Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Parker 1954
Parker 1954
Parker 1954
BY C. A. PARKER
Admiralty Materials Laboratory, Holton Heath, Poole, Dorset
Received 5th April, 1954 ; in final form, 7th July, 1954
The effect of oxygen upon the quantum yields in the photolysis of ferrioxalate in
neutral solution containing oxalate has been reinvestigated in the light of recent observa-
tions in acid solution.1 The zero yield of ferrous iron and the doubled yield of carbon
dioxide observed by Livingston 2 in the presence of oxygen is explained by thermal
autoxidation of the photochemically produced ferrous iron and the concurrent induced
autoxidation of oxalate ion. There is also some evidence that molecular oxygen can
itself participate directly in the photochemically initiated reaction chain. A mechanism
involving the photochemical formation of Fe2f and C204- and the subsequent com-
petition between these two primary products for the molecular oxygen and its primary
reduction product (02-) formally accounts for the results obtained.
The results of spectrophotometric measurements suggest that in acid solution at
least monoxalato- and bioxalato-ferric complexes are present. In neutral solution the
trioxalato complex appears to be the predominating species.
EXPERIMENTAL
In all the photochemical experiments 15 ml of solution were exposed to the 365-366 mp
group of mercury lines. Either oxygen or oxygen-free nitrogen was passed through the
liquid. The apparatus was similar to that previously described 1 employing mercury
lamp, copper sulphate and Chance OX1 filters and a phototube monitoring unit. As
before the irradiation vessels were fitted with loosely fitting polythene covers and in this
sense exclusion of air was not absolutely complete. Access of air was also possible
during the short period of manipulation before colorimetric reaction. Immediately
after irradiation, 1 ml aliquots were withdrawn for ferrous iron determination by the
standard method.1 The liquid was then allowed to stand for 2 h without further passage
of gas and a second determination of ferrous iron made. The results are shown in
table 1. The time of irradiation was 5 min for expt. 1-4 and 10 min for expt. 5-8.
Quantities of ferrous iron found are expressed as g equiv. x 10-6/min.
Thermal oxidation experiments were carried out using 15 ml quantities of solutions
of composition corresponding to expt. (3), (4), ( 5 ) and (6) in table 1. The solutions were
1213
View Article Online
saturated with the appropriate gas, 1 ml of ferrous iron solution was added, containing
10.0 x 10-6 mole of ferrous iron in 0.01 N sulphuric acid. The ferrous iron remaining
in the solution after 10 min and 2 h was determined by the standard method using 1 : 10-
phenanthroline.1 The results are shown in table 2.
TABLE1.-PHOTOLYSIS
OF POTASSIUM FERRIOXALATE-EFFECT OF OXYGEN
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
TABLE
3 .-FERR~US-INDUCED AUTOXIDATION OF OXALATE
1 0.1 M Na2C2O4 0.02 M FeS04 < 0.01 h nil 49.65 5-00 0.35 0.07
0.02 M H2SO4 (25 ml) (02 for 3 h)
(50 ml)
2 ditto ditto 3h nil 48-16 5.00 1.84 0.37
3 0.1 M Na2C204 0.01 M FeS04
0-02 M H2SO4 0005 M H2SO4 < 0.01 h 0.01 49.33 9.99 0.67 0.07
(50 ml) (100 ml) ( 0 2 for 4 h)
pH = 4.0
4 ditto ditto 4h 0.24 46-64 9.76 3.36 0.34
5 50ml water 001 M FeS04 < 0.01 h 9-97 - 0.03 - -
(100 ml) (subse-
quently
oxygen-
ated for
4 h) final
pH=4.4
6 0.12 M NaAc ditto ditto 9-95 - 0.05 - -
0.036M H2S04 (final
(50 ml) pH 4-6)
View Article Online
C . A. PARKER 1215
Two pairs of experiments were carried out using larger quantities of ferrous iron.
In one of each pair the ferrous iron solution was added all at once while in the other it
was added gradually over a period of several hours to the vigorously stirred oxalate
solution. A current of oxygen was passed through the oxalate solution throughout the
tests. The ferrous iron remaining in the solution was determined colorimetrically by the
standard method.1 The oxalate remaining was titrated with standard permanganate
solution, a correction being applied, where necessary, for the small amount of ferrous
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
iron present.
Two similar oxidation experiments were performed in the absence of oxalate to confirm
the comparative insensitivity to autoxidation under these conditions. In this case the
extent of the oxidation was small and it was determined by measuring the increase in
the extinction at 300 mp due to the formation of ferric iron, after adjusting the acidity
to 0.8 N sulphuric acid. The results are shown in table 3.
Wave length my
FIG. 1.-Absorption spectra.
Curve 1, 0.018 M Fe3+ in 0.1 N sulphuric acid ;
curve 2, 0.018 M Fe3+ and 0.018 M oxalic acid in 0.1 N sulphuric acid ;
curve 3, 0.018 M Fe3+ and 0.054 M oxalic acid in 0.1 N sulphuric acid ;
curve 4, 0.018 M Fe3+ and 0-108 M oxalic acid in 0.1 N sulphuric acid ;
curve 5, 0.018 M potassium ferrioxalate in water.
each solution in turn, a current of nitrogen was passed through the solution and the
potential of the platinum electrode measured against a saturated calomel electrode. The
results are shown in table 4 (expt. 1-6), and can be represented by a straight line when
plotted against log [Fe3+]. Some similar solutions were prepared which contained in
addition 0.006 M potassium ferrioxalate and concentrations of added ferric sulphate
I
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
I 2 3 4 6
Molar ratio, bxalic acid/Ee’I
FIG. 2.-Optical density as a function of oxalate/iron ratio.
Curve 1,0*018M Fe3+in 0.1 N sulphuric acid with oxalic acid concentrations as indicated
(measured at 490 mp) ;
curve 2, 0,006 M Fe3+ in 0.1 N sulphuric acid with oxalic acid concentrations as indicated
(measured at 480 mp).
%
MoI a r ra t i0, f=e3 xa I at 4
FIG. 3.-Reaction of ferric iron with acid potassium ferrioxalate.
All solutions contained 0.006 M potassium ferrioxalate to which were added [Fe3+] to
give the indicated iron/oxalate ratios.
Slope of dotted line corresponds to extinction per unit (1/3) of ferric iron added assuming
no reaction with oxalate.
corresponding to those in the solutions used for photolysis (table 5). The electrode po-
tentials of the solutions (expt. 7-11 in table 4) were assumed to correspond to the ferric
iron not combined as oxalate (i.e. it was assumed that the activity coefficient of the ferric
sulphate was not affected by the addition of 0.006 M potassium ferrioxalate) and on this
basis they were converted to concentration of “ free ” ferric iron by reference to the plot
of expt. 1-6. Using these concentrations of ferric iron (column 5 of table 4), the
View Article Online
C . A. PARKER 1217
proportion of light absorbed by uncombined ferric iron and by ferric oxalate complexes
was calculated and the results are shown in table 5. With these values and the observed
gross quantum efficiencies it was then possible to calculate the actual quantum efficiencies
of the ferric oxalate complexes present (column 8 of table 5).
TABLE4.-sUMMARY OF ELECTRODE POTENTIALS
+ 0.001 M FeS04
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
RESULTS
The following conclusions can be drawn from the results in table 1.
(9 In neutral solution oxygenation reduces the quantum yield of ferrous iron, On
subsequent standing a further consumption of ferrous iron occurs (expt. 1 and 2).
(ii) The presence of excess oxalate in neutral solution causes a marked decrease in
ferrous iron yield and no ferrous iron remains even in the nitrogenated solution
(i.e. low but not zero [OZ]after 2 h (expt. 3 and 4)).
(iii) In weakly acid oxygenated solution containing excess oxalate no ferrous iron
was formed (expt. 5-i.e. in agreement with Livingston) but if an excess of
sulphuric acid is present the " inhibiting effect of oxalate is greatly reduced
"
(expt. 6).
(iv) In strongly acid solution without added oxalate the presence of oxygen causes
only a very slight reduction in the yield of ferrous iron. Subsequent thermal
oxidation in such solutions is negligible (expt. 7 and 8).
It would appear therefore that the " inhibiting effect " of oxygen in the photochemical
reaction is favoured both by low acidity and high oxalate concentration and that the thermal
oxidation of ferrous iron is the most rapid in conditions where the " inhibiting effect " is
the most prevalent. Nevertheless expt. 7 and 8 indicate that a small inhibiting effect
can occur in the photochemical reaction under conditions where thermal oxidation is
View Article Online
negligible and (in this case at least) oxygen must be participating slightly in the photo-
chemically initiated reaction chain. That a purely thermal oxidation of ferrous iron
is sufficient to account for the major inhibiting effects observed in the other experiments
is shown by the results in table 2 where ferrous sulphate (10 x 10-6 mole) was added
to 15 ml quantities of solutions of composition corresponding to expt. 3, 4, 5 and 6 in
table 1, and the rate of oxidation determined.
The first two pairs of experiments in table 3 demonstrate that (i) ferrous iron is readily
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
oxidized by oxygen in weakly acid oxalate solutions, and (ii) this autoxidation induces
the oxidation of oxalate, the relative consumption of oxalate being critically dependent
on the concentration of ferrous ions allowed to accumulate in the solution. Clearly,
the consumption of oxalate by this mechanism is likely to be favoured in the photochemical
reaction where, with normal light intensities, the ferrous iron is produced gradually and
uniformly. A consumption ratio of 0.37 was observed in one experiment (table 3) where
ferrous iron addition was slow and a ratio of 0-5 might well apply in the photochemical
reaction. The ferrous-induced autoxidation of oxalate could then account for the doubled
quantum efficiency observed by Livingston.
Naturally this does not rule out the possibility of direct reaction of molecular oxygen
with photochemically produced oxalate radical ion as an additional cause of the increased
oxalate consumption, but it is significant that under conditions where oxygen has little
effect on the ferrous iron yield (e.g. expt. 8 in table 1) it was found to have little effect on
the oxalate consumption also.
C . A. PARKER 1219
oxalic acid present in the unmodified acid potassium ferrioxalate solution. The curve
approaches asymptotically the slope corresponding to the optical density of ferric sulphate
solution and it is clear that when [Fe3+]/[oxalate]= 5/3,little further reaction with ferric
iron is taking place and the oxalate must be present almost completely as the monoxalato
complex.
The rates of photolysis (365-366 mp) of all five solutions were determined and were
corrected for the inner-filter effect of the “ free ” ferric iron present (the Iatter was deter-
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
DISCUSSION
The dependence of the induced oxalate oxidation upon the ferrous iron con-
centration is similar to the effect observed in the oxidation of oxalate by Fenton’s
reagent 4 and suggests that a similar type of mechanism applies. Weiss 6 has 5 9
suggested that the first stage in the autoxidation of ferrous iron is the formation
of 02- by electron transfer :
Fe2+ 0 2+ + Fe3+ 02-. +
Energetic considerations 7 suggest that the equilibrium is normally far to the left
and that moderate concentrations of Fe3+ will be reduced by 02-. Complex
formation with phosphate or fluoride would favour an equilibrium shift to the
right and is in fact found to increase the autoxidation rate.S.9. 10 The results
in tables 1, 2 and 3 suggest that complexing with oxalate does likewise. We ma
thus represent the initial stage in the autoxidation process as follows :
+
Fe2+ 0 2 --Fe3+ ’ +
02-,
+
Fe3+ OH- t -
[Fe(OH)J2+, etc.,
+
neutral solution [Fe(C204)2]2- 0 2 + _-[Fe(C204)21- 02-, + (3)
{
---+
This competition between Fe2+ and C2O42- explains the marked dependence of
oxalate consumption on the rate of addition of ferrous iron solution. In the
limit, with large [C2042-] and very small [Fe2+]all the HO2 radicals initially formed
would be reduced by oxalate and the consumption ratio A[C20$-][A[Fe2+]
would tend to 0.5. Applied to the autoxidation of the photochemically formed
Fe2+this mechanism could clearly account quantitatively for the double quantum
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
C. A . P A R K E R 1221
reducing this to the observed values (e.g. 1.18 at 365-366 mp 1) is indicated by the
results of some experiments on the effect of varying light intensity. It has been
found that with 0.006 M ferrioxalate in 0.1 N sulphuric acid the quantum yield
of Fez+ with 365-366 mp radiation is independent of light intensity over a wide
range (0.003-7 micro-einsteins/cm2 sec). Over this range of intensities therefore
it would appear that reaction (10) does not contribute to an appreciable extent.
Published on 01 January 1954. Downloaded by University of Warsaw on 04/12/2014 10:09:14.
Experiments with still higher intensities are in progress and the results will be
reported in detail elsewhere. The relative importance of reaction (10) could
be confirmed by observing the effect on the quantum yield of the addition of re-
agents for C204- or HC204 (e.g. reagents for free radicals). Oxygen itself is,
of course, an unsuitable reagent owing to the autoxidation of ferrous iron already
discussed.
The author desires to express his thanks to Dr. E. J. Bowen for much helpful
advice. This paper is published by permission of the Admiralty.
1 Parker, Proc. Roy. SOC. A, 1953,220, 104.
2 Livingston, J. Physic. Chem., 1940, 44,601.
3 Allmand and Webb, J. Chem. Soc., 1929, 1518.
4 Weiss, Faraday SOC. Discussions, 1947, 2, 188.
5 Weiss, Symposium Sur Transferts Electronique en Solution et aux Electrodes (Paris,
1951).
6 Weiss, Naturwiss., 1935, 23, 64. 7 Uri, Chem. Rev., 1952, 50, 375.
8 Spoehr, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1924, 46, 1999.
9 Smith and Spoehr, J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1926,48, 107.
10 Lamb and Elder, J . Amer. Chem. SOC., 1931, 53, 137.
11 Bobtelsky, Chasson and Klein, Anal. Chim. Acta. 1953, 8, 460.
l 2 Posner, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1953, 49, 382.
13 Cartledge, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1941, 63, 906.
14 Evans, Santappa and Uri, J. Polymer Sci., 1951, 7, 243.
15 Sidgwick, Chemical Elements and Their Compounds (Oxford University Press, 1950),
p. 1347.