Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7501 - Module1 - Sample Assignment
7501 - Module1 - Sample Assignment
Code - Sample
& Title
Table of Content
SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION 6
Reference list 17
Appendix 1 18
Appendix 2 20
Appendix 3 21
Appendix 4 22
Appendix 5 23
Appendix 6 24
Appendix 7 25
Appendix 8 26
Appendix 9 27
Appendix 10 28
Appendix 11 27
SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION
This critical reflection will focus upon and explore the development of my practice and
the nature of my professional responsibilities as a subject leader. I aim to do this
through both current and previous leadership experiences within Physical Education
(PE) and through my involvements among supporting other educational areas. This
reflection should further showcase and critically analyse my previous teaching and
education experiences, across a number of different settings and educational
environments. I will have a specific emphasis on my personal understandings of
relevant teaching theories, learning theories, pedagogies and leadership approaches
that have helped me.
Additionally, this essay and professional portfolio, should provide an insight into how I
currently have such a vital part, in supporting the growth and professional development
of not just myself, but most importantly the teachers within my field. I will try to relate
to the appropriate references and academic journals, in hope that this will support and
showcase my critical approach to developing my own practice through leadership,
especially in current and uncertain times within education.
It is a fundamental for all subjects across education to have the necessary tried and
tested practices, leadership approaches and ideologies, to reach the much wanted
standard of ‘outstanding’ (Beere, 2002). Ofsted in the UK, claim that the components
above, are some of key ingredients for success in education and within lessons.
Ofsted, also elaborate on other elements such as, teachers having the knowledge and
understanding of behaviour management, differentiation and assessment for learning
to help create educational success (Beere, 2002). These areas, most definitely allow
for reflective actions and I will relate more to this in other sections, with regards to ‘in
action’ and ‘on action’.
To the above elements and from my experiences, I firmly agree with what inspection
bodies, such as Ofsted and Irtiqaa suggest as paramount elements. However, upon
reflection, I believe that one of the most forefront proficiencies that a teacher should
learn, is the ability to reflect upon and to be able to create an effective learning
environment. Boyes (2003) details that this capability of reflecting and creating the
right learning environment is “special” for teachers, both personally and professionally
for success.
From my current job perspective, I am the person who observes and gives the
feedback to teachers and other leads, with a strategic approach in mind. I believe that,
I have only got to this stage of my professional career, by being able to take in and
understand educational processes and procedures that are required. I have done this
through having a thoughtful and open mind to developing my own practice, which links
heavily to critical reflection within education.
I feel that I can relate strongly, to John Dewey’s (1933) theory, which communicates
the substantial need for having a thoughtful approach within education. He centres this
upon reflective activity of an individual and the fact that this can, then bring new
situations from present ones. Dewey’s five stages of reflection is one of the most
notable within education and I have given a brief of these stages below to show my
understanding;
I have experienced myself and now understand that from a leadership point of view,
knowledge is not enough. I have openly tried to lead other teachers to the benefit of
understanding that such approaches to reflection can help develop their practice
further. There are many educators and teachers that will be able accelerate their
practice by simply understanding and thinking about the Dewey’s five stage approach
and the importance of reflection.
I relate to this, to not only help outline the importance of my analysis within this piece,
but to support my understanding of the relevant and current literature used for
education. Current literature profoundly supports the need for the ‘professional
portfolios process’ in practice and reflection. The portfolio process, breaks down into
many different aspects (Barret 2000), and to support this, below I have given details
based upon the work covered by Charlotte Danielson. This is something that again, I
can definitely relate to within my current job, as I use Danielson’s frameworks with all
teachers and understand that this framework connects to what Dewey and Schon
theoretically underpinned.
To critique this further, in other sections of this essay, I will show how Danielson’s
‘teaching framework’ and this portfolio process, are forefronts of my practice and that
they are one of the most notable tools for reflection. Adding reference to this, appendix
1 demonstrates how the portfolios are used and shared with me, by my teachers.
To further analyse what I have already specified, I can reflect and relate back to
situations from when I was a teacher, a coach and an educator, and how I have learned
and developed through various stages.
One of the first reflection points for me, as an education practitioner, came from the
transitional changes that I went through. I started my teaching journey over 7 years
ago, in a Further Education (FE) setting. I did this, transitioning from sports coaching
with young children, to then educating adults.
After that, I went into directing my own educational provision business, working with
all ages and delivering Continual Professional Development (CPD) for teachers,
through live PE delivery.
Having an understanding of the different teaching styles and approaches was vital and
something I could only do through professional reflection. In appendix 2, I have
attached an example and a copy of how I electronically used to update teacher
portfolios in the CPD process, on a week by week basis. This will show and connect
my pieces of evidence within the appendices and how my experiences have developed
my use of reflection in teaching and now leadership.
By identifying some of the issues that I have faced within my own teaching experiences
and from the transitions in different teaching scenarios, not only allows me the
awareness to critically analyse teachers that I currently work with, but it is massively
important knowledge for whole subject development (Cole and Knowles 2000). Being
able to recognise, acknowledge and reflect on what teachers actually go through, can
only be of value to my leadership skills (Horsford 2010).
I can again relate and link back to Schon (1984), as a leader of my subject and
elaborate on the association of his ‘in’ and ‘on’ reflective action theory. I can compare
such aspects as the portfolio process further and below I have created a table and
explained how each part is currently used within my practice and shows my
understanding from my working position in regards to teaching.
In action – Thinking and doing Things that might affect these factors
things dynamically, relying upon,
knowledge, skills and judgement.
Following teacher expectations In an ideal world, all teachers follow expectations and
and procedures guidelines. However, education reflection should dynamically
link to child centred learning and this has to be considered in
any learning environment (Sripraska, 2012). If it is not right for
the child or puts them in danger of any sort, change must
dynamically happen.
Behaviour management PE can sometimes be fast paced and competitive (Capel and
Piotrowski, 2013). Occasionally these elements contribute and
lead to misbehaviour within classes and may even scupper
overall lesson objectives being met. How a teacher deals with
this should be again, in a dynamic way. However, with this
certain element is can also be a reflective ‘on’ action and can
be done afterwards.
Curriculum content, aims and Sometimes as a PE teacher you will need to take a step back
objectives. and watch the lesson from different viewpoints. This way offers
an opportunity to really take in the learning that is taking place.
Occasionally the curriculum content might not be working with
a certain class or group. Reflecting fast and changing the
content, aims or objectives of the lesson can ensure children
are fully engaged and stay on task of essentially learning.
Lesson evaluations
Lesson evaluations offer the best individual way for a teacher
to reflect. However, the reality of this, based upon a teacher’s
timeframe, is what I have experienced as being the most
difficult part. Teachers do not always get the time to evaluate
lessons and as a busy PE teacher, you already have so much
to do and to think about. Such as lesson planning, detailing
assessments, managing behaviours, creating school sports
competitions and much more. The reality can be, in the UAE,
that simple and effective reflecting, like a teacher should, is not
always an option. (Veal and Anderson, 2011).
I would like to highlight and relay back to one of the most important theories that I can
remember, from my time studying my BA hons. Kolb’s experiential learning cycle
(1984), had such a positive effect on my practice. Not only does this theory relate
massively to other pedagogies already mentioned within this piece, but it something I
have taken with me, into all my roles within education. I was a huge believer in being
creative with my lessons and planning. With the after aim of going away and reflecting
on the experience within lessons.
The interaction of critical and reflective thinking in Kolb’s experiential learning theory,
offers a framework to structure outcomes and objectives, which in hand, supplement
the learning experiences for students (Kolb 1984). As the example above, of me
always reflecting upon the experiences of lessons, this theory is clearly heavily
dependent on critical and reflective thinking, and as you will see from the points below,
I have given my own understanding of how this works;
“the framework for teaching embodies a number of features that ensure both
its validity and its applicability to wide range of instructional settings”
I agree, and from my experience, following this framework, it makes a difference to
teaching. Throughout the school year and as a subject, I focus heavily on teacher
reflection off the back of Danielson’s framework. Appendix 7, gives an example of a
formal observation that I have completed with a teacher. This shows the expectations
for every PE teacher and how I use the framework to not only assess, but to help
teachers to develop. Teachers can then add this to their electronic portfolio, giving
opportunity for constant review. To give another example of the features of teacher
reflection from my current role, you will see the strong connection of critical thinking
that is required professionally in appendix 8. This example shows how myself and one
of my new PE teachers have reflected and reviewed lesson plans. As part of a
supportive process, I have done this for the last the last 2 years, as he is new to
teaching. I have personally managed and monitored his portfolio, checking for
continuous reflection and professional development and constantly relating back to the
framework.
How can a teaching framework, help so much with reflection? It offers a structure and
a process for all to follow (Danielson, 2007).
If I consider the 4 domains from Danielson’s framework, I can see that each domain
has such specific relevance and importance to teaching and by the domain titles I can
also see that critical reflection is available in each area.
Domain 3: Instruction
(Danielson, 2007)
More notably in domain 4, there is a direct element of reflection. ‘4a’ has a whole focus,
called ‘Reflecting on teaching’.
As part of the ongoing leadership within my practice appendix 9 –shows the targets
that I have for one of my teachers based upon his performance and the what I believe
he is missing within his teaching, according to the framework. Appendix 1, shows how
he has gone away and evidenced targets within his portfolio and submitted the access
to me, from going away and understanding his framework.
Each of my previous jobs and experiences have been totally different and required a
huge amount of contemplation and thought. To look back at my tools of reflective
practice from working with young children, where success came from being able to get
to the different levels of the children (Jones 2006), was and is, completely different to
how you educate and get the best from adults. One of the best ways that I did this, is
that I had an awareness of my educational environment and I did this through SMART
target setting, which set objectives for me and allowed for reflection. As a teacher, this
has to be taken into account considerably and it was with future and previous lessons
in mind. This was one of the most important aspects of critical reflection for me in
teaching and is still the same within my leadership role. Especially when going through
such transitional stages.
With adults, safety became more of a perceptual factor, simply because they already
had the ability to review their own safety based upon their surroundings. The
responsibility of me as an educator or teacher within the learning environment, then
consisted of facilitating their learning requirements. There is no looking past the
pressures within education and that creating a ‘safe’ learning environment is an
enormous professional responsibility of teachers, educators, schools and institutions
(Fisher & Hawkins, 2013). Dealing with such pressures require both ‘in action’ and ‘on
action’ of reflective practice.
To justify this again, in my current role here in the UAE, Danielson’s framework is used
as a structured tool. Not only does this tool help recognise the importance of reflection,
but the thoughtfulness process required through individual and electronic subject
specific portfolios (Blanchard 2013). Appendices 3 and 4, again offer an example of
how I help teachers professionally and continuously maintain staff portfolios through
OneNote.
According to Hall (1992) there is very little doubt that the possible benefits of
professional development portfolios and structured tools of practice for individuals and
teachers are productive. Hall additionally claims, that professional portfolios are one
of the biggest advantages to reflective actions, and I can relate strongly again to the
already noted ‘portfolio process’.
Appendix 1 – shows and represents how different teacher portfolios are shared and
how Danielson’s framework is strongly linked.
Appendix 2
Appendix 4 – This screen shows how I gather evidence and maintain portfolios. All
staff including myself use Microsoft OneNote as a tool for reflection.
Appendix 5
Appendix 5 – This page show the type of lesson reflection I undertake with my
teachers. It indicates the steps of delivery taken during PD sessions with all staff.
Appendix 6
Appendix 6 – Evidence of the carousel that was created. The session was designed
and based upon on reflection for PD purposes, allowing staff to reflect and share
good practice.
Appendix 7
Appendix 7 – This
screen shows further
evidence of the
carousel that was
created. The session
was designed and
based upon on
reflection for PD
purposes, allowing
staff to reflect and
share good practice.
Appendix 8
Appendix 8 – Here you will see evidence of my strong relationship and the
leadership I have with one of my teachers. We sat down after the lessons to reflect
and adapt future lesson plans to suit class needs and teaching styles.
Appendix 9
Appendix 9 – This screen shows an example of how I set targets for teachers, by
using Danielson’s Framework
Appendix 10
Appendix 10 – This screen shows teachers sharing their evidence with me. I check
such posts on a regular basis and then discuss reflections with them.
Appendix 11