Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Fleksibilitas
Jurnal Fleksibilitas
Individuals involved with physical activity with The resultant effects depend upon the technique
poor flexibility, the risks exceeding the and duration of stretch. But the aim of the study
extensibility limits of the muscle skeletal unit.2 was to find the significance between the active
Once the flexibility is assessed and flexibility and passive stretching in improving the
insufficiency is identified, a stretching hamstring flexibility in football players.
programme can be customized, emphasizing Hamstring tightness is defined as the inability
those areas in need of important. Flexibility is a to extend the knee to less than 20 degrees of
key component for injury prevention and knee flexion with the femur held at 90 degree
rehabilitation. Stretching is important for of hip flexion while the person was positioned
reducing injury and improving performance in in supine.7
sports and for overall physical fitness. Athletes
The double arm clear goniometries used to
are often given stretching protocol to improve
measure the tightness of hamstring. There are
their flexibility. Adequate flexibility may help
various studies shown that goniometric
prevent muscle strain and such orthopedic
measurements are reliable and valid. The
problems such as backache3, good flexibility may
studies conducted by GogiaPP, Braatz JH on
bring about improved performance in athletes.
reliability and validity of goniometric
Flexibility gains in the hamstrings have been
measurements at knee prove that the
demonstrated after a multiple day stretching
goniometric measures are reliable and valie.8
programme. Active and passive stretching
expand the range of motion by working in Need of the Study: There are various stretching
muscles tendons, capsules and ligaments; methods are available to improve the flexibility
stretching of the muscles before an event is an of the muscles which is proven to produce effects
extremely important factor in the achievement on the muscles. The purpose of this study was
of optimal athletic performance.4 to find out the effectiveness of sum of the
techniques used to improve the flexibility of the
The peculiar characteristics of hamstring muscles
muscles. Both these stretching techniques are
is a biarthrodial, made predominantly of type
used to improve the flexibility. But the purpose
two fibres and containing less amount of titin
of the study was to find the existing difference
proteins may put the muscle group at higher risk
between these two stretching techniques (active
of strains, so hamstring injuries are common on
stretching and passive stretching) in the
athletes.5
improvement of flexibility in foot ball. The
Studies have shown that muscle strains are present study deals with the foot ball players this
common in sports injuries and represent 41% of is why because the foot ball players are more
all injuries reported in foot ball clubs. Hamstring prone to develop hamstring injuries, hamstring
injuries are account for to 11% of all injuries and strains occur when strong concentric quadriceps
32% of all muscular strains. They are also contraction generate forces that the eccentric
common in football players. Injuries in strength of hamstring cannot with stand, they
hamstring are common during the eccentric are therefore prevalent in sports requiring
phase of contraction, which occurs in the sudden burst of speed. In soccer the forwards
hamstrings while decelerating the swing phase who take off more often with sudden bursts of
leg or the leg after kicking a ball. Running by itself speed had the highest relative risk of hamstring
is known to produce tight weak hamstrings. injury and the midfielders do more running they
Foot players are involved with more amount of are also more prone to develop hamstring
running so they are prone to develop the injuries.5
hamstring tightness and player who have
The study conducted in subjects at the duration
imbalance between the quadriceps and
of 30 seconds and 5 times per week for 6 weeks.9
hamstrings also prone for hamstring strains.6
The same stretching duration was used for both
Purpose of the study was to find the the active and passive stretching to find out
effectiveness of both active and passive whether same stretch duration, will have any
stretching. Both the active and passive significant difference in the flexibility of the
stretching is used to improve the flexibility. muscles between the two techiniques.
Int J Physiother Res 2014;2(5):725-32. ISSN 2321-1822 726
Divan Mohaideen Abbas, Bilques Sultana.EFFICACY OF ACTIVE STRETCHING IN IMPROVING THE HAMSTRING FLEXIBILITY.
METHODLOGY PROCEDURE:
According to the selection criteria sixty subjects
Study has conducted as an experimental study
(60) were selected with consent letter, subjects
design with pre and post test design and
are male adults.
conducted at Sri Krishna Nagar Football club –
Hyderabad, India for Six Weeks, for the study The total number samples are divides into two
sixty subjects were selected by random sampling groups. Each group consists of thirty (30)
technique, further more sample has divided in subjects, the tightness of the hamstring muscles
two Groups i.e. are measured by using the Goniometer.
N1= Group A =30= Active stretching In group (A) active stretching was administered,
the stretch must be hold for the duration of 30
N2 = Group B=30 =passive stretching
seconds.
During random sampling technique, we have
In group (B) passive stretching was administered,
fallowed the fallowing inclusion and exclusion
the stretch also holds for the duration of 30
criteria.
seconds.
Inclusion criteria: Subjects are professional
Each group is property instructed and
football players under club level for the past one
demonstration of procedure has been given to
year. Adult male individual age between 18 and
the patients in order to find the exact
30, Individuals with no history of knee and hip
measurement and to avoid the trick moments
injury, Individual with hamstring tightness,
of the joints. A frame is used to maintain the
Individual without history of neurological
hip at 90 degree of flexion. The frame consists
impairment and orthopedic condition affecting
of a horizontal bar in length, which is used to
hamstring flexibility, Co operative subjects.
keep the upper thigh in contact during the
Exclusion criteria: Individuals with history of stretching procedure.
knee and hip injury, Individual with history of
Both of stretches are given at the duration of 30
neurological complications, Individual with any
seconds and five times per day.
systemic diseases, Individuals who are not fit
into the Inclusion Criteria. The post test measurements are taken after the
successful course of six weeks of stretching.
Parameters used in this study is: Range of
motion and Hamstring muscle Flexibility Pre-stretching and post stretching
Materials /Tools included for this study is measurements:
Goniometer, Stop clock, Frame to maintain hip Both the pre-stretching and post stretching
at 900 flexion. measurements are taken in order to find the
Descriptions of tools effect of each stretching procedures.
The tools used for this study are goniometer, Subjects in both the groups are positioned in
stopwatch and a frame to maintain hip at 90 supine lying. The hip joint is positioned in flexion
degrees. at 90 degree and the anterior aspect of thigh
Goniometer: Goniometer is the universally contact the wedge in the frame, then the
accepted tool to measure the range of motion therapist passively move the leg in to the
in joints. There are numerous studies available terminal position of the knee extension, which
to prove the reliability and validity of was defined as the point at which the subject
goniometric measurements. report feeling of discomfort and the
measurement is taken with the use of double
Stopwatch: Stop watch is used to measure the
arm goniometer14. Goniometer is placed over
time taken for each stretches of the hamstring
the lateral aspect of knee joint exactly at the
muscle.
point over the lateral condyle of femur. The
A frame: A wooden frame is used to maintain moving arm of the goniometer has to be in
the hip at 90 degrees of flexion in order to parallel with tibia and the static arm should be
measure the tightness of the hamstring muscle. aligned parallel to the femur.7
Int J Physiother Res 2014;2(5):725-32. ISSN 2321-1822 727
Divan Mohaideen Abbas, Bilques Sultana.EFFICACY OF ACTIVE STRETCHING IN IMPROVING THE HAMSTRING FLEXIBILITY.
Graph 1: Comparison Of Pre And Post Test In Group A Table 6: Comparison Of Improvement In Range Of
and Group B. Motion In Fourth Week.
GROUP (A) GROUP (B)
Standard Standard ‘t’ test Significance
Mean Mean
Deviation Deviation
WEEK 4 3.27 0.79 2.8 0.66 2.486 0.016
3
MEAN VALUES
Table 9: Comparison Of Pretest And Post Test Results -cant difference between two groups. In second
In Group A. week p<0.01, so there is significant difference
Pre test Post test between two groups. In third week P<0.05,
Standard Standard ‘t’ test Significance there is 95% significance in the improvement in
Mean Mean
Deviation Deviation the range of motion. In the fourth week p<0.01
Group A 26.3 3.79 8.07 3.83 37.347 0 there is 99% significance in the improvement in
While comparing the pre test and post test the range of motion, in the fifth week p<0.05
results in group (A) the ‘p’ value of 0.000 there is 95% significance in the improvement in
suggests that there is significance in the results. the range of motion. In the sixth week p>0.05,
Table 10: Comparison Of Pretest And Post Test Results so there is no significant difference in the
In Group B. improvement in the range of motion.
Pre test Post test DISCUSSION
Standard Standard ‘t’ test Significance There are various studies shown that both the
Mean Mean
Deviation Deviation active and passive stretching improves the
Group B 26.13 3.76 10.13 3.73 32.111 0
flexibility and relieves the muscle tightness. But
While comparing the pre test and post test the focus of this study was relying on the
results in group (B) the ‘p’ value of 0.000 comparison of these two techniques in
suggests that there is significance in the results. improving the flexibility of the hamstring
muscles in foot ball players.
RESULTS
This study was designed in order to obtain the
Present study was a comparative study. Two effective of active and passive stretching method
different stretching technique are used for in improving the flexibility of hamstring muscle.
experiment. This study was statistically known The sample are selected according to the
as the pre and post test- experimental study and selection criteria, samples are professional foot
the two tests are used for the statistical analysis. ball players played under club level for the past
Independent “t” was used for the comparison one year.
between the two groups. Group (A) active
The results was shown that active stretching
stretching group, group (B) passive stretching
given with 30 seconds duration and 30 seconds
group.
rest with a frequency of five times per week for
Paired “t” test was used for the comparison with the duration of six weeks found to produce a
the group20. The comparison is between the pre significant results in improving the flexibility of
and post test measurements. hamstring muscle.10
When the “p” value is less that 0.05 the The present study results shows that the active
significance is about 95% and the ‘p’ value of stretching is more effective that the passive
0.001 suggest that there is 99% significance in stretching, the studies conducted by safran,
the results. seaber and garnet in 1989 proves that the static
When comparing the pre test measurements in stretching is probably the most effective
both the groups there is no significance, the method, with effects lasting up to 90 minutes.20
value is 0.865 “p” value is greater than 0.05, so So the results of the present study is supported
there is no significance. by this study.
When comparing the post and pre test results The 30 seconds duration is an effective amount
of Group (A) and group (B), the values shows of time to sustain a hamstring muscle. Stretch
there is significance in the results, the value of in order to increase the range of motion, no
0.002 is less than that of the “p” value of 0.05 so increase in flexibility occurred when the duration
there is significance. This results shows that the lasts more that 30 or 60 seconds (bandyw.d.
active stretching is more effective than the irioin j m 1994). Comparing the results of present
passive stretching. When looking up the study with earlier studies showing the similar
comparison of improvement in range of motion results and supports this study. In the present
for the first week (p>0.05). So there is no signifi- study the main tool used for measuring the
Int J Physiother Res 2014;2(5):725-32. ISSN 2321-1822 730
Divan Mohaideen Abbas, Bilques Sultana.EFFICACY OF ACTIVE STRETCHING IN IMPROVING THE HAMSTRING FLEXIBILITY.
tightness of the hamstring muscle is double arm 2. Shrier I. Stretching before exercise does not reduce
clear goniometer, the studies conducted by the risk of local muscle injury: a critical review of
goggia pp, braatz in 1987 on the reliability and the clinical and basic science literature. Clin J Sport
validity of goniometric measurements are Med. 1999 Oct;9(4):221-7.
reliable and valid.8 The other tool used for this 3. Charles E. Corbin, Ruth Lindsay, 9th edition in 1997,
Concepts of physical fitness.
study is stop watch its measurements are also 4. Wernerkuprian, Helmutork, Physical therapy for
reliable and valid. Most of the other studies used sports chapter 9, 2nd edition 1997.
the same duration for the purpose of stretching 5. B Dadebo, J White, K P George. A survey of flexibility
of the hamstring muscle. But they used a training protocols and hamstring strains in
different technique for stretching the hamstring professional football clubs in England. Br J Sports
Med 2004;38:388-394 doi:10.1136/
muscle. But he results shows the similar effects. bjsm.2002.000044
RECOMMENDATION: 6. Thomas E., Marianne S. Gengenbach, eds.
Conservative management of sports injuries. Jones
Present study has done on the effectiveness of & Bartlett Learning, 2006.
two stretching techniques in the improvement 7. J Brent Feland, J William Myrer, Shane S Schulthies,
Gill W Fellingham, Gary W Measom. The Effect of
of flexibility; we can also compare the effect by
Duration of Stretching of the Hamstring Muscle
using stretching with the modalities like Group for Increasing Range of Motion in People
cryotherapy or heat therapy. In this study only Aged 65 Years or Older. Physical Therapy May 2001
male subjects were selected and in the right vol. 81 no. 5 1110-1117.
lower limb the measurements are taken for the 8. Gogia Prem P, James H. Braatz, Steven J. Rose, and
Barbara J. Norton. Reliability and validity of
evaluation. The present study can be compared
goniometric measurements at the knee. Physical
with the males and females subjects and this therapy 1987; 67(2): 192-195.
study can be compared with the lower limbs. In 9. Willy, Richard W., Bryan A. Kyle, Shawn A. Moore,
this study the age groups of the subjects are and Gary S. Chleboun. Effect of cessation and
18-30, subjects are adults, and the study can be resumption of static hamstring muscle stretching
on joint range of motion. Journal of Orthopaedic &
conducted in adolescent’s population also.
Sports Physical Therapy 2001; 3 (3): 138-144.
10. Bandy William D, Jean M. Irion, Michelle Briggler.
CONCLUSION The effect of static stretch and dynamic range of
The present study was demonstrated that there motion training on the flexibility of the hamstring
is a significant difference in improving the muscles. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical
Therapy 1998; 27(4):295-300.
flexibility of hamstring muscle by using the active
11. Reid Duncan A, PETER J. McNair. Passive force angle,
stretching (static stretching) than the passive and stiffness changes after stretching of hamstring
stretching though both the stretching muscles. Medicine and science in sports and
techniques given at the same duration of 30 exercise 2004; 36(11): 1944-1948.
seconds. The active stretching group shows a 12. Jaegger Gayle, Denis J. MarcellinLittle, David Levine.
Reliability of goniometry in Labrador Retrievers.
better improvement in the flexibility of
American journal of veterinary research 2002;
hamstring muscles. 63(7): 979-986.
The present study helps to conclude that the 13. Taylor Dean C, James D. Dalton, Anthony V. Seaber,
patient treated with active stretching will have William E. Garrett. V iscoelastic properties of
muscle-tendon units the biomechanical effects of
the better improvement in the flexibility of stretching.” The American journal of sports
hamstring muscles, so while treating the football medicine 1990; 18(3): 300-309.
players either for training or for rehabilitation 14. Fredriksen H, H. Dagfinrud, V. Jacobsen, S.Maeh-
active stretching is more effective method for lum. Passive knee extension test to measure
flexibility. hamstring muscle tightness. Scandinavian journal
of medicine & science in sports 1997; 7(5): 279-
Conflicts of interest: None 282.
REFERENCES 15. Shellock Frank G, William E. Prentice. Warming-up
and stretching for improved physical performance
1. Worrell TW, Smith TL, Winegardner J. Effect of and prevention of sports-related injuries. Sports
hamstring stretching on hamstring muscle Medicine 1985; 2(4): 267-278.
performance. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1994
Sep;20(3):154-9.
Int J Physiother Res 2014;2(5):725-32. ISSN 2321-1822 731
Divan Mohaideen Abbas, Bilques Sultana.EFFICACY OF ACTIVE STRETCHING IN IMPROVING THE HAMSTRING FLEXIBILITY.
16. Sullivan Michael K, Joseph J. Dejulia, Teddy W. 19. Safran Marc R, William E. Garrett, Anthony V.
Worrell. Effect of pelvic position and stretching Seaber, Richard R. Glisson, Beth M. Ribbeck. The
method on hamstring muscle flexibility. Medicine role of warmup in muscular injury prevention.” The
and science in sports and exercise 1992; 24(12): American Journal of Sports Medicine 1988; 16(2):
1383-1389. 123-129.
17. Zacheski J, Zachezewski JE. Improving flexibility. In: 20. Hicks Carolyn M. Research methods for clinical
Scully RM, Barnes MR, editors. , eds. Physical therapists: applied project design and analysis.
Therapy. Philadelphia, PA: JB Lippincott Co; 1989; Elsevier Health Sciences, 2009.
698–699.
18. Bandy William D, Barbara Sanders, eds. Therapeutic
exercise for physical therapist assistants. Lippincott
Williams & Wilkins, 2007.