Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TBA - TE-1910-0318 REV 0c
TBA - TE-1910-0318 REV 0c
TBA - TE-1910-0318 REV 0c
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS (ID<2300 mm / P<50kg)
SAUDI KAYAN
ATTACHMENTS
ATTACHMENT # DESCRIPTION
Attachment 01 Technical Tabulation Rev. 0
Attachment 02 Deviation List (Daekyung Machinery) Rev. 0
Attachment 03 Deviation List (Seoul Machinery) Rev. 0
Attachment 04 Deviation List (Wooyang HC) Rev. 0
Attachment 05 Deviation List (Zamil Steel) Rev. 0
Yousef Al-
José Ribeiro Isidro Luna Jesús Riera A. Turkistani
Mohammedsaleh
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 2 of 9
CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION
2. QUOTATIONS EVALUATED
3. GENERAL COMMENTS
4. QUOTATIONS REVIEWED BUT TECHNICALLY REJECTED
5. RELEVANT CORRESPONDENCE
6. SPECIFIC COMMENTS TO EACH TECHNICAL BID (TECHNICAL DISCUSSION)
7. QA REVIEW
8. HSE REVIEW
9. TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATION
10. OUTSTANDING TECHNICAL MATTERS
11. ATTACHMENTS
Technical tabulation
Deviation Lists
-Daekyung Machinery
-Seoul Machinery
-Wooyang HC
-Zamil Steel
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 3 of 9
1. INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this technical evaluation is to provide a technical summary of the bids reviewed
against the requirements of the Enquiry Requisition R-1910-0318 and to make a recommendation
for purchase of the equipment listed below:
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 4 of 9
2. QUOTATIONS EVALUATED
The following quotations were reviewed:
3. GENERAL COMMENTS
The Suppliers were requested to quote their best price and delivery.
NONE
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 5 of 9
5. RELEVANT CORRESPONDENCE
Please refer to the following Correspondence Summary for each Bid. These
correspondence logs are an integral part of Supplier’s base offer and shall take
precedence in cases of conflicts with base offer.
GULF STEEL Email Subject: Gulf Steel Works Quotation E/7842/SPA/07 dated
WORKS 11th August 2007 for 24 off KCS Vessels (ID<2300mm, P<50kg),
RFQ 1910-0318 Dated 3rd July 2007.
Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia
TRF – Gulf Steel Works dated 12th September 2007
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 6 of 9
SEOUL
MACHINERY, Co., TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 12th September 2007
LTD.
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 12th September 2007
Korea
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 24th September 2007
Seoul Machinery – TRF dated 27th September 2007
TRF – Seoul Machinery dated 28th September 2007
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 7 of 9
6.1 DAEKYUNG MACHINERY (Ref Quote Q2007-08-303, dated 9 th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)
6.1.1 The Vendor states compliance with all requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318
with the exception of paragraphs 6.1.2. , 6.1.3. and 6.1.4. below.
6.1.3 Vendor has not considered the local authorities regulations and requirements,
however this is NOT mandatory as the equipment will be manufactured outside of the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
6.1.4 Vendor to provide for two (2) Penberthy Model 2” Eductors in 304ss for item V-52273
before order placement.
6.2 DAEKYUNG TECHNOS (Ref Quote DK07-08-P410, dated 6 th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)
6.2.1 This Vendor has not contested any e-mails; therefore their offer cannot be compared
on an equal basis, hence NOT CONSIDERED.
6.3 GULF STEEL WORKS (Ref Quote E/7842/SPA/07, dated 11 th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)
6.3.1 This Vendor has not contested any e-mails; therefore their offer cannot be compared
on an equal basis, hence NOT CONSIDERED.
6.4 SEOUL MACHINERY (Ref Quote SMC-27260, dated 10th August 2007 & Correspondence
summary as above)
6.4.1 This Vendor has not contested any e-mails; therefore their offer cannot be compared
on an equal basis, hence NOT CONSIDERED.
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 8 of 9
6.5 WOOYANG HC (Ref Quote WHC-CR07-256 Rev. 0, dated 9 th August 2007 &
Correspondence summary as above)
6.5.1 This Vendor has not contested any e-mails; therefore their offer cannot be compared
on an equal basis, hence NOT CONSIDERED.
6.6 ZAMIL STEEL., (Ref Quote SP/07/0782/00/A dated 6th August 2007& Correspondence
summary as above)
6.6.1 Vendor states compliance with all the requirements of TRF Requisition R-1910-0318.
7. QA REVIEW
Vendors confirm compliance with Project Procedure 500-00Z-0024 “QA/QC Requirements
for Suppliers”.
8. HSE REVIEW
Vendors confirm compliance with Project Procedure 500-30Z-0005 “HSE Instructions to
Vendors and subcontractors”.
9. TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATION
Based on all of above described and additional information shown on attached technical
tabulation, TRF technically recommends the following proposals:
DAEKYUNG MACHINERY
ZAMIL STEEL
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
FOR KCS VESSELS ( ID<2300mm / P<50kg)
DOCUMENT #: TE-1910-0318 REV: 01 PAGE 9 of 9
- Vendor to provide for two (2) Penberthy Model 2” Eductors in 304ss for item V-52273
before order placement.
- There are no outstanding technical issues to be settled with the Zamil Steel bid.
11. ATTACHMENTS.
Technical Tabulation
Deviation Lists:
-Daekyung Machinery.
-Zamil Steel.