Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access.

This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Date of publication xxxx 00, 0000, date of current version xxxx 00, 0000.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.DOI

FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant


images for plant disease detection and
classification with deep learning
EMMANUEL MOUPOJOU1 , APPOLINAIRE TAGNE2 , FLORENT RETRAINT3 , ANICET
TADONKEMWA4 , DONGMO WILFRIED5 , HYPPOLITE TAPAMO6 , AND MARCELLIN
NKENLIFACK.7
1
Université de Technologie de Troyes, 10300 Troyes, France (e-mail: emmanuel.moupojou_matango@utt.fr)
1
Institut Universitaire Saint Jean du Cameroun, Cameroon (e-mail: emmanuel.moupojou@institutsaintjean.org)
2
Institut de Recherche Agricole pour le Developpement, Cameroon (e-mail: atagne2002@yahoo.com)
3
Université de Technologie de Troyes, 10300 Troyes, France (e-mail: florent.retraint@utt.fr)
4
Institut Universitaire Saint Jean du Cameroun, Cameroon (e-mail:anicet.tadonkemwa@institutsaintjean.org)
5
University of Dschang, Cameroon (e-mail: dongmowilfried@yahoo.fr)
6
University of Yaounde 1, Cameroon (e-mail: hippolyte.tapamo@facsciences-uy1.cm)
7
University of Dschang, Cameroon (e-mail: marcellin.nkenlifack@gmail.com)
Corresponding author: Emmanuel Moupojou (e-mail: emmanuel.moupojou_matango@utt.fr).
This work was partially supported by the Cooperation and Cultural Action Service (SCAC) of the French embassy in Cameroon, by Institut
Universitaire Saint Jean du Cameroun (IUSJC), and by Computer Science & Digital Society Laboratory (LIST3N) of Université de
Technologie de Troyes.

ABSTRACT The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations suggests increasing the food
supply by 70% to feed the world population by 2050, although approximately one third of all food is wasted
because of plant diseases or disorders. To achieve this goal, researchers have proposed many deep learning
models to help farmers detect diseases in their crops as efficiently as possible to avoid yield declines. These
models are usually trained on personal or public plant disease datasets such as PlantVillage or PlantDoc.
PlantVillage is composed of laboratory images captured under laboratory conditions, with one leaf each
and a uniform background. The models trained on this dataset have very low accuracies when running on
field images with complex backgrounds and multiple leaves per image. To solve this problem, PlantDoc
was built using 2,569 field images downloaded from the Internet and annotated to identify the individual
leaves. However, this dataset includes some laboratory images and the absence of plant pathologists during
the annotation process may have resulted in misclassification. In this study, FieldPlant is suggested as a
dataset that includes 5,170 plant disease images collected directly from plantations. Manual annotation of
individual leaves on each image was performed under the supervision of plant pathologists to ensure process
quality. This resulted in 8,629 individual annotated leaves across the 27 disease classes. We ran various
benchmarks on this dataset to evaluate state-of-the-art classification and object detection models and found
that classification tasks on FieldPlant outperformed those on PlantDoc.

INDEX TERMS Deep learning, Field images, Laboratory images, Plant disease dataset, Plant disease
detection and classification

I. INTRODUCTION because of plant diseases or disorders [3] [4]. In terms of


economic value, plant diseases alone cost approximately US$
HE global population is expected to reach 10 billion
T peole by 2050. Therefore, food production must absorb
this population growth, although the amount of available
220 billion annually [4].

Loss of crop yield is a major research concern. Plants die


arable land is limited [1]. The Food and Agriculture Orga- if their leaves cannot produce chlorophyll via photosynthesis
nization of the United Nations (FAO) suggests increasing because of diseases or disorders. Artificial Intelligence(AI)
the food supply by 70% to feed the future population by has been extensively considered to solve the problem of
2050 [2], while about one third of all grown food is wasted crop yield loss, particularly in the areas of Computer Vision

VOLUME 4, 2016 1

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

and Machine Learning. Therefore, many deep Convolutional individual leaf annotations across 27 disease classes. This
Neural Networks (CNN) have been proposed by researchers dataset is intended for researchers to build models that offer
for plant disease identification and classification; some of the practical solutions to farmers for plant disease identification
most popular CNN are highlighted by Adi et al. [5]. The and classification under real conditions.
purpose of these solutions is to provide farmers with a way
to identify diseases that attack plants as soon as possible and II. RELATED WORK
suggest countermeasures to avoid crop losses. A. PLANT DISEASE DETECTION DATASETS
The PlantVillage [2], iBean [6], citrus [7], rice [8], cassava Although there are several datasets related to plant diseases,
[9], and AI Challenger 2018 datasets [10] are among the most PlantVillage and PlantDoc remain the two most publicly
widely used plant disease datasets, with available laboratory available.
images. These datasets have been widely used to train CNN
for plant disease identification and classification. Neural 1) PlantVillage
networks trained on these datasets were able to achieve a PlantVillage [2] is the largest plant disease dataset. The initial
high classification accuracy during training. However, when data records for 2016 contained 54,309 images spanning
these systems were tested under real field conditions, their 14 crop species including- apple, blueberry, cherry, corn,
performance decreased sharply. This is because in contrast grape, orange, peach, bell pepper, potato, raspberry, soy-
to laboratory images, field images have complex background bean, squash, strawberry, and tomato. These expertly cu-
features, including other leaves, stems, fruits, soil, and mulch. rated images of healthy and infected crop leaves were made
Studies have demonstrated that complex backgrounds in field available through the existing online platform, PlantVillage
images significantly contribute to this drop in performance, (www.plantvillage.org). Diseases affecting these plants are
and that background removal can enhance disease recogni- divided into 17 fungal diseases, four bacterial diseases, two
tion accuracy [11]. mold (oomycete) diseases, two viral diseases, and one mite
Therefore, plant disease classification systems trained on disease. The dataset contains 38 classes of plant diseases and
laboratory images are not usable in practice owing to the one class of background images, as shown in Fig. 2.
structural difference between laboratory and field images This initial data setup was the beginning of an ongoing
[12] [13] [11]. Laboratory images were captured under con- crowdsourcing effort to enable computer vision approaches
trolled lighting and uniform background conditions, with to solve the problem of yield losses in crop plants owing to
each image containing only one leaf. Field images typically infectious diseases.
have several interwoven leaves, stems, branches, flowers, From fields with crops infected with the disease, techni-
non-leaf objects, and complex backgrounds, as illustrated in cians collected leaves by removing them from the plant and
Fig. 1. Li et al. [14] highlighted in their study the need to placing them against a paper sheet that provided a grey or
establish a large dataset of plant diseases in field conditions black background. All the images were captured under full il-
for plant disease detection. Indeed, researchers need to test lumination. Once the images were collected, they were edited
their models on datasets acquired from fields [15] to provide by cropping away much of the background and orientating
practical solutions to farmers to address crop losses. all leaves such that they tip pointed upward, as shown in Fig.
To address this challenge, Singh et al. [4] proposed a 3. The images from this dataset are referred to as laboratory
dataset of field images called PlantDoc, a dataset for visual images.
plant disease detection containing 2,598 data points across
13 plant species and up to 17 classes of diseases. Although 2) PlantDoc
it contains many laboratory images, PlantDoc has been used PlantDoc [4] is a dataset of 2,569 images across 13 plant
in some studies on plant disease detection, but has achieved species (apple, bell pepper, blueberry, cherry, corn, grape,
very low performance [13]. Because of the lack of extensive peach, potato, raspberry, soyabean, squash powder, straw-
domain expertise, some images in this dataset may be incor- berry, and tomato) and 30 classes (diseased and healthy) for
rectly classified [4]. The major challenge in plant disease image classification and object detection. The distribution of
identification from field images is to build a sufficiently images of plant species and diseases is shown in Fig. 4.
accurate model to identify the plant involved in the image PlantDoc contains field plant disease images downloaded
and the associated disease, which is a complicated task. from the internet and annotated to train models for detecting
In this study, we propose FieldPlant1 as a new dataset for crop diseases from field condition images, as shown in Fig.
the identification and classification of plant diseases from 5. Because the images in the dataset were downloaded from
field images captured under different lighting conditions. The the internet, they were generally of poor quality, and some
5,170 original images captured in plantations were annotated images contained leaves that had not been photographed on
using the RoboFlow on-line platform [16], to identify the plants and were more akin to laboratory images as shown
individual leaves. Some images had only one leaf to annotate in Fig. 6. However, for the annotations of images made
and others had multiple leaves to annotate, resulting in 8,629 without the assistance of plant pathologists, it is very likely
that annotation errors slipped into the dataset [4] because
1 https://universe.roboflow.com/plant-disease-detection/fieldplant certain plant diseases are very similar in appearance. Finally,
2 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

FIGURE 1. Some plant disease images under laboratory and field conditions [13]

FIGURE 2. Statistics of PlantVillage dataset leaves diseases [2]

B. PLANT DISEASE DETECTION MODELS


In contrast to conventional machine-learning techniques,
deep learning can automatically learn the hierarchical fea-
tures of pathologies. This eliminates the need to separately
design the morphological operations of feature extraction
for future classification. Therefore, we present the recent
research on convolution neural networks for plant disease
detection and classification.

FIGURE 3. Apple scab leaf from the PlantVillage dataset 1) Pre-built Models
In many cases, the authors used existing state-of-the-art con-
volutional neural networks to address the problem of plant
the number of annotated images in different categories is disease identification and classification. When the models
generally insufficient for training models that are capable of were not completely re-trained because of insufficient data
achieving high accuracy. or missing computational power, transfer learning was used
VOLUME 4, 2016 3

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

an accuracy of 79.19% in the detection and classification of


six rice leaf diseases: blast, bacterial leaf blight, brown spot,
narrow brown spot, bacterial leaf streak, and rice ragged stunt
virus disease. The experiment was conducted by using 6,330
self-collected images.

2) Authors-built Models
Often, specific constraints such as preprocessing steps, net-
work architecture, or dataset structure have led the authors to
suggest specific models for plant disease detection.
Asad et al. [22] proposed a 2-layers CNN model that
extracts complementary discriminative features from cit-
rus fruits and leaves by integrating multiple layers. The
model differentiated healthy fruits and leaves from fruits or
leaves with common citrus diseases, such as black spots,
canker, scab, greening, and melanose, with a test accuracy
of 94.55%. The dataset used in this study contained only 213
images from the PlantVillage [2] and Citrus [7] datasets.
The unwanted background and noise of the input image
can have a significant negative impact on the model accuracy.
To overcome this problem, the study in [23] used U 2 -Net
by first producing a mask of the region of interest from
FIGURE 4. Statistics of PlantDoc dataset leaves diseases [4]
the original image. Then, a bitwise operation was applied
to the original image and mask produced by U 2 -Net. The
EfficientNetV2 [24] model was used for cardamom plant
disease detection, achieving a detection accuracy of 98.26%.
To reduce the number of parameters of the model, Amin et
al. [25] used two pre-trained convolutional neural networks,
EfficientNetB0 and DenseNet121, to extract deep features
-
from corn plant images. The extracted deep features from
each CNN were then fused using the concatenation technique
to produce a more complex feature set, from which the
FIGURE 5. PlantDoc annotated model could learn the dataset better, achieving a classification
field tomato leaves image FIGURE 6. PlantDoc annotated
lab strawberry leaves image accuracy of 98.56% on a subset of the PlantVillage dataset.
To reduce the neural network training time, Sk et al. [26]
suggested a reduction in the model parameters based on the
to maintain the pre-trained weights and reduce computation inception layer, residual connection, and depth-wise separa-
time. ble convolution. The accuracies obtained for the PlantVillage,
To take advantage of existing neural networks trained rice [8] and cassava [9] datasets were 99.39%, 99.66%, and
on large datasets, stepwise transfer learning was used by 76.59%, respectively.
Ahmad et al. [12] on pre-trained neural networks to avoid Zhou et al. [27] proposed a hybrid deep learning model
negative transfer learning. They used MobileNetV2 [17] pre- that combines the advantages of deep residual networks and
trained weights to build the model and achieved 99% and dense networks to reduce the number of training process pa-
99.69% accuracy on the Pepper and PlantVillage datasets, rameters and improve calculation accuracy. The experimental
respectively. results show that this model can achieve a top-1 average
Elfatimi et al. [18] presented a deep learning approach for identification accuracy of 95% on the tomato test dataset in
classifying bean leaf diseases. The model was trained using the AI Challenger 2018 dataset [10].
MobileNetV2 [17] architecture under controlled conditions Wang et al. [13] suggested a dual-stream hierarchical
to obtain faster training times, higher accuracy, and easier bilear-pooling model for the multi-task classification of
retraining. To achieve these goals, the authors attempted plant diseases. The authors used fine-grained image recogni-
different hyper parameters and optimization methods. The tion methods to extract discriminative fine-grained features,
model achieved an accuracy of 97% for 1296 field images thereby enhancing the representation capability of the model.
taken from the iBean dataset [6]. The PlantDoc dataset [4] was used for the experiment, and
The YOLO [19] neural network has been one of the great- after optimizing multi-task learning using homoscedastic
est achievements in object detection in the field of Artificial uncertainty, the plant and disease accuracies obtained were
Intelligence. The study [20] used YoloV3 [21] ] and achieved 84.71% and 75.06%, respectively.
4 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

3) Practical solutions for plant disease detection major staple food in the developing world, providing a basic
Based on deep learning models, two main mobile apps for diet for over half a billion people [35].
plant disease detection have emerged in the community: The different diseases represented in the dataset for cas-
Plantix and PlantVillage Nuru. sava crops are as follow: Cassava Bacterial Disease Cassava
Plantix [28] is a smartphone application trained to identify Brown Leaf Spot, Cassava Healthy, Cassava Mosaic and
a large range of plant diseases. Users snap a cropped image Cassava Root Rot.
using their phone, which sends the image to the server to
perform an analysis using its on-line deep learning model. 2) Corn
The results are reported back to the phone with suggestions Corn has become a staple food in many parts of the world,
for suitable countermeasures. Although the image dataset and with the total production of corn surpassing those of wheat
the deep learning model of Plantix are not available, Gon- and rice. Corn is cultivated worldwide, and more corn is
charov et al. [29] conducted a study showing that the model produced each year than, any other grain. In 2021, total world
could identify plants with an accuracy of 87%. However, production was 1.2 billion tonnes [36].
only 10% of the diseased images had the correct disease at The different diseases represented in the dataset for corn
the top of their suggestions. Plantix also requires an internet crops are: Corn Leaf Blight, Corn Brown Spots, Corn Gray
connection to use image analysis features. This can be a Leaf Spot, Corn Charcoal, Corn Chlorotic Leaf Spot, Corn
limitation for farmers working in remote areas where internet Healthy, Corn Insects Damages, Corn Mildew, Corn Purple
access might not be available. Discoloration, Corn Rust leaf, Corn Smut, Corn Streak, Corn
PlantVillage Nuru [30]] is another smartphone app for Stripe, Corn Violet Decoloration, Corn Yellow Spots and
plant disease detection that was developed under the Corn Yellowing.
PlantVillage [4] Project. It uses a single-shot multibox de-
tector (SSD) with MobileNet to detect and classify plant 3) Tomato
diseases [31]. PlantVillage Nuru requests that the user submit Numerous varieties of tomatozq are grown in temperate
six plant leaves for better classification and can run without climates worldwide, with greenhouses allowing their pro-
an Internet connection. SSD detectors localize the diseased duction throughout all seasons of the year. Cameroon is
areas using bounding boxes. However, various studies [32] the world’s tenth largest tomato producer, with an estimated
[33] have reported that the accuracy of SSD detectors for annual production of 1,279,853 tons [37].
plant disease detection is low. Mrisho et al. [34] showed The different diseases represented in the dataset for cas-
that Nuru’s accuracy for symptom recognition when using sava crops are: Tomato Alternaria, Tomato Brown Spots,
six leaves (74-88%, depending on the condition) was similar Tomato Leaf Yellow Virus, Tomato Blight Leaf, Tomato Leaf
to that of experts, 1.5 times higher than agricultural extension Mosaic Virus, Tomato Rust, Tomato Sclerotinia, Tomato
agents and two times higher than that of farmers. Bacterial Wilt and Tomato Healthy.
A literature review of CNN used for plant disease identifi-
cation and classification is presented in Table 1. B. DATA COLLECTION WORKFLOW
Fig. 8 shows the workflow used for the FieldPlant dataset set
III. THE FIELDPLANT DATASET up.
We released FieldPlant, a plant disease dataset of 5,170 Crop disease images were collected from Zones 3 and 5 of
annotated field leaf images collected from the Cameroon the five agro-ecological zones in Cameroon (Fig. 9). Images
plantations. The dataset focuses on various diseases in three were collected under the supervision of plant pathologists
tropical cultures: corn, cassava, and tomato. To the best of our at different periods of the year and stages of plant growth.
knowledge, this is the first publicly available dataset for plant The aim of this procedure was to capture the most diseases
disease detection that uses annotated cassava images. This possible, given that we do not have the same crop diseases
dataset can be used to train efficient models for plant disease in different agro-ecological zones and that they often oc-
detection using field images and object-detection models. cur at different periods of the year. Images were captured
using smartphones with 4608 × 3456 (4:3) pixel-resolution
A. DATASET CROPS AND DISEASES cameras. This was done to benefit from the flexibility and
The distribution of Fieldplant images diseases is shown in autofocus. Leaf images were captured directly from plants
Fig. 7. with a full plantation background, and usually had more than
one leaf per image.
1) Cassava Once images are collected in the field, they are made
Cassava is a root vegetable that is widely consumed in available to the plant pathologist, who then groups them into
many countries worldwide. It is extensively cultivated as an folders according to the plant and the disease identified on the
annual crop in tropical and subtropical regions because of leaf. Blurred images or images irrelevant to the study were
its edible starchy tuberous root, which is a major source of ignored.
carbohydrates. Cassava is the third-largest source of food A data scientist used the RoboFlow online platform tool
carbohydrates in the tropics after rice and maize. Cassava is a (https://roboflow.com/) to annotate images. Each image was
VOLUME 4, 2016 5

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

No. Ref. Task Dataset Method Acc. Pros and Cons

1 Plant disease Pepper dataset MobileNetV2 99% High accuracies were reached but lab images used for
[12] detection PlantVillage 99.69% training

2 Classify beans 1296 field images MobileNetV2 97% Dataset images are individual leaves cut from the plant
[18] leaf disease from iBean and held in the hand

3 Detection and 6,330 field- YOLOv3 79.19% Low performance achieved


[20] classification collected images Mask RCNN 75.92%
of 6 rice leaf Faster R-CNN 70.96%
diseases RetinaNet 36.11%

4 Plant disease 213 images from 2-layers CNN 94.55% High accuracy on a small dataset
[22] detection PlantVillage and Lab images used for training, the model will have low
Citrus datasets performance with field images

5 Detection of 5 1724 Cardamom U 2 -Net 98.26% U 2 -Net is used for background removal to keep a single
[23] citrus fruits and field leaves EfficientNetV2 leaf on the image which is suitable for classification
leaves diseases

6 Corn leaf dis- PlantVillage EfficientNetB0 98.56% More complex features captured by fusion; Lab images
[25] ease classifica- DenseNet121 used for training, low performance expected on field
tion Features concate- images
nation

7 Plant disease PlantVillage CNN based 99.39% High accuracies achieved


[26] classification Rice on inception 99.66% Lab images used for training, low performance expected
Cassava layer, residual 76.59% on field images
connection
and depth-
wise separable
convolution

8 Tomato 13.185 images Hybrid CNN 95% Requires less computation to achieve high performance
[27] leaf disease from Tomato Lab images used for training, low performance expected
identification dataset on field images

9 Plant classifica- PlantDoc Dual-stream 84.71% Identify field plants and diseases
[13] tion hierarchical 75.06% Low accuracy
Disease classi- bilinear pooling
fication model

TABLE 1. Summary of plant disease detection models

FIGURE 7. Statistics of Fieldplant dataset leaves diseases

6 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

FIGURE 8. Fieldplant dataset setup workflow

FIGURE 11. Tomato multiple


FIGURE 10. Corn single leaf leaves image
image

images were annotated. If an error occurred, the image was


returned for the annotation.
The second level of validation was performed by an expert
pathologist before the publication of the dataset. This is a cru-
cial step in which experts check whether correct annotations
have been assigned to the identifiable leaves of each image.
If any error occurred, the image was sent back to the data
scientist for annotation.
FIGURE 9. Agro-ecological zones of Cameroon [38]
The images collected using this process are presented in
Table 2. The total number of images obtained following
direct collection in the plantations was 6334, but only 5,170
annotated by specifying the disease class in its leaves. Only were retained after the second phase of the process by elimi-
identifiable leaves in the image were annotated. If a leaf was nating inconsistent images.
not infected with a disease, it was assigned to the healthy
class. During annotation bounding boxes are used to specify IV. BENCHMARKING FIELDPLANT DATASET
the position of the leaf in the image. Figs. 10 and 11 show We ran various sets of experiments on the FieldPlant(FP)
annotated images in the Fieldplant dataset. dataset to evaluate the performance of the state-of-the-art
Before adding annotated images to the dataset, the annota- CNN in identifying leaves and diseases from the images.
tions were first checked to ensure that all identifiable leaves in We trained and evaluated the performances of four CNN
the image were effectively annotated or that non-identifiable (MobileNet [17], VGG16 [39], InceptionV3 [40], and Incep-
VOLUME 4, 2016 7

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

Agroecological zone Town Period Corn Cassava Tomato Total

Dschang & Bansoa Juilly 2022 116 35 84 235

Western High Plateau Dschang & Bamendou October 2022 481 288 236 1005

Dschang & Bansoa November 2022 0 0 478 478

Yaoundé June 2022 1375 539 84 1998

Bimodal Humid Forests Yaoundé October 2022 391 1131 0 1522

Batchenga December 2022 0 0 1096 1096

Total 2363 1993 1978 6334

TABLE 2. Distribution of collected images by areas

tionResNetV2 [41]) on our dataset. B. PLANT DISEASE IMAGE CLASSIFICATION


To compare our dataset with the existing PlantVillage(PV) 1) Classification from raw images
and PlantDoc(PD) datasets, we built another dataset called First, we attempted to determine the suitability of raw Field-
Cropped-FieldPlant (C-FP) by cropping the initial annotated Plant images for classification tasks, as shown in Table 3.
images with bounding box information. The cropped images To achieve this objective, the annotated image dataset was
contained only one leaf per image with varying backgrounds, converted into a Multi-Label Classification CSV dataset us-
and usually contained snippets from other leaves, as shown in ing RoboFlow2 . In this representation, the CSV file contains
Fig. 13 obtained from Fig. 12 after cropping annotated leaves. the names of the disease classes identified in each image of
After cropping the original 5,170 images, the total number of the dataset. Therefore, the models were trained to recognize
individual leaf images was 8,629. the disease(s) present in the image regardless of its (their)
position(s).
PV, PD, and FP represent PlantVillage, PlantDoc, and
FieldPlant datasets, respectively.

2) Classification from cropped images


The second benchmark evaluates the classification accuracy
on the Cropped images of FieldPlant (C-FP). The cropping
- operation was easily performed from the original annotated
dataset using pascalvoc-to-image3 tool.
For comparison, we also ran the classification models
against PlantVillage(PV) and Cropped PlantDoc(C-PD). C-
FIGURE 13. Tomato cropped PD was obtained from PlantDoc in the same way as described
images
previously. The accuracies of the different models for various
FIGURE 12. Tomato multiple datasets are presented in Table 4.
leaves image
C. PLANT LEAVES DETECTION
In our last set of experiments, we evaluated in Table 5 the
A. SYSTEM CONFIGURATION
performance of the object detection models on our dataset
All the models in our experiments were trained on a server
using COCO pre-trained weights. The aim of this experiment
with the following characteristics:5 GPU Tesla T4 with 16
was to determine how these models identified individual
GB RAM, 4 TB HDD, and 2 AMD EPYC 7251 CPUs with
leaves in the field images of the dataset at 50% IoU. The
512GB of RAM. Experiments were performed using a GPU
TensorFlow Object Detection API of the TensorFlow Model
for faster training.
Garden [42] was used for this evaluation.
To train the networks, we used sparse_categorical_crossentropy
loss and learning rates of 0.001 for training and 0.0001
V. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
for fine-tuning. Transfer Learning was used to improve the
Table 3 show how much difficult it is for classification
accuracy of the models. We used the weights provided in
CNN models to identify diseases on raw field images. As
Keras trained on ImageNet for the pre-trained models. All
the images were resized according to the CNN models before 2 https://roboflow.com/formats/multiclass-classification-csv

being fed into the network. 3 https://pypi.org/project/pascalvoc-to-image/

8 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

CNN Model Training Test Acc. CNN Model Training Test Acc.
set(%) set(%) set(%) set(%)

PV(100) PD(100) 16,75 PV(80) PV(20) 99,24

PD(80) PD(20) 60,14 C-PD(80) C-PD(20) 73,86


MobileNet
PV(100) FP(100) 61,92 MobileNet PV(100) C-PD(100) 23,32

FP(80) FP(20) 82,9 C-FP(80) C-FP(20) 85,55

PV(100) PD(100) 12,75 PV(100) C-FP(100) 36,58

PD(80) PD(20) 40,3 PV(80) PV(20) 92,85


VGG16
PV(100) FP(100) 15,27 C-PD(80) C-PD(20) 44,32

FP(80) FP(20) 80,54 VGG16 PV(100) C-PD(100) 15,13

PV(100) PD(100) 17,32 C-FP(80) C-FP(20) 73,04

PD(80) PD(20) 48,38 PV(100) C-FP(100) 48,62


InceptionResNetV2
PV(100) FP(100) 52,87 PV(80) PV(20) 92,96

FP(80) FP(20) 81,81 C-PD(80) C-PD(20) 58,59

PV(100) PD(100) 14,25 InceptionResNetV2 PV(100) C-PD(100) 25

PD(80) PD(20) 51,27 C-FP(80) C-FP(20) 71,88


InceptionV3
PV(100) FP(100) 43,85 PV(100) C-FP(100) 64,84

FP(80) FP(20) 82,54 PV(80) PV(20) 71,85

TABLE 3. Plant disease classification benchmark on raw images C-PD(80) C-PD(20) 44,82

InceptionV3 PV(100) C-PD(100) 22,69

C-FP(80) C-FP(20) 72,31


expected, when the training and test sets are the same, the
noise backgrounds and the multiplicity of leaves on the PV(100) C-FP(100) 47,19
raw images reduce the models validation accuracies. These
TABLE 4. Plant disease classification benchmark on cropped images
accuracies are further reduced when the models are trained on
PlantVillage and tested on PlantDoc or FieldPlant because of
the significant difference in the structure between the training
and test datasets. Recall that PlantVillage has single leaf per Object Detection Model mAP PD mAP FP
image with uniform background. However, we notice that the
results obtained with FieldPlant are far better than to those YoloV8 0,55 0,102
obtained with PlantDoc. This could be because Fieldplant
SSD Mobilenet V2 0,52 0,14
has more data for models training. The fact that PlantDoc
contains both field and lab images could also influence these Faster-rcnn-inception-resnet 0,58 0,144
results.
Experiments on the cropped images presented in Table 4 TABLE 5. Plant disease detection benchmark
show that very good results were obtained when the models
were trained and tested on PlantVillage, which had one leaf
per image, with a uniform background. These results were
less effective when the models were trained and tested on models were trained on PlantVillage and tested on Cropped
Cropped FiedPlant or Cropped PlantDoc. This is also due FieldPlant or Cropped PlantDoc because of the large gap
to the complex backgrounds of the cropped images, which between the image structures. Models fail to produce accu-
can not always match between two images even if they rate results owing to background noise and scrap leaves in
identify the same disease. The results were worse when the images. Similar to the previous experiment, we found that
VOLUME 4, 2016 9

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

the results obtained from evaluations involving FieldPlant [5] Manivarsh Adi, Abhishek Kumar Singh, Harinath Reddy, Yeshwanth
were significantly better than those obtained from evaluations Kumar, Venkata Reddy Challa, Pooja Rana, and Usha Mittal. An overview
on plant disease detection algorithm using deep learning. In 2021 2nd
involving PlantDoc. The same justifications can be invoked International Conference on Intelligent Engineering and Management
here. (ICIEM), pages 305–309. IEEE, 2021.
[6] Makerere AI Lab and AIR Lab National Crops Resources Research In-
The last set of experiments in object detection on the stitute (NaCRRI). iBean. https://github.com/AILab-Makerere/ibean/blob/
PlantDoc and FieldPlant datasets show that PlantDoc per- master/README.md, 2020. [Online; accessed 31-March-2022].
forms better in identifying individual leaves from raw images [7] Muhammad Sharif, Muhammad Attique Khan, Zahid Iqbal, Muham-
mad Faisal Azam, M. Ikram Ullah Lali, and Muhammad Younus Javed.
collected in the field. Object detection in complex back- Detection and classification of citrus diseases in agriculture based on
grounds remains a challenging task [43] [44] because most optimized weighted segmentation and feature selection. Computers and
current object detection deep learning models are based on Electronics in Agriculture, 150:220–234, 2018.
[8] Prabira Kumar Sethy. Rice leaf disease image samples. Mendeley Data, 1,
high-level CNN features, which usually fail to capture fine- 2020.
grained descriptions of objects. The presence of laboratory [9] David Opeoluwa Oyewola, Emmanuel Gbenga Dada, Sanjay Misra, and
images with uniform backgrounds in the PlantDoc dataset Robertas Damaševičius. Detecting cassava mosaic disease using a deep
residual convolutional neural network with distinct block processing.
significantly improves its performance in object detection.
PeerJ Computer Science, 7:e352, 2021.
On the other hand, some plant leaves appear only partially in [10] AI Challenger. AI Challenger 2018 Datasets. https://github.com/
some images of FieldPlant, and their annotation could have a AIChallenger/AI\_Challenger\_2018, 2018. [Online; accessed 01-April-
2022].
negative impact on object recognition and detection tasks.
[11] Lawrence C Ngugi, Moataz Abdelwahab, and Mohammed Abo-Zahhad.
More generally, the benchmark results allow us to high- Tomato leaf segmentation algorithms for mobile phone applications using
light that MobileNet CNN achieves relatively better accuracy deep learning. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 178:105788,
2020.
in classification tasks for the FieldPlant or PlantDoc datasets. [12] Mobeen Ahmad, Muhammad Abdullah, Hyeonjoon Moon, and Dongil
Han. Plant disease detection in imbalanced datasets using efficient con-
volutional neural networks with stepwise transfer learning. IEEE Access,
VI. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK 9:140565–140580, 2021.
In this study, we made available to researchers FieldPlant, [13] Dongfang Wang, Jun Wang, Zhuang Ren, and Wenrui Li. Dhbp: A dual-
a dataset of 5,170 annotated plant disease images collected stream hierarchical bilinear pooling model for plant disease multi-task
classification. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 195:106788,
directly from plantations. In contrast to PlantDoc, this dataset 2022.
is composed exclusively of field images classified by plant [14] Lili Li, Shujuan Zhang, and Bin Wang. Plant disease detection and
pathologists. However, the dataset can be enriched with more classification by deep learning—a review. IEEE Access, 9:56683–56698,
2021.
disease classes. FieldPlant has the potential to be widely [15] M Nagaraju and Priyanka Chawla. Systematic review of deep learning
used in plant disease research and management, and is the techniques in plant disease detection. International Journal of System
first plant disease dataset with annotated cassava images. We Assurance Engineering and Management, 11(3):547–560, 2020.
[16] Nichols Greg. Roboflow: Give your software the power to see objects
conducted a set of experiments to evaluate the performance in images and video. https://roboflow.com/, 2022. [Online; accessed 08-
of state-of-the-art classification and object detection models. November-2022].
The results show that the existing models are not sufficiently [17] Mark Sandler, Andrew Howard, Menglong Zhu, Andrey Zhmoginov, and
Liang-Chieh Chen. Mobilenetv2: Inverted residuals and linear bottlenecks.
accurate for plant disease detection and classification of In Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision and pattern
images collected directly from the field, although the clas- recognition, pages 4510–4520, 2018.
sification task results for FieldPlant are better than those for [18] Elhoucine Elfatimi, Recep Eryigit, and Lahcen Elfatimi. Beans leaf
diseases classification using mobilenet models. IEEE Access, 2022.
PlantDoc. Therefore, suitable models should be established [19] Joseph Redmon, Santosh Divvala, Ross Girshick, and Ali Farhadi. You
to help farmers identify the diseases that attack their crops only look once: Unified, real-time object detection. In Proceedings of the
and take appropriate countermeasures. Model ensembling IEEE conference on computer vision and pattern recognition, pages 779–
788, 2016.
with image segmentation applied to field images to isolate [20] Kantip Kiratiratanapruk, Pitchayagan Temniranrat, Apichon Kitvimonrat,
individual leaves from a global image may be a promising Wasin Sinthupinyo, and Sujin Patarapuwadol. Using deep learning tech-
approach for solving this problem. niques to detect rice diseases from images of rice fields. In International
Conference on Industrial, Engineering and Other Applications of Applied
Intelligent Systems, pages 225–237. Springer, 2020.
REFERENCES [21] Joseph Redmon and Ali Farhadi. Yolov3: An incremental improvement.
arXiv preprint arXiv:1804.02767, 2018.
[1] Hongkun Tian, Tianhai Wang, Yadong Liu, Xi Qiao, and Yanzhou Li. [22] Asad Khattak, Muhammad Usama Asghar, Ulfat Batool, Muham-
Computer vision technology in agricultural automation—a review. Infor- mad Zubair Asghar, Hayat Ullah, Mabrook Al-Rakhami, and Abdu Gu-
mation Processing in Agriculture, 7(1):1–19, 2020. maei. Automatic detection of citrus fruit and leaves diseases using deep
[2] David Hughes, Marcel Salathé, et al. An open access repository of images neural network model. IEEE Access, 9:112942–112954, 2021.
on plant health to enable the development of mobile disease diagnostics. [23] CK Sunil, CD Jaidhar, and Nagamma Patil. Cardamom plant disease
arXiv preprint arXiv:1511.08060, 2015. detection approach using efficientnetv2. IEEE Access, 10:789–804, 2021.
[3] Nichols Greg. La vision par ordinateur, l’arme la plus récente [24] Mingxing Tan and Quoc Le. Efficientnetv2: Smaller models and faster
contre la perte de récolte. https://www.zdnet.fr/actualites/ training. In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 10096–
la-vision-par-ordinateur-l-arme-la-plus-recente-contre-la-perte-de-recolte-39884697.10106. PMLR, 2021.
htm, 2019. [Online; accessed 4-April-2022]. [25] Hassan Amin, Ashraf Darwish, Aboul Ella Hassanien, and Mona Soliman.
[4] Davinder Singh, Naman Jain, Pranjali Jain, Pratik Kayal, Sudhakar Ku- End-to-end deep learning model for corn leaf disease classification. IEEE
mawat, and Nipun Batra. Plantdoc: a dataset for visual plant disease Access, 2022.
detection. In Proceedings of the 7th ACM IKDD CoDS and 25th COMAD, [26] Sk Mahmudul Hassan and Arnab Kumar Maji. Plant disease identification
pages 249–253. 2020. using a novel convolutional neural network. IEEE Access, 2022.

10 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

[27] Changjian Zhou, Sihan Zhou, Jinge Xing, and Jia Song. Tomato leaf EMMANUEL MOUPOJOU obtained a mas-
disease identification by restructured deep residual dense network. IEEE ter’s degree in Information Systems and Soft-
Access, 9:28822–28831, 2021. ware Engineering at the University of Yaoundé
[28] Plantix. Plantix | best agriculture app. https://plantix.net/, 2022. [Online; 1 in Cameroon in 2014. He is currently pursu-
accessed 08-November-2022]. ing a Ph.D. in Artificial Intelligence in joint su-
[29] Pavel Goncharov, Alexander Uzhinskiy, Gennady Ososkov, Andrey pervision between the University of Yaoundé 1,
Nechaevskiy, and Julia Zudikhina. Deep siamese networks for plant Cameroon, and the University of Technology of
disease detection. In EPJ web of conferences, volume 226, page 03010.
Troyes, France.
EDP Sciences, 2020.
From 2014 to 2018, he was a part-time teacher
[30] PlantVillage Project. Plantvillage nuru. https://plantvillage.psu.edu/, 2022.
[Online; accessed 08-November-2022]. in professional courses in the Computer Science
[31] Hui Fuang Ng, Chih-Yang Lin, Joon Huang Chuah, Hung Khoon Tan, and Department of the University of Yaoundé 1 until 2018. Since 2018 he has
Kar Hang Leung. Plant disease detection mobile application development been a lecturer at the Institut Universitaire Saint Jean du Cameroun (IUSJC).
using deep learning. In 2021 International Conference on Computer & He is the author of three articles, and one conference paper. His research
Information Sciences (ICCOINS), pages 34–38. IEEE, 2021. interests include: Artificial Intelligence, Configuration Management, and
[32] Alvaro Fuentes, Sook Yoon, Sang Cheol Kim, and Dong Sun Park. A Applications Security.
robust deep-learning-based detector for real-time tomato plant diseases
and pests recognition. Sensors, 17(9):2022, 2017.
[33] Marko Arsenovic, Mirjana Karanovic, Srdjan Sladojevic, Andras Anderla,
and Darko Stefanovic. Solving current limitations of deep learning based
approaches for plant disease detection. symmetry 11, 7: 939, 2019.
[34] Latifa Mrisho, Neema Mbilinyi, Mathias Ndalahwa, Amanda Ramcharan,
Annalyse Kehs, Peter McCloskey, Harun Murithi, David Hughes, and
James Legg. Evaluation of the accuracy of a smartphone-based artificial
intelligence system, plantvillage nuru, in diagnosing of the viral diseases
of cassava. BioRxiv, 2020. APPOLINAIRE TAGNE was born in the West
[35] Wikipedia. Cassava - wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassava, Region of Cameroon in 1964. He received his BSc
2022. [Online; accessed 09-November-2022]. from the Institute of Agricultural Technology, Uni-
[36] Wikipedia. Maize - wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maize, 2022. versity of Dschang Cameroon in 1988. His MSc
[Online; accessed 09-November-2022]. and PhD were achieved at the Danish Government
[37] Wikipedia. List of countries by tomato production - wikipedia. https:
Institute of Seed Pathology, The Royal Veterinary
//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List\_of\_countries\_by\_tomato\_production,
2022. [Online; accessed 09-November-2022].
and Agricultural University Copenhagen Denmark
[38] Matteo Perini, Mohamadou Nfor, Federica Camin, Silvia Pianezze, and in 1995 and 2001.
Edi Piasentier. Using bioelements isotope ratios and fatty acid composition From 2001 to date he has been a Senior Re-
to deduce beef origin and zebu feeding regime in cameroon. Molecules, searcher at the Institute of Agricultural Research
26:2155, 04 2021. for Developpement (IRAD) Cameroon, a Consultant at the World Food
[39] Karen Simonyan and Andrew Zisserman. Very deep convolutional net- and Agricultural Organization (FAO) working on plant Diseases Diagnostic
works for large-scale image recognition. arXiv preprint arXiv:1409.1556, Mapping and Data bases, a consultant at the Interafrican Phytosanitary
2014. Coiuncil of the African Union working on pesticides of plant origin. He
[40] Christian Szegedy, Vincent Vanhoucke, Sergey Ioffe, Jon Shlens, and is a Fellow Researcher of the European Network of Dirable Crop Protection
Zbigniew Wojna. Rethinking the inception architecture for computer (ENDURE) funded by the European Union, member of the academic teams
vision. In Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision and of the UniLaSalle University in France and first author or co-authors of about
pattern recognition, pages 2818–2826, 2016. 50 scientific papers including book chapters and Proceedings. He is also a
[41] Christian Szegedy, Sergey Ioffe, Vincent Vanhoucke, and Alexander A reviewer of many scientific journals.
Alemi. Inception-v4, inception-resnet and the impact of residual connec-
tions on learning. In Thirty-first AAAI conference on artificial intelli-
gence, 2017.
[42] Yu Hongkun, Chen Chen, Du Xianzhi, Li Yeqing, Rashwan Abdullah, Hou
Le, Jin Pengchong, Yang Fan, Liu Frederick, Kim Jaeyoun, and Li Jing.
Tensorflow model garden. https://github.com/tensorflow/models, 2020.
[43] Peng Du, Xiujie Qu, Tianbo Wei, Cheng Peng, Xinru Zhong, and Chen
Chen. Research on small size object detection in complex background.
In 2018 Chinese Automation Congress (CAC), pages 4216–4220. IEEE,
2018.
[44] Yingdong Ma, Yuchen Liu, Shuai Liu, and Zhibin Zhang. Multiple object FLORENT RETRAINT received the Engineering
detection and tracking in complex background. International Journal of Diploma degree in computer science from the
Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, 31(02):1755003, 2017. Compiegne University of Technology, in 1993,
the M.S. degree in applied mathematics from EN-
SIMAG, in 1994, and the Ph.D. degree in applied
mathematics from the National Institute of Ap-
plied Sciences of Lyon, France, in 1998.
He held a postdoctoral position at CEA Greno-
ble for one year. He was a Research Engineer with
Thomson CSF for two years. Since 2002, he has
been with the Laboratory of System Modeling and Dependability, Troyes
University of Technology. He is currently a Full Professor. His research
interests include image modeling, statistical image processing, hypothesis
testing theory, and anomaly detection and localization.

VOLUME 4, 2016 11

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
This article has been accepted for publication in IEEE Access. This is the author's version which has not been fully edited and
content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3263042

Emmanuel Moupojou et al.: FieldPlant: A dataset of field plant images for plant disease detection and classification with deep learning

ANICET TADONKEMWA obtained a Bache- MARCELLIN NKENLIFACK has been Head of


lor’s degree in ICT for Development (Computer Department of Mathematics and Computer Sci-
Science) from the University of Yaoundé 1 in ence at the Faculty of Sciences of the University
Cameroon in 2017. He is in the process of ob- of Dschang since 2018, after having been Head of
taining a Master’s degree in Data Science from Department of Computer Engineering at the IUT-
the Institut Universitaire Saint Jean du Cameroun FV of Bandjoun from 1996 to 2018. He is a spe-
(IUSJC). cialist in Services and Connected Objects, Doc-
He has developed a solid experience in the field tor/PhD in Software Engineering and Automation
of IT from an intern in 2014 to a digital consultant of Hybrid Systems and Engineer in Computer En-
in a start-up software service provider. Through gineering from the Polytechnic National In, statute
his numerous roles including functional analyst, software developer and IT of the University of Yaounde 1. He is also a "graduate" of the UNU (Univer-
manager, he has developed skills in management, leadership and especially sity of United Nations) on formal methods in Software Systems Engineering.
data management. He is passionate about the digital world, especially the He is an expert for the "ICT and Artificial Intelligence" Commission of the
study of enterprise data - contributing from requirements analysis to the National Committee for the Development of Technologies (CNDT). He has
deployment of solutions in a cloud environment. However, he is looking for been a guest researcher at: the Galilée Institute -Paris13, SUPELEC -Rennes,
a high value-added project to quickly improve his skills and later position Cheik Anta Diop University -Dakar, Felix Houphouet Boigny University -
himself as a data architect on large-scale projects. Abidjan, CFICIRAD -Brazzaville.
He has successfully piloted numerous research projects funded by various
international organizations such as "Agence Universitaire de la Franco-
phonie", "Silicon Valley Community Foundation" and "US-Ar Research
Laboratory". He participated in several editions of CARI, including the
first in 1992 Yaoundé. He joined the CARI Permanent Committee in 2016
as one of the representatives of African researchers. He coordinated the
organization of CARI-2022 in Cameroon and at the University of Dschang.

DONGMO WILFRIED was born in Douala,


Cameroon in 1984. He obtained a Bachelor’s
degree in Biology in 2008 at the University of
Douala. In 2014 he obtained the degree of Agri-
cultural Engineer, and the Research Master in
Biotechnology and Plant Production option Phy-
topathology in 2017 at the University of Dschang.
He has been a PhD student in Agroecology at
the University of Dschang since 2019, and teaches
in Private University Institutes. He has conducted
several trials on the screening of maize varieties with the Institute of Agro-
nomic Research for Development (IRAD). He has published two articles on
the characterization and sustainability of the agroforestry system. He is also
the author of a book on fertilization in organic farming.

HIPPOLYTE TAPAMO has been lecturer in the


department of Computer Science of the Faculty of
Science in the University of Yaounde I - Cameroon
since 2001. He is Researcher in Computer Vision,
Image Processing and Artificial Intelligence. His
recent research focus a lot on face recognition
in scenes. His undergraduate teachings are on
databases and Geographical Infomation System
where he collaborates with geographical depart-
ment and with a lot a companies.

12 VOLUME 4, 2016

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

You might also like