Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diouf 2023
Diouf 2023
https://doi.org/10.1093/jme/tjad126
Research
Senegal has experienced periodic epidemics of dengue in urban areas with increased incidence in recent
years. However, few data are available on the local ecology of the epidemic vectors. In October 2021, a dengue
outbreak was reported in northern Senegal to the Institute Pasteur de Dakar. Entomologic investigations then
were undertaken to identify the areas at risk of transmission and to identify the vector(s). Adult mosquitoes
were collected indoors and outdoors at selected households, while containers with water were inspected
for mosquito larvae. All the Aedes aegypti (L.) collected were tested for dengue virus NS1 protein using a
rapid diagnostic test (RDT), and positive samples were confirmed by real-time RT–PCR. The qRT–PCR posi-
tive samples were subjected to whole genome sequencing using Nanopore technology. The majority of the
larvae-positive containers (83.1%) were used for water storage. The Breteau and Container indices exceeded
the WHO-recommended thresholds for the risk of dengue virus transmission except at 2 localities. Ae. aegypti,
the only reputed dengue vector, was collected resting indoors as well as outdoors and biting during the day
and night. The NS1 protein was detected in 22 mosquito pools, including one pool of females emerging from
field-collected larvae. All NS1-positive results were confirmed by RT-PCR. Virus serotyping showed that the
outbreak was caused by DENV-1. This study demonstrates the need for continuous control of adult and aquatic
stages of Ae. aegypti to prevent future dengue epidemics in Senegal. RDTs appear to be a promising tool for
dengue diagnostics and surveillance.
© The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Entomological Society of America. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: 1
journals.permissions@oup.com.
2 Journal of Medical Entomology, 2023, Vol. XX, No. XX
Graphical Abstract
fill this gap, a rapid entomological response was conducted after a Mosquito Sampling
human case of DENV-1 was detected in the city of Rosso, northern During this entomological survey, which was carried out at the same
Senegal, in October 2021 (Keita et al. 2022). The objectives of this time as the epidemiological studies, 107 suspected cases were re-
study were to assess vector abundance and behavior and to estimate corded, 102 of which were confirmed as DENV (Dieng et al. 2022).
the entomologic indicators for dengue transmission risk in the af- Sampling of immature and adult mosquitoes was conducted in-
fected areas and neighborhoods to generate recommendations for door and outdoor of houses of confirmed dengue cases, their imme-
the most appropriate control strategies. diate neighborhoods (the 4 houses located in front of, behind, to the
left, and to the right of the confirmed cases’ houses), opportunisti-
cally selected houses, and shops for used tires, which are frequently
Materials and Methods used by Ae. aegypti as larval habitats.
Fig. 1. Collection sites for aquatic and adult samples of Aedes aegypti, Richard-Toll district, October 2021.
4 Journal of Medical Entomology, 2023, Vol. XX, No. XX
(Biogents AG, Regensburg, Germany) per house baited with dry coding sequence (CDS) was amplified in 2 separate reactions using
ice and BG-Lure, with one set indoors and one set outdoors in Q5 high fidelity 2× master mix (New England Biolabs County Road,
bedrooms. Ipswich, MA, USA). Amplicons of expected 1 kb size were visualized
on agarose gels and purified using Ampure beads (Beckman Coulter)
Sample Processing in the Field at a 1:0.8 ratio. For sequencing, the Rapid Barcoding Kit 96 (SQK-
The collected larvae were transferred to labeled bottles and transported RBK110.96) was used to tag purified amplicons following the
to the field station. Immature mosquitoes sampled from each type of manufacturer’s instructions. A blank control sample was included.
water container were reared to adults and identified morphologically The libraries were quantified, normalized, pooled, and loaded
on a chill table using appropriate keys (Edwards 1941, Huang 2004). onto Oxford Nanopore MinION platform R9.4.1 flow cells (FLO-
Water containers where Ae. aegypti mosquitoes emerged were con- MIN106D). Guppy was used to “base-call” the sequencing reads,
Mosquitoes Collected as Adults resting indoors (0.9 ± 1.6 females per house) than outdoors (0.5
A total of 11,936 adult mosquitoes belonging to 4 genera and 14 ± 2.1 females per house; Fig. 3A; W = 7303, P < 0.0001). Females
species was collected by all sampling methods. A. aegypti, the only were collected host-seeking in statistically similar numbers in-
reputed dengue vector collected in the area, accounted for 13.4% of doors (38.1 ± 109.5 females per trap) and outdoors (5.1 ± 7.3
the mosquitoes collected (Table 1). females per trap; W = 49, P = 0.5). A. aegypti appeared to seek
blood meals during both the day and night, mainly within indoor
Abundance and Behavior of A. aegypti rooms (Fig. 3B). The epidemic vector was also collected resting
In the district Richard-Toll, 92.6% (673 females and 560 males, N indoors (4.7 ± 4.1 females per shop) and outdoors (4.2 ± 5.0
= 1,331) of adult Ae. aegypti were collected in 53.3% of the 166 females per shop) in comparable numbers at tire repair shops
houses investigated. Statistically more Ae. aegypti were collected (W = 49, P = 0.7).
Table 1. Adult mosquitoes collected by aspiration, BG traps, and emerging from larvae, Richard-Toll District, October 2021
Sampling methods
Aedes aegypti (Linnaeus, 1762) 260 259 129 141 343 469 1601
Anopheles coustani Laveran, 1900 — — — — 0 5 5
Anopheles gambiae Giles, 1902 51 142 — — 23 19 235
Anopheles pharoensis Theobald, 1901 1 3 — — 0 74 78
Anopheles rufipes Gough, 1910 0 1 — — 0 1 2
Anopheles sp - - — — 0 2 2
Anopheles ziemanni Grünberg, 1902 0 2 — — 0 2 4
Culex antennatus (Becker, 1903) 0 6 — — 0 151 157
Culex neavei Theobald, 1906 0 3 — — 0 1 4
Culex poicilipes (Theobald, 1903) 0 1 — — 0 22 23
Culex quinquefasciatus Say, 1823 2184 2168 44 91 2701 1534 8722
Culex tritaeniorhynchus Giles, 1901 64 152 0 2 27 826 1071
Mansonia africana (Theobald, 1901) — — — — 0 17 17
Mansonia uniformis (Theobald, 1901) 0 2 — — 0 13 15
Total 2560 2739 173 234 3094 3136 11936
DENV Detection by RDTs and RT-PCR comparable with the exception of Santhiaba 3 and Santhiaba 4,
The results of the antigenic tests showed that 14 of the 24 super which had a higher IRs compared to Santhiaba 1 (Table 2). All the
pools (comprising 57 female and 29 male pools) were positive for resting DENV-infected females were collected indoors. Statistically,
dengue NS1 protein. Individual pool tests showed that all of the more DENV-infected females Ae. aegypti were collected host-seeking
male pools were negative, whereas 22 of the 57 female pools were outdoors (13 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested) than in-
positive for DENV NS1, including 15 unfed + gravid female pools, doors (1 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested).
6 blood-fed pools and 1 pool adult females that emerged from field- In tire workshops, the 3-positive pools came from 2 of the 6
collected larvae. All of these NS1-positive samples were confirmed neighborhoods investigated: Diamagène (2 pools collected indoors)
by real-time DENV RT-PCR. and Santiaba 1 (1 pool collected outdoors) with IRs of 54 and 170
Among 22 DENV-positive samples, 15 were successfully infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested, respectively. IRs in tire
serotyped as DENV-1; 7 failed to be serotyped. Serotypes 2, 3, or 4 workshops (IR = 75.4 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested)
of DENV were not detected. were statistically higher compared to houses (IR = 2.1 infected
mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested).
The IR of blood-fed females (IR = 2.2 infected mosquitoes/1,000
Phylogenetic Analysis
mosquitoes tested) was significantly higher than that of unfed +
The Maximum Likelihood (ML) tree (Fig. 4) revealed that all the gravid females (IR = 0.5 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes
sequences obtained during this entomological investigation belonged tested).
to DENV-1/Genotype V and to the same clade as determined for Analysis of 22 pools comprised of 270 adult Ae. aegypti emerging
samples from human cases detected in Rosso during this outbreak from larvae collected in Cité Niakh, Diameguene, Medina, Santhiaba
(Dieng et al. 2022). Interestingly strains from this cluster were dif- 1, 2, 3, and 4 detected NS1 protein in 1 pool of 8 female mosquitoes
ferent from strains sequenced during previous DENV-1/Genotype collected in a water storage container in Santhiaba 4. These results
V outbreaks in Senegal which occurred in the Louga area. These were confirmed by RT–PCR detection of DENV-1 in the same pool.
results confirmed that DENV-1 was responsible of the Rosso epi- The IR was 0.2 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested.
demic. Furthermore, our results showed that circulating strains in
Rosso are closely related to strains circulating in Burkina Faso (ac-
cession number: MW243050.1) and Cote d’Ivoire (MW243052.1) Discussion
in West Africa.
A. aegypti, currently the only known vector of dengue in urban areas
of Senegal, was the only Aedes species collected in this study. This
Infection Rates of Mosquitoes species immature stages frequently were collected in water storage
Table 2 shows the IRs of Ae. aegypti mosquitoes tested by RT-PCR containers that are known to be suitable larval habitats in domestic
and collected as adults in houses and tire repair shops. Overall, environments (Koenraadt and Harrington 2008, Guindo‐Coulibaly
the IR was 2.5 infected mosquitoes/1,000 mosquitoes tested in the et al. 2022). Indeed, the long-term storage of drinking water or water
communes of Rosso Senegal. for domestic use from these containers that are constantly filled and
Household IR ranged from 39 infected mosquitoes/1,000 poorly sealed accounted for their high infestation rate compared to
mosquitoes tested in Santhiaba 4 to 1 infected mosquito/1,000 other domestic aquatic sites (Konan et al. 2013). Although water
mosquitoes tested in Santhiaba 1. These IRs were statistically storage containers were the main sites infested, the presence of
Journal of Medical Entomology, 2023, Vol. XX, No. XX 7
Fig. 4. Maximum likelihood (ML) tree based on nearly complete genome sequencing (coding region without UTRs) showing phylogenetic relationships among
DENV-1 strains from field collected mosquitoes during the Rosso outbreak in 2021 and DENV sequences from GenBank. Tips are labelled using Sequence
identifier, Region/ Country of sampling and the Year of collection. DENV serotypes labels are placed on each serotype parental nodes.
numerous used tires and dry abandoned containers in the domestic Our study showed that, more than 15 days after the last rain
environment suggests that they may have played an important role and during high ambient temperatures, BI and CI were above
in Ae. aegypti ecology during the rainy season that ended two weeks the epidemic risk threshold, with the exception of Rosso-peulh
before our survey. and Mbagam, indicating that most neighborhoods were at risk
8 Journal of Medical Entomology, 2023, Vol. XX, No. XX
Table 2. Infection rates of resting and host-seeking Aedes aegypti populations infected with dengue virus, Richard-Toll District, October
2021
Position
Indoor Outdoor
Sites Localities Method N.M N.P P.P IR CI 95% N.M N.P P.P IR CI 95% Global IR [CI]
NM: number of mosquitoes tested; NP: number of pools tested; PP: positive pools, IR: infection rate; IC 95%: confident interval at 95%.
Totals represent all 151 mosquito pools tested.
for DENV transmission. With the increasing burden of dengue al. 2018). Therefore, used tires shops should be included in surveil-
worldwide, identification of specific areas with the highest risk of lance and control programs for Ae. aegypti-borne viruses.
epidemics is of paramount importance in prioritizing resource- Molecular serotyping confirmed DENV-1 as the etiologic agent
intensive interventions (Bowman et al. 2014). This requires a good of this outbreak, suggesting that DENV-1 replaced DENV-2, that
knowledge of the resting and host-seeking behavior of the epidemic was responsible for the 2018 outbreak in Rosso (Dieng et al. 2022).
vector in the affected area. In our study, Ae. aegypti was found The introduction of this new serotype combined with other factors
resting both indoors and outdoors, as previously described in south- such as the increasing urbanization of Rosso and the strong pres-
eastern Senegal (Diallo and Diallo 2020); however, all the resting ence of Ae. aegypti could explain, in part, the high prevalence of
DENV-infected females were collected indoors. The host-seeking dengue (Keita et al. 2022) during this outbreak. Results from our
females were collected both indoors and outdoors, with higher IRs phylogenetic analysis confirmed previous findings, highlighting
outdoors. These resting and host-seeking behaviors of the epidemic that the 2021 Rosso epidemic was caused by DENV-1 (Dieng et al.
vector, which may vary among geographical areas (Diarrassouba 2022). Clustering of human strains and those from field-collected
and Dossou-Yovo 1997, Chadee 2013, Dzul-Manzanilla et al. 2016, mosquitoes highlights the occurrence of ongoing active transmission
Labbo et al. 2019, Captain-Esoah et al. 2020), may guide efficient at the time of our investigation, as well as the role of Ae. aegypti in
and effective vector control interventions for dengue risk reduction DENV transmission in Rosso. These findings corroborate previous
and outbreak mitigation. results indicating the rising regional endemic circulation of DENV,
The higher IR in blood-fed compared to unfed females indicated as our sequences grouped with limited DENV-1 sequences available
that a portion of the positive females likely had DENV in their blood from other parts of West Africa.
meal and were not truly infected. This finding suggests the possibility Our results also showed that the GADx prototype DENGUE-NS1
of using blood-fed female mosquitoes (all species) for early detection rapid test had very good sensitivity (i.e. 100%) towards DENV NS1
of DENV and other pathogens circulating in human populations protein in mosquitoes collected directly in the field when using
(Cameron and Ramesh 2021). RT–PCR as a reference method. These results were comparable to
Resting Ae. aegypti adults were collected inside and outside of previous data obtained by Tan et al. (2011), who showed that the
workshops. These locations possibly were critical sources of prolif- Dengue NS1 Ag Strip kit to was able to detect all 4 DENV serotypes
eration, maintenance, and dispersal of the vector. Indeed, the tires in laboratory-infected and wild-collected Ae. aegypti and was as
exposed outside shops are often productive oviposition and larval sensitive as real-time RT–PCR. In another study, Voge et al. (2013)
habitats for Ae. aegypti (Lounibos et al. 2002, Bennett et al. 2019, showed that detection of DENV infection using the Platelia Dengue
González et al. 2020) and indoor tire storage also provides a good NS1 Ag kit was more sensitive than RT–PCR and laboratory virus
resting place for adult mosquitoes (Diallo and Diallo 2020). The isolation. Abraham et al. (2021) also showed that a commercially
detection of DENV in mosquitoes collected in these abundant tire available Dengue NS1 antigen kit (J. Mitra & Co. Pvt. Ltd) was
workshops with higher IRs compared to those observed in houses, highly sensitive and specific towards for the detection of recombi-
indicated that they may play an important role in the spread of nant dengue virus-2 (rDENV-2) NS1 protein in serum of dengue-
DENV in Senegal. In addition, these tires act as mobile reservoirs of infected patients or spiked Ae. aegypti pools. Our results strongly
mosquito eggs and larvae, and their trade could be responsible for indicate that DENV RDTs are cheaper and easier to use and are
the introduction of DENV into disease-free areas considering the promising tools for the surveillance of DENV in areas where special-
vertical transmission that was detected in our study (Pliego Pliego et ized research laboratories are not available. Thus, these RDTs could
Journal of Medical Entomology, 2023, Vol. XX, No. XX 9
allow vector control programs to better target interventions to areas Supervision [Equal], Writing – review & editing [Equal]), El hadj
of highest risk or of ongoing epidemics, and to respond quickly and Ndiaye (Investigation [Equal], Methodology [Equal], Validation
more effectively to the emergence of DENV in new areas with sus- [Equal], Writing – review & editing [Equal]), Moufid Mhamadi
ceptible human populations. (Methodology [Equal], Resources [Equal], Writing – review & editing
The detection of DENV-1 in adult mosquitoes emerging from [Equal]), Assiyatou Gueye (Methodology [Equal], Writing – review
larvae in domestic settings indicates that virus is transmitted vertic- & editing [Equal]), Oumar Ndiaye (Resources [Equal], Validation
ally to the offspring of infected female mosquitoes, which act not [Equal], Writing – review & editing [Equal]), Ndeye Sene (Writing –
only as vectors but also as reservoirs of the virus (Fontenille et al. original draft [Equal], Writing – review & editing [Equal]), Faty SY
1997, Ibáñez‐Bernal et al. 1997). This mechanism of maintaining (Writing – original draft [Equal], Writing – review & editing [Equal]),
DENV in nature via Aedes eggs is a well-known phenomenon in Oumar Faye (Resources [Equal], Validation [Equal], Writing – review
Buckner EA, Alto BW, Lounibos LP. Vertical transmission of key West Edwards FW. Mosquitoes of the Ethiopian Region. III.-Culicine adults and
Dengue-1 virus by Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus (Diptera: Culicidae) pupae. British Museum London (Natural History); 1941. p. 6.
mosquitoes from Florida. J Med Entomol. 2013:50(6):1291–1297. https:// Faye O, Ba Y, Faye O, Talla C, Diallo D, Chen R, Mondo M, Ba R, Macondo E,
doi.org/10.1603/me13047 Siby T, et al. Urban epidemic of dengue virus serotype 3 infection, Senegal,
Cameron MM, Ramesh A. The use of molecular xenomonitoring for surveil- 2009. Emerg Infect Dis. 2014:20(3):456–459. https://doi.org/10.3201/
lance of mosquito-borne diseases. R Soc B. 2021:376(1818):20190816. eid2003.121885
https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2019.0816 Ferreira-de-Lima VH, Lima-Camara TN. Natural vertical transmis-
Captain-Esoah M, Kweku Baidoo P, Frempong KK, Adabie-Gomez D, Chabi sion of dengue virus in Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus: a system-
J, Obuobi D, Kwame Amlalo G, Balungnaa Veriegh F, Donkor M, Asoala atic review. Parasit Vectors. 2018:11(1):77. https://doi.org/10.1186/
V, et al. Biting behavior and molecular identification of Aedes aegypti s13071-018-2643-9
(Diptera: Culicidae) subspecies in some selected recent yellow fever out- Fontenille D, Diallo M, Mondo M, Ndiaye M, Thonnon J. First evidence of
to discriminate primary from secondary dengue during acute sympto- Sokhna C, Gautret P. The Grand Magal of Touba in the time of a dengue out-
matic infection. BMC Infect Dis. 2018:18(1):375. https://doi.org/10.1186/ break in Senegal. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2019:28:107–108.
s12879-018-3274-7 Tan C-H, Wong P-SJ, Li M-ZI, Vythilingam I, Ng L-C. Evaluation of the dengue
Phommasone K, Sengvilaipaseuth O, Lamballerie X. de, Vongsouvath M, NS1 Ag Strip® for detection of dengue virus antigen in Aedes aegypti
Phonemixay O, Blacksell SD, Newton PN, Dubot-Pérès A. Temperature (Diptera: Culicidae). Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2011:11:789–792.
and the field stability of a dengue rapid diagnostic test in the tropics. Am J Taufflieb R. Enquete sur Ie vecteur urbain de fievre jaune Aedes aegypti dans
Trop Med Hyg. 2015:93:33–39. 1’ouest du Sénégal. Multigraph. Doc. Dakar: ORSTOM, 2094/ R.T; 1972.
Pliego Pliego E, Velázquez-Castro J, Eichhorn MP, Fraguela Collar A. Increased ef- p. 20.
ficiency in the second-hand tire trade provides opportunity for dengue control. Thiam D, Niang M, Dia N, Sarr FD, Goudiab D, Senghor ML, Kiori D, Faye T,
J Theor Biol. 2018:437:126–136. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtbi.2017.10.025 Espie E, Ba IO, et al. Influenza sentinel surveillance network improvement
Robin Y, Cornet M, Heme G, Le Gonidec G. Isolement du virus de la dengue in Senegal and results. Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 2014:108(1):21–24. https://