Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Marginal Vs Absorption Review Questions
Marginal Vs Absorption Review Questions
per unit $
Selling price 45
Direct materials 11
Direct Labour 8
Production overhead;
Variable 4
Fixed 3
Selling overhead;
Variable 5
Fixed 2
Administration overhead;
Fixed 3
Fixed overhead costs are based on normal annual activity level of 96,000 units. These
costs are expected to be incurred at a constant rate throughout the year.
Required:
(a) Prepare in columnar format, profit statements for each of the two months of
January and February 2015 using:
(1) Absorption costing
(2) Marginal costing
(b) Reconcile and explain the reasons for any differences between the marginal and absorption
profits for each month which you have calculated in (a) above.
(c) Based upon marginal costs, calculate:
(i) The annual break-even sales value
(ii) The activity level, in units, which will yield an annual profit of USD 122,800
(d) Explain three fundamental assumptions underpinning single product breakeven
analysis
REQUIRED:
(a) (i) Calculate the fixed overhead absorption rate per unit for the last quarter, and present profit
statements using (First In, First Out using:
(ii) Absorption costing;
(iii) Marginal costing; and
(iv) Reconcile and explain the difference between the profits or losses. (12 marks)
(b) Using the same data, present similar statements to those requited in part (a). Using the AVECO
(average cost) method of valuation, reconcile the profit or loss figures, and comment briefly on
the variations between the profits or losses in (a) and (b). (8 marks) (Total 20 marks)
The outcome for 2012 was a loss of £70 000 and the management believed that a major cause of
this loss was the low overhead an costing, absorption rate which had led the company to quote
selling prices which were uneconomic.
For 2013 the overhead absorption rate was increased of £3.60 per direct labour hour and selling
prices were raised in line with the monthly loss for established pricing procedures; which involve
adding a profit mark-up of 50 per cent onto the full factory cost of the company’s products. The
new selling prices were also charged on the stock of finished goods held at the beginning of 2013.
In December 2013 the company’s accountant prepares an estimated Profit and Loss Account for
2013 and a budgeted Profit and Loss Account for 2014. Although sales were considered to be
depressed in 2012, they were even lower in 2013 but, nevertheless, it seems that the company will
make a profit for that year. A worrying feature of the estimated accounts is the high level of
finished goods stock held and the 2014 budget provides for a reduction in the stock level at 31
December 2014 so the (physical) level existing in January 2012. Budgeted sales for 2014 are set
at the 2013 sales level.
The summarized profit statements for the three years to 31 December 2014 are as follows:
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 2
PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT (B5) COVENANT FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS LIMITED
(a) You are required to write a short report to the board of Miozip explaining why the budgeted
outcome for 2014 is so different from that of 2013 when the sales revenue is the same for both
years. (6 marks)
(b) Restate the profit and loss account for 2012, the estimated profit and loss account for 2013
and the budgeted profit and loss account for 2014 using marginal factory cost for stock
valuation purposes. (8 marks)
(c) Comment on rise problems which may follow from a decision to increase the overhead
absorption rate in conditions when cost plus pricing is used and overhead is currently under-
absorbed. (3 marks)
(d) Explain why the majority of businesses use full costing systems whilst most management
accounting theorists favour marginal costing. (5 marks)
NB: Assume in your answers to this question that the value of the pound and the efficiency of the
company have been constant over the period under review. (Total 22 marks)
(i) Opening stock at the beginning of the operating period consisted of 25,000 finished units, and
5,000 units in process that were 100% complete with respect to raw materials, and 20%
complete with respect to conversion.
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 3
PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT (B5) COVENANT FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS LIMITED
(ii) During the operating period ended the company introduced and transferred out 230,000 units
to the warehouse. In the same period, the company sold 210,000 units each at Tshs 4200. The
expenditure in the period, didn’t differ from the expectations expect for reasons of operating
volume change. The company targeted to produce and sale 240,000 units.
Tshs
Unit direct materials cost 500
Unit direct labour cost 600
Unit variable factory overhead cost 400
Annual fixed factory cost 98,000,000
Annual fixed administration cost 250,000,000
Annual fixed distribution cost 100,000,000
Required:
(a) Indicate the equivalent production units to which overhead was applied in the period ended.
(4 Marks)
(b) Prepare two Statement of Income, one based on variable costing and another based on
absorption costing ( 8 marks)
(c) Reconcile the income’s difference. (8 marks)
Maravanda Company
Income statement for the month of May 2013 ( Shs)
Sales 60,000,000
Less: Variable Cost of goods sold 30,000,000
Contribution Margin 30,000,000
Less: Fixed Manufacturing costs at budget (15,000,000)
Gross Margin 15,000,000
Less: Fixed Selling and Administrative Expenses (10,000,000)
Net Income before taxes 5,000,000
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 4
PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT (B5) COVENANT FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS LIMITED
(iii) The unit fixed manufacturing overhead is based upon a normal monthly production of 15,000
units
(iv) Variable costs per unit have been stable throughout the year.
(v) Production for May 2013 was 4,500 units in excess of sales
(vi) The inventory at May 30th 2013 consisted of 8,000 units
Being the first time, the General Manager was presented with an Income statement prepared on a
direct costing basis; he was very comfortable with the results and kept on wondering what the net
income would have been under the absorption costing basis.
REQUIRED
(i) Present the May 2013 income statement on an absorption costing basis
(ii) Reconcile and explain the differences in net income between the two costing bases.
DUDUMIZA CO. INCOME STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED MARCH 31,2012
Tshs Tshs
Sales 240,000,000
Less cost of sales (not 1)
Opening stick costs 18,000,000
Add production costs 124,000,000
Available for sale 142,000,000
Closing stock 22,000,0000
Cost of sale -120,000,000
Gross profit 120,000,000
Administration expenses 40,000,000
Marketing expenses (note 2) 42,000,000 -82,000,000
Note 1: Prices for factory inputs have remained stable as was anticipated. Unit costs were as
follows:
Tshs
Unit variable costs: 220
Unit fixed overhead (at 300,000 units) 180
Total product cost 400
Note 2: A greater part of marketing cost was fixed with the exception of sales commission equal to 4% of sale v
and this is part of total marketing costs.
The report was to be used by Management in order to assess the operating outcome for the period
ended. All members of management team with the exception of the Finance Manager accepted the
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 5
PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT (B5) COVENANT FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS LIMITED
financial statement. The Finance Manager was dismayed by an omission in the report, which
rendered it to be inaccurate. This was besides the fact that it was not based on variable costing.
In the course of planning production budget for the period ended, the company did not anticipated
changes in inventory levels.
REQUIRED:
(a) Point out the omission in the report and indicate its implication. (4marks)
(b) Prepare a similar income statement which is free from the error that the Finance Manager had
in mind. (7marks)
(c) Use a Cost – Volume - Profit model to establish the profit that the business targeted to earn
in the year ended. (3 marks)
(d) Reconcile the difference between the income statement you have just prepare in requirement
(b) above and the income that the business planned to earn. (Total 22 marks)
300 200
240 160
GROSS PROFIT
Production overhead:
(over)/under absorption (12) 12
Selling cost 50 50
Distribution cost 45 40
Administration cost 80 163 80 182
NET PROFIT/LOSS 77 (22)
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 6
PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT (B5) COVENANT FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS LIMITED
The members of the management team are concerned by the significant change in
profitability between the two six-month periods. .As a management accountant, you
have analyzed the data upon which the above budget statement has been produced, with
the following results;
1. The production overhead cost comprises both fixed and variable element,the
latter appears to be dependent on the number of units produced .The fixed
element of the cost is expected to be incurred at constant rate throughout the
year.
2. The selling cost are fixed
3. The distribution comprises both fixed and variable elements,the latter appears to
be dependent on the number of units sold.The fixed element of the cost is expected
to be incurred at a constant rate throughout the year.
4. The administration costs are fixed
REQUIRED:
(a) Present the above budgeted profit statement in marginal costing format
(b) Reconcile EACH of the six-monthly profit/loss values reported respectively under
marginal and absorption costing.
(c) Reconcile the six-monthly profit for January to June from the absorption costing
statement with the six-monthly loss for July to December from the absorption
costing statement.
(d) Calculate the annual number of units required to break even.
(e) Explain briefly the advantages of using marginal costing as the basis of providing
managers with information for decision making.
Prepared By: Godson Mkaro (Jr): MSc Finance & Investment, BSc. Computer Science, ATEC II, CPBE, CPA (T),
& Goodhope Mkaro (Sr): MBA(Finance), BCOM Acc(Hons), PGD in Tax Management, CPB, CISI(UK), CPA (T)
Phone: +255 717 / 769 348 616 | Email: info@covenantfinco.com |Website: www.covenantfinco.com Page | 7