SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

As of July 2, 2021
(Final List – July 29, 2021)

65, Orig. TEXAS V. NEW MEXICO

Order: 1/27/20 – River Master’s final determination - Set for oral argument
Argument Date: 4/21/20
Date: 4/3/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 – Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/5/20 Decided: 12/14/20
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Alito (C/J/P & D/P)
Result: MOTION DENIED (ACB – no part)

142, Orig. * FLORIDA V. GEORGIA

Order: 10/5/20 – Exceptions to Second Report of Special Master – Set for oral argument
Argument Date: 2/22/21 Decided: 4/1/21
Author: J. Barrett
Result: EXCEPTIONS OVERRULED, AND CASE DISMISSED

18-540 * CFX RUTLEDGE, ATT’Y GEN. OF AR V. PHARMACEUTICAL CARE MANAGEMENT ASSN.

Court: USCA-8 Granted: 1/10/20
Argument Date: 4/27/20
Date: 4/3/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/6/20 Decided: 12/10/20
Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Thomas (C)
Result: REVERSED and REMANDED (ACB – no part)

18-956 CFX GOOGLE LLC V. ORACLE AMERICA, INC.

Court: USCA-Fed. Granted: 11/15/19
Argument Date: 3/24/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/7/20 Decided: 4/5/21
Author: J. Breyer Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (ACB – no part)

18-1259 CSY JONES V. MISSISSIPPI

Court: SC-MS Granted: 3/9/20
Argument Date: 11/3/20 Decided: 4/22/21
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Thomas (C/J); Sotomayor (D)
Result: AFFIRMED

18-1447 * CFX REPUBLIC OF HUNGARY V. SIMON

Court: USCA-DC Granted: 7/2/20
Argument Date: 12/7/20 Decided: 2/3/21
Author: Per Curiam
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

-1-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-71 * CFX TANZIN V. TANVIR

Court: USCA-2 Granted: 11/22/19
Argument Date: 3/24/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/6/20 Decided: 12/10/20
Author: J. Thomas
Result: AFFIRMED (ACB – no part)

19-108) * CMY UNITED STATES V. BRIGGS

19-184) * CMY UNITED STATES V. COLLINS
Court: USCA-AF Granted: 11/15/19
Argument Date: 3/23/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/13/20 Decided: 12/10/20
Author: J. Alito Other: Gorsuch (C)
Result: REVERSED and REMANDED (ACB – no part)

19-123 # CFX FULTON V. PHILADELPHIA

Court: USCA-3 Granted: 2/24/20
Argument Date: 11/4/20 Decided: 6/17/21
Author: Chief Justice Other: Barrett (C); Alito (C/J)
Gorsuch (C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-199 CFX SALINAS V. RAILROAD RETIREMENT BD.

Court: USCA-5 Granted: 1/10/20
Argument Date: 11/2/20 Decided: 2/3/21
Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-251) CFX AMERICANS FOR PROSPERITY FOUNDATION V. BONTA

19-255) CFX THOMAS MORE LAW CENTER V. BONTA
Court: USCA-9
Argument Date: 4/26/21
Author: Chief Justice
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
Granted: 1/8/21
Decided: 7/1/21
Other: Thomas (C/P & C/J)
Alito (C/P & C/J); Sotomayor (D)

19-292 CFX TORRES V. MADRID

Court: USCA-10 Granted: 12/18/19
Argument Date: 3/30/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/14/20 Decided: 3/25/21
Author: Chief Justice Other: Gorsuch (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (ACB – no part)

-2-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-309 * CFX CARNEY V. ADAMS

Court: USCA-3 Granted: 12/6/19
Argument Date: 3/25/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/5/20 Decided: 12/10/20
Author: J. Breyer Other: Sotomayor (C)
Result: VACATED and REMANDED (ACB – no part)

19-351 * CFX FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY V. PHILIPP

Court: USCA-DC Granted: 7/2/20
Argument Date: 12/7/20 Decided: 2/3/21
Author: Chief Justice
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

19-357 * CFX CHICAGO V. FULTON

Court: USCA-7 Granted: 12/18/19
Argument Date: 4/20/20
Date: 4/3/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/13/20 Decided: 1/14/21
Author: J. Alito Other: Sotomayor (C)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (ACB – no part)

19-368)1 # CSX FORD MOTOR CO. V. MONTANA EIGHTH JUDICIAL DIST. COURT
19-369)2 # CSX FORD MOTOR CO. V. BANDEMER
Court: 1SC-MT; 2SC-MN Granted: 1/17/20
Argument Date: 4/27/20
Date: 4/3/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/7/20 Decided: 3/25/21
Author: J. Kagan Other: Alito (C/J): Gorsuch (C/J)
Result: AFFIRMED (ACB – no part)

19-416) CFX NESTLE USA, INC. V. DOE

19-453) CFX CARGILL, INC. V. DOE
Court: USCA-9 Granted: 7/2/20
Argument Date: 12/1/20 Decided: 6/17/21
Author: J. Thomas Other: Gorsuch (C)
Sotomayor (C/P & C/J); Alito (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-422) CFX COLLINS V. YELLEN

19-563) CFX YELLEN V. COLLINS
Court: USCA-5 Granted: 7/9/20
Argument Date: 12/9/20 Decided: 6/23/21
Author: J. Alito Other: Thomas (C); Gorsuch (C/P)
Kagan (C/P & C/J)
Sotomayor (C/P & D/P)
Result: AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND
REMANDED

-3-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-438 CFH PEREIDA V. WILKINSON

Court: USCA-8 Granted: 12/18/19
Argument Date: 3/30/20
Date: 3/16/20 – Argument Postponed: 4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term
Rescheduled Argument Date: 10/14/20 Decided: 3/4/21
Author: J. Gorsuch Other: Breyer (D)
Result: AFFIRMED (ACB – no part)

19-508 * CFX AMG CAPITAL MGMT., LLC V. FTC

Courts: USCA-9 Granted: 7/9/20
Order Date: 11/9/20 – No longer consolidated with No. 19-825
Argument Date: 1/13/21 Decided: 4/22/21
Author: J. Breyer
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-511 # CFX FACEBOOK, INC. V. DUGUID

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 7/9/20
Argument Date: 12/8/20 Decided: 4/1/21
Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Alito (C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-546 * CFX BROWNBACK V. KING

Court: USCA-6 Granted: 3/30/20
Argument Date: 11/9/20 Decided: 2/25/21
Author: J. Thomas Other: Sotomayor (C)
Result: REVERSED

19-547 CFX UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERV. V. SIERRA CLUB, INC.
Court: USCA-9 Granted: 3/2/20
Argument Date: 11/2/20 Decided: 3/4/21
Author: J. Barrett Other: Breyer (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-783 CFY VAN BUREN V. UNITED STATES

Court: USCA-11 Granted: 4/20/20
Argument Date: 11/30/20 Decided: 6/3/21
Author: J. Barrett Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-840 ) CFX CALIFORNIA V. TEXAS

19-1019) CFX TEXAS V. CALIFORNIA
Court: USCA-5 Granted: 3/2/20
Argument Date: 11/10/20 Decided: 6/17/21
Author: J. Breyer Other: Thomas (C); Alito (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

-4-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-863 CFX NIZ-CHAVEZ V. GARLAND

Court: USCA-6 Granted: 6/8/20
Argument Date: 11/9/20 Decided: 4/29/21
Author: J. Gorsuch Other: Kavanaugh (D)
Result: REVERSED

19-897 CFX JOHNSON V. GUZMAN CHAVEZ

Court: USCA-4 Granted: 6/15/20
Argument Date: 1/11/21 Decided: 6/29/21
Author: J. Alito Other: Thomas (C/P & C/J); Breyer (D)
Result: REVERSED

19-930 * CFX CIC SERVS., LLC V. IRS

Court: USCA-6 Granted: 5/4/20
Argument Date: 12/1/20 Decided: 5/17/21
Author: J. Kagan Other: Sotomayor (C); Kavanaugh (C)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-968 CFX UZUEGBUNAM V. PRECZEWSKI

Court: USCA-11 Granted: 7/9/20
Argument Date: 1/12/21 Decided: 3/8/21
Author: J. Thomas Other: Kavanaugh (C); Chief Justice (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-1039 CFX PENNEAST PIPELINE CO. V. NEW JERSEY

Court: USCA-3 Granted: 2/3/21
Argument Date: 4/28/21 Decided: 6/29/21
Author: Chief Justice Other: Gorsuch (D); Barrett (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-1155) * CFX GARLAND V. MING DAI

19-1156) * CFX GARLAND V. ALCARAZ-ENRIQUEZ
Court: USCA-9 Granted: 10/2/20
Argument Date: 2/23/21 Decided: 6/1/21
Author: J. Gorsuch
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

19-1189 CFX BP P.L.C. V. MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF BALTIMORE

Court: USCA-4 Granted: 10/2/20 (SAA – no part)
Argument Date: 1/19/21 Decided: 5/17/21
Author: J. Gorsuch Other: Sotomayor (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (SAA – no part)

-5-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-1231) * CFX FCC V. PROMETHEUS RADIO PROJECT

19-1241) * CFX NATIONAL ASSN. OF BROADCASTERS V. PROMETHEUS RADIO PROJECT
Court: USCA-3 Granted: 10/2/20
Argument Date: 1/19/21 Decided: 4/1/21
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Thomas (C)
Result: REVERSED

19-1257) CFX BRNOVICH V. DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL COMMITTEE

19-1258) CFX ARIZONA REPUBLICAN PARTY V. DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL COMMITTEE
Court: USCA-9 Granted: 10/2/20
Argument Date: 3/2/21 Decided: 7/1/21
Author: J. Alito Other: Gorsuch (C); Kagan (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-1414 * CFY UNITED STATES V. COOLEY

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 11/20/20
Argument Date: 3/23/21 Decided: 6/1/21
Author: J. Breyer Other: Alito (C)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

19-1434) CFX UNITED STATES V. ARTHREX, INC.

19-1452) CFX SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. V. ARTHREX, INC.
19-1458) CFX ARTHREX, INC. V. SMITH & NEPHEW, INC.
Court: USCA-Fed. Granted: 10/13/20
Argument Date: 3/1/21 Decided: 6/21/21
Author: Chief Justice Other: Gorsuch (C/P & D/P)
Breyer (C/J/P & D/P); Thomas (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

19-1442)1 ** # CFX CARR v. SAUL

20-105 )2 **# CFX DAVIS V. SAUL
Court: 1USCA-10; 2USCA-8 Granted: 11/9/20
Argument Date: 3/3/21 Decided: 4/22/21
Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Thomas (C/P & C/J);
Breyer (C/P & C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

19-5410 CFY BORDEN V. UNITED STATES

Court: USCA-6 Granted: 3/2/20
Argument Date: 11/3/20 Decided: 6/10/21
Author: J. Kagan Other: Thomas (C/J); Kavanaugh (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

-6-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-5807 CFH EDWARDS V. VANNOY

Court: USCA-5 Granted: 5/4/20
Argument Date: 12/2/20 Decided: 5/17/21
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Thomas (C); Gorsuch (C)
Kagan (D)
Result: AFFIRMED

19-8709 # CFY GREER V. UNITED STATES

Court: USCA-11 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/20/21 Decided: 6/14/21 (with No. 20-444)
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Sotomayor (C - as to 19-8709);
(C/P, D/P & D/J – as to 20-444)
Result: AFFIRMED (Opinion also for tandem case United States v. Gary, No. 20-444
– Reversed; unanimous in judgment as to No. 19-8709 only)

20-18 # CSY LANGE V. CALIFORNIA

Court: CA-CA, 1st App. Dist. Granted: 10/19/20
Argument Date: 2/24/21 Decided: 6/23/21
Author: J. Kagan Other: Kavanaugh (C)
Thomas (C/P & C/J)
Chief Justice (C/J)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

20-107 CFX CEDAR POINT NURSERY V. HASSID

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 11/13/20
Argument Date: 3/22/21 Decided: 6/23/21
Author: Chief Justice Other: Kavanaugh (C); Breyer (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

20-157 * CFX CANIGLIA V. STROM

Court: USCA-1 Granted: 11/20/20
Argument Date: 3/24/21 Decided: 5/17/21
Author: J. Thomas Other: Chief Justice (C); Alito (C)
Kavanaugh (C)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

20-222 CFX GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. V. ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM
Court: USCA-2 Granted: 12/11/20
Argument Date: 3/29/21 Decided: 6/21/21
Author: J. Barrett Other: Sotomayor (C/P & D/P)
Gorsuch (C/P & D/P)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

20-255 CFX MAHANOY AREA SCHOOL DIST. V. B. L.

Court: USCA-3 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/28/21 Decided: 6/23/21
Author: J. Breyer Other: Alito (C); Thomas (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
-7-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

20-297 CFX TRANSUNION LLC V. RAMIREZ

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 12/16/20
Argument Date: 3/30/21 Decided: 6/25/21
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Thomas (D); Kagan (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

20-315 * CFX SANCHEZ V. MAYORKAS

Court: USCA-3 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/19/21 Decided: 6/7/21
Author: J. Kagan
Result: AFFIRMED

20-334 * CFX SAN ANTONIO V. HOTELS.COM, L.P.

Court: USCA-5 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/21/21 Decided: 5/27/21
Author: J. Alito
Result: AFFIRMED

20-366 ATX TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF U.S. V. NEW YORK

Court: USDC-S. Dist., NY Juris Postponed: 10/16/20
Argument Date: 11/30/20 Decided: 12/18/20
Author: Per Curiam Other: Breyer (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

20-382 * CFX GUAM V. UNITED STATES

Court: USCA-DC Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/26/21 Decided: 5/24/21
Author: J. Thomas
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

20-437 * CFY UNITED STATES V. PALOMAR-SANTIAGO

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/27/21 Decided: 5/24/21
Author: J. Sotomayor
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

20-440 CFX MINERVA SURGICAL, INC. V. HOLOGIC, INC.

Court: USCA-Fed Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/21/21 Decided: 6/29/21
Author: J. Kagan Other: Alito (D); Barrett (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

-8-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

20-444 CFY UNITED STATES V. GARY

Court: USCA-4 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/20/21 Decided: 6/14/21 (with No. 19-8709)
Author: J. Kavanaugh Other: Sotomayor (C – as to 19-8709);
(C/P, D/P & D/J – as to 20-444)
Result: REVERSED - See Opinion Greer v. United States, No. 19-8709

20-472 CFX HOLLYFRONTIER CHEYENNE REFINING, LLC V. RENEWABLE FUELS ASSN.

Court: USCA-10 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/27/21 Decided: 6/25/21
Author: J. Gorsuch Other: Barrett (D)
Result: REVERSED

20-512)* CFX NATIONAL COLLEGIATE ATHLETIC ASSN. V. ALSTON

20-520)* CFX AM. ATHLETIC CONFERENCE V. ALSTON
Court: USCA-9 Granted: 12/16/20
Argument Date: 3/31/21 Decided: 6/21/21
Author: J. Gorsuch Other: Kavanaugh (C)
Result: AFFIRMED

20-543) CFX YELLEN V. CONFEDERATED TRIBES OF CHEHALIS RESERVATION

20-544) CFX ALASKA NATIVE VILLAGE CORP. V. CONFEDERATED TRIBES CHEHALIS
RESERVATION
Court: USCA-DC Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/19/21 Decided: 6/25/21
Author: J. Sotomayor Other: Gorsuch (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

20-5904**# CFY TERRY V. UNITED STATES

Court: USCA-11 Granted: 1/8/21
Argument Date: 4/20/21
Date: 3/19/21 – Removed from April 2021 argument calendar
Rescheduled Argument Date: 5/4/21 Decided: 6/14/21
Author: J. Thomas Other: Sotomayor (C/P & C/J)
Result: AFFIRMED

NOTE:

19-825 CFX FTC V. CREDIT BUREAU CENTER

Courts: USCA-7 Granted: 7/9/20 (see 11/9/20 order)
Order: 11/9/20 – No longer consolidated with No. 19-508, and 7/9/20 order granting
certiorari vacated (ACB – no part)
Decided: 5/3/21
Result: DENIED (ACB – no part)

-9-
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

19-963 CFX HENRY SCHEIN, INC. V. ARCHER AND WHITE SALES, INC.
Court: USCA-5 Granted: 6/15/20
Argument Date: 12/8/20 Decided: 1/25/21
Author: Per Curiam
Result: DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED

19-1212 CFX MAYORKAS V. INNOVATION LAW LAB

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 10/19/20
Argument Date: 3/1/21
Order Date: 2/3/21 – Further briefing held in abeyance, and case removed from the
February 2021 argument calendar
Decided: 6/21/21
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED with instructions to direct the District Court to
vacate as moot the April 8, 2019 order granting preliminary injunction.

19-1328 CFX DEPT. OF JUSTICE V. HOUSE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

Court: USCA-DC Granted: 7/2/20
Argument Date: 12/2/20
Order Date: 11/20/20 – Removed from the December 2020 Argument Calendar
Decided: 7/2/21
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED with instructions to direct the District Court to
vacate the October 25, 2019 order granting Committee’s application.

20-37) CFX BECERRA, SEC. OF H&HS V. GRESHAM

20-38) CFX ARKANSAS V. GRESHAM
Court: USCA-DC Granted: 12/4/20
Argument Date: 3/29/21
Date: 3/11/21 – Removed from calendar for March 2021 argument session
Order Date: 4/5/21 - Cases held in abeyance pending further order of Court.

20-138 CFX BIDEN, PRESIDENT OF U.S. V. SIERRA CLUB

Court: USCA-9 Granted: 10/19/20
Argument Date: 2/22/21
Order Date: 2/3/21 – Further briefing held in abeyance, and case removed from the
February 2021 argument calendar
Decided: 7/2/21
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED with instructions to direct the District Court to
vacate its judgments.

- 10 -
 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST
OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

Cases (Arguments) Made Available: 66 (52)

Cases (Arguments) Available per Rescheduling from 2019 Term: 12 (10)
TOTAL Available for Argument: 78 (62)
Cases (Arguments) Disposed of Without Argument: 3 (3) + 1*
- BY SIGNED OPINION/JUDGMENT:
- BY PER CURIAM OPINION:
- DISMISSED:
- OTHER: 3 (3) + 1 (*FORMER CONSOLIDATED CASE NO. 19-825 GRANT ORDER VACATED; PETITION DENIED)
Cases (Arguments) Argued: 72 (58)
Cases (Arguments) Disposed of With Argument: 72 (58)
- BY SIGNED OPINION/JUDGMENT: 69 (55)
- BY PER CURIAM OPINION: 2 (2)
- DISMISSED IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED/OTHER: 1 (1)
No. of Opinionsi for Argued Cases: 57
Cases (Arguments) in Abeyance: 2 (1)

CASE CODE KEY

 First Letter = Jurisdictional Grounds (ex. 20-000 CSX)

C - Certiorari
A - Appeal
Q - Certified Question

 Second Letter = Court Below (ex. 20-000 CSX)

S - State
F - U.S. Court of Appeals
T - Three-Judge District Court
M - U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces
O - Other Court

 Third Letter = Nature of Case (ex. 20-000 CSX)

X - Civil
Y - Criminal
H - Habeas Corpus or other collateral attack

i
NOTE: * Unanimous Opinion/ ** Unanimous in Part/ # Unanimous in Judgment

- 11 -