Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assam - Research - Reporton Field Survey On Agriculture Marketing in Rural Areas and The Role of Middleman
Assam - Research - Reporton Field Survey On Agriculture Marketing in Rural Areas and The Role of Middleman
Assam - Research - Reporton Field Survey On Agriculture Marketing in Rural Areas and The Role of Middleman
2011-12
AGRICULTURAL
MARKETING
SYSTEM IN
ASSAM
National
Institute of
Agricultural
Marketing
Report Prepared By
(NIAM)
Hema Yadav
Jaipur Deputy Director
Rajasthan NIAM
2011
`
Index
Chapter I
Introduction……………………………………………………………………………
Annexure
Reference
List of Tables Page No.
Dr R P Meena, IAS
Director General
Executive Summary
Overview
1. Agricultural marketing system in Eastern and North-Eastern States is distinctly
different from the other states in the country. It is observed that, the ownership
structure and functioning of the markets in these states is heterogeneous. Hence,
the argument put-forth by these states is that, it is rather difficult to implement
the reforms process initiated by GOI in the absence of uniformity in the
functioning of the markets.
2. As per the decision taken in a meeting of Committee of State Agriculture
Marketing Ministers, held on 25th April, 2011, the present study was assigned to
National Institute of Agricultural Marketing, Jaipur with the objective to study
ownership and management
Agricultural Marketing Environment
3. Multiplicity of regulatory Acts- Assam Agricultural Produce market act 1972,
Panchayat Act 1994 and Municipal Act 1956 acting in parallel has resulted in
absence of unidirectional development. The APMR act has been amended in 2006
to make provisions for contract farming, direct marketing and private markets
6. In the 24 markets under the regulation of the APMR Act, the primary focus has
been on revenue collection relegating facilitation such as market information
system, infrastructure, and extension to second place.
7. The system of collection of market fees at the check gate has been a major
obstacle in development of markets. The system needs to be abolished to develop
a orderly system of marketing in Assam
Strengthening Access to markets
8. Farmers of Assam have sufficient market surplus, with a market within 5 km.
However, the Physical access to market is constrained by bad condition of the
road and high transportation cost. The rural markets often become inoperable
because of water logging.
9. Farmers sell their produce to a weekly market within close proximity. While
deciding which market to sell to, the most important factor is the price. Distance
from the market and related transportation cost followed by infrastructure
facilities are other considerations.
10. Farmers get knowledge about prices through word-of-mouth which is often
unreliable making the farmer unable to demand the right price.
11. The markets with weekly periodicity have been handling agricultural and non
agricultural products for last 40 to 50 years. The marketing system is in dire need
of attention for development of infrastructure, expansion of market network and
channels to help in delivering the benefits of marketing opportunities.
12. One of the major infrastructure constraint in all the markets is unavailability of
electricity. Since markets function during evening and functions till night,
markets function under gasoline lamp or diesel generators which exert extra cost
on the farmers.
13. At rural markets and primary markets, only unauthorized middlemen or agents
of outside district operate as buyers. These middlemen neither maintain any
documents nor issue any receipts. The method of sale is traditional, non
transparent and coercive.
14. The annual income of markets reveal that the Municipality Markets generate
highest income and function as major markets for arrival. However there is a
overlap in the functions of markets under Municipal Bodies and RMC.
15. The alternative management system of the prevailing markets can be engaging
farmer groups, trader association to operate the markets.
16. Among the various vegetable crops, ginger offers tremendous scope for
commercialisation in Assam. There a scope of encouraging organic farming in
pineapple, turmeric, orange etc.
17. In tandem with typical characteristic of service product mandi as service
organization has to be spruced up to measure to measure up the expectation of
the different stakeholders .There should be a service delivery culture.
18. The Study suggests that a electronic system of weighment be introduced in the
markets to bring transparency
19. The prevailing auction system of giving markets to lesse needs to be replaced by
having a open auction system to have better participation.
20. The study suggests that in Assam Agricultural Marketing Board has to play a
major role in developing basic infrastructure in the markets.
21. Promoting the development of efficient and competitive system that can
effectively respond to the changes require greater role of public and private
sector in providing enabling environment for growth, increasing, enhancing
market facilities and market information.
22. The social and cultural fabric of the state has shown traditional set up of the
communities where the community groups in tribal areas have taken
responsibility of shared resources and groups activities in rearing ducks, pigs,
weaving, collection of honey, crafting etc. The study finds well established grass
root collectivism in taking economic activity. The State has the potential to bring
transformation through rural innovation and knowledge sharing. A further
investigation in documenting the rural technology sharing and innovation will
further provide guidance bringing vital changes through participation and due
cognizance of local needs
23. The summary of the conclusions and suggested action plan is shown in the table
that follows
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
1.7 The growth of the Agriculture and Allied sector is projected at 3.15 percent in
2010-11(A) as the State has experienced sufficient rainfall during the kharif
season which is congenial for rice cultivation in the State.
1.8 The production and productivity of all major crops has increased
significantly in 2008-09 by achieving the total production of 120.35 lakh MT.
The implementation of National Food security mission in 13 states has
achieved a record rice production. The production of Rice in 2009-10 was
42.60 lakh MT. Similar trend was also visible in Oilseed, Sugarcane, Jute.(
Table 1.2)
TABLE 1.2- PRODUCTION OF CROPS ( In lakh MT , Jute in Lakh bales)
1.9 Land Utilization: As per the Land Utilization Statistics for the year 2008-09,
the total reporting area of the State was 78.50 lakh hectares. Out of the total
reporting area, net sown area constitute 35.80 percent[28.10 lakh hectares],
23.61 percent was under forest, land not available for cultivation 26.26 lakh
hectares or 33.45 percent of the total reporting area and other uncultivable
area was 4.32 lakh hectares or 5.5 percent . While Fallow land constitutes 1.63
percent of the total reporting area with around 1.28 lakh hectares, land under
still water and water logged area jointly constitutes 1.78 lakh hectares or 2.27
percent.
1.10 Assam covers an area of 78,438 sq. km. with a population of 26638407.
The percentage shares of area and population of the State to that of the
country are 2.4 and 2.6 respectively. The State can be divided into three
distinct natural regions viz. The districts (27) are further subdivided into 56
sub-divisions and 145 revenue circles ( Fig 1.1)
1
www.asamb.in
2.5.5 During the visit to Regulated markets, it was found that although
auction platforms are existent, there is no auction in trading
taking place. Many of the markets where the land is owned by
RMC but it has been occupied by Army or CRPF. The Market
secretary collects the market fees at the check gates .
2.5.6 The Assam Agricultural Produce Market Act, 1972 has been
amended in 2006 to make provisions for (a) Private Marketing (b)
Direct Marketing (c) Consumer-Farmers Market and (d) Contract
Farming as per guidelines of Govt. of India.
2.5.7 The State Agricultural Produce Market Act aims at regulating
marketing practices mainly at Assembly Market Level. It has not
succeeded in getting administrative or managerial control over
Rural Weekly Market through which 60-65% agricultural and
allied products of the State are serviced.
2.6 Rural Market System:
2.6.1 There are approximately 1150 rural markets in Assam. Locally
these are known as haats or bazaar. The rural markets are
managed by Anchalik Parishad (block level) .The Markets are
leased annually by inviting bids. The bid for one market varies
from 5 lakhs to 15 lakhs depending on market size. Anchalik
Parishad receives money from lessee of which 40% is retained by
Anchalik Parishad, 40% is given to Gram Panchayat as the
ownership of the land lies with Gram Panchayat and rest 20% is
given to Zila Parishad.
2.6.2 The rural markets mainly function as the primary markets which
serve a small area of 1.5 to 3 km radius and operate once or twice
a week. There is relatively small market attendance of 500 to 2000
person per market day where farmer –producers sell their surplus
to local consumers.
2.6.3 There are also local assembly markets which serve a larger area
with a radius of 3 to 8 km and on average 2000 to 5000 people
attend these markets per market day which is usually twice a
week. Here the farmer has an opportunity to sell to either local
consumer or to itinerant trader. In some of these markets livestock
is also assembled for sale in bigger markets. Also non farm
products for daily needs are sold.
2.6.4 In Rural Markets, trade is characterized by direct sales of small
quantities of produce by producers to village traders and by retail
sales to rural consumers. The Rural Markets normally form part of
a local trade network and are usually arranged on a periodic basis,
on specific weekdays. They are more commonly organized at a
central place in a village or district centre or beside a village’s
access road. The market circuits are an example of commodity
flow are inherent characteristic of rural periodic markets.
2.6.5 Rural Markets in Assam generally perform three functions, viz,
(1) selling of local produce within the area (ii) assembly of local
products for selling to other areas and (iii) retailing of wholesale
lots from other areas in the local area. The selling of local produce
to traders & consumers is the predominant activity in these
markets. Here farmers represent the biggest group either as sellers
or as buyers. At times, farmers retail their produce & become
traders also. Besides, goods, that are not produced locally, are
brought by smaller & occasional traders to retail to local
population. These markets, through their interconnections, are a
farmer's main connection point with the inter and intra regional
marketing system.
2.6.6 The ruling prices in these primary markets are invariably much
lower. Price variations are attributed to lack of infrastructure such
as storage, transport, etc. Due to lack of infrastructure, many times
the farmer is forced to sell at harvest time, at low prices, only to
buy back in off season at higher prices. This highlights the need
for planning of Rural Markets to enable them to play their role
effectively. They can be provided with need based infrastructure
to come up to a level.
2.6.7 Although trading is the basic function of Rural Markets, a
number of other activities take place, which for some market
users are more important. Amongst these are the social functions,
such as meeting other persons and obtaining news, and, other
service functions such as tailoring, repairs, health, catering to
daily needs of life etc. There is an increasing awareness amongst
the rural population about advantages of selling their produce at
market points to secure competitive prices. This, coupled with
increase in Agricultural & Horticultural production, will generate
larger arrivals in Rural Markets. Handling of larger turnovers will
necessitate providing appropriate infrastructure facilities at these
markets. Rural Markets developed appropriately will attract
produce presently by-passing the market &also become more
price competitive.
2.6.8 Gram Panchayats lease-out these markets annually by inviting
bids. The prime objective is to collect lease-money every year. The
lessee gets busy collecting ground rent, parking fees, bullock fees,
etc. by employing people specifically for the purpose. Farmers
and traders visit weekly & daily Panchayat Markets where Lassez
faire approach is prevalent.
2.6.9 During the various visits to Rural Markets of different districts, it
was found that facilitating services to both farmers & traders are
absent in general. Nobody owns responsibility towards marketing
efficiency: price, operational, innovative or for that matter of any
kind. It has been a long felt need to address the marketing issues
to improve and strengthen the marketing system to become a
stronger link of the State's agricultural economy.
2.7 Municipality and Town committee markets:
2
http://sfcassam.nic.in/report/MUNICIPALFINANCES.pdf
However the fees collected from rent from market and trades is
not plowed back towards the improvement of the markets. These
markets have good trade and the facilities are better than the
Rural Markets. But the revenue earned from trade is not used for
development instead it is used to pay the rents, bills and
Gram panchayat Municipality and Regulated
Markets Town Committee Market
3.2 Most of the markets are of age between 15 to 40 years and it is also important to
note that only 9 markets are upto the age of 15yrs. Market development since last
ten years has been slow and hence congestion and stagnation in development is
perceptible. The markets with weekly periodicity have been handling
agricultural and non agricultural products for last 40 to 50 years. The marketing
system is in dire need of attention for development of infrastructure,
expansion of market network and channels to help in delivering the benefits
of marketing opportunities.
3.3 Access to Market: The market survey of 196 market Distance from Market ( Km) %
reveals that the main markets are in approach of only Upto 5 kms 71
upto 5 km (Table). Majority of the farmers have access 5 to 10 22
10 to 15 3
to the market but the road conditions are bad.60% of
15 to 20 1
the farmers have unpaved roads to travel to the
Above 20 2
market. Common mode of transport used by farmers
Table 3.1 Distance from Market
is the bicycle. Depending upon the volume, cycle
thela, truck, minivan wooden cart, etc. are hired for transport. The constraints to
physical access to markets are the bad condition of the roads and the high
transportation costs.( Table 3.1)
3.4 Connectivity of Markets by Phone and Internet. The study shows that markets
are poorly linked with Telephone and Internet facilities, only 45% markets are
linked with telephone facility and rest 107 markets have no access to ICT
services. Following table shows distribution of markets by connectivity.( Table
3.2)
3.5 Access to Market Information: Farmers have no knowledge about what price
they should ask for the produce during the transaction. Many of the farmers gain
first hand information about prices from fellow farmers and traders. Paddy
producers go by the prices fixed by the millers. Few educated farmers keep in
mind cost of production, transportation, etc. while negotiating in the market or
even with the miller. As many as 64% of the farmers are not able to decide to sell
on a certain price.
3.6 Access to formal credit: There are 21 commercial banks with a network of 323
branches. The banking facilities of the rural people are being served by a network
of Gramin Vikas Banks. The Assam Co-operative Apex Bank is the only State Co-
operative Bank which advances credit to the farmers. Availability of agricultural
credit in Assam per hectare is only 30% of the national average. According to RBI
report, 22 districts of the State remain under banked. The average area covered
by the bank branches operating in the state is as large as 60 Sq Kms per branch
and per capita credit disbursement to farmers in Assam was Rs 91 only against
the all India of Rs 1122 in 2004-05.
3.8 At the village haats and primary markets, there are, as such, no authorized
commission agents. Only unauthorized middlemen or agents of outside districts
operate as the buyers. These middlemen neither maintain any documents nor
issue any receipts. In the larger terminal markets like Maskhowa (Guwahati),
several brokers operate and charging commission on “per pack basis”. In this
market also, the transactions are not documented and no record is maintained
which makes the marketing system non transparent.
3.10 Price access: The large proportion of marketable surplus (60-70%) is sold at
village level giving rise to the problem of price access (farmers access to receive
price discovered under competitive setting in large markets) as these
transactions take place in a non-competitive setting with farmers having unequal
access to price information. In unregulated markets, there are low trading
volumes and a market setting represented by a large number of sellers and a
relatively small number of buyers. Although the regulated markets clearly spell
out the rules of price discovery, the study point out that the traders in these
markets show collusive tendencies, which adversely affect the fair price
discovery and benefits received by the farmers from such markets.
3.11 It is very important to develop the marketing system in such a way that
competition is created in smaller markets by developing proper channels and
adequate number of buyers to create competitive markets so that small farmers
can participate in the markets.
3.15 Arrival and Markets; Commodity wise Market Arrivals, wholesale price
and value of commodities is as shown in Annexure Some of the major
commodity arriving in market and the seasonal trend, price and pattern is
discussed below:
3.15.1 Rice : Rice is a major staple food of Assam. Rice is a three-season crop,
viz, autumn (Ahu), winter (Sali) and summer (boro) in Assam. A notable change
in rice production system is the introduction of boro rice in Assam. Boro rice is a
low risk option with yield being 30 to 40 percent higher than the normal level.
The winter rice is medium and fine quality rice. The study of 196 markets of
Assam State shows that out of a total production of 42 lakh MT of rice, annual
arrivals at the markets is 8.8 lakh MT. The districts of Darrang Shivsagar,
Goalpara, Shivsagar, Cachar and Karbianglong has markets doing business in
rice. Amongst the markets, Sibsagar Municipal Market emerges as the largest
market for receiving rice. The market receives 12.97% of the total arrivals. As
seen from the table municipality markets are important business centres for rice
as compared to Panchayat markets and regulated markets.
3.15.2 Betel leaf and Areca nut: There are about 100 varieties of betel vine in the
world, of which about 40 are found in India. Assam state is an important
producer of betel leaf and areca nut. Areca nut and betel leaf are produced in the
homestead garden and every farmer family owns an areca nut tree. Betel, being
'vine', it grows in the shade and also it entwines the areca tree. The betel leaves
are brought in to the markets as fresh leaves packed in a bunch. Each bunch,
called as Gussi, has 20 leaves, and, twenty gussi makes one disha which
comprises of 400 leaves. The price of the betel leaves in a market varies from
variety to variety. The price is also observed to vary from morning to evening,
since the leaves are highly perishable in nature. Producer normally receive a
price which ranges between Rs 100 to Rs 300 per disha (400 leaves). In winter,
which is the peak season, betel leaf is sold at Rs 3 per leaf. The betel leaves are
sold at very low prices in the rainy season; the producers end up fetching a price
of 50 Paisa per leaf
3.15.3 Vegetables:
the market place. In the event where different contracts are given for collection of
fees charges etc. and parking etc; in that case, total amounts of both the contracts
would be the income of the markets. In case of Regulated market the source of
annual income in the market fees, license fees, rentals, penalty etc.
The annual income of markets owned and operated by Municipality committee are
biggest earners. Silchar Municipality market earns Rs 35 lakh annually followed by
Barpeta Road and Kharupetia regulated market.( Fig 3.4)
In 2008-09 the number of markets earning incomes between Rs. 5 to 10 lakhs was
18, and, the incomes of 5 markets was above Rs. 20 lakhs. It has been found that
municipal markets in Barpeta, Jorhat, Nalbari, which are daily markets, have
incomes above Rs. 20 lakhs. Regulated markets under study are also daily markets,
but, the incomes earned by these markets are between Rs. 5-10 lakhs only.
Management of Markets
4.2 The Gram Panchayat Act suffers from enforcement of rules to inculcate good
marketing practices. After the markets are leased out the Zila Parishad should
have supervision on the market charges levied by lesse, the facilities rendered
by lesse, unhygienic conditions prevailing in the markets etc. The contract
agreement between the market committee and service provider, in this case the
mahaldar should have a penalty clause to be imposed in the instances of default.
The trained manpower at block level would be prerequisite to check the
activities of service provider and thereby facilitating better marketing in these
markets.
4.3 The Municipality Act has a role to provide facilities for retail trading for
consumers in the market. It has been found that the markets under municipality
Board and town committees also have wholesale trading of rice, betel nut, fish,
orange, banana etc. There is an overlap of function performed at Municipality
markets and regulated markets. The wholesale functions needs to be segregate
as laid down in the Municipality Act and to be regulated as per APMA act. The
wholesaling of agricultural commodities needs to be transferred to RMC and
brought under APMA
4.4 The Assam Agricultural Produce Market Act of 1972 is an act to provide for
better regulation of buying and selling of agricultural produce and the
establishment of market for agricultural produce in the State of Assam. The Act
was amended in 2006 to allow for provisions laid down in the Modal Act.
4.5 The State Government has constituted a State Agricultural Marketing Board
consisting of a Chairman and 17 other members. The Assam State Agricultural
Marketing Board (ASAMB), Guwahati was established on 1976, under Section 3
of the Assam Agricultural Produce Market Act, 1972.
The situation of Howly APMC market shown in Box that the market receives
income in the form of cess which is collected at the checkgates.
Box 4.1
Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee Howly
The Howly primary yard was established in 1977. Its subyards are Sarbhog, Barpeta
It has a 15 member elected-body headed by a Chairman. The Primary market yard has a
godown shed, staff quarters, toilet, auction hall, cycle and scooter stands. The market
has been occupied by CRPF, Rs 36 lakh is due from CRPF towards rent. APMC has
demanded Rs 23 lakhs but nothing has been received so far. The cess is collected at the
check gate only. There are various check gates through which the produce passes and
they have become cess collection gates. During the discussions, it emerged that market
secretary is only performing the role of collection of cess by visiting checkgates. The
checkgate of Howly is in Sarbhog. All over Assam there are around 20 checkgates.
Regulated Market Committee provides license to traders. The license fees of Rs 10 and
1% as cess is charged (cess is mentioned in the APMC Act itself and is synonymous to
fees). The Regulated Market Committee (RMC) gives license to all the traders whether
they are operating in Munipality, Town Committee or Panchayat Markets. The RMC
Howly has issued 600-700 licenses; of which maximum license holders are Farias (they
are mobile traders who aggregate the supplies and send them to bigger markets).
Around 50% of the income of APMC goes to State Agricultural Marketing Board. From
By and large the function of APMC for which it was established has been completely
ignored in the regulated markets and their role has been limited to that of fees
collection.
CHAPTER V
Issues in parallel Market System
Agricultural marketing system and market in Assam lacks orientation for growth
for development. The observations are as follows:
1.1 Markets are left to lessees to manage who take over the operation of markets
as stipulated in the legislations I) Municipal Act 1936 II) Agricultural
Produce market regulation Act 1972 III) Panchayat Act 1994. These three
agencies they operate in isolation to each other. While the Assam State
Agricultural Marketing Board (ASAMB) has ploughed back some revenue in
market development but municipalities, town councils and panchayats have
failed to do so all these years. Resultantly the primary markets, the backbone
of the State’s network have remained undeveloped. They are over congested,
unhygienic, devoid of need based facilitating infrastructure, supporting
services, innovations etc.
1.2 The bidding system under which the markets are leased out is in fact like a
cartel – who takes markets on lease everybody’s name year by year and turn
by turn. Once the bid is finalized Anchalik Parishad plays no role in the
development of the market. The bid money is shared by Anchalik Parishad,
Zilla parishad and Gram Panchayat in the proportion of the 40:40:20. The
revenue sharer is not accountable for development of the market.
1.3 The efforts of the State Government to set up orderly market network for
organised marketing through Agricultural Marketing Regulation Act, 1972
( implemented w.e.f 15.6.77) met with a limited success. The legislation could
not bring all markets in the State under its developmental umbrella to
undertake cohesive development. It proved to be another parallel legislation.
It could not uplift marketing system of the state and has focused on the
collection of cess at district check gates set up for the purpose. The enactment
of the act only facilitated receiving central government assistance for market
development under the centrally sponsored scheme for which the act was a
precondition.
1.4 The structure of market fees varies across the markets. The charges recovered
by lesse are not formalized and has freedom to charge any fees. In absence of
any regulation and checks the income of the money is not plowed back to the
system. The irrational collection of money and evasion of revenue of
Government has resulted in un developed markets and poor infrastructure.
1.5 There is a good amount of money collection in the weekly but in absence of
any receipt or issuance of wrong receipts the income of the market has been
underreported. Due to unsystematic and irrational charges which varies from
poultry bird, pig, fish to meat the estimation of the income is a difficult one
1.6 Majority of the markets have spill over and retailers sit outside the market,
ground rent is also recovered from the users sitting outside the market.
1.7 There is prevalence of weighment units such as pon in betel, gussi and dicha
in betle leaves, basta in case of rice, number in oranges and other local
measurements. The estimation is only approximation since these units need
to be converted in Kg and quintals
1.8 The markets are leased out for 3 to five years and the lease amount varies
from 3 lakh to 12 lakhs. There is collusion in grant of lease and during
discussion with market authorities it emerged that leasing remains in a
family year by year.
1.12 Markets are viewed as a source of revenue. The municipal markets have
large arrivals of agricultural produce and the revenue earned is used for
urban facilities. The periodic markets operated and managed by a contractor
or a lessee is run with the objective to earn profits.
1.13 Markets are full of garbage, muddy water logging, and, inhospitable to
producers and other market users.
1.14 The markets suffer from lack of enforcement of rules and regulations. The
market authorities have ignored market development and there is actually
nobody to check the operations in the market which has slowly become
exploitative and unfriendly to the farmers.
Chapter VI
Bringing Reforms in Agricultural Marketing
6.1 Role of the State in Agricultural Marketing: The State marketing Board has a
legal stature to regulate the functioning of the market to provide a equal platform for
an effective system. Such a system has an importance of being there to set rules
under which markets operate. An effective Market system should provide an outlet
and incentive for increased production. With the increased production of food grains
and horticultural products in Assam , it would be necessary to provide a an effective
marketing system with the objective to increase rural income and ensure affordable
supplies of food stuff.
6.2 The reforms in the present system are required to remove restriction and
duplication in the process and to reduce uncertainty by providing needful
infrastructure. The reforms process to bring efficiency and participation will require:
- Promoting Private sector for investment and creation of values within the
supply chain
- Reducing the administrative controls on license and taxation at check gates
The process of reforms involves a process of redefining property rights,
responsibilities towards management including the relative roles of different
agencies within government as well as outside government.
6.3 Regulation and reforms are instrument to perform a enabling function. The law
in this context defines the ownership of the market and establishes rules to protect it.
The process of reforms also establishes a relationship of person to good as to who
can trade and what can be traded. The right to participate in a market is also
protected by law of the market. Regulating when the markets are held by ion of
allocate on of stalls, types of produce that can be sold, the location of selling space
for different commodities, collection of revenue and the maintenance of hygiene,
multiple payment and charges in the market.
6.3 Effectiveness of market is enhanced when contracts and other liability are
defined and provides a dispute re addressal System.
6.4 Agricultural markets in the State of Assam are multi commodity and multi
functional. Instances are common where particular markets performs wholesale
function for some commodity and semi wholesale or retail function for some other
commodity, at the same time. All functions being performed for a single commodity
is also not uncommon. The handling of multiple commodity and functions has lead
to severe operational difficulties. The encroachment upon already inadequate
infrastructure and facilities and spill over are a big hindrance in operation of the
markets. Under the circumstances business thinking would be to develop markets
commodity wise and function wise. A management approach to the new markets
which are coming up requires:
- segregation of the commodities
- segregation of function
6.5 Such measures would reduce volume of transactions, arrival, pressure of space,
services and facilities on a single day and promote business smoothly. The
overlapping of functions and responsibilities resulted in neglecting market
development by the concerned agencies. The market system as it is today is totally
inadequate and unprepared to take on increasing competition between domestic and
imported agricultural products, arising out of liberalization and globalization.
6.6 The Model Act adopted by State ushers a new leash into marketing environment.
Rules for contract farming, establishing private markets, spot exchanges will help in
bringing the desired changes. Agricultural markets and marketing system has to be
proactive to development and sensitive to emerging requirement In order to develop
markets to be competitive following steps for management are suggested for
bringing the change in marketing and inculcating good marketing practices.
6.7 Strengthening State Agricultural Marketing Board Assam State Agricultural
marketing board which is established to facilitate marketing in the State has not been
able to bring the desired changes in the marketing system of the State for three
reasons.
- Staff of AAMB is positioned at Check gates to extort fees from the traders
entering the state with agricultural products
- In RMC where infrastructure has been created trading is not taking place or has
not been shifted.
- RMC is also levying fee from traders who are operating in markets not owned by
RMC but by the condition that they are located in RMC market area.
In the wake of reforms Assam State Agricultural Marketing Board has to play a
proactive role and strengthened. AAMB requires to be oriented to take following
responsibilities:
6.7.1 Service Orientation: RMC which came into existence to provide service to
sellers and buyers is presently oriented to revenue generation. They have eluded
from being a facilitator. It was due to this that RMC are uncompetitive as compared
to the markets owned and operated by Municipality Board and PRI in Assam State.
The service orientation to the present RMC need to be brought by taking following
steps:
- Market committee needs to work with farmers by consolidating them in groups
and giving training them on market led extension
- Developing a market information of their own market at least and disseminating
them to the market users
- Introducing innovations in marketing such aggregation of product, using shared
transportation, linking farmers with agribusiness companies, organizing farmer
markets etc. This will be possible with a close bonding and networking with farmers
- Effective checking of marketing practices and imposing penalties in the market
to stop the malpractice in weighment, payment, unjustified charges. The provision of
imposing penalties is there in the APMR Act but they have not been executed and
for this single reason the markets across the State are thriving on unjustified and
exploitative practices.
- Increasing the Staff and manpower and positioning them at market Yards to take
the responsibility of making it a competitive place for buyers and sellers
6.8 Introducing measures to increase efficiency of the market under Local bodies
The markets under municipal bodies which are daily markets attract buyer and
sellers and has income which is higher than other markets. Similarly the periodic
and primary markets are also important trading place for agri produce. In spite of
the thriving malpractices and unchecked overcharges by lesse of the market trading
takes place without inhibitions. The Model Act fosters the idea of liberalizing the
marketing environment by enhancing the private roles, the markets under ULB and
PRI are here to stay.
6.8.1 The responsibility to eradicate malpractices and inculcate good marketing
practices lies with State. The Assam Panchyat Act, 1994 only stipulates the approved
list of collection that a lesse is supposed to charge from market users (Rs 10-15 on a
market day) but has no provision of imposing penalty in cases where the charges are
higher than approved.
While the ownership can remain unchanged, concrete steps to free these markets
from exploitative practices need to be taken. While awarding a contract to lesses to
operate in the market , the terms and conditions should be particular about the
responsibilities of the contractor to be a facilitator and indulgence in exploitative
practice should evoke a penalty. In present system the lesse has free hand in
escalating the charges and this remains unchecked. The staff of Zila Parishad need to
be trained and empowered to play a facilitating roles and Institutions like SIRD,
SAMB can be geared up to provide market led extension training. A regular
consultation, facilitation and hand holding between different institutions will
gradually bring a conducive marketing environment in the state.
6.9 Management and segregation of function: Under the Municipality Act the
markets are operated for retailing function but it has been seen that these markets
have overlapping functions of wholesaling and retailing of agricultural products.
6.9.1 A legal intervention is required to segregate the market functions in
Municipality and Town committee markets. Wholesaling of agricultural products
should be disallowed in market and if AAMB is ready to take the responsibility, the
wholesale activity should be transferred to them for regulation. This will bring the
clarity of market functions and responsibilities amongst the parallel Institutions
running markets in States.
6.10 Strengthening Traders association for operating the markets: With the
liberalization of economy there is increased focus on market, business and profit.
The market trends are well understood and known to traders. The association of
agricultural traders have the potential to both facilitate the work of their members
and to achieve greater efficiency in the marketing chain. It is time to recognize their
role in improving the infrastructural and regulatory framework under which trading
takes place in markets It is necessary to involve traders and their association in
operating and managing the market. Owing to their strong influence and traditional
linkage with producers, fellow traders, buyers in these destination markets and
service providers, It is with this view it is possible for them to operate and manage
markets efficiently taking all segments with them. There is a need to try innovations
in uplifting the marketing system by giving association of market traders to operate
and manage markets within the framework of law.
6.11 To begin with, this could be a joint responsibility of public and private sector in
order to generate adequate financial resources and competition. The agricultural
marketing reforms adopted by the State Government have paved a way for
professional management, direct marketing, contract farming etc. These instruments
of reforms should provide leverage to usher in new way to develop network of well
equipped and efficient markets in the State. Having approved in principle, further
modalities- legal administrative, financial could be worked out for
6.12 It would require preparation of mandatory set of rules and regulations in
consultation with trade for operation and management with well stipulated duties
and responsibilities for the operation. Qualifying criteria for the association to run
the market would also have to decided. Revenue sharing arrangements between
association and government is will have to be worked out. If required a, constitution
of traders association as business companies may have to be looked into.
6.13 Strengthening Farmer Groups for engaging in marketing: Many poor people find
it difficult to engage successfully in markets. The barriers poor people face in
markets include lack of financial and physical assets, lack of access to key
information and services, lack of negotiating power and competitiveness due to the
production of very small volumes of low-quality products, and a lack of self-
Confidence . The formation of farmer groups at village level needs to be taken
as a priority by enhancing their capacity in market engagement. The
collective group can increased the access of small and marginal farmers. The
key to this approach for strengthening capacity of small farmers for market
engagement vis the combination of skill sets such as Group organization and
management, Internal saving and lending; Experimentation and innovation
(knowing how to access and apply new technology) and Basic market skills. Basic
market skills prepare farmers in small groups to produce effectively for the market
by organizing their production (for example, the crop variety, the planting dates, the
area to plant, etc.) to satisfy market demand .These skills also help farmers to
organize harvest and post-harvest management to collectively present their products
with the quality, amounts and timing requested by the buyers. As a result, farmers
can improve their sale price, and their cash income. Acquiring basic bargaining
skills helps marginal farmers to improve their market power, challenge barriers to
selling their products and realize higher profits.
Field Management Committees (FMCs), SHG and general farmers and their linkages
can be particularly helpful for marketing of particular type of commodities. The
formation of Farmer Interest group (FIG) will particularly help to reduce the
transportation costs of the farmers and thereby enhance profitability of the farmers.
The growers society formed by AAMB can be strengthened by imparting right kind
of skills to be able to manage a market.
CHAPTER VII
Promoting Vibrant and Competitive Agricultural Marketing
The promotion of marketing requires a systematic approach with the singular objective
of fostering competitive agricultural marketing system. The real challenges
a
The idea is not to have a parallel competitive system to the existing one, but to develop a
professional and a modern system around it. The proposed action plan suggests and
covers the key area e.g Market regulation, market infrastructure, marketing extension,
agribusiness and entrepreneurship in Assam.
Action:
Rural haats which are of the nature of assembly market can be handed over to
marketing board for management and to facilitate marketing. This arrangement
would enable the govt to develop market infrastructure in the weekly markets
under Central Government Schemes available to the states who have adopted
reforms.
The present system of awarding contract to lesse through closed tender needs to
be replaced by having open tender system with wide publicity to have better
participation
D Developing markets as agrimarts: The markets on the rural and urban fringe
should be given requisite technical support so that they can be used for effective credit
delivery, input marketing, procurement, information kiosk. Under the changed
economic environment, the rural markets can be a financially self supporting unit and a
source of income to finance further developmental infrastructure
Action: Since Assam State has adopted Model Act the market facities, infrastructure
and development of markets should be developed under Central Sector Schemes and
financial assistance from and other developmental organization. A careful locational and
neighborhood analysis of markets should be the prime consideration while developing
markets and infrastructure.
7.3 Rational utilization of market revenue: As discussed the revenue earned from the
markets of Assam State is often siphoned for other purposes and market development
has been ignored. The markets develop significant revenue from marketing fees, ground
fess, parking fees and rentals. The Market fees is collected in lieu of service rather than
being taken as a tax. The revenue gained from transactions is to be utilized in
developing facilities in markets.
Recommendation: The large evasion of revenue require effective system to check the
income from the markets and to ensure that revenue is uitlized for developing basic
facilities in market such as shops, parking, drainage , sheds, troughs for cattle, drinking
water, public toilet. The system of audit of accounts of the markets and having
transparency will help in planning rational allocation of revenue and resources.
Action:
1. The practice of collecting market fees at the check gates needs to be abolished
2. The multiple charges and irrational fees charged by the lessee needs to be
checked and monitored
3. The wholesale markets of Assam need to be brought under the regulation so that
market fees collected can be budgeted and plowed to develop facilities.
7.4 Strengthening domestic grades and standards: The study finds that there is
absence of grading and standards in markets. The grading in these markets is done by
traders is on the basis of size and color of fruits and vegetables. Even in the regulated
markets of State, grading practice is conspicuous by its absence.
Grading after harvest effects the price realization by farmers and facilitates trade.
Grading as a voluntary measure needs to be encouraged and made mandatory in
commodities which have potential for export market viz pineapple, orange and
vegetables.
Recommendation: Grading after harvest effects the price realization by farmers and
facilitates trade. Grading as a voluntary measure needs to be encouraged and made
mandatory in commodities which have potential for export market viz pineapple,
orange and vegetables.
Action
1) The adoption of grading and standards for food safety needs to be inculcated by
provision for training, extension and information.
2) This also calls for having trained manpower for assessing risk and managing food
safety protocols.
3) Besides this well equipped laboratories for testing and certification will be required to
be set up in collaborations which can be done in a PPP mode
7.5 Improving access to credit: Access to credit is one of the biggest hindrance faced by
the farmers. Banks and other institutions are hardly providing credit for harvesting,
procurement packaging, transportation, storage etc. In the present system the credit
needs of the framers are fulfilled by the informal sources.
Recommendation: Improving the credit system both formal and informal is also
required so that farmers can be saved from unauthorized moneylenders who charge
high rate of interest and are exploitative in nature. During the interaction with various
Women groups in the remote tribal area, it has been found that Women SHG have fared
well in terms of management, operation and effective utilization.
Action
1) Lending by rural and co-operative banks have to increase its area of reach by giving
them better framework for functioning
2) Institutional efforts needs to directed in making attractive schemes for availability
of finance and various other assistances including technical know how, training,
sales, purchases, etc.
3) Promoting micro finance in rural areas for credit requirements. The Micro
finance Institutions should facilitate of financial and non-financial services such as
loan funds, grant support, equity and institution building support so as to facilitate
development of enterprises in rural into financially sustainable entities .
4) Formation of SHG for flow of small credit has been witnessed in Assam. Women
SHG are functioning well but they need to be strengthened by increasing credit flow
training in management and entrepreneurship
5) The warehouse receipts should be made a prime tool for trade and facilitating
finance against warehouse receipts. The negotiable warehouse system will increase
liquidity in rural areas and encourage scientific warehousing of goods. The role of
APMC in encouraging the use of negotiable warehouse receipt is of important one.
7.6 Strengthening rural road connectivity: The condition of rural roads in Assam is
poor and has posed a major challenge for the transportation of products. Poor road
connectivity is also one of the contributory factor in low realization of value. As a
consequence of the poor road condition, transportation costs are higher, loading and
unloading creates difficulties and results in produce losses. Because of poor rural road
network, produce marketing tends to shift near major highways, thereby leading to
suboptimal market pattern
Recommendation: Public investment in rural roads by increasing rural connectivity can
have a significant impact on access to market by farmers, the development of supply
chains and overall marketing efficiency in addition to other beneficial impacts on rural
households. The World Bank study shows that improving the road conditions will
induce farmers to sell more in the market instead of farmgate.3
Action: 1) Panchayat Raj bodies at district block and village level can play a pivotal role
in construction and management of rural roads.
2) Substantial investment needs to be made in development of rural road network. As in
States like Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, the construction of rural roads is done by State
Marketing Board, for this the kind of System in Assam more and more market needs to
be brought under regulation and taken over by Assam State marketing Board.
7.7 Developing effective farmer linkage to supply chain: The market system in state
has fragmented and un coordinated supply chain for marketing of produce. In addition
to this, farmers lack in marketing skills, receiving market information, formation of
group. Producers are seen selling small volume of produce in markets of Assam, which
is due to absence of aggregation at assembly market or at collection centre.
Action: 1) Developing marketing system and channels for effective delivery system for
which the market committee of rural and wholesale market should play a proactive role
3
India taking Agriculture to the markets, 2006 , Document of World Bank PP 23
in developing proper channels, adequate number of buyers to create competitive market
so that small farmers can participate in the markets
Action:1) Collaborating with NGO at taluka level to impart market led extension and
training to the farmers to form groups
2) Making producer’s organization for selling organic products in Assam. As the market
for organic product is growing it is important to have certification companies and
organization to leverage the advantage.
Action:
In the existing practices the weekly rural markets (the focal points of rural business) are
run by dominant groups (traditionally male) in the society, who are legitimized to
collect revenue against each vendor in contractual basis through community acceptances
or through Government formalities. The vendors set by the outsiders are inlets of
essential commodities to the villages as well as outlets of village produces to the outside
world. The rural women who are the main producer of rural produces have to depend
on the middlemen for selling of their produces and thus have to remain in the low paid
end of the market.
Recommendation: To eliminate this traditional barrier and policy gap the movement of
Amar Bazar (Our market) has been initiated by Rural Volunteer Centre, Akajan in the
year 2003. The formation of SHG and empowering women by enhancing their role in
marketing will help in promoting vibrant marketing in Assam During the study, many
SHG were found working efficiently in Damoria, Narayanpur,Akajan.
Action: Consolidating the Women SHG and strengthening them with proper training in
accounts and management.
Action:
2) Developing cold stores and refer transport system to ensure longer period of
availability and access to market
The move intends to cover around 15,000 farmers in the districts of Lakhimpur,
Baksa (Tamulpur), Kokrajhar, Bongaigaon, Udalguri, Nagaon, Kamrup and
Goalpara (Dudhnoi). The Central Government has already released an amount of
Rs 15 lakh as initial an installment for execution of the programme.
Recommendation:
_________________________
Annexure-I
As per entrepreneur’s feed back farmers are not educated so they do not
know meaning of high yield and have difficulty in adoption, that’s why
they are not able to reduce cultivation cost which is a big barrier of
Competitiveness in comparison of UP and Uttranchal and other states.
Due to lack of awareness farmers are not getting good quality of seeds,
pesticides, fertilizers and other inputs on right price that’s why there yield
and quality is inferior but entrepreneur has good analytical capacity,
negotiation skills and purchasing power to buy such input on very
competitive price to reduce cultivation cost. in this case farmers
production cost is three rupee fifty paisa and selling price is six rupee at
farm gate but as a part of future strategy by supplying good quality input
cost will reduce further for farmer and a result farmer will be able to get
more profit in percentage.
Entrepreneurs are also seeking some infrastructural help from govt. they
said shortage of industrial land is a problem for future expansion of
industry simultaneously Cold Storage and Transportation facility of
Potato from Naogaon and other districts of Assam is also required to
develop contract farming in whole state of Assam. This infrastructure
could be useful for Farmers, SHG, NGO, and Industrialist on payment
basis.
Even at the same time market price of potato was much higher than
contract price for example contract price was Six Rupee per k.g and
market price was Eight Rupee per k.g. but farmer felt they are in better
position by selling through contract farming.
For the purpose of cost reduction they have expressed that they need
constant supply of electricity so they can use electric pump set for
irrigation. They said diesel is very expensive in comparison of electricity
to reduce farming cost.
Farmers are also facing a problem which is drainage of rain/flood water in
Naogaon district. they said proper water drainage in Kolong river can
increase our production and profit
This is a small case of linking the farmers with the processor. As discussed
the farmers need to be trained in better production techniques, marketing,
handling and packaging, using market information to be able to sustain the
arrangement on long term
Annexure V
All the small farmer brings their produce to one place i.e. the house of a big farmer,
who is the group manager. He guides the small farmers how the field management is to
be done. At present Sonepat miller M/S Ajoy Katiyr’s. Rice mill at Sonepat has entered
into a contract with the producers here to buy the entire production of all the farmers
here, who cultivate Joha rice under organic method.
Price of paddy
At the Guwahati market price for Paddy, the grower was paid at the rate of
Rs.1500.00 (Rs.600.00 per 40 kg Paddy + Rs.20.00 as carrying cost). The certificate was
valid up to 31st December 2007. The validity of the certificate solely depends on the
organization’s continued compliance to indicated standards, which is subject to annual
surveillance inspection.
The certificate is valid for those products and areas that have been specified in the
annexure of the certificate. Certificate no is 7060A.
Production and Demand
Production of organic Joha paddy is 9 quintals per bigha i.e. 90 quintals per
hectares. The agreed purchase price was Rs.1600.00 per quintal of Joha paddy at
Guwahati. There is a huge demand for this aromatic rice. But the SUN STAR Company
purchased Joha rice at the rate of Rs.30.00 per kg. Now there is a competition amongst
buyers for buying this organic Joha (aromatic) rice. M/S Jaiprakash & co of Guwahati
agreed to pay higher price. M/s Katiyr Haryana agreed to pay Rs.20.00 per quintal
higher. This programme started in 2004 and is continuing up till now and has created a
very good response & demand in the market.
Reference
1. Agriculture at a Glance, Directorate of Agriculture, Assam.