Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dh43ibc01 31171024313 Coca Cola
Dh43ibc01 31171024313 Coca Cola
Học kỳ doanh nghiệp (Trường Đại học Kinh tế Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank the individuals and organizations that have supported me so that I
can complete this graduation thesis.
First of all, I would like to deliver my gratitude to Mrs. Duong Ngoc Hong, the instructor
guiding the graduation thesis implementation. Thank you for always enthusiastically
guiding, giving useful advice in the process of implementing the topic and helping me
learn more knowledge and skills needed.
I wish you good health and success in life and wish CCBVL develop further shortly
Yours Faithfully,
ii
ENDORSEMENT
This graduation report was written by me and not copied from any articles of any other
organization or individual. I hereby certify that all data and research results mentioned in
this report are true. Any assistance in the implementation of this report has been gratefully
acknowledged and the information cited in the report has been traced and authorized for
publication.
Author
iii
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recognizing the significance of customer satisfaction to every company, especially for
the FMCG field and the issue within CCBVL in the GT channel, the study is conducted in
the scope of Ho Chi Minh City to analyze the factors that affect the satisfaction of outlet
owners purchasing Coca- Cola products, as a result, brings out some recommendations for
the company.
After analyzing the SWOT of the company and based on the preliminary scale of previous
researchers, the quantitative methodology is used to figure out the relationship between
customer satisfaction and the listed factors. The data is collected from 137 retailers in Ho
Chi Minh City and is analyzed by SmartPLS 3.0. After using the Outer model to test the
reliability of our scale, the Inner model is used to test the relationship among hypotheses
and the proposed model. The outcome is that the Process, Information, Service, Perceived
Value have direct effects on Customer Satisfaction and Expectation also have indirect
influence through Perceived Value
The study also comes up with some recommendations for the company to enhance the
satisfaction of retailers- who are important links between the company and end-users. All
the recommendations are stated in practical ways and adjusted to be compatible with
CCBVL context. The author also points out the strategy for corporate in the next 2 years
in the potential region as Ho Chi Minh City
iv
TABLE OF CONTENT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................. i
ENDORSEMENT ................................................................................................................ii
INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................ 1
vi
3.1.4 Identifying target potential customers for giving promotions & improving the
process of giving promotion ........................................................................................ 42
CONCLUSION .................................................................................................................. 46
REFERENCE ..................................................................................................................... 47
vii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. 1 CCBVL Internship Task .................................................................................... 15
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
ix
LIST OF ACRONYMS
ASM: Area Sales Manager
AVE: Average Variance Extracted
CCBVL: Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited
CR: Composite Reliability
CSR: Corporate Social Responsibility
FMCG: Fast-Moving Consumer Goods
The GT channel: The General Trade Channel
MNC: Multinational Company
MT Channel: The Modern Trade Channel
PLS-SEM: Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling
RCM: Regional Commercial Manager
SEM: Structural Equation Modeling
SmartPLS: Smart partial least squares
SR: Sale Representative
TSM: Territory Sales Manager
INTRODUCTION
Internship Background
FMCG is one of the biggest industries nowadays with undeniable growth and it is
considered to be a competitive field. The Coca- Cola Company appeared to be the top
MNC in the Beverage Industry all over the world, and in Vietnam as well which for years
it has occupied the top rank in compared with competitors. The Coca- Cola Company has
succeeded in gaining a huge market share, with impressive marketing campaigns and
effective business strategies. As a result, I9m honored to have a chance to be an intern in
Commercial Department- Routes to Market team, of Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam
Limited, which I believe that in the time here, I could achieve a load of experience and
knowledge of FMCG industry, specifically, in <Route to market= field- which would give
me a wider and deeper sight of the supply chain in The GT channel from the distributors
to consumers, and how to build and plan effective sale routes to create the benefits for the
company and the satisfaction of customers in of one of the most outstanding companies in
Beverages field. Besides, working under the culture of a leading MNC, I could build
myself a professional style and a good attitude in work, which definitely one of the
decisive factors in my career development in the future.
Reasons for choosing the topic
FMCG is usually unable to create sustainable loyalty. Recognizing one of the problems
that affect sale performance is the dissatisfaction of the customers, and the problems
staying in the selling operation and the route to market probably cause that, which leads to
their purchasing decision of switching to use products from competitors or another source
of suppliers.
Customer data is not updated continuously, a lot of data has not been checked and
updated for many years, leading to errors and the stagnancy in delivery time, or delivery
to wrong destinations. Inaccurate information also consumes resources of the company in
trade marketing programs, customer service, while some outlets have not received
appropriate promotions, which intensely affect to the satisfaction of customers
Sale Representative (SR) mostly sells according to habit, many outlets, even though they
are on the route, are not visited and offered regularly, leading to their loss and
dissatisfaction, which is also one of the reasons for customers to switch to use products of
competitors or did not purchase directly from CCBVL distributors
Moreover, the rate of SR turnover is still quite high. When the old SR is off, the new SR
does not capture the entire sales route and the old SR's customers, which leads to a break
in continuing to do business with the customer, thereby losing a large number of
customers. This can lead to customers being able to switch to a competitor's products. Or
in some cases, for each customer, there will be a special note and unique service, when
the old SR - who knows how to best serve each customer quits his job, the practical
experiences from the old person has not passed on to the new one, leading to the
dissatisfaction of the outlet owners, or the frustration of having to work with a different
employee.
In general, the performance of some SRs are not totally good, although the company's
resources have poured down a lot, and always run continuously promotions and
marketing programs for customers, because SR does not offer and introduce, the company
does not collect results as desired. Some customers stated that they used their competitor's
products because they received a promotion program that benefited them, while the
programs of the company offered were not less competitive. The company also provides
goods such as umbrellas, tables, and chairs, ... but often the products that are used to serve
its customers are transferred or appear in outlets, businesses that do not use Coca- Cola
products, or become inventories, cannot be used, consumes company resources and does
not bring value as the company planned and implemented as originally planned.
Based on the reality above, which can be considered as significant issues of the
commercial department of CCBVL that since we could not fulfill the demand of the
customers, especially for The GT channel, and for years, it has brought serious damage to
the company, thesis analyzes in detail about the reality of the routes to market of CCBVL,
point of the problem existing and from that, bring out the effective solution to enhance the
satisfaction of the customers.
billion USD, taking to account the establishment period to 2020. Coca- Cola always
strives to create positive differences on the path of growth, the real and lasting benefit for
both the nation and the civilians. The organization has continually invested in a high-tech
and environmentally sustainable manufacturing system since 2013. Coca- Cola is tightly
regulated at any point of development. Coca- Cola has launched the intelligent factory
model, in particular to apply the production approach in Industry 4.0. This is a business
breakthrough that marks environmental growth, increases the quality and efficacy of the
whole system, and leads to the conservation of the environment
Coca- Cola is constantly searching for, exploring, and innovating and introducing new
lines of high-quality drinks that meet desire, preferences, fitness, and varied customer
lifestyle, making them a beverage brand that can satisfy everybody. Convenient to
packaging and offering specific nutritional information, Coca-Cola uses to minimize
sugar in many items, launch new products with a high essential nutrient quality, which
lets consumers make appropriate purchase decisions
Building and preparation of qualified human capital are not considered one of Coca-
Cola's strategic priorities outside of the goal of improving socio-economic services in
Vietnam. The business spends 1.4 million USD per year to improve Vietnamese workers
while at the same time building an optimal environment for its employees
1.1.3 Core value and culture
The values of Coca- Cola are:
Teamwork: Working together to support one another and to motivate one another.
A strong culture is a crucial element for MNC such as Coca-Cola not only to encourage
successful corporate growth but also to create a uniquely coordinating behavior for the
organization. On the market we are, and where we connect with our customers, "Either
we sell or assist in selling." We behave as owners: Keep an industry spirit; completely
comprehend the practice-related approach in our sector. We want to win and enjoy
together by incorporating 'playing together by hard work with a balance'
Vinh Long have the financial and economic opportunities. Duration. In EKOCENTERs
and in Northwestern provinces, the entrepreneurial training programs, specifically
targeted at local women, have been created
1.2 Organizational Structure
1.2.1 Business Performance
10
With a diversified beverages structure from carbonated beverages, green tea, energy drinks,
purified water ... Suntory Pepsi has an outstanding revenue scale, reaching more than
18,300 billion VND in 2019 - an increase of 2,300 billion compared to the year before and
outstripped the two following businesses Coca-Cola (9,300 billion) and Tan Hiep Phat
(9,200 billion). In fourth place, representative from the Philippines also pursued fiercely
with more than 7,000 billion VND. There is no official statistic, but fifth place is likely to
belong to Masan Consumer. Masan Consumer's beverage segment revenue in 2019 reached
nearly VND 5,600 billion, of which VND 3,500 billion came from bottled beverages
(mineral water, energy drinks ...) and the rest came from instant coffee, cereals. Other large
beverage businesses generally have a much smaller scale such as La Vie (belonging to
Nestle) with 3,000 billion VND, Kirin Interfood reaching 1,600 billion, Red Bull reaching
1,000 billion…
10000 20%
8000 15%
15% 14%
6000
11% 10%
4000
2000 5%
0 0%
Suntory Pepsi Coca- Cola Tan Hiep Phat URC Masan Consumer
11
the largest revenue proportion to the total, it needs to be more efforts to occupy this
region. The statistics in Mekong Delta regions show that CCBVL is behind the
competitors, which should be taken into account to find a solution
12
which can meet the demand, taste, nutrition, and the diverse lifestyle of consumers. In
practice, Coca- Cola proceeds to reduce sugar on many products, introduces new drinks
with high essential nutrients, convenient packaging, and provides clear nutritional
information which helps consumers easier to bring out an appropriate purchasing
decision. As an example, in March 2018, Coca- Cola launched a new product line: Coca-
Cola added pure coffee. In 100ml product capacity, 50% reduction in sugar and 30%
more caffeine than traditional Coca- Cola.
Established in 1994, CCBVL with its leading product is carbonated drinks, now
diversifies the products with different kinds of packaging, flavors, colors,… such as
Fanta, Sprite, Minute Maid, Nutriboost, Dasani, Fuze Tea, Aquarius, Samurai,… These
are all famous brand of Coca- Cola at more than 200 countries all over the world. On the
26 years journey of establishing and developing in Vietnam, CCBVL has aimed to
become a comprehensive beverages brand, not only focusing on carbonated beverages.
The company always strives to innovate traditional products to meet the demand and
suitable for the taste of Vietnamese, which can be seen in launching Fanta Lemon, Fanta
Strawberry, ... Coca- Cola always pays an attention to the diversity and nutrition in each
line of product. In 2016, Coca- Cola launched sugar-free Coca to compete directly with
Pepsi, at the same time responding to the increasing trend of consumers to use low-sugar
drinks to avoid obesity and sugar-related diseases. Up till 2020, the key products of Coca-
Cola in the Vietnam market can be considered are Coca- Cola, Dasani Water, and
Nutriboost Fruit Milk
- Coca-Cola: With 4 main products, such as Coca-Cola Original with original
flavors - was created and developed in 1886, Coca-Cola Light minimizes sugar,
Coca-Cola Zero has no sugar. To reduce conditions associated with obesity, Coca-
Cola Plus adds dietary fiber
- Dasani: Since its launch in Vietnam, all Dasani bottled water products are in a
recyclable PET plastic bottle. In addition to using recyclable and reusable
materials, Coca-Cola now continues to work to reduce waste by discarding PET
shrink film on Dasani bottled water. The removal of the plastic shrink film
completely does not affect the quality of Dasani bottled water products. Dasani's
13
reliable design with a cap securely attached to the bottleneck ensures quality and
safety. Dasani bottled water products always comply with the strict Coca- Cola
standards of products and ingredients in general, as well as the quality of bottled
water in particular.
- Nutriboost: A product that always puts product quality and the health of the user
first. Each Nutriboost bottle, before being delivered to the consumer, is subjected
to a rigorous review process from raw material input, production to finished
product. In addition to the two main ingredients: New Zealand high-quality milk
and premium juice, no colorants, no preservatives, Nutriboost is also fortified with
essential micronutrients for the body such as vitamins B3, B6, E, Protein, Calcium,
and Zinc. Nutriboost used to struggle in the Vietnamese market in its early stages,
but by changing its unique strategy, now the Nutriboost brand has become one of
the three key products of CCBVL.
14
15
Solution team, National Commercial Transformation & Digital team. Each team has its
purpose and mission and cross- collaborates to enhance the performance of one of the
most important parts of the company- Commercial Department
Collaborating with the Providing SR with technical support in the EDS project.
Sales team at Distributor
On-field checking the status of operation of the outlets and
houses
taking notes of special cases
Designing Optimal Sale Adopting assigned tasks related to review and align with
Routes regions for routes after route optimization in Ho Chi Minh
City
16
Conclusion of Chapter 1
This chapter analyzes the introduction of CCBVL and the Internship Position includes (1)
Overview of the company, (2) Organizational Structure, (3) Introduction of Internship
Position. Through this chapter, key information of The Coca- Cola Company and CCBVL
is summarized and the job description, as well as the internship department, is also
demonstrated
17
18
Number of brands
19
diners, restaurants, café, etc with large sales volume which buying directly from CCBVL
and sell to end-users). In addition, wholesalers and retailers are included in the GT
channel. The business has two types at the wholesale level: Exclusive Distributor and
Wholesales. Although wholesales are wholesalers who traded a wide variety of goods
including products from Coca-Cola competitors, in the Coca-Cola distribution channel,
the exclusive distribution system plays a crucial role because CCBVL is an instrument to
gain an advantage over Pepsi. CCBVL has 25 exclusive distributors all over Ho Chi Minh
city and neighbors including Bien Hoa and Binh Duong up until August 2020. Each
distributor takes charge of from 2000 to 4000 outlets depending on operation areas. The
Commercial Department is assigned the task of managing the distribution channel. To
accomplish this task, this department has established various teams to serve each type of
customer such as the Retail team, the Whole Sales team, the Supermarket team, and the
Key Accounts team. Currently, CCBVL has 3 million Sale Representatives in the whole
of Ho Chi Minh City.
During a year, approximately 50 compensation programs are run for customers. One of
the most significant programs that can be considered is <Loyalty Program= which will
award 4 Dasani Cases for retailers that meet the requirement of displaying and
purchasing. Moreover, Window programs will change from month to month which
provides customers with different awards based on the package they choose
2.1.2 Weaknesses
Carbonated drinks are one of the major sources of sugar intake. It results in two grave
health issues – obesity and diabetes. Coca-Cola is the biggest manufacturer of carbonated
beverages. Many health experts have prohibited the use of these soft drinks. It is a
controversial issue for the company. However, Coca-Cola has not devised any health
alternative or solution for this problem yet.
Negative publicity is also an issue of CCBVL, since, at the end of December 2019,
CCBVL had to receive an administrative penalty decision on tax through tax compliance
inspection with the total amount of more than 821.4 billion VND. The management
agency said that this enterprise had made false declarations, resulting in a lack of payable
tax amounts. Out of a total of 821.4 billion VND, 471 billion VND is in arrears.
20
21
the demand of flavors, health, nutrition, ... From these achievements, Coca- Cola can
continue to investigate and introduce more kinds of products, which contribute to their
total revenue and help them branch out from carbonated drinks.
Bring advanced supply chain systems – Coca- Cola9s business is entirely dependent upon
logistics and supply chain. Besides, investing and continuously updating tech as well as
enhancing using modern machines help Coca- Cola reduce significantly labor cost,
operating, and administration costs. Thus, coming up with some advanced and improved
systems for distribution can be an opportunity.
Coca- Cola has purchased several packaged drinking water brands, which give it a huge
advantage of deducting cost and being independent of third parties. Owning these
companies helps Coca- Cola expand the operation and avoid the risk and pressure from
third parties.
With the large market share, CCBVL is potential to investigate and invest more to expand
the market in different regions of Vietnam, especially in the Mekong Delta regions, where
Pepsi is the leading Beverages Company.
Coca- Cola also has the opportunity to advertise its less popular products. With a large
income, it has the available money to put some of these other beverages on the market.
This could be very beneficial to the company if they could start selling these other
products to the same extent that they do with their main products.
Another undeniable opportunity of Coca- Cola is its ability to purchase competitors9
companies, although this task is almost impossible with even large corporates. With the
financial potential and power in beverages fields, Coca- Cola has succeeded in buying
countless numbers of brands, and obviously, turning their profits into its profits and
reducing intense competition in the market. Brand awareness is a significant factor
affecting Coca- Cola competitive position. Despite the fact Coca Cola is already well-
known by 90% of the world population, it wants to get its brand name known even better
and possibly get closer and closer to 100%. As its plan occurs, Coca- Cola has an
opportunity to continue to widen the gap between them and their competitors.
22
2.1.4 Threats
People have lately been more worried than ever with health, so it is no doubt that because
of the high sugar and calorie content they are beginning to decrease their intake of
carbonated drinks. This means that Coca-Cola must launch healthier product lines while
keeping the name from being ruined. Changing customer habits poses a disturbing
menace to Coca- Cola and other drinks business firms.
Although Coca- Cola is one of the leading companies in the beverages industry,
competition is intensely increasing, especially in the Vietnamese market, where the
annual beverages industry's growth rate is steadily increasing by 6-7% regularity. In
addition to the fierce competition with Pepsi, CCBVL has to be wary of two domestic
brands Chuong Duong Corp and Tan Hiep Phat Beverages Group because these two
companies have the advantage of understanding the market and taste Vietnam. In general,
the market share of CCBVL is relatively far behind Pepsi, and it also one of the biggest
threats of the competition of Coca- Cola in the Vietnam market
10
21 40
29
23
CCBVL is very strongly levied directly and implicitly on laws and taxes of the
Vietnamese government. Anti-currency conversion tools are legalized under legislation,
including tax administration principles for each form of company or profile transaction
value calculation, for the prevention of tax evasion by currency conversion over the past
years. The brand success and revenue sources can be profoundly influenced here.
It is necessary for the organization to manage its image by removing negative public
sentiment. With tax avoidance, when routinely reviewed and advertised by tax industries,
CCBVL is in danger of losing reputation in the Vietnamese economy. In comparison,
TVC and other media promotional material uses the term "Mo lon Vietnam" and causes
ferocious uproar as the sentence does not conform to fine customs in Vietnam.
2.2 Research methodology
2.2.1 Purpose of study
Identifying the factors that affect customer satisfaction and bringing out the
recommendations for enhancing the satisfaction of retailers of Coca- Cola Beverages
Vietnam Limited
2.2.2 Subjects of the study
(i) The factors which have influence on customer satisfaction.
(ii) The strategies of improving the satisfaction of the customer
2.2.3 Scope of the study
The research is conducted in outlets that are customers of Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam
Limited in Ho Chi Minh City
2.2.4 Research Process
24
25
come back, on the other hand, when customers are dissatisfied, they are more likely to
find other options (Heskett et al., 1994; Strauss et al., 2001; Zairi, 2000). Stated by
Anderson and Sullivan, 1993; Fornell, 1992; Rust et al., 2004; Shemwell et al., 1998 in
the literatures of customer satisfaction, service quality is perceived as important factor as
it is an antecedent of customer satisfaction. In addition, Boshoff and Tait, 1996 give the
opinion that examining the employee9s behavior is critical since the interaction between
customers and employees sharply affects customer satisfaction. Instead of being
theoretical, Gowing and Lindholm (2002) opined that it should be based on the
relationship of the prevailing culture of the organization. Gale and wood (1994) favored
customer value and the creation of such quality and service that customers can visualize
pay attention and see. Also, it was recommended to re-designing generic strategies to
improve the satisfaction of the customer. In a study conducted by Leeds (1992), in
businesses where the underlying products have become commodity-like, quality of
service depends strongly on the quality of its personnel. Documents conducted by
Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry (1993) illustrated SERVQUAL which delivers the basis
for the measurement of customer satisfaction with a service by using the gap between the
customer's expectation of performance and their perceived experience of performance.
This provides the researcher with a satisfaction "gap" which is semi-quantitative in nature.
Cronin and Taylor extended the disconfirmation theory by combining the "gap" described
by Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry as two different measures (perception and
expectation) into a single measurement of performance relative to expectation.
Based on the research model of the study <Flexible approach to satisfaction index: an
Indian case study of health drink sector= (Sadia Samar Ali and Faizan Ahmad, 2010),
combining and adapting factors in accordance with the research environment in Vietnam,
the study has provided an initial research model for the study <The factors affect to the
satisfaction of outlet owners who are customers of Coca Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited
in The GT channel in Ho Chi Minh City= with 5 factors have influences on the
satisfaction of retailers purchasing Coca- Cola
26
Figure 2. 4 Proposed Framework of the factors affect the satisfaction of outlet owners
who are customers of Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited in The GT channel in Ho
Chi Minh City
Source: Flexible approach to satisfaction index: an Indian case study of health drink
sector (Sadia Samar Ali and Faizan Ahmad, 2010)
27
According to Hair et al. (2014), if apply Maximum Likelihood method, the minimum
sample size is from 100 to 150. Besides, the sample size adopted in the SEM model has 3
types, small size which is equal or lower than 100, the medium size is between 100 and
200 and large size is from 200 and above. In this study, the author chooses 137 as the
sample size of this research
2.4.2 Methodology
Step 1: The questionnaire was developed via some related studies with modifications to
fit the subject of the study and the scope of the study. All items in the questionnaire were
estimated on a 5‐point Likert scale with the "1: Strongly disagree" to "5: Strongly agree"
Step 2: Using preliminary questionnaires to interview 5 respondents to preliminarily
evaluate the scale and adjust the sentence to suit the research content to ensure that
respondents can understand and respond properly.
Step 3: After the test interview, the author corrects preliminary questionnaires to the
official questionnaires, which is used to collect research sample information.
2.4.3 Data Analysis Method
The method of Data Analysis used in research consists of Outer Model and Inner Model.
All collected data is processed by SmartPLS 3.0 software.
2.4.3.1 Outer model
The standard of choosing scale is Cronbach9s Alpha from 0.6 or more. The reliability of
the observed variables must have the outer loading coefficient greater than or equal to 0.5
to meet the requirements for reliability and the composite reliability coefficient must be
greater than or equal to 0.7 to satisfy the requirement. (Hulland, 1999). Convergent
validity is used to assess the stability of a scale. According to Fornell and Larcker (1981),
AVE coefficient (average variance extracted) must be greater than or equal to 0.5 to
satisfy the requirement. The factor loading of each observed variable on the factor should
be higher than 0.5, and ideally, 0.7 or higher (Hair et al., 2014) and is meant as evidence
of the reliability of the scales. Discriminant validity measures discriminatory validity to
help ensure that there is no relation between the elements used to measure factors. To
measure the discriminant validity, the square root AVE of each measurement factor is
28
greater than the latent variable correlations between that factor and other factors,
indicating the differentiation and reliability of the factors. (Fornell and Larcker, 1981).
2.4.3.2 Inner model
PLS-SEM relies on a nonparametric bootstrap procedure (Efron and Tibshirani, 1986;
(Buckland et al., 1998) to test the significance of estimated path coefficients in PLS-SEM.
This method uses a non-relational approach between variables and factors to predict the
accuracy of relationships in PLS. With the bootstrapping technique, the recovered sample
can be considered as a whole, the N subsamples in the population are formed by sampling
method with the change of observed values in the original sample size (N=137). After
that, the relationships begin to be predicted for each new pattern created. Distribute the
predictions from the sample M generated to calculate the t-value of the relationship.
2.5 Result of the study
Code
29
The brand/service of this firm is a good product for the price PV4
deducted by discounts
The brand/service of this firm is value for money compared with PV5
that of major competitors
30
The choice of transacting with the firm is a right decision when PV6
price and other expenses are considered
Customer The offerings always meet my expectation CS1
Satisfaction
Taking my experience with other companies, I am satisfied with CS2
(H6)
our offerings
Eating channel 21 15
Drinking channel 42 31
Channel
Grocery Channel 54 39
Difference 0 0
Twice a week 27 20
Frequency
Once a week 68 50
31
Difference 11 8
< 1 year
27 20
Time doing
1-3 years 23 17
business with Coca-
3-5 years 30 22
Cola
> 5 years
57 42
Cronbach’s
Outer loadings alpha CR AVE
32
PC1 0.890
PC2 0.902
PC3 0.893
PC4 0.883
PC5 0.856
PC6 0.886
PC7 0.885
IF1 0.781
IF2 0.794
IF3 0.811
IF4 0.857
IF5 0.856
IF6 0.890
SV1 0.881
SV2 0.899
SV3 0.844
SV4 0.824
SV5 0.756
SV6 0.665
EP1 0.743
EP2 0.841
33
EP3 0.807
EP4 0.770
EP5 0.648
EP6 0.810
PV1 0.837
PV2 0.933
PV3 0.865
PV4 0.891
PV5 0.851
PV6 0.863
CS1 0.930
CS2
0.937
CS3
0.943
34
35
36
37
38
Stated from the results, Expectation of Retailers does not directly affect Customer
Satisfaction, but it has impacts on Customer Satisfaction through Perceived Value, which
means that Expectation influence the Perceived Value of customers, and Perceived Value
directly affect to Customer Satisfaction. The difference from the initial model could be
explained by that in the GT channel in Vietnam, retailers of CCBVL pay more attention
to the process of doing business, that whether they receive the excellence and variety
products, convenient, fast, friendly, and economical procedure from throughout the whole
process; clear and updated information about either product and the scheme, upcoming
programs of the company, and they recognize that the price they have to pay is reasonable
than what competitors offer; as well as the attitude of employees who are directly working
with them, who can brings them the prestige or not, and from that create their safety feels
when doing the business with CCBVL. In this particular context of The GT channel of
CCBVL, Expectation of outlet owners do not have impact on Satisfaction as the result of
research of the author in India; However, since Expectation can also have positive effect
on Perceived value of Customer, in order to increase Customer Satisfaction, the author
could also indirectly influence through improving Expectation of Customers.
From the table, the author extracts some of the observations that are not stated in
Hypothesis
Process directly affects Customer Satisfaction
The retailer also needs to consider the preference of their customers, so the variety and the
quality of products also play important role in developing retailer satisfaction. Besides,
they also care about the policy of the company such as the friendly exchange policy for
inferior quality products, or the wasting time from ordering to receiving goods as well as
employees9 strength. These all affect directly to their business, as a result, Process can
directly drive Customer Satisfaction
Information directly affects Customer Satisfaction
Retailers are the intermediary bridges between the company and the end-users, the
outlets9 owners need to be well-informed about the products, service, and the programs of
the company. Companies can also take notice of retailers9 suggestions such as offer of
39
scheme and bargains. Receiving offers/ schemes or samples for pre-launching can also
affect the satisfaction of the retailers, as well as when they know that the price they have
to afford is more reasonable in compared with the competitors9, they can be more
satisfied.
Service directly affects Customer Satisfaction
The prestige is essential in doing business, safety when conducting business with every
party is the top element that almost retailers consider. If the retailers perceive that they are
getting preferential treatment, and they satisfy with the deal, the satisfaction of them rises.
Conclusion of Chapter 2
This chapter analyzes the SWOT of CCBVL, as well as points out some problems of the
company. Based on some theoretical background, quantitative research is conducted with
137 samples with the subjects are outlet owners purchasing Coca- Cola products in Ho
Chi Minh City. From the results after running SmartPLS, the study comes up with some
key findings of the factors have impacts on Customer Satisfaction
40
CHAPTER 3: RECOMMENDATIONS
3.1 Recommendations
3.1.1 Reducing lead time
A small number of customers complained that delivery time is delayed, or interrupted due
to holidays, or Sunday, resulting in their business being affected, in which case they
switch to use goods from wholesalers to be more quick and convenient. It has become a
habit for a long time, and since then, they no longer buy products directly from the
company. It is essential for the company to control lead time from the order time,
confirmation to delivery times to be as fastest as possible and ensure that in the
refrigerator or on the shelves of customers Coca- Cola products always appear. Checking
customers refrigerators or shelves regularly during a visit ensures the control of
customers' inventory quantities so that there is a plan to prepare stocks and deliver on
time when the customer requires, on the other hand, increase brand awareness, and help
Coca-Cola's products catch the attention of customers, thereby indirectly selling more
products.
3.1.2 Increasing the quality and variety of products
Retailers purchase goods based on the preference of their customers, when their
customers, who are end-users ask for another product because they feel that Coca-Cola's
product does not meet their needs, or it has not enough diversity, it also affects retailer
satisfaction that they cannot 100% meet their customers' requirements, and their revenue
drops. It is clear that the retailer is influenced and pressured by their customers, who
directly use the product, since then, it shows that increasing product quality, as well as
creating diversity in the products should be focused. In addition, there should be stronger
marketing strategies with other product lines of the company in order to compete with
competitors, rather than only focus on the key product of the company, which is Coca-
Cola. According to the figure, it can be demonstrated clearly that except for Coca- Cola,
other products of the company do not get the high brand recognizing of consumers.
41
% Percent
42
process, sales skills, communication skills with customers, ... to be able to undertake the
job quickly, ensuring the Sales team is always capable to meet the needs of customers. In
addition, with large outlets that need special and thorough care (outlets that have revenue
accounting for 70% of the total revenue of the route), there should be supervision from
the direct superior (TSM), the close monitoring of superior management helps the
business process with customers not be interrupted, the business becomes more
convenient and supportive for customers. TSM can also arrange suitable staff for the sale
route, SR can help each other and cross-work in necessary cases under the direction of
superiors.
3.1.4 Identifying target potential customers for giving promotions & improving the
process of giving promotions
The recording and estimating the sales volume of each outlet, as well as the quantity and
volume of their orders every month is also important in identifying key customers and
potential customers to have favorable policies, special service to maintain relationships
with customers. Based on the exact number that SR input into the system, the company
can identify key customers, loyal customers with Coca-Cola to take special care of them.
The survey results on 137 elective samples showed that 42% of customers have been
doing business with Coca-Cola for more than 5 years, it's obvious that if the company
brings good cares to them, their satisfaction can turn to the loyalty with the brand, as a
result, thereby increasing sales and profits for Coca-Cola. In addition, the appropriate
assessment of where are the profitable fields also helps Coca-Cola to bring out potential
customers and has a strategy to compete directly with competitors by offering marketing
programs, promotions, and the price that customer perceived that is more reasonable than
competitors offer, from that increasing the market share of CCBVL at Ho Chi Minh City
It is obvious that receiving incentives, promotions also greatly affect customer
satisfaction, but the process of receiving incentives, paying bonuses, or issuing company
items needs to be convenient, time-saving, and simple for customers. One year, Coca-
Cola runs nearly 50 programs, including large and small ones for customers, including
bonus programs, discounts, Loyalty programs, ... but some customers complain that they
are often paid for a long time, or even not paid, since the company works with the
43
customers through SR, who is the one that directly works with retailers, it needs to be
more strict in the process of giving promotion and paying bonuses for customers. Some
other programs of the company which are free providing and installing refrigerators,
gifting display items to the store including banners, eating utensils, shelves, ... should
avoid complicated and unnecessary procedures to increase the comfort of customers, to
avoid the annoyance result in negative consequences, even though giving them a
promotion
3.1.5 Improving data management
Data should be constantly updated to ensure accuracy, information about key customers,
important customers, and considerations when working with them should be recorded on
the system. Working with customers, especially important customers by manually way
needs avoiding, instead, the process should be managed by the system, since the
partnership and relationship between the company and customers which are based solely
on the SR have high risks, especially with the high turnover rate at FMCG. This will help
the company to manage better, and rebuilding the sale routes, changing the routes for
employees do not face too much dissatisfaction and discomfort from customers.
Currently, the company has implemented many projects to survey and rebuild customer
information, but to ensure information and data are constantly updated, the company
should have regular data purification and has close supervision. Improving customer data
also helps the company to come up with after-sales programs, better policies to increase
customer satisfaction, thus their purchase intention. Besides, building an updated sales
system helps the company improve its effectiveness and efficiency in the sales process.
Applying the point of sale coordinate positioning helps SR to determine the correct
location of the store, as well as fast accurate delivery, and adjust the appropriate cost-
profit design. As a result, it not only brings the outcomes which are the satisfaction of
customers but also reduce costs and increase efficiency for businesses
In addition, the confidentiality of customer information is also extremely important, this
not only affects the company's reputation and the prestige toward customers but also
seriously affects the interests of the company. The process of controlling authorized
employees to access the customer information system on the portal should be strictly
44
implemented to ensure that only those with relevant and authorized duties can access it.
Besides, they also have to ensure certain security conditions. The data management
system should also be maintained and upgraded regularly to avoid virus or malicious
attack
3.1.6 Improving professional working attitude of SR when doing business with
customers
The improvement of SR's working attitude also greatly affects the reliability and
satisfaction of customers. The SR training is done very professionally in the CCBVL by
the Sale Trainers team. SR will be trained from the beginning of adopting the job, and the
training contents will be enhanced over time such as Negotiation skills, Overcome
objection skills, ... Every once or twice a month, training occurs, training sessions should
be realistic, outcomes from training programs are that SR has skills to build trust in
customers, calm negotiating ability, professional attitude and create satisfaction from
retailers. A company's service is always important for customers to continue using the
product for a long time, especially in the FMCG sector where brands are easily replaced
when product quality is equivalent to the same standard, so building a good Customer
Service is a must in all businesses, especially when a retailer is a bridge between the
company and consumers.
3.2 Strategy for the company in the next 2 years
Up till now, CCBVL has 16 years of development in Vietnam and has gained several
achievements. However, FMCG is a competitive field, especially in the beverages
industry in Vietnam with the biggest competitor is Suntory Pepsi and the local competitor
is Tan Hiep Phat. The company's upcoming development strategies need to be
groundbreaking but sustainable.
Development goals for the next 2 years
Increasing the revenue in Ho Chi Minh City. Although Ho Chi Minh City region
contributes to the largest revenue of the total revenue all over the country, the potential
here has not been fully exploited, in the near future, CCBVL can still develop strongly in
Ho Chi Minh City.
45
Expanding the market share in Ho Chi Minh City to narrow the gap with the biggest
competitor, which is Suntory Pepsi, until 2019, the market share of CCBVL is far behind
Suntory Pepsi. Ho Chi Minh City is a dynamic city, with economic potential as well as an
advantage to develop a business, CCBVL has not made much effort to regain market
share in this area, evidence shows that CCBVL lost a lot of exclusive contracts from big
customers to Suntory Pepsi.
Managing the cost to increase the net revenue. Currently, the sales process is still in the
procedure of improvement and modification to be both cost-effective and efficient, the
project to rebuild the sales routes has been built many times in the previous years but not
yet successful, the goal in the next 2 years is accomplishing it and creating the
effectiveness in doing business
Maintaining and increasing the company9s brand name and reputation, the company needs
to constantly innovate and increase the quality of services provided. Also, CSR is one of
the important things since ensuring the responsibility with the community is a key factor
to grow sustainably in a country
3.3 Limitation of the study
As a result of time limitation, the research was only conducted in some districts in Ho Chi
Minh City, which could not bring to a general view of Ho Chi Minh City market as the
purpose of research.
Some errors in the data as well as the limitations of the total sample's surveying capacity
(random sampling method) can cause the survey results to deviate from reality.
Conclusion of Chapter 3
This chapter proposed recommendations of improving customers satisfaction of CCBVL
include: (1) Reducing lead time, (2) Increasing the quality and variety of products, (3)
Enhancing the sales force, (4) Identifying target potential customer for giving promotions
& improving the process of giving promotions, (5) Improving data management, (6)
Improving professional working attitude of SR when doing business with customers. This
also analyzes some strategies for the company in the next 2 years, and limitations of the
study
46
CONCLUSION
Realizing the importance of the satisfaction of customers within every corporate,
especially with the context of CCBVL in the GT channel in Ho Chi Minh City, the study
was conducted to investigates the factors that affect the satisfaction of outlet owners who
are purchasing products from CCBVL. The results from data analysis show that the
satisfaction of customers is influenced directly by the process of doing business, the
information customers receive, the service that the company brings to them, the perceived
value of quality of the company, and the expectation of customer also can impact
indirectly on the satisfaction through its effect on perceived value. From the problems
stated and the result of the analysis, the study comes up with some recommendations that
are practical and most compatible with CCBVL to enhance the satisfaction index of
retailers and points out the strategies of the company in the next 2 years to achieve the
growth in business in Ho Chi Minh City.
Throughout the analysis of SWOT of CCBVL and data analysis, the recommendation of
this study hopefully brings out some solution that can enhance the satisfaction of outlets
owners that are partners of CCBVL, as well as utilize the potential opportunity to achieve
the competitive advantages in this tough industry. The study is conducted within the
period the author is working in CCBVL as a Commercial Intern, it is evitable that there
are still some shortcomings in research interpreting and recommending, the author hopes
that this study could be the premise for other researches and be improved completely in
the future
47
REFERENCE
Reference in English
Ali, S.S. and Ahmad, F. (2010) 8Flexible approach to satisfaction index: an Indian case
study of health drink9, Int. J. Indian Culture and Business Management, Vol. 3, No. 3,
pp.266-277
Anderson, E.W. and Sullivan, A.W. (1993) 8The antecedents and consequences of
customer satisfaction for firms9, Marketing Science, Vol. 12, No. 3, pp.125–143.
Boshoff, C. and Tait, M. (1996) 8Quality perceptions in the financial services sector: the
potential impact of internal marketing9, Int. J. Service Industry Management, Vol. 7, No.
5, pp.5–31.
Buckland, S., Davison, A., & Hinkley, D. (1998). Bootstrap Methods and Their
Application. Biometrics. doi: 10.2307/3109789
Efron, B., & Tibshirani, R. (1986). Bootstrap Methods for Standard Errors,
Confidence Intervals, and Other Measures of Statistical Accuracy. Statistical Science,
1(1), 54-75. doi: 10.1214/ss/1177013815
Fornell, C., & Larcker, D. (1981). Structural Equation Models with Unobservable
Variables and Measurement Error: Algebra and Statistics. Journal of Marketing
Research, 18(3), 382. doi: 10.2307/3150980
Fornell, C. (1992) 8A national customer satisfaction barometer: the Swedish experience9,
Journal of Marketing, Vol. 56, pp.6–21, January.
Gale, B.T. and Wood, R.C. (1994) Managing Customer Value: Creating Quality and
Services that Customers Can See. New York: The Free Press, pp.22–40.
Gowing, M.K. and Lindholm, M.L. (2002) 8Human resource management in the public
sector9, Human Resource Management, Vol. 41, No. 3, pp.283–295.
Hair Jnr, J., Black, W., Babin, B., & Anderson, R. (2014). Multivariate data
analysis. Essex: Pearson Education.
Heskett, J.L., Jones, T.O., Loveman, G.W., Sasser, W.E. Jr. and Schlesinger, L.A. (1994)
8Putting the service profit chain to work9, Harvard Business Review, pp.105–111, March–
April.
48
Reference in Vietnamese
Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited, 2020. History of the Coca- Cola Company.
Retrieved August 20, 2020 from https://www.cocacolavietnam.com/cau-chuyen-ve-coca-
cola/10-_i_u-b_n-ch_a-bit-v-lch-s-phat-trin-bn-vng-ca-coca-cola
Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited, 2020. Information of CCBVL. Retrieved August
20, 2020 from https://www.cocacolavietnam.com/hanh-trinh-coca-cola-viet-nam
Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited, 2020. Introduction & Overview of Company
Performance. August 2020
Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited, 2020. Products of CCBVL. Retrieved August
20, 2020 from https://www.cocacolavietnam.com/thong-hieu
49
Coca- Cola Beverages Vietnam Limited, 2020. Organizational Structure of the Company.
August 2020
Kien, K. (2020) 8Chi la cong ty gia dinh nhung Tan Hiep Phat lai 3.300 ty nam 2019, gan
bang ca Pepsi va Coca- Cola cong lai9. Retrieved August 20, 2020 from
https://cafef.vn/nhieu-tien-nhu-tan-hiep-phat-cong-ty-gia-dinh-lai-3300-ty-nam-2019-
gan-bang-ca-pepsi-va-coca-cola-cong-lai-20200908002337187.chn
MarketIntello, 2016. Khao sat thi truong san pham nuoc ngot Viet Nam. Retrieved August
20, 2020 from https://www.marketintello/kho-st-th-trng-sn-phm-nc-ngt-vit-nam
Nguyen, D.T (2011), Phuong phap nghien cuu khoa hoc trong kinh doanh, NXB
Lao Dong Xa hoi.
(knowledge, skill,
attitude)
performance of the
whole team
Friendly attitude,
being polite and soft
to all customers
Friendly attitude,
being polite and soft
to all customers
project which
conducted in
following weeks
Receiving the
allocated list of
distributors that
each individual is in
charge of
Tuesday Going to the All SRs who are trained Communication skills
Distributor house 1 deeply know about the EDS and presentation skill
to train SRs about project and exactly the
Having a humble,
doing EDS process of conducting every
conscientious, and
day
professional attitude
Getting to the field Understanding well about the Learning about how
with TSM and SRs region that in charge of and to communicate and
to conduct research collecting particular deal with the
experience when working on customer in each
the field case, how to handle
each situation when
customers have
dissatisfactions about
our products and
service
Getting to the field Understanding well about the Learning about how
with TSM and SRs region that in charge of and to communicate and
to conduct research collecting particular deal with the
experience when working on customer in each
the field case, how to handle
each situation when
customers have
dissatisfactions about
dissatisfactions about
our products and
service
Verifying 120 data Getting done data and taking How to filter data in a
downloaded from note of unreasonable errors logical order to get
the portal for confrontation with SRs rid of erroneous data
quickly
Being hard-working,
careful, and precise
when doing with data
and numbers
Verifying 380 data Getting done data and taking Being hard-working,
downloaded from note of unreasonable errors careful, and precise
the portal for confrontation with SRs when doing with data
and numbers
Verifying 400 data Getting done data and taking Being hard-working,
downloaded from note of unreasonable errors careful, and precise
the portal for confrontation with SRs when doing with data
and numbers
Monday Reporting the error Reporting to direct supervisor When problems occur
of the system to find a Solution that lack of capability
to solve, promptly
report and contact to
direct mentor and the
supervisor
Verifying 420 data Getting done data and taking Being hard-working,
downloaded from note of unreasonable errors careful, and precise
the portal for confrontation with SRs when doing with data
and numbers
Friendly attitude,
being polite and soft
to all customers
Verifying 450 data Getting done data and taking Being hard-working,
downloaded from note of unreasonable errors careful, and precise
the portal for confrontation with SRs when doing with data
and numbers
Conducting market
Getting more
research, verifying the
Completing the tasks knowledge about
operational status of 45
the market
outlets in route
Always
Contacting SRs about
considering
unreasonable the
Getting the confirmation and things in many
operational status of
explanation of SRs sides to
outlets between data SRs
understand
reported and in practice
completely
Skills of
conducting a
report,
Conducting a report to
summarizing,
the direct manager about Completing the report
and stressing
the researches
only key points
of a load of
information
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 520 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 387 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Skill of
communicating
to customers,
summarizing,
and quickly
responding
Friendly attitude,
Directly check data in the
being polite and
Field check data field to verify exactly the
soft to all
information
customers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Verifying 538 data Getting done data and taking Being hard-
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors working, careful,
portal for confrontation with SRs and precise when
doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 545 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each the Sales team of working, careful,
each distributor at the and precise when
end of the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 453 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 503 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being careful
and meticulous
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being careful
and meticulous
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Skills of
synthesizing the
Conducting and sending information,
a report of operational clearly and
Accomplishing a report
status randomly field concisely
check result to RCM presenting a
huge load of
information
Being hard-
Verifying 546 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 555 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 524 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 516 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Always being
Reporting the checking data
well-planed and
Meeting with EDS team process
oriented the
about the checking data
work, especially
process and announcing
in the final stage
the upcoming plan for Being well-prepared about
when workload
the last survey week the plan and the work for the
is extremely
last week of phase 1
large
Being hard-
Verifying 503 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 511 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Being hard-
Verifying 402 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Always promptly
reporting to the
direct the
supervisor of the
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
Presenting the
violation
precisely and
clearly to the
Presenting at the meeting
Accomplishing the work manager to get
of The Sales team
the real situation
Communication
skills and critical
thinking
Being hard-
Verifying 415 data Getting done data and taking working, careful,
downloaded from the note of unreasonable errors and precise when
portal for confrontation with SRs doing with data
and numbers
Enhancing Excel
Conducting daily report
Skills
about data collecting
process from EDS of Being hard-
Accomplishing daily report
each Sales team of each working, careful,
distributor at the end of and precise when
the day doing with data
and numbers
The important
project requires
double-checking
from many
Sending the data which
stages at any
has been checked to the The data is sent to the
step, as a result,
supervisor for randomly supervisor for re-checking
always being
re-checking
hard-working,
careful, precise,
and honest in
working
Monday Synthesizing
Getting the key points and
Meeting with the EDS they key points,
the lesson learned through
team to summarize the the drawbacks as
phase 1 of the project
process, results, and well the
lessons of EDS project advantages
phase 1 and training the during the
Learning the method of
method of aggregating project for
aggregating and classifying
and classifying data further
data
improvement
Being hard-
working, careful,
Aggregating all the data, and precise when
Accomplishing partly the
classifying, and doing with data
whole task
removing the invalid data and numbers
Recognizing
exactly the status
of each data to
classify or
remove
Enhancing
intensely Excel
Skills
Being supportive
and always
willing to help
the teammates to
Supporting checking 230 Getting done the data and
enhance the
data for partner sending back to the partner
performance
achieve the goal
of the whole
team
Enhancing
intensely Excel
Skills
Always double-
checking the
work of myself,
Receiving the feedback
Getting feedback from the fixing the
of re-checking data from
supervisor and promptly mistakes
the supervisor and
have action on the work occurred, and
making accountability
making
accountability if
it is necessary
Being supportive
and always
willing to help
the teammates to
Supporting checking 210 Getting done the data and
enhance the
data for partner sending back to the partner
performance
achieve the goal
of the whole
team
Recognizing
exactly the status
of each data to
classify or
remove
Enhancing
intensely Excel
Skills
Being supportive
and always
willing to help
the teammates to
Supporting checking 250 Getting done the data and
enhance the
data for partner sending back to the partner
performance
achieve the goal
of the whole
team
Always reporting
Reporting the process the work process
and the number of to the supervisor
The data is sent to the
aggregated data and the so that he/she
supervisor before the
status of classified data can keep track,
deadline
which have already been and give advice
done to the supervisor and feedback for
timely fixing
Recognizing
exactly the status
of each data to
classify or
remove
Enhancing
intensely Excel
Skills
Being supportive
and always
willing to help
the teammates to
Supporting checking 260 Getting done the data and
enhance the
data for partner sending back to the partner
performance
achieve the goal
of the whole
team
Always being
Meeting the
Sending total aggregating The data is sent to the
deadline under
data with classifying supervisor before the
any
status to the supervisor deadline
circumstances
Monday Skill of
Attending the training of designing the
the technique of re- Understanding the process of optimal sale
arrange the routes for how to design sale routes routes that save
The Sales team resources of the
company
Experience of
utilizing the tool
Wednesday Experience of
utilizing the tool
Continuing designing
to design sale
and mapping the sale
routes
Thursday
routes under the Accomplishing the tasks
Enhancing the
supervision of the
skills of utilizing
mentors
Software and
Computer
Part 2: Survey
Retailer
18. I am satisfied with the distributor
service
19. It is prestigious to deal with Coca- Cola
distributor
20. I feel safe in conducting business with
distributor
21. Distributor gives preferential treatment to
some retailer
competitors
35. The choice of transacting with the firm is a
right decision when price and other expenses
are considered
Customer
36. The offerings always meet my expectation
Satisfaction
37. Taking my experience with other companies,
I am satisfied with our offerings
APPENDIX 4
Construct Reliability and Validity
Cronbach's rho_A Composite AVE
Alpha Reliability
Outer loading
Customer Expectation Information Perceived Process Service
Satisfaction value
CS1 0.930
CS2 0.937
CS3 0.943
EP1 0.743
EP2 0.841
EP3 0.807
EP4 0.770
EP5 0.648
EP6 0.810
IF1 0.781
IF2 0.794
IF3 0.811
IF4 0.857
IF5 0.856
IF6 0.890
PC1 0.890
PC2 0.902
PC3 0.893
PC4 0.883
PC5 0.856
PC6 0.886
PC7 0.885
PV1 0.837
PV2 0.934
PV3 0.866
PV4 0.892
PV5 0.851
PV6 0.862
CS1 0.881
CS2 0.899
CS3 0.844
CS4 0.826
CS5 0.756
CS6 0.664