SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX

PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS (ID<2300 mm / P<50kg)

DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 1 of 9

SAUDI KAYAN

CLIENT’S DOCUMENT : Client’s ID Code (if required)

REVISION CONTROL PAGE

MAIN DOCUMENT
REV. DATE DESCRIPTION COMMENTS
00 24.09.07 Issued for Technical Evaluation

ATTACHMENTS
ATTACHMENT # DESCRIPTION
Attachment 01 Technical Tabulation Rev. 0

Discipline Engineer Lead Discipline Eng. Project Engineer SK Review SK Approval

Name Name Name Name Name

Yousef Al-
Jose Ribeiro Isidro Luna Ricardo Mateo A. Turkistani
Mohammedsaleh

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 2 of 9

CONTENTS

1. INTRODUCTION
2. QUOTATIONS EVALUATED
3. GENERAL COMMENTS
4. QUOTATIONS REVIEWED BUT TECHNICALLY REJECTED
5. RELEVANT CORRESPONDENCE
6. SPECIFIC COMMENTS TO EACH TECHNICAL BID (TECHNICAL DISCUSSION)
7. QA REVIEW
8. HSE REVIEW
9. TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATION
10. OUTSTANDING TECHNICAL MATTERS
11. ATTACHMENTS
 Technical tabulation
 Deviation List

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 3 of 9

1. INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this technical evaluation is to provide a technical summary of the bids reviewed
against the requirements of the Enquiry Requisition R-1910-0318 and to make a recommendation
for purchase of the equipment listed below:

Item No’s Tag No’s Equipment Title

1 V-51002 Transalkylator Feed Heater Condensate Pot

2 V-51021 Benzene Column Reflux Drum

3 V-51031 Cumene Column Reflux Drum

4 V-51041 PIPB Column Reflux Drum

5 V-51042 PIPB Column Reboiler Condensate Pot

6 V-51051 Propylene Rundown Drum

7 V-51701 Cumene Plant Instrument Air Receiver

8 V-52701 Phenol Plant Instrument Air Receiver

9 V-52273 CHP Receiving Drum

10 V-52401 Acetone Product Column Bottoms Separator

11 V-52432 AMS Tailing Column Reflux Drum

12 V-52441 AMS Hydrogenation Reactor Knockout Drum

13 V-52443 AMS Hydrogenation Separator

14 V-52750 HP Condensate Flash Drum

15 V-52751 Medium Pressure Condensate Flash Drum

16 V-53102 E-53102 Condensate Receiver

17 V-53107 E-53107 Condensate Receiver

18 V-53300 E-53301 Condensate Receiver

19 V-53804 IPE Column Accumulator

20 V-53808 E-53802 Condensate Receiver

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 4 of 9

21 V-53809 E-53806 Condensate Receiver

22 V-56701 BPA Instrument Air Receiver

23 V-56703 HP Condensate Flush Drum

24 V-56704 MP Condensate Flush Drum

2. QUOTATIONS EVALUATED
The following quotations were reviewed based on instructions given by J. A. Sanz e-mail
dated 17th July 2007:

SUPPLIER Ref. No. Date

DAEKYUNG MACHINERY Q2007-08-303 Rev 0 9th Aug. 2007

DAEKYUNG TECHNOS DK07-08-P410 6th Aug. 2007

GULF STEEL WORKS E/7842/SPA/07 11th Aug. 2007

SEOUL MACHINERY SMC-27260 10th Aug. 2007

WOOYANG HC WHC-CR07-256 Rev 0 9th Aug. 2007

ZAMIL STEEL SP/07/0782/00/A 6th Aug. 2007

3. GENERAL COMMENTS
The Suppliers were requested to quote their best price and delivery.

4. QUOTATIONS REVIEWED BUT TECHNICALLY REJECTED

The following quotations were reviewed but technically rejected:

SUPPLIER Ref. No. Date

NONE

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 5 of 9

5. RELEVANT CORRESPONDENCE
Please refer to the following Correspondence Summary for each Bid. These
correspondence logs are an integral part of Supplier’s base offer and shall take
precedence in cases of conflicts with base offer.

SUPPLIER Description / Ref. No. & Date

Email Subject: Daekyung Machinery Quotation Q2007-08-303

dated 9th August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm,
P<50kg), RFQ 1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.

TRF – Daekyung Machinery dated 12th September 2007

DAEKYUNG
TRF – Daekyung Machinery dated 12th September 2007
MACHINERY &
ENGINEERING Daekyung Machinery – TRF dated 13th September 2007
Co., Ltd. Daekyung Machinery – TRF dated 18th September 2007
Korea TRF – Daekyung Machinery dated 19th September 2007
Daekyung Machinery – TRF dated 20th September 2007
Daekyung Machinery – TRF dated 21st September 2007
TRF – Daekyung Machinery dated 24th September 2007
Daekyung Machinery – TRF dated 27th September 2007

Email Subject: Daekyung Technos Quotation DK-07-08-P410

dated 6th August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm,
P<50kg), RFQ 1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.
DAEKYUNG
Technos Co., Ltd.
TRF – Daekyung Technos dated 12th September 2007
Korea
TRF – Daekyung Technos dated 12th September 2007
TRF – Daekyung Technos dated 24th September 2007

GULF STEEL Email Subject: Gulf Steel Works Quotation E/7842/SPA/07 dated
WORKS 11th August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm, P<50kg),
RFQ 1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.
Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia
TRF – Gulf Steel Works dated 12th September 2007
TRF – Gulf Steel Works dated 12th September 2007

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 6 of 9

TRF – Gulf Steel Works dated 24th September 2007

TRF – Gulf Steel Works dated 25th September 2007

Email Subject: Seoul Machinery Quotation SMC-27260 dated 10th

August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm, P<50kg), RFQ
1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.

SEOUL
MACHINERY, Co., TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 12th September 2007
LTD.
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 12th September 2007
Korea
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 24th September 2007
Seoul Machinery – TRF dated 27th September 2007
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 28th September 2007

Email Subject: Wooyang HC Quotation WHC-CR07-256 Rev. 0

dated 9th August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm,
P<50kg), RFQ 1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.
WOOYANG HC,
Co., LTD.
TRF – Wooyang dated 12th September 2007
Korea
TRF – Wooyang dated 12th September 2007
Wooyang – TRF dated 20th September 2007
TRF – Wooyang dated 24th September 2007

Email Subject: Zamil Steel Quotation SP/07/0782/00/A dated 6th

August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm, P<50kg), RFQ
1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.
ZAMIL STEEL
INDUSTRIES
TRF – Zamil Steel dated 12th September 2007
Kingdom of Saudi
TRF – Zamil Steel dated 12th September 2007
Arabia
Zamil Steel – TRF dated 18th September 2007
TRF – Zamil Steel dated 24
0th September 2007

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 7 of 9

6. SPECIFIC COMMENTS TO EACH TECHNICAL BID (TECHNICAL DISCUSSION)

6.1 DAEKYUNG MACHINERY (Ref Quote Q2007-08-303, dated 3rd July 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)

6.1.1 The Vendor states compliance with all requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318
with the exception of……….

6.1.2 Vendor supplied preliminary fabrication schedule, however, documentation dates

need to be finalized before order placement.

6.2 DAEKYUNG TECHNOS (Ref Quote DK-07-08-P410 dated 3rd August 2007&
Correspondence summary as above)

6.2.1 The Vendor states compliance with all requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318
with the exception of………...

6.2.2 Awaiting revision to pricing for supply of ‘normalized’ material.

6.2.3 Vendor, as requested, supplied a separate price for the Level gauges for Item C-
53103. The final price change can be made when TRF finalise details.

6.3 GULF STEEL WORKS, (Ref Quote E/7842/SPA/07 dated 11th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)

6.3.1 The Vendor complies with all the requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318
without any deviation with the exception of………...

6.3.2 Vendor includes a list of deliverables from TRF if he is successful with his offer.
Purchasing to discuss this prior to any order placement.

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 8 of 9

6.4 SEOUL MACHINERY Co. LTD., (Ref Quote SMC-27260 dated 10th August 2007&
Correspondence summary as above)

6.4.1 Vendor states compliance with all the requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318,
but only wishes to confirm documentation delivery dates after any order with the
exception of………………….

6.5 WOOYANG HC Co., (Ref Quote WHC-CR07-256 Rev. 0 dated 9th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)

6.5.1 Vendor states compliance with all the requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318,
with the exception of ……..

6.5.2 Vendor has INCLUDED a separate price for the level gauges for Item V-53103.

6.6 ZAMIL STEEL., (Ref Quote SP/07/0782/00/A dated 6th August 2007& Correspondence
summary as above)

6.6.1 Vendor states compliance with all the requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318,
but only wishes to confirm documentation delivery dates after any order.

6.6.2 Vendor has INCLUDED a separate price for the level gauges for Item V-53103.

7. QA REVIEW
Vendors confirm compliance with Project Procedure 500-00Z-0024 “QA/QC Requirements
for Suppliers”.

8. HSE REVIEW
Vendors confirm compliance with Project Procedure 500-30Z-0005 “HSE Instructions to
Vendors and subcontractors”.

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.

 SAUDI KAYAN PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX
PHENOLICS FACILITIES PROJECT #: 01910

TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 9 of 9

9. TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATION

Based on all of above described and additional information shown on attached technical
tabulation, we technically recommend the following proposals:

 DAEKYUNG MACHINERY

 DAEKYUNG TECHNOS Co. Ltd.

 GULF STEEL WORKS

 SEOUL MACHINERY Co.

 WOOYANG HC Co.

 ZAMIL STEEL0

10. OUTSTANDING TECHNICAL MATTERS

If Hyundai are considered for the supply of the equipment they must include for the
price for any FEA analysis required.

11. ATTACHMENTS.

 Technical Tabulation

This document is property of TR Group. Reproduction thereof is forbidden.