Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2023 Fall KDOE410 Group-7 MentorHub
2023 Fall KDOE410 Group-7 MentorHub
2023 Fall KDOE410 Group-7 MentorHub
FINAL REPORT
Course: Business Project Practice – KDOE410
MENTORHUB
Group 7
Group members & Student ID:
1. Nguyễn Vũ Nhật – 2115113191
2. Nguyễn Quỳnh Châu – 2114154002
3. Lê Đăng Khoa – 2115113121
4. Nguyễn Lê Bảo Hân – 2111113072
5. Phạm Minh Quân – 2113153051
6. Phạm Thế Quang – 2113153050
7. Huỳnh Gia Bảo – 2115113029
Class: K60CLC8
Instructor: Ph.D. Phạm Thị Mai Khanh
Submission Date: December 4, 2023
FINAL REPORT
Course: Business Project Practice – KDOE410
MENTORHUB
Group 7
Group members & Student ID:
8. Nguyễn Vũ Nhật – 2115113191
9. Nguyễn Quỳnh Châu – 2114154002
10.Lê Đăng Khoa – 2115113121
11.Nguyễn Lê Bảo Hân – 2111113072
12.Phạm Minh Quân – 2113153051
13.Phạm Thế Quang – 2113153050
14.Huỳnh Gia Bảo – 2115113029
Class: K60CLC8
Instructor: Ph.D. Phạm Thị Mai Khanh
Submission Date: December 4, 2023
i
9.2. Revenue stream forecasting ............................................................................................... 45
CHAPTER 3: PROTOTYPE ............................................................................................... 49
CHAPTER 4: INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL BUSINESS VALIDATION ..................... 51
CHAPTER 5: PROCESS BOOK......................................................................................... 55
APPENDICES ..................................................................................................................... 58
REFERENCES..................................................................................................................... 75
ii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1. The increase in number of university student ............................................13
Figure 2. The proportions of respondents who need information, advice, suggestions
and guidance on each field ........................................................................................14
Figure 3. Problems in the mentoring-related solutions, according to our research on
86 respondents ...........................................................................................................15
Figure 4. Customer Persona ......................................................................................17
Figure 5. Key activities plan .....................................................................................26
Figure 6. Prototype ....................................................................................................50
Figure 7. Competition Landscape .............................................................................51
Figure 8. Market size.................................................................................................52
iii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. Mentors' information .................................................................................. 33
Table 2. Cost structure ............................................................................................. 40
Table 3. Prices of advertisement positions on website of MentorHub (VND) ........ 43
Table 4. Prices of affiliate performance on website of MentorHub (VND) ............ 44
Table 5. Summary of service prices in the first three years of MentorHub (VND). 44
Table 6. Component contribution of the revenue model for the first three-year
period ........................................................................................................................ 46
Table 7. Revenue stream forecasting for the first three-year period (VND) ........... 48
Table 8. Profit projection ......................................................................................... 54
iv
This page is intentionally left blank.
v
ABSTRACT
This report presents a comprehensive analysis of the business model canvas for
MentorHub, a start-up platform designed to connect university students in need of
academic guidance with experienced mentors. The platform aims to assist mentees,
primarily freshmen, in achieving their academic goals of raising their GPA and
succeeding in students' competitions. Simultaneously, it offers mentors a source of
income and a sense of fulfillment by promoting a studious culture in the academic
environment.
Chapter 4 delves into the internal and external validation processes undergone by
MentorHub. Internal validation involves assessing the platform's viability, scalability,
and potential risks, while external validation entails gathering feedback and insights
from potential customers, mentors, and other stakeholders. This chapter explores the
findings from these validation exercises and highlights any necessary adjustments or
improvements to the business model.
Finally, Chapter 5 presents the process book, which outlines the step-by-step journey
of developing MentorHub. It provides a comprehensive overview of the research,
ideation, development, and refinement processes, shedding light on the challenges
faced and the strategies employed.
10
CHAPTER 1: BRIEF DESCRIPTION
MentorHub is a platform designed to connect university students under two roles: the
Mentee (primarily freshmen who are in need of academic guidance) and the Mentor
(juniors and seniors who are able to provide such needed guidance).
The platform was established with the aim of helping the Mentees achieve two of
their most common academic goals, which are raising their GPA and going into
further rounds of the students’ competitions. At the same time, the platform provides
the Mentors with a source of income as well as a feeling of
accomplishment/satisfaction for taking part in promoting a studious culture in the
academic environment.
For the mentors, our service can help them cut back a significant amount of effort in
enriching their own mentoring experience and finding the appropriate mentees,
thereby helping them build better personal branding and have a source of additional
income easily.
For the mentees, our service can help them cut back a significant effort of finding
mentorship to support in delivering a high-quality outcome in university courses and
competitions by matching them with a mentor that is qualified to satisfy your specific
needs and expectations.
11
CHAPTER 2: BUSINESS MODEL CANVAS
1. Target Customers
1.1. Mentee
1.1.1. Overview:
The primary focus of MentorHub is the freshmen and sophomore students of Foreign
Trade University, Ho Chi Minh city Campus. These individuals are seeking guidance,
support, and mentorship to navigate academic challenges and get great results from
competitions during their university journey.
1.1.2. Rationale:
12
Figure 1. The increase in number of university student
With the annual increase in new university students, particularly among Freshmen
who often face challenges adjusting to university life, there is a clear and growing
demand for mentorship programs tailored to support the unique needs of this
demographic within the Vietnamese Gen Z market. Additionally, only 30% of first-
year students felt adequately prepared in terms of study skills and academic writing
according to Vietnam National University, highlighting a specific area of need that
mentorship programs could address.
The dynamic landscape of the Vietnamese Gen Z market, coupled with the significant
percentage of university students within this demographic, underscores a pressing
demand for mentorship and skill development. The statistics revealing the aspirations
of Gen Z, coupled with the identified gap in mentorship, create a compelling case for
the introduction MentorHub. As the number of new university students grows
annually, it becomes increasingly evident that Freshmen and Sophomores are the
primary clientele in need of support and guidance. The statistics, including the finding
that only 30% of first-year students feel adequately prepared in terms of study skills
and academic writing, emphasize the critical role MentorHub can play in addressing
the unique challenges faced by these students. By tailoring our services to meet the
specific needs of this demographic, MentorHub is poised to make a meaningful
impact on the educational and professional journeys of the Vietnamese Gen Z,
ensuring a smoother transition into university life and beyond.
13
1.1.3. Customer journey:
Figure 2. The proportions of respondents who need information, advice, suggestions and guidance on each
field
Despite these goals, our survey illuminated several challenges faced by these students
throughout their academic journey, which can be referred to as their Pains. 96%
encountered difficulties in the pursuit of their goals, indicating a pervasive need for
14
tailored support. Moreover, 95% expressed a desire for additional information, advice,
instructions, and feedback to refine their academic and professional pursuits,
showcasing an inherent hunger for guidance.
15
In terms of ease of use, Facebook communities and YouTube are considered
convenient and most familiar, while FTU2 groups, confessions, and clubs offer a
more relatable environment for our target customers, the FTU2 students. However,
other platforms are deemed unfamiliar to some, and finding relevant content can be
challenging.
Assessing quality and reliability, Facebook communities are criticized for the lack of
in-depth or verified information and low mentorship quality. YouTube, on the other
hand, is seen as fairly reliable, with users able to gauge the quality of videos through
metrics such as views, likes, subscriptions, and comments. Other platforms, like
studocu, are perceived as unreliable, serving merely as a repository for unverified
documents without comprehensive topic coverage.
Notably, 95% of respondents express the importance of advice from individuals with
experience and high achievements in their respective fields. The existing solutions,
however, lack in personalization. Facebook communities and FTU2 groups/clubs
face challenges in terms of slow and unsystematic processes and limited coaching,
advice, and feedback. While YouTube provides numerous resources, they are often
repetitive and lack specificity. What sets these solutions apart is the absence of
continual 1-on-1 support, a crucial element according to 87% of respondents.
Additionally, 94% express a desire for 1-on-1 mentoring through private chatting,
sharing, Q&A, and feedback at least once a week. This identified gap in personalized,
one-on-one support highlights the unique value proposition that MentorHub aims to
offer, addressing the specific needs and preferences expressed by our customers for
a more comprehensive and effective mentoring experience.
16
academic competitions. Despite their active involvement in academic pursuits, these
students grapple with the intricacies of conducting comprehensive research, crafting
impactful reports, and delivering compelling presentations, largely owing to their
relative inexperience and the absence of certain essential skills.
In response to their specific drivers and barriers, our ideal customers manifests a clear
set of preferences. 95% of this demographic desires detailed guidance from
individuals with hands-on experience and notable achievements within their areas of
interest. Additionally, 94% express a preference for one-on-one interactions, seeking
personalized mentorship that aligns with their individual learning styles and goals.
The significance of continuous mentorship throughout their learning journey is
17
underscored by 87% of respondents, emphasizing the need for consistent support and
guidance.
1.2. Mentor
According to the survey of 97 FTU2 students from 2nd-year to 4th-year, 75% of them
said they want to share their own experiences, skills, and knowledge in a certain field
with people who need it. Moreover, 66 respondents, which equals about 66%, shared
that they are willing to become a mentor to provide these kinds of support, advice,
suggestions, and guidance if they get paid, which means the financial benefit is one
of the major factors contributing to their decision to become a Mentor. Among those
who are willing to become a mentor, 26% said that they could perform mentoring
service for about 2 hours per week, and 61% said they could spend from 3 to 6 hours
per week for the mentoring job. We could say that most of the respondents perceive
mentorship as only a “part-time job”, or a “nice-to-have activity” that can bring them
financial rewards. However, among 33 respondents who are not willing to become a
mentor, the lack of expertise, experience, and time are the major causes. To be
specific, 76% of them said they do not have enough expertise or experience, while
58% said they do not have enough time to become a mentor.
18
From the rationale above, we can propose the underlying problems of these “potential
mentors”: They want to share their skills, experiences, and knowledge with people
who need it, and if giving those mentorships gets them paid, they are willing to
become mentors as a “part-time job” which only takes them around 2 to 6 hours per
week. However, the requirements and needs for mentorship vary greatly for each
mentee, therefore, they feel hesitant to become mentors as they are not sure if their
expertise and experience are appropriate with the mentee’s expectation, or if they can
have enough time for mentoring sessions to deliver the value the mentee needs.
19
2. Value Proposition
For the mentee group, our project aims to solve the problems of 1st and 2nd-year
FTU2 students. The problem we analyze and explore here is that: The students want
to produce good outcomes in course works or academic competitions, however, they
find it hard to seek for information, advice or feedback that are qualified, reliable,
and personalized, when current social networking platforms providing this service
are not popular and still do not meet the needs of mentees.
For the mentors group, we recognize that FTU2 students from 2nd to 4th year have
outstanding achievements and excellent soft skills, and have the desire to utilize these
to earn income or build their personal branding as mentors. However, they have
difficulty finding students whose needs match their expertise and their time
arrangement. Current platforms do not guarantee quality, personalization, and
especially the ability to connect mentors and mentees based on a specific match of
expertise.
20
in developing their abilities and skills. To be specific, 3 values that MentorHub
provides are:
Besides providing mentees with a reliable and personalized platform for professional
knowledge, MentorHub also encourages mentors and mentees to share about their
lives, learning environments or work experiences. This also helps mentors themselves,
21
as they are updated with students' own insights to keep up with trends and thereby
design the most suitable mentoring method. Therefore, we are confident that this
project meets the needs of two target groups: helping mentees achieve desired
outcomes and developing mentors' contributions.
For the mentors, MentorHub’s value proposition would be: ”Our service can help
you cut back a significant amount of effort in enriching your own mentoring
experience and finding the appropriate mentees, thereby helping you build better
personal branding and have a source of additional income easily”. For the mentees,
the value proposition would be: “Our service can help you cut back a significant
effort of finding mentorship to support in delivering a high-quality outcome in
university courses and competitions by matching you with a mentor that is qualified
to satisfy your specific needs and expectations”.
22
3. Customer Relationships
For the Customer Relationship, we came up with many different plans and divide
those strategies into two categories, which are Customer Acquisition and Customer
Retention as explained in the below sections.
First and foremost, we are able to acquire new customers through incessantly
maintain and improve trust and credibility since our entire service model is built on
these keywords. Initially, our team is comprised of experienced and trusted mentors
who have reputation among the students regarding the tutoring/teaching skills.
Additionally, the team expects to collaborate with experts in the education area in
order to test and enhance the tutoring skills of contracted Mentors if needed. The
guarantee in mentors’ quality is what keeps our business alive, therefore, we pay
heavy attention to this part in acquiring new users.
23
3.2. Customer retention
Generally, it is safe to say that no business can survive without maintaining their
customer base, meaning their users have to come back for them. Therefore, customer
retention is a vital factor in customer relationship management. In order to retain the
existing customers, MentorHub plans to implement two main strategies.
Firstly, we have loyalty programs in which we plan to reward the existent customers
with exclusive financial benefits (such as member discounts) and access to special
and favorable mentoring sessions. We hope to engage old customers repeatedly and
build a long-term relationship with them. Afterwards, we can offer them to be our
Mentors with more advantageous terms in order to maintain and increase our Mentor-
base.
24
4. Channels
MentorHub identifies that there will be two distinct approaches for mentors and
mentees accordingly (Appendix 6). For the Mentors group of customer, in order to
recruit the mentor force, MentorHub will reach out to them through direct marketing
and personal selling (SMS messages emails FTU2’s Facebook community, etc.) and
promise to provide them with attractive incentives to engage in our model. For the
Mentees group, they will also be approached by direct marketing and personal selling
through MentorHub’s website, FTU2’s Facebook community, and especially through
the word of mouth of the team members as well as trial users and MentorHub’s early
adopters. Word of mouth can be considered an effective tool, as according to a study
by Nielsen (2023), 92% of consumers trust recommendations from friends and family
over all forms of advertising. Another study by McKinsey (2023) found that word-
of-mouth is the primary factor behind 20-50% of all purchasing decisions. However,
it requires a compulsory condition, which is that MentorHub has to set up a
sustainable customer base, and this can only be achieved through using other channels.
Now, after acquiring mentors and mentees, it comes to the communicating phase. The
three main means of communication are telephone, email, and MentorHub’s website.
These means of communication will help MentorHub deliver not only the profile
screening result but also the contract details to the mentors. While for the mentees,
they shall be used as a means of receiving mentees’ needs, requirements, and
expectations about taking a mentorship session.
25
5. Key Activities
Testing and recruiting mentors is a key activity in MentorHub because it ensures that
the program can provide high-quality mentorship to its participants. Therefore, it
consists of compulsory steps: increasing the number of potential mentor applicants;
screening applicants’ profiles and testing their skills in mentorship; and contracting.
In terms of increasing the number of potential applicants, in Phase 0 & 1, the in-house
marketing & sales team of MentorHub performs direct marketing and personal selling
to groups of FTU2 seniors to deliver the value proposition of MentorHub directly to
the potential mentors. Moreover, certain incentive programs, such as bonuses or
26
benefits for initial mentorships, should also be introduced to these potential mentors
to improve the conversion opportunity. Since Phase 2, when having performed
service to certain numbers of customers and receiving contributive assessments from
them, the marketing & sales team will develop new marketing channels (SEO, KOL,
KOC, FTU communities) to build up MentorHub awareness and engagement among
FTU2 students and creating more potential customers.
After receiving applications, the in-house supervision team will directly check
applicants' qualifications and achievements for the mentor registered field. Regarding
attitudes and skills in mentoring, MentorHub will outsource to experts with
experience in mentorship and organize a trial mentoring session to test applicants'
mentoring abilities.
If applicants pass the profile screening and mentoring skill testing rounds, MenterHub
will sign a contract with the applicants to establish the obligations and rights between
the two parties. The contract term is a minimum of 2 months, more specifically,
Mentor is obliged to perform at least 4 sessions in 2 months if requested. The contract
will be negotiated for amendment and continuation after expiration.
To increase the number of potential customers who send MentorHub their mentorship
needs and requirements, in Phase 1, it is important to employ direct marketing and
personal selling strategies aimed at groups of individuals having certain needs
relating to mentorship. These efforts help effectively communicate the value
proposition of MentorHub directly to the target audience. Additionally, implementing
27
sales promotions, such as benefits for trial (group mentorship, combos, etc.), can
enhance conversion opportunities and encourage potential customers to engage with
the MentorHub platform. Since Phase 2, the marketing & sales team will develop new
marketing channels (SEO, KOL, KOC, FTU communities) to build up MentorHub
awareness and engagement among FTU2 students and create more potential
customers.
After customers submit their needs, requirements, and expectations about mentorship,
the customer relationships (CR) team checks the available mentor profiles to select
the most suitable mentor or re-contact the customers to specify their requirements if
necessary. After that, MentorHub informs the potential customer about the matched
mentor profile (name and contact hidden) and the quoted price for confirmation.
MentorHub will give the contact of the mentor and mentee to each other after the
mentee’s confirmation and payment.
The CR team will handle collecting mentees’ weekly assessment and feedback (along
with relevant evidence if required) upon the performance of the contract or any
problems that arise. From the collected assessment and feedback, the CR team
contacts the mentor to address customers’ needs and emerging problems as soon as
28
possible. The CR team also remains regular and responsive in communication with
mentors to provide useful support. The scope of these activities is to satisfy customers’
personalized needs and requirements.
Moreover, since Phase 2, the CR team will use the accumulated data from customers’
feedback and assessments to define the main strengths and weaknesses of mentors
and MentorHub service. Based on the defined strengths and weaknesses, MenterHub
can create training sessions (outsourcing to mentorship experts) for contracting
mentors to improve their strengths and weaknesses or make adjustments to the
MentorHub operation in certain functional areas to evaluate and optimize the
offerings to customers.
5.5. Scale-up
In the long run, two more key activities for MentorHub are market research and
partnership management. Market research aims to discover new growth opportunities
for MentorHub, specifically new customers with similar problems (students from
other schools, high school students) or old customers with similar problems. new
topic (job search, etc.). As for partnership management, MentorHub plans to
negotiate to establish affiliate or advertise relationships with businesses that share the
same potential customers to bring value to increase the number of revenue streams.
29
6. Key Resources
6.1. Sales:
Our Sales team is led by Mr. Pham Minh Quan, who brings valuable experience as a
Sales Development Representative. With a proven track record in seeking potential
customers, building relationships, and providing feedback to improve marketing
strategies, Mr. Quan is a crucial asset for the sales segment of our project.
Additionally, Mr. Huynh Gia Bao, with experience in Sales and Business
Development, contributes insights into customer acquisition and retention, making
him another key player in our sales efforts.
6.2. Marketing:
In the Marketing department, we are fortunate to have two talented individuals, Mr.
Nguyen Vu Nhat and Ms. Nguyen Quynh Chau. Both have participated in marketing
and start-up competitions, providing them with extensive knowledge and experience
in areas such as marketing strategy, market analysis, creativity, and innovation. Their
combined expertise ensures a robust foundation for our marketing initiatives.
Customer relationship management is divided into two main groups: mentees and
mentors.
Regarding managing the relationship with the mentee, the member responsible for
that is Ms. Nguyen Le Bao Han. Because she has had internship experience in a
learning development position, and also had two years of mentoring new members of
the FTU Yours club as vice president and homeroom leader, she has enough
experience and The ability to manage relationships with mentees, expand your
network and form long-term relationships with them.
As for managing the relationship with mentors, Mr. Le Dang Khoa will be the
member in charge of this area. With 2 years of experience as a mentor for a company
with similar services, Mr. Khoa clearly understands the process of caring for mentors
30
of companies and businesses with similar services, and can point out the strengths
and weaknesses. weak, and clearly understand what mentors need during the teaching
phase. In addition, a few other members who also have teaching experience will also
support this segment to operate effectively.
Taking responsibility for the partnership management is Ms. Nguyen Le Bao Han,
currently the president of the FTU Yours club at Foreign Trade University Campus
II, and also has an internship in a learning and development position. With profound
experience in contacting and negotiating with sponsoring partners for major school
competitions, this will be of great help in the partnership management aspect of the
project.
6.5. Mentorship:
For mentorship in the initial years of our project, we are fortunate to have three team
members – Mr. Nguyen Vu Nhat, Ms. Nguyen Quynh Chau, and Mr. Le Dang Khoa
– each with a minimum of two years of teaching experience. All three individuals
boast a high and stable GPA, ranging from 3.44 to 3.78. Moreover, Mr. Nhat and Ms.
Chau have experience in various marketing and startup competitions, ensuring that
we have a pool of mentors with diverse expertise in different subjects and
competitions. This wealth of experience ensures that we can guarantee at least three
mentors for the initial three years of our business, providing valuable support across
various subjects and competitions.
31
- GPA: 3.78
- GPA: 3.48
32
Pham The - Have taken an internship as a Public Relation intern in TH
Quang Corporation.
33
7. Key Partners
7.1. Mentors:
Mentors, or instructors, play an important role as Key Partners in the project, bringing
expertise and practical experience to the mentor and mentee community. The
diversity and quality of the team of mentors lay the foundation for the success of the
project.
Mentors are primarily responsible for sharing knowledge and experience with
students, helping them develop their academic and soft skills. They advise, provide
advice, and identify academic opportunities for mentees. Mentors also commit time
and effort to the mentoring relationship.
A strong team of mentors is the deciding factor in the success or failure of the project.
The diversity in experience and expertise of mentors helps bring diversity in
educational resources and mentorship. This not only creates a multi-dimensional
learning environment but also enhances the image and reputation of the project,
attracting mentees and other stakeholders.
Education and mentorship experts are considered important Key Partners of the
project, ensuring the quality and performance of the mentorship model. These experts
have extensive experience in the field of education and training, providing the project
with professionalism and valuable support.
Education and mentorship specialists are primarily responsible for designing and
implementing training programs for mentors and mentees. They develop quality
standards and ensure that every interaction meets the highest expectations.
Additionally, they manage the feedback and evaluation process to maintain and
improve the quality of mentorship.
34
Education and mentorship experts help the project ensure quality and professionalism,
building and maintaining high standards within the educational community.
Innovation and creativity in training programs also bring positive experiences for
both mentors and mentees. Not only do they assist in building a long-term and
positive commitment between mentor and mentee, but they also provide ongoing
feedback, helping the project to continually adjust and improve.
KOLs (Key Opinion Leaders) and KOCs (Key Opinion Consumers) from FTU2 play
an important role in the project's main partner system, bringing influence and positive
perspectives from the student community. Support from them not only enhances
credibility but also helps the project connect effectively with key audiences.
KOLs, who have great influence on the student community, are mainly responsible
for sharing positive messages and creating good momentum for the project. In
contrast, KOCs, students with small influence but the ability to spread messages
quickly, play a role in spreading messages from KOLs and sending feedback from
the community.
The participation of KOLs and KOCs from FTU2 brings a strategic advantage,
creating a strong network of influence within the student community. This not only
helps the project reach its goals effectively but also builds a positive image in the
minds of students and increases support from the community.
Clubs and online communities (such as Facebook groups, Confessions, and other
platforms) from FTU2 play an important role as key partners, providing diverse
community interaction and support student. Collaboration with them brings the
advantage of diversity and positivity in communicating the project's message.
35
They contribute to the success of the project by promoting messaging, sharing
information, and creating opportunities for interaction. Online groups such as
Facebook groups, Confessions, and other platforms help spread messages and create
spaces where communities can discuss and share ideas.
Moreover, collaboration with clubs and communities within FTU2 brings the benefit
of strong connections with students. Projects can use the existing structure and
influence from these groups to increase effectiveness in reaching and communicating
with audiences. At the same time, support from online groups helps the project
maintain a close and continuous connection with the community.
One of the key benefits of partnering with a website development service is their
proficiency in professional design and user experience. They understand the
principles of effective user interface design and can create visually appealing and
intuitive interfaces for MentorHub's platform. By prioritizing user experience, the
development service can optimize navigation and interactions, making it easy for
Mentees and Mentors to engage with the platform.
36
The partnership also brings advantages in terms of quality assurance and testing.
Website development services have established processes for thorough testing,
ensuring that the platform functions smoothly and efficiently. By conducting
comprehensive checks and debugging, any bugs or issues can be identified and
resolved, resulting in an optimized user experience and a reliable platform.
Time and cost efficiency are significant advantages of collaborating with a website
development service. The development team takes care of the technical aspects of the
platform, saving MentorHub valuable time and resources. This allows the MentorHub
team to focus on other critical areas of the business, such as marketing and user
acquisition. Additionally, the expertise of the development service helps avoid costly
mistakes, ensuring that the platform is developed within the allocated budget.
37
8. Cost Structure
MentorHub's cost structure is calculated based on key activities and key resources.
First, because we own an in-house team capable of managing and implementing
Marketing, Sales, and Customer relationship management (CRM) activities,
MentorHub can cut out the costs of hiring Sales staff, Marketing, and CRM.
In terms of testing the quality of mentors, a fixed payment for a contracting mentor
would be 120.000 VND per two months, which is calculated by estimating the
opportunity cost of making a 2-month contract with MentorHub (which requires
mentors to be available for at least four “1-hour mentoring sessions”) instead of doing
a part-time job with the salary of 30.000 VND/hour. Besides direct marketing and
personal selling, which are performed by the in-house marketing and sales team,
MentorHub also develops new marketing channels (nano KOL, KOC, FTU2
communities, clubs, etc.). Ms. Nguyen Le Bao Han has a strong network in
FTUYours Club, therefore, we can save costs when reaching out to potential
customers in this club. MentorHub plans to hire 4 different nano FTU2 KOLs &
KOCs a year, with a cost of about 250.000 VNĐ/ post (Dogtiev, 2023), and offer 4
sponsorships of 1.500.000 VNĐ for 4 Clubs with a large number of members (Social
Working Club, Creatio, Action Club, FTU Zone) to increase MentorHub’s awareness.
38
be 3.000.000 VNĐ. The domain name and hosting cost for the website would be
1.000.000 VNĐ per year (WEB HOSTING, n.d.; iHappy, n.d.).
For CRM, as we use our in-house team to perform CRM tasks such as matching,
feedback collecting & addressing, customer care, etc, we only spend budget on CR
programs to improve the acquisition and retention of mentees and mentors. We
concentrate on referral and membership programs because they tend to provide long-
term and consistent benefits rather than sales promotions (such as discounts, combos,
etc.). To be specific, the budget for referral and membership programs would be
3.200.000 VNĐ in year 1 and increase in following years, while the budget for sales
promotion would be 800.000 VNĐ in year 1 and decrease in following years.
39
Domain name & hosting cost for website 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,000,000
40
9. Revenue Model
The MentorHub revenue model comprises three main sources of revenue. Since we
serve two types of customers, who are Mentors and Mentees, based on our operation
model, for an easier understanding of how MentorHub generates money, we describe
our revenue model using the flow of revenue stream, which is divided into 2 parts
including cash flow in (money going from the Mentees to MentorHub) and cash flow
out (money going from MentorHub to Mentors).
1. Service-based revenue: for each service being executed, 30% of the revenue
generated shall be retained and counted as revenue from operation for
MentorHub.
For each type of problem that we service, the pricing strategy differs. According to
our survey, approximately 40% of the respondents are willing to pay for the service
in the range of 100.000 - 199.000 VND per month, and 22% of the students can pay
up to the amount of 400.000 VND per month for our type of service. Based on this
information and along with the average tutoring market prices, for the first year of
our business project, the pricing is determined as follows:
- Fixed fee: charge 200.000 VND (seen as the fee for keeping the Mentor
on-hold for the particular customer)
41
- Variable fee: (assuming all the competitions have 3 rounds, and the
customers register under team format of at least 3 members per team)
b. For the GPA category: the pricing strategy is the basic one-time full price
payment per service being executed, and such payment will be made in
advance before the mentoring session is conducted (following with a refund
policy). The price for each subject differs according to the demand for that
particular subject. However, the average price shall be 120.000 VND per
mentoring session.
Note: In peak seasons of competitions and near examination day for the GPA
category, the fees above shall be charged with an additional amount of 100.000 VND
per mentoring session.
a. Advertisement model
Week Month
b. Affiliate model
43
CPS/CPA Cost per Sale/Action Negotiable
3. Donation: If the Mentees are satisfied with the service of the Mentors and
MentorHub, then, on a voluntary basis, the Mentees can donate to the Mentors
via MentorHub. 30% of the donation amount shall be retained and counted as
revenue for MentorHub.
Based on the operation performance of the first year as well as external factors
such as market acceptance and adoption rate, the pricing strategy may have some
changes accordingly. However, we assume a stable growth rate of 10% in prices
for easier estimation of the revenue stream. Therefore, the summary of our service
prices in the first three years of operation are as follows.
Table 5. Summary of service prices in the first three years of MentorHub (VND)
Due to the contribution of the Mentors, who can also be considered to be our strategic
partner (apart from being our customers), part of the revenue generated by the service
shall be passed onto the Mentors as their income. In particular, the revenue will flow
from MentorHub to Mentors as follows:
44
1. Service-based revenue: 70% of the revenue generated from each service
conducted shall be paid to the Mentors.
2. Donation: 70% of the donation made by the Mentees will be paid to their
respective Mentors.
Based on observation and quick interviews made by the authors, MentorHub assumes
that, in general, the components that contribute to the total revenue of our service will
be as follows.
Revenue
Component Unit Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
source
Number of
Competition purchased 45 63 81
services
Service-based
revenue
Number of
GPA purchased 64 96 171
services
Percent of
Affiliate & traffic that
Affiliate 50% 60% 60%
Advertisement clicks on
links
45
Number of
All All All
Advertisement positions
positions positions positions
rented
Table 6. Component contribution of the revenue model for the first three-year period
To be more specific, the assumptions underlying the numbers above are explained
based on the foundation of, from our survey results, around 80% of our target Mentees
have the goal of obtaining a high GPA, and 30% want to be in-top of competitions.
For the first year of operation, with the current human resources (MentorHub only
has 2 available Mentors from our core team), we plan to recruit 6 more mentors,
making the total Mentors available in the first year is 8, who are experienced and
good at four different areas which are Marketing, Business, Finance, and English. We
assume that around 45 “competition” services will be purchased for the first year of
operation. This stems from the assumption that the Mentees will take part in around
9 competitions held annually, and 5 teams will purchase our services per competition.
For the GPA category, we provide service for 8 common subjects that freshmen and
sophomores of FTU2 will have, with the estimation that we can reach 8 customers
per subject. Next, assuming traffic of our website can reach to 1000 sessions per
academic year (given 10 times of access from the reached population, which is around
100 students), we expect around 50% of them click on the links one time. Also, all
positions of advertisement are contracted with our key partners and/or interested
organizations.
These numbers will grow over the years since we plan to recruit 4 more Mentors in
the second year if the business receives positive signals from the market. Likewise,
around 63 “competition” services are expected with the assumption that we will have
around 7 customers per competition for 9 competitions in total. In this year, we
expand our coverage areas to 2 more fields, which are Supply chain - Logistics and
Accounting/Auditing. Moreover, with 8 subjects common for freshmen and
sophomores, we expect each subject will be registered by 12 students (or groups of
46
students), making the total services purchased for the GPA category in the second
year 96. The traffic of our website is also expected to grow to 1400 sessions per
academic year due to the expanded pool of Mentors and Mentees, and around 60%
of them will click on the links, therefore generating revenue for MentorHub as an
affiliate partner.
For the third year assumptions, we hope to expand by recruiting more Mentors,
making the total available 21 mentors. From this number, we expect to achieve 9
customers per competition for 9 competitions as well as 19 users per subject for 9
subjects in the “GPA” category. In addition, we assume the website traffic can reach
2000 sessions per academic year, and 60% of them will click on the links.
From the information mentioned at the beginning of this section, together with our
planning and forecasting, we aim to obtain the following revenue stream.
47
Affiliate &
Advertisement 23.400.000 25.740.000 28.314.000
Advertisement
Table 7. Revenue stream forecasting for the first three-year period (VND)
In the long run, we aim to adjust and expand this model not just in FTU2 but other
universities as well. In this case, the revenue from both service-based and affiliate -
advertisement channels will increase significantly, proportionately, and favorably
with our cost structure, making sure that our model is sustainable.
48
CHAPTER 3: PROTOTYPE
Step 1: MentorHub selects 2 members who have high GPAs in certain courses or
have good skills in English, presentation, etc. to become mentors. MentorHub also
prepares a Google Form to apply for the mentor role (Appendix 1).
Step 2: Marketing and Sales team contacts potential FTU2 1st and 2nd-year students
to ask about their current needs for mentorship on university courses or competitions.
After that, MentorHub provides them the information about the 2 mentors (GPAs,
achievements, experiences) and quotes them discounted prices to test their acceptance.
After these mentees’ acceptance, MentorHub connects them with mentor Nguyen Vu
Nhat who is suitable for their requirements and needs (9.2 grade point in Principles
of Finance). (Appendix 2). MentorHub also prepares a Google Form for the
customers to fill out their specific needs and requirements for mentorship service
(Appendix 1).
49
Figure 6. Prototype
Step 4: After the service period, we collect payment and feedback from mentees
(Appendix 4). We earned a revenue of 50.000 VNĐ from Group 3, and she said that
she is willing to pay a higher price (120.000 VNĐ) for a mentoring session on
presentation skills. According to the feedback, MentorHub’s satisfying point is
delivering one-on-one mentorship as well as the experiences and detailed guidance
of the mentor to help the mentee better understand the problems. Moreover, there are
3 things MentorHub should improve to better serve mentee's needs, basing on the
feedback from customers. First, the mentor should be more proactive in giving
direction on what to learn, and what to prepare before the mentoring session. Second,
mentors and mentees must agree on the communication channel and mentorship
channel that is suitable for both parties. Third, MentorHubs must reach out to more
potential mentors in different fields to cover the mentee needs relating to different
fields, such as Marketing competition (Appendix 4). For Group 1 and Group 2, they
said that they will continue to use MentorHub service for other fields, and next time,
they are willing to pay from 270.000 to 350.000 for 2 mentorship sessions (Appendix
4).
50
CHAPTER 4: INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL BUSINESS VALIDATION
Competition Landscape
In terms of the competition landscape, we currently have not seen any direct
competitor of MentorHub. MentorHub has some potential competitors, whose
customer base also contain FTU2 students, and their solution is similar to MentorHub
to some extent (mentoring, coaching, one-on-one, education, etc.). However, these
potential competitors would face certain challenges if they choose to directly compete
with MentorHub in this market segment, and hence MentorHub would have some
advantages over these potential competitors.
Market size estimation is crucial in conducting a business project. Due to the fact that
FTU2 is a niche market and we do not have any direct competitors, based on our
survey results, it is safe to say that there certainly is room for MentorHub to operate
in and grow.
51
Since time and resources are two of our biggest constraints on calculation, the figures
we provide herein cannot be accurate; however, the MentorHub team tried our best
to come up with the numbers by utilizing secondary data and a self-conducted survey.
Using the TAM - SAM - SOM approach, with the assumptions made by the authors,
we estimate the market size as follows.
According to the Admission project of Foreign Trade University over the years,
FTU2 (Hochiminh campus) receive approximately 900-1000 new students each year.
According to data from the survey made by the team, newly admitted students
and a considerable number of second-year students (more than 90% of survey
respondents) have difficulties studying as well as competing in student
competitions, which creates the demand for MentorHub - a convenient and
affordable solution for their wants and needs.
2. SAM (service available market) is around 910 people (calculated based on the
assumption that around 70% of TAM will have demand for the service, derived
from the survey result).
52
3. SOM (service obtainable market) is around 137 people (calculated based on
the assumption that MentorHub can reach around 15% of the SAM population,
estimated for the first phase of the business, for a whole academic year).
MentorHub Milestone
The market acceptance also shows good signal as 100% of the mentees are willing to
pay for the next time using service, 86% have intentions to use MentorHub service
for upcoming competitions, and the price range they are willing to pay is from
120.000 to 175.000 VNĐ per session (Appendix 4).
Moreover, MentorHub can take advantage of the flexibility and adaptability of in-
house teams in addressing the feedbacks from customers to improve the service. From
the feedback, quantity and quality of mentors, the method of addressing questions,
the availability of offlinee sessions are among the cares of mentees, and can be
imrprove to better serve customers’ needs and requirements (Appendix 4).
Profit Projection
53
Revenue 35.285.500 45.013.350 59.118.000
54
CHAPTER 5: PROCESS BOOK
Initially, we chose to build a project under topic 2, which was to develop a product
or service for Sensay company - a startup specializing in AI-based language learning
mobile application. However, since none of the team members could come up with
any ideas for improvement for the existing product of the company, the team decided
to brainstorm one more time and switch the topic. The team came up with 7 different
ideas in various areas, such as plastic recycling services, fashion retailers, food
delivery service, etc. After that, we had a meeting in which we gave each other
feedback and constructive criticism in order to pick out the most feasible idea. Due
to our limited knowledge, expertise, experience, and resources (such as time and
humans), we chose to develop the MentorHub project, which was an area where all
members could contribute their effort to making this a feasible, desirable, and viable
project.
After determining the general outline of our project, we started to build the customer
persona, primarily by conducting a self-constructed survey. Based on our knowledge
and assumptions about the customers, we developed a questionnaire (Appendix 6)
and mass-mailed it to all students at FTU2. The results we obtained supported and
solidified our initial assumptions about the wants/needs of students and their demand
for a mentoring service. From then, we defined the pain point and gain point that we
could solve for the students. There were 2 important lessons that we learned in this
stage of the process. The first one was that we had to pay attention to the competitors'
landscape within FTU2, since there was also a mentoring project launched by a well-
known student club. Therefore, we needed to make our value proposition clearer as
well as clearly define our unique selling points in order to stand out in the market.
Secondly, we needed to narrow down the scope of problems that our service promised
to solve/ provide solutions for since the Mentees have a lot of different problems,
wants, and needs. That was why we clarified afterwards that our project primarily
solves two problems only, which were to help the Mentees gain a higher GPA and
get into the further rounds of competitions.
55
For the stage where we developed the value proposition, we learned two lessons that
we must stand from the viewpoint of the customers when coming up with the
proposition, and that we could only provide advantage of at most two out of three
factors which were quality, price, and time/convenience. We decided that our service
would help the customers in regards to quality and time, that was why we were forced
to charge relatively high prices for a proportion of students.
For the right hand side of the BMC, we received the feedback that we did not have a
clear persona as well as value proposition for the Mentors (initially, we only had for
the Mentees). This stemmed from the problem that we regarded the Mentors as our
key partners and not our customers. However, we did ask for the supply of Mentors
in the questionnaire, so coming up with the persona and value proposition for the
Mentors were added in time. Secondly, we fixed the content of the customer
relationship component because initially, we thought it was about doing marketing
campaigns and carrying out customer care activities. After the consultation with the
professor, we realized that we had to talk about activities for customer acquisition
and, more importantly, customer retention.
Regarding the left hand side of the BMC, all members contributed their ideas so that
we could define a 10-step process of how we could deliver value to our customers
(Appendix 8). From that, we defined our key activities, key partners, and channels. It
also helped us break down the costs required for this model. More particularly, for
the key resources, each member of our team listed out their achievements, capabilities,
and strengths so that we could allocate each member into suitable positions in this
startup project so as to utilize all of our available resources.
For the Cost and Revenue structures, we decided to work individually at first.
Meaning one member would be in charge of Cost and another of Revenue. However,
we soon realized that we did not match the cost and revenue, resulting in a forecast
of an incredible loss even after three years of operation. Therefore, we learned that
we must work collaboratively in order to come up with a healthy financial plan.
56
Lastly, for the prototype development, there are two main points we would like to
mention. Firstly, in the stage of acquiring early users, our team members had to do
sales activities and basic BTL (below the line) marketing activities by directly
chatting with the customers and utilizing their word of mouth to acquire the early
adopters. We realized that we must pay attention to and focus on “reminding” them
of their pain points in order to make them feel the need to try our service at a discount
price. Secondly, while delivering the mentoring sessions, we learned that for this type
of service, the demand will skyrocket in the examination season, especially two or
three days prior to the exam date. Therefore, we, as the MentorHub owners, must pay
attention to demand forecasting, contract more mentors as preparation, and charge
higher prices for peak seasons so as to best satisfy market demand. Moreover, we
must have more careful preparation in the sense that the Mentees must have time to
prepare their questions, or else they would feel like they couldn’t obtain the most out
of the mentoring session, thereby lowering the amount that they are willing to pay or,
in the extreme cases, stopping engaging with our business.
Regarding the key risks that can kill our business, we anticipate two main risks that
heavily affect our service. The first one is the possibility that the Mentees and
Mentors having each other's contacts, they would stop engaging with us and instead
make contracts on their own, which would significantly decrease the number of both
Mentors and Mentees in our business. For this risk, we mitigate it by giving Mentors
loyalty programs and offering them financial benefits in order to retain them. Second,
since we are still in the early stages of this project, our demand forecasting cannot be
fully trusted. Therefore, in the peak season, it could result in a surge in the number of
Mentees, whereas the number of Mentors cannot meet this demand. We counter this
risk by trying to develop the demand forecast model as accurately as possible over
the years so as to better prepare for the peak seasons.
57
APPENDICES
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd4kvnol4QsmqDzI3zOzrbQGYE
O0Rwtfw2bbWd3bqw6tsRyuw/viewform?usp=sharing
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeGBZLGzTiHIr8XKtCID9YXD
ERfu5Mp_NhAZl9hih-iTtClZA/viewform?usp=sharing
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
Appendix 3. Mentoring service implementation process
65
66
67
Docx dành cho Mentee input câu hỏi, thắc mắc
Câu hỏi, thắc mắc của Mentee (NHÓM 1) - Google Tài liệu
68
69
70
71
72
Appendix 5. Results of survey on Mentorship needs of FTU2 students (only
access by FTU2 gmail)
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1jJQI_3OPgn08wfi7rgP74-
9zJamjrwiXV2y57uT0YuM/edit?fbclid=IwAR3UydKcw_ZnMBTYVP0TISim
mhqMpHU0gdh5rWVxPLjGRKDBR4Zq_RII7Q0
73
74
REFERENCES
Bộ giáo dục và đào tạo (2022) SỐ Liệu Thống Kê Giáo Dục đại Học Năm Học 2021
- 2022, Cổng thông tin điện tử Bộ Giáo dục và Đào tạo. Available at:
https://moet.gov.vn/thong-ke/Pages/thong-ko-giao-duc-dai-
hoc.aspx?ItemID=8831 (Accessed: 04 December 2023).
Gilsenan, K. (2023) Insights on what gen Z really think and why you should care,
GWI. Available at: https://blog.gwi.com/chart-of-the-week/what-gen-z-really-
think/ (Accessed: 04 December 2023).
Jenkins, R. (2017) How generation Z will transform the workplace with david and
Jonah Stillman [podcast], Ryan Jenkins Next Generation Catalyst, Speaker &
Blogger. Available at: https://blog.ryan-jenkins.com/2017/03/27/how-
generation-z-will-transform-the-workplace-with-david-and-jonah-stillman-
podcast (Accessed: 04 December 2023).
Le Nguyen (2023) Số thí sinh đỗ đại học tăng, vnexpress.net. Available at:
https://vnexpress.net/so-thi-sinh-do-dai-hoc-tang-
4646313.html#:~:text=Tuy%20nhi%C3%AAn%2C%20n%C4%83m%202022
%2C%20sau,sinh%20tham%20gia%20x%C3%A9t%20tuy%E1%BB%83n.
(Accessed: 04 December 2023).
Perna, M.C. (2021) Why skill and career advancement are the way to gen-Z’s heart,
Forbes. Available at:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/markcperna/2021/03/02/why-skill-and-career-
advancement-are-the-way-to-gen-zs-heart/?sh=351bb5db22b5 (Accessed: 04
December 2023).
Phuong Lien (2023) Tuyển sinh đại học 2023: Chênh lệch lớn giữa tỉ lệ trúng tuyển
và tỉ lệ nhập học, baochinhphu.vn. Available at: https://baochinhphu.vn/tuyen-
75
sinh-dai-hoc-2023-chenh-lech-lon-giua-ti-le-trung-tuyen-va-ti-le-nhap-hoc-
102230908153951072.htm (Accessed: 04 December 2023).
Wong, A. (2023) Though mentors have become more common, gen Z has less
access to mentoring resources, USA Today. Available at:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/education/2023/01/26/mentoring-has-
become-more-popular-so-why-gen-z-getting-less-it/11120823002/ (Accessed:
04 December 2023).
5 năm qua, quy mô sinh viên tăng nhưng tỷ lệ tốt nghiệp lại giảm (2022) Giáo dục
Việt Nam. Available at: https://giaoduc.net.vn/5-nam-qua-quy-mo-sinh-vien-
tang-nhung-ty-le-tot-nghiep-lai-giam-post229122.gd (Accessed: 04 December
2023).
76