Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Malaria Convulsions
Malaria Convulsions
Malaria Convulsions
net/publication/46272947
CITATIONS READS
44 3,985
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Targeted States High Impact Project a USAID funded five year project in Northern Nigeria View project
All content following this page was uploaded by William Brieger on 15 January 2016.
ABSTRACT
An understanding of community perceptions of illness, especially disease definitions
that are unique to a part~cularculture, is essential for developing culturally
appropriate primary health care programs. Malaria is endemic in the Ibarapa District
of Oyo State, Nigeria, and one of its major complications, febrile convulsions, affects
nearly one-third of preschool children a t least once in their lifetime. Perceptions
among the local Yoruba people categorize malaria and oonvulsions as part of two
different disease processes. Ideas of causation, severity, seasonality, and treatment
are in many ways opposites. This means that parents do not perceive the dangers of
convulsions when their children surfer malaria. Unfortunately the small children
themselves cannot be part of the decision-making process which involves potentially
toxic treatment practicer Based on an understanding of Yoruba beliefs, primary
health care and health education interventions have been designed that encourage
parents to take prompt action when they recognize that their child has malaria.
This work was sponsored by the Social and Economic Scientific Working Group of the
UNDPlWorld Bank/WHO Special Programme of Research and Training in Tropical Diseases.
Malaria is a major c a u g of morbidity and mortality in much of the developing On the positive side, progress is being made on vaccine development [ I 61 .
world. Thls disease is particularly dangerous to young children where high Also, pilot work on community organization and mobilization at the village level
temperatures lead to febrile convuIsions with possible brain damage and death. t o reduce vector breeding and vector-host contact has been encouraging [17].
Although a variety of extra-cranial infections produce hlgh temperatures whlch For the meantime, prompt treatment remains one of the major tools for malaria
provoke seizures, malaria is the most common 11, 21 . The peak incidence of control a t the community level.
febrile convulsions occurs between the ages of one and three years, a stage of Me Early recognition and prompt treatment with chloroquine-based anti-malarial
when the sufferer is least able to take personal protection for prevention 131. drugs (despite parasite resistance in some areas) is the choice of action [18].
Much of the adverse consequences of malaria are preventable by early This not only limits morbidity, but also controls the resevoir of infection [14] .
recognition and prompt treatment. However, quick action may not be taken for The mehcation and the supportive therapy of cooling the feverish child by
various cultural and social reasons. When parents do react after the disease has sponging with tepid water [19] , can easily be administered by trained volunteer
reached a crisis (i.e., convuIsions), their efforts are often more life-threatening primary health workers (PHWs)based in the village [lo].
than life-saving [4] . Health services aimed at solving such problems are often Even though prompt treatment is efficacious and feasible on technical
ineffective because definitions and categories of illness perceived by patients grounds, there remain social and cultural factors whch must be understood and
and disease entities diagnosed by physicians do not mesh [5] . A communication accounted for before successful interventions can be designed. In particular,
gap exists because both parties do not speak the same "illness language" [6]. these include local perceptions of the disease and its consequences.
Not surprisingly, community members frequzntly distinguish between illnesses
that are amenable to cure by western medicine and those which respond best to
traditional treatment 17, 81 . DISEASE PATTERN IN THE STUDY COMMUNITY
What is needed in this situation is an anthropological approach that Idere is one of seven major towns in the Ibarapa Local Government of Oyo
emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between people's subjective feeling State Nigeria. Its 10,000 citizens are divided between a main town (8,000) and
of illness and the biomedically defined phenomenon of disease 191. This approximately forty small farming hamlets (2,000). Idere has been the site for
approach was taken in the town of Idere in western Nigeria in order to learn research on primary health care and tropical disease control since 1978 [20].
local perceptions on cause, severity, treatment, and prevention of malaria. The Activities have included both regular epidemiological surveys by medical
results are presented here and form the basis of an educational diagnosis for students and operations research by faculty and graduate students from the
designing culturally relevant primary health care and health education University of Ibadan, which maintains a practical field training site in the
interventions in the community. Ibarapa District. Over the years a wealth of various types of data has been
gathered on the medical and social aspects of tropical diseases including malaria.
NATURE AND TREATMENT OF MALARIA Surveys have shown a point prevalence of 19 percent for malaria parasites in
bIood samples from Idere chldren aged two t o sixteen years. Idere dispensary
Malaria is a protozoal infection caused prlrnarily by Plasmodium falciparum records show that t w o - h r d s of all patients presenting complain of malaria or
and P. vivax. These are transmitted to humans by female mosquitos of the fever. Household survey (described below) indicated that over half (57%) of
Anopheles species. P. falcip~rum,which causes life-threatening cerebral malaria, residents recall experiencing malaria a t least once annually. In the nearby
abounds in tropical Africa and accounts for 160-170 million infections and Igbo-Ora Rural Health Centre's death register, malaria and febrile illness top the
about one mdlion infant and child deaths annually [lo] . In West Africa, malaria list of causes of mortality in preschool children. With this as background, the
transmission is stable throughout the year so that adults develop potent researchers needed next to explore how the community responded to the disease.
resistance, leaving infants and small children as the most common victims of the
disease [ l l ] .
h disease control efforts, primary or early prevention may be ideal, but in METHODS AND MATERIALS
reality intervention is not always feasible dw to technological, social, and A variety of data collection methods were employed over the period 1981-85,
economic reasons. In the case of malaria, major world-wide attempts at and included household surveys, case studies with clinic patients, and in-depth
eradication met with disappointment due to lack of continual organizational and field interviews with both trahtional healers and their potential patients.
financial support, growing resistance of mosquitos to insecticides and the Participant observation provided an o v e r - r i h g framework for study since the
increasing environmental threat of these chemicals I1 2- 1 51 . authors were actively involved in the local primary health care program. This
308 1 J. AAMAKRISHNA, W. 8 . BRIEGER AND J. D, A O E N l Y l MALARIA AND FEBRl LE CONVULSIONS 1 309
multi-method approach was found necessary to yield both breadth and depth of Table 1. Believed Causes of Malaria in ldere
information.
Caue Number Percent
Ln 1981, a head of household survey was conducted in all Idere homes, both
town and farm (1935 respondents). This gathered baseline data on existing Mosquito 553 28.6
beliefs, practices, and reported prevalence of four tropical diseases (Malaria, Dust 410 21.2
onchocerciasis, schstosomiasis, and guineaworm) and jaundice. f i s provided
raw material on common beliefs about cause, prevention, and treatment of
malaria.
While the survey data provided a broad baseline, they lacked the fine Overwork 35 1.8
distinctions, interrelationships, and rationahations needed to understand local
perceptions fully and consequently to design interventions in disease control. Disease Naturally in Body 35 1.8
Subsequently, fieldwork methods were added, These included intensive Excess Palm Oil 19 1.O
interviewing of key informants (tradtional healers, town elders, experienced Bad WeatherlCold 17 1.8
health staff). Case studies of patients visiting local health facilities were
developed with the help of medtcal students. In-depth interviews were Badllnadequate Blood 12 0.6
conducted by the authors in the homes of local mothers. Fieldwork helped t o
focus malaria in the context of local disease categories and perceptions. A more Don't Know 648 33.5
detailed traditional pharmacopaeia was also obtainable through interactive data ----.--___-----.-.--------------------------
gathering. N~ 1935
A particularly important realization gained through fieldwork was that local
beliefs do not associate malaria with convulsions. An additional survey of 352 a Local word for onchmerciasis.
Excess worry, heredity, termites, eating bad food. guineaworm,
Idere parents was therefore conducted to throw more light on the issue of bad waather, work of God, not enough blood, impure blood, kokoro
convulsions. The information gathered through the above processes was used as (insects) in the body.
the basis for designing training for volunteer PHWs and primary school teachers Multiple responses recorded.
in Idere.
Results on each of the two conditions, malaria and convulsions, will be
considered by focusing on recogrution, susceptibility, severity, and seasonality. Local beliefs peg peak prevalence for malaria in the hot, dry season. This is
Also, notions of cause, prevention, and treatment will be presented. Survey data not unconnected with local notions of causation. Table 1 shows that many Idere
will appear in tables with minimal description. Supportive information obtained residents can recite the "correct" cause of malaria as mosquitos (28.6%),but
through fieldwork methods will be interwoven to give greater clarity to survey data. traditional ideas like suntheat (6.4%) and dust (2 1.2%), all common during the
dry season, persist. It is noteworthy that supernatural notions of cause were
extremely rare. The belief that malaria is caused by eating excessive red palm oil
PEHCEPTIONS OF MALARIA (1 .Wo) may connect malaria with iba ponju.
Malaria in the Yoruba language is known as iba and is recognized by high The relative large proportion of respondents who say they do not know a
temperature, chllls, and aches. In addition, people ascribe jaundice-like cause of malaria (33.5%) probably reflects a reluctance to reveal traditional
symptoms of yellow eyes and dark urine to malaria. Not surprisingly, the local beliefs during a large scale and impersonal survey. This reinforces the need to
name for jaundice is iba ponju or fever with yellow eyes. rely on a variety of investigative methods.
Through informal interviews it was gathered that people feel that all age There is little concensus on preventive measures for malaria (Table 2), with n o
groups are susceptible to malaria, though children may be more prone to it. Iba idea being the most common response (60.2%). Although a number of people
is not regarded as a serious problem, but a simple common indisposition which blamed mosquitos for causing malaria (28.6%), only 17.1 percent could mention
most people suffer from time to time. This lack of perceived seriousness is borne a mosquito-related preventive measure (nets, insecticide, coil, clearing bushes).
out by cluuc experience. Patients of all ages not uncommonly report with A few suggestions related to traditional notions of causation-avoid dust, heat,
hstories of fever lasting two, three, or more days. sun, excessive palm oil, and overwork.
310 1 J. RAMAKRtSHNA. W. R. BRIEGER AND J. 0. ADENIYI M A L A R I A AND FEBRILE CONVULSIONS 1 31 1
Table 2. Reported Malaria Prevention Activities in ldere purchased from local drug sellers. In-depth interview found that self-treatment
is the norm. Preferred modern drugs are antipyretizs/analgesics (e.g., aspirin)
Preventive Method Number Percent rather than anti-malarials whch cause itchng in some people. Even when an
anti-malarial drug is taken, a lower dosage or shorter regimen than recommended
Mosquito Coil, Net, Spray 204 10.5
is often used. The lower cost of self-treatment, particularly the traditional herbal
concoctions, is a major deciding factor in its choice.
Modern Drug Interviews with traditional healers and community members confirm that agbo
is the most common local medication for malaria. Agbo is made from family
Clear Surrounding Bushes 1 28 6.6
recipes that are handed down through generations and shared among close
Avoid Dust 33 1.7 friends. Almost everyone knows a formula, so knowledge is not exclusive to
Avoid HeatlSun traditional healers. The most common ingredients include mango, neem, orange,
lemon or pawpaw leaves, lime juice, lime peel, and lemon grass. The
Others
ingrebents are boiled in a clay pot for at least one hour. Dosage is flexible but
No Idea 11 65 60.2 consists of at least one cup per day. The concoction is drunk for three days by
_.__f_f____________--------.---+------------.-.--.------------------------------+---
which time the patient is usually said to have recovered. Smaller quantities are
lllC 1935 given to chddren. As supportive therapy, the steam from hot agbo can be
local herbal drink. inhaled, while the cooled mixture can be used for bathng.
Rest, decrease palm oil intake, prayer. blood tonic, boil wafer. Agbo is said to remove all the bad things in the body through sweat and urine.
Multiple responses recorded. Some claim that agbo is longer acting than chloroquine because it stays in the
body and continues to work.
Table 3. Reported Malaria Treatment Practice in lbarapa
--
Table 4. Recognition of Convulsion by Idere Parents Table 5. Believed Causes of Convulsion in ldere
-.
Symptom Number Percent Cause Number Percenr
Spasms Coldness 79 22.4
Crying
Heredity 72 20.4
Clenched Teeth
High Temperature
High Temperature 42 11.9
Lethargy
Fixed Gaze Dirty Environment 10 2.8
Table 7. Reported Treatment Measures for Convulsions in ldere During further interview, mothers advise that a convulsing child must be kept
warm by placing him, especially hls feet, close to the fire. A child who suffers
Measure Number Percent chronic convulsions is "fumigated" over a fire containing dried peppers.
~ g b inu
o ;gos 121 34.4
DANGERS AND DIVERGENCES
ile tutub
~gbo 90 25.6
70 19.9 A major motivating concern for this study was the greater risk of febrile
Other Agbo
convulsions experienced by Nigerian chldren compared to their counterparts in
Salt and Water 60 17.0 industrialized nations. According to Jolly, only 5 percent of preschool children
Go t o Clinic 27 7.7 in developed countries experience febrile convulsions, but reports from Idere are
approximately six times greater [l ] .
Spoon in Mouth
Idere parents recognize the true seriousness of convulsions, but ironically the
Native Cream traditional treatments put the child at greater risk. Concoctions containing cow's
Herbal Soap 4 1.1 urine produce hypoglycaemia with its scquelae: electrolyte derrangement,
vascular constriction, car diotoxic effects, and carhorespiratory distress [2, 3, 2 1,
Others 22 6.2
__*___._..._f.f*
_._+------------.-+---------------------.-------------.-.---..-.---- 221 . Children may suffer burns and pepper induced conjunctivitis during
attempts at resuscitation from coma after convulsion 14, 231 .
Other ingredients are also harmful. Napthalene is a poison and tobacco is
Drink made of onion, robacco, cow's urine, dcohol. toxic to the cardiovascular system [4] . The goal of traditional treatment is to
b Drink made of leaves, room steeped in water.
Multiple responm recorded. cause the chlld to vomit, but when the patient is semi- or unconscious, he could
inhale the regurgitated concoction whch leads to fatal bronchopneumonia [2 1] .
Ironically the goal of keeping the chld warm may actually sustain the high
temperature and speed the onset of convulsions.
Treatment in the initial stages of ile tutu consists mainly of efforts to keep Simple communication t o avoid these practices is inadequate in the face of
the suspected c M d warm-wearing extra clotlung, covering the child, sitting near disease perceptions that differ so markedly from medical views. Foremost among
the fire. After convulsion strikes the more potent form of agbo, oo gun inu igo these perceptions is the lack of acknowledged relationship between iba and ile
(medicine in a bottle) is used. This mixture is made from a variety of substances: tutu or giri. Consequently, malaria is not seen as serious and prompts little quick
shredded onion and tobacco leaves, camphor, napthalene, and animal bile are and appropriate action that could prevent convulsions. This view is not such an
soakedin either water, local gin, schnapps, or cow's urine. This is kept in a anathema when one considers that the adults who hold the view are t o a large extent
corked bottle and found hanging from the kitchen rafters in most houses, ready immune to malaria, and naturally would see an attack as a relatively inconsequential
for emergency use. If the preparation has not been used in about one year, a experience. A slrmlar perspective was found in the upper hhssissippe Valley of the
new mixture is prepared. Although most people can name some of the United States in the nine teenth century where "in the beginning the 'chills' were
ingredients for oo gun inu igo, only experienced mothers and elderly men know regarded as anecessary element of the inevitable 'acclimatization' and after having
the exact proportions. the 'shakes' for years, people got so used to it that they hardly paid attention t o a
One spoonful is the recommended dosage. The action of the drug is believed little 'ague.' This is a clear example of how an objectively dangerous and burden-
t o be related to the strong smell and foul taste. Ideally it should cause the c h l d some bodily condition can subjectively, by social convention, even lose the
to vomit andlor defecate thereby purging the bad substances associated with the
character of disease" [24]. Closer to home, the Uhrobo people of Bendel State,
disease.
Nigeria, also view malaria as an ordinaq inconvenience requiring little worry [2S].
Another treatment consists of half a teaspoon of an imported patent medicine
Table 8 synthesizes traditional perceptions of the two diseases and gives
containing 90 percent alcohol, called Alcool de Menthe. Salt in the mouth is also
further reason why Idere people would see little connection between iba and ile
recommended for keeping the child's mouth open and causing hrn to vomit. A
rum. The two are seen incorrectly as being more common at different times of
spoon or other long object is usually placed between the convulsing child's teeth
the year. Although endemic year round, malaria is more frequent when the rains
to keep him from biting his tongue. Additional treatments include herbal soaps,
increase the available mosquito breeding sites, but, of course, Idere people do not
cream, and ointments, whch may also be used prophylactically. These measures blame mosquitos for malaria.
are summarized in Table 7.
Table 8. Comparison of Traditional Yoruba Perceptions of Malaria and Febrile Convulsions
Recognized
Disease Symptoms Susceptibility Seriousness Season Causes Prevention Treatment
Iba High Temperature All Persons Not Serious Hotlory Sun Agbo Agbo to Drink,
(Malaria) Headache though more Heat (Herbal Drink) Inhale, Bathe
Weakness in Children Dust Avoid Sun, Heat,
Joint Pains Overwork Dust, Overwork,
Shivering/Chills Eating or Palm Oil
Yellow Eyes Excess Agunmu
Yellow Urine Palm Oil (Herb Powder)
2
0, Ile Tutu Early: Small Children Very Serious ColdWet Exposure Agbo Agbo with
(Cold Earth) Coldness especially t o Cold or Keep Child COW'SUrine
Shivering Heavy Ones Cold Things Warm Alcohol
Gasping Heredity Salt in Mouth
Crying out in Spoon in
Sleep Mouth
Later : Keep Chi Id
Convulsions/ near Fire
Spasms
Clenched Teeth
Crying
Fainting
318 1 J. RAMAKRISHNA, W. R. BRIEGER AND J. D. ADENlY l MALARIA AND FEBRILE CONVULSIONS 1 319
In closing, it is necessary to give further emphasis to the value of multi- 14. L. Molineaux and G. Gramiccia, The Gorki Rojecr, Research on the
method data gathering strategies. The formal household survey alone would not Epidemiology and Control of Malaria in the Sudan Savanna of West Afn'ca,
have been adequate to design culturally relevant PHW training. Because the World Health Organization, Geneva, 1980.
researchers did not perceive a distinction between malaria and febrile 1 5 . P. Yekutiel, Lessons from the Big Eradication Campaigns, World Health
convulsions,it did not occur to them to phrase survey questions in a way that Forum, 2, pp. 465-48 1, 1981.
16. J. Maurice, Malaria, Fighting "The Big One" on Three Fronts, Afn'cu Health,
would hifight local beliefs about convulsions. Follow-upwith qualitative
7, p. 22, 1985.
methods provided an in-depth understanding of local perceptions. This was used
17. P, Demissie, The Role of Community Participation in the Control of
in designing the second survey of parents whlchyielded more relevant and accurate Malaria, Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Preventive a n d Social Medicine,
response. Ideally, fieldwork methods should have even preceded the o r i p a l University of Ibadan, Nigeria, 1985.
baseline survey, and this is a major lesson whch was learned from the Idere project 18. Centers for Disease Control, Malaria: Training Course for Instructors in
and is being passed on to other health educators who are reading this article. Corn bating Childhood Communicable Diseases, International Health
Programs Office, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, 1 985.
19. D. Werner, Where There Is No Doctor, Macmillan, London, 1 979.
REFERENCES
20. S. U. Akpovi, D. C. Johnson, and W. R. Brieger, Guineaworm Control:
1. H. Jolly,Disawss of Children, Blackwell Scientific Publications, The Enghsh Testing the Efficacy of Health Education in Primary Health Care,
Language Book Society, Oxford, 198 1. ZnternutionaI JournaI of Health Education, 24: 4 , pp. 229-237, 1 98 1.
2. J. 8. Familusi and C. H. Sinnette, Febrile Convulsions in Ibadan Children, 21. R. A. Elegbe, S. 0.Bamgbme, and D. D. Oyebola, Cow's Urine Poisoning in
African Journal of Medical Sciences,2, pp. 135-149, 197 1. Nigeria: The Cardiotoxic Effects of Cow's Urine Concoction on
3. B. 0.Osuntokun, Anticonvulsant Therapy, Folic Acid Deficiency, and Anaesthetized Cats, JournaI of Tropical Pediatrics, 22, pp. 232-235, 1976.
Neuropsychiatric Disorders, British Medical Journal, 2, pp. 636-637, 1969. 22. R. A. Elegbe and D. D. Oyebola, Cow's Urine Poisoning in Nigeria:
4. B. 0. Osuntokun, E. L. Odeku, and C. H. Sinnette, Convulsive Disorders in Cardiorapiratory Effects of Cow's Urine in Dogs, Transactions of the Royal
Nigeria: The Febrile Convulsions, East African Medical Journal, 46, Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 71, pp. 127- 1 32, 1977.
pp. 385-394, 1969. 23. F. A. Ofodile and J. 0.Oluwasanmi, Burning the Feet to Treat Convulsions,
5. L. Eisenberg, Disease and Illness: Distinctions Between Professional and British Journal of Plastic Surgery, 31, p. 356, 1978,
Popular Ideas o f Sickness, Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry, 1 , pp. 9-23, 24. E. H. Ackerknecht, Malaria in the Upper Mississippi Valley 1 760-1 900,
1977. Bulietin of the History of Medicine, (Supplement No. 4 ) , Johns Hopkins
6. M. K. Nations, L. A. Camino, and F. B. Walker, "Hidden" Popular Illness in University Press, Baltimore, p. 4, 1945.
Primary Care: Residents' Recognition and Clinical Implications, Culture, 25. U. A. Igun, Models of Health Seeking Behaviour, in Nigerian Perspectives on
Medicine, and Psychiatry, 9, pp. 2 2 3 - 2 4 0 , 1985. Medical Sociology, A. Erinosho (e d.), Department of Anthropology, College
7. H. S. Could, The Implications of Technolodcal Change for Folk and of William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia, pp. 59-78, 1982.
Scientific Medicine, American Anthropologist, 59, pp. 507-5 16, 195 7. 26. W. R. Brieger and S. U. Akpovi A Health Education Approach t o Training
8. 3. Lozoff, K. R. Kamath, and R. A. Feldman, Infection and Disease in South ViUap Health Workers,ZnternationuI Quarterly of Community Health
Indian Families: Beliefs about Childhood Diarrhoea, Human Organization, Education, 3, pp. 145-15 2 , 1982-83.
34, pp. 353-358,1975. 27. W. R. Brieger, J, Rarnakrishna, S. U. Akpovi, and J. D. Adeniyi,
9. G.M. Foster and B. G. Anderson, Medico1 Anthropology, John Wiley and Organizational Development as a Health Education Strategy to Maintain
Sons, New York, 1978. Community Involvement in PHC Management, International Quarterly of
10. UNDP/World Bank/WHO, Report of the Steering Committee of the Community Health Education, 8:4, pp. 35 1-374, 1487-88.
Scientific Working Groups on Malaria, June 198BJune 1983, TDR/MAL/
SC-SWG/8@83/83.3, 1983. b r e c t reprint requests to:
1 1. A. 0.Lucas and H. M. Gilles, A Short Textbook of Preventive Medicine for Y.WWmR.m
WiIliarn R. Brieger, M.P.H. l a w . ~ r wn R d .
the Tropics, The Enghsh Universities Press, London, 1973. Whir. W) P101+59a9
12. L. J. Bruce-Chwatt, The Challenge of Malaria: Crossroads or Impasse, in African Regional Health Education Centre
Tropical Medicine: From Romance t o Reality, C . Wood (ed.), Academic Department of Preventive and Social Medicine
Press, London, 1978. University of Ibadan
13. M. A. Farid, The Malaria Programme-From Euphoria to Anarchy, World Ibadan, Nigeria
Health Forum, 1 , pp. 5-22, 1980.
View publication stats