. Use of
vibrations during machining of Inconel 718 at different speeds for
chilled air resulted in poor surface finish [12]. Arruda and Brandao (2017)
different feed rates is discussed.
performed turning operations on API 5L X70 steel seamless tubular
workpieces. The study was focused on tool wear and surface finish using
dry and cold air system. Use of cold air system resulted in increase in tool
life. The influence on wear and surface finish was dependent on the cutting
speed [13]. An investigated the machinability of titanium (grade II alloy)
using CBN tool under MQL conditions [14]. The process parameters varied
include feed rate, cutting speed, and side cutting edge angle. Response
surface methodology (RSM) was used to model cutting forces, power
consumption and tool wear. MQL is an economic and effective option,
when compared to dry and flood cooling. The forces generated, tool wear
and power consumption depended on the cutting conditions. The optimal
conditions for minimal tool wear, cutting force and power consumption
was 200 m/min, 0.10 mm/rev and 90° [14].
(a)
Based on this literature review, it is clear that there have been very few
studies regarding use of air cooling during turning of Inconel 718. Further
very few researchers have investigated the use of random forest for
modeling and prediction of surface roughness.
This study aims to investigate the use of air cooling during turning
operations on Inconel 718 at different cutting speed and feed rate. The
machinability has been evaluated in terms of tool wear, surface roughness,
cutting tool vibrations and cutting tool temperature. Further comparison
of results with dry machining has been carried out. Random forest, a
relatively new machine learning algorithm has been used to model surface
roughness and more than 77 % prediction accuracy has been achieved.
(b)
2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
Figure 2: Variation in flank wear with number of machining passes for
Turning experiments were carried out at different cutting speed and feeds different cutting speeds at (a) 0.1 mm/rev and (b) 0.2 mm/rev
on Inconel 718 bars. The dimension of the bar is 50 mm in diameter and
200 mm in length. Table 1 gives the chemical composition of alloy. Tool wear achieved is maximum at the highest speed of 80 m/min for all
the feed rates investigated and further for feed rate of 0.1 mm/rev, it
Table 1: Chemical composition of Inconel 718 reached 0.4 mm (limiting value) in only two machining passes as shown in
Figure 2a. At higher feed rates, BUE and chip weld was observed,
particularly at lower speed [15]. Cutting speed was the dominant
parameter affecting tool wear while machining super alloys including
Inconel 718 [2]. The effect of feed rate is inverse to that of speed i.e., flank
Experimentations were conducted on a CNC Turning Centre (HMT Stallion
wear was maximum for minimum feed rate as shown in Figure 2 a).
100SU) using uncoated carbide inserts (883 with MR4 chip breaker,
supplier M/s SECO tools). The cold air is supplied using vortex tube
(#3208, make EXAIR) which is 80 % of the total capacity. The experiments
are conducted at different speeds (40, 60 & 80 m/min) and feed rates (0.1,
0.15 & 0.3 mm/rev) at a common depth of cut of 0.5 mm.
Cite The Article: Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P, Mr. Gururaj K. (2019). Use of vortex tube air cooling during machining
of Inconel 718: Experimental Investigation and Modeling studies. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 42(5) : 127-131.
Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments (JMERD) 42(5) (2019) 127-131
(b)
Figure 3. illustrates that at lower feed rate, increase in cutting speed led to
an increase in temperature. As the feed rate increased, there was a
decrease in the cutting tool temperature. This has a correlation with (a)
variation in flank wear with feed rate. Feed rate has an inverse
relationship with cutting tool temperature.
(b)
(b)
Cite The Article: Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P, Mr. Gururaj K. (2019). Use of vortex tube air cooling during machining
of Inconel 718: Experimental Investigation and Modeling studies. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 42(5) : 127-131.
Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments (JMERD) 42(5) (2019) 127-131
lower than that of dry machining condition for every machining cut as Figure 8 shows the working of Random Forest. The performance of
shown in Fig. 6 c), as the cold air effectively carries away the heat random forest is evaluated based on the prediction accuracy by
produced at the cutting zone. The tool vibrations are found to be less with correlating between regression trees. From the available data set,
lower values in dry machining than vortex tube air cooling assisted training sets are selected in random by considering the predictor
machining. It was observed from the experimental results that; vortex tube features at each node in order to choose the best split. The important
cold air assisted machining reduced the tool temperature and flank wear by parameters required to be set in RFR include the number of trees, the
39% and improved surface finish by 21% but tool vibrations were found
predictor variables for splitting the training and test data and the
to be increased.
specified nodes which limits the growing the regression trees [17].
In this study, RFR has been applied for the data generated during
machining of Inconel 718 using Statistica 12 [18]. Cutting speed, feed rate,
cutting temperature, cutting tool vibrations and flank wear have been
taken as input parameters to predict the surface roughness. A total of 44
data set have been generated during machining, out of which 80% have
been considered as training data and remaining 20% have been
considered as test data. The data has been normalized and used in RFR due
to lot of variation in the values of different parameters used as predictors.
(a) (b) All the values have been brought to the range between 0 and 1. The data
has been classified randomly into training and test by the software, based
on the percentage of distribution set by the user. Initially, the number of
trees has been set to 50 and the stopping criteria has been chosen as 10
cycles. The number of trees has been varied in order to get the best possible
prediction of surface roughness. Mean squared error (MSE) of observed
value and predicted value has been calculated using the following formula,
(1)
(c) (d)
MSE was set with a cut off value of 0.05 and any value beyond that was
Figure 7: Comparison of variations in a) Surface roughness (Ra), b) Flank considered as misclassification. The data has been de-normalized before
wear, c) Tool temperature and d) Tool vibrations in machining of Inconel calculating the prediction accuracy. It was found that at 100 number of trees,
718 under dry and vortex cooling conditions at 40m/min cutting speed. RFR predicted the highest prediction accuracy of 94.28 % on training data
and 88.88 % on test data. The summary of RFR implemented in Statistica
Experimental results have shown that vortex tube cooling has negative is given in Fig. 9. It can be seen that the average squared error is decreasing
influence on flank wear and surface roughness during low speed and remained almost stable at 100 number of trees. The results obtained
machining at 40m/min as shown in Fig. 7 a) and b). Dry machining gave from RFR for test data is shown in Table 2.
better surface roughness values and flank wear values increased for
vortex tube air cooling. Cooling method doesn’t seem to have influence on
tool life by reducing flank wear and hence there is no decrease in surface
roughness as well, instead it has negative effect. However, cutting
temperature is found to be lower in each machining pass than that for dry
machining as shown in Fig. 7 c) and is due to the heat carried away by the
vortex cold air jet from the vicinity of tool chip interface. Tool vibrations
have been found to be lower during vortex cooling assisted machining
than dry machining. Irrespective of the machining speed the cutting
vibrations are mostly same during all the passes when using cold air jet,
whereas dry machining tool vibrations show variations as depicted in Fig.
7 d) and decrease at the end of tool life.
Cite The Article: Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P, Mr. Gururaj K. (2019). Use of vortex tube air cooling during machining of
Inconel 718: Experimental Investigation and Modeling studies. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 42(5) : 127-131.
Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments (JMERD) 42(5) (2019) 127-131
[7] Anupam Agrawal, Saurav Goel, Waleed Bin Rashid, Mark Price.
2015. Prediction of surface roughness during hard turning of AISI 4340
steel (69 HRC), Applied Soft Computing 30, 279–286.
3. Vortex tube cooling has greatly reduced tool temperature during [11] Rusnaldy, Paryanto, Tony Suryo Utomo & Yusuf Umardani. 2011.
machining irrespective of cutting speed and feed used. Analysis of Air jet cooling effect on the turning process of St 40 Steel, (July
2011), Available: http://www.researchgate.net.
4. At lower speed, vortex tube cooling has resulted in higher surface
roughness and flank wear and lower cutting tool vibrations. [12] Ganesh S.Kadam & Raju S.Pawade. 2017. Completely Neat Eco-
friendly HSM of Inconel 718, Proc. of 10th Int. Conf. on Precision, Meso.
5. Irrespective of use of air cooling or not, the cutting tool vibrations Micro and Nano Engineering (COPEN 10), Dec 7-9, IIT Madras, Chennai,
reduce at the end of tool life for all the cutting speed and feeds 1026-1029.
investigated.
[13] Etory Madrilles Arruda & Lincoln Cardoso Brandao. 2017.
6. Dry machining has been proved to be a better choice for obtaining Performance study of multilayer carbide tool in high- speed turning of
good surface roughness and longer tool life at lower cutting speeds. API 5L X70 pipeline steel using a cold air system, Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol.
7. Random Forest Regression technique predicted that the cutting
temperature is the dominant parameter influencing surface [14] Munish Kumar Gupta, Catalin Iulian Pruncu, Mozammel Mia,
roughness, followed by cutting tool vibrations and feed rate. Flank Gururaj Singh, Sunpreet Singh, Chander Prakash, P.K.Sood & Harjot
wear and cutting speed were least significant variables. It gave a Singh Gill. 2018. Machinability Investigations of Inconel-800
prediction accuracy of 88.88 % on the test data. Super Alloy under Sustainable Cooling Conditions, Materials, 11-2088.
REFERENCES [15] Anthony Xavior M., Manohar M., Jeyapandiarajan, P., & Patil
Mahesh Madhukar. 2017. Tool wear assessment during machining of
[1] Yogesh Vasantrao Deshpande, Atul B.Andhare & Pramod Inconel 718, Procedia Engineering, 174, 1000-1008.
M.Padole. 2018. How cryogenic techniques help in machining of nickel
alloys? A review, Machining Science and Technology, 22:4, 543-584. [16] G. D’Mello, P. Srinivasa Pai, A. Prashanth. 2018. Surface Roughness
Analysis in High Speed Turning of Ti-6Al- 4V Using Coated Carbide
[2] Eren Kaya & Birol Akyuz. 2017. Effects of cutting parameters on Inserts: Experimental and Modeling Studies, Tribology in Industry, Vol.
machinability characteristics of Ni-based superalloys: a review, Open 40, No. 3, 457-476.
Eng., 7, 330-342.
[17] Yu, X., Hyyppä, J., Vastaranta, M., Holopainen, M., & Viitala, R..
[3] Elso Kuljanic, Marco Sortino & Giovanni Totis. 2010. 2011. Predicting individual tree attributes from airborne laser point
Machinability of difficult machining materials, Proc. of 14th clouds based on the random forests technique. ISPRS Journal of
International Research / Expert Conference Trends in the Development Photogrammetry and remote sensing, 66(1), 28-37.
of Machinery and Associated Technology, TMT 2010, Mediterranean
Cruise, 11 -18 September 2010, I-1 to I-14. [18] Statistica 12 Stastistical Software, Available at
http://documentation.statsoft.com/STATISTICAHelp.aspx?path=Ra
[4] D.Fernandez, V. Garcia Navas, A.Sanda & I.Bengoetxea. 2014. ndomForests/Overviews/TechnicalNotes
Comparison of machining Inconel 718 with Conventional and
Sustainable coolant, MM Science Journal, 506-510. [19] Agrawal, A., Goel, S., Rashid, W. B., & Price, M.. 2015.
Prediction of surface roughness during hard turning of AISI 4340
[5] P.J.Liew, U.S.Hashim, & M.N.A.Rahman. 2017. Effect of chilled air steel (69 HRC). Applied Soft Computing, 30, 279-286.
Cite The Article: Mr. Bhaskara P Achar, Mr. Grynal D’Mello, Dr. Srinivasa Pai P, Mr. Gururaj K. (2019). Use of vortex tube air cooling during machining
of Inconel 718: Experimental Investigation and Modeling studies. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research and Developments, 42(5) : 127-131.