1.What is public debt? Discuss theories of public debt.

(10 marks)
Public debt is the total of unpaid deficits, which includes the sum that the government owes from past
years.Also public debt refers to the total amount of money that a government owes to external creditors
and its own citizens. It is the result of borrowing by the government through issuing bonds, bills, or
other securities to fund expenditures when its expenses exceed its revenue. Public debt can be
categorized into external debt (owed to foreign creditors) and domestic debt (owed to domestic
creditors).

• THE THEORIES OF PUBLIC DEBT.

Public debt is a complex economic concept that has been the subject of various theories and debates
among economists. Different schools of thought offer diverse perspectives on the implications, causes,
and consequences of public debt. Here are some prominent theories related to public debt:

1. THE RICARDIAN EQUIVALENCE

States that deficits are equivalent in their effects on consumption.

Lump-sum changes in taxes have no effect on consumer spending, and reduction in taxes leads
to an equivalent increase in savings. The reason is that, a consumer endowed with perfect
foresight recognizes that the government debt resulting from an increase or a reduction in taxes,
the present value of which is exactly equal to the present value of reduction in taxes. The
conditions required for Ricardian equivalence to hold are existence of infinite planning horizon,
certainty about future tax burdens, perfect capital markets (or the absence of borrowing
constraints), rational expectations, and non-discretionary taxes. The available empirical evidence for
developing and industrial countries has failed so far to provide much support for the Ricardian
equivalence hypothesis.

2. CLASSICAL THEORY:

Classical economists, like Adam Smith and David Ricardo, believed that public debt could be detrimental
to the economy. They argued that government borrowing could lead to higher interest rates, crowding
out private investment, and potentially causing inflation.

The classical view suggests that governments should avoid accumulating debt, and instead, focus on
fiscal discipline and balanced budgets.

3. KEYNESIAN THEORY:

Developed by John Maynard Keynes, this theory challenges the classical view. Keynes argued that during
economic downturns, governments should engage in deficit spending to stimulate demand and boost
the economy. In such situations, public debt is seen as a tool for managing the business cycle.

Keynesian economics suggests that public debt can be beneficial if used to fund productive investments
during economic slumps. The emphasis is on managing aggregate demand.
4. DEBT OVERHANG THEORY:

This theory suggests that excessive public debt can impede economic growth. When a government has a
high level of debt, it may be reluctant to undertake necessary fiscal reforms or invest in growth-
promoting activities due to concerns about the ability to service the debt.

The debt overhang theory implies that reducing public debt can be a prerequisite for sustainable
economic growth.

5. MODERN MONETARY THEORY (MMT):

MMT challenges the traditional view that governments must balance budgets. It argues that as long as a
country controls its own currency and inflation is in check, it can engage in deficit spending without
facing an imminent fiscal crisis.

MMT proponents argue that public debt is not necessarily a cause for concern, and governments should
focus more on managing inflation and unemployment.

6. LAFFER CURVE:

The Laffer Curve suggests that there is an optimal level of taxation beyond which increasing tax rates can
lead to a decrease in tax revenue. In the context of public debt, this theory implies that excessively high
levels of debt may hinder economic growth, making it difficult for governments to service their debt
through taxation.

The Laffer Curve is often invoked in discussions about finding the right balance between fiscal
responsibility and the need for government revenue.

Public debt is a multifaceted issue, and the appropriateness of different theories may vary depending on
economic conditions, policy context, and institutional factors. Policymakers often consider a
combination of these theories when formulating strategies for managing public debt.

2. WHAT ARE THE CAUSES OF PUBLIC DEBT? (10 marks)

Public debt can arise from a variety of factors, and it is often the result of a combination of economic,
fiscal, and policy-related influences. Here are some common causes of public debt:

1. FISCAL DEFICITS:

When a government's expenditures exceed its revenues, it incurs a fiscal deficit. To cover this gap, the
government may resort to borrowing, leading to the accumulation of public debt. Fiscal deficits can
occur due to various factors such as increased government spending, reduced tax revenues, or a
combination of both.

2. ECONOMIC DOWNTURNS:
During periods of economic contraction or recession, governments may experience lower tax revenues
and increased spending on social welfare programs and stimulus measures. Economic downturns often
result in decreased economic activity, leading to reduced government income and an increased need for
public spending to stimulate the economy.

3. WARS AND CONFLICTS:

Financing wars and dealing with the aftermath of conflicts can lead to a substantial increase in public
debt. Governments often borrow to fund military operations, reconstruction, and veterans' benefits.
The costs associated with military activities and post-war recovery can be significant, necessitating
borrowing to cover immediate expenses.

4. INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT:

Governments may borrow to finance large-scale infrastructure projects such as roads, bridges, and
public transportation systems. Infrastructure projects typically require substantial upfront investments,
and borrowing allows governments to spread the costs over an extended period.

5. SOCIAL WELFARE PROGRAMS:

Governments may accumulate debt to fund social programs such as healthcare, education, and
unemployment benefits. Providing social services to the population can be expensive, and if the
government does not generate enough revenue to cover these costs, borrowing may be necessary.

6. DEMOGRAPHIC CHALLENGES:

Aging populations and increased life expectancy can lead to higher pension and healthcare costs.
Governments may borrow to fund these obligations. As the proportion of elderly individuals in the
population grows, the financial burden of providing pensions and healthcare can strain government
budgets.

7. FINANCIAL CRISES:

Economic and financial crises may necessitate government interventions, including bailouts, stimulus
packages, and financial sector support. In times of financial instability, governments may need to borrow
to address the root causes of the crisis and stabilize the economy.

8. POLICY CHOICES:

Government policy decisions, such as tax cuts, increased public spending, or changes in regulatory
frameworks, can contribute to the accumulation of public debt. Policy choices that lead to reduced
revenue or increased spending without corresponding increases in income can contribute to budget
imbalances and the need for borrowing.

9. INTEREST RATE DYNAMICS:

Changes in interest rates can impact the cost of servicing existing debt and influence government
borrowing decisions. Rising interest rates can increase the cost of servicing outstanding debt and may
lead governments to borrow at higher interest rates, contributing to an increase in overall debt levels.

Public debt is a dynamic and complex phenomenon influenced by a range of economic, demographic,
and policy-related factors. Effective management of public debt requires careful consideration of these
factors and a balanced approach to fiscal policy.

3. WHAT ARE THE ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF PUBLIC DEBT ON A DEVELOPING COUNTRY LIKE KENYA? (10
marks)

The economic effects of public debt on a developing country like Kenya can be both positive and
negative, depending on how the debt is managed and utilized. Here are some potential economic
effects:

POSTIVE EFFECTS;

1. Infrastructure Development:

- If the borrowed funds are used to finance critical infrastructure projects, such as roads, bridges, and
energy facilities, it can stimulate economic growth and improve the country's long-term productivity.

2. Human Capital Investment:

- Public debt can be used to invest in education and healthcare, enhancing the country's human
capital. A well-educated and healthy workforce can contribute to increased productivity and economic
development.

3. Stabilization of the Economy:

- During economic downturns, deficit spending funded by borrowing can help stabilize the economy.
This counter-cyclical approach can mitigate the impact of recessions and promote recovery.

4. Technology and Innovation:

- Borrowing to invest in research and development, technology, and innovation can position a country
for long-term economic growth by fostering a more competitive and diversified economy.

5. Job Creation:

- Public debt-financed projects, particularly in infrastructure and other sectors, can create employment
opportunities, reducing unemployment and improving the standard of living for citizens.
NEGATIVE EFFECTS;

1. Debt Servicing Burden:

- If a significant portion of government revenue is allocated to servicing debt, it can limit the funds
available for essential public services such as healthcare, education, and social welfare programs,
potentially hindering overall development.

2. Crowding Out Private Investment:

- High levels of public debt can lead to higher interest rates, potentially crowding out private sector
investment. This occurs when the government competes with the private sector for available funds in
financial markets.

3. Currency Depreciation and Inflation:

- Excessive borrowing, especially in foreign currencies, can lead to a depreciation of the national
currency. This, in turn, can contribute to inflation, making imports more expensive and negatively
impacting the purchasing power of citizens.

4. Creditworthiness and Higher Borrowing Costs:

- A high level of public debt may result in a lower credit rating for the country, leading to higher
borrowing costs. This can create a cycle where the cost of servicing existing debt increases, further
exacerbating the debt burden.

5. Vulnerability to External Shocks:

- Countries with high levels of external debt may be more vulnerable to external economic shocks,
such as changes in global interest rates or commodity prices. This vulnerability can impact the country's
ability to manage its debt effectively.

6. Policy Constraints:

- High levels of public debt may constrain the government's ability to implement counter-cyclical fiscal
policies during economic downturns, limiting its capacity to stimulate growth.

7. Inter-Generational Equity Concerns:

- Excessive public debt may raise concerns about inter-generational equity, as future generations may
bear the burden of repaying debt incurred by earlier generations.

For a developing country like Kenya, it is crucial to strike a balance between leveraging debt for
productive investments and managing the associated risks. Prudent fiscal management, transparency,
and effective governance are essential to ensuring that public debt contributes positively to economic
development. It's also important for countries to implement policies that promote economic
diversification, revenue generation, and debt sustainability.

Roberts, R. O. (1942). Ricardo's theory of public debts. Economica, 9(35), 257-266.

Salsman, R. M. (2017). The political economy of public debt: three centuries of theory and evidence.
Edward Elgar Publishing.

Tsoulfidis, L. (2007). Classical economists and public debt. International Review of Economics, 54, 1-12.

Aybarç, S. (2019). Theory of public debt and current reflections. In Public economics and finance.
IntechOpen

Missale, A. (1999). Public debt management. Oxford University Press.