Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Draft Minutes of Progress Meeting No. 5 - Ruaha Rev 01cm
Draft Minutes of Progress Meeting No. 5 - Ruaha Rev 01cm
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
PROGRESS MEETING No 5
DRAFT MINUTES
Page 1 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
ATTENDANCE:
CLIENT: TANAPA
CONTRACTOR: CHICO
Key Staff
Page 2 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
S/ DISCUSSIONS ACTION
N BY
A: KIGANGA SITE
1. SITE VISIT
Page 3 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
The Chairman opened the meeting at 11: 00 am by welcoming the members and
requested each to introduce oneself in descending order and register in the circulating
INFO
Attendance sheet indicating the following columns: Name, Contractual position, phone
number, email address and the firm represented.
Members acting on “Key staff“ positions i.e not approved, were requested to write “Ag”
before their names. The meeting then proceeded as follows:
3. CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION
i. Contractor’s Mobilization
a) Establishment:
The Project Manager stated Contractor’s establishment status as had been noted during INFO
site visit and recorded above as Item 1.
Regarding WCs, the Contractor was instructed to construct additional pit for the septic
tank. He promised this to be ready within 10 days.
Page 4 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
c) Resources:
❖ Key and Non-Key Personnel:
List of key staff mobilised or not secured or approved but not on site is attached at the
back of these minutes as of this meeting. The Project Manager emphasized the need for
all key staff members to be on-site permanently for respective roles, including the CHICO
preparation of shop and as-built drawings. Contractor promised to mobilise missing staff
by coming week.
The PM further instructed the recruitment and mobilization of Electrical and Mechanical
Engineers as per the contract.
❖ Materials CHICO
➢ Fill up to CBR 15%: Available within cut section on the works
➢ Gravel / Su-base material : To be sourced from Kilimatonge BP, 6km from the site.
CBR has been confirmed to be >22% with PI as 14. The material shall be mix-
designed to get pavement layers (Sub-base CBR 35% _ PI 0 to 6 and Wearing course
CBR100% etc). Mix design trials for the subbase would be ready by 08th December
2023.
➢ Sand: To be sourced from Ruaha river (near Msembe) as shown by the Client_within CHICO
5 km from the site. Organic / impurities tests have been conducted (Sodium
Hydroxide test). Contractor promised results to be ready by 04th December 2023.
This test shall be shall routinely done.
➢ Water: To be sourced from the permanently drilled borehole. As stated under Item 1
above, additional source belonging to the Client has been agreed – the cottage and
test results has complied with requirements. Contractor was advised to fill containers CHICO
at night, probably at the cottage.
➢ Aggregates: To be sourced from Ndolela Quarry 170km from site. Already approved
except LA and soundness. Contractor was instructed to carry out outstanding tests.
He confirmed to have done concrete mix design and Consultant has already approved
C10 and C15 on 7 days strength
INFO
➢ Cement: Four manufacturers with cement strength 42.5N among other issues, have
been approved.
➢ Reinforcement bars: Manufacturer has been approved as Kiluwa Steel and test results
have received approval
➢ Polymer:. Documents from Supplier received by the Contractor, approval granted by
the Consultant with few required clarifications after which Contractor may proceed CHICO
bringing in samples for tests.
➢ Building materials samples
Contractor was requested to start getting approvals for building materials samples as HCL /
TANAPA
these may take long to procure. That the Client Technical Coordinator shall work
hand-in-hand with Consultant’s Architects for the various approvals.
CHICO
The Client and Consultant spent several minutes emphasizing that Contractor plan ahead
and start mobilizing materials to site at earliest.
Page 5 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
❖ Equipment:
Mobilised equipment as of this meeting versus contractual requirements is attached at the
back of these minutes. It remains the same as last month. Contractor continued with his
stand that the mobilised equipment are sifficient to complete the works within the contract
period.
However, the Project Manager pointed out that the RHS of the airstrip, which was initially CHICO
scheduled for completion in October, is still not completed yet. It was further noted that
the submitted work program is not really an update and was thus not accepted. Contractor
was instructed to re-submit one clearly reflecting the actual situation and mobilize
equipment accordingly.
❖ Time: CHICO
Contractor has requested Employer, through the Consultant, for permission to extend
working time from hours specified in the contract to also include Sundays and public
holidays. The request has been approved and Contractor has formally been informed.
❖ Miscellaneous provisions.
i. Contractor has provided one standby generator at the Engineer’s offices in case of CHICO
TANESCO interruptions
CHICO
Page 6 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
a) Healthy
❖ There has been some degree of compliance on a number of issues since last meeting
❖ Contractor has hired one nurse stationed at the camp and built a first aid room at
Kiganga airstrip site. Similarly, he has hired one first aider for the same as instructed INFO
in the last meeting.
❖ Hired a qualified and registered Provider to handle HIV/AIDS issues. _ already
approved by consultant
a) Safety
❖ Client and Consultant observed some degree of compliance on Safety issues
❖ Client / Consultant instructed Contractor to:
• Stock sufficient PPEs at site in accordance with his program of works
• Ensure that drivers receive education on regular vehicle maintenance.
• Appoint one specific person to communicate safety issues within the project and CHICO
introduce the person to the Consultant.
Page 7 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
c) Security
❖ Contractor has not hired security guards as advised by the Client in the last meeting
but stated that:
o He has no intention of doing that because there are no security issues in the area
o No night works scheduled at the Kiganga site yet
o Will continue to study the situation and if need arises, he will do it.
❖ Approval to work at night has been granted by the Employer. When so, rangers will
be provided at a cost
CHICO
d) Environmental
❖ Client and Consultant observed some degree of compliance on environmental issues.
However Contractor was instructed to:
o Reparir the leaking septic tank – repeatition from last meeting
o Submit a plan and prepare a trees nursery during this rain season for restoration
purposes
Consultant commended the Contractor for some improvement on compliance matters but
insisted that these are continuous processes and appropriate steps shall immediately be CHICO
taken in case of default.
Consultant was instructed to check the truth of Contractor’s statements above, including
HCL
other requirements and report back in the next meeting. He was further instructed to
prepare a compliance scheme / check list covering requirements
Page 8 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
Contractor submitted “updated Program of works” along with the Progress report on
27th November 2023. It indicates completion date as 04 th August 2024. Following
discussions on various shortfalls (i.e., activities deemed to have been completed in INFO
previous months are not done yet but still indicated so etc.) members agreed that it is
not updated. Contractor was instructed to re-submit a revised version by 07th
December 2023.
The submission shall:
a) Be resourced, a state which will demonstrate whether additional resources are
required or not
b) Comprise of a supporting report stating how they intend to accelerate the works within
the said resources. CHICO
c) Comprise of a Procurement Plan for materials as discussed in all previous
meetings.
Contractor however, continued to maintain that he has mobilized sufficient resources
to complete the works in accordance with the contract period.
In accordance with Contractor’s Progress report submitted before the meeting, the
progress is as follows inclusive from site clearance to handing over:
i.
Terminal Building_
RFF Building –
ii.
iii.
Power building_
CHICO
iv.Guard house –
v.(Civil works)
a. Runway, Graded strip and Strip excavation
b. Runway, Graded strip and Strip fill
c. Taxiways _ Vegetation clearance and setting out
d. Peripheral roads vegetation clearance
e. Apron _
6 QUALITY CONTROL
ii.Laboratory Equipment:
CHICO
Fully mobilized including all tools sufficient to carry out required tests in the project.
Page 9 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
Following approval of the QAP, Contractor was requested and he agreed to submit
Quality Assurance manual by 08 th December 2023. Shortfalls in the QAP shall be
included during submission of the respective Method Statements.
The Client’s representative and the Project Manager (PM) jointly advised the Contractor
to plan of protecting completed works in anticipation of the upcoming rain season. That
various advises and measures have been proposed to the Contractor in previous
meetings and this is just a repeatition.
Page 10 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
There has been an improvement. The meeting was informed as follows / Contractor was
reminded of the following:
i. Appropriate PPEs to be provided to workers
ii. Fuel to be used for cooking (any charcoal has to be from authorized dealers). CHICO
Consultant to follow the supplier to confirm
iii. Terminations from works have to be in accordance with laid down procedures
iv. Used oil has to be properly stored and disposed by authorized dealers. Contractor
to confirm with consultant regarding the availability and hiring of the dealer
v. A nurse has been hired and stationed at the camp. All structures are nearby
vi. Eight ladies are currently at site (five directly employed by Contractor_ One nurse,
three for domestic issues, and one at site). Three are self employed within the site
cooking for the workers _ food venders).
vii. Where stubborn workers are encountered, any terminations shall be through legal
procedures.
7. Aggregates:
Aggregates sizes 0-6mm (200m3); 6-10mm (180m3) and 10-20mm (180m3) were
noted to have been stockpiled within the camp. (Refer also to Chapters 9 and 10
below).
8. Male dormitory
i. Mosquito nets _ Contractor promised to provide them on 28 th November 2023
ii. Contractor to provide lights at night to assist against issues like snakes etc. Spot
lights (torch) may assist for all
iii. Partitioning of the dormitory into three sections has been completed. Workers
have own criterion on who have to stay on which section.
The PM emphasized the importance of creating a conducive environment for staff CHICO
members to stay on site and also stressed that having the key staff on site is crucial for
the project's progress and success. The contractor accepted this comment and
acknowledged
ii. Materials:
a) Fill and Gravel: Two BPs for natural materials have been identified at roughly 3km
from the site (G3) and 25km (CBR > 10%). Contractor stated that they need over
Page 11 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
8,000m3 for the later material and these will be hauled after the rains. Contractor was
reminded of conditions issued under Meeting No 4 regarding the G3 BP:
CHICO
b) Sand: Currently being sourced at Madunda river for temporary works. Contractor
promised to provide results for tests instructed in meeting No 4 within seven days.
The PM emphasized on organic impurity tests (Sodium Hydroxide)
c) Water: Contractor drilled one borehole 90m deep where he is currently using the
water for temporary works. In accordance with Test results:
➢ It can be used for concrete works with its chloride content of 54.50 mg/L.
➢ The water is alkaline and cannot be used for construction unless blended first.
Following further sampling and testing, results indicated that the water meets
CHICO
necessary requirements and is suitable for use in construction.
Based on initial test results and recommendation from the water authority,
Contractor is requested to make an interpretation of the test results based on its
direct use on concrete works but need to blend it for construction uses.
d) Aggregates: Contractor continues sourcing aggregates from Mswiswi where there is
one quarry belonging to another Contractor (CICO working Mbeya roads project).
iii. Equipment:
List of mobilized equipment versus contractual requirements is attached at the back of
these minutes. The list indicates 13 tipper trucks apart from other equipment. Contractor CHICO
still maintains two work fronts / teams for civil works. The Client insisisted on formation of
at least three teams to give room for breakdowns, rains etc.
i. Healthy
a) Following test results for the borehole water indicating that the water is not portable,
Contractor was instructed in the last meeting to search for another source. He
confirmed that he will have to get it from Igurusi and this was accepted. Due to poor
CHICO
accessibility during rains, Contractor proposed to collect rain water and carry out
relevant tests to confirm its use as portable.
The meeting agreed that purified rainwater is permitted but quality test has to be
conducted and evaluated as well. Contractor was instructed to submit his plan, carry
our relevant tests and submit results for approval.
b) Canteen, Kitchen and washing area to be extended within ten days and hygiene be
maintained
c) A nurse has been recruited but not first aiders. Camp and working fronts are nearby
CHICO
Page 12 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
ii. Safety
iii.Social / GBV/GRM
a) Toilets: Sufficient WCs provided at the airstrip but misses doors and water.
Contractor promised to address the shortfalls within two days.
b) Key staff to educate workers on GBV /GRM issues and provide appropriate freedom
CHICO
for reports- continuous _ Formation of GRM committee as for Kiganga
c) Sub-contractor’s workers to be recruited from within nearby villages unless there are
constraints i.e., laziness
d) Worker’s accommodation:
Some beds are missing mosquito nets – promised provision next day
iv. Security
a) Rangers are meant to maintain security against animals only. They are to remain
together at night. Security of Contractor’s properties at night remains his
responsibility.
b) Some workers have been provided with IDs. Instructed provisions to all
v. Environment
a) Contractor to have permanent tracks for his trucks transporting materials from the
BP in order to minimize damage to the environment. This was also instructed in the
last meeting.
Following a reply from the Contactor that there are only two tracks (to and from the
BP), the PM requested for Borrow Pit Management Plan which Contractor promised
to submit within 12 days.
b) Solid Waste Materials Management_ Labels for the different types of waste and the
bins to be placed at various working places.
c) Contractor to prepare trees nurseries for restoration purposes as per the contract.
d) Contractor to complete construction of the “collection bay” and “incinerator” within
seven days
In accordance with Contractor’s Progress report submitted before the meeting, the
progress is as follows inclusive from site clearance to handing over: (% to be filled in on INFO
30/11/2023)
Page 13 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
oTerminal Building_
oRFF Building –
oPower building_
oGuard house – CHICO
o(Civil works)
a. Runway, Graded strip and Strip excavation
b. Runway, Graded strip and Strip fill
c. Taxiways _ Vegetation clearance and setting out
d. Peripheral roads vegetation clearance
e. Apron _
13 QUALITY CONTROL
Consultant confirmed status on Quality Control issues to have been as follows since the
last meeting:
i. Surveys equipment / tools:
Dumpy level, RTK GPS are all on site and in working condition. Total station not
mobilized to site yet
CHICO
ii. Laboratory Equipment:
Fully mobilized including all tools sufficient to carry out required tests in the project.
iii. Quality Assurance Plan (QAP)
Contractor was requested to submit his Quality Assurance Plan for this site
iv. Method Statements:
Project Manager reminded Contractor to provide these statements for Engineer’s
approval before commencement of all major activities.
v. Requests for Inspection (RFI):
Consultants team has been attending to all RFIs promptly based on the project
specs
Consultant already issued revised design drawings. The finished design level has been HCL
reduced by 350mm
15 MEASUREMENTS AND FINANCIAL MATTERS
i. Interim Payment Certificate (IPC) No 01 is with the Client on payment procedures TANAP
ii. Contractor submitted IPC 02 on ………… A / HCL
Due to some public holidays towards end of the year and early next one, the Client TC ALL
suggested that the next Progress Meetings be held between 18 th and 20th December 2023
under the leadership of Consultant’s site staff. Minutes have to prepared and circulated
as usual.
Page 14 of 15
Minutes, once corrected and signed by the representatives of all parties to the Project as being a true
record of the proceedings, become a formal part of the records of the proceedings and, as such, may 2023
be used as evidence in any dispute.
Project Manager thanked all the participants for their participation and constructive
contributions. He then declared the meeting closed at 12:30 hours and stated that minutes
of the meeting shall be available as per the contract directives. ALL
Page 15 of 15