Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ED540232
ED540232
ED540232
It '3
- _ T
t dr
..__
_eD DEPARTMENT OF ThE INTERIOR
,
BUREAU OF EDUCATION
_ -- ..111rommrNr........
\
\
e BULLETIN, 1929, No),10
1
../
INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION
oir
1926-1928
r
By
f
4
MARIS M. PROFFITT
SPECIALIST IN INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION
/
BUREAU OF EDUCATION
ID
%AN%
1%
)
\k-1 F
11
...
\,
,
,.___
;.'rtir
',of, ,...
_ ,
...,, .
re---
;
,
...
0
I4..
ii OW . ..
i .. bb
'' V 4 is. 11111 f
a
v
.... .it
.
i
1
ali ..."
t
1 I
I%
%%
%
%%%% q104
a
. I
e
O
- I
UNITED STATES r
dly
p.
ADDITIONA L COPIES
OF TIM
PUBLICATION MAY HE
PROCURED FROM
THE SUPERINTENDENT
OF DOCUMENTS
U. S. GOVERNMENT
PRINTING OFFICE
WASHINGTON, D. C.
AT
5 CENTS PER COPY
1,
-It
41.
" 110
-
v
Ow.
INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION 1
By MARIE1 M. PROFFITT
e Specialist in Industrial Education; Bureau of Education
I The chapter does not deal with tbe administration of vocationallindustrial education
Provided by the Smith-Hughes law. The reports of the Federal Board for Vocational
&cation Cover this subject.
-
t
- -
has
2 BIENNIAL SURVEY OF EDUCATION,
1926-1928
The stimulation of the industrial
education program is due to a
number of causes. Among the most
important ones are:
1. An increased effort to make
the publi-schogl program demo-
cratic in fact a8 well aq in. name..There
is a growing demand that
the secondary schools assume their full
needs of the various groups of responsibility for meeting the
students.contained within their rapidly
increasing enrollments. In the 36 years from 1890
lation of the continental United States to 1926 the popue-
increasvd 86 per cent, while
the college and university enrollment
increased about 550 per cent,
and the-secondary school enrollment
increased almost 1.100 per cent.
The student body of the secondary
school is no longer the selected
unified group it once was. and with the
of groups with different attitudes, inclusion, in large numbers.
aptitudes, and opportupities rela-
tive to life occupational interests there
is the necessity for providing
educational training that will have functional
to the group needs and will be values corresponding
commensurate with the time. effort.
and money expended.
In 1926 public-school enrollment. in the
year of the 4-year high school, was only tentlt grade, or the second
52 per cent of the enroll-
ment in the seventh grade. Evidently
an important factor contribut-
ing to school-leaving (luring these grades
was the lack of a sufficient
variety of courses to meet the needs of the
in the school enrollment. A specific different groups included
example of this situation, to-
gether with a plan for meeting it, is found in
a certain comparatively
large city. In this particular school
system in the year 1921-28 there
were 90 per cent as many pupils enrolled
in the first year of the
4-year high-school system as were enrolled
in the last year of the
elementary schools, but the enrollment in
the,second year high school
was 27.5. per cent less. than in the first
and school board realizing the situation
year. The superintendent
'took immediate steps to pró-
vide enlarged opportunities in industrial
arts, vocational-industrial,
and tech4cal subjects with which
more nearly to meet the needs of
the cosnpolitan character of the
secondary school student body.
A well-known educator and president of
a large State university re-
cently said that " Democratic society has
insisted on the school offer-
ing training in Inany lines. * * *
Each individual is entitled to
thit educational opportunity which corresponds
pOwer to achieve."
to his ability and
2. A fuller recognition of individual
ferences which are fundamental to differences.Individual dif-
a consideration of types of train-
ing that should be provided consist
not only of differé'nces in I. Q.
and mental alertness, but differences
in attitudes,
opportunities.relative to life occupational interests asaptitudes, and
ditioned by economic and other they are con-
environmental circumstance& The
probOility of success initpy, contemplated line of
work is condition P
INDUSTAIAL EDUCATION 3
17. _ 2_zai
TENNIAL 8tIRVEY OP EDU'CATION7 , 1 9 6-1 f) 2 8
ployment officers arg accumulating
? valuable information of an
chara0er on these probiemsi-as a pa-rt of their
based upon experience. 'These v observations
types of studies trnd experi-
mental practices have set for ore clearly the feasibility of
ing v(¡Cational-industrial couFses and the provid-
possibilities which such
courses have for vocational efficiency. These
have resulted in a
stimulation of indu*trial education in the
public schools, especially
in the cooperatiowf the schools with
induAry in providing practical
types of training.
3. Growth, of the junior Nf./ h 8chool
school movement started about 1909. Inmo'rement.The junior high
1926 there! were 1,109 junior ,
high schools and in addition 1,149 junior
high school departments
in connection with senior high
schools. The rapid growth previously
made in the junior high school
developn?)ent was continued during
1926-1928. The growth° o f the junior high
school
accompanied by a very material increase in the movement has been
due, first, to the philosophy of the. junior manual arts Niti
high school, which empha-
sizes the need f6r providing for individual
and group atiffvrences,
for exploration and discovery of aptitudes
and interests, and for an
enriched curriculum of general education ; and
second, to the flexi-
bility of the instructional organization which
more easily permit's the
introductioh of shop courses.
4. Increased recognition. of the need
for training in abilities nece8-
-N
,-%
a
civAtov-'"
Il
%INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION 5
enter upon employment in the trades and industries was during the
past two years an important factor influencing the increase of vota-
tional-industrial courses in the puhN-schools. Such training should
be i)rovidrd not only because the State owes it to these individuals
az -Ocial service but also because it pays a financkal return on the
investment in the way of increased economic wealth.
In 1920, according to the United States Census report for that
year, th6re were 41.614,248 persons 10 years of age and over who
were gainful y'employed. Of thosetgaifully employed 30.8 \-)er cent
were engaged in manufacturing ailed mechanical pursuit;)6.3 per
cent in agriculture, forestry, and animal husbandry ; and 5.2 per cent
in professional service. In 1919 tereredweroi 10,812.736 persons
engaged in manufacturing industries only, of whom 79.4 per cent
were males and 20.6 pler cent..were females. Of this number 120,919
were under 16 years of age. Of these 53.3 per oft were male and
46.7 per cent were female. ,
The States wbicb htr-e made the larger relative gains in population
since 1910 are, almost without exception, the industrial ones, while
the States making the smaller relative gains are quite Ivnerally
'those in which agriculture i the domihant industry.
7. Cooperathie relatiolw with haustry.During the past two
years the cooperative relations developed with industry for the pro-
motion of vocational education have resulted in many places in the
enlargement and improvement of the vocational program. These
Mutually helpful relationships, based on a common interest and for
a common purpose, have exprecsed themgelves in v'arious ways,
among which may be mentioned:
(1) The establishment of contact or advisory committees, com-
posed of employers and employees, for the purpose of securing their
acivice and ccloperation in the determination of the courses to be
offered, the content and instructional material for the courses, the
selection of traipees, Eind the selection and qualifications of in-
structors, .
t" II
it
./
- . -- .= i . U..
4
a
I7DUStRIAL EDUCATION 7
performing operations lvious1y done by hAnd arid the demand for
refinements in. machines to meet the need for machine products
worked to smaller dimensions are constantly iricreasing the need for
high-skilled tool and machine builders th.e world over.
VARIETY IN COURSES AND INSTRUCTIONAL ORGANIZATION
4 kv
sP
INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION
.
for the print ing and carpentry trades. 't .
nate weeks. .
../..
In 1928 the Bostoh Continuation School made a study of 1,200 of
the 1,600 girls enrolled in its courses. It, wits found that thlgy left
school beginning with the sixth grade and the droppinvut process'
continued in succeeding grades through the eleventh. The Jnodel
grade for leaving school was the eighth. The largest number was
employed in çandy factories, the artificial flower business, andh in
the food products industries and service. The greatest number 9f
calls for help came from candy and other manufacturing industries
. whehe the work was of a light natute. Factory work Raid thé highest
wages. The weekly wages ranged from $8 topS.
The Washburne Continùation School, ChicAgo, Ill., is a part-time
schoollior boys, operating on an 8-hir day schtdule. Both con-
4
a
10 BIENNIAL SURVEY OF EDUCATION, 1 9 2 6-1 9 2 8
-
4
=
INDÚSTRIAL EDUCATION 13
SCHOOL EXHIBITS .
A great deal of attention has been given during the past two years
to the theory and practice of guidance. Programs of teachers' meet-
ings, research studies, and educational literature have dealt to a con-
siderable extent with the problems of guidance in the public schools.
With the growing realization of the importance of this work as a
factor in the final satisfactory adjustment of the individual into a
wage-earning life occupation, the general public has become greatly
interested in the discussions of ways and means for making guidance
effective. During-fir past two years a broader view has been talen
of the problems invalved and less emphasis has been placei upon a
hasty attempt to elide inexperienced youth with limited practical
training into sp-e-cific occupations. More emphasis has been placed
upon an educational guidance procedure covering a term of years,
which aims through various forms of direct and indirect everience to
furnish opportunities for the gradual development and discovery of
aptitudes and interests and for gaining reliable information as to
the training required for specific occupations and the employment
. r.w
18 a
BIENNIAL SURVEY OF EDUCATION, 1926-1928
boys repre-
senting a cross section of the student body of the
Rindge Technical
Vigh School, Cambridge, Mass. Of this number
361 worked after
school hZurs for pay and 397 did not. Of the
working group 107
were compelled to work in order to remain in school
and 254 worke&
in order that they might have the additional
pleasures their earnings
would afford. /The workers were distributed in
. jobs.
various common
Sixty -.four were employed on paper routes, 57 in
commercial
shops, 37 .as errand boys, 7 in libraries, 3 in
laboratories, 3 as music
teacher; and the remainder in miscellaneous jobs of
a commonetype.
Intelligence scores for each were recorded and some comparisons
made on this basis. It was found that there
was no difference be-
tiween the working group and the nonworking
group relative to in \
telligence scores. The workers, judged by the
number of failure
marks received, were a little more successful in their school
work. Of
the two working groups, those who
were obliged to work had better
average school marks, had fewer failure marks, and
more honor
marks per pupil than did the groul,.,.. who worked
to pbtain extra
spending 'honey. The average school Arks for the
group obliged to
work were higher than for either the nonworkers
or the group which
worked to earn additional spending money.
The David Ranken Junior School of Mechanical
Trades, St. Louis,
Mo., has compiled records of its graduates
for'
past 15 years with reference to their remaining -approximately the
in the trade or a
closely related line of work for which they
were trained. These
percentages for the different trades in which
instruction is offered
are as follows: Carpentry, 84 per cent ; painting,
84 per cent; plumb-
ing, 85 per cent ; auto mechanics, 85 per cent ;
machine shop practice,
81 per cent ; steam engineering, 77
per cent ; patternmaking, _76 per
cent ; and electricity, 80 per cent.
A report received from the State TtiCle
School, New Britain,
Conn., based on a study of returns from 88,
per cent of its gritduates
in the past 16 years, shows the following
Percentages of graduates
remaininX in the trade for which they were trOned
or in a closely reap
-
INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION
lated trade: Auto repair, 85 per cent ; carpentry, 100; machine draft-
ing, 98 ; electrical work, 79.4; machine trades, 95 ; masonry trades,
100;' wood patternmaking, 78.7 ; printing, 100; plumbing, 100. In-
formation/ on the question of the percentage remaining in the trade
which they were trgined indicates that it varies with a number
o factors, such as locaf employment, conditions in the trades, local
oppo 'ties for obtaining employment in other than trade lines of
work; e source and character of the students coming to the
trade school.
There is a growing demand that teachers in/guidfince work and
thosedoing vocational counseling have speçific training. New York
City has set up special qualifications for teachers ivho serve as voca-
tional counselors. They are required to pass an examination for a
speciallicense to become teachers of vocational and educational
guidance subjects. The school board has created the pctition of
director of guidance and placement, who supervises all the work for
the city.
The Vocational Service for Juniors, a privately financed organiz4-
tion of New York City, has done much to aid the development of
guidance and placement work ill that city. Its specific aim is to aid
young people to make adjustments to their future work, and to
demonstrate to the public the value of such service. It provides
scholarships to deserving children to enable them to go through
high school or to take a vocational course in trade school. For the
Et
0 TESTS
Experimental and Other forms of researclvstudies.
the past two years indicate that, the work carried on during
of developing paper tests
for discovering mechanical aptitudes is still
in the experimental stage.
'The question has been raised of the
validity of some tests which have
been devised for this purpose and there.is
need of further experi-
nwntal work to determine whether they really
ical ability. In fact, the whole question measure native rilechan-
of developing paper tests
that will have prognostic values sufficient to
this particular Purpose is still in the realm warrant
of
their use for
In the attempt to devise such tests it mu:;t. be bornethe problematical.
ability to answer a list, of questions about, in mind that the
machines, apparatus, tools,
and mechanical processes may or may not correlate
highly with the
ability to manipulate tools and materials. The
for answering suc_h questions correctly may orinformation necessary
may not have been
derived from experiences coming as a result Of natural
abilities. The fundamental factor which brought suchinterests and
experiences
into the pupil's life may have been Jibe result,
more or less, of chano
and environmental circumstances.
The value of performance tests for determining
mechanical ability
should also be the subject of further research.
Although such tests
attempt in a direct and concrete manner to determine the pupil's
mechanical ability by measuring the quality of workmanship
shown
on the test, it is not always certain lo what extent the
abilities mani-
. fested are due to native aptitudes or to skill acquired
in practice.
Moreover, the time and effort, both of the instructor and the pupil,
required for giving such tests are important factors in
the extent to which it is feaslole to use them. There aredetermining
some indi-
cations, however, that performance tests may be developed
that will
yield valuable information for the improvement of
instrtiction, even
hough their value for discovering native mechanical ability may be
exceedingly doubt ful.
Progress was made (luring the past two years in the development of
achievement or accomplishment tests in industrial educational sub-
jects. Especial was this true for mechanical drafting in which
411;4
mpusPritIAL EtATATION 21
subject some object ive tests Were devised that seem to have value for
determining pupil achievement.. With the efforts that are now
made to set up standards of accomplishment in industrial arts sub-
jeck in term of given units of training, further development and
refinement of ways and means for measuring acgomplishment abilities
Ms' be expected.
TEACHERS
_ _............0111111
INDUSTRIAL EDUCATION 23
occupational levels in the major occupational fields are very greatly
deeded for the light they woOd throw upon the need for specific
training and dpportunities for placement.
7: ne question as to the kind and am;unt .of training that-should
he provided for seriously retarded.children is still almost wholly un-
solved. Studies including all of the major occupational vocations
should be made with a view to finding a field of employment:for
retarded children when given the necessary training.
8. Housing facilities for all types of industrial worte were I'm-
proved durittg the past t wo ytiars. In some places there are definite
plans for improving tile housing facilitie for part-time classes.
.9. There is an increasing. recognition of the need for special
qualifications and, training for the supervision of industrial arts
courses. (
410
.a