Peer Edit Response Form

Your Name: ___________________________________________

Author’s Name/Number: ________________________________

Students should have #_____ peers preview their writing product in the following
areas before submitting it to the teacher for final review.

‰ The writing meets the requirements of the assignment.

‰ The title has capital letters where needed.
‰ The topic sentence (thesis statement) is clearly stated.
‰ Supporting information is adequate.
‰ The supporting paragraphs are relevant and well organized.
‰ Transitions and other linking devices connect ideas.
‰ The content is interesting and thoughtful.
‰ The conclusion is effective.
‰ The paper has complete sentences.
‰ The sentence length and structure vary.
‰ The paper has correct spelling.
‰ All sentences and proper nouns begin with a capital letter.
‰ Each sentence has end punctuation.
‰ The paragraphs are indented.

Finish the following statements as best you can. Remember, your job is to help
the writer.

1. One thing I really liked about the writing is…

2. One thing I think the author can improve upon is…

3. Something I would like the author to tell me more about is…

4. One last comment…