Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Blue Ceramic From Manises' Obradors Quarter: Technology of Production
The Blue Ceramic From Manises' Obradors Quarter: Technology of Production
The Blue Ceramic From Manises' Obradors Quarter: Technology of Production
INVESTIGACIONES RECIENTES
ABSTRACT RESUMEN
During the excavations of the workshops Durante la excavación de los talleres del ba-
from the Obradors quarter in Manises, a se- rrio de Obradors en Manises, se encontró
rial of workshop ceramic debris including una serie de desechos del taller de cerámica,
unfired, after biscuit firing and after glaze incluidas piezas sin cocer, bizcochadas y vi-
firing ceramic shards and corresponding to driadas cocidas, que corresponden a un arco
a chronology starting 1325 and ending 1790 cronológico entre el 1325 y el 1790. Se han
were found. The materials related to the analizado los materiales relacionados con la
production of blue decorated ceramics have producción de cerámicas decoradas en azul
been analysed to unveil the materials used para revelar los materiales usados y los méto-
and methods of application. dos de aplicación.
257
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
All the ceramics analysed corresponding Las cerámicas analizadas datan desde el
from the first period (1325) to 16th century, primer periodo (1325) hasta el siglo XVI, y
showed the application of the cobalt decoration muestran la aplicación de la decoración del
below the Tin glaze (underglaze decoration). cobalto debajo del vidriado de estaño (de-
Analyses of a non-fired shard indicates that coración bajo cubierta). Los análisis de los
the pigment was previously roasted. Frag- fragmentos sin cocer indican que el pigmen-
ments of biscuit fired painted ceramics dated to fue previamente cocido. Fragmentos de
between 1375-1400 shows Iron-Cobalt-Ni- cerámica bizcochada y pintada datados entre
quel-Manganese oxides and silicates and no el 1375 y el 1400 muestran óxidos y silica-
Lead is found in the pigment. tos de hierro-cobalto-niquel y manganeso,
Ceramics produced after 1520 (1525-1600) mientras que no ha sido encontrado plomo
contain Lead-Calcium arsenates crystallise in en el pigmento.
the glaze suggesting that the original pigment Las cerámicas producidas después de 1520
was skutterudite (CoAs3). (1525-1600) contienen arsenatos de plomo y
Finally, during the second half of the 18th calcio cristalizados en el vidriado, lo que su-
century (1750-1790), the samples studied giere que el pigmento original fue skutteru-
show that the blue decoration was applied dite (CoAs3).
overglaze; the Cobalt pigment appears fully
dissolved in the glaze and is also characterised
by the absence of Lead-Calcium arsenate
crystallites, nor Tin oxide as opacifier agent.
1. INTRODUCTION
The aim of this paper is to show the changes in the materials used and
methods of application of the Cobalt blue decorations in the blue and
blue and lustre decorated ceramics from a Manises’ Obradors quarter du-
ring Medieval and Modern Ages (1325 to 1790). An accurate selection of
samples recovered during excavations of different workshops in Manises
Town have been performed. Glazes and blue decorations were analysed
by optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM-EDS)
and micro-X ray diffraction in order to determine how were applied the
decoration and which materials were used.
The written documentation does not cite Manises as a production
centre for decorated Tin glazed tableware until first quart of 14th century.
Before this data, Manises was an important pottery centre producing
unglazed large jars, as well as, monochrome Lead glazed table ware and
domestic wares. The first written source citing the production of “opus
aureum” is dated 1326, giving the first evidence that lustre decorated Tin
glazed ceramics were manufactured in Manises. Moreover, the first docu-
ment mentioning Cobalt in the Valencian area is from 1333, and indica-
258
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
tes that it was combined with lustre: ‘opus terra daurati cum safra’ (López
Elum, 1984).Potteries of Manises and Paterna produced huge amounts
of blue-decorated pieces which became widespread around Europe from
the Middle to the Modern Age (Coll, 2010).
In Obradors Quarter of Manises town, different pottery workshops
were excavated. In 25 Valencia Street, Algarrra and Berrocal (1993) ex-
cavated a medieval workshop where there were found lots of unfired
ceramic shards, but decorated with Cobalt. The samples probably broke
during the drying process and were thrown back into the basin in order
to reuse the clay in the next batch (Coll, 2009). These pieces are the direct
archeological evidence that the blue decoration was applied underglaze
and before the first firing (biscuit firing) (Coll and Pérez Camps, 1993).
Previous analysis of the blue decorated ceramics from Manises, Pa-
terna and Valencian productions using LA-ICP-MS and EDXRF (Roldan
et al., 2004; Roldan et al., 2006, Pérez-Arantegui et al., 2008; Coll, 2009)
were undertaken in order to state the Cobalt pigment provenance and
suggest the channels of its trade. These studies have identified four groups
of blue decorated Tin glaze Valencian pottery between the 13th and the
16th centuries, which is summarized below:
259
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
260
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
3. RESULTS
261
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
drying process and was then thrown back into the basin to reuse the clay
in the next batch (Coll, 2009). The decoration was the same as those usually
found on pieces decorated in blue. Therefore, this sample (one among
hundreds) is a direct evidence that in this period, the blue decorations
were applied underglaze and over the raw ceramic (Coll, 2009) (fig. 1a).
SEM-EDX analysis shows that the pigment has grains of Iron-Cobalt-
Zinc oxides with a ratio 76/18/6 (fig. 1). Moreover, pyroxenes containing
Cobalt, Magnesium, Manganese and Iron are also found. The complete
absence of sulphides, carbonates or sulphates and the presence of oxides
and pyroxenes demonstrate that the Cobalt ore (containing iron and
zinc) was roasted previous to its use as pigment.
The absence of Lead associated to the decoration indicates that Lead
compounds were not used to bind the pigment to the ceramic body.
Besides, the absence of Lead in the raw pigment indicates that there is
no association of Lead and Zinc as happens in other contemporary
glasses and Limoges glazes from the 14th and 15th French productions
are (Gratuze et al., 1996).
Fig. 1. (a) MBO1 shard; (b) Backscattered SEM photomicrographs of the surface area
corresponding to the blue decoration; (c) enlarged Backscattered SEM image showing the
presence of grains of Iron-Cobalt-Zinc oxides (1) and Iron-Cobalt-Magnesium-Manganese
pyroxenes (2); (d) EDS Spectrum corresponding to the Iron-Cobalt-Zn oxide (1); (e) EDS
spectrum corresponding to the Iron-Cobalt-Magnesium-Manganese pyroxene (2).
262
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
Fig. 2 (a) MBO9 shard; (b) Backscattered SEM photomicrograph of the surface showing
octahedral crystals of Iron-Cobalt-Niquel oxides: (c) Backscattered SEM photomicrograph of
a cross section. The white inclusions are Iron-Cobalt-Niquel oxides and the grey inclusions are
Calcium-Iron-Cobalt-Niquel pyroxenes; (d) EDS spectrum of Iron-Cobalt-Niquel oxide; (e)
EDS spectrum of the Calcium-Iron-Cobalt-Niquel pyroxene.
263
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
Fig.3 (a) MBO7 shard; (b) Backscattered SEM photomicrograph of the MBO7 surface; (c)
EDS spectrum of a white inclusion (1) corresponding to a Lead compound; (d) EDS spectrum
of the white inclusion (2) corresponding a Lead glaze chip with cassiterite (SnO2) crystals.
264
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
Fig. 4. (a) MBO-5 shard showing the blue decoration under partly molten glaze. (b) Optical
Microscopy image of a cross section of the Tin glaze showing the blue decoration with bright
particles of Iron-Cobalt-Copper-Zinc oxides, the red particle marked with a cross corresponds
to a fragment of red clay + PbO. (c) Backscattered SEM photomicrograph of the same area
where the melanotekite crystals appear white. Grey particles are Iron-Cobalt, Iron-Cobalt-Co-
pper or Iron-Cobalt-Copper-Zinc oxides.
265
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
whether the pigment was applied underglaze or not. At the interface cera-
mic-glaze crystallites of wollastonite (a calcium silicate) are formed but,
they do not contain Iron nor Cobalt (fig. 5). As melanotekite crystals are
not found, this indicates a firing temperature above 950ºC as melanoteki-
te melts at about 925ºC (Di Febo et al., 2018).
Fig. 5. (a) MBO-6 shard; (b) Backscattered SEM image of a thin section of the Tin glaze. The
white crystals are cassiterite, while those dark crystallites present at the interface are wollastonite.
There is no evidence of the blue decoration as the pigment has been completely dissolved.
266
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
Fig.6 (a) MBO10 sample;(b) OM of a thin section of the Tin glaze; (c) OM in reflected light
of the same area; (d) Backscattered SEM photomicrograph of the same area.
267
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
illite, some alkaline aluminium silicates and cassiterite (Tin oxide), (fig.
7). Lead carbonate is formed by weathering of Lead oxide but also of a
Lead glaze in an acidic environment.
Fig.7 (a) MBO4 shard; (b) µ-XRD spectrum of the glaze. Green = cerussite PbCO3, Yellow =
quartz, Blue = calcite, Red = cassiterite, SnO2 and Pink = potassium sodium aluminium silicate.
268
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
Fig. 9. (a) MBO13 shard; (b) Optical Microscopy image of a thin section. Brown clouds
are clusters of small SnO2 crystals (c) Backscattered SEM image of an area near the interface
showing grey crystals of Lead-calcium arsenates. The blue decoration was painted underglaze.
(d) EDS spectrum of a Lead-calcium arsenate crystal containing also some Silicon, Phosphor
and Chlorine.
269
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
ones. On the one hand, the glaze does not contain Tin oxide as opacifier
(SnO2, cassiterite) (fig. 10). The white colour of the glaze isobtained in-
corporating large quantities of silicate inclusions (quartz and feldspars)
and using a rich in Calcium clay for the ceramic. Secondly, the pigment
was applied overglaze, as seen in the thin section images (fig. 10b and
d). Finally, the blue decoration was applied using a blue glazewhich was
potassium rich. Cobalt is completely dissolved and it is not possible to
detect by EDS other chemicals associated to Cobalt apart from Iron.
Fig 10. (a) MBO12 shard; (b) OM image of a thin section showing the blue decoration applied
overglaze; (c) Backscattered SEM image of the glaze. The grey inclusions are quartz and potas-
sium feldspars; (d) enlarged OM image of the thin section showing the blue decoration applied
overglaze. The glaze close to the ceramic appears transparent, while those near the surface is blue.
CONCLUSIONS
270
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
271
JUDIT MOLERA - JAUME COLL - TRINITAT PRADELL
BIBLIOGRAFÍA
Algarra Pardo, V.M.; Berrocal Ruiz, P. (1993): “El taller de cerámicas bajomedievales de la
C/. València, n.25, de Manises: espacios y producción”, Actas del IV Congreso de Arqueo-
logía Medieval Española, Vol. III, (Alicante 1993), Asociación Española de Arqueología
Medieval, Diputación Provincial de Alicante, Alicante, 1993: 869-877.
Di Febo, R.; Molera, J.; Pradell, T.; Vallcorba, O.; Capelli, C. (2018): “Technological
implications of neo-formed hematite crystals in ceramic Lead glazes”. STAR: Science &
Technology of Archaeological Research. https://doi.org/10.1080/20548923.2017.1419675.
Coll Conesa, J.; Perez Camps, J. (1993): “Aspectos de la técnica de fabricación en la cerámica
de Manises (siglos XIV-XVI)”, Actas del IV Congreso de Arqueología Medieval Española,
Vol. III (Alicante 1993), Asociación Española de Arqueología Medieval, Diputación
Provincial de Alicante, Alicante, pp. 879-889.
Coll Conesa, J. (2010): “La cerámica Valenciana. Apuntes para una síntesis”, Asociación
Valenciana de Cerámica. RM Ediciones, S.L.
Coll Conesa, J. (2009): “Cobalt blue in medieval ceramic production in the Valencian
workshops. Manises, Paterna and Valencia, Spain”, Medieval Ceramics 31, pp. 11-24.
Gratuze, B; Soulier, I; Blet, M.; Vallauri, L. (1996): “De l’origine du cobalt: du verre à la
cèramique”. Révue d’Archéologie 20, pp. 77-94.
Lopez Elum, P. (1984): “Los orígenes de la cerámica de Manises y Paterna (1285-1335)”. Valencia,
Ed. Federico Domènech, S.A.
Molera, J; Pradell, T; Merino, L; Garcia-Valles, M; Garcia-Orellana, J; Salvado, N;
Vendrell-Saz, M. (1999): “La tecnología de la cerámica islámica y mudéjar’’, II Congreso
Nacional de Arqueometría, 16-19 de Septiembre de L997, Caesaraugnsta, 73, Instituto
Fernando el Católico’, Zaragoza, pp. 5-41.
Pérez-Arantegui, J.; Resano, E.; García-Ruíz, F.; Vanhaecke, C.; Roldán, J.; Ferrero,
J. Coll, J. (2008): “Characterization of cobalt pigments found in traditional Valencian
ceramics by means of laser ablation-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry and
portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometry”, Talanta, 74, pp. 1271-1280.
Porter, Y. (1997): “Origines et difussion du cobalt utilisé en céramique à l’èpoque médiévale.
Etude préliminaire”, La céramique médiévale en Méditerranée AIECM2 Narration éditions,
Aix-en-Provence, pp. 505-512.
Pradell, T.; Molera, J.; Roque, J.; Smith, A.; Crespo, D.; Pantos, E.; Vendrell-Saz, M.
(2005): “Ionic-exchange mechanism in the formation of medieval luster decorations”. Journal
of the American Ceramic Society, 88, pp. 1281-1289.
Pradell, T.; Molera, J.; Salvado, N.; Labrador, A. (2010): “Títol: Synchrotron radiation
micro-XRD in the study of glaze technology”, Applied Physics A: Materials Science and
Processing, 99, pp. 407-417.
Pradell, T.; Molina, G.; Molera, J.; Labrador, A. (2012): “The use of micro-XRD for the
study of glaze color decorations”, Applied Physics A: Materials Science and Processing, 111,
1, pp. 121-127.
Roldan Garcia, C.; Coll Conesa, J.; Ferrero Calabuig, J. L.; Juanes Barber, D. (2004):
“Identification of overglaze and underglaze cobalt decoration of ceramics from Valencia
(Spain) by portable EDXRF spectrometry”, X-Ray Spectrometry, 33, pp. 28-32.
272
THE BLUE CERAMIC FROM MANISES’ OBRADORS QUARTER...PRODUCTION
Roldan, C.; Coll Conesa, J.; Ferrero, J. (2006): “EDXRF analysis of blue pigments used in
Valencian ceramics from the 14th century to modern times”, Journal of Cultural Heritage
7, pp. 134-138.
Zucchiatti, A.; Bouquillon, A.; Katona, L; D’Alessandro, A. (2006): “The ‘della Robbia
Blue’: a case study for the use of cobalt pigments in ceramics during the Italian Renaissence”,
Archaeometry, Vol. 48/1, pp. 131-152.
273