Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fulmer Et Al 2021 Actualizing Better Health and Health Care For Older Adults
Fulmer Et Al 2021 Actualizing Better Health and Health Care For Older Adults
Fulmer Et Al 2021 Actualizing Better Health and Health Care For Older Adults
By Terry Fulmer, David B. Reuben, John Auerbach, Donna Marie Fick, Colleen Galambos, and
Kimberly S. Johnson doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2020.01470
HEALTH AFFAIRS 40,
NO. 2 (2021): 219–225
This open access article is
C o m m e n ta ry distributed in accordance with the
terms of the Creative Commons
supports. If these priorities are addressed proactively, an infrastructure Donna Marie Fick is director
can be created that promotes better health and equitable, goal-directed of the Center of Geriatric
Nursing Excellence in the
care that recognizes the preferences and needs of older adults. College of Nursing at the
Pennsylvania State University,
in University Park,
Pennsylvania.
I
n 2018 the US population ages sixty-five motion and disease prevention and receive equi- Bader Endowed Chair of
and older numbered 52.4 million, with table, person-centered, high-quality care. Effec- applied gerontology at the
older adults representing 15.6 percent of tive policies are needed that can bridge the gaps University of Wisconsin–
the population.1 By 2030, 20 percent of between public health, health care, and other Milwaukee, in Milwaukee,
Wisconsin.
Americans will be age sixty-five or older. sectors of the economy, focusing on social deter-
The most striking aspect of this population is its minants of health and preventive measures to Kimberly S. Johnson is an
heterogeneity. In 2017, 23 percent of older Amer- reduce the burden of chronic disease while also associate professor in the
icans were members of racial and ethnic popu- providing person-centered care to those with se- Division of Geriatrics at the
Duke University School of
lations, and this percentage will increase by an rious illness. Online appendix exhibit A1 illus- Medicine, in Durham, North
estimated 135 percent between 2017 and 2040, trates this approach.3 Carolina.
compared with 36 percent for the non-Hispanic In 2016, as part of the National Academy of
White population.2 And although stereotypes Medicine’s Vital Directions for Health and
portray older people as frail, disengaged, and Health Care initiative, an expert panel wrote a
cognitively impaired, many are industrious, cre- paper that provided guidance for preparing the
ative, and intelligent into the tenth decade of life. nation for the realities of an aging population.4
Because of momentous advances in science Since the publication of “Preparing for Better
and technology, the knowledge and skills exist Health and Health Care for an Aging Population:
to provide excellent preventive and clinical care A Vital Direction for Health and Health Care,”5
to this cohort. What is now needed is the policy, emerging trends have included more personal-
and the will, to take collective action to ensure ized approaches to care; greater elicitation of
that all older adults are engaged in health pro- goals and preferences from those receiving care;6
and growing sophistication in the use of elec- ternships, as well as efforts to train professionals
tronic health records (EHRs) to identify risk, and direct care workers who are already in the
classify subpopulations, and direct appropriate workforce.
interventions. Alternative payment models and Strengthen The Role Of Public Health
Medicare Advantage have created flexibility that Congress and the administration should mobi-
permit innovation in care delivery and promote lize and fund the Centers for Disease Control and
more efficient and higher-quality health care. Prevention (CDC) and state and local health
The CAPABLE (Community Aging in Place— agencies to make healthy aging an essential com-
Advancing Better Living for Elders) model is ponent of public health. The Department of
a good example of this flexibility: Section 1915 Health and Human Services (HHS) should en-
Medicaid home and community-based services sure that public health efforts for older adults are
waiver dollars are used for home repairs and in- aligned with those in the health care and com-
home care that improves safety and health out- munity-level services sectors at local, state, and
comes for older adults.7 federal levels.
Yet most older people remain insured under Remediate Disparities And Inequities The
traditional fee-for-service Medicare, which in- administration and Congress should support the
centivizes profit-generating services. Policy establishment of a cross-agency, cross-secretari-
changes such as bundled, capitated, and other at committee to develop and implement policies
value-based payments are urgently needed to and programs that eliminate the social, structur-
promote the delivery of care that addresses the al, and economic obstacles to the optimal health
social determinants of health, encompasses life- and well-being of older adults. Such interven-
style modifications, recognizes the diversity of tions will require integration of federal, state,
the older population, and provides needed ser- and local government agencies, as well as public
vices for elders with serious illnesses. health and community-based organizations to
The 2016 Vital Directions authors expressed address the full spectrum of social determinants
deep concerns regarding health care disparities, of health. In addition to a continued focus on
inequality, structural racism, and the resulting social needs such as housing, food security, and
disproportionate risk for adverse outcomes transportation, new attention should be given to
among those who are disadvantaged and most addressing social isolation among older adults.
at risk. In 2020 these concerns are even more Develop New Approaches To Care Delivery
grave, and they present an opportunity for re- Congress and CMS should work toward optimiz-
newed assessment and policy directions for ad- ing the balance in payment between remote and
dressing persistent issues. Further, the corona- in-person care for older adults and should pro-
virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has mote policies that ensure education and resourc-
exposed fundamental problems in the US health es for the integration of telehealth into existing
care system that specifically affect older people. and new evidence-based practice models. En-
In this article, as part of the National Academy couraging innovation and increasing access to
of Medicine’s Vital Directions for Health and EHRs for older adults and caregivers is impor-
Health Care: Priorities for 2021 initiative, we tant, as is increasing broadband access to all
identify six vital directions to improve the care communities.
and quality of life for all older Americans. The Allocate Resources To Palliative And
National Academy of Medicine invited this au- End-Of-Life Care Congress and the administra-
thor group, from diverse professional back- tion, including HHS and CMS, should expand
grounds, to iteratively generate policy recom- access to and use of palliative care for older
mendations for the next administration. We adults. Serious illness care, dementia care mod-
provide the following agenda for policy makers els, and other evidence-based programs that fo-
to actualize better health and health care for cus on improving quality of life, including end-
older adults. of-life care, should be prioritized. Access to such
programs should be based on need instead of
being tied to prognostic estimates.
Recommendations Redesign Long-Term Services And Sup-
Create An Adequately Prepared Workforce ports Government entities including HHS,
The Health Resources and Services Administra- CMS, state Medicaid programs, the Administra-
tion (HRSA) and the Centers for Medicare and tion for Community Living, and the CDC should
Medicaid Services (CMS) must strategically plan test and adopt successful innovations and con-
for and support the creation of a robust, quali- comitant payment models to expand services to
fied workforce across settings through a coordi- improve the quality of care in nursing homes
nated interdisciplinary approach that includes and home and community-based services. Older
scholarships, loan forgiveness, and clinical in- adults should be able to choose whenever possi-
CMS expanded coverage via Medicare Advan- tiveness of the use of telehealth for dementia
tage plans to include benefits that relate to the care, which should be adopted broadly.30
social determinants of health, such as air condi- Approaches to optimizing telehealth should
tioners for people with asthma, healthy groceries include efforts outside health care (for example,
for people on medically prescribed diets, and expanding broadband access and including
home-delivered meals for people who are immu- older adults and diverse populations31 when de-
nocompromised.24 This type of coverage should signing and testing new portals and apps) and
be expanded for all older adults who are dually within health care (for example, routinely asking
eligible for Medicare and Medicaid. Efforts to older adults about their access to technology,
promote racial equity should include ensuring incorporating sociodemographic and literacy
access to comprehensive health insurance and metrics, and increasing patients’ and caregivers’
high-quality care, implementing programs and access to EHRs). For people with cognitive, sen-
policies such as criminal justice reform, and fa- sory, and functional impairments, adaptive sol-
cilitating meaningful partnerships with commu- utions such as remote cognitive assessment to
nity-based organizations that serve people of detect change and video monitoring to assist
color. with safe medication management have been
Social isolation is caused or exacerbated by valuable clinical tools.
social, economic, and environmental condi- Although telehealth may improve care coordi-
tions. Isolation is an underappreciated health nation and access by connecting community-
concern that is associated with an increased risk based organizations with health care systems,
for premature mortality that is comparable to barriers remain, including privacy concerns re-
that of smoking, obesity, and physical inactivity. lated to the Health Insurance Portability and
Up to 24 percent of community-dwelling older Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996 as well as
adults experience social isolation, and up to lack of infrastructure, interoperability, and ex-
43 percent of adults ages sixty-five and older pertise at these organizations.
report being lonely. Difficult and abusive rela- OpenNotes, a movement aimed at ensuring
tionships also are known to increase isolation, that all patients can access and edit their care
loneliness, and elder mistreatment.25 records as needed, encourages communication
Referrals to agencies that provide in-home and transparency among older adults, families,
support can help address social isolation and and providers through shared access to notes.32
loneliness. Isolation can be reduced or prevented Open access to health care records was mandated
by the development of innovative housing op- in the 21st Century Cures Act of 2016.33 The next
tions, recreational and employment opportuni- priority should be to pass federal legislation al-
ties, and improved transportation and public lowing patients and authorized family caregivers
safety measures.26 The secretary of housing and to modify and edit their own health records to
urban development should be directed to fund improve care and outcomes.
housing models that promote equity and address Access to tools such as Zoom videoconferenc-
the social determinants of health. ing and FaceTime have been shown to be helpful
Develop New Approaches To Care Delivery in reducing social isolation and improving mo-
Policy changes to Medicare and Medicaid during bility and mood.34,35 Such technologies have been
the COVID-19 pandemic have reduced barriers shown, for example, to decrease agitation and
to telehealth access and promoted its use.27 Pro- behavioral problems such as excessive vocaliza-
fessional medical societies have endorsed tele- tion in older adults with dementia. Remote sen-
health, whereas telehealth experts have docu- sors may improve safety and reduce falls in peo-
mented improved patient health outcomes.28 ple with dementia.36 The advent of robotics,
However, with the growth of telehealth and oth- including robotic pets for therapy, holds prom-
er virtual services, technology must be continu- ise for improving care for older adults.37
ously adapted to the needs and capabilities of all Technology can improve workflow in nursing
older adults. Advances in telehealth and technol- homes and other institutional settings (for ex-
ogy should be promoted through regulatory ac- ample, delivering linens and patient food trays
tion, payment incentives, federal and state dem- could be automated), allowing the workforce to
onstration projects, and the development of focus on tasks that require a human touch.38
public-private partnerships. Allocate Resources To Palliative And
The lack of access to technology, low digital End-Of-Life Care Many older adults are living
health literacy, and design barriers in patient with serious illness, defined as “a health condi-
portals and apps have disproportionately affect- tion that carries a high risk of mortality AND
ed older adults, especially those in underserved either negatively impacts a person’s daily func-
communities.29 The National Institute on Aging tion or quality of life, OR excessively strains their
has funded research that documents the effec- caregivers.”39 Only a small proportion of older
erate technology solutions, bolster efforts to in- across traditional silos, a commitment to pro-
tegrate Medicare and Medicaid financing for du- longing optimal health and independence, the
ally eligible older adults, and advance legislation restructuring of financing, and unwavering sup-
and funding for healthy aging programming at port for person-centered care. The changes will
the CDC and other federal and state agencies. not come easily. But the burgeoning demo-
The current fragmentation of care, disregard graphics and the critical needs of the older adult
for prevention, and disparate approaches to care population make the challenge urgent and com-
can be resolved. It will take a willingness to work pelling. ▪
The authors acknowledge the editorial Gretchen Alkema (The Scan Foundation). provided the original work is properly
support of Jessica Marx (National This is an open access article cited, not altered, and not used for
Academy of Medicine), Marcus distributed in accordance with the terms commercial purposes. See https://
Escobedo, Jennifer Phillips (The John A. of the Creative Commons Attribution creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/
Hartford Foundation), Wendy Huang and (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) license, which 4.0/. [Published online January 21, 2021.]
Jinghan Zhang (Columbia University), and permits others to distribute this work
NOTES
1 Census Bureau [Internet]. National Academies Press; 2008. 17 Department of Health and Human
Washington (DC): Census Bureau. 9 Flaherty E, Busby-Whitehead J, Services, Health Resources and Ser-
Press release, Older people projected Potter J, Lundebjerg N, Trucil DE. vices Administration. Geriatrics
to outnumber children for first time The Geriatric Workforce Enhance- Workforce Enhancement Program
in U.S. history; 2018 Mar 13 [revised ment Program: review of the Co- [Internet]. Washington (DC): HRSA;
2018 Sep 6 and 2019 Oct 8; cited ordinating Center and examples of 2019 [cited 2020 Dec 18]. Available
2020 Dec 18]. Available from: the GWEP in practice. Am J Geriatr from: https://www.hrsa.gov/grants/
https://www.census.gov/ Psychiatry. 2019;27(7):675–86. find-funding/hrsa-19-008
newsroom/press-releases/2018/ 10 Brotherton SE, Etzel SI. Graduate 18 Lehning A, De Biasi A. Creating an
cb18-41-population-projections.html medical education, 2018–2019. age-friendly public health system:
2 Administration for Community Liv- JAMA. 2019;322(10):996–1016. challenges, opportunities, and next
ing, Administration on Aging. 2018 11 American Academy of Nurse Practi- steps [Internet]. Washington (DC):
profile of older Americans [Inter- tioners. Retirement of the GNP Na- Trust for America’s Health; 2018
net]. Washington (DC): ACL; 2018 tional Certification Examination Mar [cited 2020 Dec 18]. Available
Apr [cited 2020 Dec 2]. Available [Internet]. Austin (TX): AANP; 2012 from: https://www.tfah.org/wp-
from: https://acl.gov/sites/default/ [cited 2020 Dec 2]. Available from: content/uploads/2018/09/Age_
files/Aging%20and%20Disability https://www.aanpcert.org/news Friendly_Public_Health_
%20in%20America/2018Older item?id=7 Convening_Report_FINAL__
AmericansProfile.pdf 12 Lees Haggerty K, Epstein-Lubow G, 1___1_.pdf
3 To access the appendix, click on the Spragens LH, Stoeckle RJ, Evertson 19 Trust for America’s Health. What are
Details tab of the article online. LC, Jennings LA, et al. Recommen- the 5Cs of an age-friendly public
4 Rowe JW, Fulmer T, Fried L. Pre- dations to improve payment policies health system? [Internet].
paring for better health and health for comprehensive dementia care. J Washington (DC): TFAH; 2020 [cit-
care for an aging population. JAMA. Am Geriatr Soc. 2020;68(11): ed 2020 Dec 2]. Available from:
2016;316(16):1643–4. 2478–85. https://www.tfah.org/wp-content/
5 Rowe JW, Berkman L, Fried L, 13 Reuben DB, Gazarian P, Alexander uploads/2020/03/5CsSummary
Fulmer T, Jackson J, Naylor M, et al. N, Araujo K, Baker D, Bean JF, et al. Rpt_FNL.pdf
Preparing for better health and The Strategies to Reduce Injuries 20 World Health Organization. Gender,
health care for an aging population: and Develop Confidence in Elders equity, and human rights: social
a vital direction for health and health intervention: falls risk factor as- determinants of health [Internet].
care [Internet]. Washington (DC): sessment and management, patient Geneva: WHO [cited 2020 Dec 17].
National Academies Press; 2016 Sep engagement, and nurse co-manage- Available from: https://www.who
19 [cited 2020 Dec 17]. Available ment. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2017;65(12): .int/gender-equity-rights/
from: https://nam.edu/wp-content/ 2733–9. understanding/sdh-definition/en/
uploads/2016/09/Preparing-for- 14 Unützer J, Katon W, Callahan CM, 21 Bonilla-Silva E. Rethinking racism:
Better-Health-and-Health-Care-for- Williams JW Jr, Hunkeler E, Harpole toward a structural interpretation.
an-Aging-Population.pdf L, et al. Collaborative care manage- Am Sociol Rev. 1997;62(3):465–80.
6 Reuben DB, Tinetti ME. Goal- ment of late-life depression in the 22 Rivera-Hernandez M, Kumar A,
oriented patient care—an alternative primary care setting: a randomized Epstein-Lubow G, Thomas KS. Dis-
health outcomes paradigm. N Engl J controlled trial. JAMA. 2002; parities in nursing home use and
Med. 2012;366(9):777–9. 288(22):2836–45. quality among African American,
7 Spoelstra SL, Sikorskii A, Gitlin LN, 15 Shah RC, Supiano MA, Greenland P. Hispanic, and White Medicare resi-
Schueller M, Kline M, Szanton SL. Aligning the 4Ms of Age-Friendly dents with Alzheimer’s disease and
Dissemination of the CAPABLE Health Systems with statin use for related dementias. J Aging Health.
model of care in a Medicaid waiver primary prevention. J Am Geriatr 2019;31(7):1259–77.
program to improve physical func- Soc. 2020;68(3):463–4. 23 Pan D, Sze S, Minhas JS, Bangash
tion. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2019;67(2): 16 Guth A, Chou J, Courtin SO, Ford C, MN, Pareek N, Divall P, et al. The
363–70. Hennawi G, Brandt N. An interdis- impact of ethnicity on clinical out-
8 Institute of Medicine, Committee on ciplinary approach to implementing comes in COVID-19: a systematic
the Future Health Care Workforce for the Age-Friendly Health System 4Ms review. EClinicalMedicine. 2020;
Older Americans. Retooling for an in an ambulatory clinical pathway 23:100404.
aging America: building the health with a focus on medication safety. J 24 Waddil K. MA plans slowly begin
care workforce: Washington (DC): Gerontol Nurs. 2020;46(10):7–11. integrating SDOH into 2020 plan