Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Synopsis114553 - Marital Rape and Criminalisation of Sexual Assualts in Marriages
Synopsis114553 - Marital Rape and Criminalisation of Sexual Assualts in Marriages
1
Abstract
Rape exposes the failures of a society in terms of providing better security to individuals within
it. A rape not only is an attack on a person physically but it also leaves the person mentally
unstable. Assaulting individuals through the shameful act of rape is becoming a grave concern
for the society. One of the most heinous crimes that occur these days is marital rape. This
terminology breaks the sacred bond between a man and a woman. Forcing someone into physical
intercourse is never desirable among civilised people. Marital rape is a global problem and the
developing countries are mostly facing these issues as there is lack of awareness and lack of laws
to address these concerns. Marital rape reaps apart the soul of a women and it can be considered
It is observed that the lack of law enforcement is allowing the beast disguised as human to fulfil
their sexual needs via forcing the wives to participate in an intercourse. Marital rape is only
establishing Satanist activity instead of serenity in the holy bond of marriage. Any forceful
intercourse without consent can be identified as heinous as rape and the paper aims to identify
marital rape as a different form of rape and discusses the historical background of how marital
rape obtained legal sanctity. The paper also aims to discuss the prevalence of marital rape
globally and its effects on the victims. The criminalisation of the marital rape will also be
focused upon while showing a comparison between the rules of marital rape in countries like
2
Table of Contents
Introduction......................................................................................................................................4
● Meaning of marital rape......................................................................................................4
● Historical background.........................................................................................................4
● Rationale behind research...................................................................................................5
Research Problem............................................................................................................................6
Review of Literature........................................................................................................................6
● Forms of marital rape..........................................................................................................6
● Concept of consents in marriages........................................................................................7
● Ground for non-criminalisation of marital rape vs. ground for criminalising marital rape..8
● Aspect of a victim in marital rape.......................................................................................9
● Legal provisions under the penal code of India, and USA................................................10
Research Objectives.......................................................................................................................10
Relevance of research....................................................................................................................11
● Perception of criminalisation of marital rape....................................................................11
Proposed Research Methodology..................................................................................................12
● Research Approach...........................................................................................................12
● Research Philosophy.........................................................................................................13
● Research Design...............................................................................................................13
● Data Collection: Primary and secondary data...................................................................14
● Sampling...........................................................................................................................15
● Data analysis.....................................................................................................................16
● Ethical Consideration........................................................................................................16
● Limitations........................................................................................................................16
Research Dimensions.....................................................................................................................17
● Survey results and literature review..................................................................................17
Expected Outcomes and Implications...........................................................................................17
● Understanding the arguments on criminalisation of marital rape......................................17
● Needs for the enforcement of domestic violence protection act........................................18
References......................................................................................................................................20
3
Introduction
Marital rape has been a widespread problem for women which is existing over centuries. Married
women of different ages are suffering from physical or sexual assaults. Marriage has been
considered as the holy ritual that binds together two different souls. This relationship involves
not only two people but also their families (Yewale, 2022). Then how can a heinous crime like
“rape” be related with marriage? To answer this question one needs to summarise the situation
that explains any sexual activity by the partner without the consent of other is signified as
“marital rape”. This occurs specifically with women who have not consented for the sexual
activity, however, get forced, and tortured by the partner to fulfil their physical desire. It is quite
a debatable topic across nations since people believe that marriage is an open licence to fulfil
sexual desires anytime anywhere. Many people don't have the idea on concepts of consent and
marital rape. They are not ready to accept the fact that unconsented and forced sexual activity is
● Historical background
In the 17th century, there were beliefs that a man is never accused of having physical intimacy
with his wife after marriage and a wife is automatically expected to offer herself to the husband
and should not retract it. Hence, it is clear from the history itself that marital rapes are not being
reported.
As per reports, about 32 countries have still not yet criminalised the marital rape though it was
recognised as crime worldwide. According to the experts of law, the basic human rights are
getting violated for not legalising marital rape (Banerjee, and Rao, 2022). However, marital rape
is to some extent neglected in legislature. For example in India, the marital rape is not directly
4
listed in the penal code. Under the section 375 of Indian Penal Code (IPC), which criminalises
rape makes an exception such that “Sexual intercourse of man with his own wife, the wife not
being under the age of 15 years, is not rape”. Therefore, if the wife is above the age of 15 years
then unconsented sexual intercourse will not be an issue (Balazsi, 2021). The research tries to
focus on the aspects of marital rape and how the judiciary should take necessary steps to control
it. The research also further compares the laws regarding marital rape case in developed country
such as USA while comparing them with the laws of India and understanding how it can be
adopted.
Women in many countries are flailing prey marital rape, unwanted touching in private part,
shoving or pressing male penis against their body. After, the 20th century, the awareness against
rape engorged the stand that even married people must have some boundaries between them
(Godha, 2021). Any sexual anatomy of a woman's body requires consent even if she is married.
However, to the irony, the socio-legal problems regarding marital rape is not recognised yet in
these countries like India. The problem also explains further issues of being sexually injured or
Traditionally, marriage is considered as the holy matrimonial bond between a man and women.
However, the cruellest crimes such as rape or precisely marital rape is leaving people in deep
concern and they have started questioning the validity of marriages. The case studies from India,
and other developing countries are quite shocking. Marital rate in countries like India violates
human rights. Though there is no direct law in the constitution of India, the act of marital rape
violates the saying of article 14 and 21 (Singh, 2022). These articles preserve the right of women
to live independently in a safe place and have equal human rights as men.
5
The research is influenced with the grief and sadness that the rape victims bear inside their heart.
Moreover, in most cases they are not even getting the desired support they want. With further
advancement in research it is found that there is lack of awareness regarding this topic and
people hesitate to report physical aggressiveness or sexual coercion in marriages (Rao Kallakuru,
and Soni, 2018). Therefore, criminalising the sexual assault becomes important and that is why
Research Problem
Research problem is something that defines the need for the research.
Research Question: What is marital rape and how the criminalisation of sexual assaults within
Problem: The act of sexual intercourse with the spouse without individual consent
Intervention: Identifying penal laws and amending current penal laws that can provide safety and
security for the innocent women falling prey of marital rape (Kumar, 2021)
Comparison: Comparing the different real time data gathered from developing countries like
Outcomes: Bringing awareness to the woman in the society whether married or going to be
married
Review of Literature
The main issue that is being discussed in this writing is marital rape and criminalisation of sexual
assaults within marriage. Marital rapes can be cruel and most of the time bride herself is unable
to realise the crime. Several literature is available in the libraries which enlighten people on the
6
act of domestic violence and sexual rights of a woman. The different forms of marital rape can
be presented as follows:
Battering rape: Under this circumstances, a man beats his wife and after that he forces himself on
the wife to have physical intimacy. In this case both physical and sexual “hostility” coexist. Due
to the nature of rape vast marital rape cases fall into the category. Next comes the
Forceful rapes: This happens when the woman refuses to have physical intercourse with the
partner and the man resorts to force (Mehta, 2021.). This type of marital rape includes no battery
of physical violence.
Lastly,
Obsessive rape: This rape is carried out by a husband with a purpose of eliciting emotional
responses. All of these rape forms are allegedly leaving a harm on the self-respect and human
As defended by the European commission human right “a rapist is a rapist, no matter what type
of relationship is shared between the two” (Robinson, 2017). However, the police officials,
prosecutors and general public show off such shame to the woman, that she herself feels helpless
The ritual of consent in marriages includes a “yes” from both the partners. In the 21st century,
every single person is born free and equal. The male and female consent protects each citizen’s
liberty and their rights to live in harmony. Consent is a term that can be determined as the
personal interaction between man and woman in their marriage. After a woman accepts the
marriage proposal from a man, she is expected to provide her explicit agreement at every step.
There is a very thin line that distinguishes rape from natural sexual intercourse and that line is
7
called consent. To the irony, in most of the case, woman’s agreement to “sexual relations is
inferred after her marriage” and she is usually not expected to revoke it (Garg, and Singla, 2013).
Traditionally, in developing countries like India, a woman is the responsibility of her father
before marriage and becomes a property of her husband after marriage. These concepts are
demeaning and often people use deception, trickery, fraud and dishonesty to get a woman’s
company. However, some people mix up consent with submission. In the sphere of marital rape
consent, submissions should be treated individually. Also, the constitution needs to understand
that the women’s lack of protest does not mean that she agreed for physical intimacy.
Only because she did not object, it never gives a man the right to invade a woman’s privacy.
Sadly, only in case of marital rapes, the wives consent is automatically considered irrespective of
her resistance (Pandey, 2013). This is a clear violation of a woman’s free will and such incidents
are required to be avoided for maintaining women's basic human rights. Getting permission from
both parties before engaging in sexual intercourse cannot be overstated. Hence, in this research
the factors that influence marital rape are going to be discussed and focus will be not
criminalising it.
● Ground for non-criminalisation of marital rape vs. ground for criminalising marital
rape
For a longer period of time, women have been considered as incapable of making their own
judgements in orthodox society (Singh, 2022). Therefore, their partners are always looked upon
while they make decisions. That is why she is presumed to have provided her consent in the case
of having sexual pleasure. This thinking leads towards the thought of non-criminalising marital
8
1) Criminalising marital rape would destroy the holy event of marriage while labelling the
woman as a rebel in front of the society. This will also question the husband’s rights of
fulfilling physical desires since he has been providing for the unemployed woman
3) There might be an increase seen of false cruelty and dowry accusations made by the
The ground for criminalising the marital rape includes management of legal rights for woman.
Basic human rights include the right to say no in sexual intercourse even if the act is initiated by
the husband. The history itself has always been against women. For example, Cameroon’s law
can be taken into consideration which creates legal impunity for the men who sexually assault
their wives (Pandey, 2013). The wives are often considered as the sex slaves who are bound to
serve themselves every day before their husband to fall prey of rape. In most of the case, the
insensitivity of the officials during handling the marital rape case is something that one should
Showing violence towards a woman and participating in forceful penetration requires immediate
law enforcement to be stopped. The act of brutality during intercourse, needs to be corrected to
ensure the wellbeing of women. The Indian Law Commission and government officials have
confirmed that criminalising marital rape is not easy because of the relativism. The
discrimination against women has increased. Although the Domestic violence act of 2005 gives
punishment for a woman being injured due to reckless physical intercourse. The section 13 of
“Hindu Marriage act” allows taking divorce on the grounds of “cruelty” (Angel, 2021). While
several exceptions to the Indian Evidence Act are generated, it is essential that the marital rape
incident is criminalised.
9
● Aspect of a victim in marital rape
A victim of marital rape can face multiple injuries. Out of them, repeated bruising and other
physical injuries to the regions of vagina and anus can be considered. These bruises might never
heal since they are frequently getting tortured in the same place. Forceful sexual activity can be a
reason behind the anxiety, shock and psychological issues. There can be health hazards such as
miscarriage, STDs (Sexually transmitted Disease), or unwanted pregnancy. Some symptoms, like
Since the attacker of the victim is a known person, a woman often observes utter powerlessness.
In developing countries there is absolutely no legislation against the marital rape and nobody is
Imposing penalties for rape in married couples has become a challenge in the provision of
countries like India. On the other hand, countries like USA was the first ever to define the crime
of rape. Section 271 of the code defined any unwanted penetration as sexual assault. The serious
crime of rape is a punishable offense such as 10 years in prison (Easterby-Smith et al., 2018). If
this sexual assault occurs within a marriage the spouse is eligible for punishment.
On the other hand, the spousal rape is never considered as a crime in India and they are always
getting away even after committing such a heinous crime. However, in developed countries have
taken stricter action against the rape and it has to be reported within the 30 days of the act. The
following states of the country USA, such as California, South Carolina is part of taking steps
towards reducing marital rape rates. “The United Nations Committee on the Elimination of
Discrimination against Women (CEDAW Committee)” pushed the countries to align rape laws
as per the international law standards (Banerjee, and Rao, 2022). The act of rape will be
10
specifically defined based on the terminology of “lack of consent”. The “UN handbook” under
these circumstances can be identified as the most important element. Moreover, the
implementation of facts such as women, peace and security in 2009, allows assault victims to get
Research Objectives
The research tries to understand whether why the criminalisation of the marital rape has not yet
taken place. Does this mean that marriage provides a license to rape? The research would be
going through a socio-legal analysis of marital rape in different countries like India, and USA to
gather real time data and strengthen the research. According to the Indiana University Press data,
“more than 1 in every 7 women who have been married has been raped in their marriage”
(Robinson, 2017). As per the data of “United Nations Population Fund”, women of the age group
of 15-55 years are vulnerable towards forceful sex, battery and physical torture. In short the
● To investigate the current legal framework and identify the barriers towards
● To provide a comparative analysis on the status of marital rapes between countries like
● To identify measures that can be undertaken to spread awareness regarding this heinous
crime and promote the concepts of consent taking before physical intercourse takes place
Relevance of research
11
● Perception of criminalisation of marital rape
The 1983 criminal amendment act established protection against rape and preserving woman
rights. Initially, the measures were established to identify custodial rape, acknowledge power
abuse, and identify those in positions of leadership who frequently suffered abuse. Hospital staff
and management, public employees, jail superintendents, or managers, have all been charged
with misusing their power and influence. Evidence manipulation is conceivable because of the
position of authority, which was acknowledged in 1983. Later on the Amendments of 2013,
helped women to get justice against the heinous crimes like rape. The term "rape" was defined in
section 375 to encompass all forms of bodily penetration, including rape, on any portion of a
Prior to this change, the Indian Penal Code described rape as occurring only when a man's penis
reached a woman's vagina. There is now a seventh "circumstance": when a woman is unable to
communicate her permission. Inclusion of this new clause clarifies that the simple absence of
physical consent is not implied by resistance. Rape committed by members of the armed forces
and by relatives, guardians, and educators has been included into Section 376. A new category
was created at this point to highlight the crime or rape committed by an individual in a position
of authority or power. Criminalisation was also applied to other types of sexual assault against
women, including voyeurism and stalking (Robinson, 2017). Resulting from a 2013 alteration,
the consent age was increased from 16 to 18 years old, "outraging the modesty of a woman" was
kept, and the act executions occurred. It is often seen that due to sexual assault, the victim either
passed away, became mentally disturbed or went into vegetative state. Overall, by amending the
12
● Research Approach
beliefs that direct researchers in the performance of their studies is known as the research
approach. There are three sorts of research methodologies: inductive, abductive and deductive.
Deductive procedures help create theories and are intended to test hypotheses (Scotland, 2012).
The positivist philosophy is appropriate for this method (Maher & et al., 2018). This method has
involved developing theories based on assumptions, with the results helping to either confirm or
refute the theories. When a high number of samples are obtained using quantitative procedures, it
analysis findings (Ranney & et al. 2015). Last but not the least, there is an abductive type of
approach. This approach is starting with new facts and completely devoted to the explanation of
content.
Since, the aim of this study is to deliver an understanding of the requirement of criminalising
● Research Philosophy
The definition of research philosophy is defined as knowledge creation that integrates concepts
and techniques through structural phases. There are three varieties of it such as positivist
philosophy, pragmatism, and interpretivism (Ranney 2015). When researchers employ statistical
techniques to examine hypotheses and are connected to reality, they apply the positivist
ideology. According to Creswell (2013), positivism is a philosophy that uses a methodical and
scientific approach to examine society and establish connections between various variables. The
interpretivism school of thought emphasises the recognition of phenomena and processes. The
13
philosophy of pragmatism is one that develops research methods and strives to resolve problems
Since, the aim of this study is to deliver an understanding of the requirement of criminalising
marital rape, the best applicable method is positivism. As it deals with statistical information.
● Research Design
The technique that helps researchers construct study elements in order to draw research
conclusions is known as research design. There are three different kinds of research designs such
research to identify phenomena by posing questions and looking for fresh perspectives. (Maher
& et al., 2018). A descriptive design is one that provides an explanation of occurrences by
analysing them from different angles. Explanatory research designs are used in quantitative
Since, the aim of this study is to deliver an understanding of the requirement of criminalising
The process of conducting a research study in order to gather information and data that are
necessary for the study is known as data gathering. Primary data are first-hand information
gathered from many sources such as surveys, observations, interviews, and so on. Secondary
sources are also used in this data collection process. It is real-time data that requires a longer
time span, is expensive, and is highly complex (Easterby-Smith et al., 2018). These statistics
have already been published and were gathered from a variety of websites, books, papers, and
other publications.
14
Since, the research is based on the investigation of criminalisation of marital rape there is an
extreme need of using primary and secondary data. The primary data is analysed through
preparing graphs and charts. All these charts are made clear where survey data from different
participants are gathered and the relevant work is presented. These data sources are highly valid
and also accurate and even assist in gaining updated data. The collected data is also stored in a
transcript in the researcher’s laptop and that too with high security (Singh, 2022). All the
documents are password protected which ensures that the research is filled with integrity to the
core. In addition, secondary material for this study was gathered from books, news, articles, and
other sources. Every piece of information gathered from secondary sources has helped
The most impactful data that would complement this research has been identified as the primary
quantitative data and secondary qualitative data. The secondary qualitative data will use a
thematic analysis process so that journals and articles providing information on the topic get the
maximum values. The researcher has used qualitative approaches since they aid in data
processing and provide a full description of the study. This study has also employed this research
methodology as it operates on a tight budget and yields results quickly (Dammak, 2015). This
approach will even assist in obtaining specific understanding to increase corporation revenue and
However, there is a greater likelihood that qualitative research would be subjective and
approaches concentrate on quantifying data and tracking empirical factors (Rahi, 2017). In order
to investigate significance and variances, this approach requires bigger sample sizes and use
15
statistical procedures. Researchers can identify issues that require more investigation and create
● Sampling
There are two forms of sampling: probability and non-probability. In probability sampling,
researchers employ tools connected to probability theory to pick a sample from a broader
population (Flick, 2012). Statistical theory is utilised in this sampling process to randomly select
a small sample size from a larger population group. Non-probability sampling is a technique
where samples are chosen based on the researcher's discretion. This probability sampling is used
Purposive sampling was chosen for this investigation through the use of probability sampling
techniques. This kind of random sampling technique involves the researcher purposefully
selecting a sample that provides data relevant to the research questions. Purposive sampling was
used to choose 100 participants (Verma, 2023). These respondents answered questions in a
closed-loop fashion with recorded survey results. Every participant received a consent document
indicating their freedom to participate in the interview. Nobody was coerced into taking part in
the survey. This sampling is simple to use and has helped in connecting with the target
population alone.
● Data analysis
Data analysis is the process of organising facts and numbers to address research issues. It is
crucial for both data interpretation and research answer discovery. Descriptive thematic data
analysis was selected since the study's goal is to explore long-term legal changes for marital rape
in order to increase women's empowerment (Irene, 2014). In order to provide theory that is
16
connected to study findings, this approach has helped researchers by providing themes that
● Ethical Consideration
This study placed a strong emphasis on ethics by requiring individuals to give informed consent
before participating. All the data associated with this research were efficiently stored to ensure
data security and prevent unauthorised access. Peer-reviewed publications were the only
authentic sources of data used in this study, which exclusively collected data from reliable
academic sources. Since each piece of work in this study was thoroughly examined, the
● Limitations
The rationale behind the work is quite clear since it reviews the present socio-legal scenario. The
research needs to identify why there is a barrier behind the criminalisation of marital rape. While
doing the research some resources were found to be paid. Since the projects are not backed up by
the university, the paid elements were hard to access. Most importantly, time constraints were
limiting the research as there was less time allocated to gather field data. The research can only
suggest methods by which the situation can be improved. However, there is no authority
Research Dimensions
The research uses close ended questions of survey results to organise the content. The best ever
literatures across the continents will be utilised in this case. The literatures will be searched in
17
● Understanding the arguments on criminalisation of marital rape
The Indian courts and non-governmental organisations have provided several justification in
favour of criminalising marital rape. The arguments on criminalisation are important to protect
the basic human rights of a woman. Physical and psychological effects on a victim’s health
highly affects the person’s overall existence (Verma, 2023). If the law against marital rape is not
implemented then it will keep on growing while a violation of the constitution will be seen. The
violation will also include not following article 14. Irrespective of the religion, ethnicity and
gender each individual is entitled to get the equal protection from law. The reformation of law is
important. The state’s commitment towards providing an independent lifestyle to women helps
The future generation also needs a clean and safe environment. This environment can only be
provided by understanding how human rights can be preserved for a woman. A woman whether
married or not has full rights over her body and she can say no to any person in terms of sexual
activities.
Marital rape act cannot stand alone and it will require clauses which will be taken from the
domestic violence act. The domestic violence protection act helps in managing the physical
assaults and battery. Eliminating all forms of discrimination against women is possible via
eliminating the physical torture. Helping the women to manage their human rights allows them
to fight against miscarriages, early pregnancy, unwanted pregnancy, STD, and unsafe abortions.
The right to family equality helps in managing gender based violence. Getting rid of the gender
stereotypes is essential while making it clear that the woman is not a husband’s property.
18
The message has to be pretty clear on the point that marriage does not give a person liberty to
anything and everything forcefully with the wife (Singh, 2022). Just because a man is taking
responsibility for a woman financially it never makes sense to treat the wife as a sex slave.
Imposing penalties for rape in married relationships is a necessary first step towards
criminalising the act itself. One of the most important aspects of managing marital rape is to
make it illegal to claim marital status as an excuse while rape charges are imposed. The next in
line is the establishment of police practices. The authorities in power need to become more
The section 498A of the Indian Penal Code was enacted in 1983 to manage any sort of assault on
the women by the spouse or in-laws. Any nasty behaviour was supposed to be mitigated through
this law. However, the law only protects the women from being physically tortured. Not a single
stance in the law talked about the forceful sexual penetration by the spouse. The concept of
consent is the least that one can expect in the act. It is evident that the society’s norms and
culture are always preferring the men and the one who is providing. Sometimes the woman
might find that the remedy is ineffective since the husband and the family could be only charged
with physical trauma. Hence, the research aims are justified and it is expected to invoke human
emotions in hearts of law makers so that they take steps against the crime.
19
References
Angel, J.K., 2021. Marital Rape: A Crime Undefined in Indian Legal Scenario. Issue 2 Int'l JL
Balazsi, L., 2021. Marital rape in India: the subject of a private matter within the four walls of a
marital home?.
Banerjee, D. and Rao, T.S., 2022. The dark shadow of marital rape: Need to change the
Bennice, J.A. and Resick, P.A., 2003. Marital rape: History, research, and practice. Trauma,
Garg, D.M. and Singla, D.N., 2013. Marital rape under Indian law: A study. International
Godha, S., 2021. Legal Scenario of Marital Rape in India: A Critical Analysis. Supremo
Kumar, V., 2021. Marriage or License to Rape? A Socio-Legal Analysis of Marital Rape in
Mehta, H., 2021. Marital Rape and the Indian Legal Scenario. Issue 3 Int'l JL Mgmt. &
Human., 4, p.756.
Pandey, P.K., 2013. Marital Rape in India-Needs Legal Recognition. Available at SSRN
2290027.
Rao Kallakuru, R. and Soni, P., 2018. Criminalisation of Marital Rape in India: Understanding
Its Constitutional, Cultural and Legal Impact. NUJS L. Rev., 11, p.121.
Rao Kallakuru, R. and Soni, P., 2018. Criminalisation of Marital Rape in India: Understanding
Its Constitutional, Cultural and Legal Impact. NUJS L. Rev., 11, p.121.
20
Rao Kallakuru, R. and Soni, P., 2018. Criminalisation of Marital Rape in India: Understanding
Its Constitutional, Cultural and Legal Impact. NUJS L. Rev., 11, p.121.
Singh, V.P., 2022. Judicial Approaches to the Criminalisation of Marital Rape. Indian Journal of
Yewale, C., 2022. A Study of Marital Rape in India with A Comparison of the UK, USA and
Canada.
Academic Council of the Faculty of Law of the National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy
(protocol No. 9 of October 23, 2023). Approved for publication by the Editorial Board
Publishing”.
Kumar, P., 2022. MARITAL RAPE. VIDHIGYA: The Journal of Legal Awareness, 17.
Fabian, J.M. and Oswald, M.N., 2022. Capacity to Enter into Sexual and Marital Relations. In A
Noreen, S., 2021. Ideal Marital Life Principles in Islamic Law. AL-QAWĀRĪR, 2(04), pp.73-85.
21
Verma, A.K., 2023. Problems Relating to Marital Rape Laws in India. Issue 1 Indian JL & Legal
Rsch., 5, p.1.
22