Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sexual Abuse and Sexual Risk Behavior, Beyond The Impact
Sexual Abuse and Sexual Risk Behavior, Beyond The Impact
of Psychiatric Problems
Christopher D. Houck, PHD, Nicole R. Nugent, PHD, Celia M. Lescano, PHD, April Peters, MDIV, and
Larry K. Brown, MD
Bradley/Hasbro Children’s Research Center of Rhode Island Hospital and Warren Alpert Medical
School of Brown University
Key words adolescents; child abuse and neglect; HIV/AIDS; risk behavior.
A recent review of studies on childhood and adolescent and treatment applications]. Individuals with a history of
sexual abuse (SA) found consistent associations between SA endorse more negative attitudes about their sexuality
SA and subsequent sexual risk behaviors (e.g., younger and report lower levels of interpersonal power in sexual
age at first consensual intercourse, unprotected sex, relationships (Finkelhor & Browne, 1985). Another inves-
number of partners) as well as evidence that these relation- tigation reported that even 10 years following SA disclos-
ships are identifiable starting in adolescence (Senn, Carey, ure, participants with a history of SA endorsed lower
& Vanable, 2008). However, the effects of SA and the birth control efficacy than comparison participants (Noll,
effects of mental health problems associated with Trickett, & Putnam, 2003). In addition to risk related to
SA are entangled in many studies, making it difficult to perceived self-efficacy, individuals with a history of SA may
distinguish between the effects of SA and the effects of have difficulty regulating affect (Van der Kolk et al., 1996;
psychological symptoms on sex risk. Two studies Zlotnick, Zakriski, Shea, & Costello, 1996). This is particu-
using symptom checklists have shown risk behaviors to larly important to adolescent sexual decision making, as
be associated with SA even after controlling for psycho- those with a history of SA who have difficulty managing or
logical symptoms (Auslander, et al., 2002; Elze et al., expressing affect may become overwhelmed by the task
2001). A third investigation of only girls controlled for of negotiating safe sex and respond with avoidance, dis-
clinically significant elevations in depressive symptoms, sociation, or impulsivity. Alexithymia, or the inability to
with SA continuing to predict sex risk behaviors (Buzi express feelings with words, may be a marker of problems
et al., 2003). in affect regulation and is present in adults with a history
SA history may influence sex risk behaviors via a of SA (McLean, Toner, Jackson, Desrocher, & Stuckless,
variety of mechanisms such as attitudes about self and 2006; Scher & Twaite, 1999; Zlotnick, Mattia, &
sex [see Lescano and colleagues’ (2004) review of theory Zimmerman, 2001; Zlotnick et al, 1996).
All correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Christopher Houck, Ph.D., Bradley/Hasbro
Children’s Research Center, One Hoppin Street, Suite 204, Providence, RI 02903, USA. Email: chouck@lifespan.org
Journal of Pediatric Psychology 35(5) pp. 473–483, 2010
doi:10.1093/jpepsy/jsp111
Advance Access publication December 4, 2009
Journal of Pediatric Psychology vol. 35 no. 5 ß The Author 2009. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society of Pediatric Psychology.
All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oxfordjournals.org
474 Houck et al.
Quina and colleagues (2004) have posited a theoret- placements reported using a condom during their most
ical model by which childhood sexual abuse leads to adult recent sexual intercourse (Grunbaum, Lowry, & Kann,
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) risk. In this theory, 2001). Examination of the association between SA
SA causes feelings of stigmatization, powerlessness, and and risk behaviors in these youth is warranted (Buzi
fear, as well as sexualization in children, which in turn et al, 2003).
influence attitudes and cognitions about the self and Only one published investigation has examined
sexual situations. These cognitions are theorized to have the association between SA and risk behaviors in female
a potentially bidirectional relationship with problem behav- adolescents in alternative school settings (Buzi et al.,
iors, such as less intention to use condoms or more sub- 2003). In this study, approximately one quarter (27%) of
notion that SA is associated with sexual risk regardless of computer-assisted self-interviews (ACASI), administered
its influence on one’s mental health. on laptop computers to ensure privacy. Of these, 162
(88%) had data for items relevant to the present analyses.
Participants were provided a 90-day calendar, and a stand-
Methods ard script instructing participants to recall significant
Study Design and Sample events of the last three months was used to assist in
Data were collected as part of the baseline assessment of recall of the past 90 days. Research staff supervised com-
an HIV prevention program (Project STAR- Safe Thinking pletion of the measures and answered participant ques-
and Affect Regulation) conducted with students attending tions as they arose.
protected sexual acts was calculated by dividing the Higher scores on these measures indicate more posi-
number of protected acts by the total number of sexual tive, less risky attitudes/ cognitions and more knowledge.
intercourse acts. This percentage provides a description
of risk behavior separate from the absolute number of Psychological Factors
risk acts. For example, two adolescents who both have Computerized Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children
5 unprotected sexual encounters are not similar if one (C-DISC; Shaffer, Fisher, Lucas, Dulcan, & Schwab-
had sex 6 times and the other had sex 100 times. The Stone, 2000). The C-DISC is a structured, computer-
relationship between these two variables in this sample assisted diagnostic interview that screens for a full range
suggests that they are related but distinct constructs of DSM-IV diagnoses and was administered via
Table I. Rates of positive or intermediate diagnoses from the C-DISC among adolescents in alternative/therapeutic schools by history of sexual
abuse (N ¼ 155)
health and pathology of the family via 12 items (e.g., ‘‘We compared to those without such histories on demographic
can express feelings to each other’’) on a 4-point scale variables, presence of psychiatric disorders, sexual risk,
(‘‘strongly agree’’ to ‘‘strongly disagree’’). sexual attitudes, and psychological factors using Chi-
Weinberger Adjustment Inventory (WAI; Weinberger, square analyses and t-tests. For those sexual variables
Feldman, Ford, & Shastain, 1987). The WAI measures (behaviors, attitudes, and cognitions) significantly related
overall adjustment of adolescents; this study used two to SA in bivariate analyses, adjusted odds ratios (AORs)
12-item subscales, Distress (alpha ¼ .88, range 14–59) were calculated using multiple logistic regression to exam-
and Restraint (alpha ¼ .81, range 18–59), rated on ine the hypothesis that a history of SA would be associated
5-point scales (‘‘mostly false’’ to ‘‘mostly true’’). The with sex risk even after controlling for gender and the pres-
Distress subscale includes items related to anxiety, depres- ence of a psychiatric disorder. Some participants did not
sion, and low self-esteem, such as ‘‘I usually think complete all measures (e.g., seven adolescents did not
of myself as a happy person.’’ The Restraint subscale complete the CDISC). Analyses included all possible
assesses the ability to control impulses and suppress participants, and sample sizes for each analysis are
aggression (e.g., ‘‘I do things without giving them described in Tables 1–3.
enough thought’’).
Toronto Alexithymia Scale (TAS; Bagby, Parker, &
Taylor, 1994). The TAS is a 20-item questionnaire Results
(alpha ¼ .75, range 23–83) measuring symptoms of diffi- Consistent with prior investigations of alternative school
culties identifying and describing feelings. Participants settings (Buzi et al, 2003), 37 participants (23%) reported
responded to items such as ‘‘I am able to describe my SA in the moderate or severe classifications of the CTQ.
feelings easily’’ on a 5-point scale (‘‘strongly disagree’’ to More females reported having been sexually abused than
‘‘strongly agree’’). males [29% vs. 15%; w2 (1, N ¼ 162) ¼ 4.75, p < .05], and
Hope Scale (Snyder et al., 1997). This scale is a 6-item of those abused, 73% (N ¼ 27) were girls. Due to small
assessment (alpha ¼ .84, range 8–36) of optimistic think- samples of individual minority racial groups, white partici-
ing (e.g., ‘‘Even when others want to quit, I know that I can pants were compared to non-white participants. No signifi-
find ways to solve the problem’’) rated on a 6-point scale. cant differences with regards to abuse emerged [23% vs.
With the exceptions of the Hope Scale and WAI 29%; w2 (1, N ¼ 146) ¼ .631, p ¼ .43]. Similarly, Latino
Restraint, higher scores indicate more symptoms or impair- ethnicity [28% vs. 21%; w2 (1, N ¼ 160) ¼ .756, p ¼ .38]
ment for all scales. and age [15.3 vs. 15.3; t(160) ¼ .04, p ¼ .97] were not
related to reports of SA.
Data Analysis Sixty-one percent of the sample endorsed positive
Analyses were performed using SPSS 14.0 for Windows or intermediate diagnosis on the C-DISC for at least one
(SPSS Inc., 2006). Students with histories of SA were of the six diagnostic categories, as shown in Table 1.
478 Houck et al.
Table II. Differences between adolescents in alternative/therapeutic schools with and without SA histories
Sexual behaviors
Ever had sex 52% 78% w2 ¼ 8.11* 160
a
Sex in the last 90 days 51% 75% w2 ¼ 4.57* 87
Proportion of protected sex actsb .63 .39 .37 .44 t ¼ 2.20* 50
Number of sexual partners last 90 daysb 1.9 1.1 1.6 0.8 t ¼ .86 51
Number of unprotected sex actsb 5.8 16.0 16.6 28.0 t ¼ 1.59 50
Adolescents with histories of SA were more likely Students who had been sexually abused
to be diagnosed than those who denied abuse expressed riskier attitudes toward condoms. Specifically,
[w2 (1, N ¼ 155) ¼ 10.11, p ¼ .001], and they were more they endorsed more negative reactions to condoms
likely to endorse multiple diagnoses [w2 (1, N ¼ 155) ¼ [t(150) ¼ 2.72, p ¼ .007], fewer advantages of condom
9.30, p ¼ .002]. They were also significantly more likely use [t(141) ¼ 3.42, p ¼ .001], and lower self-efficacy for
to receive a positive or intermediate diagnosis of MDD using condoms [t(34.99) ¼ 2.88, p ¼ .007]. They did not
and CD. No significant differences emerged for PTSD, exhibit differences in knowledge of HIV-related informa-
ODD, GAD, or Mania/Hypomania. tion, tolerance for people who have HIV, or sexual
As seen in Table 2, students with a history of SA were self-esteem.
significantly more likely to have ever had vaginal, anal, or On psychological measures, adolescents with histories
oral sex [w2 (1, N ¼ 160) ¼ 8.11, p ¼ .004] than those of SA reported greater functional impairment on the CIS
without histories of SA. Of those who were ever sexually [t(156) ¼ –2.78, p ¼ .006], and more psychological symp-
active, adolescents with histories of SA were more like- toms on the BSI [t(160) ¼ –2.44, p ¼ .016]. In addition to
ly to report vaginal or anal sex in the past 90 days rating family functioning more poorly on the FAD
[w2 (1, N ¼ 87) ¼ 4.57, p ¼ .03]. Of those who were sexu- [t(133) ¼ –2.48, p ¼ .014], teens with histories of SA
ally active in the last 90 days, students with histories of endorsed more distress [t(159) ¼ –2.45, p ¼ .016] and
SA reported significantly lower proportions of sexual acts less restraint [t(159) ¼ 3.49, p ¼ .001] on the WAI and
protected by a condom than those without such histories more alexithymia on the TAS [t(155) ¼ –2.94, p ¼ .004]
[t(48) ¼ 2.20, p ¼ .03]. No significant differences emerged than those who did not report significant abuse. No sig-
related to number of sexual partners or the absolute nificant difference on the Hope Scale emerged.
number of acts unprotected by a condom among recently To control for the significant influences of gender and
sexually active adolescents. psychiatric symptomatology on SA as well as sexual
Sexual Abuse and Sexual Risk Behavior 479
with histories of SA reported fewer advantages towards condoms, and condom use and lead to less risk for this
using condoms than those without histories of SA. While vulnerable population.
attitudes and cognitions related to condoms differed in Limitations to the present research exist. First, the
bivariate analyses, other attitudes and cognitions (tolerance study did not assess details of abuse histories that might
for people with HIV, sexual self-esteem, and HIV know- be useful in describing the sample, such as the frequency
ledge) did not, suggesting that the difference between of the abuse (such that repeated sexual trauma may have
groups was specifically related to condoms and not different deleterious effects than single events) or the
merely a general difference on all scales related to sex or timing of abuse in relation to other developmental mile-
sexual outcomes. It is also noteworthy that a low rate of stones (such as puberty or onset of mental health prob-
critical importance. Fortunately, alternative and therapeut- inpatients. Journal of the American Academy of Child
ic schools can also provide rich settings for addressing and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36, 316–322.
these topics with these vulnerable youth. Brown, L., Lourie, K., Zlotnick, C., & Cohn, J. (2000). The
impact of sexual abuse on the sexual risk taking
behavior of adolescents in intensive psychiatric treat-
Funding ment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 157, 1413–1415.
Buzi, R., Tortolero, S., Roberts, R., Ross, M., Addy, R.,
National Institute of Mental Health grants R01 61149 and & Markham, C. (2003). The impact of a history of
R01 66641 to the senior author and the Lifespan/Tufts/ sexual abuse on high-risk sexual behaviors among
Kilpatrick, D., Ruggiero, K., Acierno, R., Saunders, B., conduct interviews on sensitive topics with children.
Resnick, H., & Best, C. (2003). Violence and risk of Journal of Sex Research, 34, 3–9.
PTSD, major depression, substance abuse/ Scher, D., & Twaite, J.A. (1999). The relationship between
dependence, and comorbidity: Results from the child sexual abuse and alexithymic symptoms in a
National Survey of Adolescents. Journal of Consulting population of recovering adult substance abusers.
and Clinical Psychology, 71, 692–700. Journal of Childhood Sexual Abuse, 8, 25–40.
Kowaleski-Jones, L., & Mott, F. (1998). Sex, contraception Schutzwohl, M., & Maercker, A. (1999). Effects of varying
and childbearing among high-risk youth: Do different diagnostic criteria for posttraumatic stress disorder are
factors influence males and females? Family Planning endorsing the concept of partial PTSD. Journal of
stress disorder in Vietnam Theater veterans. Journal of Zlotnick, C., Mattia, J.I., & Zimmerman, M. The relation-
Traumatic Stress, 5, 365–376. ship between posttraumatic stress disorder,
Weller, N.F., Tortolero, S.R., Kelder, S.H., Grunbaum, J.A., childhood trauma and alexithymia in an
Carvajal, S.C., & Gingiss, P.M. (1997). Health risk outpatient sample. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 14,
behaviors of texas students attending dropout 177–188.
prevention/recovery schools in 1997. Journal of School Zlotnick, C., Zakriski, A.L., Shea, M.T., & Costello, E.
Health, 69, 22–28. (1996). The long-term sequelae of sexual abuse:
Zeanah, P.D., & Schwarz, J.C. (1996). Reliability and Support for a complex posttraumatic stress disorder.
validity of the sexual self-esteem inventory for women. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 9, 195–205.