Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Counselling People On The Autism Spectrum 1656426040
Counselling People On The Autism Spectrum 1656426040
Counselling People On The Autism Spectrum 1656426040
of related interest
The Complete Guide to Asperger’s Syndrome
Tony Attwood
ISBN 978 1 84310 495 7
An Asperger Marriage
Gisela and Christopher Slater-Walker
Foreword by Tony Attwood
ISBN 978 1 84310 017 1
How to Find Work that Works for People with Asperger Syndrome
The Ultimate Guide for Getting People with Asperger Syndrome into the Workplace
(and keeping them there!)
Gail Hawkins
ISBN 978 1 84310 151 2
www.jkp.com
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any material form (including
photocopying or storing it in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or
incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright owner
except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the
terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London,
England W1T 4LP. Applications for the copyright owner’s written permission to reproduce any part of
this publication should be addressed to the publisher.
Warning: The doing of an unauthorised act in relation to a copyright work may result in both a civil
claim for damages and criminal prosecution.
Acknowledgments 9
Introduction 11
Why a counselling manual for people on the autism spectrum? 13
Organization of the manual 16
1. Autism: An Overview 21
History of autism and theoretical paradigms 21
Characteristics and implications of autism, Asperger’s,
and PDD-NOS 29
Autism and comorbidity 45
References 189
List of Figures
3.1 Thoughts, feelings, and actions diagram 80
3.2 Emotional thermometer 81
3.3 Example of a response quality scale 82
3.4 Thoughts, feelings, and actions mobile 86
3.5 Worksheet of helpful and not so helpful thoughts 89
3.6 Examples of visual reframing 92
3.7 Sample of a choice and possible consequence chart 94
3.8 Sample self-monitoring checklist 101
4.1 Positive thoughts game scorecard 110
7.1 Stages of stress 168
Acknowledgments
9
Introduction
11
12 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
not reach the same stage of development at the age of the onset of
adulthood as that of your more typical peers.
The prevalence of persons on the autism spectrum has been estimated
as being 0.5 per cent (Rutter 2005), and these numbers are increasing
(Samuels 2005). What is left unsaid is that these individuals will grow
into adults who will continue to be members of mainstream communities,
may find employment, and may begin families of their own. There is a
growing body of literature that suggests that persons on the spectrum
struggle with issues of anxiety and depression (Ghaziuddin, Weidmer-
Mikhail and Ghaziuddin 1998; Lainhart 1999; Prestwood 1999). In
addition, those with mental retardation are at a higher risk for physical,
emotional, and sexual abuse that will require counselling services (Cutler
2001). It is likely that many therapists and counselling professionals will
encounter persons on the spectrum throughout their career, particularly
as children become fully participating adults in mainstream communities.
It is this writer’s goal that this manual will provide tools for working with
the emotional needs of these individuals.
Currently, persons on the autism spectrum may be underrepresented
as clients in the counselling profession, although they do seek profes-
sional help (Aston 2003; Attwood 1998; Hare and Paine 1997; Jacobsen
2003; Meyer 1999). They are also underrepresented in the psychother-
apy and counselling literature (Stoddart 1999), though notably present in
the behavioural therapy literature. Perhaps the paucity of information can
be attributed to professional perception of this population as having little
to no emotion, as well as challenges stemming from aspects of
symptomology of the autism spectrum, and the use of behavioural
measures as diagnostic criteria (APA 1994). Behavioural approaches have
been primarily used as treatment approaches in autism to address the core
areas of deficit and behavioural issues. Behavioural approaches are seen as
the technology of choice when working with autism spectrum disorders
(Fombonne 2003; Green 1996; Rogers 1998a; Smith 1996).
While behavioural interventions have been at the forefront of treat-
ments for individuals with ASD, the emotional issues of these persons
have not been given much attention (Stoddart 1999).
Introduction 15
There are always emotional issues with which the children with
serious impairments struggle. Without a high level of staff training
in development (normal and disordered) and clinical work,
emotional issues may be easily missed and, therefore, not addressed.
(Ruberman 2002, p.265)
1998; Jones, Zahl and Huws 2001; Ruberman 2002). Yet people on the
autism spectrum have higher rates of depression and anxiety than people
who are not on the spectrum (Ghaziuddin et al. 1998; Lainhart 1999).
Counsellors and clinicians may find that their talking and insight-
oriented therapies may not be effective with these clients (Jacobsen
2003), but may not find other interventions that are better suited for
working with them. The intent of this manual is to fill that gap and
provide counsellors and clinicians with the tools and strategies to work
with people on the autism spectrum in ways that can effectively address
the emotional, relational, and cognitive issues that they bring to the
counselling session.
into the mind of someone on the autism spectrum, and to begin to under-
stand why they are so confusing to people not on the spectrum.
The remaining chapters comprise the Part Two of this manual, and
discuss specific issues and empirically supported treatments. Adaptations
of general counselling strategies are covered in Chapter 3. This is where
general counselling modifications and strategies are discussed. Chapters
4 through 8 focus on specific issues and their relevant counselling strate-
gies and modifications.
Chapter 4 discusses depression and modified counselling strategies
as relating to an individual on the autism spectrum. Chapter 5 explores
anxiety and obsessive-compulsive issues; counselling strategies modified
to work with individuals who have autism spectrum disorders are
presented. Included in this chapter are modifications to address autistic
perseveration. Chapter 6 explores the social arena in more depth. Social
difficulties and the implications of difficulty with social interaction are
explored, including interpersonal relations and employment social skills.
Social skill development and social strategies are examined. Chapter 7
addresses stress reduction, including modifications for stress reduction
strategies for individuals with ASD. Chapter 8 concludes with counsel-
ling techniques and strategies to address emotional regulation.
Chapter 9 concludes the manual with some quick rules of thumb
about working with people with autism spectrum disorders.
Part One: Understanding
Autism – Autism Spectrum
Characterisitics and
Cognitive Patterns
CHAPTER 1
Autism: An Overview
21
22 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
key areas to improve the quality of life of both children and adults on the
autism spectrum.
There is little doubt that behavioural interventions are effective
(Green 1996; Rogers 1998a, 1998b). The main issues with behavioural
technologies are that they are powerful tools of compliance (Lovett
1997) and have sometimes been described as an approach that treats the
symptom and not the person. Cognitive and emotional issues that may be
“driving the behaviour” (Renna 2004, p.18) are seldom addressed by
behavioural interventions.
Aspects of thinking and feeling were often left unexplored, despite
the fact that people with autism spectrum disorders have difficulties with
understanding their environment and with emotional regulation. Under-
standing the reasoning or purpose behind a behavioural request may be
left unexplored, or may be meaningless to someone with ASD. Thus, the
request generates confusion. Why would someone do a meaningless
thing? Enhancing meaning and understanding combined with behav-
ioural change forms the basis of the cognitive behavioural approach.
Attribution of meaning to a situation will affect behaviour (Attwood
1998).
Behavioural approaches may prove to be ineffective with some of the
higher functioning people with ASD, as antecedent and consequence
management may not address the ASD individual’s perception or inter-
pretation of the situation. For many high functioning people, reinforce-
ment and consequence driven behavioural approaches will be resisted as
they may perceive the treatment “as being forced on them” (Heflin and
Simpson 1998, p.200). However, once a practical understanding is
reached regarding the reason for change, people on the autism spectrum
are often more amenable if the meaning makes sense to them, and they
can see the utility of changing their behaviour (Aston 2003).
Aetiology
The aetiology of autism is complex. There are genetic factors that appear
to cause autism, and environmental insults that can also lead to autism.
For a small percentage of people, no cause has been identified (Rutter
2005). Autism is usually diagnosed during childhood, although it is not
uncommon for people who have high functioning autism (HFA) or
Autism: An Overview 25
Non-genetic factors
Several non-genetic factors appear to play a role in the aetiology of
autism, including the use of prescribed drugs such as thalidomide or
valproic acid use during pregnancy. Recreational drug or alcohol use
during pregnancy seems to enhance the risk of the fetus developing
autism. Also, there seems to be an established link between congenital
rubella and autism. Research has not proved that thermisol, a mercury-
based component of the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccina-
tion, leads to autism, despite the controversy, although there is some
speculation that children who become autistic after the MMR vaccine
may be more sensitive to toxins such as mercury. To date, however, no
conclusive link has been found (Rutter 2005).
Genetic inheritance
Twin studies have shown a rate of 60 per cent of twins both having
autism when the twins are identical. This is compared to a 5 per cent rate
of fraternal twins. When examining identical twins where only one has
autism, the rate of the other twin being somewhere on the milder side of
the spectrum is much higher than the rate of fraternal twins, showing
strong heritability: “Taken together with the population base rate for
autism, this implies that the heritability or underlying genetic liability is
about 90% – the highest figure among all multifactorial child psychiatric
disorders” (Rutter 2005, p.232). Families with one member diagnosed on
the autism spectrum report a 6 per cent rate of autism, much higher than
the 0.5 per cent rate in the general population. There are between 3 and
12 susceptibility genes for autism that act in a synergistic manner that
produces the variation of the autism spectrum (Rutter 2005).
Neurological differences
The ability of modern technology to unlock the mysteries of the brain has
shown that there are several differences in the brains of those who are on
the autism spectrum, as compared with those who are normal. Magnetic
26 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
resonance imaging (MRI) studies indicate that people with autism tend to
have larger brains overall, larger cerebellar hemispheres, parieto-
temporal lobes, and amygdala, with a reduced corpus callosum
(Brambilla et al. 2003). The limbic system, the seat of emotion, is reported
to be impaired (Rogers 1998b).
People on the autism spectrum do not use the fusiform face gyrus, the
area of the brain that is associated with facial recognition, when looking
at and identifying faces (Schultz 2005). Schultz suspects that the differ-
ences in facial processing may explain the difficulties in recognizing
facial emotions. It may also explain why people on the autism spectrum
may not acknowledge friends and acquaintances when they pass them on
the street or in the hall.
Cerebellum abnormalities are suspected as contributors to the behav-
ioural and cognitive phenotype of autism. The cerebellum is crucial in
learning motor sequencing and adaptation learning, and may explain
why people on the autism spectrum do not accommodate well to change
(Mostofsky, Goldberg, Landa and Denckla 2000).
There appears to be a hemisphere reversal of the brain areas that are
involved in language listening, from the normal left hemisphere to the
right hemisphere in autism. Left dominance for language is found in less
than 5 per cent of right-handed individuals with autism, and in more
than 95 per cent of right-handed people who are not on the autism
spectrum (Muller et al. 1999). As Euro-American educational systems
highly value verbal learning, people on the autism spectrum who have
clear brain abnormalities regarding language are at a disadvantage.
Nonverbal auditory patterns are also unusual, with reduced bilateral
superior temporal and cerebellar activities, and unusual activation of the
left anterior cyngulate gyrus. This demonstrates that the difficulty with
interpreting nonverbal communication lies in the difference in brain
physiology. The anterior cingulated gyrus is normally implicated in
cognitive-attentional and emotional functions, and could be related to
auditory hypersensitivity found in autism (Muller et al. 1999).
Müller, Cauich, Rubio, Mizuno and Courchesne (2004) reported
abnormal motor organization, with diffuse cerebral activation, instead of
the more focused normal activation in the ipsilateral anterior cerebellum.
Activation patterns for simple motor patterns showed a higher scatter
Autism: An Overview 27
than that found in the control sample. People on the autism spectrum
often have difficulty with motor planning, which can be attributed to
these differences.
People who have autism tend towards having higher brain volume
than that of the normal population. This increase is not present at birth,
but brain volume increases after the age of two. This suggests that the
normal neural pruning which occurs during childhood does not occur in
the usual fashion for those who are on the autism spectrum. In contrast,
the corpus callosum, which is the brain structure that provides the com-
munication pathway between the two hemispheres, specifically the
posterior midsagittal corpus callosum, appears smaller, suggesting that
information may not travel between hemispheres as rapidly as in the
normal population (Palmen and van Engeland 2004).
Prevalence
The rate of schoolchildren diagnosed with autism has increased expo-
nentially. In the 1970s the rate of autism was less than 3 in 10,000
children, while in the 1990s the rate was about 30 in 10,000 (Blaxil
2005). The incidence of the larger autism spectrum disorders are between
30 and 60 cases per 10,000 (Rutter 2005), making autism spectrum
disorders “more prevalent in the pediatric population than cancer,
diabetes, spina bifida, and Down’s syndrome” (Filipek et al. 1999, p.440).
This increase is accounted for by actual increase in numbers, as well as
better diagnostic tools and wider diagnostic criteria, encompassing the
range of the autism spectrum (Samuels 2005). There is a prevalence of
males to females of 3:1, with mental retardation occurring in about 80
per cent of the cases (Fombonne 1999). About one in five first-degree
relatives have a much milder variant of autism. Autism appears to affect all
social classes and ethnicities equally (Rutter 2005).
Aging issues
People with ASD enjoy lifespans that are comparable to their peers who
are not on the spectrum (Howlin 2000), and will encounter the loss of
significant persons in their lives, as do typical individuals. However,
people on the autism spectrum may have more difficulty adapting to the
changes. Loss of a significant other may mean changes in living arrange-
ments, routines, and all of the familiar things that enable a person with
ASD to function in mainstream society. In a sense, the person with ASD
may lose their entire familiar world with the death of a parent or signifi-
cant other (Botsford 2000). For people on the autism spectrum, these
changes can be extremely challenging and debilitating, as the people
who know best how to support the person are gone. A good example as
to how changes can be extremely challenging was demonstrated in the
movie Rainman (Molen and Levinson 1988), where Raymond had to
suddenly live with his younger brother. In the movie, simple changes like
having the wrong toothbrush upset Raymond to the point where he
could no longer cope.
People with ASD do not always express emotions in the same manner
as those who are not on the spectrum. Grieving may go unrecognized, or
may be dealt with in an unusual manner. Communication difficulties will
negatively affect the grieving process and behaviours may surface as ways
to cope with grief. Social grieving rituals may be unfamiliar to people on
the autism spectrum. For many, odd behaviours may surface, such as
Autism: An Overview 29
Characteristics of autism
Autism consists of three major areas of difficulty (see Table 1.1): commu-
nication deficits, social deficits, and stereotypical behaviour (APA 1994).
Both receptive and expressive language are affected, impacting social
language as well (Maurice 1996; Quill 1995). Stereotypical behaviour
can include behaviours such as hand flapping, twirling, pacing, and
rocking (Janzen 1996). People with autism range from those who are
severely impaired with significant mental handicaps to those who have
average or above average intelligence. The more severe forms of autism,
which include stereotypical behaviours, and more severely impaired
communication, often associated with a mental handicap, are frequently
referred to as Kanner-type autism (Filipek et al. 1999; Fombonne 1999).
Relative challenges
As mentioned earlier, receptive and expressive communication is affected
with varying degrees of impairment, with those on the higher function-
ing end of the spectrum being least affected. Most frequently receptive
language is stronger than expressive. They have difficulty with expres-
sions of speech (colloquialisms) and are very literal in their interpretation
of language (Happé 1995; Noens and van Berckelaer-Onnes 2004).
People with autism have difficulty shifting their attention. There is
difficulty in shifting attention rapidly and smoothly from one thing to
another. This rapid attention shifting is essential in social conversation,
particularly if there is more than one conversational partner involved. The
inability to switch easily from one subject or activity to another makes it
difficult for someone to transition from one activity to another. Difficulty
with switching attention impacts the ability to switch sensory modalities as
well. It may be difficult for some people on the autism spectrum to switch
between seeing and hearing, or hearing and touching, for example. Activi-
ties that involve all the senses at once can be challenging (Attwood 1998;
Tsatsanis 2004).
Autism: An Overview 33
Does not seek to share interests or Does not reciprocate emotional and
achievements with others social cues
Lack of, or delay in acquiring, spoken Impaired ability to start and uphold
language, with no attempt to use reciprocal conversation
different communication systems in its
place
Must also have delays or abnormal functioning (evident before 3 years of age) in
social interaction, communicative language, or imaginary play.
Note: Adapted from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn (APA
1994).
34 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Relative strengths
Although there are many deficits, there are some strengths that people on
the autism spectrum may have. People with autism are visual learners and
may have extraordinary visual discrimination skills, often noticing details
that most people miss. Often their visual spatial abilities are above average
Autism: An Overview 35
(Grandin 1996; Tsatsanis 2004). Some may have the ability to illustrate
what they have seen with extraordinary precision.
One study validated that children (and probably adults) on the autism
spectrum are primarily visual thinkers, and do not visualize things differ-
ently from what they have seen in real life during day-to-day doings
(Frith and Happé 1999). With this in mind, this writer would postulate
that television images may act in a similar fashion, being visualized much
in the same way as day-to-day reality, perhaps blurring the boundaries of
reality and television. Aston (2003) commented that some of her clients
appeared to be learning social skills from the television. This author
wonders how accurately people on the autism spectrum can distinguish
reality from fantasy when they have seen it on television. It has been this
writer’s experience that many people who have autism spectrum
disorders have great difficulty distinguishing between what is
Hollywood glitz and glamour, and what is more representative of
everyday life.
Recall of rote memory learning is a particular strength, and can be
used to help teach new material (Tsatsanis 2004). This strength in rote
learning makes unlearning something very difficult, and, in this writer’s
experience, near impossible. When teaching someone on the autism
spectrum, this writer recommends that the individuals are instructed in
the correct method the first time something is taught, as it will be very
difficult to change how they complete the activity at a later date.
However, it is this writer’s experience that sometimes reframing a new
way of doing things as a rule change due to growing older can be helpful.
Framing a change as a way that adults (or people over 40) are supposed to
do it can sometimes help someone with an autism spectrum disorder
accommodate to the change.
Does not seek to share interests or Does not reciprocate emotional and
achievements with others social cues
Note: Adapted from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn (APA
1994).
verbal memory. They tend towards being higher functioning and have
normal to high intelligence and may have excellent logic skills, although
the logic may be based on faulty assumptions (Aston 2003; Frith 2004;
Perlman 2000; Tsatsanis 2004).
Often people with Asperger’s develop coping strategies that can hide
the social difficulties they experience, and can present as not having any
disability. Often they can integrate socially, although they may appear
shy, aloof, awkward, overly friendly, or too talkative. It is this ability to
cope and present well that confuses parents and professionals, as well as
delaying or hindering recognition that these people require support or
help (Portway and Johnson 2003; Willey 1999).
Autism: An Overview 37
Note: Adapted from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn
(APA 1994).
Autism: An Overview 39
Communication difficulties
Communication impairments increase with the degree of autism, and
both receptive and expressive language is impaired to varying degrees.
There is a high correlation between IQ and verbal ability in autism.
Nonverbal persons on the autism spectrum are much more likely to have a
learning disability or mental retardation, and a much poorer prognosis.
By the time an ASD child has reached high school, their level of commu-
nication closely resembles the level of their future adult abilities (Noens
and van Berckelaer-Onnes 2004).
Communication differences include egocentric speech, failure to
recognize the speaker’s meaning, and pragmatic language difficulties,
such as incorrect use of pronouns and odd prosody. Often their speech
has odd intonation patterns, a droning quality, and with inappropriate
volume. Nonverbal and paraverbal cues are not understood when given
by others, and are not used in the usual fashion by the person on the
autism spectrum. They may use words in an idiosyncratic manner, but
grammar and vocabulary may be intact. Communication errors also occur
around the distinctions of giving new information and information
assumed to be known, and failure to conform to conversational rules and
turn taking. People on the autism spectrum may also ask questions to
which they already know the answer, or ask questions in an abnormal
way (Perlman 2000).
40 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
unaware that their meaning may be different from the meaning the
receiver has determined from the conversation.
Language may be well understood only in highly familiar situations
and topics of expertise. People on the autism spectrum will, to varying
degrees, perseverate on a topic of interest and fail to maintain the topic of
discourse if it is outside their subject interest (Noens and van
Berckelaer-Onnes 2004; Perlman 2000).
For some other ASD individuals, most notably ones that have more
severe impairment, receptive communication may be stronger, although
both are impaired. They may use echolalia to a greater degree, and not
always in a manner that conveys language fluency. These are the people
with word retrieval issues who cannot find the right words easily to
express themselves. Again, emotional language is the most impaired.
These people may be partly verbal, and rely on echolalic tendencies to
express themselves verbally (Attwood 2003; Meyer 1999).
Echolalia
There are two types of echolalia. Immediate echolalia involves the
immediate repeating back of what is said, while delayed echolalia is the
repeating back of something that was heard in the past. An example of
immediate echolalia would be when a person says the word “coffee” after
he or she were asked whether they would like a coffee. Delayed echolalia
would be the repeating back of something that was heard a while ago,
such as repeating back the news broadcast from the night before, word
for word, including commercials; or repeating back, word for word,
including vocal tone and intonation, the telephone conversation a parent
had a week ago. Most often echolalia consists of chunks of sentences, and
the person may not completely comprehend the nuances of the language
they are using. Echolalia can be a bridge for acquiring verbal language
(Janzen 1996).
Social impairments
Social impairment is profound in persons who have autism, with a lesser
impairment in those who have Asperger’s or PDD-NOS. The difficulty
arises from a lack of understanding of social rules, not from a lack of
42 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Emotional impairments
People on the autism spectrum have difficulty both expressing emotions
and understanding others’ emotions. They may show difficulty in distin-
guishing between physical sensations and emotional arousal. There
appears to be more impairment in understanding emotions than in
expressing them, at least in higher functioning people with ASD. There is
an inability to discern others’ emotions from their eyes and significant
difficulties determining others’ emotions from vocal tone or prosody
(Rutherford, Baron-Cohen and Wheelwright 2002). Facial expression
can be flat, exaggerated, or unusual (Attwood 1998; Hill, Berthoz and
Frith 2004; Jones et al. 2001).
Emotional regulation
When in a calm state, children (and adults) with ASD can use their
language abilities to seek help or change the situation to maintain
emotional regulation. This breaks down, however, when they are no
longer emotionally regulated or are overaroused. Often the dysregulated
Autism: An Overview 43
behaviours stand in sharp contrast with their abilities when they are emo-
tionally calm and are confusing to the people around them. Emotional
regulation, which is how one achieves an optimum arousal state to be
fully participating in social activities or to meet environmental demands,
is crucial to remain socially acceptable, solve problems, and communicate
effectively (Laurent and Rubin 2004).
It is common for people on the autism spectrum to show behavioural
signals that they are becoming emotionally dysregulated or overaroused.
Some of these signs can include toe walking, hand flapping, carrying
around a favourite toy or article and refusing to let it go, or chewing on
clothing. Signs of greater dysregulation are lashing out behaviours, with-
drawal, or tantrums. Often these signs of dysregulation are not responded
to as coping strategies indicating difficulty, and communication partners
may see these as problem behaviours. Punishing or ignoring these behav-
iours seldom helps the ASD person to regulate their emotions in the
social situation, and adds to the individual’s stress (Laurent and Rubin
2004).
Sensory abnormalities
Sensory abnormalities are commonly found in people on the autism
spectrum, such as hypersensitivity to sounds and tactile defensiveness, a
case where different kinds of touch, often light or gentle touch, are felt as
44 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Stereotypical behaviours
People on the autism spectrum have what are known as stereotypical
behaviours. These behaviours can consist of rocking, flapping the arms
and/or hands, twirling in circles, and pacing. Other behaviours that are
odd and repetitively done can also be included as stereotypical. An
example might be making odd noises, jumping, and twirling fingers in
front of the eyes. Stereotypical behaviours are within the individual’s
control, and are often engaged in as a stress releaser or for the sensations
they bring. When these behaviours are engaged in for pleasure, they are
called self-stimulatory behaviours. Often self-stimulating behaviour is
engaged in for the sensory pleasure it provides (Harrison and Hare 2004;
Janzen 1996; Jones et al. 2003; Sofronoff and Attwood 2003).
(Ghaziuddin et al. 1998; Hare, Jones and Paine 2000; Lainhart 1999;
Ruberman 2002).
Autistic Thinking
and Autistic Logic
One of the aspects of the autism spectrum that can be confusing for prac-
titioners is the cognitive distortions and unusual logic found with this
population. Given the sensory processing differences, the language
impairments, emotional impairments, and high rates of comorbidity,
there is little wonder that their way of thinking may be different from that
of the population that is not on the autism spectrum. Often their way of
thinking makes no sense given what counsellors know about the theories
of personality, relationships, and the unconscious:
Jacobsen prepares us with her statement that much of what we have come
to understand does not apply without taking into consideration the char-
acteristics of the autism spectrum. There are curious deficits in cognition
that are rather unique to this population, regardless of the level of intelli-
gence. Understanding how people on the autism spectrum think will
facilitate understanding the individual in the counselling room.
49
50 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
VISUAL THINKING
One of the hallmarks of the autism spectrum is their propensity to think
visually. For some people on the autism spectrum, there are only pictures
inside their heads (Grandin 1996; Willey 1999). Attwood (2003) quotes
an adolescent with Asperger as saying: “I have the picture in my mind but
not the thousand words to describe it” (p.82). This was demonstrated in
one experiment with children who were on the autism spectrum (Frith
and Happé 1999). Several children with autism recorded their immediate
experience or thoughts when a beeper went off during the day. The
results were primarily of images, including words written on the image to
make a thought. There was little, if any, difference between the visual
thought and what was seen in real life, as if the children could not
imagine something that was not true.
Grandin (1996) noted that most of the people who surrounded her in
college thought in verbal words. People on the autism spectrum do not
use verbal strategies to memorize information, and may seldom use
verbal strategies at all (Tsatsanis 2004). Verbal, language-based learning
is the primary modality of schooling in North America. As visual thinkers
in a language-based learning environment, people on the autism
spectrum are at a disadvantage in our educational systems. Attwood
(1998) indicated that people on the autism spectrum visualize informa-
tion instead of recalling words verbally in their head. This strategy leads
to poorer recall of verbal information. Attwood reports of one person on
the autism spectrum who indicated that verbal words did not seem to stay
in her head in any meaningful way. How much information is lost when
stories and text are converted to pictures and videos? What is gained in
the translation?
This visual thinking may not be exclusive in all people on the autism
spectrum, and some people with ASD may also talk to themselves as they
think, but current research seems to indicate that visual processing of
information and visual thinking are the norms for people on the autism
spectrum (Attwood 1998; Grandin 1996). The implications are
profound. Visual images tend towards the concrete, not the abstract. How
many abstract concepts have no visual image? Grandin discussed how she
made visual images for concepts, sometimes using printed words with the
images. What happens to meaning making and language comprehension
Autistic Thinking and Autistic Logic 51
when you can only recode it in your mind as a picture? Grandin wrote
that abstract concepts were translated into pictures of movies that showed
the concept or something closely associated to the concept. She reported
that things that are more abstract could be incomprehensible:
Many, if not most, social concepts are abstract, and may only be under-
stood by someone on the autism spectrum by translating the concept into
concrete examples of behaviours that would occur. Grandin (1996)
reported using this strategy to understand concepts like honesty. She
collected pictures and video examples of what honesty would look like in
real life, and stored these in her mind as a way to understand the concept.
She was able to understand abstract social concepts only when the
concept was made concrete and visual. She could not understand the
abstract concepts without translating them into images. Visual thinking
tends to be concrete in nature.
Fortunately, one can cope in our world at the concrete operational
stage, as only about 35 per cent of people in industrialized countries ever
progress past the concrete operational stage to the formal operational
stage of development. At the concrete operational stage, logic has
developed, although abstract thinking and thinking about the future are
not mastered (Huitt and Hummel 2003). However, the difficulty with
conceptualizing abstract concepts in visual modalities can lead to differ-
ences in the understanding of these concepts. People on the autism
spectrum may have idiosyncratic meanings and associations for abstract
concepts (Grandin 1996).
Frith and Happé (1999) noted that the children they studied did not
seem to be able to visualize anything other than what was in their
immediate environment. Aston (2003) writes about one partner of a man
on the spectrum who appeared to watch something on the television, and
then try it on his wife. He was using the television as a social model. This
demonstrates that television can provide the visual images and movies
52 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
that people on the autism spectrum learn from. The use of videos to
instruct people with autism spectrum disorders has been shown to be
effective (Charlop-Christy and Daneshvar 2003) and compares
favourably to in vivo modelling of a task. This demonstrates that informa-
tion is digested best when it is created in a visual format. The challenge is
to take counselling, which is based mostly on talking, and adapt it to a
visual mode.
and a rather large mushroom farm under his bed of these very same
mushrooms, the school continued to suspect abuse. However, in
this case, it was simply that Bill’s favourite activity and drawing
subject had a provocative shape. Sometimes the drawing is literally
exactly what it is – no more, no less. This writer concurred with the
school that a thorough investigation was warranted to determine if
there were any issues of abuse, but that the drawings themselves
may not be related to issues of sexual abuse. With most children,
repetitive drawing of penis-shaped mushrooms would be a cause
for concern; for a child with ASD who has a mushroom farm as his
favourite hobby, drawings of mushrooms may only be an expres-
sion of his favourite activity.
LITERAL THINKING
People on the autism spectrum are often literal thinkers (Happé 1995;
Martin and McDonald 2004; Noens and van Berckelaer-Onnes 2004;
Ogletree and Fischer 1995). Figures of speech confuse them, and are mis-
understood. It is this writer’s guess that this colloquialism confusion
makes sense from a visual thinking perspective, as many figures of speech
do not make sense as pictures. Take the example of the expression of
raining cats and dogs. What would it look like to have cats and dogs
falling from the sky? What would it sound like? What image comes to
mind when thinking about cats and dogs hitting the ground from that
height? The visual image is rather gruesome, don’t you think? Feeling
blue? How does that make sense? Does that mean that you would have
blue skin? What if having blue skin would make you happy? The thought
of having a frog in your throat might be rather disturbing. Would being
full of bull feel painful? If someone called you a smart Alec, would that
mean you were dumb if your name was Bill? It does not take many collo-
quialisms to demonstrate that they would be confusing to someone who
is a visual and literal thinker.
before the lunch break, he proceeded to eat his after school snack.
Jack became angry when stopped, as he was not instructed not to
eat his after school snack. He was asked not to eat his lunch, and no
one had said that he was not to eat any food at this time. When Jack
was given clear and detailed directions, covering all contingencies,
he complied. Jack was taught that finding a way around the rule
was called finding a loophole. Jack was given a rule to help him
out. That rule stated that if Jack could find a loophole or way
around a rule, he was to ask the person directing him if the
loophole was okay to do. Jack enjoyed this as a game, and it helped
the people around him to say what they meant and to mean what
they said.
SELF-CONCEPT
Adults on the autism spectrum lack a sense of self or reference to self,
leading to problems in processing words related to the self. There appears
to be a profound deficit of self-consciousness (Toichi et al. 2002). It is as if
there is no concept of a self, no concept of personal identity. It may be
that self-concept and self-referents are too abstract to be made into visual
images for people on the autism spectrum to understand.
Children on the autism spectrum were shown to have greater diffi-
culty in remembering events that they had personally experienced than
events that they saw another child experience, yet there were no differ-
ences in free recall tasks. Millward, Powell, Messer and Jordan (2000)
Autistic Thinking and Autistic Logic 57
postulated that having another person accompany the child may enhance
their memory, perhaps serving as a memory cue.
This writer proposes a different possible way to interpret their
findings in the light of the characteristic of visual thinking. It may make
sense from the perspective of the discovery made by Frith and Happé
(1999) regarding the random thoughts of the children they studied.
These children’s thoughts were mostly of the visual images that their
environment presented to them at the time when the alarm went off and
they were to indicate what they were thinking at that moment. Two
things are highlighted in this study. The first is that the recall was of
images only, and the second is that the images are from that moment in
time, suggesting that the children are highly visual and tend to experi-
ence life in the moment.
If you were to extend these findings to the recall of self versus others’
experiences, it would make sense that recall would be better for what the
individual with ASD saw another person experience, because there is an
entire visual image of a person in that memory, and actor in the play, so to
speak. If you consider how people experience sight, we do not see
ourselves performing a task unless we are viewing ourselves in a mirror.
Visually all we can see are parts of our bodies, perhaps our hands and feet,
participating in the task. We cannot see our whole body engaging in the
task. Perhaps from a person with autism’s point of view, disembodied
hands and feet are performing the task, or, if the visual orientation is not
on the parts of the body, there is no person seen doing the task. There is
no self attached to the task. On the other hand, when they watch
someone else perform the task, not only is there clearly a visual person
involved, but they themselves become another recall cue. Perhaps what
Millward et al. (2000) have indirectly shown is the difficulty that people
on the autism spectrum have with visualizing a self when the self is not
directly seen, and organizing memories around a self that visually does
not exist in any cohesive manner.
Most of the people this writer has worked with are not this extreme,
although they often do not completely understand their authorship in
their actions until they see themselves on videotape, or imagine the
situation as if they were a video camera watching from the sidelines.
Aston (2003) recounts an episode where one of her clients went for a
drive while crossdressing. He was locking his car and about to go into a
restaurant when a motorcycle gang saw him and harassed him. He was a
very large man and did not pass well as a woman. He was utterly
convinced that the reason the bikers knew he was a man was because he
wore men’s shoes. He could not see that someone with his body shape
could not pass as a woman. He had no sense of himself and how he
presented to others as a crossdresser.
Many children on the autism spectrum (and, assumedly, adults) lack
self-awareness and an awareness of how their actions impact others or
bring about consequences. They also have difficulty being aware of their
own mental states, and thus are unaware that their thinking impacts their
choices in acting. Understanding mental states is a skill required to
understand oneself and one’s social interchanges (Frith and Happé
1999).
When children are able to report their own mental states they are
also able to report the mental states of others. Conversely, when they
Autistic Thinking and Autistic Logic 59
The ability to understand that others have minds, thoughts, and feelings
of their own develops around the same time as their sense of self, and
seems to be intimately related (Frith and Happé 1999). This lack of a
sense of self and a sense of others is often referred to as having a theory of
mind (TOM).
THEORY OF MIND
Theory of mind is the awareness that you have a mind separate and
unique to yourself and others have minds of their own that are unique to
them. This knowledge includes that these others do not necessarily expe-
rience and know what you know. This ability is often called mind reading
or mentalizing (Leudar, Costall and Francis 2004). The inability to
understand another’s thoughts, emotions, and intent is called mind
blindness. Having a theory of mind helps in the judgment and prediction
of others’ words and actions, and how they may respond to your words
and actions. People on the autism spectrum can seem “oblivious on every
level to their effect on others, and sometimes oblivious to their own
actions” (Jacobsen 2003, p.571). Having no theory of mind means that
you do not think about yourself or your actions. The ability to make infer-
ences regarding someone else’s mental state is pivotal to social relations
(Hill et al. 2004).
People with ASD often cannot predict or understand the conse-
quences of their actions, and may not attribute the end result to their
behaviour. Blame is often externalized, as they may not recognize their
part in the situation. Blaming others also occurs when the person with
ASD incorrectly interprets another’s actions (Attwood 1998). In this case
there may be theory of mind ability, but it is faulty.
Theory of mind abilities are on a continuum, with autism being at the
most impaired end of the continuum and those with Asperger’s
somewhat closer to the middle of the continuum, with people not on the
autism spectrum at the other end. Those with PDD-NOS show similar
60 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
EXECUTIVE FUNCTIONING
There can also be problems with executive function, or the ability to plan,
organize, and monitor one’s own performance. Executive functioning
means the metafunctions of the mind, and can be described as the
executive (or boss) that manages thoughts and awareness. Executive func-
tioning describes the metacognitive processes that monitor, assess, and
organize thinking. Executive functions include central coherence,
cognitive flexibility, organization abilities, source monitoring, inhibitory
functions, and meaning attribution.
Central coherence
Central coherence is the way that things are formed to make a whole of
the big picture. Strong central coherence gives someone the ability to
remember the gist of a story, to get a sense of the whole. It is the ability to
understand the theme or common thread in information. Central
coherence allows people to understand broad concepts without necessar-
ily knowing all the details (Martin and McDonald 2004).
Weak central coherence, on the other hand, means that details are
remembered, often in a disjointed manner, with no sense of a global
meaning. Every detail is as important as every other detail, and no weight
is given to more important information. There is no clear beginning or
ending. These are impairments in the central cohesion of thinking. In
other words, where people not on the autism spectrum tend to fit pieces
of information into some greater whole, people on the autism spectrum
tend to keep the parts separate and unrelated. Having central coherence
weaknesses means that people on the autism spectrum are detail thinkers
but do not think in themes or broad interpretations. Weak central
coherence leads to deficits in using sentence context in comprehension
but verbatim recall is excellent (Martin and McDonald 2004; Teunisse et
al. 2001). It is this lack of central coherence and orientation to detail that
creates what this author calls loophole thinking (discussed earlier in this
chapter).
Sense making may be fragmented and literal as details are not
combined on common themes. There may be a lack of ability to create
themes from several sentences. Central coherence is the ability to pull
66 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Cognitive inflexibility
People with autism tend towards concrete thinking, which negatively
impacts their ability to change how they conceptualize things, known as
cognitive flexibility. Lack of cognitive flexibility of thinking impairs the
ability to make plans and creatively problem solve, as thinking remains
stuck. Transference of learning and information is often an issue, as
rigidity in thinking impedes the transfer of knowledge across situations
(Attwood 2003; Tsatsanis 2004).
Rigidity in thinking was studied by Russell and Jarrold (1998). Upon
examining the errors that children on the autism spectrum make, they
noted that the children with ASD both made more mistakes than their
peers, and corrected proportionately fewer mistakes than their peers,
although the ASD individuals corrected the relative same number of
mistakes as their peers. Thus, they tended to make more errors without
self-correcting their mistakes as often. The difference made in the
absolute mistakes was what contributed to the difference in the total
number of mistakes made by people with ASD. Some of the mistakes
made could be explained through cognitive inflexibility, where the
children could not easily change their responses to accommodate to the
change in rule of the task. The assumption is that this cognitive inflexibil-
ity continues into adulthood.
Autistic Thinking and Autistic Logic 67
Organizational deficits
Organization is a challenge for people on the spectrum. For some people,
thoughts, tasks, and possessions are in total chaos as they do not know
where to begin or how to self-organize. Others show organization in
their possessions, and become upset if anything is moved out of place, but
this organization is externally created. Difficulty in organizing results in
the experience of memories as discontinuous and disconnected (Aston
2003; Attwood 1998).
68 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
medication, and to track his work shifts. His PDA became quite the
hit when it helped him to remember his anniversary and his wife’s
birthday.
This author has been made aware of PDA software that can utilize
touchscreen input to generate prerecorded words or phrases for individu-
als who cannot communicate vocally. The phrases are connected to
pictures, words, or symbols that are displayed on the touchscreen. A
different program for PDAs displays pictures or photographs of the steps
in a task. Each step is displayed singly, and the next step is shown when
the touchscreen is activated to indicate that the current step is completed.
This writer is unaware if any research has been conducted using these
software and hardware tools. These tools look promising for persons on
the spectrum who are nonverbal or illiterate.
Computers have been shown to be useful teaching aids for people on
the autism spectrum (Moore, McGrath and Thorpe 2000). Their ability to
provide reminders that can be set for differing time periods makes them
useful cueing systems for self-monitoring. A future possibility will be to
use portable computers to assist in cognitive behavioural treatment
programs, such as treatments for anxiety (Newman, Consoli and Taylor
1999; Newman, Kenardy, Herman and Taylor 1997). This writer has
successfully used handheld computers such as Palm Pilots and Pocket
PCs for self-management systems, as reminder devices, self-monitoring
devices, and reinforcers. These devices tend to be trendy, and therefore do
not stigmatize the person utilizing them.
Source monitoring
People on the autism spectrum have difficulty with source monitoring
tasks, or determining the origins of memory, beliefs, and knowledge.
Often they cannot tell if someone said something, which of two people
said something, or whether they themselves have said it, which is external
source monitoring, or whether they just thought it in their heads, which
is internal source monitoring. Source monitoring difficulties are often
shown when a person on the autism spectrum is unaware that they
expressed their thoughts out loud, or thought they had said something to
you when they only said it in their heads. This is different from the
70 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
cookies were gone. For Tim, this also meant that if all his tools were
laid out for a task he would feel compelled to complete the task,
whether or not he really wanted to. He became a very good worker
at his job placement, providing the tools were laid out within his
field of vision.
Meaning attribution
Individuals on the autism spectrum may have difficulty with attributing
meanings in a way that would appear logical to a typical individual. Diffi-
culty with understanding central coherence, combined with unusual
logic, can result in unusual meaning attribution. This can be seen in
Aston’s (2003) example of a male partner with ASD who did not
associate having sex with a man as committing adultery, and therefore did
not believe that he was being unfaithful to his female partner. Homosex-
ual activities had no meaning of unfaithfulness attributed to them.
groups of males, while both male groups scored about the same. These
results support the idea that people with autism spectrum conditions
demonstrate an empathizing deficit whilst having a level of systemizing
skills that is, at least, in the normal range (Baron-Cohen and Wheelwright
2004). These deficits in empathizing have a profound impact on personal
relationships.
In-the-moment thinking
Often people with ASD experience life in the moment, without a sense of
the past or the future. This is more pronounced in persons who are more
severely affected. When this is the case, it becomes very difficult for
learning from past experience to be brought into the present experience.
This may be one explanation of why people on the autism spectrum do
not transfer learning to different situations. It is difficult to recall learning
when your cognitive state and capacity fluctuate from moment to
moment (Ory 1995). This is compounded by the sensory abnormalities
and fluctuations that occur in persons who have ASD (Attwood 1998),
74 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
77
78 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
counselling room. In other words, if the client does not see something as
a problem they will not talk about it unless asked some very pointed and
specific questions (Aston 2003).
Clients on the autism spectrum will require a more structured
approach, longer time to process new information, and perhaps shorter
sessions and many more practice sessions. Typewritten notes may be
helpful and group settings may not have therapeutic value, as the ASD
client will struggle with the social aspects of groups. Groups are only rec-
ommended if the target for intervention is social skill development
(Aston 2003; Attwood 2003; Hare and Paine 1997).
Often it is helpful to find examples of times when the client was able
to maintain self-control or otherwise overcome their problem. Many
clients on the autism spectrum engage in all-or-nothing thinking and do
not notice or remember successes (Ory 2002a, 2003). From this you can
identify intact coping strategies and build upon this, as well as provide
evidence that the client is capable of solving their own problems and suc-
ceeding (Hare and Paine 1997).
commented that he did not think the diagrams and notes were
necessary, but the notes “facilitated understanding and integration
of the concepts.” This writer has discovered that writing concepts
down during sessions and diagramming concepts facilitates client
understanding and focus. Giving the client a copy of the notes and
diagrams encourages follow through outside of sessions, and can
act as a touchstone for the beginning of the next session.
thoughts
feelings actions
Figure 3.1 Thoughts, feelings, and actions diagram This diagram can be helpful in explaining
how thoughts, feelings, and behaviours interact with each other. This is a useful visual
tool for ASD clients who are having difficulty understanding how their thinking,
behaviour, and feelings interconnect. The superimposed person connects the concept
to an individual. On occasion, this writer has used photographs of the client’s face for
the diagram, further connecting the thoughts, feelings, and actions to the client.
Other creative ways to make concepts concrete and visual are also
helpful. One client, who wanted to rid himself of disturbing thoughts,
wrote them down on toilet paper and flushed them. Once he saw the
paper swirl down the toilet, he knew it was gone, and since the paper was
gone, he could no longer get the thought back. By this client’s autistic
logic, once he saw the thoughts written on to paper disappear, they no
General Strategies and Modifications for Cognitive Behavioural Therapy 81
longer existed for him. He could then carry around new and better
thoughts on non-flushable paper so that he would have them when he
needed them.
Assessment tools
Assessment can be done with many of the clinical tools available, but
modifications may be required for emotional evaluation. Graduated
responses of emotion may best be represented visually, such as an
emotional thermometer, bar graphs indicating degree of emotion, or
number scales to show the degree of a quality (Attwood 2003). For some
examples, see Figures 3.2 and 3.3. What you are attempting to do is make
the abstract concept of degree, quality, or quantity of emotion or opinion
concrete and tangible to facilitate the identifying of the amount of what
the assessment tool is measuring. This writer has noticed that having a
visual scale measure may reduce some of the all-or-nothing thinking that
can occur with people on the autism spectrum (Portway and Johnson
2003).
L
Figure 3.2 Emotional thermometer This tool can be used to graphically display gradients
of emotion, satisfaction, or ratings of a particular characteristic, such as one’s ability to
cope. An emotional thermometer can help a client determine the various degrees of an
emotion that he or she is experiencing. For example, a child may use the thermometer to
visually rate how well they think they used their coping skills or how they were feeling
after attempting a new activity.
82 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
J K L
Figure 3.3 Example of a response quality scale A response or quality scale visually divides a
particular quality into smaller increments, which can vary from five increments, shown
above, to seven or ten increments. This tool facilitates the scaling of different qualities,
such as emotion or satisfaction. Repeated use of a scale such as this to measure the same
quality over a period of time provides clinicians with a system to demonstrate change.
An example of using a rating scale is to rate agreement with a series of statements, such
as rating agreement to a statement regarding feeling happy most of the time or usually
engaging in self-calming behaviours when agitated. A sample statement could be “I am
usually happy.”
COGNITIVE RESTRUCTURING
People on the autism spectrum tend to have errors in logical thinking,
cognitive distortions, and mistaken beliefs. Logic on the autism spectrum
is markedly different from what is considered to be normal logic, but
makes sense once the practitioner examines it from the perspective of
someone on the autism spectrum who may be basing the logic on
mistaken assumptions and lack of information. Often the cognitive
mistakes arise from a lack of information that would commonly be
available to a person not on the autism spectrum, combined with difficul-
ties understanding the invisible social rules, as people with ASD have
difficulty in correctly inferring social rules, and may have trouble under-
standing complex cause and effect relationships. People with ASD are
frequently literal and polarized thinkers and have faulty underlying
assumptions. Often they cannot predict the consequences of their actions.
They typically misread context and come to the wrong conclusions. This
may lead to cognitive distortions (Attwood 2003; Meyer 1999; Portway
and Johnson 2003; Prestwood 1999).
Cognitive restructuring can be used with clients on the autism
spectrum, including those with mild to moderate mental handicaps, as it
has been effectively used with people with below average intelligence.
Cognitive restructuring is not recommended when the client is out of
touch with reality or locked into inflexible thinking. Cognitive disputing,
which is the process of challenging cognitive distortions with more
realistic thoughts, may not be applicable with clients who do not have the
metacognitive ability to analyze their thoughts, but rational coping state-
ments can be quite effective (Gandy 1997; Grave and Blissette 2004).
FEELINGS
THOUGHTS
Figure 3.4 Thoughts, feelings, and actions mobile The interactive dynamics between
feelings, thoughts, and actions may be difficult to grasp for people with ASD. This
writer has used a mobile to demonstrate the interaction between cognition, affect, and
behaviour. The demonstration involves moving one part of the mobile and directing
the client to observe what happens to the other parts of the mobile. For example, if a
counsellor wished to demonstrate how thoughts impact feelings and behaviour, the
counsellor would take the thoughts part of the mobile and move it, directing the client
to observe what the other parts do. This demonstrates how change in one area, such as
cognitive change, affects change in both behaviour and affect.
General Strategies and Modifications for Cognitive Behavioural Therapy 87
Questions to ask:
Does this thought help me stay calm? Does this thought help me cope with the
situation?
• If yes, then it is a realistic response or antidote.
• If no, then this is a cognitive distortion, or poisonous thought.
as thoughts that other people on the autism spectrum may have, which
may be similar to the client’s possible coping thoughts, can be useful.
For some clients, pairing an antidote thought to a cognitive distortion is
the most that can be gained (Gandy 1997). They may not be able to
identify the schemata underlying their cognitive distortions. It is rec-
ommended that clients review coping thoughts prior to engaging in
various activities, such as before going to work or school. This can be
referred to as a booster shot, to prevent the thought viruses from
making the person feel bad.
Here is a place to put your own unhelpful and helpful thoughts. How do they
make you feel?
Figure 3.5 Worksheet of helpful and not so helpful thoughts This is a worksheet to teach
cognitive restructuring. The illustrated facial expressions highlight how different
thoughts can result in different emotions. Clients are encouraged to provide their own
thoughts and related feelings to delineate how their thoughts relate to their emotions.
90 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Mental filter. You focus only on the negative, filtering out all positive things that
have happened. You just do not see the positives even when they are right in
front of you.
Disqualifying the positive. You reject all positives and minimize them by insisting
that they don’t count and are not important. You just do not see the positive.
Mind reading. You think you know what others are thinking, but have not asked
them what they think.
Fortune telling. You predict that something will turn out badly before trying it to
see if it really will turn out badly.
Emotional reasoning. Your emotions form the base of your logic. If you feel bad,
then the situation is bad. If you “should” do something, that means that you are a
bad person if you don’t do it. If someone else “ought to” do something, he or she
is a bad person if he or she does not do it. “Should” statements.
Blaming others. You blame others and do not see how you contribute to the
situation.
Personalization. You blame yourself as the cause of negative things, but see others
or luck as the cause of positive things.
Attribution of actions
Often people with ASD will frequently blame others for the conse-
quences of their actions, or take the blame for others’ actions. They are
not aware of how their actions affect others (Baron-Cohen and Wheel-
wright 2004). Sometimes the person with ASD may act omnipotently or
arrogantly when they do not perceive themselves as being in control of
the situation. In this case, specific individuals may be held responsible for
the outcome and may be targeted for retribution if the outcome is not
what the person with ASD deems as the desired outcome. The person
with ASD does not perceive their contribution to the outcome in this
situation (Aston 2003; Attwood 2003).
When the client has low self-esteem, they may feel personally respon-
sible for everything, and may also believe that they are helpless to change
the situation or change their own abilities. This learned helplessness is
common and may contribute to feelings of anxiety and perhaps guilt
(Aston 2003; Attwood 2003).
Attribution retraining is where the client examines the situation and
correctly attributes responsibility in the situation (Cormier and Nurius
2003). Through logic and examination of the situation, the client learns a
new perception of themselves. Often this is accomplished by drawing the
situation into a cartoon. Using a cartoon format you can demonstrate
cause–effect reactions as well as explore other people’s possible inten-
tions and thoughts (Kerr and Durkin 2004).
Automatic thought
Ha! Hee-hee! Ha ha! Boy,
They’re laughing was that ever funny!
at me! That’s not
very nice! Grrr!
Coping/realistic
Thoughts
Ha! Hee-hee! Ha ha! Boy,
was that ever funny!
Figure 3.6 Examples of visual reframing This cartoon shows cognitive reframing. The use
of cartoons to show the difference between automatic thoughts and reframed thoughts
enables a clinician to demonstrate the changes in related emotions. This added
emotional information may be helpful to people with ASD to understand how cognitive
reframing works.
new ones. The coping thought is then written on new paper and kept.
This strategy takes the abstract concept of cognitive restructuring and
makes it concrete and visual – thus easier to understand for someone with
ASD. It is similar in form to the previous example of a person with autism
spectrum disorder’s idea of flushing cognitive distortions, although
perhaps not as colourful.
Choice mapping
Even the most profoundly cognitively disabled person with autism
exercises choice (Proctor 2001), although they may often not be aware of
the consequences of their choices (Baron-Cohen and Wheelwright
2004). A visual way to show choices and possible outcomes is through
the use of cognitive mapping of choices. In this manner, the initial choice
can be examined with the relationship of the other choices that were
made. Responses to the situations are also examined, as the client may
have a very limited response repertoire. During attribution retraining, the
client and the therapist can explore alternative responses and the possible
consequences that could be predicted when the response is given.
Attwood (2003) recommends using a list of possible responses to a given
situation with adults, and flow charts with children. This writer prefers
using flow charts with both adult and child clients, as they clearly
highlight the connections between choices and results. Often, when
working with children, this writer utilizes both flow charts and drawings,
particularly drawing faces to indicate emotions. Sometimes the stick
figure drawings and emotion faces have had a greater impact than the
flow chart, showing how incidents and actions are linked together.
Understanding of situational choices can be facilitated by using
visual choice trees or flow charts, with lines that connect the response to a
possible outcome (see Figure 3.7). Colour coding may help highlight
which person made what choice. This writer has used visual mapping
successfully with clients who could not link their actions to others’
responses very well, but who did have a sense that they somehow had
played a part. Mapping the choices and linking the actions and conse-
quences in a flow chart format appeared to help my clients link their
actions to the outcome, and helped them see what responsibility they had
in the outcome. This mapping strategy may not be effective with those
94 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
First choice
Ask boss for a raise.
Fifth choice
Third choice Third choice Prepare before the
Struggle to find a job Decide not to look for interview. Have a list
when your boss gives a job. Go on welfare. of all the good reasons
you a bad reference. Blame your old boss why you deserve a
for your loss of anger raise. Prepare to
control. discuss calmly any
reasons why you don’t
deserve a raise.
Figure 3.7 Sample of a choice and possible consequence chart The choice and possible
consequence chart is a useful tool to show the chain of events that are possible from one
choice. Choice charts can also show how a single action can lead to a series of events.
Colour can be used to delineate choice trees, or to code emotions associated with a
choice. In the above example, colour was used to differentiate choices that were more
likely to have a positive result from those that would be more likely to generate a
negative result. This enabled the client to process the emotional component to the
choices he made and the results the choices could bring.
General Strategies and Modifications for Cognitive Behavioural Therapy 95
who cannot see that they play a part in how the scenario unfolds; they
first have to realize that their actions have later consequences. Mapping
choices can also facilitate exploring different possible choices and conse-
quences. This facilitates building a larger response repertoire as well.
Attwood (2003) recommends including choices of self-disclosure to
teach clients that others are interested in their experiences and emotional
state. Use of choice charts can also indicate where self-disclosure is not
appropriate.
Relapse prevention
Framing relapses as a normal part of the change process addresses the
process of all-or-nothing thinking and perfectionism that can occur with
behaviour changes. Relapse prevention is a crucial component when
working with people on the autism spectrum, as they will not anticipate
relapses and have difficulty problem solving when relapse occurs (Grave
and Blissette 2004; Laurent and Rubin 2004).
Goal setting
Goal setting may appeal to many people on the autism spectrum, as it is a
concrete and measurable way to assess progress. Good goal setting is
specific, which appeals to people with ASD. Learning to set goals and
subgoals is part of learning to plan, a weakness of many people on the
autism spectrum. Use of a goal-setting worksheet with spaces provided
96 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
TRANSITIONS
People with ASD may have difficulty switching from one activity to
another, often referred to as transitions. Transitioning from one activity to
another can cause anxiety and confusion. Using visuals as cues and scripts
for transitions enhanced their predictability and lowers the confusion and
possible crisis situation. Provide advance warning that the transition will
be coming, and give the person time to prepare to get ready for the transi-
tion. Often questioning the person about what is happening next can
help them orient to their visual schedule or list that lets them know what
is next (Attwood 1998; Ory 1995).
Automatic refusals
Some people with ASD will automatically answer “no” to any choice,
whether it is a choice that they usually like or not. Often this initial refusal
is a strategy to buy time, or has been the learned response for someone
who has a history of being asked to comply with things they were not
interested in. To address this, talk about the possible choices without
expecting any response, and discuss the positives and negatives of each
choice. This gives the person with ASD the answers to the questions that
he didn’t think to ask before he has to make a choice. It also gives him or
her time to think before making the choice. With people who say “no” to
any offered choice, prepare them that they will be offered a choice within
five minutes, and briefly outline what the choices will be. For those with
language processing difficulties, follow up with some kind of visual to
represent the choices. Often, once the person with an autism spectrum
disorder is prepared to make a decision, they will accept a choice or
provide an alternative. Their initial refusal may stem from difficulty in
shifting attention quickly and the need for extended processing time to
make a decision.
PROBLEM-SOLVING APPROACHES
Effective problem solving can be taught to people on the autism
spectrum. Those with ASD often have difficulties with finding solutions.
The difficulty may be in generating solutions, but difficulties in assessing
General Strategies and Modifications for Cognitive Behavioural Therapy 99
Is it fair to everyone? o o
Is it safe? o o
Will everyone feel okay about the solution? o o
Will something bad happen if I try my solution? o o
Will it work? o o
Totals:
If all yeses, If there are any
do it! answered “no”,
don’t do it!
Today’s jobs
1 Complete math homework. S
Figure 3.8 Sample self-monitoring checklist Sample checklist used for self-monitoring
work habits. Criteria for reinforcement and the cue to self-reinforce are built into the
sheet.
SELF-TALK
Some people on the spectrum engage in self-talk that can be less than
helpful for them (Attwood 2003). Self-monitoring self-talk can be, in
and of itself, a successful intervention. Sometimes data collection can
impact behaviour, as taking notice of behaviour can influence the
frequency with which a person will engage in that behaviour. For
example, taking data on negative self-talk can decrease it, as the person
becomes more self-conscious of making negative self-statements, or it
can increase in frequency as the person becomes more focused on the
negative things that they may say about themselves. What may be a more
useful strategy, however, is to focus on the opposite of negative self-talk,
102 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
DIAGNOSING DEPRESSION
Vulnerability to depression may be more likely among higher function-
ing people with autism than those with comorbid mental retardation, as
103
104 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
room after school, refusing to come out even for meals. Todd
became totally absorbed in computer games after school, often
staying up throughout the night. Todd stopped returning phone
calls from his one friend, and became reluctant to go to school.
Shortly after that, Todd expressed the desire to commit suicide.
PHARMACOLOGICAL APPROACHES
Antidepressant medication is often prescribed for individuals on the
autism spectrum, although there is little efficacy research reported with
this population. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are often
used, followed by non-SSRI medications. Neuroleptics are also
sometimes used but may not show good results (Ghaziuddin et al. 2002).
It is important to know the medication that a client may be taking and the
side effects that have been noted with use in the autism population.
Reframing
People on the autism spectrum tend towards cognitive inflexibility
(Tsatsanis 2004). This can lead to “‘functional fixity’ – that is, seeing
things from only one perspective or being fixated on the idea that this
particular situation, behaviour pattern, or attribute is the issue” (Cormier
and Nurius 2003, p.394). They become stuck in one-way thinking,
without being able to see that there are alternative possibilities.
Reframing the meaning of a situation or attribute is a cognitive behav-
ioural technique to open thinking towards alternative possibilities,
thereby creating a change in meaning, which will affect behaviour.
Reframing context provides a positive function or usefulness for
behaviour and reduces generalization.
Care must be taken when reframing with people on the autism
spectrum, as they may have idiosyncratic meaning attributions that are
not amenable to reframing, or cannot discriminate between contexts
where a behaviour is acceptable. Cartooning can facilitate reframing and
provide sufficient boundaries for contextual reframes (Gray 1994b,
1995). An example of this is found in Figure 3.6 (p.92). The client draws
out his interpretation of the situation, and the counsellor draws the
reframed situation (Gray 1994b). Reframing in this visual format
resembles the use of comic strip conversations, which have been shown to
be very effective with people on the autism spectrum (Attwood 1998;
Gray 1994b, 1995).
Accepting that one has a diagnosis of autism can be difficult.
Cognitive restructuring regarding one’s disability may be effective as a
disability tends to remain permanent, but how one thinks about the dis-
ability is amenable to change. It is possible to use cognitive restructuring
Depression and Treatment Approaches 109
to effect change in one’s core beliefs about life. However, this may not be
effective with people who have more severe forms of autism (Gandy
1977).
Total: Total:
Figure 4.1 Positive thoughts game scorecard Scorecards are helpful tools to keep data on
behaviours. Using an analogy of winning or losing a game can provide motivation to
track the data, especially if there are incentives for keeping score. For clients who are
uninterested in games and scores, a science experiment analogy can be used. The above
example tracks positive and negative thoughts. The emotional thermometer provides a
graphic display of the general emotion for the day, giving a visual link between the
number and type of thoughts with the overall daily emotion. For people with ASD, this
provides a link between thought and emotion.
are becoming depressed, and doing something you would enjoy that
would distract you from the feelings. For many clients this simplified
approach may be what they can handle. An addition of coping state-
ments, such as expressing confidence that doing something fun will
combat the depression, would prove beneficial (Glasman et al. 2004;
Singh, Wahler, Adkins and Meyers 2003).
Addressing lethargy
One characteristic of depression is lethargy. This is often seen with
people on the autism spectrum who are depressed. Inactivity is exacer-
bated by fortune-telling cognitive distortions that the activity will be
awful. Activity scheduling is recommended to combat lethargy associ-
ated with depression. Scheduling has many general benefits for people
with ASD such as reducing discomfort and anxiety, thus making this
intervention ideal for alleviating discomfort as well as lethargy (Burns
1980; Ghaziuddin et al. 2002; Glasman et al. 2004).
Before suggesting to your client that one way to combat the lethargy
associated with depression is to get out and do something different, you
must assess your client’s social functioning and skill repertoire. It may be
detrimental to ask your client to engage in novel social situations without
knowing if they have the skill base to do so, or if social anxiety prohibits
the use of this technique at this time. It may be preferable to begin with
activities the client is skilled at that may not involve intensive social inter-
action. Inactivity or lethargy may be a tool to avoid stressful social situa-
tions, and may be an indication that social skill training is needed (Aston
2003; Sofronoff and Attwood 2003).
To assess possible activities, ask your client to make a list of things
that they used to enjoy doing, things that they enjoy doing now, and
things that they may like to try. This list can be written or done in
pictures, including old family photos. Each activity that is tried is rated on
an enjoyment visual scale (see Figure 3.3, p.100). Mood is also tracked
using a mood thermometer (see Figure 3.2, p.90). Overall improvements
can be tracked through the use of these scales.
112 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Relapse prevention
Depression should be viewed from a chronic conditions framework, as
depression does not get cured overnight, and relapse is possible if all
interventions cease. Keeping depression at bay will be hard work using
the strategies provided by cognitive behavioural therapy over a long
period of time for continued success. Continual use of CBT has been
shown to be effective in keeping full-blown depression at bay. Vigilance
in monitoring and planning for relapses is important for ongoing success.
Clients on the autism spectrum need to know that depression will not just
go away without continual effort on their part. Relapse prevention
should be part of a depression treatment plan, with the option for return
appointments, or tune ups. The provision of written notes or audiotapes
of sessions and techniques may be useful for future reference (Glasman et
al. 2004; Sarafino 2002).
One tool that this writer has found to be useful is the creation of
relapse prevention books for clients. These books have specific individu-
alized instructions regarding different degrees of depression, using a
rating scale as the measure. At each stage, suggestions of interventions are
made. These books have specific instructions as to what tools may be
helpful, with a customized example of the client’s own cognitive distor-
tions and coping thoughts. Included in the book are directions regarding
seeking help when depression increases and/or items indicating an
increase of risk of harm to self or harm to others have been identified. At
the end of the book is a list of community resources that the person can
turn to for immediate help, such as community crisis lines. One
component in the book is the reminder that the client can call this writer
or another counsellor if they are unsure of how they are doing, or if they
feel the need for a booster session.
114 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Anxiety, OCD,
and Treatment Approaches
115
116 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Childhood anxiety
Anxiety in children in the general population is relatively stable, often
lasting from two to five years (Gillott et al. 2001). In the not too distant
past, childhood anxiety was discounted as something that children
would naturally grow out of (Kendall and Choudhury 2003). Children
Anxiety, OCD, and Treatment Approaches 117
Social anxiety
Social anxiety is assumed to come from lack of social competence, hence
social skills training with corrective feedback is the most common mode
of treatment. Social skills training is covered in more detail in Chapter 6.
Often social skill instruction is paired with strategies to reduce anxiety.
Once skill level is adequate, cognitive restructuring for social anxiety is
used to address the anxious thoughts that occur in social situations.
Cognitive restructuring shows the best effect when it is used before,
during, and after exposure to social situations. In this use exposure is seen
as an opportunity to challenge and disprove inaccurate thoughts
(Rodebaugh, Holaway and Heimberg 2004).
Anxious perseveration
Perseverative behaviour and the insistence on keeping things the same
may be ways to reduce anxiety, or are driven by anxiety. Anxiety has been
discussed as being both a consequence of autistic behaviours and a cause
of these same behaviours. Stereotypical behaviours and repetitive behav-
iours may be coping strategies to reduce feelings of anxiety, as these
behaviours tend to increase when the person is emotionally distressed or
anxious. Obsessions and rituals are likewise possible anxiety-reducing
strategies, as interrupting these sequences can cause distress and anxiety.
Lack of approval regarding perseverative or stereotypical autistic behav-
iours can lead to feelings of anxiety, leading to more behaviour, creating
an escalating cycle (Gillott et al. 2001; Ory 2002a).
118 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
train could go a different way, one that did not involve a broken
bridge. With this image in mind, he was able to understand the
process of learning to control and cope with his anxiety.
anxiety and fear are like paralyzing poisons that make it more difficult to
act (Sofronoff and Attwood 2003).
People on the autism spectrum often have unusual or irrational fears
(Attwood 1998; Janzen 1996). It is important to normalize fear and
describe when fear is functional, such as when there is actual danger.
Specific examples, like that of a fire drill when there is no fire, can be
helpful. Anxiety problems are like when you know that the fire drill will
be occurring, and you feel anxious even when you know you are safe.
Feeling anxious when you are not sure there is a real fire or when you
smell smoke is a good thing. Your fear is appropriately warning that you
may be in danger. Anxiety is also functional if you are anxious about an
upcoming job when you have not made the necessary preparations. This
again is functional anxiety, as the anxiety is communicating to you that
you are not ready. In this circumstance, you would want to use problem
solving to address the anxiety. Sometimes the cognitive distortions occur
due to a misunderstanding regarding the risk of the situation. In this case,
providing information resolves the issue. It may be helpful to teach the
individual to ask for clarification or direction in a situation, to ease their
anxiety (Piacentini and Langley 2004).
When assessing a perceived risk of danger, it is important to clarify
the actual risk of harm. Some people on the autism spectrum do not have
an accurate sense of danger (Attwood 1998; Janzen 1996). This writer
has observed that sometimes the assessment of risk is due to the person
not knowing what to do and correctly concerned that they will injure
themselves attempting something that is unfamiliar, although a person
not on the autism spectrum would understand that they could not be
harmed in the situation. In these situations this writer has found that
teaching problem-solving skills, including asking for assistance and
direction, can reduce anxiety. Knowing what to do when one is confused
is an essential coping skill (Ory 1995). Teaching problem solving is
discussed in Chapter 3.
Anxiety can be assessed visually, using a thermometer or number line.
Measuring anxiety in this manner helps the individual with autism gain
an understanding that there are varying degrees of anxiety (Sofronoff
and Attwood 2003). This information can be used to track progress as
well. Some clients understand their progress best when these ratings are
Anxiety, OCD, and Treatment Approaches 121
blowing his worries and fears into his balloon, the balloon broke.
Kevin’s mother froze, expecting an explosive outburst. Kevin
looked around and then smiled. He came to the conclusion that
there were no more worries, since there was no more balloon! On a
different day, Kevin’s balloon got away from him, and he laughed
as the balloon flew about the room, spraying his worries all over
the place. Kevin discovered that he could not feel afraid and laugh
at the same time.
Desensitization
Desensitization is one of the most effective ways to treat fears. Systematic
desensitization has been shown to be effective with people on the autism
spectrum (Jackson 1983; Koegal, Openden and Koegal 2004). This is
desensitization through reciprocal inhibition. Simply put, systematic
desensitization involves counterconditioning the anxiety response with a
relaxation response or competing enjoyable activity. The counter-
conditioning stimulus must be more powerful than the fear or anxiety it is
meant to inhibit. Usually a relaxation response is chosen as the
counterconditioning stimulus (Cormier and Nurius 2003).
As the person gains mastery over a graduated series of anxious situa-
tions, they develop self-efficacy regarding their ability to master their
anxieties. When using desensitization, it is important to teach ways to
self-calm or otherwise distract oneself from the feelings of anxiety. Part of
this self-calming instruction can include cognitive restructuring of
cognitive distortions. Instructions on teaching self-calming and relax-
ation skills are to be found in Chapter 7 (Cormier and Nurius 2003).
When using desensitization with clients on the autism spectrum, it is
best to progress more slowly to ensure success. Setbacks can occur when
Anxiety, OCD, and Treatment Approaches 123
clients are under undue stress, feeling ill, or are exhausted (Cormier and
Nurius 2003; Jackson 1983; Sofronoff et al. 2005).
Exposure therapy
Exposure is a key ingredient of cognitive behavioural approaches to
anxiety, where the client remains in an anxiety-provoking situation
despite distress. This is desensitization through extinction. Exposure is
based on the idea that the client must fully experience the anxiety-
producing situation for cognitive and behavioural change to occur.
Exposure leads to a new learning, which competes with the old fear,
taking the potency of the fear down to where it is manageable (Cormier
and Nurius 2003; Rodebaugh et al. 2004).
A fear and avoidance hierarchy is developed with the client, and
exposure to anxiety-producing situations begins with the least severe,
and progresses to the most severe, as each previous situation is mastered.
Exposure sequences follow the anxiety hierarchy, from lowest to highest.
The client is instructed to stay with the feared situation until a new
learning occurs or habituation happens. In-session exposures use role
playing and imagination/visualization, while homework involves
exposure to the actual situation. Exposure therapy has been shown to be
effective with people on the autism spectrum (Jackson 1983; Rodebaugh
et al. 2004).
Therapists should be aware that subtle avoidance, such as paying
attention to internal sensations, can undermine the effectiveness of
exposure therapy. This may be a common occurrence with social anxiety
or social phobia, and clients should be instructed to pay attention to the
situation and not distance themselves from it by focusing on internal
senses or by discounting the experience as artificial. The client needs to
actively engage with the situation for exposure to be effective
(Rodebaugh et al. 2004).
Safety behaviours are common, and often attributed to the success of
coping with an anxiety-provoking experience. These behaviours tend to
have negative consequences. An example of a safety behaviour is to hold
your hands behind your back when speaking in public. This may address
the fear of shaking in public, but it will not help your presentation as a
speaker. Safety behaviours interfere with habituation as the decrease in
124 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Sometimes the items of the hierarchy indicate a deeper issue, such as fear
of criticism and not social phobia. Asking the client what would change if
they no longer had the fear may provide some clues as to any underlying
issues (Cormier and Nurius 2003). Do not be surprised, however, if the
client cannot contemplate their future in that manner, as people on the
autism spectrum are often unable to think about their future, particularly
those who are moderately or severely affected. Thinking about the future
is too abstract a concept for many people on the autism spectrum.
Clients need to learn how to self-monitor. A fear log is a tool to chart
anxiety between sessions, and to show progress (Moynahan 2003;
Sofronoff and Attwood 2003). A cheat sheet of relaxation or distraction
strategies at the front of the log may be a helpful reminder for clients.
They need to feel comfortable admitting and identifying their fear before
the fear log can be accurate. Included in the log is what the client did in
the situation, as well as ratings of the fear or anxiety. Part of the log can
include a list of things that worked well and things that did not work very
well (Kellner and Tutin 1995). This provides the client with a list of their
successes and a list of things to avoid doing. Clients may have trouble
coming up with their own solutions, as people on the autism spectrum
have difficulty generating solutions, and often do not recognize when a
solution is inappropriate or impractical.
Thought stopping
Thought stopping is the practice of becoming aware of your thoughts
and intentionally distracting yourself away from them. The use of
concrete cues for thought stopping have been shown to be helpful for
people on the autism spectrum. Thought stopping is the basis of mindful-
ness practices, where you consciously switch your focus from a thought
Anxiety, OCD, and Treatment Approaches 127
must not respond to the fear trigger as if it is special. They need to ignore
the fear trigger. Often people around someone with a phobic-like fear
will become hypervigilant to protect the person from the fear trigger.
This sends an underlying message that there really is something
dangerous about the fear trigger. Ignoring the fear trigger communicates
that there is nothing to be afraid of. “The genesis of a child’s dog phobia
could reside in a direct traumatic experience…while the phobia is main-
tained by excessive attention from the parents” (Jackson 1983, p.194).
The second key component involves the use of digital image editing,
or creative cut and paste. This part of the intervention uses the strength
that individuals on the autism spectrum have of being visual thinkers
(Attwood 1998, 2003; Frith and Happé 1999; Grandin 1996). Within a
Social Story™ this writer placed digital photographs of the person and
the feared object or feared situation. As the story progresses, the feared
object is moved closer to the person’s image in the photo. All pictures are
of the person happy and calm.
For many people on the autism spectrum, not knowing what to do can
create anxiety. They prefer to have some concrete rules to follow, a prop
that acts as a cue or reminder of what they are supposed to be doing, and a
role that fits into the situation. The use of rules and rituals can make the
abstract concrete, assisting the person with ASD in coping with the
abstract, and reducing anxiety (Ory 1995, 2002a). An example would be
to hand someone on the autism spectrum a dishtowel when they entered
the kitchen. The dishtowel becomes the prop, or cue that they should dry
dishes. The role of drying dishes has a definite set of rules and routines
that assists in completing the task correctly, and anxiety is reduced as the
script is familiar and routine.
Anxious questions
Often people with autism spectrum disorders ask questions that may be
interpreted by the receiver as a profound question deserving an abstract
answer, but this may not be the case if the answer is above the person’s
developmental level. An abstract answer may create confusion and
anxiety if the person with ASD cannot make sense of the abstract. Often it
is best to start with concrete answers and move to the abstract only if the
person on the spectrum pursues the matter. Double meanings and
132 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Perfectionistic anxiety
Many people with autism spectrum disorders will not attempt to do
anything unless they do it perfectly the first time. They may not attempt
an activity until they know all the rules and feel that they can complete all
the necessary steps correctly. Perfectionism may interfere with the ability
to produce work, as continual correction may mean that the work is
perfect but took many more hours to complete than the teacher or
employer may be ready to accept. Sometimes accommodations can be
made, like using a computer to produce written work, or the steps to the
task can be modelled prior to asking the person with ASD to attempt the
task. Preteaching tasks can help prepare people with ASD to attempt new
things. Using scripts and checklists can also facilitate trying a novel
activity or task. For many, helping someone else with the tasks is a low
anxiety way to facilitate their trying something new. There is no pressure
for them to do it correctly, as they are only the helpers (Ory 1995,
2002b).
TREATMENT OF OCD
Throughout the treatment of OCD, lists and session notes are helpful to
make the process more visual for the person with ASD. Pictures and illus-
trations can be used with people who have difficulty with written
language. Using pictures may be of benefit to many clients, and OCD
treatment can be written up in a social story format for use in between
sessions (Attwood 1998; Gray 1994a, 1994b, 1995). For some, drawing
Anxiety, OCD, and Treatment Approaches 135
their OCD and what they would be like without it may help them see the
benefits of treatment (Reaven and Hepburn 2003).
Treatment of OCD with people on the autism spectrum begins with
psychoeducation regarding what obsessive compulsive disorder is, and
distinguishing OCD from repetitive behaviours and perseverative topics
of interest that are normally found within autism spectrum disorders. A
list or chart can be created to visually illustrate what OCD is and what it is
not, and to dispel myths regarding OCD. The client should be asked to
supply their personal symptoms of anxiety, as behavioural symptoms
may be different from the symptoms we often associate with anxiety. Dif-
ferences should be discussed between perseverative interests and
favourite subjects, in that perseverative subjects and special interests
bring enjoyment, much as hobbies do, and therefore are not symptoms of
OCD. A list of OCD symptoms should be created, with estimates of how
much time is spent on OCD behaviours. This can later be used as an
assessment measure (Reaven and Hepburn 2003).
Interacting with other people is one of the primary areas of difficulty for
people who are on the autism spectrum (Attwood 1998, 2003; Filipek et
al. 1999; Rutter 2005). Some people on the autism spectrum do form
friendships and intimate partnerships (Aston 2003). Social skills are some
of the most important abilities for both academic and employment
success (Elliott and Gresham 1991). Quality of life in adults on the autism
spectrum is negatively impacted by poor social skills (Gustein and
Whitney 2002). Poor social skills do not appear to be from lack of social
exposure but lack of social understanding, although this author has
noted that poor social understanding can lead to social withdrawal:
Adults are often judged by the same yardstick as children with ASD, with
perhaps the exception that their behaviour is perceived as more volitional
(Aston 2003). Their atypical behaviour and difficulties following the
social norms and practices result in varying degrees of social anxiety.
High functioning people with ASD may be aware of social rules as they
try to conform to them to fit in with the rest of the social world. However,
trying to conform may not be completely successful. Trying to make
137
138 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
sense of the social world has been described by some people with ASD as
“perpetual culture shock” (Jones and Meldal 2001, p.40).
Social situations can be overstimulating. The ability to inhibit
behaviour is negatively impacted by hyperarousal (Raymaekers et al.
2004). This may be why some people with ASD go out of control in
social situations. Social codes of conduct are often invisible to someone
on the autism spectrum. Not understanding the social codes of conduct
can be anxiety producing (Attwood 1998). Social anxiety tends to be
high among individuals with ASD.
An analogy would be the experience of being dropped in a foreign
land without understanding the language, knowing the social codes and
mores, and having no tour guide or guidebook to assist you. Imagine that
the culture is so different that everything that you know is wrong about
this culture. Imagine that you could be arrested and sent to prison for
doing the wrong thing. This could be similar to the experience of living
on the autism spectrum. If you were aware of the idea that engaging in
some behaviour can result in a jail term, you would be very anxious that
you did not engage in those things, even though you did not know what
they were exactly. If you were oblivious to the fact that some of your
behaviours could put you in jail, you would do whatever you thought was
right, and then become outraged and confused when the police arrested
you. Again, this may be similar to the experience of someone on the
autism spectrum who was not very aware of the social codes, or that their
behaviour impacted other people. Also, they may not be aware that others
may have a different perspective or different information than they have,
resulting in difficulty understanding the other person’s reaction towards
their behaviour.
The National Autistic Society of Great Britain conducted a study that
showed that 37 per cent of adults on the autism spectrum reported that
they engaged in no social activities and half reported going out only once
or twice a month (Gustein and Whitney 2002). In the Orsmond et al.
(2004) study, only about 8 per cent of their participants reported having
reciprocal friendships outside of “prearranged settings” (p.253), with half
reporting no peer relationships outside of school and work. Social
impairments can have a major negative impact on the ability to live inde-
Relationships and Social Skills 139
these rules need to be spelled out very specifically. One crucial piece of
information for an individual on the autism spectrum was knowing
whom to go to when help was needed. People with ASD benefit from
extensive on-the-job training. Extensive training facilitates generaliza-
tion of job skills to the job setting (Hurlbutt and Chalmers 2004).
their deficits. Indeed, for some, social small talk and emotionality are so
foreign that they cannot comprehend them, let alone attempt to engage in
these kinds of behaviour (Aston 2003; Attwood 1998).
partner will probably have stopped being nice due to her resentment that
her ASD partner is not the wonderful giving man that she fell in love
with. Often it is simply a case that the ASD male does not realize that the
courtship behaviour, such as giving gifts and doing nice things for the
woman, should not stop when the relationship is secure, but should be
ongoing to a lesser degree. ASD men cannot respond to the subtle cues
that their partners send. If they are not told specifically that they are
appreciated and doing what their partner wants, they will get into diffi-
culties and become confused. Specific suggestions of doing something
special or nice for the partner at times may be necessary. This may seem
unromantic and mechanistic, but this specificity is what the person with
the autism spectrum disorder needs (Aston 2003). He just simply does
not intuitively know that being nice and doing special things for your
partner is something that needs to be ongoing in a relationship. He needs
to know when, how much, and, specifically, what things she would
consider pleasurable. After all, if he finds lightbulbs pleasurable, wouldn’t
he believe that his partner would share that same enjoyment? However,
this writer does not know many women who would welcome the gift of a
lightbulb.
to use. Jack was given a smaller box with several copies of the days
of the week printed on them. Every Monday morning Jack was to
draw a card (after shuffling the deck) to determine which day of
the week he would do something from the romance box. Some
of the cards had “two days” written on them. His instructions on
the two-day cards were to pick two romance cards and do two
romantic things that week, one on each day. The instructions
included not telling Joan anything about the romantic thing, so it
would be a surprise. One instruction added later was to have Jack
inquire about Joan’s plans for the week, to ensure that there would
be no scheduling conflicts. They tried this system for two months
and decided that this met both of their needs. In fact, they both
said that they were enjoying being with each other again, and Jack
indicated that Joan was the wonderful woman he fell in love with
all over again. Joan commented that she enjoyed this so much that
she asked Jack to give her some cards with romantic ideas that
he would like her to do, because she felt that Jack was having all
the fun.
home lives, as these are seldom found in their working or school lives.
Predictability and routines create order in an often confusing and over-
whelming world, and are a sense of comfort for someone on the autism
spectrum (Aston 2003; Attwood 1998).
Sexuality
Men with ASD cannot easily understand social signals or social cues. This
is even more the case when attempting to read their partner to determine
if sexual intimacy is welcome. Misinterpreting sexual interest cues can
have serious consequences when the partner is unwilling, and can lead to
a lot of confusion for the ASD male. Frequently there are communication
issues around intimacy. Partners who are not on the spectrum may find it
stifling and contrived to instruct their partner regarding their sexual
wants and desires, seeing this as unromantic. However, this level of com-
munication may be necessary for fulfilment of sexual needs when the
partner has ASD (Aston 2003).
About half of the couples that Aston (2003) studied indicated that
they had had no sexual relations in the past year, and that sexual intimacy
was not important in their relationship. Some of the men had homosexual
affairs but did not see this as wrong as they were not having sex with
another woman. From their point of view they were not being unfaithful
if they met their sexual needs with another man. For them there was no
relationship, just a mutual enjoyment. One man on the spectrum
explained to this writer that having a homosexual relationship was not
cheating on his marriage as it was simply physical, much like two men
playing a sport. He could not comprehend his partner’s emotions around
this. He could not understand why she was upset when he practised safe
sex with other men. He could only understand the concrete complica-
tions of contracting a sexually transmitted disease, but not the emotional
ramifications of cheating on his partner.
Some of the idiosyncratic interests found in people on the autism
spectrum can occur in the area of sexuality or attraction. Some ASD men
fixate on women’s body parts, and cannot understand their partner’s lack
of interest or disapproval. These fixations can be perceived as stalking,
with serious consequences, as the ASD male may not accurately read the
signals sent by the person to whom their interest is directed. ASD people
Relationships and Social Skills 149
may choose their partners based on some of these fixations, such as par-
ticular hairstyles or body shapes (Aston 2003).
Adolescents tend to mature physically at the same rate as their peers,
but lag behind in social skills and emotional maturation. The media can
contribute to informal sexual education, but often misinform. This can
cause difficulty for people on the autism spectrum who cannot determine
what is realistic and what is show business. Growing sexual drives
without the corresponding social knowledge can lead to many embar-
rassing and potentially troubling situations. For those with moderate
mental handicaps, behaviours such as touching other people’s private
parts, public masturbation, and self-exposure can cause serious problems
(Koller 2000).
Teasing
Teasing is a complex social behaviour that can initiate social engagement,
negotiate group membership and hierarchies, and ostracize. Teasing is
most common among peers and family members. This aspect of socializ-
ing is very difficult for children and adults on the autism spectrum as they
often cannot understand teasing and may take teasing literally. They may
not know how to tease appropriately, and often do not know when to
stop teasing. To understand teasing an individual must be able to under-
stand intent, hidden intent, pretending, and nonliteral communication,
all of which are areas of difficulty and deficit for people on the autism
spectrum. The nonverbal indicators of teasing may prove to be the most
challenging for people on the autism spectrum, as the nonverbal
language is difficult to interpret, and may be subtle or exaggerated, either
condition which is apt to be missed by someone on the autism spectrum
(Herrey, Capps, Keltner and Kring 2005).
as well as when to use the skill. There may be a need for some practice in
the actual situations before the skill transfers out of a clinical setting.
Social skill development is often successfully implemented in a group
format, as this provides a safe arena to practise social skills. Sometimes
individual instruction prior to group instruction is helpful (Attwood
2003; Marks et al. 1999; Sofronoff and Attwood 2003).
Poor social skills are related to the inability to understand other
people’s perspectives, known as theory of mind, and the inability to
process emotional information, as well as a difficulty with emotional rec-
ognition (Ponnet, Roeyers, Buysse, DeClercq and van Derheyden 2004).
People on the autism spectrum may appear to cognitively understand the
emotions of other people, but do not use visual facial emotion cues accu-
rately to read the relevant emotions. Reciprocal interactions may be
impaired. Only about 20 per cent of people on the autism spectrum can
pass a first order theory of mind task, which involves attributing different
beliefs to another person that the individual does not have himself. More
capable people on the spectrum can pass second order theory of mind
tasks, which is when you can correctly identify someone else’s beliefs
about a third person (Ochs, Kremer-Sadlik, Sirota and Solomon 2004).
Time needed to process social information to make inferences about
another’s thoughts and feelings is often much longer than the instanta-
neous processing that social situations require. Understanding social
nuances may lag far behind their intellectual ability. High functioning
people on the autism spectrum have difficulty inferring emotions
correctly using pictures of other people’s eyes and voice recordings of
intonation. These nonverbal cues, which guide typical individuals
towards a correct assessment of emotion, are not utilized effectively by
people who have ASD. Awareness of emotion is often lacking, and people
with ASD often respond poorly to others’ expressions of emotions (Ochs
et al. 2004; Ponnet et al. 2004).
Social awareness involves a sense of social consequences. Most
people with ASD lack insight into their own difficulties, but Green et al.
(2000) found that a third of their sample of youth and young adults with
Asperger’s had no insight whatsoever into their own difficulties. People
with ASD make fewer correct interpretations of intention and mental
state during tasks like understanding awkward moments, or when
Relationships and Social Skills 153
explaining the hidden social rules, and exploring choices and conse-
quences (Hodgdon 1995; Smith-Myles and Simpson 2001).
One strategy that is proving effective is using a video camera analogy
for the mind. With this strategy, the person with ASD is asked to imagine
that what other people experience is similar to that of a video camera that
has observed the same situation. For some unknown reason, individuals
with ASD can correctly infer what a person has seen or the knowledge
that they have gained from a situation when they imagine what a video
camera would know, hear, and see in the situation. The mind is compared
to that of a video camera, in that it becomes a storage device for sound,
sight, and knowledge. This framework has been effective in helping
children on the autism spectrum to understand what information and per-
ceptions another person would have of a given situation (Baron-Cohen et
al. 1996).
When examining social situations, the therapist and client need to
look for the salient features that provide clues about social rules, and then
brainstorm for possible options of ways to respond or solve the social
dilemma, and then look at the possible consequences of each of the
choices. Once a clear choice with good consequences is identified,
planning needs to happen to make the choice occur. All that is left then is
to try out the solution and evaluate the results. This process can be made
visual through a choice chart (see Figure 3.7, p.94). This problem-solving
process can be used to review a social situation that did not go as planned
to determine where it went wrong and what possible things could be
done differently in the future (Smith-Myles and Simpson 2001). Teach
how to use self-talk strategies, as these are successful social strategies used
by people who are not on the autism spectrum (Marks et al. 1999).
Hidden social rules and procedures need to be explicitly taught
(Smith-Myles and Simpson 2001). One format this writer has found
useful is called a book of life. All the relevant social information that an
individual with ASD would need is recorded and personalized to the
individual’s particular situation. The book details basic things like bus
rules, scripts for leaving messages on someone’s answering machine, and
rules about inviting someone over for a movie, and other sundry everyday
information. Social actions are also included in the book. Social actions
can be grouped into those that are friendly and those that are unfriendly.
Relationships and Social Skills 155
Unfriendly actions are things like interrupting and standing too close,
while friendly actions are helping someone and coping with mistakes.
The ASD person needs to learn how to determine when acts are acciden-
tal or intentional (Attwood 2003). Sometimes using the aforementioned
concept of other people’s minds being like video cameras can facilitate
this understanding (Baron-Cohen et al. 1996).
Making social skills visual and highlighting social rules facilitates
learning. There is a need to teach coping skills, such as self-calming skills
and how to handle confusion or frustration, to combat the negative
thinking and faulty assumptions common with ASD social meaning
making. ASD people need to learn how to cope with things when they do
not go the way they want. Teaching key social phrases may help (Marks et
al. 1999).
Social skill instruction usually implies having social partners to facili-
tate teaching. Social skills groups have been shown to have good effect in
helping adolescents and adults on the autism spectrum develop social
skills. Specific performance feedback is essential. Use of videotapes to
show the learner’s performance of good social skills is helpful (Marks et
al. 1999).
Social Stories™
Social Stories™ are an adapted form of bibliotherapy developed by Carol
Gray. The social situation is detailed in a comic strip or story format
(Attwood 1998; Gray 1994b). The story highlights the salient features of
a situation, providing descriptions of the situation, what the expectations
are, and the reasons behind some of the occurrences of the situation.
Comic Strip Conversations take this a step further by detailing other
people’s thoughts in thought balloons. They are created with the individ-
ual who has ASD to determine their interpretation of the situation (Kerr
and Durkin 2004). Emotion can be colour coded by using different
colours in the thought or word balloons. This can provide the counsellor
with an idea of the person on the autism spectrum’s perception of
emotion, which can often be incorrect. The comic strip can be redrawn
with corrections to provide an accurate view of the situation, and some
possible options of what to do (Attwood 1998).
156 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Social Stories™ have been used effectively to teach social skills, and
have been shown to have a positive effect on changing social behaviours,
although they are mostly used with children and adolescents (Sansosti,
Powell-Smith and Kincaid 2004). An adult adaptation of Social
Stories™, called social articles, can be expected to show positive results
based on the successful use with adolescents (Attwood 1998). “Based on
current research and informal experience my theory is that social articles
may be effective for some adults with ASD” (Carol Gray, personal com-
munication, October 29, 2005). Social articles are similar to Social
Stories™, with the exception that they are more like a newspaper or
journal article regarding a particular social topic. Social articles provide
more background, reasons, and detail regarding a social practice, and less
direction.
Social Stories™ and Comic Strip Conversations can provide social
scripts as well. People with ASD have fewer social cognitive scripts than
people not on the autism spectrum. This was confirmed by
Trillingsgaard’s (1999) study of children on the autism spectrum. These
children were unable to produce basic social scripts of common, everyday
social routines. People on the autism spectrum have greater difficulty
generating appropriate cognitive scripts for various social situations, but
can identify about the same number of core social scripts as controls
when viewing a videotape, indicating that they can recognize social
cognitive scripts but are impaired in generating them. When in a struc-
tured situation, predicting the next sequence in an unknown script
improved. However, Trillingsgaard (1999) discovered that although
verbal recall of scripts was evident, the ability to use these scripts effec-
tively in social situations may be impaired. People with autism can use the
understanding of social rules and scripts to follow the rules and scripts,
and to recognize script and rule violations.
Social Stories™ or articles become a guidebook to different social situ-
ations, providing instruction and guidance much like a traveller’s guide to a
foreign country: “The story itself becomes a ‘how to’ book for initiating,
responding to, and maintaining appropriate interactions for individuals
with ASD” (Sansosti et al. 2004, p.195). Social Stories™ are often read
prior to entering the target situation, becoming a reminder of the social
expectations and salient features. Social Stories™ can also be used to teach
problem-solving skills through the use of a problem-solving script.
Relationships and Social Skills 157
Social Stories™ are created for each person with a focus around a
problematic situation or behaviour. The salient cues or features of the
situation are highlighted to provide understanding of what elements of
the situation indicate that a particular response is required. The story
provides the who, what, where, when, how long, and why information
that is hidden to people on the autism spectrum (Sansosti et al. 2004).
Stories are written at a level that the individual can easily read. For
nonreaders, the story is read to the person using language that the indi-
vidual easily understands. There are several types of sentences used.
Description sentences provide the description of the situation including
the salient features. Directive statements provide the instructions of what
is expected to be done in this kind of situation. Perspective statements
offer the perspectives and feelings of others, as well as the possible per-
spective of the person for whom the story was written. Affirmative state-
ments outline the cultural beliefs. Control sentences use analogies to
facilitate understanding, and cooperative sentences provide information
regarding who may be able to offer help when asked in this situation. It is
a general rule to use a ratio of two to five descriptive, affirmative, or coop-
erative statements for every directive or control statement. The emphasis
of the story is to provide information and facilitate understanding. The
understanding of the story must be assessed to determine if it will be
effective, and to clear up any misunderstandings (Attwood 1998; Gray
1994a; Sansosti et al. 2004).
159
160 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
success of people who are on the autism spectrum (Grandin 1996; Willey
1999).
Stress reduction strategies are often effective for people on the
spectrum. However, sources of stress must be considered as well. Much of
the daily stress revolves around social situations and not knowing what to
do, or misunderstanding what went wrong. It is often the unstructured
times, such as coffee break, lunch, or recess, which can be the most
stressful time periods. Unexpected change can be a great source of stress
or dealing with the other-than-expected. Advanced preparation, social
scripts, activity checklists, and regular routines are useful strategies to
reduce social anxiety, which lowers overall stress (Aston 2003; Attwood
2003). Change in environments can also be a source of stress for people
on the autism spectrum (Groden et al. 2001).
Groden et al. (2001) developed the first stress survey for people who
are on the autism spectrum. Although it has not been researched inten-
sively to date, it is the only stress measurement tool that recognizes the
unique characteristics of people on the autism spectrum. Some of the
areas of stress that loaded heavily were changes in environment,
transitioning activities, sensory components, and prevention of ritual
completion. Positive stress measures such as receiving reinforcement
were included in the survey, recognizing that good stress, or eustress, can
contribute to stress levels in people who are on the autism spectrum.
There are two stages in the appraisal of stress. In the primary stress
appraisal, stress is assessed for degree of harm/threat or challenge. The
secondary appraisal determines whether the person feels that he or she
has the personal resources to cope with the situation. Stress is the result of
perceiving the threat or challenge to be beyond the coping resources.
162 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Meaning reattribution
Meaning reattribution can reduce stress levels. Reattributions of
causation that increase the possibility of having some personal control
over parts of a situation tend to improve outcome. A sense of self-efficacy
regarding a stressful situation ameliorates the effects of stress. Attribu-
tions regarding self-efficacy lie on three dimensions: internal or external
locus of control, stable or unstable causes, and global or specific causal
factors. Faulty attributions or attributions that tend towards an external
locus and global and stable causal factors are more likely to result in lower
self-efficacy (Park and Folkman 1997; Sarafino 2002). In the case study
above, when Thomas was able to attribute a different meaning to his
teacher’s black shirt, such as that his teacher ran out of other colours to
wear, he was able to cope more successfully with black shirts on his
teachers.
STRESS MANAGEMENT
There are three primary intervention areas of stress management. These
are: problem-solving interventions, cognitive reappraisal strategies, and
relaxation training. Often stress reduction treatments involve a combina-
tion of all three approaches. No matter what approach you use, the person
on the autism spectrum may require assistance in learning to identify
their stress continuum and their related stress symptoms (Wagenaar and
La Forge 1994; Sarafino 2002).
Stress and Relaxation 163
using seven steps may be preferable, where each arm and leg is treated as a
separate step (Cormier and Nurius 2003; Singh et al. 2003). Table 7.1
outlines the muscle group breakdown.
The sequence of progressive muscle relaxation can be made visual by
creating a picture script of the sequence, which has been shown to facili-
tate learning for people on the autism spectrum. Mullins and Christian
(2001) successfully used 13 steps with an adolescent that were described
and pictured in a relaxation book.
Progressive muscle relaxation is a key component to managing the
physical sensations of anxiety. Generally, clients are shown how to do
progressive muscle relaxation, and are then taught to use it daily, as well
as during everyday situations. This is known as applied relaxation. Over
time clients are asked to use progressive muscle relaxation during stress-
provoking situations, moving up their stressful situation hierarchy while
using PMR, building their skill as they progress (Rodebaugh et al. 2004;
Sarafino 2002).
Relaxation objects
Attwood (2003) suggests using tangible objects as relaxation cues. This
author has used relaxation items as props for engaging in relaxation strat-
egies. One prop that has been successfully utilized is the stress ball, which
consists of a squishy round object that is very difficult to rupture. Others
are soft, rubbery balls that have multiple soft protrusions, often known as
koosh balls. This author has taught progressive muscle relaxation using
the stress balls as props, where the client places the squishy object on a
spot on their body, such as between their chin and their chest. Muscle
tension is demonstrated by asking the client to hold the stress ball in that
location on their body. In a pinch, this author has used rolled up socks as
objects to squish. One caution is noteworthy, however. It has been this
author’s professional experience that using socks as relaxation objects
often involves a lot of laughter, particularly when the socks fall. Laughter
is a stress reducer, but may not be the appropriate strategy to use in a
situation where being quiet is valued.
Stress and Relaxation 167
Stress inoculation
Stress inoculation is the strategy of teaching someone proactive ways to
manage stress to enable them to cope with inevitable stress more effec-
tively. It involves both physical and cognitive coping skills. Stressful situ-
ations are anticipated, and stress inoculation techniques are part of a stress
action plan. Having an action plan can significantly reduce feelings of
stress (Cormier and Nurius 2003; Sarafino 2002).
Stress inoculation training involves education around the stress
response and identification of stress triggers, skill acquisition, and skill
application. Stress inoculation has been successfully used with
cognitively challenged adults (Malcolm and Hiebert 1986). Stress inocu-
lation is a preplanned and somewhat scripted process, which lends itself
well to use with people on the autism spectrum, as they benefit from
planned and practised responses. For people on the autism spectrum,
having a plan to address troublesome situations facilitates remaining calm
and coping. The rationale for stress inoculation is that there will always
be situations that trigger emotions such as anger or anxiety, where acting
on the emotion will not help the situation. When these trigger situations
are encountered, it is time to engage in stress reduction activities to help
the person cope with the situation, thus reducing stress (Cormier and
Nurius 2003; Sarafino 2002).
When teaching stress inoculation, the use of visual aids is recom-
mended. Stress thermometers or stress and anger symptom lists are
helpful visual aids for people with cognitive challenges, including those
with developmental disabilities (Malcolm and Hiebert 1986). Listing the
client’s cognitive distortions that escalate stress facilitates cognitive
restructuring of those thoughts. Breaking down the stress pattern into
different phases, such as the anticipatory phase, the confrontational
phase, the coping phase, and the assessment and reinforcement phase,
helps to identify which coping strategies are most useful for the particular
phase of stress (Cormier and Nurius 2003). These phases can be drawn in
a cartoon format to indicate progression and possible coping strategies
(see Figure 7.1). The stress inoculation plan can be created in a social
story format as well.
168 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Figure 7.1 Stages of stress Individuals who have ASD may not recognize that there are
several steps to feeling stressed. Cartoons that depict the stages of stress can provide
examples of the emotional increase and decrease that accompanies the stages of stress.
Cartoons allow the counsellor to include personalized stressful thoughts and coping
thoughts, which may facilitate active coping with stress.
Mindfulness-based practices
Mindfulness-based strategies, or mindfulness meditation, shift the focus
from the emotion, such as anger or fear, to a more neutral item, such as a
body part or breathing. Mindfulness-based anger control has been used
with persons on the autism spectrum, including some with mental retar-
dation. Mindfulness meditation is a relatively simple, four-step process of
identifying emotional arousal, shifting attention to a neutral part of the
body, calming down, and making a choice of what to do (usually walking
away with a smile when the anger was successfully controlled), thus
making this technique one that more challenged persons can complete.
Part of the shifting of attention is to change the body posture to one that
is neutral or calm, and breathing naturally. The person is instructed to
focus on their breath or a body part for several moments, thus distracting
them from their emotion and providing sufficient time to become calm.
Creating a visual script of the mindfulness meditative procedure facili-
tates learning (Singh et al. 2003).
Emotional Expression,
Identification, and Regulation
EMOTIONAL IDENTIFICATION
People on the autism spectrum often do not identify the varying degrees
of emotions that they may experience and may require specific instruc-
tion in how to identify their internal emotions, including physical sensa-
tions of emotions (Attwood 1998; Meyer 1999). Often people on the
171
172 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
she raised her voice. He would ask her if she were angry with him,
regardless of the emotion she was displaying. It became apparent
that Claude could not interpret his mother’s facial expressions or
tone of voice for emotional content. This writer taught Claude a
game about guessing emotions from a person’s tone or face and
posture. Claude was instructed on what features to look for when
guessing emotion. Claude loved to play this game with his mother.
He began to play it with people on the television, particularly the
ones on his mother’s favourite soap opera. Claude would turn
down the volume and try to guess the emotion from the person’s
expression, and then turn up the volume and cover his eyes to guess
the emotion from the tone of voice. Although Claude was often
mistaken, he learned to confirm his guess, and was no longer dis-
tressed by others’ emotions.
continuum scales for people with ASD (Hare et al. 2000). Emotional
labels, descriptive phrases, and pictures of faces can be used to help clarify
the degrees of emotion (see Table 8.1). Clients can develop a list of the
physiological and behavioural cues that identify an increase in emotion,
and connect them to the particular emotion being experienced. It is
helpful to include the purpose that the emotion may serve, such as anxiety
or fear being an alert regarding possible danger, and anger being a signal
that you are being threatened with some kind of loss. Sometimes teaching
emotional identification involves attending to in-the-moment body
language, such as fist clenching or head shaking. Often the person with
ASD is unaware of the body language signals that they are displaying,
and may show conflicting signals such as smiling and shaking a fist
(Attwood 2003; Meyer 1999; Perlman 2000).
Cross Forehead feels tight, Tell the other person that you are
other muscles may feel feeling cross. Explain why you are
tight, voice may get feeling cross.
louder.
Irritated Forehead muscles are Tell the other person that you are
tight, eyebrows move feeling irritated. Explain why you are
down, voice changes feeling irritated. Ask to be left alone
pitch, voice gets for a while, if this will help you calm
louder. down.
Angry Muscles are tight, Tell the other person that you are
eyebrows are pulled angry. Let them know what happened
down close to the eye, that angers you. Tell the person that
heart rate increases, you need a few minutes to calm
voice gets louder. down. Go somewhere quiet and calm
down.
Emotional Expression, Identification, and Regulation 175
Enraged Muscles are tight, Use your words. Tell the other person
eyebrows are pulled that you are very angry. Find a place
down close to the eye, to go to calm down. Do not come
heart rate increases, back until you are calm. When you
voice gets louder, fists are calm, explain what happened that
may clench. made you get angry.
Furious Muscles are tight, Use your words. Tell the other person
eyebrows are pulled that you are very, very angry. Find a
down close to the eye, place to go to calm down. Do not
heart rate increases, come back until you are calm. When
voice gets louder, fists you are calm, explain what happened
clench. that made you get so very angry.
Note: This tool can be used to graphically display gradients of emotion, and include
some of the ways that the individual can recognize this emotional state. Examples of
actions are included to guide the individual in how to express the particular emotional
state in a socially acceptable manner.
EMOTIONAL EXPRESSION
Learning to express emotions involves more than just words, however,
and the actions and nonverbals need to be explicitly taught and described
in the emotional dictionary. These skills also need to be practised, both in
session and between sessions, before the person with ASD will become
somewhat proficient. Videotaping clients as they practise expressing
emotions has been recommended as a useful feedback tool (Meyer 1999;
Moynahan 2003). Often people with autism spectrum disorders have no
idea how they present emotions, and can utilize video feedback effec-
tively.
People on the spectrum may use extreme emotional phrases to
describe how they feel without the sense of the emotional nuances. This
may be a part of their all-or-nothing type of thinking (Ory 2003;
Portway and Johnson 2003). Extreme expressions of emotion, such as
expressing a wish to be dead when frustrated or upset, are not unheard of.
This does not mean, however, that suicidal talk should be ignored.
Indeed, with depression being a common comorbid condition of autism
spectrum disorders (Ghaziuddin et al. 1995, 1998, 2002), such talk must
always be explored, as people on the autism spectrum are not immune to
being suicidal (Hardan and Sahl 1999).
EMOTIONAL RESPONSIVENESS
There appears to be a greater deficit in emotional responsiveness as
compared to emotional perception in others. Emotional responsiveness is
more than the ability to interpret others’ emotions. Once the emotion is
identified, one must have some idea of how to respond. ASD people often
do not know how to respond to others’ emotions, or they respond inap-
propriately (Attwood 2003; Travis and Sigman 1998).
Emotional Expression, Identification, and Regulation 179
Emotional mirroring
Some people with ASD who appear to be “emotionally fragile” (Ory
2004), or emotionally volatile, also appear to reflect back the emotions of
those around them, sometimes called “emotional mirroring” (Ory 2004).
The implication of this is simple but profound. Those who work with
someone who tends to emotionally mirror need to monitor and adjust
their own emotions, as they will be reflected back to them by the emo-
tionally fragile person on the autism spectrum. The person with ASD will
get into whatever emotional state they perceive their caregiver as
showing, which may lead to difficulties when they misinterpret the other
person’s emotion (Attwood 1998; Ory 2004). It is this author’s profes-
sional experience that many people with ASD who are emotional mirrors
tend not only to reflect back any negative emotions of the people in their
environment, but also to amplify these emotions.
People on the autism spectrum have difficulty with emotional regula-
tion, which can often escalate towards anger (Laurent and Rubin 2004;
Raymaekers et al. 2004). In this author’s clinical experience, strong
emotional mirroring can lead to emotional dysregulation in people who
are on the autism spectrum. This can be troublesome in relationships, as a
partner’s strong emotions can disinhibit the ASD person’s emotions,
which can lead to angry outbursts or withdrawal (Aston 2003).
Emotional coping
Emotional coping involves strategies to negate or balance emotions to
facilitate coping. Strong negative emotions are reduced or avoided as a
way to cope. Emotional coping is most helpful when the situation cannot
180 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
taught violent solutions to problem situations. In one case this writer was
involved with, a young child on the spectrum attacked his parent with a
knife. His explanation was that this was how problems were solved in his
games. When you kill it, the problem goes away. He was not malicious; he
simply modelled what he learned by game playing and transferred that
learning to a different situation.
ANGER MANAGEMENT
People on the autism spectrum have difficulties with emotional regula-
tion (Laurent and Rubin 2004; Raymaekers et al. 2004), particularly
anger control (Moynahan 2003). One of the best-researched areas
regarding the use of cognitive behavioural emotional control for people
with ASD is anger management (Kellner and Tutin 1995). It is logical
that many, if not all, of the interventions and steps that are successful in
teaching anger management and regulation should prove to be effective
in facilitating the regulation of other emotions as well.
Aston (2003) studied people who had a spouse with Asperger’s
syndrome. Forty per cent of the Asperger’s men and 75 per cent of the
Asperger’s women had been violent towards their partners. The women
used more hitting, kicking, and punching, while the men tended towards
shoving and restraining. Aston reported that anger is the most common
response when a partner with Asperger’s felt that he or she was losing
control over a situation: “It is at the point when the AS partner feels that
he is losing control that profound and illogical anger might unexpectedly
be directed at his partner” (Aston 2003, p.138). This anger is a result of
his losing control of his feelings and being unable to cope with the
situation.
Aggressive people on the autism spectrum often show cognitively
distorted thinking and a limited capacity for coming up with several
possible alternative solutions (Miranda and Presentación 2000;
Sukhodolsky, Kassinove and Gorman 2004). They may misread or mis-
interpret social cues, or fail to think about the consequences of their
actions. Often the cognitive distortions show a bias towards the attribu-
tion of hostility in other people’s actions. People on the autism spectrum
have difficulty interpreting other people’s emotions, or distinguishing
182 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Visual adaptations
An adaptation to teaching anger management involves making lists of
triggers, lists of how anger was managed, both successfully and unsuc-
cessfully, and a list of coping strategies. These lists can be taken home as
reminders and cues of what to do when anger is identified (Kellner and
Tutin 1995).
The use of a diary to record daily situations in which anger may have
been triggered is helpful. This diary is often referred to as a “hassle log”
(Kellner and Tutin 1995). Diaries provide information regarding what
social situations require intervention. The hassle log records anger
triggers, settings, how the situation was handled, and self-appraisal,
including if there was an improvement in skills (Kellner and Tutin 1995;
Moynahan 2003).
Cue cards can be developed with coping thoughts and helpful anger
management strategies to facilitate anger management between sessions
(Kellner and Tutin 1995; Miranda and Presentación 2000). A different
visual format is a Social Story™. Social Story™ and comic strip formats
can provide scripts and strategies for coping with anger trigger situations.
These can be reviewed in advance if a specific trigger situation is predict-
able and reoccurs in the ASD person’s life. One advantage to using Social
Stories™ and Comic Strip Conversations is that the other person’s
thoughts can be shown, facilitating correction of misunderstood social
situations (Attwood 1998; Gray 1994a, 1994b).
184 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Working with people on the autism spectrum, their families, partners, and
employers can appear to be a daunting task at first. Indeed, this writer
would expect that by the time you have finished reading this manual the
task may seem insurmountable. There are many factors to consider, espe-
cially when autism spectrum disorders may be unfamiliar. Working with
people on the autism spectrum may also be fascinating and exciting if
approached with an open mind. This author experiences autism spectrum
disorders as if they are facets of a different culture, with practices and
rules that are unique and interesting. As with working with any group,
this author has found that there are some helpful “rules of thumb” that
make the process easier.
First and foremost, write down anything of consequence or impor-
tance, as an aid for yourself, if not as a counselling aid. Practise this so it
does not interfere with counselling. Making the process visual will go a
long way towards making counselling work for people on the autism
spectrum. Use diagrams and doodles to get your message across. This
writer has found that the process of making counselling visual enhances
the counselling relationship as well as facilitating understanding and
growth. Provide tools for the person on the spectrum to write or draw out
their meanings, if they desire to do so.
Ask the person what might help them get the most out of counselling.
Often they can tell you what they need, or at least tell you what doesn’t
work for them. Ask them how they best learn and retain information.
Tailor what you do to meet these parameters. Try to feel fine with doing
185
186 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
At other times, though, this writer may not be able to get a word in
edgewise.
Use language the client understands. Try to get the client to describe to
you exactly what his or her words mean. It may be very helpful to get an
understanding of how their favourite subject works, such as how
computers work, or plumbing. These can provide good illustrations of
how things work in real life. Choosing favourite topics as analogies or
frameworks to describe things can bring interest into the discussion. It
may also help your client bring to session his expert knowledge of how
something works, a strength that can help him move towards change.
188 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Last, and perhaps not least, say exactly what you mean, and mean
exactly what you say. Be specific in your language. You will get far better
results. If you use figures of speech or colloquialisms, explain what they
mean. Some of your clients may need this explanation.
Working with people who are on the autism spectrum can be exhila-
rating, as it is never the same day twice. Along with many challenges and
unexpected surprises, people on the spectrum can provide some amazing
insights as well as some astounding perspectives on life. More than once
this author has stopped to wonder at what her clients who have an autism
spectrum disorder have taught her about life, honesty, and relationships.
And that wondering continues to this day with each novel insight from
the autism spectrum.
References
189
190 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Cormier, S. and Nurius, P. S. (2003). Interviewing and Change Strategies for Helpers:
Fundamental Skills and Cognitive-Behavioral Interventions (5th ed.). Pacific Grove, CA:
Brooks/Cole.
Cutler, L. A. (2001). Mental health services for persons with mental retardation: Role of
the advanced practice psychiatric nurse. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 22,
607–620.
Dennis, M., Lockyer, L. and Lazenby, A. L. (2000). How high-functioning children
with autism understand real and deceptive emotion. Autism, 4(4), 370–381.
Elliott, S. N. and Gresham, F. M. (1991). Social Skills Intervention Guide. Circle Pines,
MN: American Guidance Service.
Evans, K. and Dubowski, J. (1988). Art Therapy with Children on the Autism Spectrum:
Beyond Words. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Filipek, P. A., Accardo, P. J., Baranek, G. T., Cook, E. H., Dawson, G., Gordon, B., et al.
(1999). The screening and diagnosis of autistic spectrum disorders. Journal of Autism
and Developmental Disorders, 29, 439–484.
Fombonne, E. (1999). The epidemiology of autism: A review. Psychological Medicine, 29,
769–786.
Fombonne, E. (2003). Modern views of autism. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 48,
503–505.
Friedberg, R. D. (2002). How to do cognitive behavioral therapy with young children.
The Brown University Child and Adolescent Behaviour Letter, 18(4), 5–7.
Frith, U. (2004). Emanuel Miller lecture: Confusions and controversies about Asperger
syndromes. UK Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 45(4), 672–686.
Frith, U. and Happé, F. (1999). Theory of mind and self-consciousness: What is it like
to be autistic? Mind and Language, 14(1), 1–22.
Fullerton, A. and Coyne, P. (1999). Developing skills and concepts for self-
determination in young adults with autism. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental
Disorders, 14(1), 42–52.
Gandy, G. L. (1997). Disability and rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT). In
Caring and the Age of Technology: Proceedings of the International Conference on Counseling
in the 21st Century (pp.119–123). Beijing, China. (ERIC Document Reproduction
Service No. ED 439 329.)
García-Villamisar, D., Ross, D. and Wehman, P. (2000). Clinical differential analysis of
persons with autism in a work setting: A follow-up study. Journal of Vocational
Rehabilitation, 14, 183–185.
Gerber, P. J., Price, L. A., Mulligan, R. and Shessel, I. (2004). Beyond transition: A
comparison of the employment experiences of American and Canadian adults with
LD. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 37(4), 283–291.
Gerland, G. (1999). Letter to the editors: Autism and psychodynamic theories. Autism,
3(3), 309–311.
192 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Ghaziuddin, M., Aleissi, N. and Greden, J. F. (1995). Life events and depression in
children with pervasive developmental disorders. Journal of Autism and Developmental
Disorders, 25(5), 495–502.
Ghaziuddin, M., Ghaziuddin, N. and Greden, J. (2002). Depression in persons with
autism: Implications for research and clinical care. Journal of Autism and Developmental
Disorders, 32(4), 299–306.
Ghaziuddin, M., Weidmer-Mikhail, E. and Ghaziuddin, N. (1998). Comorbidity of
Asperger syndrome: A preliminary report. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 42,
279–283.
Gillberg, C. and Billstedt, E. (2000). Autism and Asperger syndrome: Coexistence with
other clinical disorders. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 102, 321–330.
Gillott, A. L., Furniss, F. and Walter, A. (2001). Anxiety in high-functioning children
with autism. Autism, 5(3), 277–286.
Glasman, D., Finlay, W. M. L. and Brock, D. (2004). Becoming a self-therapist: Using
cognitive-behavioural therapy for recurrent depression and/or dysthymia after
completing therapy. Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, and Practice, 77,
335–351.
Glenn, E., Bihm, E. M. and Lammers, W. J. (2003). Depression, anxiety, and relevant
cognitions in persons with mental retardation. Journal of Autism and Developmental
Disorders, 33, 69–76.
Grandin, T. (1996). Thinking in Pictures and Other Reports from My Life with Autism.
Toronto: First Vintage Books.
Grave, J. and Blissette, J. (2004). Is cognitive behavior therapy developmentally
appropriate for young children? A critical review of the evidence. Clinical Psychology
Review, 24, 399–420.
Gray, C. (1994a). Comic Strip Conversations: Colorful, Illustrated Interactions with Students
with Autism and Related Disorders. Arlington, TX: Future Horizons.
Gray, C. (1994b). The New Social Story Book. Arlington, TX: Future Horizons.
Gray, C. (1995). Teaching children with autism to “read” social situations. In K. Quill
(Ed.), Teaching Children with Autism: Strategies to Enhance Communication and
Socialization (pp.219–242). Toronto: Delmar.
Green, G. (1996). Early behavioral intervention for autism: What does research tell us?
In C. Maurice (Ed.), Behavioral Intervention for Young Children with Autism: A Manual for
Parents and Professionals (pp.29–44). Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.
Green, J., Gilchrist, A., Burton, D. and Cox, A. (2000). Social and psychiatric
functioning in adolescents with Asperger syndrome compared with conduct
disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 30(4), 279–293.
Groden, J. and LeVasseur, P. (1995). Cognitive picture rehearsal: A system to teach
self-control. In K. Quill (Ed.), Teaching Children with Autism: Strategies to Enhance
Communication and Socialization (pp.105–132). Toronto: Delmar.
Groden, J., Diller, A., Bausman, M., Velicer, W., Norman, G. and Cautela, J. (2001). The
development of a stress survey schedule for persons with autism and other
References 193
Lainhart, J. E. (1999). Psychiatric problems in individuals with autism, their parents and
siblings. International Review of Psychiatry, 11, 278–298.
Landry, R. and Bryson, S. E. (2004). Impaired disengagement of attention in young
children with autism. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 45(6), 1115–1122.
Larkin, M. (1997). Approaches to amelioration of autism in adulthood. Lancet, 349
(9046). Retrieved October 4, 2004, from Academic Search Premier database
(password protected).
Laurent, A. C. and Rubin, E. (2004). Challenges in emotional regulation in Asperger
syndrome and high-functioning autism. Topics in Language Disorders, 24(4), 286–297.
Lawson, J., Baron-Cohen, S. and Wheelwright, S. (2004, June). Empathising and
systemising in adults with and without Asperger syndrome. Journal of Autism and
Developmental Disorders, 34(3), 301–310.
Leudar, I., Costall, A. and Francis, D. (2004). Theory of mind a critical assessment.
Theory and Psychology, 14(5), 571–578.
Lovett, H. (1997). Learning to Listen. Baltimore, MA: Paul H. Brookes.
Maiello, S. (2001). Prenatal trauma and autism. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 27,
107–124.
Malcolm, D. and Hiebert, B. (1986). Cognitive stress-inoculation training for anger
outbursts with a 30 year old mentally retarded residential patient: A case study.
British Columbia Journal of Special Education, 10, 139–146.
Manassis, K., Avery, D., Butalia, S. and Mendlowitz, S. (2004). Cognitive-behavioral
therapy with childhood anxiety disorders: Functioning in adolescence. Depression
and Anxiety, 19, 209–216.
Marks, S. U., Schrader, C., Levine, M., Hagie, C., Longaker, T., Morales, M., et al.
(1999). Social skills for social ills: Supporting the social skills development of
adolescents with Asperger’s syndrome. Teaching Exceptional Children, 32(2), 56–61.
Martin, I. and McDonald, S. (2004). An exploration of causes of non-literal language
problems in individuals with Asperger syndrome. Journal of Autism and Developmental
Disorders, 34(3), 311–328.
Maurice, C. (1996). Why this manual? In C. Maurice (Ed.), Behavioral Intervention for
Young Children with Autism: A Manual for Parents and Professionals (pp.3–12). Austin,
TX: Pro-Ed.
McLellan, J. and Werry, J. S. (2003). Evidence-based treatments in child and adolescent
psychiatry: An inventory. Adolescent Psychiatry, 42(12), 1388–1400.
Meyer, R. N. (1999). Counseling AS adults – It’s All in the Process. Retrieved February 12,
2007, from http://rogermeyer.com/counseling_articles_counselling_as_adults.html.
Millward, C., Powell, S., Messer, D. and Jordan, R. (2000). Recall for self and other in
autism: Children’s memory for events experienced by themselves and their peers.
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 30(1), 15–28.
Miranda, A. and Presentación, M. J. (2000). Efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy in
the treatment of children with ADHD, with and without aggressiveness. Psychology
in the Schools, 37(2), 169–182.
196 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Ochs, E., Kremer-Sadlik, T., Sirota, K. G. and Solomon, O. (2004). Autism and the
social world: An anthropological perspective. Discourse Studies, 6(2), 147–183.
Ogletree, B. T. and Fischer, M. A. (1995). An innovative language treatment for a child
with high-functioning autism. Focus on Autistic Behavior, 10(3). Retrieved January 2,
2004, from Academic Search Premier database (password protected).
O’Neill, M. and Jones, R. S. (1997). Sensory-perceptual abnormalities in autism: A case
for more research? Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 27(3), 283–293.
Orsmond, G. I., Krauss, M. and Seltzer, M. M. (2004). Peer relationships and social and
recreational activities among adolescents and adults with autism. Journal of Autism
and Developmental Disorders, 34(3), 245–256.
Ory, N. (1995). Working with People with Challenging Behaviors: A Guide for Educators and
Caregivers. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Challenging Behavior Analysis and
Consultation.
Ory, N. (2002a). Overcoming resistive behaviour, letting it be their idea! Retrieved June 2,
2003, from http://autismtoday.com/articles/Overcoming_Resistive_Behavior.asp?
name=Nathan%20Ory
Ory, N. (2002b, October 5). Supporting children and adults with persistent, repetitive
behaviours: Having trouble with transitions, and autistic thinking and autistic logic: How to use
this as an asset for coping and problem solving. Paper presented at the Island Mental
Health Support Team and Vancouver Island Health Authority Autism Workshop,
Victoria, BC, Canada.
Ory, N. (2003). How to explain “black and white” thinking to a person who only thinks in “black
and white”. Retrieved January 4, 2004, from http://autismtoday.com/articles/
black_and_white.asp?name=Nathan%20Ory
Ory, N. (2004). Brief guidelines for caregivers supporting persons who are emotionally fragile.
Retrieved June 28, 2004, from http://autismtoday.com/articles/brief_guidelines.asp?
name=Nathan%20Ory
Øyane, N. M. F. and Bjorvatn, B. (2005). Sleep disturbances in adolescents and young
adults with autism and Asperger syndrome. Autism, 9(1), 83–94.
Palmen, S. J. M. C. and van Engeland, H. (2004). Review on structural neuroimaging
findings in autism. Journal of Neural Transmission 111, 903–929.
Park, C. L. and Folkman, S. (1997). Meaning in the context of stress and coping. Review
of General Psychology, 1(2), 115–144.
Parsons, S., Mitchell, P. and Leonard, A. (2004). The use and understanding of virtual
environments by adolescents with autistic spectrum disorders. Journal of Autism and
Developmental Disorders, 34(4), 449–466.
Perlman, L. (2000). Adults with Asperger disorder misdiagnosed as schizophrenic.
Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 31(2), 221–225.
Piacentini, J. and Langley, A. K. (2004). Cognitive-behavioral therapy for children who
have obsessive-compulsive disorder. JCLP/In Session, 60(11), 1181–1194.
Ponnet, K., Roeyers, H., Buysse, A., DeClercq, A. and van Derheyden, E. (2004).
Advanced mind-reading in adults with Asperger syndrome. Autism, 8(3), 249–266.
198 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Portway, S. and Johnson, B. (2003). Asperger syndrome and the children who “don’t
quite fit in.” Early Child Development and Care, 173(4), 435–443.
Prado de Oliveira, L. E. (1999). Little Jeremy’s struggle with autism, schizophrenia and
paranoia. International Forum of Psychoanalysis, 8, 172–188.
Prestwood, S. (1999). The Sheffield counselling service for people with autism and Asperger
syndrome. Retrieved November 30, 1999, from http://trainland.tripod.com/
sueprestwood.htm
Proctor, H. G. (2001). Personal construct psychology and autism. Journal of
Constructivist Psychology, 14, 107–126.
Quill, K. (1995). Introduction. In K. Quill (Ed.), Teaching Children with Autism: Strategies
to Enhance Communication and Socialization (pp.1–8). Toronto: Delmar.
Quinn, C. and Swaggart, B. L. (1994). Implementing cognitive behaviour management
programs for persons with autism: Guidelines for practitioners. Focus on Autistic
Behavior, 9(4), 1–14.
Raja, M. and Azzoni, A. (2001). Asperger’s disorder in the emergency psychiatric
setting. General Hospital Psychiatry, 23, 285–293.
Raymaekers, R., van der Meere, J. and Roers, H. (2004). Event-rate manipulation and
its effect on arousal modulation and response inhibition in adults with
high-functioning autism. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 26(1),
74–82.
Reaven, J. and Hepburn, S. (2003). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of obsessive-
compulsive disorder in a child with Asperger syndrome: A case report. Autism, 7(2),
145–164.
Renna, R. (2004). Autism spectrum disorders: Learning to listen as we shape behaviors
blending choice theory with applied behavioral analysis. International Journal of
Reality Therapy, 23(2), 17–22.
Rodebaugh, T. L., Holaway, R. M. and Heimberg, R. G. (2004). The treatment of social
anxiety disorder. Clinical Psychology Review, 24, 883–908.
Roe, K. (1999). Asperger syndrome and terror. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental
Disabilities, 14, 252–253.
Rogers, S. (1998a). Empirically supported comprehensive treatments for young
children with autism. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 27(2), 168–179.
Rogers, S. (1998b). Neuropsychology of autism in young children and its implications
for early intervention. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research
Reviews, 4, 104–112.
Ruberman, L. (2002). Psychotherapy of children with pervasive developmental
disorders. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 56, 262–273.
Ruble, L. A. and Dalrymple, N. J. (1996). An alternative view of outcome in autism.
Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 11(1). Retrieved October 4, 2004,
from Academic Search Premier database (password protected).
References 199
Russell, J. and Jarrold, C. (1998). Error-correction problems and autism: Evidence for a
monitoring impairment? Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 28(3),
177–188.
Rutherford, M. D., Baron-Cohen, S. and Wheelwright, S. (2002). Reading the mind in
the voice: A study with normal adults and adults with Asperger syndrome and high
functioning autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 32(3), 461–469.
Rutter, M. (2005). Aetiology of autism: Findings and questions. Journal of Intellectual
Disability Research, 49(4), 231–238.
Sainsbury, C. and Gerland, G. (1999). Open exchange: An autistic perspective on Live
Company. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 25, 153–161.
Samuels, C. A. (2005, February 23). GAO: Big jump in children with autism seen,
Education Week, 24(24). Retrieved March 4, 2005, from Academic Search Premier
database (password protected).
Sansosti, F. J., Powell-Smith, K. A. and Kincaid, D. (2004). A research synthesis of
social story interventions for children with autism spectrum disorders. Focus on
Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 19(4), 194–204.
Sarafino, E. P. (2002). Health Psychology: Biopsychosocial Interactions (4th ed.). Hoboken,
NJ: Wiley.
Schultz, R. T. (2005). Developmental deficits in social perception in autism: The role of
the amygdala and fusiform face area. International Journal of Developmental
Neuroscience, 23, 125–141.
Seltzer, M. M., Shattuck, P., Abbeduto, L. and Greenberg, J. S. (2004). Trajectory of
development in adolescents and adults with autism. Mental Retardation and
Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 10, 234–247.
Shuttleworth, J. (1999). The suffering of Asperger children and the challenge they
present to psychoanalytic thinking. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 25, 239–265.
Singh, N. N., Wahler, R. G., Adkins, A. D. and Meyers, R. E. (2003). Soles of the feet: A
mindfulness-based self-control intervention for aggression by an individual with
mild mental retardation and mental illness. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 24,
158–169.
Smith, T. (1996). Are other treatments effective? In C. Maurice (Ed.), Behavioral
Intervention for Young Children with Autism: A Manual for Parents and Professionals
(pp.45–59). Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.
Smith-Myles, B. and Simpson, R. L. (2001, November). Effective practices for children
with Asperger syndrome. Focus on Exceptional Children, 34, 1–14.
Sofronoff, K. and Attwood, T. (2003). Cognitive behaviour therapy intervention for
anxiety in children with Asperger’s syndrome. Good Autism Practice, 4, 2–8.
Sofronoff, K., Attwood, T. and Hinton, S. (2005). A randomised controlled trial of a
CBT intervention for anxiety in children with Asperger syndrome. Journal of Child
Psychology and Psychiatry, 45, 1–9.
Stein, D., Ring, A., Shulman, C., Meir, D., Holan, A., Weizman, A., et al. (2001). Brief
report: Children with autism as they grow up – description of adult inpatients with
severe autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 31(3), 355–360.
200 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Note: page numbers in italics and emotional symptoms 29, 32–45, 33,
refer to information contained in identification 172 36, 38
tables and diagrams. in girls 37 avoidance behaviour 45, 119,
social skills deficits of 139, 123
152
symptoms of 35–7, 36,
abstraction 50–1 40–1 behavioural approaches 14–15,
actions, misattribution of 91 assessment tools 81–4, 81, 82 23–4
activity schedules 111–12 attachment 22–3 beliefs, mistaken 85
adaptive skills 23–4 attention, stuck 63–4 bereavement 28–9
adolescence 105, 149, 150–1 attention deficit hyperactivity bibliotherapy 79, 155
aging, autism and 13, 27–9 disorder (ADHD) 46, 182 big picture 65–6
alcohol consumption 25 attention shifting 32, 63–4, 169 bipolar disorder 46
all-or-nothing thinking 78, 81, Attributes Activity 31 black and white thinking 74
90, 103, 177–8 attributions blaming 59, 90, 91
ambivalent attachment 22–3 faulty 91, 112–14, 160–2, body language, in-the-moment
analogy 31, 62, 118–19, 122, 181–2 174
154–5, 157, 165, 177, retraining 91 “book of life” 154–5
184, 187 auditory hypersensitivity 26, 43, brain 25–7
anger 172, 174–5, 179 44 breathing techniques 121–2,
management 180–4 autism 16, 21–47 163–4, 169
triggers 182, 183 adult outcomes 27–9 bubble talk 184
anorexia nervosa 46 aetiology 24–7 bullying 37, 151
anterior cyngulate gyrus 26 and aging 13, 27–9
antidepressants 106, 112, 133 atypical 38
anxiety, comorbid 14, 16–17, cognition of 59–60 cartooning 108, 132
46, 64, 115–33 and comorbidity 45–7 case studies 13
assessment 120–1 diagnosis 24–5, 27 adapted CBT 78–9, 84, 98
causes of 115–16 and emotional art therapy 52–3
childhood 116–17 identification 172–3 common knowledge
diagnosis 116–19 history of 21–4 deficits 187
functional 120 Kanner-type 29–30, 32, comorbid anxiety 118–19,
normalizing 120 38, 46, 140 121–2, 125–31
prevalence 115 prevalence 27 comorbid depression
train analogy of 118–19 strengths of 34–5 104–5, 109–10, 112,
transitional 96 symptoms of 32–5, 33, 114
treatment 119ù33 41–2 coping with change 64
see also social anxiety see also high functioning disorganized thoughts 34
anxiety hierarchies 123, 124, autism emotional issues 172–3,
125–6 autism spectrum disorders (ASD) 175–8
anxiety logs 126 11–17, 16, 21–47 faulty logic 73
art therapy 52–3 CBT adaptations for literal thinking 53–6
Asperger’s syndrome 11, 21, 29 77–102 organizational deficits
CBT modifications for 78 cognition of 16–17, 49–74 68–9
cognition of 50, 53–4, comorbid 45–7, 103–14, perseveration 63–4, 67
59–60 115–36 savant skills 39
common knowledge diagnosis 29–31 self-concept deficits 57–8
deficits 187 guidelines for working with self-control issues 70–1
comorbid 47, 104–5, 115, 185–8 social skills 141–2, 146–7,
118–19 prevalence 14 158
diagnosis 25, 29, 30, 31 and social skills 137–58 stress management 161,
162, 169
201
202 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
205
206 Counselling People on the Autism Spectrum
Happé, F. G. E. 32, 40, 53, 118 La Forge, J. 162 Noens, I. 32, 39, 40, 41, 52, 53,
Hardan, A. 46, 177 Lainhart, J. E. 14, 16, 46, 47, 66
Hare, D. J. 14, 15, 44, 45, 46, 103, 115 Norbury, C. F. 70
77, 78, 82, 124, 135, 174 Lammers, W. J. 103 Nurius, P. S. 87–8, 91, 96, 100,
Harrison, J. 44, 45 Landa, R. J. 26 103, 107–8, 109, 119,
Heflin, L. J. 12, 24 Landry, R. 63 122–7, 136, 164, 166–7,
Heimberg, R. G. 117 Langley, A. K. 120, 134, 135, 169
Henderson, A. M. E. 70 136, 180
Henley, D. 22, 23 Larkin, M. 11, 13
Hepburn, S. 116, 133, 134, 135, Laurent, A. C. 40, 42, 43, 74, Ochs, E. 152
136, 180 95, 99, 145, 159, 179, Ogletree, B. T. 40, 53
Herman, S. 69 181 O’Neill, M. 44, 159
Herrey, E. A. 151 Lawson, J. 71–2 Openden, D. 122
Hiebert, B. 163, 167, 180 Lazenby, A. L. 173 O’Riordan, M. 153
Hill, E. 42, 59, 160 Le, L. 158 Orsmond, G. I. 104, 138, 159
Hill, J. 172 Leonard, A. 157 Ory, N. 63, 67, 70, 73, 74, 78,
Hinton, S. 37 Leudar, I. 59, 60, 160 96, 97, 107, 117, 120,
Hodgdon, L. Q. 154 LeVasseur, P. 92 121, 129, 131, 132, 164,
Holaway, R. M. 117 Levinson, B. 28, 30, 38 177, 179
Howlin, P. 27, 28 Lockyer, L. 173 Øyane, N. M. F. 47
Huitt, W. 51 Lovett, H. 24, 130
Hummel, J. 51
Hurlbutt, K. 96, 103, 115, 130, Paine, C. 14, 15, 46, 77, 78
139, 140, 141, 142, 143 Maiello, S. 23 Palmen, S. J. M. C. 27
Huws, J. C. 16, 44 Malcolm, D. 163, 167, 180 Park, C. L. 160, 161, 162
Manassis, K. 117, 119, 121 Parsons, S. 157
Marks, S. U. 152, 153, 154, 155 Perlman, L. 21, 22, 36, 39, 40,
Jackson, H. J. 122, 123, 128, Martin, I. 40, 53, 60, 65, 66, 41, 42, 43, 44, 172, 174
180 108 Piacentini, J. 120, 134, 135,
Jacobsen, P. 14–16, 21–3, 49, Maurice, C. 32 136, 180
59, 61–3, 72, 95, 124 McDonald, S. 40, 53, 60, 65, 66, Plaisted, K. 153
Janzen, J. E. 21, 23, 25, 29, 32, 108 Plumb, I. 172
34, 41, 45, 113, 120 McGrath, P. 69 Ponnet, K. 152
Jarrold, C. 66 McLellan, J. 106, 119 Portway, S. 36, 37, 42, 81, 85,
Johnson, B. 36, 37, 42, 81, 85, McNerney, E. 22 103, 104, 177
103, 104, 177 Meldal, T. O. 138, 143, 144 Powell, S. 56–7
Jones, J. P. R. 46 Mendlowitz, S. 117 Powell-Smith, K. A. 156
Jones, R. 153 Messer, D. 56–7 Prado de Oliveira, L. E. 23
Jones, R. S. 44, 159 Meyer, R. N. 14, 15, 40, 41, 85, Presentación, M. J. 99, 165, 180,
Jones, R. S. P. 16, 42, 44, 45, 95, 116, 124, 144, 158, 181, 182, 183
138, 143, 144, 159 171, 174, 177 Prestwood, S. 14, 85
Jordan, R. 56–7 Meyers, R. E. 111 Price, L. A. 139–40
Millward, C. 56–7 Proctor, H. G. 93
Miranda, A. 99, 165, 180, 181,
Kabat-Zinn, J. 164 182, 183
Kanner, L. 21 Mitchell, P. 157 Quigney, C. 44
Kassinove, H. 181 Mizuno, A. 26–7 Quill, K. 21, 22, 23, 29, 32
Keenan, M. 159 Molen, J. 28, 30, 38 Quinn, C. 100, 118
Kellner, M. 12, 84, 126, 180, Moore, D. 69, 157
181, 182, 183 Mostofsky, S. H. 26
Kelso, S. E. 153 Raja, M. 46
Moynahan, L. 126, 177, 181, Rasmussen, C. 70
Keltner, D. 151 182, 183, 184
Kenardy, J. 69 Raste, Y. 172
Müller, E. 140, 141, 142 Raymaekers, R. 44, 74, 138,
Kendall, P. C. 116 Muller, R. A. 26
Kerr, S. 62, 91, 155, 179 145, 159, 179, 181
Müller, R. A. 26–7 Reaven, J. 116, 133, 134, 135,
Kincaid, D. 156 Mulligan, R. 139–40
Koegal, L. K. 22, 122 136, 180
Mullins, J. L. 159, 166 Renna, R. 24
Koegal, R. L. 22, 122, 180
Koller, R. 149, 150 Rodebaugh, T. L. 117, 123, 124,
Krauss, M. 104 Nesbitt, S. 139, 142, 143 166
Kremer-Sadlik, T. 152 Newman, M. G. 69 Roe, K. 116
Kring, A. M. 151 Nikopoulos, C. K. 159 Roers, H. 44
Author Index 207
Tani, P. 46, 47
Taylor, C. B. 69
Teunisse, J. P. 34, 65, 66, 108
Thorpe, J. 69
Toichi, M. 56
Tolin, D. F. 133
Travis, L. L. 178
Trillingsgaard, A. 156
Tsatsanis, K. 32, 34, 35, 36, 37,
40, 50, 63, 66, 108, 153
Tutin, J. 12, 84, 126, 180, 181,
182, 183