Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Publications 012
Publications 012
ScienceDirect
Article history: Diesel engines have been considered as a major source in nitrogen oxide (NOx) formation
Received 23 November 2016 worldwide. The widespread use of diesel engines in consequence of their low fuel con-
Received in revised form sumption, high durability and efficiency increases NOx emissions day by day. NOx emis-
31 January 2017 sions from diesel engines cause unavoidable damage on environment and people health.
Accepted 1 February 2017 Although so many technologies such as exhaust gas recirculation (EGR), lean burn com-
Available online 24 February 2017 bustion, electronic controlling fuel injection systems, etc. have been developed to control
NOx emissions from diesel engines, they couldn't meet the desired reduction in NOx
Keywords: emissions. In any case, Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) as one of the most promising
Hydrogen aftertreatment-emission control technologies is an effective solution in restriction of NOx
Selective catalytic reduction emissions. The use of SCR systems especially in heavy-duty diesel powered vehicles has
NOx been increasing nowadays. In these systems, to use of hydrogen (H2) as a reductant or
Diesel engine promoter have been improved the conversion efficiency especially at low exhaust tem-
peratures. Many researchers have been focused on the use of H2 in SCR systems for con-
trolling NOx emissions.
In this study, the applications of H2 in SCR of NOx have been discussed. The studies on
use of H2 in SCR of NOx emissions were examined and the effects on NOx conversions were
determined. Consequently, it is confirmed that H2 is a promising and alternative reductant
in SCR of NOx and it has been kept as an attracting subject for many researchers.
© 2017 Hydrogen Energy Publications LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
actively and degraded H2 provides NO conversion effectively Park et al. [45] used zirconia as a main substrate expect
[36]. Pt is the most common noble metal catalyst for H2-SCR conventional alumina and silica in H2-SCR systems. Pt was
[41]. The reactions initiate with a low light-off temperature used as based noble metal in this study. The results showed
about 90 C over Pt/Al2O3 catalyst by the presence of H2 as that zirconia had better performance as a catalytic support
reductant [44]. compared alumina and silica in the term of conversion effi-
Although Pt based catalysts have high activity at low ciency and hydrothermal stability.
temperatures, it has high selectivity for N2O formation and Li et al. [17] tested four different catalysts as, Pt/ƴ-Al2O3, Pt/
lower selectivity for N2 [22,31]. However, many studies have MgO, Pt/HZSM-5 and Pt/ZrO2 in H2-SCR system. They found
been carried out on new catalysts and to improve the N2 that conversion efficiency of catalysts were greatly depended
selectivity of Pt based catalyst with reductant of hydrogen on Pt content in catalyst and NOx adsorption capacity of
under excess oxygen [35]. substrates.
The type of catalyst substrate (Al2O3, SiO2, ZSM5, etc.) af- Table 1 shows the activity of different catalyst type in H2-
fects strongly the activity of Pt catalyst. Especially the alka- SCR. In this table, Tcon. is the minimum temperature at which
linity and acidity of catalyst has an impact on the dispersion of maximum conversion efficiency is obtained. Considering the
Pt on catalyst and thus on the activity of catalyst [17]. Expect of studies carried out on H2-SCR catalyst, it is shown that Pt
Al2O3 substrate, different substrate such as; Pt/SiO2 [45], based catalyst is best choice for H2-SCR applications. NOx
NiFe1.95Pt0.05O4 [15], Pt/TiO2 [46], Pt/MnOx [34], Pt/Ce1xZrxO2d conversions were obtained in high rates at low temperatures
[47] worked in researches. Burch and Coleman [44] compared almost for all Pt based catalyst.
Al2O3 and SiO2 as Pt catalyst support considering their activity Clearly, Pd is the most promising catalyst which comes
in H2-SCR. Pt/SiO2 showed best performance in terms of ac- after Pt based catalysts with high conversion efficiencies near
tivity at low temperatures. the Pt based catalysts. Compared Pt, Pd is remarkable with the
The effects of H2 on selective catalytic reduction of NO over specifications of cheaper, high thermal stability, easily avail-
Pt/ƴ-Al2O3, Pd/ƴ-Al2O3 and Ir/ƴ-Al2O3 were studied by Goula able and higher N2 selectivity [13,52]. Especially the activity of
et al. [10]. In this research, Pt based catalyst showed higher Pd based catalyst in SCR of NO is so high compared to Pt and
activity compared to other noble metal based catalysts. other noble metal catalysts [53]. Different supports for Pd
The supplement of WO3 to Pt/TiO2 catalysts for H2-SCR of based catalysts such as PdeIr/TiO2 [33], Pd/K2O-6TiO2 [50], Pd/
NOx investigated by Liu et al. [46]. They found that the sup- TiO2-Al2O3 [51] performed in H2-SCR of NOx by researchers. Qi
plement of WO3 led to increase in conversion efficiency at low et al. [5] used H2 as a reductant to catalytic reduction of NOx
temperatures. The NOx conversion efficiency at low temper- with Pd catalysts. They found that H2 gave high NO conversion
atures reached up to 90% with the addition WO3. at low temperatures with Pd catalysts.
Except Pt and Pd, different catalysts such as Rh, Ni, Ir, TiO2, the effect of hydrogen on the efficiency of NOx reduction with
Co, etc. have been developed by researchers as alternative HC-SCR was carried out by Gu et al. [43] using both laboratory
catalysts for H2-SCR applications. Xu et al. [13] developed and engine test-bench. They preferred Ag/Al2O3 catalyst in
NiFe2xPdxO4 catalysts for the SCR of NO by hydrogen. They their research because of its high performance for HC-SCR
obtained nearly 100% NO conversion at 190 C. In their other applications. Results showed that H2 had an improving ef-
study [27], they searched the effect of aluminate spinel oxides fect on NOx conversion at both laboratory condition and real
(CuAl2O4, CoAl2O4, ZnAl2O4) and palladium-substituted alu- working situation. NOx conversion rates increased up to three
minates (CuAl1.95Pd0.05O4, CoAl1.95Pd0.05O4, ZnAl1.95Pd0.05O4) times with the use of H2 in the tests carried out on engine test-
on H2-SCR of NO. Palladium-substituted aluminates showed bench. Shimizu et al. [29] investigated the hydrogen effect on
better activity compared to aluminate spinel oxides under the HC-SCR. Ag-MFI was used as catalyst in this experimental
same reaction conditions. Approximately maximum conver- study. The use of hydrogen led to increase the coverage of
sion efficiency was obtained as 95% with CoAl1.95Pd0.05O4. surface intermediates, NO2 concentration and N2 formation.
The hydrogen effect on SCR of NO by propane over Ag/
H2 assisted HC-SCR system Al2O3 catalyst was investigated by Richter et al. [57]. They
found that the propounding of H2 avoid to NO conversion to
H2 has been also used as promoter in HC-SCR systems. H2 NO2 form substantially. The presence of H2 raised the NOx
improves conversion efficiency of HC-SCR affecting catalyst conversion up to 60% from marginal conversion rates.
and other reactants [39]. Especially at low temperature, the Theinnoi et al. [58] searched the effect of H2 promotion on
supplement of H2 into exhaust gas increase catalyst activity passive HC-SCR activity. They performed their study over Ag/
[54]. Many researches have been carried out on H2 assisted Al2O3 catalyst promoting H2 (500e3000 ppm) with real diesel
HC-SCR systems. Ag/Al2O3 has been most common catalyst in exhaust gas. Consequently, they reached two results for H2
these researches due to its high activity and efficiency in SCR effects on silver catalysis. These results were the increase in
of NO by hydrocarbons [55]. Except Al2O3, different supports initial activity and the decrease in deactivation rate of
like MFI zeolite [29,56] have been used in Ag based catalyst for catalyst.
H2 assisted HC-SCR. Sadokhina et al. [2] searched the catalytic activity of Ag/
Abu-Jrai and Tsolakis [42] studied the effect of H2 and CO Al2O3 catalyst in SCR of NOx in the presence of small amount
addition on HC-SCR activity over 1% Pt/Al2O3. Unlike other of H2. In this experimental study, the addition of ~1000 ppm
studies they performed their study using real diesel engine hydrogen improved activity and selectivity of catalyst.
exhaust gas. H2 addition improved the HC-SCR activity at low Zhang et al. [59] searched the effect of hydrogen on reac-
temperatures between 100 C and 300 C. Another study on tion intermediates in the selective catalytic reduction of NOx
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 2 ( 2 0 1 7 ) 2 3 3 8 9 e2 3 3 9 4 23393
by C3H6. Ag/Al2O3 was preferred as catalyst in their study since effects on the real-driving emissions of light diesel vehicles.
its high NOx conversion efficiency by alcohols. They found Sci Total Environ 2013;461e462:377e85.
that the addition of H2 was significantly increased NOx con- [10] Goula MA, Charisiou ND, Papageridis KN, Delimitis A. A
comparative study of the H2-assisted selective catalytic
version at low temperature range of 200e350 C.
reduction of nitric oxide by propene over noble metal (Pt, Pd,
Stakheev et al. [60] investigated the effects of H2 addition Ir)/g-Al2O3 catalysts. J Environ Chem Eng 2016;4:1629e41.
amount on HC-SCR of NOx over Ag/Al2O3. They used different [11] Valiheikki A, Petallidou KC, Kalamaras CM, Kolli T. Selective
H2 amounts from 0 to 1600 ppm in their researches. Conse- catalytic reduction of NOx by hydrogen (H2-SCR) on WOx-
quently, NOx conversion showed increase in direct propor- promoted CezZr1zO2 solids. Appl Catal B: Environ
tionally with H2 addition amount. 2014;156e157:72e83.
[12] Resitoglu IA, Altinisik K, Keskin A. The pollutant emissions
from diesel-engine vehicles and exhaust aftertreatment
systems. Clean Technol Environ Policy 2015;17:15e27.
Conclusions [13] Xu C, Sun W, Cao L, Yang J. Selective catalytic reduction of
nitric oxide by hydrogen over NiFe2xPdxO4 catalysts at low
This review focused on H2 applications in SCR technology. The temperature. Chem Eng J 2016;283:1137e44.
H2-SCR technology was expressed and the researches on H2- [14] Alkemade UG, Schumann B. Engines and exhaust after
SCR was scrutinised in this study. The researches carried out treatment systems for future automotive applications. Solid
State Ion 2006;177:2291e6.
on H2-SCR showed that the addition of hydrogen resulted in
[15] Sun W, Qiao K, Liu J, Cao L, Gong C, Yang J. Pt-doped NiFe2O4
conversion of the oxidized nitrogen to N2 on the catalyst
spinel as a highly efficient catalyst for H2 selective catalytic
surface. H2 has an improving effect on SCR activity especially reduction of NO at room temperature. ACS Comb Sci
at low temperature. Pt and Pd based catalysts are the most 2016;18:195e202.
feasible and current for H2-SCR applications while Ag based [16] Wang X, Wen W, Mi J, Li X, Wang R. The ordered mesoporous
catalysts have high efficiency in H2 assisted HC-SCR applica- transition metal oxides for selective catalytic reduction of
tions. The most of researches on H2-SCR have been carried out NOx at low temperature. Appl Catal B Environ
2015;176e177:454e63.
in laboratory conditions. The studies carried out in real
[17] Li X, Zhang X, Xu Y, Liu Y, Wang X. Influence of support
working conditions of engine are substantially restricted. In- properties on H2 selective catalytic reduction activities and
vestigations in real working situations must be increased with N2 selectivities of Pt catalysts. Chin J Catal
future studies. In conclusion, H2 is a promising reductant for 2015;36:197e203.
SCR applications of NOx without caused any formation of [18] Schaber P, Colson J, Higgins S, Thielen D, Anspach B, Brauer J.
pollutants and the researches on improving of H2-SCR will Thermal decomposition (pyrolysis) of urea in an open
continue for a longer time. reaction vessel. Thermochim Acta 2004;424:131e42.
[19] Azis MM, Harelind H, Creaser D. Kinetic modeling of H2-
assisted C3H6 selective catalytic reduction of NO over silver
alumina catalyst. Chem Eng J 2015;278:394e406.
references
[20] Shimizu K, Satsuma A. Selective catalytic reduction of NO
over supported silver catalysts-practical and mechanistic
aspects. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2006;8:2677e95.
[1] Cai X, Sun W, Xu C, Cao L, Yang J. Highly selective catalytic [21] Arve E, Eranen K, Snare M, Klingstedt F, Murzin D. Selective
reduction of NO via SO2/H2O-tolerant spinel catalysts at low catalytic reduction of NOx over Ag/Al2O3 using various bio-
temperature. Environ Sci Pollut Res 2016;23:18609e20. diesels as reducing agents. Top Catal 2007;42:399e403.
[2] Sadokhina NA, Prokhorova AF, Kvon RI, Mashkovskii IS. [22] Caraviggo G, Nossova L, Burich R. Influence of supports on Pd
Dependence of the catalytic activity of Ag/Al2O3 on the silver catalysts for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with H2
concentration in the selective reduction of NOx with n- and CO. Emiss Control Sci Technol 2016;2:10e9.
hexane in the presence of H2. Kinet Catal 2012;53:107e16. [23] Zhou JH, Cheung CS, Leung CW. Combustion, performance
[3] Wang X, Zheng Y, Xu Z, Liu X, Zhang Y. Low-temperature and emissions of a diesel engine with H2, CH4 and H2eCH4
selective catalytic reduction of NO over MnOx/CNTs catalysts addition. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014;39:4611e21.
effect of thermal treatment condition. Catal Commun [24] Saravanan N, Nagarajan G. An insight on hydrogen fuel
2014;50:34e7. injection techniques with SCR system for NOx reduction in a
[4] Zhang Q, Qiu C, Xu H. Low-temperature selective catalytic hydrogenediesel dual fuel engine. Int J Hydrogen Energy
reduction of NO with NH3 over monolith catalyst of MnOx/ 2009;34:9019e32.
CeO2eZrO2eAl2O3. Catal Today 2011;175:171e6. [25] Chong JJ, Tsolakis A, Gill SS, Theinnoi K, Golunski SE.
[5] Qi G, Yang RT, Thompson LT. Catalytic reduction of nitric Enhancing the NO2/NOx ratio in compression ignition
oxide with hydrogen and carbon monoxide in the presence engines by hydrogen and reformate combustion, for
of excess oxygen by Pd supported on pillared clays. Appl improved aftertreatment performance. Int J Hydrogen
Catal A: General 2004;259:261e7. Energy 2010;35:8723e32.
[6] Clark PD, Nielsen AD, Dowling NI. Catalytic reduction of [26] Abu-Jrai A, Tsolakis A, Megaritis A. The influence of H2 and
nitric oxide by hydrogen sulfide over ƴ-alumina. Catal Lett CO on diesel engine combustion characteristics, exhaust gas
2005;104:73e8. emissions, and after treatment selective catalytic NOx
[7] Qi G, Wang Y, Yang RT. Selective catalytic reduction of nitric reduction. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2007;32:3565e71.
oxide with ammonia over ZSM-5 based catalysts for diesel [27] Xu C, Sun W, Cao L, Li T, Cai X, Yang J. Highly efficient Pd-
engine applications. Catal Lett 2008;121:111e7. doped aluminate spinel catalysts with different divalent
[8] Roy S, Hegde MS, Madras G. Catalysis for NOx abatement. cations for the selective catalytic reduction of NO with H2 at
Appl Energy 2009;86:2283e97. low temperature. Chem Eng J 2017;308:980e7.
[9] Lee T, Park J, Kwon S, Lee J, Kim J. Variability in operation [28] Arve K, Backman H, Klingstedt F, Eranen K, Murzin D. Kinetic
based NOx emission factors with different test routes, and its considerations of H2 assisted hydrocarbon selective catalytic
23394 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 2 ( 2 0 1 7 ) 2 3 3 8 9 e2 3 3 9 4
reduction of NO over Ag/Al2O3 I. Kinetic behaviour. Appl [45] Park SM, Jang H, Kim ES, Han HS, Seo G. Incorporation of
Catal A General 2006;303:96e102. zirconia onto silica for improved Pt/SiO2 catalysts for the
[29] Shimizu K, Sugino K, Kato K. Reaction mechanism of H2- selective reduction of NO by H2. Appl Catal A: General
promoted selective catalytic reduction of NO with C3H8 over 2012;427e428:155e64.
Ag-MFI zeolite. J Phys Chem C 2007;111:6481e7. [46] Liu Z, Lu Y, Yuan L, Ma L. Selective catalytic reduction of NOx
[30] Furfori S, Russo N, Fino D, Saracco G, Specchia V. NO SCR with H2 over WO3 promoted Pt/TiO2 catalyst. Appl Catal B
reduction by hydrogen generated in line on perovskite-type Environ 2016;188:189e97.
catalysts for automotive diesel exhaust gas treatment. Chem [47] Kalamaras CM, Olympiou GG, Parvulescu VI, Cojocaru B,
Eng Sci 2010;65:120e7. Efstathiou AM. Selective catalytic reduction of NO by H2/C3H6
[31] Huai L, Wang H, He C, Wen H. Effect of subsurface oxygen on over Pt/Ce1xZrxO2d: the synergy effect studied by transient
selective catalytic reduction of NO by H2 on Pt(100): a first- techniques. Appl Catal B Environ 2017;206:308e18.
principles. Study J Phys Chem C 2015;119:24819e26. [48] Burch S, Scire S. An investigation of the mechanism of the
[32] Xu C, Sun W, Cao L, Yang J. Highly efficient Pd-doped ferrite selective catalytic reduction of NO on various metal/ZSM-5
spinel catalysts for the selective catalytic reduction of NO catalysts: reactions of H2/NO mixtures. Catal Lett
with H2 at low temperature. Chem Eng J 2016;289:231e8. 1994;27:177e86.
[33] Li J, Wu G, Guan N, Li L. NO selective reduction by hydrogen [49] Wu P, Li L, Yu Q, Wu G, Guan N. Study on Pt/Al-MCM-41 for
over bimetallic PdeIr/TiO2 catalyst. Catal Commun NO selective reduction by hydrogen. Catal Today
2012;24:38e43. 2010;158:228e34.
[34] Park SM, Kim MY, Kim ES, Han HS, Seo G. H2-SCR of NO on [50] Li L, Zhang F, Guan N, Schreier E, Richter M. NO selective
PteMnOx catalysts: reaction path via NH3 formation. Appl reduction by hydrogen on potassium titanate supported
Catal A General 2011;395:120e8. palladium catalyst. Catal Commun 2008;9:1827e32.
[35] Rodriguez GC, Kelm K, Saruhan B. H2-selective catalytic [51] Qi G, Yang RT, Rinaldi FC. Selective catalytic reduction of
reduction of NOx activity and microstructural analysis of nitric oxide with hydrogen over Pd-based catalysts. J Catal
new BaTi0.95Pd0.05O3 catalyst. Appl Catal A General 2006;237:381e92.
2010;387:173e84. [52] Huai L, He C, Wang H, Wen H. NO dissociation and reduction
[36] Wang L, Yin C, Yang RT. Selective catalytic reduction of nitric by H2 on Pd (111): a first-principles study. J Catal
oxide with hydrogen on supported Pd: enhancement by 2015;322:73e83.
hydrogen spillover. Appl Catal A General 2016;514:35e42. [53] Martin JC, Suarez S, Yates M, Avila P. Pd/ceAl2O3 monolithic
[37] Breen JP, Burch R, Hill CJ. NOx storage during H2 assisted catalysts for NOx reduction with CH4 in excess of O2: effect of
selective catalytic reduction of NOx reaction over a Ag/Al2O3 precursor salt. Chem Eng J 2009;150:8e14.
catalyst. Catal Today 2009;145:34e7. [54] Sitshebo S, Tsolakis A, Theinnoi K. Promoting hydrocarbon-
[38] More PM. Effect of active component addition and support SCR of NOx in diesel engine exhaust by hydrogen and fuel
modification on catalytic activity of Ag/Al2O3 for the selective reforming. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2009;34:7842e50.
catalytic reduction of NOx by hydrocarbonea review. J [55] Klingstedt F, Arve K, Eranen K, Murzin D. Toward improved
Environ Manag 2017;188:43e8. catalytic low-temperature NOx removal in diesel-powered
[39] Lee DH, Lee J, Kim K, Song Y, Kim E, Han H. Hydrogen in vehicles. Acc Chem Res 2006;39:273e82.
plasma-assisted hydrocarbon selective catalytic reduction. [56] Sawabe K, Hiro T, Shizimu K, Satsuma A. Density functional
Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012;37:3225e33. theory calculation on the promotion effect of H2 in the
[40] Yu Q, Richter M, Kong F, Li L. Selective catalytic reduction of selective catalytic reduction of NOx over AgeMFI zeolite.
NO by hydrogen over Pt/ZSM-35. Catal Today 2010;158:452e8. Catal Today 2010;153:90e4.
[41] Schott FJP, Balle P, Adler J. Reduction of NOx by H2 on Pt/WO3/ [57] Richter M, Bentrup U, Eckelt R, Schneider M, Pohl M, Fricke R.
ZrO2 catalysts in oxygen-rich exhaust. Appl Catal B Environ The effect of hydrogen on the selective catalytic reduction of
2009;87:18e29. NO in excess oxygen over Ag/Al2O3. Appl Catal B: Environ
[42] Abu-Jrai A, Tsolakis A. The effect of H2 and CO on the 2004;51:261e74.
selective catalytic reduction of NOx under real diesel engine [58] Theinnoi K, Sitshebo S, Houel V, Rajaram RR, Tsolakis A.
exhaust conditions over Pt/Al2O3. Int J Hydrogen Energy Hydrogen promotion of low-temperature passive
2007;32:2073e80. hydrocarbon-selective catalytic reduction (SCR) over a silver
[43] Gu H, Chun KM, Song S. The effects of hydrogen on the catalyst. Energy Fuels 2008;22:4109e14.
efficiency of NOx reduction via hydrocarbon-selective [59] Zhang X, Yu Y, He H. Effect of hydrogen on reaction
catalytic reduction (HC-SCR) at low temperature using intermediates in the selective catalytic reduction of NOx by
various reductants. Int J hydrogen energy 2015;40:9602e10. C3H6. Appl Catal B Environ 2007;76:241e7.
[44] Burch R, Coleman MD. An investigation of the NO/H2/O2 [60] Stakheev AY, Pributkov PV, Dahl S, Gekas I. Two reaction
reaction on noble-metal catalysts at low temperatures under pathways in the selective catalytic reduction of NOx by C6H14
lean-burn conditions. Appl Catal B Environ 1999;23:115e21. over AgeAl2O3 with H2 co-feeding. Top Catal 2009;52:1821e5.