Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crystalloid For The Management of Burn Shock
Crystalloid For The Management of Burn Shock
Category: Burn
It is well know that the early management of major burns improves survival.1-
3.Immediate burn care involves airway management and fluid resuscitation, the most
important period being the first few hours after the burn injury. The resuscitation of major
burns involves the administration of large volumes of fluids calculated on the basis of
burn surface area and body weight, and different burn centers use different formula
depending on their own clinical experiences .
TABLE No: 01
Parkland formula for burns resuscitation
DURATION OF STUDY: This study carried out for a period of 1 year from Feb 2006 to
Jan 2007.
PATIENTS & METHODS: The study comprised 150 (50 children and 100 adults) burn
patients admitted to the Burn Unit of Liaquat University of Medical & Health Sciences
Jamshoro (Pakistan) with burns exceeding 10 % total body surface area (TBSA); whether
Flame burn or Scalds.
Exclusion criteria
Fluid regimens.
Total body Surface area burn is calculated using Lund & Browder Charts 18. The body
weight is assessed using a weighbridge. The I/v line maintained with 18 gauge I/V
cannula & an indwelling Foley’s catheter passed .The first 48 post-burn hours are
divided into six 4-hour periods in order to facilitate the nursing routine and eliminate
possible complications arising from the large volumes of fluid infused. Then the amount
of fluid to be infused over first 24 hours is calculated according to PARKLAND’S
FORMULA (4 ml/Kg/% TBSA), and subsequently adjusted to maintain optimum urine
output (1.5ml/Kg/Hour in children and 1 ml/Kg/Hour 17 or 50-100 ml/Hour in adult 19). The
higher limit of the urine output was chosen due to previous experience of high
incidence of acute renal failure. The 50% of calculated amount infused within 8 hours
and the other 50% in next 16 hours as shown in table No 2.
Due to the time limited nature of the changes in capillary permeability, the aim after
the first 24 hours post burn is to expend the intravascular volume and provision of daily
maintenance fluids plus any losses ( for e.g. vomiting, nasosgastric aspiration). For the
next 24 hours; with aim to expend the intravascular volume we infuse artificial colloid
HAEMACCEL® 0.5 ml/Kg/% BSA plus 1ml/Kg/% Burn of 5% D/S for adults and 5% D/W in
0.45 Saline for Children. It has recently been shown that HAEMACCEL® can safely be
use even in neonates 20. The calculated amount of Inj: HAEMACCEL® infused in first 8
hours and the maintenance fluids over the next 16 hours as shown in table No 3.
1st 24 Hours
TABLE No: 02
Total Fluid Calculated according to PARKLAND FORMULA and adjusted according to Urine output.
Fluid use Inj: Ringer’s Lactate only.
riod
TABLE No: 03
2nd 24 Hours
Total fluid Calculated, 0.5 ml/Kg/ % BSA for Artificial colloid &
6th Period
12.5%
INJ: HAEMACCEL INJ: 5% Dextrosaline for Adults &
Adequacy of resuscitation
Various parameters are suggested, but many are simply of academic interest and did
not provide practical benefits to patients and therefore we choose fallowing
parameters;
Pulse rate.
Mean arterial pressure.
Urine output 1ml/Kg/hour (0r 50 -100 ml/Hour) in adults and 1.5 ml/Kg/Hour
in children weighing up to 30 Kg; reading taken every 4 hourly; However in
children weighing above 30 Kg the urine output was maintain at adult
level 21.
Haematocrit; estimated on admission and every 6 hourly for 48 hours, and
then daily for next 5 days.
The studied variables were evaluated on admission of the patients, and were
considered the pre-infusion values. Thereafter these variables were re-evaluated 6, 12,
and 24 h after initiation of fluid therapy.
Death within the first week of admission is considered to be the failure of resuscitation12.
Hypothesis: The Parkland formula suited for all age group presenting with different major
burn in our climatic conditions.
Alternate Hypothesis: The Parkland formula in not adequate for all patients
Alternate Hypothesis: The parkland formula is more then adequate for some patients.
Statistical analysis .
Data were presented as means and Percent. The statistical analysis of demographic
data (age, sex distribution, TBSA, percentage burned TBSA) was performed using one-
factor analysis of variance. Different groups were compared for changes occurring in
the studied variables using the two-tailed t-test and within group paired t-test was used.
The level of significance was set at a p value <0.05. Computations were performed
using the statistical software package Minitab ® 15 of Minitab Inc.
The mean body surface area involved was 30.37% (ranges from11.5% to 63.5%).
The mean age of 100 adult patients was 29.20 years (ranges13 to 65 years).58 males
(58%) & 42(42%) females. Their mean body weight was 62.240 Kg (ranges between 34 to
82 Kg). The mean body surface area involved was 47.33 % (min15.5 & max 96%). The
male to female ratio is shown in chart No 01.
CHART No: 01
SEX RATIO
ADULT BURN PATIENTS
PAEDRITICS BURN PATIENTS
26.0%
42.0%
58.0%
74.0%
Due to wide variations in BSA affected , fluid calculated and amount actually infused,
data will be consider in accordance with the %BSA affected. The P-value was set at
0.05 with alternate hypothesis that fluid infused and fluid calculated are not equal.
In practice, to get the urine output of 1.5 ml/Kg/Hour or more; for peads patients the
fluid infused was much greater then that calculated. The mean amount infused during
first 24 hrs was 4153 ml (min 940ml & max10530ml) was in quite contrast to that
calculated; (Mean 3386ml min 612ml & max10032ml) as can be seen from table No 4.
The highest fluid requirement is seen in pts presented with 11-20% ( approx 55.45% more
fluid) while for others group it was 43.70% more for 21-30%; Approx 31.20 % more for 31-
40% ,about 13.98% for 41-50% and approx 7.90% for 51-60%. While for 61-70% we
observe about 9.01% reduction. The p-value for different groups was also significant.
TABLE No: 04
Total 50
For adult patients mean fluid infused was 10553 ml ranging from 3295 ml to 15245 ml in
contrast to mean fluid calculated 12110 ml ranging from 2312 ml to 30176 ml as shown
in table No 5. Again the fluid requirement for patients with 11-20% burn was highest
(41.52% more then the calculated fluid), for 21-30% it was 32.97%; for 31-40% it was
19.31%; for 41-50% it was 9.26% additional fluid. On the other hand for more then 50%
BSA burn we notice that infused fluid was less then the calculated fluid. For 51-60% BSA
we found 3.6% reduction; for 61-70% BSA it was 17.20%; for 71-80% it was 30.27%; for 81-
90% BSA it was 43.20% and for 91-100% burn fluid requirement was least (55.19% less then
the calculated fluid).
TABLE No 05
100
Early Mortality:
As a general census the death during first week of admission is consider to be the failure
of resuscitation, though the death may apparently be due to other causes. During first
week of admission, in our series 23(15.34%) patients expired; as shown in table No 6.
TABLE No: 06
Cerebrovascular 1 - - 1 67.0% 62
accident
Aspiration - - 1 1 18% 1
pneumonia
Total 6 2 8 7 23
The most common cause of death was cardiopulmonary arrest (34.78%) fallowed by
respiratory failure due to inhalation injury (21.74%) and the multiple organ failure
(21.74%). The other causes were acute renal failure in 3 cases (13.05%), aspiration
pneumonia in 1 case (4.35%) and cerebrovascular accident (4.35%) in 1 case as seen in
chart No 2.
CHART No: 2
CAUSES OF DEATH
ADULT & CHILDREN
Cause of Death
Acute Renal Fialure
3, 13.0% Cerebrovascular Accidents
Cardiopulmonary Arrest
5, 21.7%
Severe Inhalation Injury
1, 4.3% Aspiration Pneumonia
M ultiple Organ Failure
1, 4.3%
8, 34.8%
5, 21.7%
1: Urine output.
For our peads patients; the urine output was maintained at or greater then
1.5ml/Kg/Hour, while for patients above 30 Kg it was maintain according to the adult
patients. Mean urine output for first 24 hours after admission was 1.52 ranging from 1.32
to 1.58 ml/Kg/Hr, while mean urine output for next 24 hours was 1.5 ml/Kg/Hr.
For adult patients the mean urine output during first 24 hrs was 69.360
Ml/Hr (mean body weight was 62.240 Kg) and for the next 24 hours it was 69.670 ml/Hr.
2: Heamatocrit.
For group 1 pts the mean for 1st 24 hours was 47.520 (Min42-Max52) while for next 24 hrs
it was 42.520 (Min 40- Max 46). For group 2 pts the mean Hct for first 24 hours was 59.030
(Min 44.00 Max 78.00) while for the next 24 hours it was 49.140 (Min 38.0 Max
54.0)
3: Serum Potassium.
The serial measurement of serum K+ performed for each patient of both group. Mean
serum potassium for peads patients during 1st 24 hours was 5.4 mEq/L while for next 24
hours it was 4.3 mEq/L; and for adult patients it was 6.1 mEq/L and 4.7 mEq/L, resp.
4: Pulse rate.
Pulse rate was monitor regularly during the entire period of resuscitation every 4 hour
and was almost the mirror image of the urine output i.e. as the urine output gradually
improves the pulse returns to normal. In 70% cases it was after completion of the 1st
phase (within 08 hours) of resuscitation, when 50% of the calculated fluid has infused.
While considering the adequacy of parkland formula, the results of our study showed
that it is both inadequate and more then adequate. The fluid practically infused to
patients having BSA affected less then 50% in adult and less then 60% BSA in children
was much greater then the fluid calculated based on parkland formula. Mean fluid
infused for children was 3985 ml as compared to mean fluid calculated 3156 ml, Paired
t-test P=0.000 , while mean fluid infused for adult patients 8602 versus mean fluid
calculated 6978 ml, P=0.000. However we observed mirror image in patients presented
with burn involving more then 50% BSA in children and more then 60% BSA in children.
The mean fluid infused to adult was 13036 ml versus 18641 ml calculated fluid P = 0.000;
for children mean fluid infused was 8175 versus 8921 ml calculated amount P= 0.171. It is
very difficult to give a simple explanation of the above finding as probably various
factors are operative.
On the average we observed 0.045ml increment for every % burn when BSA affected
was less then 50% & 60% in adult and Children respectively. Similarly decrement of 0.042
ml for every % burn noted for Burn involving more then 50% & 60% BSA in adult and
children respectively.
However when analyzing decresed fluid requairments when BSA affected was more
then 50% & 60% in adult & children respectively, the only possible explanation cuold be
that; as the BSA affected is incresed the ratio of deep to superficial burn steaadily
increasd and as a matter of fact superficial burn are always more exudative as
compared to deep burn.
Of the parameters evaluationg the efficacy of the crystalloid to manage acute burn
shock, the result of this study showed that despite the large load of Na+, K+, and the
serum potassium level that showed moderate increase during the first 24 hours returns
well within the normal limit over the next 24 hours in both groups.
The urine output showed a small, insignificant increased after the first 24 hours; probably
due to the infusuion of colloid.
The heamotocrit remained at high levels, despite the administration of large fluid
volumes throughout the first 24 hours; it showed steady reduction after the
administration of artificial colloid and maintenance fluid at the beginning of the second
24 hours.
When comparing crystalloid with albumin with respect to mortality, the current census is
that the use of albumin does not reduce the risk of death, instead it may be associated
with an increased risk 24, 25. The cost of management when resuscitation done with
albumin also increases tremendously without any added advantage. The result of this
study also favors the same finding when overall mortality of this series {15.34% (23/150} is
compare with those where albumin/HPPF was use as resuscitative fluid with invasive
monitoring, 26, and 27,,28,29,30,31.
The most common complication associated with infusion of such large amount of
crystalloid , like pulmonary edema, heart failure, compartmental syndrome were not
seen in any of our patients.
The causes of death; within 1st week of admission; reflecting failure of the resuscitation;
in this series was cardio-pulmonary arrest (34.78%) fallowed next by severe inhalation
injury and multiple organ failure (21.74% each). The acute renal failure was the terminal
event in 3 cases (13.04%), while 1 patient expired due to inhalation pneumonia and 1
case developed accelerated hypertension on 4th post burn day ;without past history of
hypertension; leading to cerebrovascular accident that lead to his death. When
considering each death at its own in view of haemodynamic derangement in major
burn then only 08 deaths (5 due to multiple organ failure and 3 due to acute renal
failure) can directly be attributed to failure of resuscitation.
Conclusion:
We conclude that the Parkland formula should always be consider just a starting point
and the amount required to resuscitate must always be individualized. Urine output
should always be maintain at upper limit i.e. aim should be to have ADEQUATE output
rather then SUFFICIENT. The results we achieved with crystalloid are in no way inferior to
those centers where human albumin/colloids are use for resuscitation.
REFRENCES:
1: Jackson DM. Burns: McIndoe's contribution and subsequent advances. Ann R Coll Surg
Engl 1979; 61:335–40.
2: Danaf AE. Burn variables influencing survival: a study of 144 patients. Burns 1995; 21:517–
20.
3: Fratianne RB, Brandt CP. Improved survival of adults with extensive burns. J Burn Care
Rehabil 1997; 18:347–51.
4: Pruitt B.A., jr: Advances in fluid therapy and early care of the burn patient. World J. Surg.,
2: 139-48, 1978.
5: Sneve H.: The treatment of burns and skin grafting. JAMA, 45: 1, 1905
8: Cope O., Moore F.D.: The distribution of body water in the fluid therapy of burned
patient. Ann. Surg., 126: 1013, 1947.
9: Evans E.I., Purnell, O.J., Robinett P.W., Batchelor A., Martin M.: Fluid and electrolyte
requirements in severe burns. Ann. Surg., 135: 804-17, 1952.
10: Moyer C.A., Margraft H.W., Monafo W.W. Jr.: Bum Shock in Association with Extravascular
Sodium Deficiency: A Report on the Treatment with Ringer's Solution with Lactate. Arch.
Surg. 90: 799, 1965.
11: Baxter C.: Guidelines for Fluid Resuscitation. J. Trauma 21: 687, 1981.
12: Baxter C.R., Shires G.I.: Physiologic response to crystalloid resuscitation of severe burns.
Ann. New York. Acad. Sci., 150: 874-94, 1968.
13. Baxter C. Fluid volume and electrolyte changes of the early postburn period. Clin Plast
Surg. 1974;1:693–709.
14. Baxter C. Fluid resuscitation, burn percentage, and physiologic age. J Trauma.
1979;19(suppl 11):864–865.
15. Baxter C, Shires T. Physiologic response to crystalloid resuscitation in severe burns. Ann NY
Acad Sci. 1968;150:874–893.
17: Shehan Hettiaratchy, Remo Papini ; ABC of burns BMJ. 2004 July 10; 329(7457): 101–103.
18 : Lund CC, Browder NC. Estimation of areas of burns. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1944;79:352–8.
19: Mcdougal, W. scott; Slade, C. Lawrence and Pruitt, Basil A., JR.
―Manual of Burns‖ NY, Heidelberg and Berlin, Springer-Verlag. 1978, First Edition. (ISBN:
0387903194).
20: P.A. Stoddart; A comparison of 4.5% human albumin solution and Haemaccel in
neonates undergoing major surgery. Pediatric Anesthesia 6 (2), 103–106.)
21: Glenn D. Warden; Burn shock resuscitation; World Journal of Surgery. 1992, 16:1; 16-23
www.weather.gov.hk
25: Human albumin administration in critically ill patients: systematic review of randomized
controlled trials. Cochrane Injuries Group, Department of Epidemiology and Public
Health, Institute of Child Health, London WC1N 1EH; BMJ. 1998 July 25; 317(7153): 235–240.
27: Stassen,-N-A; Lukan,-J-K; etal Thermal injury in the elderly: when is comfort the right
choice? Am-Surg. 2001 Jul(7): 704-8
29: Lari,-A-R; Alaghehbandan,-R; Nikui,-R Epidemiological study of 3341 burns patients during
three years in Tehran, Iran Burns. 2000 Feb; 26(1) 49-53