BATANG TORU HEPP

Design Review Form

BT-23-TEC-LE-HD-SH-1006

Employer’s Engineer / HDEC

Prepared by: Zhu Ruichen, He Taolin
Issued by: He Taolin
Date: September 18, 2023
HD-Ref-NO.: BG-2023-091

Related Document
The Employer / Engineer The Contractor
BT-23-TEC-LE-HD-SH-0927 BT-23-TEC-LE-SH-HD-0833
/ BT-23-TEC-LE-SH-HD-0924

1/5
 BATANG TORU HEPP

Doc. No.: BT-23-TEC-LE-SH-HD-0924

Subject: Submittal for Dam, Concrete Outline, Mid-level Spillway Monolith (No4 Monolith) Rev 2.0

Approval Status: ☐ Approved ☐ Approved Except as Noted ☒ Returned for Correction

Section in Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response Engineer’s Comments

No. Document/ Rev. 1.0 Rev 1.0 Rev. 2.0
Drawing No. (2023-09-02) (2023-09-11) (2023-09-18)

(1) The contraction joint layout from
EL.362.00m to EL.365.00m of this
monolith is inconsistent with the
general layout drawings; please
check it together with the
treatment of the joint.
(2) The layout of the air vent is not
BT-SH-D1- detailed enough, and the material
1 05-DGD-21- of the vent is inconsistent in the
010-2.0 drawings, please check.
(3) There are two sections with the
number of j-j, please check.
(4) Please clarify the treatment
measures for the partial joint.
(1) According to the arrangement of the
dam body joints, the 3m
conventional concrete of the dam
foundation has been shown in the
No. 4 monolith.
(2) The detailed drawing of the air vent
outlet has been added, and the air
vent steel pipe in the drawing has
been unified as Q235B.
(3) One of the section j-j has been
modified.
(4) The treatment measures for the
partial joint will be shown in the BT-
SH-D1-05-DGD-21-022 Dam, Joint
Arrangement and Grouting. The
relevant drawings will be submitted
(1) Noted. Please update the plan view
accordingly.
(2) The bottom elevation of the air vent
outlet is 433.5m, which is lower than
the FWL 434.5m; please check the
water level in the air vent at the FWL
condition.
(3) The section number in Detail B is
inconsistent with the section k-k in
sheet 14/14. The “section d-d” is in
the wrong place.
(4) Noted. It will be reviewed after
submission.
(5) Please add the outline control
parameters of the monolith such as
the radius and center of the dam

2/5
BATANG TORU HEPP

in the near future. axis.

(6) Please clarify the access plan from

the dam crest at EL.436.00m to
the operation platform at
EL.420.00m and between all the
hoist rooms at EL.420.00m, as well
as the maintenance access from
the EL.420.00m platform to the
gate support beam, which should
fully meet the requirements for
safe operation.

(7) Please check the net clearance

between the maintenance flow
chamber and the spillway surface.

(8) The annotation “1:0.2218” in Section

A-A is wrong, please check and
revise.

(9) Please indicate the range of the

steel lining more clearly.

(10) It is suggested to unify the

downstream outline to Sta. D
0+007.50 to make it connect smooth
to adjacent monolith.

3/5
BATANG TORU HEPP

(11) Please detail the EL.413.10m

platform in Detail B.

(12) Please check the concrete zoning

boundary of C5-1, which along the
radial gate slot is improper.

(13) It is suggested to add construction

joints to the spillway surface, which
located at the bottom of the
contraction joints at Sta. D
0+031.51, and adjust the related
joints treatment measures and
waterstops accordingly.

(14) The bending part of the vertical

reinforcement in Detail E towards
downstream will leads to
inconvenience for construction, it is
suggested to adjust it.

(15) Please add necessary embedment

parts to show the relationship
between the embedment parts and
the concrete outline.

4/5
 BATANG TORU HEPP

He Taolin
Design Director

Attachment:
NO Document Number Document Title
Dam, Concrete Outline, Mid-level Spillway Monolith (No4
1 BT-SH-D1-05-DGD-21-007-2.0
Monolith)

5/5