sna aif Asa HG CrAla Ca Aer fet: ees POWER GRID COMPANY OF BANGLADESH LTD. 's0g001 205, (An Enterprise of Bangladesh Power Development Board) ‘TITLE: DOCUMENT/DRAWING APPROVAL/COMMENT TRANSMITAL Project: Design, Supply, Installation, Testing and Commissioning of new 400/230/132 KV GIS SS at Korethat and Upgradation of 230/33 kV Substation to 400/230/33 kV GIS at Mirsharai ‘Contract No.s PGCB/WBYESPNERP/GIS/P4; Dated: 28-02-2022 Document Submittal Ref: Consultant ref letter: KEPCO-ESPNERP/P4-122;Date:August 16, 2023 Consultant ref letter: KEPCO-ESPNERP/P4-074-1:Date:July 12, 2023 Consultant ref leer: KEPCO-ESPNERP/PA-074;Date:May 14, 2023 ‘CNTIC ref leter: WBP4-CNTIC-SEC-PGCB-280; Date: 13® April, 2023, SUBJECT: Comment on EMTP Study (Interim Report) To, Copy to, Project Director Easter Region Project [P-04], x] Managing Decor, PGCE ‘LDC Bhaban, Aftabnagar, Badda, Dhak. Power Grid Company of Bangladesh Ltd. x] Fsecuive iesor (PD), PGCE | Chien Engineer (P & D), PGCE Y] eree,vorenic « sec Y] Master Fite Deat Sir Issued by: We are pleased to enclose the following documents for the purpose indicated below SB Seas 25/o8l202% Approval/CommentsInformation conveyed herein neither relieves the Scpernonden Engineer (Ad Ch ‘of dimensions, material of constructions, weight, quantities, design details, pees Lal ree ie potas ei ad a of Mee Peatocnam Ae I ty be appl . Dated:- August 23, 2023 Employer's right under the contract.” v Tiem No | Description of Drawing | Drawing No | Revision Status Enclosed a 3 4 s 6 Approved (A) Yo | EMTP Study (Int Approved with i ian ae : cev-) | Comments (AC) Report) Rev-00 ‘Comments (©) |x Request for Resubmission (RR) ‘Comments are attached as “Annexure-1”, 1cknowlodge receipt of documents: Hank, (WNic@se 2aloghay PGCB Bhaban, Avenue-3, Jahurul Islam City, Aftabnagar, Badda, Dhaka-1212 Web: www-pgcb.gov.bd, PABX: +88-02 55046731-35, Fax: +88-02 55046722, E-mail: info@pgcb.gov.bdAnnexure-1 Comments: 1). Proposed line reactor size 25 MVAR Korerhat-Meghnaghat 400 KV fine may be considered as acceptable considering that mote than 1.04 PU switching end voltage can be used at Methnaghat end, 2) Report along with associated result shall be updated considering the Meghna ghat 400 KV and Modunaghat 400 KW line reactor and associated in NGR size communicated vide PGCB letter no: 2721" 2604.436.14 604.2023,3573; dated-07.05,2023 3) Shifting of 50 MVAR line reator (Proposed by consultant) from Modunaghst 400 ky to Korethat 400K may tot be possible in current situation due to contractual warranty issue associated with separate Modunaghat 400/230 KY substation contract under another PGCB projet. 4) Final PSCAD model shall be handover directly © PGCB. All the component parameter shell be accessible and editable inthe new model. 5)_A point wise reply of PGCB and consultant comment shall be enclosed as annexure in the final report 6) All the input data (system data, line, and tower data from PGCB and switchgeariequipment data from ofiginal equipment manufacturers or standard/typical value) shall be atached as annexures with the study report for reference 7) Complete network scenatio is not included inthe report though an Appendix reference is mentioned in Hem 2.3.1 8) Transformer no load loss is mentioned 0.0002884pu whereas the approved no load loss i 0.000186pu in Page 22. 9) Transformer saturation is shown disabled in study report (page 22). Please 10) In page 18, 48, $6, 60, 73 a series of simulation is mentioned but exact simulation number is not mentioned as per contrac. 11) In page 65 the voltage dip is 1.0pu please explain how to recover ths voltage dip. 12) In page 68, the minimal load recommendation is given for ferroresonance but the percentage of load has not been ‘recommended through simulation for safe operation, 13) From Page 73: Figure 44 itis found that for reclosing .085(0.15s-.1s) dead time consider. But generally Breaker duty 3 Second (Cycle 0-0,3SEC-CO-3MIN-CO), Please include CB actual dead time for TRAPPED CHARGE PHENOMENA in the report and simulation 14) In page 91, secondary are curent is mentioned 22.6,Arms. As per IEEE secondary are currents Fup to about 20A mms allow reclosing in about one second. Explanation is requited. 15) In page 123, DS and Circuit Breaker capacitance is ignored which needs clarification. This Substation has longer GiS duct in bay side and this capacitance ignore in the study. Please include this inthe report and simulation with caleulaton 16) Please include a table of available BIL. Reserve Margin according to IEC /contract forall equipment (Ci Transformer, DS, ES, CT, PT, Shunt reacior ee) showing all equipment has BIL Reserve Margin within range 17) CT, VT saturation shall be simulated and added in report and adequate dta shal beaded in executive summary (er! goo 4 ({"" Page 2 of 2 Our Ret: 272.0000 410.48.0023.1456 ete August 23,2028