Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Answer
Answer
1st reviewer:
1. The authors said in the article that the plasma reaction of methane to hydrogen,
acetylene and carbon is an exothermic reaction, please give a specification of the
conclusion. As all known that the decomposition of methane is endothermic reaction
from thermodynamic analysis.
Answer:
Actually the conclusion that gliding plasma reaction is exothermic reaction because the
heat that is produced itself. The experiment shows that the outlet gas temperature has
increased around 30-50oC. If we just consider the increasing heat just coming from
external AC power supply, and it is applied to equation 6 and 8, the increment of
temperature will be much lower than the reality (in the manuscript, it stated just 20-30%
contribution to the increment of temperature). So, from where the rest energy to make
the temperature increase 70%-80% more comes? By calculation, it is almost exactly that
it comes from the reaction. In order to make it into less ambiguous, the author has
changed the sentence form to make it clear that 70%-80% of increasing temperature was
caused by exothermic reaction.
2. Some mistakes were made in Figure 6 and Figure 7. In Figure 6c and Figure 7c it is
not clear which is the simulation one or the experimental data.
Answer:
Author thanks to the reviewer for the very precise checking and it has been changed in
the revised manuscript.
4. The unit used in this article such as Nl/min should be transfer to international
standard unit.
Answer:
Once more, author thanks to the reviewer for the recommendation. Author already put
the equivalent of this dimension to the international standard (see page 4). Following 2 nd
author, the dimension has been changed from Nl/min to L/min. The reason why the
author didn’t change it into SI unit is, as seen in page 4, the format is quite difficult to
be captured by reader which appears uncommon with 10-5 basis. It is easier for the
reader to understand and imagine in format of L/min which give shorter form, such as 1
L/min or 1.5 L/min.
2nd reviewer:
n
3. In Table 1, what’s the meaning of the sentence of “ k = AT exp(− E / RTr ) , in cm,
kJ, s, and mole units”. And what are the units of A, n, E in Table 1.
Answer:
By the following the reaction list sources (ref. 32 -34), k has dimension [s-1], A=[cm3
mol-1 s-1], T=[K], E=[kJ mol-1]. All variable units have been added in the revised
manuscript (below the table 1).
4. There are some mistakes in Figure 6, 7. In Figure 6, the figure (d) is designated as
(b), please revise it; In Figure 7, the Figure 7(c) is designated as Figure 7(b), please
revise it.
Answer:
Author thanks to the reviewer for the very precise checking and it has been changed in
the revised manuscript.