ENGLISH த ழ் বাংলা മലയാളം िहं दी मराठी

Follow Us:

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Home India Cities Opinion IPL 2020 Entertainment Lifestyle Tech Videos Explained Audio
SUBSCRIBE
Epaper Sign in
Home / Opinion / Before the next disaster: What Mumbai needs to learn from Cyclone Nisarga

Before the next disaster: What

Mumbai needs to learn from
Cyclone Nisarga
Why, I wonder, do city planners and development agencies not produce
adaptation or mitigation programs given the vulnerabilities of the city to
climate change?

Written by Nikhil Anand | June 4, 2020 9:56:13 am

Residents of Darukhana slum evacuate as Cyclone Nisarga sets in, in Mumbai. (Express Photo: Nirmal
Harindran)

Cyclone Nisarga spared Mumbai. This time. After a very stressful 24 hours for
residents and leaders alike, the eye of the storm made landfall at Alibag, south of
the city. Mumbai’s residents were lucky. Residents of Ratnagiri and Alibag less so.
The significant human costs of this disaster will become clearer in the coming days.
Cyclone Nisarga, just before making landfall on June 3, 2020. As seen on Windy.com.

Yet it is not clear if Mumbai will remain as lucky in the future. Nisarga was the first
major cyclonic storm that affected Mumbai since 1948. Yet, this does not mean it
will be eighty years before the next one.

The Indian Ocean is today the fastest warming ocean in the world. In the Indian
Ocean, the Arabian Sea is warming faster than the Bay of Bengal. Scientists and
fishermen are already noticing the changes.

Fishers are finding their commercially valuable species vanish and new ones
ending up in their nets. Scientists have noticed how cyclones, formerly rare in the
Arabian Sea, are now more frequent. For much of the twentieth century, there was,
on average, less than one cyclone a year in the Arabian Sea. Last year there were
four.

This is more than a coincidence.

In a 2019 paper, climate scientist Adam Sobel showed that our expectations of
cyclones being extremely unlikely in Mumbai are more the result of a sampling
error than of fundamental cyclone climatology. Put in other words, that cyclones
haven’t happened in Mumbai in recent history does not mean that they cannot
happen. Less than a year later, Cyclone Nisarga proved him correct.

A different paper, published by Hiroyuki Murukami and his colleagues has not only
shown that the cyclones in the Arabian Sea are more likely today, but also that this
is attributable to climate change. Additionally, research by Amato Evan points to
aerosolised fossil fuel emissions that now hang above the Arabian Sea as an
additional factor causing more intense cyclones.

All signs point in the same direction. We can expect more intense cyclones in the
Arabian Sea in the future, and with this, it is increasingly likely that some of these
cyclones might hit Mumbai.

The state and city administration needs to be commended for taking quick action
by moving one lakh people out of harm’s way yesterday. The next cyclone may not
be as gentle as Nisarga. It may not be manageable the day before the storm.

Accordingly, the Government of Maharashtra and the Municipal Corporation of

Greater Mumbai need to proactively design urban infrastructures and public space
so that Mumbai can better accommodate and withstand major cyclone and extreme
weather events much before the next cyclone comes. And it may not miss Mumbai.

It may also be considerably stronger. Nisarga only appeared in Mumbai as a

Category I cyclone. Yet just four days before landfall, models showed it might
develop into something far worse, a Category 3 storm, with wind speeds up to 160
kmh. What might this have looked like?
In his book, The Great Derangement, Amitav Ghosh points to the many ways in
which Mumbai’s location on the open sea, its construction on landfill, and its
blocked water bodies make it especially vulnerable to a stronger cyclone.

Much of Mumbai’s skyline, built on land ll, sits only a few meters over sea level. (Photo Credit: Nikhil
Anand)

For instance, on June 3 IMD officials warned that Nisarga’s storm surge might
inundate nearly 3 kilometers of coastline in Pen. As Ghosh points out, the distance
between Mumbai’s western and eastern coast is only 4 kilometers in the south of
the city. A resulting storm surge could easily inundate vast sections of Mumbai had
a slightly stronger cyclone passed north of the city.
The stronger winds of a category 3 cyclone could lift debris, loose materials, roofing
materials, and throw them against its glamourous towers made of glass, imperiling
rich and poor residents alike. If the city’s electricity grid collapsed, as it did in New
York City after Hurricane Sandy, residents in the city’s high rises, like those in
poorer sections of the city, would not have water for days.

I have recently been consumed by these spectral events since Ghosh laid them out
in his book. I also continue to be puzzled by the city’s refusal to address them in a
systematic and proactive way.

Why, I wonder, do city planners and development agencies not produce adaptation
or mitigation programs given the vulnerabilities of the city to climate change?

It is not like they do not know the risks. A twitter post shared by the BMC a day
before the cyclone foresees the cyclone disrupting energy, water and gas
infrastructure.
List of Do’s and Don’ts Posted by BMC on Twitter, June 2, 2020. Here the BMC warns residents that
Nisarga might cause water, gas and electricity infrastructures to fail.

Urban researchers Hussain Indorewala and Shweta Wag have suggested that city
officials are moved more by the mundane and material profits of real estate
speculation than to ensure urban sustainability. In work I have recently completed,
I found planners and city officials frequently dismissing climate change inflected
disasters by suggesting these are unlikely events in a distant future; that the city has
more important matters to take care of.

Yesterday, Cyclone Nisarga has shown most vividly that climate change impacts are
not distant, unthinkable or insignificant. They are imminent specters of
catastrophic loss that hang over the city every day.

While risk modelers and scientists suggest that events like the floods of 2005 or the
cyclone of 2020 are rare, this does not prevent them from happening at any time.
Even if they are improbable, the next cyclone could occur in a few months or
several years from now. Improbable events are happening more frequently, in
Mumbai and beyond.

For example, in a recent presentation at the Penn Program in Environmental

Humanities, Domenic Boyer pointed out that the city of Houston has been visited by
three 500-year floods in 2 years alone! This includes Hurricane Harvey, the largest
ever recorded rainfall event in the United States.

If the city remains vulnerable to such events, there is much work that needs to be
done. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and the Government of
Maharashtra does not have the luxury to wait until COVID 19 is cured to do so, nor
can it expect to have eighty years before the next climate event. It need to create an
empowered and resourced task force to address these potential catastrophes
tomorrow.

“Our inability to imagine catastrophe assures that the catastrophe will happen,”
Amitav Ghosh pointed out in a recent interview. And absent a serious engagement
with the new normal of coastal cities, the catastrophe will be worse not if, but when
it happens. We just don’t know when.
Before the next cyclone. Sunset over Bandra after Nisarga passed overhead, June 3, 2020. (Photo
Credit: Shaina Anand)

Mumbai’s residents and leaders alike must demand and produce an ambitious,
imaginative and just climate action plan that protects all citizens, particularly its
most vulnerable. As we saw yesterday, informal residents are most exposed to
extreme weather events.

Ambitious, because doing more of what has been done before simply won’t work
for the city today. Reclamation and landfill have made the Mumbai of the 19th and
20th century, but they have also made the city of the 21st century vulnerable to
storm surges, extreme rainfall and flooding.
Imaginative, because as storm surge expert Adam Sobel suggests, new roads,
housing developments and airports that are now being built on existing wetlands
and intertidal regions in Mumbai only makes the city more vulnerable to storm
surge.

Award winning landscape architects and design researchers Anuradha Mathur and
Dilip da Cunha agree. In their book SOAK: Rethinking Mumbai in an Estuary, they
draw lessons from the Mumbai floods of 2005 to suggest the city needs to reimagine
the relationship between the city and the fickle gradients of land and water across
its terrain.

Towards this, they suggest a revitalisation of several city infrastructures- nalas,

maidans, wetlands and indeed the sea itself- so that climate changed waters are
accommodated by urban designs and infrastructure planning.

Just, because the planning design interventions need to not only involve experts but
also the city’s diverse populations, including those living in the city’s informal
settlements. Urban planning has seldom been a participatory democratic process
anywhere in the world. It needs to become one if it is to secure the legitimacy and
co-operation of the populations it seeks to govern.

Here, Mumbai’s politicians and planners would do well to learn from ongoing
work by planners of other megacities like Jakarta, that also face the simultaneous
challenges of informal housing, big infrastructure works, climate change and
coastal inundation.

I make these suggestions not to generate a list of tasks the city needs to accomplish.
I write them to speculate the beginnings of a process to carefully, urgently and
justly reimagine the possibilities of Mumbai, with the specters of cyclones, storms
and floods that the city and its citizens are living with today.

We need to initiate this process not because we are concerned about the future of
the urban environment. We need to do so because we are concerned about the
future of Mumbai itself.

Nikhil Anand is Associate Professor of Anthropology at the University of

Pennsylvania. His current research focuses on cities, infrastructure, seas, and
climate change in Mumbai.

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel
(@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App.

© IE Online Media Services Pvt Ltd

TAGS: Cyclone Nisarga Maharashtra Mumbai

1 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by indianexpress.com.

EXPRESS OPINION
Opinion
Fifty-eight years later,
India-China relationship
has changed. Inequality
has grown

Opinion
Isher Ahluwalia and
Devaki Jain fashioned
feminism out of lived
experience

Opinion
The economic rise of
Bangladesh is also an
opportunity for India

Opinion
Policy needs to address
— and help — those who
have seen the greatest
distress during
lockdown

BEST OF EXPRESS
What impact will ban on visitors at Durga Puja
pandals in Bengal have?
 Live Updates
PM Modi to address
nation at 6 pm

Entertainment
The iconic DDLJ turns
25, but how does it hold
up today?

Entertainment
Prithviraj tests positive
for coronavirus

Trending
Woman runs mile in 5
minutes during the
ninth month of
pregnancy, netizens
shower praise

Trending
Photo of goddess
Durga reimagined as a
doctor killing
'coronasur' goes viral

Sports
To bring IPL stands
alive in UAE, Mumbai
engineers cut-paste
audio

Sports
RELIVE | Virender
Sehwag's ve ODI
centuries on his 42nd
birthday

Opinion
Fifty-eight years later,
India-China relationship
has changed. Inequality
has grown
 Quixplained: As schools
reopen, a look at the
guidelines for students
and staff

Lifestyle
Covid-19: Simple
precautionary
measures and
immunity-bosting tips
for pregnant women

Technology
Here are the cheapest
and most expensive
places to buy iPhone 12

MUST READ
Sports
To bring IPL stands
alive in UAE, Mumbai
engineers cut-paste
audio

Sports
RELIVE | Virender
Sehwag's ve ODI
centuries on his 42nd
birthday

Sports
A season too far: CSK’s
chances seem all but
over after tepid loss

Technology
Here are the cheapest
and most expensive
places to buy iPhone 12

Technology
These WhatsApp
features are coming
soon for Android,
iPhone users

Technology
When will PlayStation 5 release in India, what is
the price?
 Lifestyle
Covid-19: Simple
precautionary
measures and
immunity-bosting tips
for pregnant women

MORE EXPLAINED
Quixplained: As schools
reopen, a look at the
guidelines for students
and staff

What impact will ban on

visitors at Durga Puja
pandals in Bengal have?

Why scientists are

trying to cultivate heeng
in the Indian Himalayas

Five main strategic

implications of
Bangladesh's economic
rise

OCT 20: LATEST NEWS

HUL Q2 net up 8.6% at

Rs 1,974 crore; net
sales up 15.9% at Rs
11,510 crore

US diplomats and spies battle Trump

administration over suspected attacks
 UK residents tweets ‘I
am not OK’, netizens
from around the world
try to cheer him up

25 years of DDLJ:
Simran is a little old-
fashioned but cool,
says Kajol

US charges Russian
intelligence o cers in
major cyberattacks

Patients and healthcare

workers perform garba
at COVID-19 facility, get
praise on social media

IPL 2020, KXIP vs DC

Live Cricket Streaming:
When and where to
watch Kings XI Punjab
vs Delhi Capitals?

World Osteoporosis Day

2020: What
postmenopausal
women ought to know
about their bones

Naach Meri Rani: Nora

Fatehi impresses with
her perfect dance
moves again

K Srikkanth slams MS
Dhoni’s ‘ridiculous’
selections, asks what
‘spark’ did he see in
Kedar Jadhav

TRENDING NEWS

Covid-19 Vaccine Horoscope Today Coronavirus India News RCB Team 2020 Players
 List

CSK Team 2020 Players MI Team 2020 Players List SRH Team 2020 Players DC Team 2020 Players List
List List

KXIP Team 2020 Players KKR Team 2020 Players IPL 2020 Points Table Maharashtra Coronavirus
List List News

US Elections 2020 Karnataka Coronavirus

News

FOLLOW US

DOWNLOAD APPS

EXPRESS GROUP

The Indian Express The Financial Express

Loksatta Jansatta

IE Tamil IE Bangla

IE Malayalam inUth

The ExpressGroup Ramnath Goenka Awards

IE-26/11 MyInsuranceClub
QUICK LINKS

T&C Privacy Policy

Advertise with Us Contact Us

Subscribe Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses)

Code of ethics for digital news websites

Copyright © 2020 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved