07-DEC-2018

EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 1 of 13
 Comment Sheet of Drawing /
Document
Project Name: Dangote Refinery and Petrochemical Projects
EIL Job No.: A545
Name of Package : M/s HTC (HANGZHOU STEAM TURBINE CP., LTD. CHINA)

EIL Transmission Doc. No.

Document Ref. No. A545-02-41-681-1114B

Document Ref. Titile Document No. 0-0642-5604-00

Steram & Drainage P&ID
COMMENTS VENDOR CLARIFICATION/
S.NO. EIL COMMENTS/OBSERVATIONS EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE
DATE RESPONSE
Signal is connected to DEH as per terminal
2017-2-9 drawing.The same shall be suitably indicated
1 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 at all place wherever signal is connected to
Vendor's control System.
2017-2-9 Scheme not clear. vendor to clarify why
the PV is control by downstream
2 interlock has been provided for control valve Closed
图纸上的批复 operation
steam pressure.
2017-2-9 PSV size and orifice designation to be
3 Finalize the size. noted and confirmed CLOSED
图纸上的批复 provided in the P&ID
Open/close Limit switches shall be indicated
2017-2-9 EIL tag no. is added but the
with tag numbers. Connectivity of the same to interlock is not applicable, only
4 connectivity is not clear because it CLOSED
图纸上的批复 DCS or ESD if/as applicable shall be
is supplied by EIL
connect to DCS
indicated in the P&ID.
2017-2-9 Uniformity shall be maintained for tag
5 numbers of a single loop.Like with TT-411 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 control valve tag number is PV-403.
2017-2-9 Instrument air connection to control valve
6 noted Closed
图纸上的批复 shall be tubing, as per PR.

2017-2-9 HTC to also refer to attached hand marked

7 P&ID for comments. The same shall be noted Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 resolved/ incorporated in revised P&ID.
MP steam line numbers shall be designated
with –SM- and HP steam line with –SH- and
2017-2-9 VHP steam line with –SVH- in P&ID’s. HTC to Discussed and shall be
8 noted and modified Not modified. Correct to SM. CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 ensure the same in P&ID. It was observed remained as SL
that MP steam used for seal control is
designated
HTC as scope
to check –SL- of PI 1301/404 and TI
2017-2-9 in EIL drawing A545-02-41-680-
1301/407 in MP steam
9 1113, the four gauge is not marked Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 extraction line from STG as per PR as VF, so it is not in HTC's scope
requirements
Control Oil P&ID is not 2 PT are required as per
2017-2-9 HTC to show two PT’s in MP steam submitted. EIL P&IDs. OR HTC shall 2 PTs are revised in
PT 411 is for extraction pressure
10 extraction line after PT-402 A/B/C Extraction pressure control control oil PID is submitted. Two closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 for extraction pressure controller. control in control oil system PID
shall be as per PR P&ID in submit the write up for not CONTROL OIL PID
the MP extraction line providing 2 PTS
HTC to provide STG tripping logic at low MP
2017-2-9 steam extraction pressure based on three PT’ L for LOW alarm, LL for LOW
what is the significance of 'L',
11 s (2oo3) PT-402 A/B/C as per PR noted LOW trip delay,LLL for LOW CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 requirement. For trip logic, always three PT’s 'LL' and 'LLL'.
LOW LOW trip
are to be used
HTC to check requirement of PSV in
2017-2-9 refer MOM 2.3 Maintain the set pressure
downstream of de superheater and the PSV Each PSV shall be sized for
12 the PSV is 50% rated flow a write up has already emailed REVISED AS PER WRITE UP closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 sizing shall be checked for HP BFW control 100%.
to EIL as agreed in MOM.
valve full open condition.
2017-2-9 as per chinese standard, the flow refer MOM 2.1 Shall be as per email
MP steam header line size shall be retained
13 rate is to low for MP steam , a Mark reducer size 20" X 24". a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 as 24” as per PR P&ID. reducer is set at battery limit to EIL confirmation.

2017-2-9 as per chinese standard, the flow refer MOM 2.2 Shall be as per email
HP steam header line size shall be retained
14 rate is to low for HP steam , a Mark reducer size 8" X 18". a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 as 18”as per PR P&ID. reducer is set at battery limit to EIL confirmation.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 2 of 13
 2017-2-9 HTC to check scope of PI 1302/403 and TI in EIL drawing A545-02-41-680-
15 1303/406 in HP steam extraction line from 1113, the four gauge is not marked Closed CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 STG as per PR requirements. as VF, so it is not in HTC's scope
2 PT are required as per
2017-2-9 HTC to show two PT’s in HP steam extraction Extraction pressure control noted, control oil PID will be
PT 411 is for extraction pressure EIL P&IDs. OR HTC shall
16 line after PT-401 A/B/C for extraction shall be as per PR P&ID in submitted and 2 PTs to SAME AS SL.10 CLOSED closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 pressure controller. control in control oil system PID
the HP extraction line extraction pressure control submit the write up for not
providing 2 PTS
HTC to provide STG tripping logic at low HP
2017-2-9 steam extraction pressure based on three PT’
17 s (2oo3) PT-401 A/B/C as per PR noted Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 requirement. For trip logic, always three PT’s
are to be used
HTC to check requirement of PSV in
2017-2-9 downstream of super heater and the PSV
18 the PSV is 50% rated flow Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 sizing shall be checked for VHP Steam
control valve full open condition.
HTC to clarify SS mentioned for High and low
2017-2-9 instrument readings. We understand that this A stands for alarm and SS stands
19 Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 signifies tripping of the machine. HTC to for trip
clarify our understanding.
2017-2-9 HTC to include description of blowers
20 mentioned in Gland Condenser such as noted and modified Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 capacity head etc
noted and will be revised,
except 112
112 is altenator speed indicator
is required for all package 67.78.79 are added.
Provide all Instruments as per Control and Instrument missing are at sl. vendor, HTC shall follow the Instrument 67, 78, 79, 84,
Comments is not clear. Please 84 is not required.
2017-7-20 Instrumentation data sheet A545-680-16-45- no. - 58, 65, 67(for exhaust request 112 still missing.
22 indiacte which instruments are frequency is shown in closed
图纸上的批复 DS-5103. condensing line), 78, 79, 82, after checked with generator 112 is required necessarily
Some instruments are still missing.
missing.
83, 84, 112, 113 vendor, 112 alternator speed is protection panel, so 112
to monitor the speed.
not applicable because the is not required
generator speed can be
calculated from ST speed and
they have never provided the
2017-7-20 Motorized drain valve to be provided at valve supplied by EIL, HTC to
23 Closed
图纸上的批复 upstream of ESV. indicate
Incorporate previous piping & process
2017-7-20 comments also. If there is any doubt in any
24 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 comment, please contact or write a mail to
us 1) pipings in skid will not have line
no. some pipings informations are
1. all lines shall be indicated
still hold.
1)Provide line nos shown with "X" & "XX". with their line sizes and any
2) added
Also provide line nos at other points where line which is at the interface
3) noted 1. Closed
not given. Many lines are without line nos. shall be indicated with line 1. noted and will be revised
4) some pipings such as balancing
2017-7-20 2) Steam Inlet pressure (PT) required. numbers. 4. This area is not accessable
piping 8-SL-681-4A05A-B2A, it is in
25 3)Steam Exhaust pressure (PT) with Alarm 2. Closed for person , insulation is not
图纸上的批复 and trip required.
the hole below the ST where no
3. Closed required will be reviewed at 3 D 4. Shall be reviewed during
people can get close to. And also
4) Show Insulation where required. 4. Wherever there is a scope model review.
many pipings in the hole, there is no 3D model review.
5) Check PMS for each line with insulations of reaching a person,
space for piping insulation. as per
and tracings. insulation shall be provided
HTC experience, this pipings is not
for safety.
insulated
5) noted
Not modified as per MOM. As per MOM, HTC refer to MOM.2.1 and in
2017-7-20 refer MOM 2.1
Provide this scheme as per MOM dated 02nd 24" inlet required with one line proposed for 14" which is latest PID, VHP inlet line
26 Drawing is modified as per MOM. a write up has already emailed closed
图纸上的批复 March 2017. with a reducer of 24"X12"
to EIL not considered as standard is 18". (EIL to give
shall be shown. size and hence 16" shall be clearence)
noted, control oil PID will be
submitted. About the pressure
Extraction pressure control control transmitter. HTC has Provide technical write up
2017-7-20 Provide Extraction Pressure controller as per pressure controlled by extraction SAME AS SL.10
27 shall be as per PR P&ID in remembered that this is mentioning non reliability of closed
图纸上的批复 P&ID. control valve mounted in turbine CLOSED
the MP & HP extraction line discussed in the former meeting, using 2 PTs with PIC.
the logic of the 2PTs is not
reliable
2017-7-20
28 shall be tubing as per PR any specific legend for tube? Closed
图纸上的批复

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 3 of 13
 EIL and DORC proposed that all DISCUSSED AND DRIP
2017-7-20 All drip leg shall be routed to drip leg shall be connected to LEG SHALL NOT BE
29 Drip Leg Noted and modified. Shall be shown in the PID. closed
图纸上的批复 condensate header. flash tank. ROUTED TO FLASH
TANK
EIL and DORC proposed that all DISCUSSED AND DRIP
2017-7-20 All drip leg shall be routed to drip leg shall be connected to LEG SHALL NOT BE
30 Drip Leg Noted and modified. Shall be shown in the PID. closed
图纸上的批复 condensate header. flash tank. ROUTED TO FLASH
TANK
IN HP EXTRACTION LINE In the revised PID, the sizes
2017-7-20 INLET NPS6 OUTLET NPS 8 MArk the same in the P&ID the final sizes are shown
31 Confirm the size of PSV revised are not as shown in the closed
图纸上的批复 IN MP EXTRACTION LINE also. in PID
INLET NPS12 OUTLET NPS 16 resolution in coloumn aside.
2017-7-20 Refer direction of bullet
Direction of NRV shall be as per earlier direction is already shown, HTC will
32 shown in the commented revised CLOSED
图纸上的批复 comments enlarge the arrow
P&ID above
2017-7-20 Refer Commented P&ID for
33 1302, 1301, 1301 Noted and modified. tag no correction. CLOSED
图纸上的批复 Closed.
HP steam header line size
mentioned by HTC is 8" and
10" in P&ID but no reducer
2017-7-20 HTC consider the pipe to be 20" for refer MOM 2.2 is shown. Moreover, HTC to
Line Size shall be 18" as
34 18" better piping design and will be 24" a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
图纸上的批复 at the battery limit
mentioned in the PR P&ID.
to EIL recheck for 8" & 10" line
size as the same is having
high velocity and pressure
drop. Refer email.
2017-7-20
35 Unit in kg/cm2 Noted and modified. Not modified. revised CLOSED
图纸上的批复
2017-7-20 HTC consider the pipe to be 20" for refer MOM 2.1 Refer email reply to write
Line Size shall be 24" as
36 Line size shall be 24". better piping design and will be 24" a write up has already emailed refer to MOM closed
图纸上的批复 at the battery limit
mentioned in the PR P&ID.
to EIL up.
It was discussed and
explained the meaning to
PMS is changing from B2A to spec break to HTC during
2017-7-20 noted. But this is not a spec
37 Show spec break no spec break here A2A, so spec break shall be meeting and was agreed to HTC clarified and closed closed
图纸上的批复 break, PID has modified
shown. get it changed, as
commented. Please revise
the P&ID and show spec
2017-7-20 Which symbol is this. Mention in the legend Mention in the legend list of a drawing of SYMBOLS AND
38 expansion joint CLOSED
图纸上的批复 list. P&ID. LEGEND is submitted
2017-7-20
39 Line size 1978×978×10 square pipe Closed
图纸上的批复
2017-7-20
40 Line size Not finalized yet. Finalize. revised but some line stays hold Shall be finalised soon. REVISED closed
图纸上的批复
Following equipment information
needs to be added along with
tag no.
2017-7-20 equipment tag no. is not clear, Tag no is 681-LZ-1004 1. QCNRV
41 Write equipment Tag no. CLOSED
图纸上的批复 please clarify A/B/C/D. 2. Super heater and desuper
heater
3. gland condenser
4 Exhaust spray valve
1) Show the inlet line size as per PR 1. Show 24" line then a
P&ID. reducer from 24" to 18", as
1)added
2) Silencer in vendor scope.
42 2017-11-1 2)noted discussed in the meeting. same as sl. 13 closed
3) Follow full scheme along with the
type of
3)noted 2. Mark the scope in P&ID.
valves shown in the PR P&ID. 3. Closed.
43 2017-11-1 Mention tag numbers of the instrument revised Closed
For superheater and desuperheater,
44 2017-11-1 follow revised Closed
scheme as per PR P&ID.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 4 of 13
 not required in the inlet because PT
PT with L&H alarm logic in steam inlet are A single PT may be required
discussed and PT is not
45 2017-11-1 of mounted in the main steam line. in order to monitor the pressor closed
required.
sealing superheater And C&I in the same line.
datasheet doesn't require these
Size of the control valves shall
be mentioned in the P&IDs.
Tags for Modulating control
46 2018-1-9 revised closed
valves shall be PV/TV /LV etc.
PCV /TCV shall be used for
Self actuated control
Tags used in interlock shall
47 2018-1-9 revised closed
not be considered as FF
This VHP steam drain shall
48 2018-1-9 add one manual valve closed
have double isolation valve
PT shall be provided here discussed and acceptable as
49 2018-1-9 closed
also, as before valve 2301. per PID
PI shall be provided at each
50 2018-1-9 local gauge are provided closed
seal inlet.
Please provide double temp. discussed and one temp. to be discussed during
51 2018-1-9 discussed and no need CLOSED
element for this transmitter element is acceptable HAZOP
This steam drain line shall double isolation valve
why not provide for MP
52 2018-1-9 revised for pressure above CLOSED
have double isolation valve steam line
40kg/cm2
Any motor signals from MCC
53 2018-1-9 to DCS shall also be indicated revised closed
in theP&ID.
54 2018-1-9 Line no to be provided? this is a rectangular duct closed
discussed in HAZOP. Two ESVs
HTC to clarify why PT and TE/TT are
are connected so the value are
provided in this line but only PI/TI are
55 2018-2-23 the same and also there are CLOSED
provided in line number 4B03A. Maintain
TT/PT in 18" main line. So no
consistency.
need
Clarify basis of 2" line size. Can these
vent lines be combined in to single vent discussed with EIL process
56 2018-2-23 CLOSED
line with HV and provided near 18"×12" engineer and no need to combine
reducer
IH are added for accessable
57 2018-2-23 Why IH not required? Please clarify CLOSED
piping
why A2A spec is followed for MP steam
58 2018-2-23 modified to B2A CLOSED
line
tag number repeating check w.r.t PRV401
59 2018-2-23 tag number revised CLOSED
PRV403
The PSV location is changed from the
it is HAZOP meeting
60 2018-9-25 previous revision nd the same may be
requirement,CLOSED
accepted
in document A545-680-16-45-SS-
5442 6.0 xi required two
silencers in HP extraction
line. The new added PSV is
Vendor to review requirement of silencer Comment over cost / time
OEM's recommendation for
61 2018-9-25 at outlet of PRV – 407 and supply of implication is not silencer is added
superheater. Considering there
the same as applicable for other PSV’s. acceptable
is no enough time to purchase
and manufacture new silencer in
this period. Kindly request EIL
to accept.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 5 of 13

this is minute of DCS FAT
I-1406B, 1407B, 1404G are shown for PV-
62 417, TV-408, TV-411. As there are in
closed loop interlock should be removed
from P&ID
07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)
Page 6 of 13
Note,It is control loop and
will be listed in another table of the reason of time
following the interlock table
Vendor to supply the
silencer if the same is
required technically.
Vendor to furnish
It seems M/S EIL commented
technical reason for not
in the old revision.Silenser
providing the same instead
has already added in R8.
kindly ask M/S EIL to give
constraint.
CODE1 so that all PIDs are
As per our understanding
approved.
the silencer at outlet of
PRV-407 is must and shall
be provided without any
time/cost implication.
 Approved in Code- 1 subject to incorporation of the minor comment in the
as built document.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 7 of 13
Approved in Code- 1 subject to incorporation of the minor
comment in the as built document.
Regarding the warm-up vent line size, in rev 4 P&ID, 2” size was shown
for each warm-up vent line. However it has been revised to ¾” in latest
P&ID which is not acceptable. The line being in EIL Scope, HTC is
requested to update their P&ID to show 2” size for each warm-up vent
line in the as built drawing.

EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

07-DEC-2018

Page 8 of 13
 Comment Sheet of Drawing /
Document
Project Name: Dangote Refinery and Petrochemical Projects
EIL Job No.: A545
Name of Package : M/s HTC (HANGZHOU STEAM TURBINE CP., LTD. CHINA)

EIL Transmission Doc. No.

Document Ref. No. A545-02-41-681-1114B

Document Ref. Titile Document No. 0-0642-5604-00

Steram & Drainage P&ID
COMMENTS VENDOR CLARIFICATION/
S.NO. EIL COMMENTS/OBSERVATIONS EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE EIL REPLY VENDOR RESPONSE
DATE RESPONSE
Signal is connected to DEH as per terminal
2017-2-9 drawing.The same shall be suitably indicated
1 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 at all place wherever signal is connected to
Vendor's control System.
2017-2-9 Scheme not clear. vendor to clarify why
the PV is control by downstream
2 interlock has been provided for control valve Closed
图纸上的批复 operation
steam pressure.
2017-2-9 PSV size and orifice designation to be
3 Finalize the size. noted and confirmed CLOSED
图纸上的批复 provided in the P&ID
Open/close Limit switches shall be indicated
2017-2-9 EIL tag no. is added but the
with tag numbers. Connectivity of the same to interlock is not applicable, only
4 connectivity is not clear because it CLOSED
图纸上的批复 DCS or ESD if/as applicable shall be
is supplied by EIL
connect to DCS
indicated in the P&ID.
2017-2-9 Uniformity shall be maintained for tag
5 numbers of a single loop.Like with TT-411 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 control valve tag number is PV-403.
2017-2-9 Instrument air connection to control valve
6 noted Closed
图纸上的批复 shall be tubing, as per PR.

2017-2-9 HTC to also refer to attached hand marked

7 P&ID for comments. The same shall be noted Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 resolved/ incorporated in revised P&ID.
MP steam line numbers shall be designated
with –SM- and HP steam line with –SH- and
2017-2-9 VHP steam line with –SVH- in P&ID’s. HTC to Discussed and shall be
8 noted and modified Not modified. Correct to SM. CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 ensure the same in P&ID. It was observed remained as SL
that MP steam used for seal control is
designated
HTC as scope
to check –SL- of PI 1301/404 and TI
2017-2-9 in EIL drawing A545-02-41-680-
1301/407 in MP steam
9 1113, the four gauge is not marked Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 extraction line from STG as per PR as VF, so it is not in HTC's scope
requirements
Control Oil P&ID is not 2 PT are required as per
2017-2-9 HTC to show two PT’s in MP steam submitted. EIL P&IDs. OR HTC shall 2 PTs are revised in
PT 411 is for extraction pressure
10 extraction line after PT-402 A/B/C Extraction pressure control control oil PID is submitted. Two closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 for extraction pressure controller. control in control oil system PID
shall be as per PR P&ID in submit the write up for not CONTROL OIL PID
the MP extraction line providing 2 PTS
HTC to provide STG tripping logic at low MP
2017-2-9 steam extraction pressure based on three PT’ L for LOW alarm, LL for LOW
what is the significance of 'L',
11 s (2oo3) PT-402 A/B/C as per PR noted LOW trip delay,LLL for LOW CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 requirement. For trip logic, always three PT’s 'LL' and 'LLL'.
LOW LOW trip
are to be used
HTC to check requirement of PSV in
2017-2-9 refer MOM 2.3 Maintain the set pressure
downstream of de superheater and the PSV Each PSV shall be sized for
12 the PSV is 50% rated flow a write up has already emailed REVISED AS PER WRITE UP closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 sizing shall be checked for HP BFW control 100%.
to EIL as agreed in MOM.
valve full open condition.
2017-2-9 as per chinese standard, the flow refer MOM 2.1 Shall be as per email
MP steam header line size shall be retained
13 rate is to low for MP steam , a Mark reducer size 20" X 24". a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 as 24” as per PR P&ID. reducer is set at battery limit to EIL confirmation.

2017-2-9 as per chinese standard, the flow refer MOM 2.2 Shall be as per email
HP steam header line size shall be retained
14 rate is to low for HP steam , a Mark reducer size 8" X 18". a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 as 18”as per PR P&ID. reducer is set at battery limit to EIL confirmation.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 9 of 13
 2017-2-9 HTC to check scope of PI 1302/403 and TI in EIL drawing A545-02-41-680-
15 1303/406 in HP steam extraction line from 1113, the four gauge is not marked Closed CLOSED
EIL 的 CRS 表 STG as per PR requirements. as VF, so it is not in HTC's scope
2 PT are required as per
2017-2-9 HTC to show two PT’s in HP steam extraction Extraction pressure control noted, control oil PID will be
PT 411 is for extraction pressure EIL P&IDs. OR HTC shall
16 line after PT-401 A/B/C for extraction shall be as per PR P&ID in submitted and 2 PTs to SAME AS SL.10 CLOSED closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 pressure controller. control in control oil system PID
the HP extraction line extraction pressure control submit the write up for not
providing 2 PTS
HTC to provide STG tripping logic at low HP
2017-2-9 steam extraction pressure based on three PT’
17 s (2oo3) PT-401 A/B/C as per PR noted Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 requirement. For trip logic, always three PT’s
are to be used
HTC to check requirement of PSV in
2017-2-9 downstream of super heater and the PSV
18 the PSV is 50% rated flow Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 sizing shall be checked for VHP Steam
control valve full open condition.
HTC to clarify SS mentioned for High and low
2017-2-9 instrument readings. We understand that this A stands for alarm and SS stands
19 Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 signifies tripping of the machine. HTC to for trip
clarify our understanding.
2017-2-9 HTC to include description of blowers
20 mentioned in Gland Condenser such as noted and modified Closed
EIL 的 CRS 表 capacity head etc
noted and will be revised,
except 112
112 is altenator speed indicator
is required for all package 67.78.79 are added.
Provide all Instruments as per Control and Instrument missing are at sl. vendor, HTC shall follow the Instrument 67, 78, 79, 84,
Comments is not clear. Please 84 is not required.
2017-7-20 Instrumentation data sheet A545-680-16-45- no. - 58, 65, 67(for exhaust request 112 still missing.
22 indiacte which instruments are frequency is shown in closed
图纸上的批复 DS-5103. condensing line), 78, 79, 82, after checked with generator 112 is required necessarily
Some instruments are still missing.
missing.
83, 84, 112, 113 vendor, 112 alternator speed is protection panel, so 112
to monitor the speed.
not applicable because the is not required
generator speed can be
calculated from ST speed and
they have never provided the
2017-7-20 Motorized drain valve to be provided at valve supplied by EIL, HTC to
23 Closed
图纸上的批复 upstream of ESV. indicate
Incorporate previous piping & process
2017-7-20 comments also. If there is any doubt in any
24 Noted and modified. Closed
图纸上的批复 comment, please contact or write a mail to
us 1) pipings in skid will not have line
no. some pipings informations are
1. all lines shall be indicated
still hold.
1)Provide line nos shown with "X" & "XX". with their line sizes and any
2) added
Also provide line nos at other points where line which is at the interface
3) noted 1. Closed
not given. Many lines are without line nos. shall be indicated with line 1. noted and will be revised
4) some pipings such as balancing
2017-7-20 2) Steam Inlet pressure (PT) required. numbers. 4. This area is not accessable
piping 8-SL-681-4A05A-B2A, it is in
25 3)Steam Exhaust pressure (PT) with Alarm 2. Closed for person , insulation is not
图纸上的批复 and trip required.
the hole below the ST where no
3. Closed required will be reviewed at 3 D 4. Shall be reviewed during
people can get close to. And also
4) Show Insulation where required. 4. Wherever there is a scope model review.
many pipings in the hole, there is no 3D model review.
5) Check PMS for each line with insulations of reaching a person,
space for piping insulation. as per
and tracings. insulation shall be provided
HTC experience, this pipings is not
for safety.
insulated
5) noted
Not modified as per MOM. As per MOM, HTC refer to MOM.2.1 and in
2017-7-20 refer MOM 2.1
Provide this scheme as per MOM dated 02nd 24" inlet required with one line proposed for 14" which is latest PID, VHP inlet line
26 Drawing is modified as per MOM. a write up has already emailed closed
图纸上的批复 March 2017. with a reducer of 24"X12"
to EIL not considered as standard is 18". (EIL to give
shall be shown. size and hence 16" shall be clearence)
noted, control oil PID will be
submitted. About the pressure
Extraction pressure control control transmitter. HTC has Provide technical write up
2017-7-20 Provide Extraction Pressure controller as per pressure controlled by extraction SAME AS SL.10
27 shall be as per PR P&ID in remembered that this is mentioning non reliability of closed
图纸上的批复 P&ID. control valve mounted in turbine CLOSED
the MP & HP extraction line discussed in the former meeting, using 2 PTs with PIC.
the logic of the 2PTs is not
reliable
2017-7-20
28 shall be tubing as per PR any specific legend for tube? Closed
图纸上的批复

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 10 of 13
 EIL and DORC proposed that all DISCUSSED AND DRIP
2017-7-20 All drip leg shall be routed to drip leg shall be connected to LEG SHALL NOT BE
29 Drip Leg Noted and modified. Shall be shown in the PID. closed
图纸上的批复 condensate header. flash tank. ROUTED TO FLASH
TANK
EIL and DORC proposed that all DISCUSSED AND DRIP
2017-7-20 All drip leg shall be routed to drip leg shall be connected to LEG SHALL NOT BE
30 Drip Leg Noted and modified. Shall be shown in the PID. closed
图纸上的批复 condensate header. flash tank. ROUTED TO FLASH
TANK
IN HP EXTRACTION LINE In the revised PID, the sizes
2017-7-20 INLET NPS6 OUTLET NPS 8 MArk the same in the P&ID the final sizes are shown
31 Confirm the size of PSV revised are not as shown in the closed
图纸上的批复 IN MP EXTRACTION LINE also. in PID
INLET NPS12 OUTLET NPS 16 resolution in coloumn aside.
2017-7-20 Refer direction of bullet
Direction of NRV shall be as per earlier direction is already shown, HTC will
32 shown in the commented revised CLOSED
图纸上的批复 comments enlarge the arrow
P&ID above
2017-7-20 Refer Commented P&ID for
33 1302, 1301, 1301 Noted and modified. tag no correction. CLOSED
图纸上的批复 Closed.
HP steam header line size
mentioned by HTC is 8" and
10" in P&ID but no reducer
2017-7-20 HTC consider the pipe to be 20" for refer MOM 2.2 is shown. Moreover, HTC to
Line Size shall be 18" as
34 18" better piping design and will be 24" a write up has already emailed REFER TO MOM closed
图纸上的批复 at the battery limit
mentioned in the PR P&ID.
to EIL recheck for 8" & 10" line
size as the same is having
high velocity and pressure
drop. Refer email.
2017-7-20
35 Unit in kg/cm2 Noted and modified. Not modified. revised CLOSED
图纸上的批复
2017-7-20 HTC consider the pipe to be 20" for refer MOM 2.1 Refer email reply to write
Line Size shall be 24" as
36 Line size shall be 24". better piping design and will be 24" a write up has already emailed refer to MOM closed
图纸上的批复 at the battery limit
mentioned in the PR P&ID.
to EIL up.
It was discussed and
explained the meaning to
PMS is changing from B2A to spec break to HTC during
2017-7-20 noted. But this is not a spec
37 Show spec break no spec break here A2A, so spec break shall be meeting and was agreed to HTC clarified and closed closed
图纸上的批复 break, PID has modified
shown. get it changed, as
commented. Please revise
the P&ID and show spec
2017-7-20 Which symbol is this. Mention in the legend Mention in the legend list of a drawing of SYMBOLS AND
38 expansion joint CLOSED
图纸上的批复 list. P&ID. LEGEND is submitted
2017-7-20
39 Line size 1978×978×10 square pipe Closed
图纸上的批复
2017-7-20
40 Line size Not finalized yet. Finalize. revised but some line stays hold Shall be finalised soon. REVISED closed
图纸上的批复
Following equipment information
needs to be added along with
tag no.
2017-7-20 equipment tag no. is not clear, Tag no is 681-LZ-1004 1. QCNRV
41 Write equipment Tag no. CLOSED
图纸上的批复 please clarify A/B/C/D. 2. Super heater and desuper
heater
3. gland condenser
4 Exhaust spray valve
1) Show the inlet line size as per PR 1. Show 24" line then a
P&ID. reducer from 24" to 18", as
1)added
2) Silencer in vendor scope.
42 2017-11-1 2)noted discussed in the meeting. same as sl. 13 closed
3) Follow full scheme along with the
type of
3)noted 2. Mark the scope in P&ID.
valves shown in the PR P&ID. 3. Closed.
43 2017-11-1 Mention tag numbers of the instrument revised Closed
For superheater and desuperheater,
44 2017-11-1 follow revised Closed
scheme as per PR P&ID.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 11 of 13
 not required in the inlet because PT
PT with L&H alarm logic in steam inlet are A single PT may be required
discussed and PT is not
45 2017-11-1 of mounted in the main steam line. in order to monitor the pressor closed
required.
sealing superheater And C&I in the same line.
datasheet doesn't require these
Size of the control valves shall
be mentioned in the P&IDs.
Tags for Modulating control
46 2018-1-9 revised closed
valves shall be PV/TV /LV etc.
PCV /TCV shall be used for
Self actuated control
Tags used in interlock shall
47 2018-1-9 revised closed
not be considered as FF
This VHP steam drain shall
48 2018-1-9 add one manual valve closed
have double isolation valve
PT shall be provided here discussed and acceptable as
49 2018-1-9 closed
also, as before valve 2301. per PID
PI shall be provided at each
50 2018-1-9 local gauge are provided closed
seal inlet.
Please provide double temp. discussed and one temp. to be discussed during
51 2018-1-9 discussed and no need CLOSED
element for this transmitter element is acceptable HAZOP
This steam drain line shall double isolation valve
why not provide for MP
52 2018-1-9 revised for pressure above CLOSED
have double isolation valve steam line
40kg/cm2
Any motor signals from MCC
53 2018-1-9 to DCS shall also be indicated revised closed
in theP&ID.
54 2018-1-9 Line no to be provided? this is a rectangular duct closed
discussed in HAZOP. Two ESVs
HTC to clarify why PT and TE/TT are
are connected so the value are
provided in this line but only PI/TI are
55 2018-2-23 the same and also there are CLOSED
provided in line number 4B03A. Maintain
TT/PT in 18" main line. So no
consistency.
need
Clarify basis of 2" line size. Can these
vent lines be combined in to single vent discussed with EIL process
56 2018-2-23 CLOSED
line with HV and provided near 18"×12" engineer and no need to combine
reducer
IH are added for accessable
57 2018-2-23 Why IH not required? Please clarify CLOSED
piping
why A2A spec is followed for MP steam
58 2018-2-23 modified to B2A CLOSED
line
tag number repeating check w.r.t PRV401
59 2018-2-23 tag number revised CLOSED
PRV403
The PSV location is changed from the
it is HAZOP meeting
60 2018-9-25 previous revision nd the same may be
requirement,CLOSED
accepted
in document A545-680-16-45-SS-
5442 6.0 xi required two
silencers in HP extraction
line. The new added PSV is
Vendor to review requirement of silencer Comment over cost / time
OEM's recommendation for
61 2018-9-25 at outlet of PRV – 407 and supply of implication is not silencer is added
superheater. Considering there
the same as applicable for other PSV’s. acceptable
is no enough time to purchase
and manufacture new silencer in
this period. Kindly request EIL
to accept.

07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)

Page 12 of 13

this is minute of DCS FAT
I-1406B, 1407B, 1404G are shown for PV-
62 417, TV-408, TV-411. As there are in
closed loop interlock should be removed
from P&ID
07-DEC-2018
EASWARAN MAHESH (A804)
Page 13 of 13
Note,It is control loop and
will be listed in another table of the reason of time
following the interlock table
Vendor to supply the
silencer if the same is
required technically.
Vendor to furnish
It seems M/S EIL commented
technical reason for not
in the old revision.Silenser
providing the same instead
has already added in R8.
kindly ask M/S EIL to give
constraint.
CODE1 so that all PIDs are
As per our understanding
approved.
the silencer at outlet of
PRV-407 is must and shall
be provided without any
time/cost implication.