Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Oles - TOWARDS THE PSYCHOLOGICAL MODEL OF MIDLIFE CRISIs1999
Oles - TOWARDS THE PSYCHOLOGICAL MODEL OF MIDLIFE CRISIs1999
PIOTR K. OLES
'Please address correspondence and reprint requests to Piotr K. Oles, Department of Clinical
Psychology and Personalit Catholic University of Lublin, Al. Racla\vickie 14, 20-950 Lublin,
poland or e-mail (oles@k~!i~blin.~).
Tables of means and SDs for sca es are on file in MD-1999-0008. Remit $6.25 for photocopy
to the Archive for Psychological Data, P.O. Box 7922, Missoula, MT 59807-7922.
1060 P. K. OLES
the typical age for such crisis is between 40 and 45 years, according to
Jaques (1965) or Gould (1978) at around 37 years. Ln an extensive review of
the literature Kearl and Hoag (1984) mentioned that average beginning age
for the crisis cited in psychological articles is 37.7 yr. Some theories empha-
size that midlife crisis is a common phenomenon for all or almost all men,
because every man arriving at his middle age has himself to confront with
similar difficulties, h e biological, psychological, and sociocultural signs that
lde is half over, changes in family roles and professional status, and growing
awareness of one's own mortality (Gould, 1978; Levinson, 1986). Other the-
ories, however, point out that midlife crisis occurs only in some men, while
many others pass this period of life without any explicit or implicit signs of
crisis (see, e.g., Colarusso & Nemiroff, 19811, whereas Costa and McCrae
(1978) or Kruger (1994) argued that midhfe crisis is rather like a chimera
than a real phenomenon in psychological research because no one has con-
vincingly shown there is higher anxiety or depression in a midhfe sample.
The notion of midlife crisis, like 'identity crisis', however, is applied to
a developmental rather than a pathological phenomenon, so it is manifested
by an essential change in one's point of view about Me and not a particular
level of any clinical variable, e.g., anxiety. And as conceptualized, it certainly
is a crisis, a period of transition, and a process of successive internal and
external changes. All these changes may constitute a period of internal tur-
moil and external distress, called 'midlde crisis', followed by a new Me atti-
tude described by Er~kson(1963) as generativity. A man has to build up a
new lde structure, which means he has to change or adapt his personal be-
liefs, values, expectations, feehgs, and ways of coping (Levinson, Darrow,
Klein, Levinson, & McKee, 1978; Ciernia, 1985; Wolfe, O'Connor, & Gary,
1990). On the one hand, midhfe crisis has to do with a re-evaluation of the
past and dissatisfaction with the present. O n the other hand, mi&e transi-
tion or m i u e crisis offers new opportunities to follow personal dreams and
to reformulate personal strivings.
Summing up, midlife crisis in men is a process of an intensive and ddfi-
cult transition of the self caused by the awareness that the adaptation style
which has been adequate in young adulthood has become inadequate in mid-
dle age. This process involves changes in time perspective from 'time since
birth' to 'time left to live' (Neugarten, 19681, the experience of one's own
mortality, a review of past and present achievements and losses, and a re-
evaluation of personal goals. Moreover, major social changes influence the
way in which a person goes through midlife (Riegel, 1975; Chiriboga, 1989).
Numerous investigations dealing with the problem of mi&fe crisis have
proven that the ways in which nlen go through midlife depend on the follow-
ing variables: ( I ) Valuation (Fiske & Chiriboga, 1990; Drebing & Gooden,
1991), (2) Time orientation (Bardwick, 1978; McAdarns, Ruetzel, & Foley,
MODEL OF MIDLIFE CRISIS 1061
1986; Shmotlun, 1991), (3) Ways of coping (Kalish, 1989; Juhan, McKenry,
& Arnold, 1990), and (4) Basic structure of personality (Waskel & Coleman,
1991; Waskel, 1995). Thus, the question is which particular variables from
these four broad domains of Valuation, Time orientation, Coping, and Per-
sonality traits influence midhfe crisis.
METHOD
Measures
Midfzje Crisis Questionnaire.-Miwe crisis was measured by means of
the Midhfe Crisis Questionnaire developed by Oles (1994). The items were
formulated based upon the various symptoms of midhfe crisis described in
the psychological literature (see, e.g., Jaques, 1965; Gould, 1978; Sherman,
1987; Hunter & Sundel, 1989). The questionnaire has 76 items, which are
sentences answered by >-point scales ranging from 0: I definitely do not
agree to 4: I definitely agree. It was constructed and vahdated on a sample
of 120 men, aged 35-45 years, mainly with university education, represent-
ing various professions. Three general scales were extracted by means of
principal components factor analysis. The scale, Lntensity of Midlrfe Crisis,
has 52 items. The internal consistency is high (Cronbach alpha= .93). The
scale measures intensity of midlife crisis, especially with respect to changes
in the self. It covers a broad scope of problems associated with reaching mid-
dle age such as bodily changes, negative self-appraisals, personality change, a
negative overview of the past, a sense of disorganization of personal striv-
ings, re-evaluation of personal goals and life priorities, and a lack of plans
for the second half of life. Some sample items are "I definitely have less en-
ergy now than before," "I disperse my energy and I am wasting time on
meaningless activities," and "In my past I lost many chances in life."
The Psychological Maturity Scale has 18 items. The internal consistency
is good; a = 3 3 . The scale measures obtained maturity and deals with such
issues as engagement in important life goals and task reahation, seek~ngltfe
meaning, the problem of choosing meaningful activities and tasks, and the
readiness to share one's own knowledge and wisdom with younger people.
Some sample items are "I have a sense that I have gained much valuable life
experience," "I try to live in such a way that I continue to do something re-
ally important," and "I like to share my knowledge and experience with
others,"
The Acceptance of Fate and Death Scale has 10 items with an internal
consistency (Cronbach alpha) of .71. This scale measures personal attitudes
towards time passing and death. It deals with the philosophical reflection on
life and death, time, and fate. Sample items are "I accept my fate," "I feel
prepared for aging and death," and "I accept peacefully the fact that time
goes by."
1062 P. K. OLES
There are two sources of the causal model of midlife crisis introduced
here, a theoretical evaluation of the phenomenon and the findmgs of previ-
ous investigations (Oles, 1995; Shek, 1995). The construction of our model
was based on a regression analysis with Intensity of midlde crisis, Psycholog-
ical maturity, and kcceptance of fate and death as dependent variables, and
the following 10 measures as independent variables: Value crisis, Problem-
focused coping, Emotion-focused coping, Telicity (Goals), Planning, Past
time orientation, Time pressure, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, and Open-
ness to experience.
All three dimensions of midlife crisis were postulated as influenced by
value crisis, telicity, and problem-focused coping because midlife crisis has
to do with re-evaluation of ltfe and inadaptive coping. The other inde-
pendent variables were regarded as specific for particular dimensions of
midhfe crisis. For intensity of midlife crisis, predictors were emotion-focused
coping, and time pressure, for a heightened sense of urgency combined with
such coping which tends to reduce emotions may cause even greater prob-
lems in the long run. For psychological maturity there were h k s with
planning, orientation towards the past, and conscientiousness because a gen-
erative attitude implies responsible use of past experience for future tasks. Fi-
nally, in the case of acceptance of fate and death, substantial predictors were
extraversion and openness to experience because for acceptance of the h i t -
edness of life some reflection (introversion) and openness for new and threat-
ening ideas is needed.
The model, resented in Fig. 1, was tested using LISREL 7 (Joreskog
& Sorbom, 1989; SPSS, Inc., 1990). Statistical criterion values demonstrated
1064 P. K. OLES
cia1 conditions; on the other hand, the findings which are similar to che re-
sults obtained in different studies seem to allow in some aspects a broader
discussion. Although midlife crises occur in different cultures, the timing,
structure, and resolution of the crisis depend on sociocultural conditions.
According to the present model, the way in which Polish men enter
middle age can be explained by an intriguing combination of variables. First
of all, midlife crisis seems to be associated with the difficulties concerning
the valuing process. That is, conficts between different values, the disorgani-
zation of the valuing process, re-evaluations, and lowered sense of realization
- -
ternal problems. Note that effective striving for important and challenging
goals is clearly associated with life satisfaction and well-being (see, e.g.,
Wheeler, Munz, & Jain, 1990; Brunstein, 1993). Moreover, a positive orien-
tation towards the future is essential for mental health and well-being (Re-
ker, Peacock, & Wong, 1987; Taylor & Brown, 1988). Thus, psychological
functioning of men in intensive midlife crisis, is to some extent, unadaptive
and similar to that of mildly depressed people (see e.g., Kuiper, O h g e r , &
Swallow, 1987; Brandtstadter & Renner, 1990; May & Lipman, 1992).
Nevertheless, there is also a fundamental difference between the crisis
and depression. The crisis as developmental phenomenon involves a period
of difficult personal changes (Levinson, 1986; Wolfe, O'Connor, & Crary,
1990). Almost all participants were engaged in professional and family life,
and nobody has reported any problems with mental health. So, their possi-
ble "depressive state" means most likely sorrow associated with the lost
youth and doubts concerning the future which do not diminish personal
ability to "love and workH-the effect found, for example, in Born and Nel-
son's (1983-84) study. Midlife troubles may lead to a lowered mood and in
this way they are similar to depression. In contrast to depression, however,
they do not diminish person's activity but may contribute to even higher ac-
tivity by a sense of urgency. Moreover, an ambivalent future outlook is not
necessarily unadaptive, particularly during the time of social changes as in
Poland. The future perceived as uncertain provokes the formulation of vari-
ous and ambivalent future selves, and motivation to strive for personal goals
is even higher when desired and undesired possible selves are combined
(Cross & Markus, 1991; Ryff, 1991; Hooker & Kaus, 1994).
Some additional remarks are needed. Considering the model from the
perspective of the five-factor model, it is interesting to notice that the inten-
sity of midhfe crisis appears not to be assoc~atedwith the five basic person-
ality factors. Only Conscientiousness has a s~gnificantcorrelation with Psy-
chological Maturity, and Extraversion and Openness to experience contrib-
ute to the Acceptance of fate and death. The first trait has something to do
with the value-goal domain. The two other dimensions suggest that introver-
sion and openness to new experiences constitute predispositions for philo-
sophical reflection on life and death that may contribute to personal growth
and maturity. Moreover, existential reflection opens the possibility for per-
sonality change (Levinson, 1986; Kuuire, 1993; Jones & Meredith, 1996), that
is, to develop renewed identity (Kroger & Haslett, 1991; Whitbourne & Van
Manen, 1996) and the generative attitude crucial for successful resolution of
midlife crisis (de St. Aubin & McAdams, 1995; Peterson & Stewart, 1996).
Note, one of the implications drawn from the presented model is that for
the establishment of personal maturity, a balance between future and past
time orientation is needed.
MODEL OF MIDLIFE CRISIS 1067
CROSS.S., &MARKUS. H. (1991) Possible selves across the hfe span. Hzrman Developtnenf, 34,
230-255.
DE ST. AUBIN, E., &MCADAA~S, D. I? (1995) The relations of generative concern and generative
action to ersonality traits, satisfaction/happiness with life, and ego development. Iournal
8
of Adult evelopment, 2, 99-112.
DREBING, C. E.. &GOODEN.W E. (1991) The impact of the dream on mental health [unction-
ing in male midlde transition. International Jozrnzal of Aging and Hzrman Development, 32,
227-287.
ERIKSON, E. H. (1963) Childhood and society. New York: Norton.
FISKE,M., &CHIRIBOGA. D. A. (1990) Change and continui~yin adult lqe. San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
FOLKMAN, S., & LAZARUS, R. S. (1980) An analysis of coping in a middle-aged community sam-
ple. ]ozrrnal o/ Health and Social Behavior, 21, 219-239.
GOUGH,H. G., & HEILBRUN, A. B. (1983) The A&cfive Check List: manrral. Palo Alto, CA:
Consulting Psychologists Press.
GOULD,R. L. (1978) Transformatiorzs: growth and change in adtrlt life. New York: Simon &
Schuster.
HERMANS, H. 1. M., &OLES,I? K. (1999) Midlife crisis in men: affective organization of per-
sonal meanings. Hrrlnon Relations, 52.
HOOKER,K., & L U S ,C. R. (1994) Health-related possible selves in young and middle adult-
hood. Psychology and Aging, 9, 126-133.
HUNTER,S., & SUNDEL, M. (Eds.) (1989) Midlde myths: irsrres, findings, and pracfice implica-
tions. Newbuty Park, CA: Sage.
JAQUES, E. (1965) Death and the mid-hfe crisis. The Irztertzarional]ourrzal of Psy~hoanal~sir, 46,
502-514.
JONES,C. J., &MEREDIM,W. (1996) Patterns of personality change across the hfe span. Psy-
chology and Aging, 11, 57-65.
1068 P. K. OLES
JORESKOC, K. G., &SORBOM,D. (I9SC)I LlSREL 7: rrser's reference guide. Mooresville, IN: Sci-
entific Software, Inc.
JULIAN,T. W., MCKENRY,I? C., &ARNOLD,K. (1990) Psychosocial predictors of stress associ-
ated with the male midlife transition. Sex Roles, 22, 707-722.
KALISH,R. D. (Ed.) (1989) MidliJe loss: coping sfrafegies. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
KEARL,M. C., & HOAC,L. 1. (1984) The social construction of the midlife crisis: a case study
in the temporalities of identity. Sociological I~zqrriy,54, 279-300.
KLOHNEN, E. C., VANDEWATER, E. A,, &YOUNG,A. (1996) Negotiating the middle years: ego-re-
siliency and successful midlife adjustment in women. P.~chologyand Aging, 11, 431-442.
KROGER, J., & HASLET, S. J . (1991) A comparison of ego identity status transition pathways
and change rates across five identity domains. I~zfernatiorzalJorrnzal of Aging and Hrrmair
Drvelopment, 32, 303-330.
KRUCER, A. (1994) The midlife transition: crisis or chimera. Psychological Reports, 75, 1299-
1305.
KUIPER. N. A., OLINCER, L. J.. &SWALLOW, S. R. (1987) Dysfunctional attitudes, mild depres-
sion, view of selF, self-consciousness, and social perceptions. Mofivation and Emofion, 11,
379-401.
KUIJIRE,A. A. (1993) The event of physical weakening: a transcendence crisis as an invitation
and as opportunity to foster formative anticipation. Studies in Formative Spirituality, 14,
367-380.
LABOWE-VIEF, G., ORWOLL. L., &MANION,M. (1995) Narratives of mind, gender, and the life
course. Hurnarz Developmerzt, 38, 239-257.
LEVINSON, D. J. (1986) A conception of adult develpment. A~nericartPsychologist, 41, 3-13.
LEVINSON, D. ., DARROW,C., KLEIN,E., LEVINSON, M., & MCKEE,B. (1978) The seasoris of
,neni l r i . New York: Knopf.
LEVINSON. D.J., &LEVINSON, J. (1996) The seasons of wornen's liJe. New York: Knopf.
LOEVINGER, J . (1962) Measuring personality patterns of women. Genetic Psychology Mono-
graphs, 65, 53-136.
LOMRANZ, J., SHMOTKIN, D., EYAL,N., & FRIEDMAN, A. (1994) Expectations for changes in
midhfe men. Social Behavior and Personality, 22, 111-122.
~ ~ Y E N. R(1978)
, The male mid-lrle criris: fresh starts afier forly. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
M&I\Ms, D. I?. D E ST. AUBIN.E.. &LOGAN,R. L. (1993) Generativity among young, midlife,
and older adults. Psychology and Aging, 8, 221-230.
M&AMS,, D. l?, RUETZEL, K.. & FOLEY,J . M. (1986) Complexity and generativity at midlife:
relations amon social motives, ego development, and adult's plans for future. Jorrrnal of
Per.ronalrly a,zk~ocialPsychology, 50, 800-807.
NEUCARTEN, B. L. (1968) Adult personality: toward a psychology of Me cycle. In B. L.
Neugarten (Ed.), middle age and aging: a reader in social psychology. Chicago, IL: The
Univer. of Chicago Press. P p . 137-147.
NOSAL,C. (1993) Style percepcji czasu: Wymiary i struktura [The styles of time perception: di-
mensions and structurel. In J. Brzezinski (Ed.), Psychologiczne i psycho7netryczrte proble~ny
rlingrrostyki psychologicznej [Psycholo ical and psychome~rical proble~ns of psychological
diagnosis].Poznan, Poland: Adam ~icgiezuiczUniver. Pp. 721-141.
OLES,l? (1994) Konstrukcja Kwestionariusza do badania Kryzysu Pokowy Zycia: zabienia a
fakty empir czne [Construction of the Wciltfe Crisis Questionnaire: assumptions and em-
pirical facts!. Przeglad Psychologiczny, 37, 159.166.
OLES,l? (1995) ICryzys "potozuy zycia" rr ?neiayzrt: ps cholo iczne badania ernpiyczne ["Mid-
life" crisis in men: psychological empirical researc~l.~ u % l i nPoland:, Catholic Univer. of
Lublin Press.
OLES,P. K. (1991) Value crisis: measurement and personality correlates. Polirh Psychological
Bz~lletin,22, 53-62.
PETERSON, B. E.. &STEWART. A. J . (1996) Antecedents and contexts of generativity motivauon
at m i m e . Psychologv and Aging, 11, 21-33.
PIEDMONT, R. L.,MCCRAE.R. R., &COSTA,l? T.. JR. (1991) Ad'ective Check List scales and the
five-factor model. Joi,rnal of Per.rorrali/y and Social ~ s y c h o l o ~60,
y , 630-637.
REKER,G. T,, PEACOCK, E. J., & WONG,P. T. (1987) Meaning and purpose in life and well-be-
ing: a life-span perspective. Jorirnal of Gerorztology, 42, 44-49.
MODEL O F MIDLIFE CRISIS 1069
RIEGEL,K. (1975) Adult Me-crises: a dialectic inter retation of develo ment In N Datan & L
Ginsberg (Eds.). LiJe-span develop~nentalpsyc!ology: narrative 111 mik. blew York: ~ c a :
demic Press. Pp. 99-128.
RYFF,C. D. (1991) Possible selves in adulthood and old age: a tale of shifting horizons. Pzy-
chology and Aging, 6, 286-295.
SHEK.D. L. (1995) A scale for the assessment of midlife crisis in Chinese people. Psychologia,
38, 164-173.
SHEK,D. T. L. (1994) Meaning in life and adjustment amongst midlife parenrs in Hong Kong.
International Forzrm for Logotherapy, 17, 102-107.
SHERMAN, E. (1987) Meaning in mid-liJe transifio~ts. Albany, NY: State Univer. of New York.
SHMOTKIN, D. (1991) The role of time orienration in life sarisfaction across the life span. The
Joirrnal of Gero~tfology, 46, P243-P250.
SPSS, INC. (1990) LISREL 7 user's gzride and preference. Chicago, IL: SPSS, Inc.
TAYLOR. S. E., &BROWN, J. D. (1988) Illusion and well-being: a social psychological perspective
on mental health. Psychological Bulletin, 103, 193-210.
WASKEL. S. A. (1995) Temperament types: midlife death concerns, demographics, and intensiry
of crisis. Jozrrnal ofPsychology, 129, 221-233.
WASKEL, S. A,. &COLEMAN. J. (1991) Correlations of temperament types, intensity of crisis at
- . . 68. 1187-1190.
midlife with scores on a death scale. Psvcholonical Reports.
2
WHEELER, R. I., MUNZ,D. C., & J A I NA. , (1990) Life goals and general well-being. Psychological
Reports, 66. 307-312.
WHITBOURNE, S. K., &VANMANEN,K-J. W. (1996) Age differences in and correlates of identity
status from college through middle adulthood. Joztr~zalof Adzrlt Deuelopmen~,3, 59-69.
WOLFE,D., O'CONNOR, D., &CRARY, M. (1990) Transformations of life structure and personal
paradigm during the midMe transition. Hzrman Relatio~rs,43, 957-973.