ETAHoffmann Nussknacker

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 63

(7$+RIIPDQQ

1X‰NQDFNHUXQG
0DXVHN|QLJ
(7$+RIIPDQQ

+RIIPDQQZXUGHDPLQ.|QLJVEHUJJHERUHQ6HLQ
9DWHUZDU$GYRNDW1DFKGHP*\PQDVLXPLQ.|QLJVEHUJ
VWXGLHUWHHUYRQ-XUD$OV5HIHUHQGDUDUEHLWHWHHU
LQ*ORJDXXQGLQ%HUOLQ$EDUEHLWHWHHUDOV
$VVHVVRULQ3RVHQZXUGHVWUDIYHUVHW]WQDFK3OR]NLQ3ROHQ

(WZD]RJHUQDFK%HUOLQ ZRVLFKVHLQH%HJDEXQJDOV
0XVLNHU=HLFKQHUXQG6FKULIWVWHOOHUYROOHQGVHQWZLFNHOQ
NRQQWH$EZDUHUZLHGHUDP.DPPHUJHULFKWLQ%HUOLQ
DQJHVWHOOW+RIIPDQQVWDUEDPLQ%HUOLQ
'HU:HLKQDFKWVDEHQG
$PYLHUXQG]ZDQ]LJVWHQ'H]HPEHUGXUIWHQGLH.LQGHUGHV
0HGL]LQDOUDWV6WDKOEDXPGHQJDQ]HQ7DJEHUGXUFKDXVQLFKWLQ
GLH0LWWHOVWXEHKLQHLQYLHOZHQLJHULQGDVGDUDQVWR‰HQGH
3UXQN]LPPHU,QHLQHP:LQNHOGHV+LQWHUVWEFKHQV
]XVDPPHQJHNDXHUWVD‰HQ)ULW]XQG0DULHGLHWLHIH
$EHQGGlPPHUXQJZDUHLQJHEURFKHQXQGHVZXUGHLKQHQUHFKW
VFKDXULJ]XPXWHDOVPDQZLHHVJHZ|KQOLFKDQGHP7DJH
JHVFKDKNHLQ/LFKWKHUHLQEUDFKWH)ULW]HQWGHFNWHJDQ]LQVJHKHLP
ZLVSHUQGGHUMQJHUQ6FKZHVWHU VLHZDUHEHQHUVWVLHEHQ-DKU
DOWJHZRUGHQ ZLHHUVFKRQVHLWIUKPRUJHQVHVKDEHLQGHQ
YHUVFKORVVHQHQ6WXEHQUDXVFKHQXQGUDVVHOQXQGOHLVHSRFKHQ
K|UHQ$XFKVHLQLFKWOlQJVWHLQNOHLQHUGXQNOHU0DQQPLWHLQHP
JUR‰HQ.DVWHQXQWHUGHP$UPEHUGHQ)OXUJHVFKOLFKHQHUZLVVH
DEHUZRKOGD‰HVQLHPDQGDQGHUVJHZHVHQDOV3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHU
'DVFKOXJ0DULLHGLHNOHLQHQ+lQGFKHQYRU)UHXGH]XVDPPHQXQG
ULHI$FKZDVZLUGQXU 3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUIUXQV6FK|QHV
JHPDFKWKDEHQ'HU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW'UR‰HOPHLHUZDUJDUNHLQ
KEVFKHU0DQQQXUNOHLQXQGPDJHUKDWWHYLHOH5XQ]HOQLP
*HVLFKWVWDWWGHVUHFKWHQ$XJHVHLQJUR‰HVVFKZDU]HV3IODVWHU
XQGDXFKJDUNHLQH+DDUHZHVKDOEHUHLQHVHKUVFK|QHZHL‰H
3HUFNHWUXJGLHZDUDEHUYRQ*ODVXQGHLQNQVWOLFKHV6WFN
$UEHLWhEHUKDXSWZDUGHU3DWHVHOEVWDXFKHLQVHKUNQVWOLFKHU
0DQQGHUVLFKVRJDUDXI8KUHQYHUVWDQGXQGVHOEVWZHOFKH
PDFKHQNRQQWH:HQQGDKHUHLQHYRQGHQVFK|QHQ8KUHQLQ
6WDKOEDXPV+DXVHNUDQNZDUXQGQLFKWVLQJHQNRQQWHGDQQNDP
3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUQDKPGLH*ODVSHUFNHDE]RJVHLQJHOEHV
5|FNFKHQDXVEDQGHLQHEODXH6FKU]HXPXQGVWDFKPLW
VSLW]LJHQ,QVWUXPHQWHQLQGLH8KUKLQHLQVRGD‰HVGHUNOHLQHQ
0DULHRUGHQWOLFKZHKHWDWDEHUHVYHUXUVDFKWHGHU8KUJDUNHLQHQ
6FKDGHQVRQGHUQVLHZXUGHYLHOPHKUZLHGHUOHEHQGLJXQGILQJ
JOHLFKDQUHFKWOXVWLJ]XVFKQXUUHQ]XVFKODJHQXQG]XVLQJHQ
ZRUEHUGHQQDOOHVJUR‰H)UHXGHKDWWH,PPHUWUXJHUZHQQHU
NDPZDV+EVFKHVIUGLH.LQGHULQGHU7DVFKHEDOGHLQ
0lQQOHLQGDVGLH$XJHQYHUGUHKWHXQG.RPSOLPHQWHPDFKWH
ZHOFKHVNRPLVFKDQ]XVHKHQZDUEDOGHLQH'RVHDXVGHUHLQ
9|JHOFKHQKHUDXVKSIWHEDOGZDVDQGHUHV$EHU]X:HLKQDFKWHQ
GDKDWWHHULPPHUHLQVFK|QHVNQVWOLFKHV:HUNYHUIHUWLJWGDV
LKPYLHO0KHJHNRVWHWZHVKDOEHVDXFKQDFKGHPHV
HLQEHVFKHUWZRUGHQVHKUVRUJOLFKYRQGHQ(OWHUQDXIEHZDKUW
ZXUGH $FKZDVZLUGQXU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUIUXQV6FK|QHV
JHPDFKWKDEHQULHIQXQ0DULH)ULW]PHLQWHDEHUHVN|QQHZRKO
GLHVPDOQLFKWVDQGHUVVHLQDOVHLQH)HVWXQJLQGHUDOOHUOHLVHKU
KEVFKH6ROGDWHQDXIXQGDEPDUVFKLHUWHQXQGH[HU]LHUWHQXQG
GDQQP‰WHQDQGHUH6ROGDWHQNRPPHQGLHLQGLH)HVWXQJ
KLQHLQZROOWHQDEHUQXQVFK|VVHQGLH6ROGDWHQYRQLQQHQWDSIHU
KHUDXVPLW.DQRQHQGD‰HVWFKWLJEUDXVWHXQGNQDOOWH1HLQ
QHLQXQWHUEUDFK0DULHGHQ)ULW]3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUKDWPLUYRQ
HLQHPVFK|QHQ*DUWHQHU]lKOWGDULQLVWHLQJUR‰HU6HHDXIGHP
VFKZLPPHQVHKUKHUUOLFKH6FKZlQHPLWJROGQHQ+DOVElQGHUQ
KHUXPXQGVLQJHQGLHKEVFKHVWHQ/LHGHU'DQQNRPPWHLQ
NOHLQHV0lGFKHQDXVGHP*DUWHQDQGHQ6HHXQGORFNWGLH
6FKZlQHKHUDQXQGIWWHUWVLHPLWV‰HP0DU]LSDQ6FKZlQH
IUHVVHQNHLQHQ0DU]LSDQILHO)ULW]HWZDVUDXKHLQXQGHLQHQ
JDQ]HQ*DUWHQNDQQ3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUDXFKQLFKWPDFKHQ
(LJHQWOLFKKDEHQZLUZHQLJYRQVHLQHQ6SLHOVDFKHQHVZLUGXQVMD
DOOHVJOHLFKZLHGHUZHJJHQRPPHQGDLVWPLUGHQQGRFKGDVYLHO
OLHEHUZDVXQV3DSDXQG0DPDHLQEHVFKHUHQZLUEHKDOWHQHV
IHLQXQGN|QQHQGDPLWPDFKHQZDVZLU ZROOHQ1XQULHWHQGLH
.LQGHUKLQXQGKHUZDVHVZRKOGLHVPDOZLHGHUJHEHQN|QQH
0DULHPHLQWHGD‰0DPVHOO7UXWFKHQ LKUHJUR‰H3XSSH VLFKVHKU
YHUlQGHUHGHQQXQJHVFKLFNWHUDOVMHPDOVILHOHVLHMHGHQ
$XJHQEOLFNDXIGHQ)X‰ERGHQZHOFKHVRKQHJDUVWLJH =HLFKHQLP
*HVLFKWQLFKWDEJLQJHXQGGDQQVHLDQ5HLQOLFKNHLWLQGHU
.OHLGXQJJDUQLFKWPHKU]XGHQNHQ$OOHVWFKWLJH$XVVFKHOWHQ
KHOIHQLFKWV$XFKKDEH0DPDJHOlFKHOWDOVVLHVLFKEHU
*UHWFKHQVNOHLQHQ6RQQHQVFKLUPVRJHIUHXW)ULW]YHUVLFKHUWH
GDJHJHQHLQWFKWLJHU)XFKVIHKOHVHLQHP0DUVWDOOGXUFKDXVVR
ZLHVHLQHQ7UXSSHQJlQ]OLFKDQ.DYDOOHULHGDVVHLGHP3DSD
UHFKWJXWEHNDQQW 6RZX‰WHQGLH.LQGHUZRKOGD‰GLH(OWHUQ
LKQHQDOOHUOHLVFK|QH*DEHQHLQJHNDXIWKDWWHQGLHVLHQXQ
DXIVWHOOWHQHV ZDULKQHQDEHUDXFKJHZL‰GD‰GDEHLGHUOLHEH
+HLOLJH&KULVWPLWJDUIUHXQGOLFKHQIURPPHQ.LQGHVDXJHQ
KLQHLQOHXFKWHXQGGD‰ZLHYRQVHJHQVUHLFKHU+DQGEHUKUWMHGH
:HLKQDFKWVJDEHKHUUOLFKH/XVWEHUHLWHZLHNHLQHDQGHUH'DUDQ
HULQQHUWHGLH.LQGHUGLHLPPHUIRUWYRQGHQ]XHUZDUWHQGHQ
*HVFKHQNHQZLVSHUWHQLKUHlOWHUH6FKZHVWHU/XLVHKLQ]XIJHQG
GD‰HVQXQDEHUDXFKGHU+HLOLJH&KULVWVHLGHUGXUFKGLH+DQG
GHUOLHEHQ(OWHUQGHQ.LQGHUQLPPHUGDVEHVFKHUHZDVLKQHQ
ZDKUH)UHXGHXQG/XVWEHUHLWHQN|QQHGDVZLVVHHUYLHOEHVVHU
DOVGLH.LQGHUVHOEVWGLHP‰WHQGDKHUQLFKWDOOHUOHLZQVFKHQ
XQGKRIIHQVRQGHUQVWLOOXQGIURPPHUZDUWHQZDVLKQHQ
EHVFKHUWZRUGHQ'LHNOHLQH0DULHZXUGHJDQ]QDFKGHQNOLFKDEHU
)ULW]PXUPHOWHYRUVLFKKLQ(LQHQ)XFKVXQG +XVDUHQKlWWLFK
QXQHLQPDOJHUQ

(VZDUJDQ]ILQVWHUJHZRUGHQ)ULW]XQG0DULHIHVW
DQHLQDQGHUJHUFNWZDJWHQNHLQ:RUWPHKU]XUHGHQHVZDU
LKQHQDOVUDXVFKHHVPLWOLQGHQ)OJHOQXPVLHKHUXQGDOVOLH‰H
VLFKHLQHJDQ]IHUQHDEHUVHKUKHUUOLFKH0XVLNYHUQHKPHQ(LQ
KHOOHU6FKHLQVWUHLIWHDQGHU:DQGKLQGDZX‰WHQGLH.LQGHUGD‰
QXQGDV&KULVWNLQGDXIJOlQ]HQGHQ:RONHQIRUWJHIORJHQ ]X
DQGHUQJOFNOLFKHQ.LQGHUQ,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNJLQJHVPLW
VLOEHUKHOOHP7RQ.OLQJOLQJNOLQJOLQJGLH7UHQVSUDQJHQDXIXQG
VROFKHLQ*ODQ]VWUDKOWHDXVGHPJUR‰HQ=LPPHUKLQHLQGD‰GLH
.LQGHUPLWODXWHP$XVUXI$FK $FKZLHHUVWDUUWDXIGHU
6FKZHOOHVWHKHQEOLHEHQ$EHU3DSDXQG0DPDWUDWHQLQGLH7UH
ID‰WHQGLH.LQGHUEHLGHU+DQGXQGVSUDFKHQ.RPPWGRFK QXU
NRPPWGRFKQXULKUOLHEHQ.LQGHUXQGVHKWZDVHXFKGHU+HLOLJH
&KULVWEHVFKHUWKDW
'LH*DEHQ
,FKZHQGHPLFKDQGLFKVHOEVWVHKUJHQHLJWHU/HVHURGHU=XK|UHU
)ULW] 7KHRGRU (UQVW RGHUZLHGXVRQVWKHL‰HQPDJVWXQGELWWH
GLFKGD‰GXGLUGHLQHQOHW]WHQPLWVFK|QHQEXQWHQ*DEHQUHLFK
JHVFKPFNWHQ:HLKQDFKWVWLVFKUHFKWOHEKDIWYRU$XJHQEULQJHQ
P|JHVWGDQQZLUVWGXHVGLUZRKODXFKGHQNHQN|QQHQZLHGLH
.LQGHUPLWJOlQ]HQGHQ$XJHQJDQ]YHUVWXPPWVWHKHQEOLHEHQZLH
HUVWQDFKHLQHU:HLOH0DULHPLWHLQHPWLHIHQ6HXI]HUULHI$FK
ZLHVFK|Q DFKZLHVFK|QXQG)ULW]HLQLJH/XIWVSUQJH
YHUVXFKWHGLHLKPEHUDXVZRKOJHULHWHQ$EHUGLH.LQGHU
PX‰WHQDXFKGDVJDQ]H-DKUEHUEHVRQGHUVDUWLJXQGIURPP
JHZHVHQVHLQGHQQQLHZDULKQHQVRYLHO6FK|QHV+HUUOLFKHV
HLQEHVFKHUWZRUGHQDOVGLHVHV0DO'HUJUR‰H7DQQHQEDXPLQGHU
0LWWHWUXJYLHOHJROGQHXQGVLOEHUQHbSIHOXQGZLH.QRVSHQXQG
%OWHQNHLPWHQ=XFNHUPDQGHOQXQGEXQWH%RQERQVXQGZDVHV
VRQVWQRFKIUVFK|QHV1DVFKZHUNJLEWDXVDOOHQbVWHQ $OVGDV
6FK|QVWHDQGHP:XQGHUEDXPPX‰WHDEHUZRKOJHUKPW
ZHUGHQGD‰LQVHLQHQGXQNHOQ=ZHLJHQKXQGHUWNOHLQH/LFKWHUZLH
6WHUQOHLQIXQNHOWHQXQGHUVHOEVWLQVLFKKLQHLQ XQG
KHUDXVOHXFKWHQGGLH.LQGHUIUHXQGOLFKHLQOXGVHLQH%OWHQXQG
)UFKWH]XSIOFNHQ8PGHQ%DXPXPKHUJOlQ]WHDOOHVVHKUEXQW
XQGKHUUOLFK ZDVHVGDDOOHVIUVFK|QH6DFKHQJDE MDZHUGDV
]XEHVFKUHLEHQYHUP|FKWH0DULHHUEOLFNWHGLH]LHUOLFKVWHQ
3XSSHQDOOHUOHLVDXEHUHNOHLQH*HUlWVFKDIWHQXQGZDVYRUDOOHP
VFK|QDQ]XVHKHQZDUHLQVHLGHQHV.OHLGFKHQPLWEXQWHQ%lQGHUQ
]LHUOLFKJHVFKPFNWKLQJDQHLQHP*HVWHOOVRGHUNOHLQHQ0DULH
YRU$XJHQGD‰VLHHVYRQDOOHQ6HLWHQEHWUDFKWHQNRQQWHXQGGDV
WDWVLHGHQQDXFKLQGHPVLHHLQ0DOEHUGDVDQGHUHDXVULHI
$FKGDVVFK|QHDFK GDVOLHEH OLHEH.OHLGFKHQXQGGDVZHUGH
LFK JDQ]JHZL‰ GDVZHUGHLFKZLUNOLFKDQ]LHKHQGUIHQ )ULW]
KDWWHLQGHVVHQVFKRQGUHL RGHUYLHUPDOXPGHQ7LVFK
KHUXPJDORSSLHUHQGXQGWUDEHQGGHQQHXHQ)XFKVYHUVXFKWGHQ
HULQGHU7DWDP7LVFKHDQJH]lXPWJHIXQGHQ:LHGHUDEVWHLJHQG
PHLQWHHUHVVHLHLQHZLOGH%HVWLHGDVWlWHDEHUQLFKWVHUZROOH
LKQVFKRQNULHJHQXQGPXVWHUWHGLHQHXH6FKZDGURQ+XVDUHQ
GLHVHKUSUlFKWLJLQ5RWXQG*ROGJHNOHLGHWZDUHQODXWHUVLOEHUQH
:DIIHQWUXJHQXQGDXIVROFKHQZHL‰JOlQ]HQGHQ3IHUGHQULWWHQ
GD‰PDQEHLQDKHKlWWHJODXEHQVROOHQDXFKGLHVHVHLHQYRQ
SXUHP6LOEHU(EHQZROOWHQGLH.LQGHUHWZDVUXKLJHUJHZRUGHQ
EHUGLH%LOGHUEFKHUKHUGLHDXIJHVFKODJHQZDUHQGD‰PDQ
DOOHUOHLVHKUVFK|QH%OXPHQXQGEXQWH0HQVFKHQMDDXFK
DOOHUOLHEVWHVSLHOHQGH.LQGHUVRQDWUOLFKJHPDOWDOVOHEWHQXQG
VSUlFKHQVLHZLUNOLFKJOHLFKDQVFKDXHQNRQQWH -DHEHQZROOWHQ
GLH.LQGHUEHUGLHVHZXQGHUEDUHQ%FKHUKHUDOVQRFKPDOV
JHNOLQJHOWZXUGH6LHZX‰WHQGD‰QXQGHU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHU
HLQEHVFKHUHQZUGHXQGOLHIHQQDFKGHPDQGHU:DQGVWHKHQGHQ
7LVFK6FKQHOOZXUGHGHU6FKLUPKLQWHUGHPHUVRODQJHYHUVWHFNW
JHZHVHQZHJJHQRPPHQ:DVHUEOLFNWHQGDGLH.LQGHU $XI
HLQHPJUQHQPLWEXQWHQ%OXPHQJHVFKPFNWHQ5DVHQSODW]
VWDQGHLQVHKUKHUUOLFKHV6FKOR‰PLWYLHOHQ6SLHJHOIHQVWHUQXQG
JROGQHQ7UPHQ(LQ*ORFNHQVSLHOOLH‰VLFKK|UHQ7UHQXQG
)HQVWHUJLQJHQDXIXQGPDQVDKZLHVHKUNOHLQHDEHU]LHUOLFKH
+HUUQXQG'DPHQPLW)HGHUKWHQXQGODQJHQ6FKOHSSNOHLGHUQLQ
GHQ6lOHQKHUXPVSD]LHUWHQ,QGHP0LWWHOVDDOGHUJDQ]LQ)HXHU
]XVWHKHQVFKLHQ VRYLHO/LFKWHUFKHQEUDQQWHQDQVLOEHUQHQ
.URQOHXFKWHUQ WDQ]WHQ.LQGHULQNXU]HQ:lPVFKHQXQG
5|FNFKHQQDFKGHP*ORFNHQVSLHO(LQ+HUULQHLQHPVPDUDJGHQHQ
0DQWHOVDKRIWGXUFKHLQ)HQVWHUZLQNWHKHUDXVXQGYHUVFKZDQG
ZLHGHUVRZLHDXFK3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUVHOEVWDEHUNDXPYLHO
K|KHUDOV3DSDV'DXPHQ]XZHLOHQXQWHQDQGHU7UGHV6FKORVVHV
VWDQGXQGZLHGHUKLQHLQJLQJ)ULW]KDWWHPLWDXIGHQ7LVFK
JHVWHPPWHQ$UPHQGDVVFK|QH6FKOR‰XQGGLHWDQ]HQGHQXQG
VSD]LHUHQGHQ)LJUFKHQDQJHVHKHQGDQQVSUDFKHU3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHU/D‰PLFKPDOKLQHLQJHKHQLQGHLQ6FKOR‰ 'HU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWEHGHXWHWHLKQGD‰GDVQXQJDQ]XQGJDUQLFKW
DQJLQJH(UKDWWHDXFKUHFKWGHQQHVZDUW|ULFKWYRQ)ULW]HQGD‰
HULQHLQ6FKOR‰JHKHQZROOWHZHOFKHVEHUKDXSWPLWVDPWVHLQHQ
JROGQHQ7UPHQQLFKWVRKRFKZDUDOVHUVHOEVW)ULW]VDKGDV
DXFKHLQ1DFKHLQHU:HLOHDOVLPPHUIRUWDXIGLHVHOEH:HLVHGLH
+HUUQXQG'DPHQKLQXQGKHUVSD]LHUWHQGLH.LQGHUWDQ]WHQGHU
VPDUDJGQH0DQQ]XGHPVHOEHQ)HQVWHUKHUDXVVDK3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUYRUGLH7UHWUDWGDULHI)ULW]XQJHGXOGLJ3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUQXQNRPPPDO]XGHUDQGHUQ7UGDGUEHQ
KHUDXV'DVJHKWQLFKWOLHEHV)ULW]FKHQHUZLGHUWHGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDW1XQ VROD‰PDOVSUDFK)ULW]ZHLWHUOD‰PDO
GHQJUQHQ0DQQGHUVRRIWKHUDXVNXFNWPLWGHQDQGHUQ
KHUXPVSD]LHUHQ'DVJHKWDXFKQLFKWHUZLGHUWHGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWDXIVQHXH6RVROOHQGLH.LQGHU
KHUXQWHUNRPPHQULHI)ULW]LFKZLOOVLHQlKHUEHVHKHQ(LGDV
JHKWDOOHVQLFKWVSUDFKGHU2EHUJHULFEWVUDWYHUGULH‰OLFKZLHGLH
0HFKDQLNQXQHLQPDOJHPDFKWLVWPX‰VLHEOHLEHQ6RR"
IUDJWH)ULW]PLWJHGHKQWHQ7RQGDVJHKWDOOHVQLFKW"+|UPDO
3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUZHQQGHLQHNOHLQHQJHSXW]WHQ'LQJHULQGHP
6FKORVVHQLFKWVPHKUN|QQHQDOVLPPHUGDVVHOEHGDWDXJHQVLH
QLFKWYLHOXQGLFKIUDJHQLFKWVRQGHUOLFKQDFKLKQHQ 1HLQGD
ORELFKPLUPHLQH+XVDUHQGLHPVVHQPDQ|YULHUHQYRUZlUWV
UFNZlUWVZLHLFK VKDEHQZLOOXQGVLQGLQNHLQ+DXVJHVSHUUW
8QGGDPLWVSUDQJHUIRUWDQGHQ:HLKQDFKWVWLVFKXQGOLH‰VHLQH
(VNDGURQDXIGHQVLOEHUQHQ3IHUGHQKLQXQGKHUWURWWLHUHQXQG
VFKZHQNHQXQGHLQEDXHQXQGIHXHUQQDFK+HU]HQVOXVW$XFK
0DULHKDWWHVLFKVDFKWHIRUWJHVFKOLFKHQGHQQDXFKVLHZXUGHGHV
+HUXPJHKHQVXQG7DQ]HQVGHU3SSFKHQLP6FKORVVHEDOG
EHUGUVVLJXQGPRFKWHHVGDVLHVHKUDUWLJXQGJXWZDUQXU
QLFKWVRPHUNHQODVVHQZLH%UXGHU)ULW]'HU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW
'UR‰HOPHLHUVSUDFK]LHPOLFKYHUGULH‰OLFK]XGHQ(OWHUQ)U
XQYHUVWlQGLJH.LQGHULVWVROFKNQVWOLFKHV:HUNQLFKWLFKZLOOQXU
PHLQ6FKOR‰ZLHGHUHLQSDFNHQGRFKGLH0XWWHUWUDWKLQ]XXQG
OLH‰VLFKGHQLQQHUQ%DXXQGGDVZXQGHUEDUHVHKUNQVWOLFKH
5lGHUZHUN]HLJHQZRGXUFKGLHNOHLQHQ3SSFKHQLQ%HZHJXQJ
JHVHW]WZXUGHQ'HU5DW QDKPDOOHVDXVHLQDQGHUXQGVHW]WHHV
ZLHGHU]XVDPPHQ'DEHLZDUHUZLHGHUJDQ]KHLWHUJHZRUGHQ
XQGVFKHQNWHGHQ.LQGHUQQRFKHLQLJHVFK|QHEUDXQH0lQQHUXQG
)UDXHQPLWJROGQHQ*HVLFKWHUQ+lQGHQXQG%HLQHQ6LHZDUHQ
VlPWOLFKDXV7KRUQXQGURFKHQVRV‰XQGDQJHQHKPZLH
3IHIIHUNXFKHQZRUEHU)ULW]XQG0DULHVLFKVHKUHUIUHXWHQ
6FKZHVWHU/XLVHKDWWHZLHHVGLH0XWWHUJHZROOWGDVVFK|QH
.OHLGDQJH]RJHQZHOFKHVLKUHLQEHVFKHUWZRUGHQXQGVDK
ZXQGHUKEVFKDXVDEHU0DULHPHLQWHDOVVLHDXFKLKU.OHLG
DQ]LHKHQVROOWHVLHP|FKWHHVOLHEHUQRFKHLQEL‰FKHQVR
DQVHKHQ0DQHUODXEWHLKUGDVJHUQ
'HU6FKW]OLQJ
(LJHQWOLFKPRFKWH0DULHVLFKGHVKDOEJDUQLFKWYRQGHP
:HLKQDFKWVWLVFKWUHQQHQZHLOVLHHEHQHWZDVQRFKQLFKW
%HPHUNWHVHQWGHFNWKDWWH'XUFKGDV$XVUFNHQYRQ)ULW]HQV
+XVDUHQGLHGLFKWDQGHP%DXPLQ3DUDGHJHKDOWHQZDUQlPOLFK
HLQVHKUYRUWUHLIOLFKHUNOHLQHU0DQQVLFKWEDUJHZRUGHQGHUVWLOO
XQGEHVFKHLGHQGDVWDQGDOVHUZDUWHHUUXKLJZHQQGLH5HLKHDQ
LKQNRPPHQZHUGH*HJHQVHLQHQ:XFKV ZlUHIUHLOLFKYLHOHV
HLQ]XZHQGHQJHZHVHQGHQQDEJHVHKHQGDYRQGD‰GHUHWZDV
ODQJHVWDUNH2EHUOHLEQLFKWUHFKW]XGHQNOHLQHQGQQHQ
%HLQFKHQSDVVHQZROOWHVRVFKLHQDXFKGHU.RSIEHLZHLWHP]X
JUR‰9LHOHVPDFKWHGLHSURSUH.OHLGXQJJXWZHOFKHDXIHLQHQ
0DQQYRQ*HVFKPDFNXQG%LOGXQJVFKOLH‰HQOLH‰(UWUXJQlPOLFK
HLQVHKUVFK|QHVYLROHWWJOlQ]HQGHV+XVDUHQMlFNFKHQPLWYLHOHQ
ZHL‰HQ6FKQUHQXQG.Q|SIFKHQHEHQVROFKH%HLQNOHLGHUXQGGLH
VFK|QVWHQ6WLHIHOFKHQGLHMHPDOVDQGLH)‰HHLQHV6WXGHQWHQMD
ZRKOJDUHLQHV2IIL]LHUVJHNRPPHQVLQG6LHVD‰HQDQGHQ
]LHUOLFKHQ%HLQFKHQVRNQDSSDQJHJRVVHQDOVZlUHQVLHGDUDXI
JHPDOW.RPLVFKZDUHV]ZDUGD‰HU]XGLHVHU.OHLGXQJVLFK
KLQWHQHLQHQVFKPDOHQXQEHKROIHQHQ0DQWHOGHUUHFKWDXVVDKZLH
YRQ+RO]DQJHKlQJWXQGHLQ%HUJPDQQVPW]FKHQDXIJHVHW]W
KDWWHLQGHVVHQGDFKWH0DULHGDUDQGD‰3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUMDDXFK
HLQHQVHKUVFKOHFKWHQ0DWLQXPKlQJHXQGHLQHIDWDOH0W]H
DXIVHW]HGDEHLDEHUGRFKHLQJDUOLHEHU3DWHVHL$XFKVWHOOWH
0DULHGLH%HWUDFKWXQJ DQGD‰3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUWUJHHUVLFK
DXFKEULJHQVVR]LHUOLFKZLHGHU.OHLQHGRFKQLFKWHLQPDOVR
KEVFKDOVHUDXVVHKHQZHUGH,QGHP0DULHGHQQHWWHQ0DQQ
GHQVLHDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNOLHEJHZRQQHQLPPHUPHKUXQGPHKU
DQVDKGDZXUGHVLHHUVWUHFKW LQQHZHOFKH*XWPWLJNHLWDXI
VHLQHP*HVLFKWHODJ$XVGHQKHOOJUQHQHWZDV]XJUR‰HQ
KHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ$XJHQVSUDFKQLFKWVDOV)UHXQGVFKDIWXQG
:RKOZROOHQ(VVWDQGGHP0DQQHJXWGD‰VLFKXPVHLQ.LQQHLQ
ZRKOIULVLHUWHU%DUWYRQZHL‰HU%DXPZROOHOHJWHGHQQXPVRPHKU
NRQQWHPDQGDVV‰H/lFKHOQGHVKRFKURWHQ0XQGHVEHPHUNHQ
$FKULHI0DULHHQGOLFKDXVDFKOLHEHU9DWHUZHPJHK|UWGHQQ
GHUDOOHUOLHEVWHNOHLQH0DQQGRUWDP%DXP"'HUDQWZRUWHWH
GHU9DWHUGHUOLHEHV.LQGVROOIUHXFKDOOHWFKWLJDUEHLWHQHU
VROOHXFKIHLQGLHKDUWHQ1VVHDXIEHL‰HQXQGHUJHK|UW/XLVHQ
HEHQVRJXWDOVGLUXQGGHP)ULW]'DPLWQDKPLKQGHU9DWHU
EHKXWVDPYRP7LVFKHXQGLQGHPHUGHQK|O]HUQHQ0DQWHOLQGLH
+|KHKREVSHUUWHGDV0lQQOHLQGHQ0XQGZHLWZHLWDXIXQG
]HLJWH]ZHL5HLKHQVHKUZHL‰HUVSLW]HU=lKQFKHQ0DULHVFKREDXI
GHV9DWHUV*HKHL‰HLQH1X‰KLQHLQXQG NQDFN KDWWHVLHGHU
0DQQ]HUELVVHQGD‰GLH6FKDOHQDEILHOHQXQG0DULHGHQV‰HQ
.HUQLQGLH+DQGEHNDP1XQPX‰WHZRKOMHGHUXQGDXFK0DULH
ZLVVHQGD‰GHU]LHUOLFKHNOHLQH0DQQDXVGHP*HVFKOHFKWGHU
1X‰NQDFNHUDEVWDPPWHXQGGLH3URIHVVLRQVHLQHU9RUIDKUHQ
WULHE6LHMDXFK]WHDXIYRU)UHXGHGDVSUDFKGHU9DWHU'DGLU
OLHEH0DULH)UHXQG1X‰NQDFNHUVRVHKUJHIlOOWVRVROOVWGXLKQ
DXFKEHVRQGHUVKWHQXQGVFKW]HQXQHUDFKWHWZLHLFKJHVDJW
/XLVHXQG)ULW]LKQPLWHEHQVRYLHOHP5HFKWEUDXFKHQN|QQHQDOV
GX 0DULHQDKPLKQVRJOHLFKLQGHQ$UPXQGOLH‰LKQ1VVH
DXINQDFNHQGRFKVXFKWHVLHGLHNOHLQVWHQDXVGDPLWGDV
0lQQOHLQQLFKWVRZHLWGHQ0XQGDXIVSHUUHQGXUIWHZHOFKHVLKP
GRFKLP*UXQGHQLFKWJXWVWDQG/XLVHJHVHOOWHVLFK]XLKUXQG
DXFKIUVLHPX‰WH)UHXQG1X‰NQDFNHUVHLQH'LHQVWHYHUULFKWHQ
ZHOFKHVHUJHUQ]XWXQVFKLHQGDHULPPHUIRUWVHKUIUHXQGOLFK
OlFKHOWH)ULW]ZDU XQWHUGHVVHQYRPYLHOHQ([HU]LHUHQXQG5HLWHQ
PGHJHZRUGHQXQGGDHUVROXVWLJ1VVHNQDFNHQK|UWHVSUDQJ
HUKLQ]XGHQ6FKZHVWHUQXQGODFKWHUHFKWYRQ+HU]HQEHUGHQ
NOHLQHQGUROOLJHQ0DQQGHUQXQGD)ULW]DXFK1VVHHVVHQZROOWH
YRQ+DQG]X+DQGJLQJXQGJDUQLFKWDXIK|UHQNRQQWHPLW$XI
XQG=XVFKQDSSHQ)ULW]VFKRELPPHUGLHJU|‰WHQXQGKlUWVWHQ
1VVHKLQHLQDEHUPLWHLQHP0DOHJLQJHV NUDFN NUDFN XQG
GUHL=lKQFKHQILHOHQDXVGHV1X‰NQDFNHUV0XQGHXQGVHLQ
JDQ]HV8QWHUNLQQZDUORVHXQGZDFNOLFKW $FKPHLQDUPHU
OLHEHU1X‰NQDFNHUVFKULH0DULHODXWXQGQDKPLKQGHP)ULW]
DXVGHQ+lQGHQ'DVLVWHLQHLQIlOWLJHUGXPPHU%XUVFKHVSUDFK
)ULW]:LOO1X‰NQDFNHUVHLQXQGKDWNHLQRUGHQWOLFKHV*HEL‰
PDJZRKODXFKVHLQ+DQGZHUNJDUQLFKWYHUVWHKQ *LELKQQXU
KHU0DULH(UVROOPLU1VVH]HUEHL‰HQYHUOLHUWHUDXFKQRFKGLH
EULJHQ=lKQHMDGDVJDQ]H.LQQREHQGUHLQZDVLVWDQGHP
7DXJHQLFKWVJHOHJHQ1HLQQHLQULHI0DULHZHLQHQGGX
EHNRPPVWLKQQLFKWPHLQHQOLHEHQ1X‰NQDFNHUVLHKQXUKHUZLH
HUPLFKVRZHKPWLJDQVFKDXWXQGPLUVHLQZXQGHV0QGFKHQ
]HLJW $EHUGXELVWHLQKDUWKHU]LJHU0HQVFK 'XVFKOlJVWGHLQH
3IHUGHXQGOl‰WZRKOJDUHLQHQ6ROGDWHQWRWVFKLH‰HQ 'DV
PX‰VRVHLQGDVYHUVWHKVWGXQLFKWULHI)ULW] DEHUGHU
1X‰NQDFNHUJHK|UWHEHQVRJXWPLUDOVGLUJLELKQQXUKHU
0DULHILQJDQKHIWLJ]XZHLQHQXQGZLFNHOWHGHQNUDQNHQ
1X‰NQDFNHUVFKQHOOLQLKUNOHLQHV7DVFKHQWXFKHLQ'LH(OWHUQ
NDPHQPLWGHP3DWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUKHUEHL'LHVHUQDKP]X
0DULHQV/HLGZHVHQ)ULW]HQV3DUWLH'HU9DWHUVDJWHDEHU,FK
KDEHGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUDXVGUFNOLFKXQWHU0DULHQV6FKXW]JHVWHOOW
XQGGDZLHLFKVHKHHUGHVVHQHEHQMHW]WEHGDUIVRKDWVLHYROOH
0DFKWEHULKQRKQHGD‰MHPDQGGUHLQ]XUHGHQKDWhEULJHQV
ZXQGHUWHVPLFKVHKUYRQ)ULW]HQGD‰HUYRQHLQHPLP'LHQVW
(UNUDQNWHQQRFKIHUQHUH'LHQVWHYHUODQJW$OVJXWHU0LOLWlUVROOWH
HUGRFKZRKOZLVVHQGD‰PDQ9HUZXQGHWHQLHPDOVLQ5HLKHXQG
*OLHGVWHOOW" )ULW]ZDUVHKUEHVFKlPWXQGVFKOLFKRKQHVLFK
ZHLWHUXP1VVHXQG1X‰NQDFNHU]XEHNPPHUQIRUWDQGLH
DQGHUH6HLWHGHV7LVFKHVZRVHLQH+XVDUHQQDFKGHPVLH
JHK|ULJH9RUSRVWHQDXVJHVWHOOWKDWWHQLQV1DFKWTXDUWLHUJH]RJHQ
ZDUHQ0DULHVXFKWH1X‰NQDFNHUVYHUORUQH=lKQFKHQ]XVDPPHQ
XPGDVNUDQNH.LQQKDWWHVLHHLQ KEVFKHVZHL‰HV%DQGGDVVLH
YRQLKUHP.OHLGFKHQDEJHO|VWJHEXQGHQXQGGDQQGHQDUPHQ
.OHLQHQGHUVHKUEOD‰XQGHUVFKURFNHQDXVVDKQRFKVRUJIlOWLJHU
DOVYRUKHULQLKU7XFKHLQJHZLFNHOW6RKLHOWVLHLKQZLHHLQNOHLQHV
.LQGZLHJHQGLQGHQ$UPHQXQGEHVDKGLHVFK|QHQ%LOGHUGHV
QHXHQ%LOGHUEXFKVGDVKHXWHXQWHUGHQDQGHUQYLHOHQ*DEHQODJ
6LHZXUGHZLHHVVRQVWJDUQLFKWLKUH$UWZDUUHFKWE|VHDOV
3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUVRVHKUODFKWHXQGLPPHUIRUWIUDJWHZLHVLH
GHQQPLWVROFKHLQHPJUXQGKl‰OLFEHQNOHLQHQ.HUOVRVFK|QWXQ
N|QQH"-HQHUVRQGHUEDUH9HUJOHLFKPLW'UR‰HOPHLHUGHQVLH
DQVWHOOWHDOVGHU.OHLQHLKU]XHUVWLQGLH$XJHQILHONDPLKU
ZLHGHULQGHQ6LQQXQGVLHVSUDFKVHKUHUQVW:HUZHL‰OLHEHU
3DWHREGXGHQQSXW]HVWGXGLFKDXFKVRKHUDXVZLHPHLQOLHEHU
1X‰NQDFNHUXQGKlWWHVWGXDXFKVROFKHVFK|QHEODQNH
6WLHIHOFKHQDQZHUZHL‰REGXGHQQGRFKVRKEVFKDXVVHKHQ
ZUGHVWDOVHU 0DULHZX‰WHJDUQLFKWZDUXPGHQQGLH(OWHUQ
VRODXWDXIODFKWHQXQGZDUXPGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWVROFK HLQHURWH
1DVHEHNDPXQGJDUQLFKWVRKHOOPLWODFKWHZLH]XYRU(V
PRFKWHZRKOVHLQHEHVRQGHUH8UVDFKHKDEHQ
:XQGHUGLQJH
%HL0HGL]LQDOUDWVLQGHU:RKQVWXEHZHQQPDQ]XU7UH
KLQHLQWULWWJOHLFKOLQNVDQGHUEUHLWHQ:DQGVWHKWHLQKRKHU
*ODVVFKUDQNLQZHOFKHPGLH.LQGHUDOOGLHVFK|QHQ6DFKHQGLH
LKQHQMHGHV-DKUHLQEHVFKHUWZRUGHQDXIEHZDKUHQ'LH/XLVHZDU
QRFKJDQ]NOHLQDOVGHU9DWHUGHQ6FKUDQNYRQHLQHPVHKU
JHVFKLFNWHQ7LVFKOHUPDFKHQOLH‰GHUVRKLPPHOKHOOH6FKHLEHQ
HLQVHW]WHXQGEHUKDXSWGDV*DQ]HVRJHVFKLFNWHLQ]XULFKWHQ
ZX‰WHGD‰DOOHVGULQQHQVLFKEHLQDKHEODQNHUXQGKEVFKHU
DXVQDKPDOVZHQQPDQHVLQ+lQGHQKDWWH,PREHUVWHQ)DFKH
IU0DULHQXQG)ULW]HQXQHUUHLFKEDUVWDQGHQGHV3DWHQ
'UR‰HOPHLHU.XQVWZHUNHJOHLFKGDUXQWHUZDUGDV)DFKIUGLH
%LOGHUEFKHUGLHEHLGHQXQWHUVWHQ)lFKHUGXUIWHQ0DULHXQG)ULW]
DQIOOHQZLHVLHZROOWHQMHGRFKJHVFKDKHVLPPHUGD‰0DULHGDV
XQWHUVWH)DFKLKUHQ3XSSHQ]XU:REQXQJHLQUlXPWH)ULW]
GDJHJHQLQGHP)DFKHGUEHUVHLQH7UXSSHQ
.DQWRQLHUXQJVTXDUWLHUHEH]LHKHQOLH‰6RZDUHVDXFKKHXWH
JHNRPPHQGHQQLQGHP)ULW]VHLQH+XVDUHQREHQDXIJHVWHOOW
KDWWH0DULHXQWHQ0DPVHOO7UXWFKHQEHLVHLWHJHOHJWGLHQHXH
VFK|QJHSXW]WH3XSSHLQGDVVHKUJXWP|EOLHUWH=LPPHU
KLQHLQJHVHW]WXQGVLFKDXI=XFNHUZHUNEHLLKUHLQJHODGHQ6HKU
JXWP|EOLHUWZDUGDV=LPPHUKDEHLFKJHVDJWXQGGDVLVWDXFK
ZDKUGHQQLFKZHL‰QLFKWREGXPHLQHDXIPHUNVDPH=XK|UHULQ
0DULHHEHQVRZLHGLHNOHLQH6WDKOEDXP HVLVWGLUVFKRQEHNDQQW
ZRUGHQGD‰VLHDXFK0DULHKHL‰W MD LFKPHLQHREGXHEHQVR
ZLHGLHVHHLQNOHLQHVVFK|QJHEOPWHV6RIDPHKUHUHDOOHUOLHEVWH
6WKOFKHQHLQHQQLHGOLFKHQ7HHWLVFKYRUDOOHQ'LQJHQDEHUHLQ
VHKUQHWWHVEODQNHV%HWWFKHQEHVLW]HVWZRULQGLHVFK|QVWHQ
3XSSHQDXVUXKHQ"$OOHVGLHVHVVWDQG LQGHU(FNHGHV6FKUDQNV
GHVVHQ:lQGHKLHUVRJDUPLWEXQWHQ%LOGHUFKHQWDSH]LHUWZDUHQ
XQGGXNDQQVWGLUZRKOGHQNHQGD‰LQGLHVHP=LPPHUGLHQHXH
3XSSHZHOFKHZLH0DULHQRFKGHQVHOEHQ$EHQGHUIXKU0DPVHOO
&OlUFKHQKLH‰VLFKVHKUZRKOEHILQGHQPX‰WH

(VZDUVSlWHU$EHQGJHZRUGHQMD0LWWHUQDFKWLP$Q]XJHXQG
3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUOlQJVWIRUWJHJDQJHQDOVGLH.LQGHUQRFKJDU
QLFKWZHJNRPPHQNRQQWHQYRQGHP*ODVVFKUDQNVRVHKUDXFK
GLH0XWWHUPDKQWHGD‰VLHGRFKHQGOLFKQXQ]X%HWWHJHKHQ
P|FKWHQ(VLVWZDKUULHIHQGOLFK)ULW]GLHDUPHQ.HUOV VHLQH
+XVDUHQPHLQHQG ZROOHQDXFKQXQ5XKHKDEHQXQGVRODQJHLFK
GDELQZDJW VNHLQHUHLQEL‰FKHQ]XQLFNHQGDVZHL‰LFKVFKRQ
'DPLWJLQJHUDE0DULHDEHUEDWJDUVHKU1XUQRFKHLQ
:HLOFKHQHLQHLQ]LJHVNOHLQHV:HLOFKHQOD‰PLFKKLHUOLHEH
0XWWHUKDELFKMDGRFKPDQFKHV]XEHVRUJHQXQGLVWGDV
JHVFKHKHQVRZLOOLFKMDJOHLFK]X%HWWHJHKHQ0DULHZDUJDU
HLQIURPPHVYHUQQIWLJHV.LQGXQGVRNRQQWHGLHJXWH0XWWHU
ZRKORKQH6RUJHQVLHQRFKEHLGHQ6SLHOVDFKHQDOOHLQODVVHQ
'DPLWDEHU0DULHQLFKWHWZDJDU]XVHKUYHUORFNWZHUGHYRQGHU
QHXHQ3XSSHXQGGHQVFK|QHQ6SLHOVDFKHQEHUKDXSWVRDEHU
GLH/LFKWHUYHUJl‰HGLHULQJVXPGHQ:DQGVFEUDQNEUHQQWHQ
O|VFKWHGLH0XWWHUVLHVlPWOLFKDXVVRGD‰QXUGLH/DPSHGLHLQ
GHU0LWWHGHV=LPPHUVYRQGHU'HFNHKHUDEKLQJHLQVDQIWHV
DQPXWLJHV/LFKWYHUEUHLWHWH.RPPEDOGKLQHLQOLHEH0DULH
VRQVWNDQQVWGXMDPRUJHQQLFKW]XUHFKWHU=HLWDXIVWHKHQULHI
GLH0XWWHULQGHPVLHVLFKLQGDV6FKODI]LPPHUHQWIHUQWH6REDOG
VLFK0DULHDOOHLQEHIDQGVFKULWWVLHVFKQHOOGD]XZDVLKU]XWXQ
UHFKWDXIGHP+HU]HQODJXQGZDVVLHGRFKQLFKWVHOEVWZX‰WH
VLHQLFKWZDUXPGHU0XWWHU]XHQWGHFNHQYHUPRFKWH1RFK
LPPHUKDWWHVLHGHQNUDQNHQ1X‰NQDFNHUHLQJHZLFNHOWLQLKU
7DVFKHQWXFKDXIGHP$UPJHWUDJHQ-HW]WOHJWHVLHLKQEHKXWVDP
DXIGHQ7LVFKZLFNHOWHOHLVHOHLVHGDV7XFKDEXQGVDKQDFKGHQ
:XQGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUZDUVHKUEOHLFKDEHUGDEHLOlFKHOWHHUVR
VHKUZHKPWLJIUHXQGOLFKGD‰HV0DULHQUHFKWGXUFKGDV+HU]
JLQJ$FK1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQVSUDFKVLHVHKUOHLVHVHLQXUQLFKW
E|VHGD‰%UXGHU)ULW]GLUVRZHKHJHWDQKDWHUKDWHVDXFKQLFKW
VRVFKOLPPJHPHLQWHULVWQXUHLQEL‰FKHQKDUWKHU]LJJHZRUGHQ
GXUFKGDVZLOGH6ROGDWHQZHVHQDEHUVRQVWHLQUHFKWJXWHU-XQJH
GDVNDQQLFKGLFKYHUVLFKHUQ1XQZLOOLFKGLFKDEHUDXFKUHFKW
VRUJOLFKVRODQJHSIOHJHQELVGXZLHGHUJDQ]JHVXQGXQGIU|KOLFK
JHZRUGHQGLUGHLQH=lKQFKHQUHFKWIHVWHLQVHW]HQGLUGLH
6FKXOWHUQHLQUHQNHQGDVVROO3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUGHUVLFKDXI
VROFKH'LQJHYHUVWHKW $EHUQLFKWDXVUHGHQNRQQWH0DULHGHQQ
LQGHPVLHGHQ1DPHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUQDQQWHPDFKWH)UHXQG
1X‰NQDFNHUHLQJDQ]YHUGDPPWVFKLHIHV0DXOXQGDXVVHLQHQ
$XJHQIXKUHVKHUDXVZLHJUQIXQNHOQGH6WDFKHOQ,QGHP
$XJHQEOLFNDEHUGD‰0DULHVLFKUHFKWHQWVHW]HQZROOWHZDUHVMD
ZLHGHUGHVHKUOLFKHQ1X‰NQDFNHUVZHKPWLJOlFKHOQGHV*HVLFKW
ZHOFKHVVLHDQEOLFNWHXQGVLHZX‰WHQXQZRKOGD‰GHUYRQGHU
=XJOXIWEHUKUWHVFKQHOODXIORGHUQGH6WUDKOGHU/DPSHLP
=LPPHU1X‰NQDFNHUV*HVLFKWVRHQWVWHOOWKDWWH%LQLFKQLFKWHLQ
W|ULFKW0lGFKHQGD‰LFKVROHLFKWHUVFKUHFNHVRGD‰LFKVRJDU
JODXEHGDV+RO]SSSFKHQGDN|QQHPLU*HVLFKWHUVFKQHLGHQ
$EHUOLHELVWPLUGRFK1X‰NQDFNHUJDU]XVHKUZHLOHUVRNRPLVFK
LVWXQGGRFKVRJXWPWLJXQGGDUXPPX‰HUJHSIOHJWZHUGHQ
ZLHVLFK VJHK|UW'DPLWQDKP0DULHGHQ)UHXQG1X‰NQDFNHULQ
GHQ$UPQlKHUWHVLFKGHP*ODVVFKUDQNNDXHUWHYRUGHPVHOEHQ
XQGVSUDFKDOVR]XUQHXHQ3XSSH,FKELWWHGLFKUHFKWVHKU
0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQWULWWGHLQ%HWWFKHQGHPNUDQNHQZXQGHQ
1X‰NQDFNHUDEXQGEHKHOIHGLFKVRJXWZLHHVJHKWPLWGHP
6RID%HGHQNHGD‰GXVHKUJHVXQGXQGUHFKWEHL.UlIWHQELVW
GHQQVRQVWZUGHVWGXQLFKWVROFKHGLFNHGXQNHOURWH%DFNHQ
KDEHQXQGGD‰VHKUZHQLJHGHUDOOHUVFK|QVWHQ3XSSHQVROFKH
ZHLFKH6RIDVEHVLW]HQ

0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQVDKLQYROOHPJOlQ]HQGHQ:HLKQDFKWVSXW]VHKU
YRUQHKPXQGYHUGULH‰OLFKDXVXQGVDJWHQLFKW0XFN:DV
PDFKHLFKDEHUDXFKIU8PVWlQGHVSUDFK0DULHQDKPGDV
%HWWHKHUYRUOHJWHVHKUOHLVHXQGVDQIW 1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQKLQHLQ
ZLFNHOWHQRFKHLQJDUVFK|QHV%lQGFKHQGDVVLHVRQVWXPGHQ
/HLEJHWUDJHQXPGLHZXQGHQ6FKXOWHUQXQGEHGHFNWHLKQELV
XQWHUGLH1DVH%HLGHUXQDUWLJHQ&OlUHGDUIHUDEHUQLFKW
EOHLEHQVSUDFKVLHZHLWHUXQGKREGDV%HWWFKHQVDPWGHP
GDULQQHOLHJHQGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUKHUDXVLQGDVREHUH)DFKVRGD‰
HVGLFKWQHEHQGHPVFK|QHQ'RUI]XVWHKHQNDPZR)ULW]HQV
+XVDUHQNDQWRQLHUWHQ6LHYHUVFKOR‰GHQ6FKUDQNXQGZROOWHLQV
6FKODI]LPPHUGD KRUFKWDXI.LQGHU GDILQJHVDQOHLVH OHLVH
]XZLVSHUQXQG]XIOVWHUQXQG]XUDVFKHOQULQJVKHUXPKLQWHU
GHP2IHQKLQWHUGHQ6WKOHQKLQWHUGHQ6FKUlQNHQ 'LH
:DQGXKUVFKQXUUWHGD]ZLVFKHQODXWHUXQGODXWHUDEHUVLHNRQQWH
QLFKWVFKODJHQ0DULHEOLFNWHKLQGDKDWWHGLHJUR‰HYHUJROGHWH
(XOHGLHGDUDXIVD‰LKUH)OJHOKHUDEJHVHQNWVRGD‰VLHGLH
JDQ]H8KUEHUGHFNWHQXQGGHQKl‰OLFKHQ.DW]HQNRSIPLW
NUXPPHQ6FKQDEHOZHLWYRUJHVWUHFNW8QGVWlUNHUVFKQXUUWHHV
PLWYHUQHKPOLFKHQ:RUWHQ8KU8KUH8KUH8KUHQP‰WDOOH
QXUOHLVHVFKQXUUHQOHLVHVFKQXUUHQ 0DXVHN|QLJKDWMDZRKOHLQ
IHLQHV2KU SXUUSXUU SXPSXPVLQJWQXUVLQJWLKPDOWHV
/LHGOHLQYRU SXUUSXUU SXPSXPVFKODJDQ*O|FNOHLQVFKODJDQ
EDOGLVWHVXPLKQJHWDQ8QGSXPSXPJLQJHVJDQ]GXPSIXQG
KHLVHU]Z|OIPDO 0DULHQILQJDQVHKU]XJUDXHQXQGHQWVHW]W
ZlUVLHEHLQDKHGDYRQJHODXIHQDOVVLH3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHU
HUEOLFNWHGHUVWDWWGHU(XOHDXIGHU:DQGXKUVD‰XQGVHLQH
JHOEHQ5RFNVFK|‰HYRQEHLGHQ6HLWHQZLH)OJHOKHUDEJHKlQJW
KDWWHDEHUVLHHUPDQQWHVLFKXQGULHIODXWXQGZHLQHUOLFK3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUZDVZLOOVWGXGDREHQ".RPP
KHUXQWHU]XPLUXQGHUVFKUHFNHPLFKQLFKWVRGXE|VHU3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHU $EHUGDJLQJHLQWROOHV.LFKHUQXQG*HSIHLIHORV
UXQGXPKHUXQGEDOGWURWWLHUWHXQGOLHIHV KLQWHUGHQ:lQGHQZLH
PLWWDXVHQGNOHLQHQ)‰FKHQXQGWDXVHQGNOHLQH/LFKWHUFKHQ
EOLFNWHQDXVGHQ5LW]HQGHU'LHOHQ$EHUQLFKW/LFKWHUFKHQZDUHQ
HVQHLQNOHLQHIXQNHOQGH$XJHQXQG0DULHZXUGHJHZDKUGD‰
EHUDOO0lXVHKHUYRUJXFNWHQXQGVLFKKHUYRUDUEHLWHWHQ%DOGJLQJ
HVWURWW WURWW KRSSKRSSLQGHU6WXEHXPKHU LPPHUOLFKWHUH
XQGGLFKWHUH+DXIHQ0lXVHJDORSSLHUWHQKLQXQGKHUXQGVWHOOWHQ
VLFKHQGOLFKLQ5HLKHXQG*OLHGVRZLH)ULW]VHLQH6ROGDWHQ]X
VWHOOHQSIOHJWHZHQQHV]XU6FKODFKWJHKHQVROOWH'DVNDPQXQ
0DULHQVHKUSRVVLHUOLFKYRUXQGGDVLHQLFKWZLHPDQFKHDQGHUH
.LQGHUHLQHQQDWUOLFKHQ$EVFKHXJHJHQ0lXVHKDWWHZROOWHLKU
HEHQDOOHV*UDXHQYHUJHKHQDOVHVPLWHLQHPPDOVRHQWVHW]OLFK
XQGVRVFKQHLGHQG]XSIHLIHQEHJDQQGD‰HVLKUHLVNDOWEHUGHQ
5FNHQOLHI $FKZDVHUEOLFNWHVLHMHW]W 1HLQZDKUKDIWLJ
JHHKUWHU/HVHU)ULW]LFKZHL‰GD‰HEHQVRJXWZLHGHPZHLVHQXQG
PXWLJHQ)HOGKHUUQ)ULW]6WDKOEDXPGLUGDV+HU]DXIGHPUHFKWHQ
)OHFNHVLW]WDEHUKlWWHVWGXGDVJHVHKHQ ZDV0DULHQMHW]WYRU
$XJHQNDPZDKUKDIWLJGXZlUVWGDYRQJHODXIHQLFKJODXEH
VRJDUGXZlUVWVFKQHOOLQV%HWWJHVSUXQJHQXQGKlWWHVWGLH
'HFNHYLHOZHLWHUEHUGLH2KUHQJH]RJHQDOVJHUDGHQ|WLJ $FK
 GDVNRQQWHGLHDUPH0DULHMDQLFKWHLQPDOWXQGHQQK|UWQXU
.LQGHU GLFKWGLFKWYRULKUHQ)‰HQVSUKWHHVZLHYRQ
XQWHULUGLVFKHU*HZDOWJHWULHEHQ6DQGXQG.DONXQG]HUEU|FNHOWH
0DXHUVWHLQHKHUYRUXQGVLHEHQ0lXVHN|SIHPLWVLHEHQ
KHOOIXQNHOQGHQ.URQHQHUKREHQVLFKUHFKWJUl‰OLFK]LVFKHQGXQG
SIHLIHQG DXVGHP%RGHQ%DOGDUEHLWHWHVLFKDXFKGHU
0DXVHN|USHUDQGHVVHQ+DOVGLHVLHEHQ.|SIHDQJHZDFKVHQ
ZDUHQYROOHQGVKHUYRUXQGGHUJUR‰HQPLWVLHEHQ'LDGHPHQ
JHVFKPFNWHQ0DXVMDXFK]WHLQYROOHP&KRUXVGUHLPDOODXW
DXITXLHNHQGGDVJDQ]H+HHUHQWJHJHQGDVVLFKQXQDXIHLQPDOLQ
%HZHJXQJVHW]WHXQGKRWWKRWW WURWW WURWWJLQJHV DFK
JHUDGH]XDXIGHQ6FKUDQN JHUDGH]XDXI0DULHQORVGLHQRFK
GLFKWDQGHU*ODVWUHGHV6FKUDQNHVVWDQG9RU$QJVWXQG*UDXHQ
KDWWH0DULHQGDV+HU]VFKRQVRJHSRFKWGD‰VLHJODXEWHHV
PVVHQXQJOHLFKDXVGHU%UXVWKHUDXVVSULQJHQXQGGDQQP‰WH
VLHVWHUEHQDEHUQXQZDUHVLKUDOVVWHKHLKUGDV%OXWLQGHQ
$GHUQVWLOO+DOERKQPlFKWLJZDQNWHVLH]XUFNGDJLQJHVNOLUU
NOLUU SUUXQGLQ6FKHUEHQILHOGLH*ODVVFKHLEHGHV6FKUDQNV
KHUDEGLHVLHPLWGHP(OOERJHQHLQJHVWR‰HQ6LHIKOWHZRKOLQ
GHP$XJHQEOLFNHLQHQUHFKWVWHFKHQGHQ6FKPHU]DPOLQNHQ$UP
DEHUHVZDULKUDXFKSO|W]OLFKYLHOOHLFKWHUXPV+HU]VLHK|UWH
NHLQ4XLHNHQXQG3IHLIHQPHKUHVZDUDOOHVJDQ]VWLOOJHZRUGHQ
XQGREVFKRQVLHQLFKWKLQEOLFNHQPRFKWHJODXEWHVLHGRFKGLH
0lXVHZlUHQYRQGHP.OLUUHQGHU6FKHLEHHUVFKUHFNWZLHGHU
DEJH]RJHQLQLKUH/|FKHU $EHUZDVZDUGHQQGDVZLHGHU"
'LFKWKLQWHU0DULHQILQJHVDQLP6FKUDQNDXIVHOWVDPH:HLVH]X
UXPRUHQXQGJDQ]IHLQH6WLPPFKHQILQJHQDQ$XIJHZDFKW
DXIJHZDFKW ZROOQ]XU6FKODFKW QRFKGLHVH1DFKW DXIJHZDFKW
 DXI]XU6FKODFKW 8QGGDEHLNOLQJHOWHHVPLWKDUPRQLVFKHQ
*O|FNOHLQJDUKEVFKXQGDQPXWLJ$FKGDVLVWMDPHLQNOHLQHV
*ORFNHQVSLHOULHI0DULHIUHXGLJXQGVSUDQJVFKQHOO]XU6HLWH'D
VDKVLHZLHHVLP6FKUDQNJDQ]VRQGHUEDUOHXFKWHWHXQG
KHUXPZLUWVFKDIWHWHXQGKDQWLHUWH(VZDUHQPHKUHUH3XSSHQGLH
GXUFKHLQDQGHUOLHIHQXQGPLWGHQNOHLQHQ$UPHQKHUXPIRFKWHQ
0LWHLQHPPDOHUKREVLFKMHW]W1X‰NQDFNHUZDUIGLH'HFNHZHLW
YRQVLFKXQGVSUDQJPLWEHLGHQ)‰HQ]XJOHLFKDXVGHP%HWWH
LQGHPHUODXWULHI.QDFNNQDFN NQDFN GXPPHV0DXVHSDFN
GXPPHUWROOHU6FKQDFN 0DXVHSDFN .QDFN .QDFN 0DXVHSDFN
 .ULFNXQG.UDFN ZDKUHU 6FKQDFN8QGGDPLW]RJHUVHLQ
NOHLQHV6FKZHUWXQGVFKZDQJHVLQGHQ/IWHQXQGULHI,KU
PHLQHOLHEHQ9DVDOOHQ)UHXQGHXQG%UGHUZROOWLKUPLU
EHLVWHKHQLPKDUWHQ.DPSI" 6RJOHLFKVFKULHQKHIWLJGUHL
6NDUDPX]]HHLQ3DQWDORQYLHU6FKRUQVWHLQIHJHU]ZHL
=LWKHUVSLHOPlQQHUXQGHLQ7DPERXU-D+HUU ZLUKlQJHQ(XFK
DQLQVWDQGKDIWHU7UHXH PLW(XFK]LHKHQZLULQ7RG6LHJXQG
.DPSIXQGVWU]WHQVLFKQDFKGHPEHJHLVWHUWHQ1X‰NQDFNHU
GHUGHQJHIlKUOLFKHQ6SUXQJZDJWHYRPREHUQ)DFKKHUDE-D
MHQHKDWWHQJXWVLFKKHUDEVWU]HQGHQQQLFKWDOOHLQGD‰VLHUHLFKH
.OHLGHUYRQ7XFKXQG6HLGHWUXJHQVRZDULQZHQGLJLP/HLEH
DXFKQLFKWYLHODQGHUVDOV%DXPZROOHXQG+lFNVHOGDKHU
SOXPSWHQVLHDXFKKHUDEZLH:ROOVlFNFKHQ$EHUGHUDUPH
1X‰NQDFNHUGHUKlWWHJHZL‰$UPXQG%HLQHJHEURFKHQGHQQ
GHQNWHXFKHVZDUEHLQDKH]ZHL)X‰KRFKYRP)DFKHZRHU
VWDQGELV]XPXQWHUVWHQXQGVHLQ.|USHUZDUVRVSU|GHDOVVHL
HUJHUDGH]XDXV/LQGHQKRO]JHVFKQLW]W-D1X‰NQDFNHUKlWWH
JHZL‰$UPXQG%HLQHJHEURFKHQZlUHLP$XJHQEOLFNDOVHU
VSUDQJQLFKWDXFK0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQVFKQHOOYRP6RID
DXIJHVSUXQJHQXQGKlWWHGHQ+HOGHQPLWGHPJH]RJHQHQ
6FKZHUWLQLKUHQZHLFKHQ$UPHQDXIJHIDQJHQ$FKGXOLHEHV
JXWHV&OlUFKHQVFKOXFK]WH0DULHZLHKDEHLFKGLFKYHUNDQQW
JHZL‰JDEVWGX)UHXQG1X‰NQDFNHUQGHLQ%HWWFKHQUHFKWJHUQH
KHU'RFK0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQVSUDFKMHW]WLQGHPVLHGHQMXQJHQ
+HOGHQVDQIWDQLKUHVHLGHQH%UXVWGUFNWH:ROOHW(XFKR+HUU
NUDQNXQGZXQGZLH,KUVHLGGRFKQLFKWLQ.DPSIXQG*HIDKU
EHJHEHQVHKWZLH(XUHWDSIHUHQ9DVDOOHQNDPSIOXVWLJXQGGHV
6LHJHVJHZL‰VLFKVDPPHOQ6NDUDPX]3DQWDORQ
6FKRUQVWHLQIHJHU=LWKHUVSLHOPDQQXQG7DPERXUVLQGVFKRQXQWHQ
XQGGLH'HYLVHQ)LJXUHQLQPHLQHP)DFKHUKUHQXQGUHJHQVLFK
PHUNOLFK:ROOHWR+HUULQPHLQHQ$UPHQDXVUXKHQRGHUYRQ
PHLQHP)HGHUKXWKHUDE(XHUQ6LHJDQVFKDXQ6RVSUDFK
&OlUFKHQGRFK1X‰NQDFNHUWDWJDQ]XQJHElUGLJXQGVWUDPSHOWH
VRVHKUPLWGHQ%HLQHQGD‰&OlUFKHQLKQVFKQHOOKHUDEDXIGHQ
%RGHQVHW]HQPX‰WH,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNOLH‰HUVLFKDEHUVHKU
DUWLJDXIHLQ.QLHQLHGHUXQGOLVSHOWH2'DPHVWHWVZHUGLFK
(XUHUPLUEHZLHVHQHQ*QDGHXQG+XOGJHGHQNHQLQ.DPSIXQG
6WUHLW'DEFNWHVLFK&OlUFKHQVRWLHIKHUDEGD‰VLHLKQEHLP
bUPFKHQHUJUHLIHQNRQQWHKRELKQVDQIWDXIO|VWHVFKQHOOLKUHQ
PLWYLHOHQ)OLWWHUQJH]LHUWHQ/HLEJUWHOORVXQGZROOWHLKQGHP
.OHLQHQXPKlQJHQGRFKGHUZLFK]ZHL6FKULWWH]XUFNOHJWHGLH
+DQGDXIGLH%UXVWXQGVSUDFKVHKUIHLHUOLFK1LFKWVRZROOHWR
'DPH(XUH*XQVWDQPLUYHUVFKZHQGHQGHQQHUVWRFNWH
VHXI]WHWLHIDXIUL‰GDQQVFKQHOOGDV%lQGFKHQZRPLWLKQ0DULH
YHUEXQGHQKDWWHYRQGHQ6FKXOWHUQGUFNWHHVDQGLH/LSSHQ
KLQJHVZLHHLQH)HOGELQGHXPXQGVSUDQJGDVEODQNJH]RJHQH
6FKZHUWOHLQPXWLJVFKZHQNHQGVFKQHOOXQGEHKHQGHZLHHLQ
9|JHOFKHQEHUGLH/HLVWHGHV6FKUDQNVDXIGHQ)X‰ERGHQ,KU
PHUNWZRKOK|FKVWJHQHLJWHXQGVHKUYRUWUHIIOLFKH=XK|UHUGD‰
1X‰NQDFNHUVFKRQIUKHUDOVHUZLUNOLFKOHEHQGLJZRUGHQDOOHV
/LHEHXQG*XWHZDVLKP0DULHHU]HLJWHUHFKWGHXWOLFKIKOWHXQG
GD‰HUQXU GHVKDOEZHLOHU0DULHQVRJDUJXWZRUGHQDXFKQLFKW
HLQPDOHLQ%DQGYRQ0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQDQQHKPHQXQGWUDJHQ
ZROOWHXQHUDFKWHWHVVHKUJOlQ]WHXQGVHKUKEVFKDXVVDK'HU
WUHXHJXWH1X‰NQDFNHUSXW]WHVLFKOLHEHUPLW0DULHQVVFKOLFKWHP
%lQGFKHQ $EHUZLHZLUGHVQXQZHLWHUZHUGHQ" 6RZLH
1X‰NQDFNHUKHUDEVSULQJWJHKWDXFKGDV4XLHNHQXQG3LHSHQ
ZLHGHUORV$FKXQWHUGHPJUR‰HQ7LVFKHKDOWHQMDGLHIDWDOHQ
5RWWHQXQ]lKOLJHU0lXVHXQGEHUDOOHUDJWGLHDEVFKHXOLFKH0DXV
PLWGHQVLHEHQ.|SIHQKHUYRU :LHZLUGGDVQXQZHUGHQ
'LH6FKODFKW
6FKODJWGHQ*HQHUDOPDUVFKJHWUHXHU9DVDOOH7DPERXUVFKULH
1X‰NQDFNHUVHKUODXWXQGVRJOHLFKILQJGHU7DPERXUDQDXIGLH
NQVWOLFKVWH:HLVH]XZLUEHOQGD‰GLH)HQVWHUGHV*ODVVFKUDQNV
]LWWHUWHQXQGGU|KQWHQ 1XQNUDFNWHXQGNODSSHUWHHVGULQQHQXQG
0DULHZXUGHJHZDKUGD‰GLH'HFNHOVlPWOLFKHU6FKDFKWHOQZRULQ
)ULW]HQV$UPHHHLQTXDUWLHUWZDUPLW*HZDOWDXI XQGGLH6ROGDWHQ
KHUDXVXQGKHUDELQVXQWHUVWH)DFKVSUDQJHQGRUWVLFKDEHULQ
EODQNHQ5RWWHQVDPPHOWHQ1X‰NQDFNHUOLHIDXIXQGQLHGHU
EHJHLVWHUWH:RUWH]XGHQ7UXSSHQVSUHFKHQG.HLQ+XQGYRQ
7URPSHWHUUHJWXQGUKUWVLFKVFKULH1X‰NQDFNHUHUERVWZDQGWH
VLHKDEHUGDQQVFKQHOO]XP3DQWDORQGHUHWZDVEOD‰JHZRUGHQ
PLWGHPODQJHQ.LQQVHKUZDFNHOWHXQGVSUDFKIHLHUOLFK
*HQHUDOLFKNHQQHLKUHQ0XWXQG,KUH(UIDKUXQJKLHUJLOW V
VFKQHOOHQhEHUEOLFNXQG%HQXW]XQJGHV0RPHQWV LFKYHUWUDXH
,KQHQGDV.RPPDQGRVlPWOLFKHU.DYDOOHULHXQG$UWLOOHULHDQ HLQ
3IHUGEUDXFKHQ6LHQLFKW6LHKDEHQVHKUODQJH %HLQHXQG
JDORSSLHUHQGDPLWOHLGOLFK7XQ6LHMHW]WZDV,KUHV%HUXIVLVW
6RJOHLFKGUFNWH3DQWDORQGLHGUUHQODQJHQ)LQJHUFKHQDQGHQ
0XQGXQGNUlKWHVRGXUFKGULQJHQGGD‰HVNODQJDOVZUGHQ
KXQGHUWKHOOH7URPSHWOHLQOXVWLJJHEODVHQ'DJLQJHVLP6FKUDQN
DQHLQ.LFKHUQXQG6WDPSIHQXQGVLHKH)ULW]HQV.UDVVLHUHXQG
'UDJRQHUYRUDOOHQ'LQJHQDEHUGLHQHXHQJOlQ]HQGHQ+XVDUHQ
UFNWHQDXVXQGKLHOWHQEDOGXQWHQDXIGHP)X‰ERGHQ1XQ
GHILOLHUWH5HJLPHQWDXI5HJLPHQWPLWIOLHJHQGHQ)DKQHQXQG
NOLQJHQGHP6SLHOEHL1X‰NQDFNHUYRUEHUXQGVWHOOWHVLFKLQ
EUHLWHU5HLKHTXHUEHUGHQ%RGHQGHV=LPPHUV$EHUYRULKQHQ
KHUIXKUHQUDVVHOQG)ULW]HQV.DQRQHQDXIYRQGHQ.DQRQLHUQ
XPJHEHQXQGEDOGJLQJHVEXPEXPXQG0DULHVDKZLHGLH
=XFNHUHUEVHQHLQVFKOXJHQLQ GHQGLFNHQ+DXIHQGHU0lXVHGLH
GDYRQJDQ]ZHL‰EHUSXGHUWZXUGHQXQGVLFKVHKUVFKlPWHQ
9RU]JOLFKWDWLKQHQDEHUHLQHVFKZHUH%DWWHULHYLHO6FKDGHQGLH
DXI0DPDV)X‰EDQNDXIJHIDKUHQZDUXQG3XP 3XP 3XP
LPPHUKLQWHUHLQDQGHUIRUW3IHIIHUQVVHXQWHUGLH0lXVHVFKR‰
ZRYRQVLHXPILHOHQ'LH0lXVHNDPHQDEHUGRFKLPPHUQlKHU
XQGEHUUDQQWHQVRJDUHLQLJH.DQRQHQDEHUGDJLQJHV3UU 3UU
3UUXQGYRU5DXFKXQG6WDXENRQQWH0DULHNDXPVHKHQZDVQXQ
JHVFKDK'RFKVRYLHOZDUJHZL‰GD‰MHGHV.RUSVVLFKPLWGHU
K|FKVWHQ(UELWWHUXQJVFKOXJXQGGHU6LHJODQJHKLQXQGKHU
VFKZDQNWH'LH0lXVHHQWZLFNHOWHQLPPHUPHKUXQGPHKU
0DVVHQXQGLKUHNOHLQHQVLOEHUQHQ3LOOHQGLHVLHVHKUJHVFKLFNW
]XVFKOHXGHUQZX‰WHQVFKOXJHQVFKRQELVLQGHQ*ODVVFKUDQN
KLQHLQ9HU]ZHLIOXQJVYROOOLHIHQ&OlUFKHQXQG7UXWFKHQXPKHU
XQGUDQJHQVLFKGLH+lQGFKHQZXQG6ROOLFKLQPHLQHU
EOKHQGVWHQ-XJHQGVWHUEHQ LFKGLHVFK|QVWHGHU3XSSHQ
VFKULH&OlUFKHQ+DELFKGDUXPPLFKVRJXWNRQVHUYLHUWXPKLHU
LQPHLQHQYLHU:lQGHQXP]XNRPPHQ"ULHI7UXWFKHQ'DQQILHOHQ
VLHVLFKXPGHQ+DOVXQGKHXOWHQVRVHKUGD‰PDQHVWURW]GHV
WROOHQ/lUPVGRFKK|UHQNRQQWH'HQQYRQGHP6SHNWDNHOGHU
QXQORVJLQJKDEWLKUNDXPHLQHQ%HJULIIZHUWH=XK|UHU 'DV
JLQJ 3UU 3UU 3XII3LII 6FKQHWWHUGHQJ 6FKQHWWHUGHQJ
%XP%XUXP%XP %XUXP %XP GXUFKHLQDQGHUXQGGDEHL
TXLHNWHQXQGVFKULHQ0DXVN|QLJXQG0lXVHXQGGDQQK|UWHPDQ
ZLHGHU1X‰NQDFNHUVJHZDOWLJH6WLPPHZLHHUQW]OLFKH%HIHKOH
DXVWHLOWHXQGVDKLKQZLHHUEHUGLHLP)HXHUVWHKHQGHQ
%DWDLOORQHKLQZHJVFKULWW 3DQWDORQKDWWHHLQLJHVHKUJOlQ]HQGH
.DYDOOHQHDQJULIIHJHPDFKWXQGVLFKPLW5XKPEHGHFNWDEHU
)ULW]HQV+XVDUHQZXUGHQYRQGHU0lXVHDUWLOOHQHPLWKl‰OLFKHQ
EHOULHFKHQGHQ.XJHOQEHZRUIHQGLHJDQ]IDWDOH)OHFNHLQLKUHQ
URWHQ:lPVHUQPDFKWHQZHVKDOEVLHQLFKWUHFKWYRUZROOWHQ
3DQWDORQOLH‰VLHOLQNVDEVFKZHQNHQXQGLQGHU%HJHLVWHUXQJGHV
.RPPDQGLHUHQVPDFKWHHUHVHEHQVRXQGVHLQH.UDVVLHUHXQG
'UDJRQHUDXFKGDVKHL‰WVLHVFKZHQNWHQDOOHOLQNVDEXQG
JLQJHQQDFK+DXVH'DGXUFKJHULHWGLHDXIGHU)X‰EDQNSRVWLHUWH
%DWWHULHLQ*HIDKUXQGHVGDXHUWHDXFKJDUQLFKWODQJHVRNDP
HLQGLFNHU+DXIHVHKUKl‰OLFKHU0lXVHXQGUDQQWHVRVWDUNDQ
GD‰GLHJDQ]H)X‰EDQNPLWVDPWGHQ.DQRQLHUHQXQG.DQRQHQ
XPILHO1X‰NQDFNHUVFKLHQVHKUEHVWU]WXQGEHIDKOGD‰GHU
UHFKWH)OJHOHLQHUFNJlQJLJH%HZHJXQJPDFKHQVROOH'X
ZHL‰WRPHLQNULHJVHUIDKPHU=XK|UHU)ULW]GD‰HLQHVROFKH
%HZHJXQJPDFKHQEHLQDKHVRYLHOKHL‰WDOVGDYRQODXIHQXQG
EHWUDXHUVWPLWPLUVFKRQMHW]W GDV8QJOFNZDVEHUGLH$UPHH
GHVNOHLQHQYRQ0DULHJHOLHEWHQ1X‰NQDFNHUVNRPPHQVROOWH
:HQGHMHGRFKGHLQ$XJHYRQGLHVHP8QKHLODEXQGEHVFKDXH
GHQOLQNHQ)OJHOGHU1X‰NQDFNHULVFKHQ$UPHHZRDOOHVQRFK
VHKUJXWVWHKWXQGIU)HOGKHUUQXQG$UPHHYLHO]XKRIIHQLVW
:lKUHQGGHVKLW]LJVWHQ*HIHFKWVZDUHQOHLVHOHLVH0lXVH
.DYDOOHULHPDVVHQXQWHUGHU.RPPRGHKHUDXVGHERXFKLHUWXQG
KDWWHQVLFKXQWHUODXWHPJUl‰OLFKHQ*HTXLHNPLW:XWDXIGHQ
OLQNHQ)OJHOGHU1X‰NQDFNHULVFKHQ$UPHHJHZRUIHQDEHU
ZHOFKHQ :LGHUVWDQGIDQGHQVLHGD /DQJVDPZLHHVGLH
6FKZLHQJNHLWGHV7HUUDLQVQXUHUODXEWHGDGLH/HLVWHGHV
6FKUDQNV]XSDVVLHUHQZDUGDV'HYLVHQ.RUSVXQWHUGHU
$QIKUXQJ]ZHLHUFKLQHVLVFKHU.DLVHUYRUJHUFNWXQGKDWWHVLFK
HQTXDUUÒSODLQIRUPLHUW 'LHVHZDFNHUQVHKUEXQWHQXQG
KHUUOLFKHQ7UXSSHQGLHDXVYLHOHQ*lUWQHUQ7LUROHUQ7XQJXVHQ
)ULVHXUV+DUOHNLQV.XSLGRV/|ZHQ7LJHUQ0HHUNDW]HQXQG
$IIHQEHVWDQGHQIRFKWHQPLW)DVVXQJ0XWXQG$XVGDXHU0LW
VSDUWDQLVFKHU7DSIHUNHLWKlWWHGLHV%DWDLOORQYRQ(OLWHQGHP
)HLQGHGHQ6LHJHQWULVVHQZHQQQLFKWHLQYHUZHJHQHUIHLQGOLFKHU
5LWWPHLVWHUWROONKQYRUGULQJHQGHLQHPGHUFKLQHVLVFKHQ.DLVHU
GHQ.RSIDEJHELVVHQXQGGLHVHULP)DOOHQ]ZHL7XQJXVHQXQG
HLQH0HHUNDW]HHUVFKODJHQKlWWH'DGXUFKHQWVWDQGHLQH/FNH
GXUFKGLHGHU)HLQGHLQGUDQJXQGEDOGZDUGDVJDQ]H%DWDLOORQ
]HUELVVHQ'RFKZHQLJ9RUWHLOKDWWHGHU)HLQGYRQGLHVHU8QWDW
6RZLHHLQ0lXVHNDYDOOHULVWPRUGOXVWLJHLQHQGHUWDSIHUQ*HJQHU
PLWWHQGXUFK]HUEL‰EHNDPHUHLQHQNOHLQHQJHGUXFNWHQ=HWWHOLQ
GHQ+DOVZRYRQHUDXJHQEOLFNOLFKVWDUE +DOIGLHVDEHUZRKO
DXFKGHU1X‰NQDFNHULVFKHQ$UPHHGLHHLQPDOUFNJlQJLJ
JHZRUGHQLPPHUUFNJlQJLJHUZXUGHXQGLPPHUPHKU/HXWH
YHUORUVRGD‰GHUXQJOFNOLFKH1X‰NQDFNHUQXUPLWHLQHPJDU
NOHLQHQ+lXIFKHQGLFKWYRUGHP*ODVVFKUDQNHKLHOW"'LH5HVHUYH
VROOKHUDQ 3DQWDORQ 6NDUDPX]7DPERXU ZRVHLGLKU" 6R
VFKULH1X‰NQDFNHUGHUQRFKDXIQHXH7UXSSHQKRIIWHGLHVLFK
DXVGHP*ODVVFKUDQNHQWZLFNHOQVROOWHQ(VNDPHQDXFKZLUNOLFK
HLQLJHEUDXQH0lQQHUXQG)UDXHQDXV7KRUQPLWJROGQHQ
*HVLFKWHUQ+WHQXQG+HOPHQKHUDQGLHIRFKWHQDEHUVR
XQJHVFKLFNWXPVLFKKHUXPGD‰VLHNHLQHQGHU)HLQGHWUDIHQXQG
EDOGLKUHP)HOGKHUUQ1X‰NQDFNHUVHOEVWGLH0W]HYRP.RSIH
KHUXQWHUJHIRFKWHQKlWWHQ'LHIHLQGOLFKHQ&KDVVHXUVELVVHQLKQHQ
DXFKEDOGGLH%HLQHDEVRGD‰VLHXPVWOSWHQXQGQRFKGD]X
HLQLJHYRQ1X‰NQDFNHUV:DIIHQEUGHUQHUVFKOXJHQ1XQZDU
1X‰NQDFNHUYRP)HLQGHGLFKWXPULQJWLQGHUK|FKVWHQ$QJVWXQG
1RW(UZROOWHEHUGLH/HLVWHGHV6FKUDQNVVSULQJHQDEHUGLH
%HLQHZDUHQ]XNXU]&OlUFKHQXQG7UXWFKHQODJHQLQ2KQPDFKW
VLHNRQQWHQLKPQLFKWKHOIHQ +XVDUHQ 'UDJRQHUVSUDQJHQ
OXVWLJEHLLKPYRUEHLXQGKLQHLQGDVFKULHHUDXILQKHOOHU
9HU]ZHLIOXQJ(LQ3IHUG HLQ3IHUG HLQ.|QLJUHLFKIUHLQ
3IHUG ,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNSDFNWHQLKQ]ZHLIHLQGOLFKH7LUDLOOHXUV
EHLGHPK|O]HUQHQ0DQWHOXQGLP7ULXPSKDXVVLHEHQ.HKOHQ
DXITXLHNHQGVSUHQJWH0DXVHN|QLJKHUDQ0DULHZX‰WHVLFKQLFKW
PHKU]XIDVVHQ2PHLQDUPHU1X‰NQDFNHU PHLQDUPHU
1X‰NQDFNHUVRULHIVLHVFKOXFK]HQGID‰WHRKQHVLFKGHXWOLFK
LKUHV7XQVEHZX‰W]XVHLQQDFKLKUHPOLQNHQ6FKXKXQGZDUILKQ
PLW*HZDOWLQGHQGLFNVWHQ+DXIHQGHU0lXVHKLQHLQDXILKUHQ
.|QLJ,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNVFKLHQDOOHVYHUVWREHQXQGYHUIORJHQ
DEHU0DULHHPSIDQGDPOLQNHQ$UPHLQHQQRFKVWHFKHQGHUQ
6FKPHU]DOVYRUKHUXQGVDQNRKQPlFKWLJ]XU(UGHQLHGHU
'LH.UDQNKHLW
$OV0DULHZLHDXVWLHIHP7RGHVVFKODIHUZDFKWHODJVLHLQLKUHP
%HWWHKHQXQGGLH6RQQHVFKLHQKHOOXQGIXQNHOQGGXUFKGLHPLW
(LVEHOHJWHQ)HQVWHULQGDV=LPPHUKLQHLQ'LFKWQHEHQLKUVD‰
HLQIUHPGHU0DQQGHQVLHDEHUEDOGIUGHQ&KLUXUJXV
:HQGHOVWHUQHUNDQQWH'HUVSUDFKOHLVH1XQLVWVLHDXIJHZDFKW
'DNDPGLH0XWWHUKHUEHLXQGVDKVLHPLWUHFKWlQJVWOLFK
IRUVFKHQGHQ%OLFNHQDQ$FKOLHEH0XWWHUOLVSHOWHGLHNOHLQH
0DULHVLQGGHQQQXQGLHKl‰OLFKHQ0lXVHDOOHIRUWXQGLVWGHQQ
GHUJXWH1X‰NQDFNHUJHUHWWHW"6SULFKQLFKWVROFKDOEHUQHV
=HXJOLHEH0DULHHUZLGHUWHGLH0XWWHUZDVKDEHQGLH0lXVH
PLWGHP1X‰NQDFNHU]XWXQ$EHUGXE|VHV.LQGKDVWXQVDOOHQ
UHFKWYLHO$QJVWXQG6RUJHJHPDFKW'DVNRPPWGDYRQKHUZHQQ
GLH.LQGHUHLJHQZLOOLJVLQGXQGGHQ(OWHUQQLFKWIROJHQ'X
VSLHOWHVWJHVWHUQELVLQGLHWLHIH1DFKWKLQHLQPLWGHLQHQ3XSSHQ
'XZXUGHVWVFKOlIULJXQGPDJHVVHLQ GD‰HLQ
KHUYRUVSULQJHQGHV0lXVFKHQGHUHQHVGRFKVRQVWKLHUQLFKWJLEW
GLFKHUVFKUHFNWKDWJHQXJGXVWLH‰HVWPLWGHP$UPHLQH
*ODVVFKHLEHGHV6FKUDQNVHLQXQGVFKQLWWHVWGLFKVRVHKULQGHQ
$UPGD‰+HUU:HQGHOVWHUQGHUGLUHEHQGLHQRFKLQGHQ:XQGHQ
VWHFNHQGHQ*ODVVFKHUEFKHQKHUDXVJHQRPPHQKDWPHLQWGX
KlWWHVW]HUVFKQLWWGDV*ODVHLQH$GHUHLQHQVWHLIHQ$UP
EHKDOWHQRGHUGLFKJDUYHUEOXWHQN|QQHQ*RWWVHLJHGDQNWGD‰
LFKXP0LWWHUQDFKWHUZDFKHQGXQGGLFKQRFKVRVSlWYHUPLVVHQG
DXIVWDQGXQG LQGLH:RKQVWXEHJLQJ'DODJVWGXGLFKWQHEHQ
GHP*ODVVFKUDQNRKQPlFKWLJDXIGHU(UGHXQGEOXWHWHVWVHKU
%DOGZlULFKYRU6FKUHFNDXFKRKQPlFKWLJJHZRUGHQ'DODJVWGX
QXQXQGXPGLFKKHU]HUVWUHXWHUEOLFNWHLFKYLHOHYRQ)ULW]HQV
EOHLHUQHQ6ROGDWHQXQGDQGHUH3XSSHQ]HUEURFKHQH'HYLVHQ
3IHIIHUNXFKPlQQHU1X‰NQDFNHUODJDEHUDXIGHLQHPEOXWHQGHQ
$UPHXQGQLFKWZHLWYRQGLUGHLQOLQNHU6FKXK$FK0WWHUFKHQ
0WWHUFKHQILHO0DULHHLQVHKHQ6LHZRKOGDVZDUHQMDQRFK
GLH6SXUHQYRQGHUJUR‰HQ6FKODFKW]ZLVFKHQGHQ3XSSHQXQG
0lXVHQXQGQXUGDUEHUELQLFKVRVHKUHUVFKURFNHQDOVGLH
0lXVHGHQDUPHQ1X‰NQDFNHUGHUGLH3XSSHQDUPHH
NRPPDQGLHUWHJHIDQJHQQHKPHQZROOWHQ'DZDUILFKPHLQHQ
6FKXKXQWHUGLH0lXVHXQGGDQQZHL‰LFKZHLWHUQLFKWZDV
YRUJHJDQJHQ'HU&KLUXUJXV:HQGHOVWHUQZLQNWHGHU0XWWHUPLW
GHQ$XJHQXQGGLHVHVSUDFKVHKUVDQIW]X0DULHQ/D‰HVQXUJXW
VHLQPHLQOLHEHV.LQG EHUXKLJHGLFKGLH0lXVHVLQGDOOHIRUW
XQG1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQVWHKWJHVXQGXQGOXVWLJLP*ODVVFKUDQN
1XQWUDWGHU0HGL]LQDOUDWLQV=LPPHUXQGVSUDFKODQJHPLWGHP
&KLUXUJXV:HQGHOVWHUQGDQQIKOWHHU0DULHQV3XOVXQGVLHK|UWH
ZRKOGD‰YRQHLQHP:XQGILHEHUGLH5HGHZDU6LHPX‰WHLP
%HWWHEOHLEHQXQG$U]HQHLQHKPHQXQGVRGDXHUWHHVHLQLJH7DJH
ZLHZRKOVLHDX‰HUHLQLJHP6FKPHU]DP$UPVLFKHEHQQLFKW
NUDQNXQGXQEHKDJOLFKIKOWH6LHZX‰WHGD‰1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQ
JHVXQGDXVGHU6FKODFKWVLFKJHUHWWHWKDWWHXQGHVNDPLKU
PDQFKPDOZLHLP7UDXPHYRUGD‰HUJDQ]YHUQHKPOLFKZLHZRKO
PLWVHKUZHKPWLJHU6WLPPHVSUDFK0DULHWHXHUVWH'DPH
,KQHQYHUGDQNHLFKYLHOGRFKQRFKPHKUN|QQHQ6LHIUPLFK
WXQ0DULHGDFKWHYHUJHEHQVGDUEHUQDFKZDVGDVZRKOVHLQ
N|QQWHHVILHOLKUGXUFKDXVQLFKWHLQ6SLHOHQNRQQWH0DULHJDU
QLFKWUHFKWZHJHQGHVZXQGHQ$UPVXQGZROOWHVLHOHVHQRGHU
LQGHQ%LOGHUEFKHUQEOlWWHUQVRIOLPPHUWHHVLKUVHOWVDPYRUGHQ
$XJHQXQGVLHPX‰WHGDYRQDEODVVHQ6RPX‰WHLKUQXQZRKOGLH
=HLWUHFKWKHU]OLFKODQJZHUGHQXQGVLHNRQQWHNDXPGLH
'lPPHUXQJHUZDUWHQZHLOGDQQGLH0XWWHUVLFKDQLKU%HWW
VHW]WHXQGLKUVHKUYLHO6FK|QHVYRUODVXQGHU]lKOWH(EHQKDWWH
GLH0XWWHUGLHYRU]JOLFKH*HVFKLFKWHYRP3ULQ]HQ)DNDUGLQ
YROOHQGHWDOVGLH7UHDXIJLQJXQGGHU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUPLWGHQ
:RUWHQKLQHLQWUDW1XQPX‰LFKGRFKZLUNOLFKHLQPDOVHOEVW
VHKHQZLHHVPLWGHUNUDQNHQXQGZXQGHQ0DULH]XVWHKW6RZLH
0DULHGHQ3DWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHULQVHLQHPJHOEHQ5|FNFKHQ
HUEOLFNWHNDPLKUGDV%LOGMHQHU1DFKWDOV1X‰NQDFNHUGLH
6FKODFKWZLGHUGLH0lXVHYHUORUJDUOHEHQGLJYRU$XJHQXQG
XQZLOONUOLFKULHIVLHODXWGHP2EHUJHULFKWVUDWHQWJHJHQ23DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUGXELVWUHFKWKl‰OLFKJHZHVHQLFKKDEHGLFKZRKO
JHVHKHQZLHGXDXIGHU8KUVD‰HVWXQGVLHPLWGHLQHQ)OJHOQ
EHGHFNWHVWGD‰VLHQLFKWODXWVFKODJHQVROOWHZHLOVRQVWGLH
0lXVHYHUVFKHXFKWZRUGHQZlUHQ LFKKDEHHVZRKOJHK|UWZLH
GXGHP0DXVHN|QLJULHIHVW ZDUXPNDPVWGXGHP1X‰NQDFNHU
ZDUXPNDPVWGXPLUQLFKW]X+OIHGXKl‰OLFKHU3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUELVWGXGHQQQLFKWDOOHLQVFKXOGGD‰LFKYHUZXQGHW
XQGNUDQNLP%HWWHOLHJHQPX‰"  'LH0XWWHUIUDJWHJDQ]
HUVFKURFNHQ:DVLVWGLUGHQQOLHEH0DULH"$EHUGHU3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUVFKQLWWVHKUVHOWVDPH*HVLFKWHUXQGVSUDFKPLW
VFKQDUUHQGHUHLQW|QLJHU6WLPPH3HUSHQGLNHOPX‰WHVFKQXUUHQ
 SLFNHQ ZROOWHVLFKQLFKWVFKLFNHQ 8KUHQ 8KUHQ
8KUHQSHUSHQGLNHOPVVHQVFKQXUUHQ OHLVHVFKQXUUHQ VFKODJHQ
*ORFNHQODXWNOLQJNODQJ +LQNXQG+RQNXQG+RQNXQG+DQN
3XSSHQPlGHOVHLQLFKWEDQJ VFKODJHQ*O|FNOHLQLVWJHVFKODJHQ
0DXVHN|QLJIRUW]XMDJHQNRPPWGLH(XOLPVFKQHOOHQ)OXJ 3DN
XQG3LNXQG3LNXQG3XN *O|FNOHLQELPELP 8KUHQ VFKQXUU
VFKQXUU 3HUSHQGLNHOPVVHQVFKQXUUHQ SLFNHQZROOWHVLFKQLFKW
VFKLFNHQ 6FKQDUUXQGVFKQXUUXQGSLUUXQGSXUU 0DULHVDK
GHQ3DWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUVWDUUPLWJUR‰HQ$XJHQDQZHLOHUJDQ]
DQGHUVXQGQRFKYLHOKl‰OLFKHUDXVVDKDOVVRQVWXQGPLWGHP
UHFKWHQ$UPKLQXQGKHUVFKOXJDOVZUGHUJOHLFKHLQHU
'UDKWSXSSHJH]RJHQ(VKlWWHLKURUGHQWOLFKJUDXHQN|QQHQYRU
GHP3DWHQZHQQGLH0XWWHUQLFKW]XJHJHQJHZHVHQZlUHXQG
ZHQQQLFKWHQGOLFK)ULW]GHUVLFKXQWHUGHVVHQKLQHLQJHVFKOLFKHQ
LKQPLWODXWHP*HOlFKWHUXQWHUEURFKHQKlWWH(L3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUULHI)ULW]GXELVWKHXWHZLHGHUDXFKJDU]X
SRVVLHUOLFKGXJHElUGHVWGLFKMDZLHPHLQ+DPSHOPDQQGHQLFK
OlQJVWKLQWHUGHQ2IHQJHZRUIHQ'LH0XWWHUEOLHEVHKUHUQVWKDIW
XQGVSUDFK/LHEHU+HUU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWGDVLVWMDHLQUHFKW
VHOWVDPHU6SD‰ZDVPHLQHQ6LHGHQQHLJHQWOLFK"0HLQ
+LPPHOHUZLGHUWH'UR‰HOPHLHUODFKHQGNHQQHQ6LHGHQQQLFKW
PHKUPHLQKEVFKHV8KUPDFKHUOLHGFKHQ"'DVSIOHJLFKLPPHU]X
VLQJHQEHLVROFKHQ3DWLHQWHQZLH0DULH'DPLWVHW]WHHUVLFK
VFKQHOOGLFKWDQ0DULHQV%HWWHXQGVSUDFK6HLQXUQLFKWE|VH
GD‰LFKQLFKWJOHLFKGHP0DXVHN|QLJDOOHYLHU]HKQ$XJHQ
DXVJHKDFNWDEHUHVNRQQWHQLFKWVHLQLFKZLOOGLUDXFKVWDWW
GHVVHQHLQHUHFKWH)UHXGHPDFKHQ'HU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWODQJWH
PLWGLHVHQ:RUWHQLQGLH7DVFKHXQGZDVHUQXQOHLVHOHLVH
KHUYRU]RJZDUGHU1X‰NQDFNHUGHPHUVHKUJHVFKLFNWGLH
YHUORUQHQ=lKQFKHQIHVWHLQJHVHW]WXQGGHQODKPHQ.LQQEDFNHQ
HLQJHUHQNWKDWWH0DULHMDXFK]WHODXWDXIYRU)UHXGHDEHUGLH
0XWWHUVDJWHOlFKHOQG6LHKVWGXQXQZRKOZLHJXWHV3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUPLWGHLQHP1X‰NQDFNHUPHLQW"'XPX‰WHVDEHU
GRFKHLQJHVWHKHQ0DULHXQWHUEUDFKGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWGLH
0HGL]LQDOUlWLQGXPX‰WHVDEHUGRFKHLQJHVWHKHQGD‰
1X‰NQDFNHUQLFKWHEHQ]XPEHVWHQJHZDFKVHQXQGVHLQ*HVLFKW
QLFKWHEHQVFK|Q]XQHQQHQLVW:LHVRWDQH+l‰OLFKNHLWLQVHLQH
)DPLOLHJHNRPPHQXQGYHUHUEWZRUGHQLVWGDVZLOOLFKGLUZRKO
HU]lKOHQZHQQGXHV DQK|UHQZLOOVW2GHUZHL‰WGXYLHOOHLFKW
VFKRQGLH*HVFKLFKWHYRQGHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGHU+H[H
0DXVHULQNVXQGGHPNQVWOLFKHQ8KUPDFKHU"+|UPDOILHOKLHU
)ULW]XQYHUVHKHQVHLQK|UPDO3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUGLH=lKQHKDVW
GXGHP1X‰NQDFNHUULFKWLJ HLQJHVHW]WXQGGHU.LQQEDFNHQLVW
DXFKQLFKWPHKUVRZDFNHOLJDEHUZDUXPIHKOWLKPGDV6FKZHUW
ZDUXPKDVWGXLKPNHLQ6FKZHUWXPJHKlQJW"(LHUZLGHUWHGHU
2EHUJHULFEWVUDWJDQ]XQZLOOLJGXPX‰WDQDOOHPPlNHOQXQG
WDGHOQ-XQJH:DVJHKWPLFK1X‰NQDFNHUV6FKZHUWDQLFKKDEH
LKQDP/HLEHNXULHUWPDJHUVLFKQXQVHOEVWHLQ6FKZHUWVFKDIIHQ
ZLHHUZLOO'DVLVWZDKUULHI)ULW]LVW VHLQWFKWLJHU.HUOVR
ZLUGHUVFKRQ:DIIHQ]XILQGHQZLVVHQ$OVR0DULHIXKUGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWIRUWVDJH PLUREGXGLH*HVFKLFKWHZHL‰WYRQ
GHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDW"$FKQHLQHUZLGHUWH0DULHHU]lKOH
OLHEHU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHU HU]lKOH,FKKRIIHVSUDFKGLH
0HGL]LQDOUlWLQLFKKRIIHOLHEHU+HUU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWGD‰,KUH
*HVFKLFKWHQLFKWVRJUDXOLFKVHLQZLUGZLHJHZ|KQOLFKDOOHVLVW
ZDV6LHHU]lKOHQ"0LWQLFKWHQWHXHUVWH)UDX0HGL]LQDLUlWLQ
HUZLGHUWH'UR‰HOPHLHULP*HJHQWHLOLVWGDVJDUVSD‰KDIWZDV
LFKYRU]XWUDJHQGLH(KUHKDEHQZHUGH(U]lKOHRHU]lKOHOLHEHU
3DWHVRULHIHQGLH.LQGHUXQGGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWILQJDOVRDQ
'DV0lUFKHQYRQGHUKDUWHQ1X‰
3LUOLSDWV0XWWHUZDUGLH)UDXHLQHV.|QLJVPLWKLQHLQH.|QLJLQ
XQG3LUOLSDWVHOEVWLQGHPVHOEHQ$XJHQEOLFNDOVVLHJHERUHQ
ZXUGHHLQHJHERUQH3ULQ]HVVLQ'HU.|QLJZDUDX‰HUVLFKYRU
)UHXGHEHUGDVVFK|QH7|FKWHUFKHQGDVLQGHU:LHJHODJHU
MXEHOWHODXWDXIHUWDQ]WHXQGVFKZHQNWHVLFKDXIHLQHP%HLQH
XQGVFKULHHLQ0DOEHUGDVDQGHUH+HLVD KDWPDQZDV
6FK|QHUHVMHPDOVJHVHKHQDOVPHLQ3LUOLSDWFKHQ"  $EHUDOOH
0LQLVWHU*HQHUDOHXQG3UlVLGHQWHQXQG6WDEVRIIL]LHUHVSUDQJHQ
ZLHGHU/DQGHVYDWHUDXIHLQHP%HLQHKHUXPXQGVFKULHQVHKU
1HLQQLHPDOV =XOHXJQHQZDUHVDEHUDXFKLQGHU7DWJDUQLFKW
GD‰ZRKOVRODQJHGLH:HOWVWHKWNHLQVFK|QHUHV.LQGJHERUHQ
ZXUGHDOVHEHQ3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDW,KU*HVLFKWFKHQZDUZLHYRQ
]DUWHQOLOLHQZHL‰HQXQGURVHQURWHQ6HLGHQIORFNHQJHZHEWGLH
bXJHOHLQOHEHQGLJHIXQNHOQGH$]XUHXQGHVVWDQGKEVFKGD‰
GLH/|FNFKHQVLFKLQODXWHUJOlQ]HQGHQ*ROGIDGHQNUlXVHOWHQ
'D]XKDWWH3LUOLSDWHKHQ]ZHL5HLKHQNOHLQHU3HUO]lKQFKHQDXIGLH
:HOWJHEUDFKWZRPLWVLH]ZHL6WXQGHQQDFKGHU*HEXUWGHP
5HLFKVNDQ]OHULQGHQ)LQJHUEL‰DOVHUGLH/LQHDPHQWHQlKHU
XQWHUVXFKHQZROOWHVRGD‰HUODXWDXIVFKULH2MHPLQH
$QGHUHEHKDXSWHQHUKDEH$XZHK JHVFKULHQGLH6WLPPHQ
VLQGQRFKKHXW]XWDJHGDUEHUVHKUJHWHLOW.XU]3LUOLSDWFKHQEL‰
ZLUNOLFKGHP5HLFKVNDQ]OHULQGHQ)LQJHUXQGGDVHQW]FNWH/DQG
ZX‰WHQXQGD‰DXFK*HLVW*HPWXQG9HUVWDQGLQ3LUOLSDWV
NOHLQHPHQJHOVFK|QHQ.|USHUFKHQ ZRKQH :LHJHVDJWDOOHVZDU
YHUJQJWQXUGLH.|QLJLQZDUVHKUlQJVWOLFKXQGXQUXKLJ
QLHPDQGZX‰WHZDUXP"9RU]JOLFKILHOHVDXIGD‰VLH3LUOLSDWV
:LHJHVRVRUJOLFKEHZDFKHQOLH‰$X‰HUGHPGD‰GLH7UHQYRQ
7UDEDQWHQEHVHW]WZDUHQPX‰WHQGLHEHLGHQ:lUWHULQQHQGLFKW
DQGHU:LHJHDEJHUHFKQHWQRFKVHFKVDQGHUH1DFKWIU1DFKW
ULQJVXPKHULQGHU6WXEHVLW]HQ:DVDEHUJDQ]QlUULVFKVFKLHQ
XQGZDVQLHPDQGEHJUHLIHQNRQQWHMHGHGLHVHUVHFKV
:lUWHULQQHQPX‰WHHLQHQ.DWHUDXIGHQ6FKR‰QHKPHQXQGLKQ
GLHJDQ]H1DFKWVWUHLFKHOQGD‰HULPPHUIRUW]XVSLQQHQJHQ|WLJW
ZXUGH(VLVWXQP|JOLFKGD‰LKUOLHEHQ.LQGHUHUUDWHQN|QQW
ZDUXP3LUOLSDWV0XWWHUDOOGLHVH$QVWDOWHQPDFKWHLFKZHL‰HV
DEHUXQGZLOOHVHXFKJOHLFKVDJHQ(VEHJDEVLFKGD‰HLQPDODQ
GHP+RIHYRQ3LUOLSDWV9DWHUYLHOHYRUWUHIIOLFKH.|QLJHXQGVHKU
DQJHQHKPH3ULQ]HQYHUVDPPHOWZDUHQZHVKDOEHVGHQQVHKU
JOlQ]HQGKHUJLQJXQGYLHO5LWWHUVSLHOH.RP|GLHQXQG+RIElOOH
JHJHEHQZXUGHQ'HU.|QLJXPUHFKW]X]HLJHQGD‰HVLKPDQ
*ROGXQG 6LOEHUJDUQLFKWPDQJOHZROOWHQXQHLQPDOHLQHQUHFKW
WFKWLJHQ*ULIILQGHQ.URQVFEDW]WXQXQGZDV2UGHQWOLFKHV
GDUDXIJHKHQODVVHQ(URUGQHWHGDKHU]XPDOHUYRQGHP
2EHUKRINFKHQPHLVWHULQVJHKHLPHUIDKUHQGD‰GHU+RIDVWURQRP
GLH=HLWGHV(LQVFKODFKWHQVDQJHNQGLJWHLQHQJUR‰HQ
:XUVWVFKPDXVDQZDUIVLFKLQGHQ:DJHQXQGOXGVHOEVW
VlPWOLFKH.|QLJHXQG3ULQ]HQQXUDXIHLQHQ/|IIHO6XSSHHLQXP
VLFKGHUhEHUUDVFKXQJPLWGHP.|VWOLFKHQ]XHUIUHXHQ1XQ
VSUDFKHUVHKUIUHXQGOLFK]XU)UDX.|QLJLQ'LU LVWMDVFKRQ
EHNDQQW/LHEFKHQZLHLFKGLH:UVWHJHUQKDEH 'LH.|QLJLQ
ZX‰WHVFKRQZDVHUGDPLWVDJHQZROOWHHVKLH‰QlPOLFKQLFKWV
DQGHUVDOVVLHVHOEVWVROOWHVLFKZLHVLHDXFKVRQVWVFKRQJHWDQ
GHPVHKUQW]OLFKHQ*HVFKlIWGHV:XUVWPDFKHQVXQWHU]LHKHQ
'HU2EHUVFKDW]PHLVWHUPX‰WHVRJOHLFKGHQJUR‰HQJROGQHQ
:XUVWNHVVHOXQGGLHVLOEHUQHQ.DVVHUROOHQ]XU.FKHDEOLHIHUQHV
ZXUGHHLQJUR‰HV)HXHUYRQ6DQGHOKRO]DQJHPDFKWGLH.|QLJLQ
EDQGLKUHGDPDVWHQH.FKHQVFKU]HXPXQGEDOGGDPSIWHQDXV
GHP .HVVHOGLHV‰HQ:RKOJHUFKHGHU:XUVWVXSSH%LVLQGHQ
6WDDWVUDWGUDQJGHUDQPXWLJH*HUXFKGHU.|QLJYRQLQQHUHP
(QW]FNHQHUID‰WNRQQWHVLFKQLFKWKDOWHQ0LW(UODXEQLVPHLQH
+HUUHQ ULHIHUVSUDQJVFKQHOOQDFKGHU.FKHXPDUPWHGLH
.|QLJLQUKUWHHWZDVPLWGHPJROGQHQ6]HSWHULQGHP.HVVHO
XQGNHKUWHGDQQEHUXKLJWLQGHQ6WDDWVUDW]XUFN(EHQQXQZDU
GHUZLFKWLJH3XQNWJHNRPPHQGD‰GHU6SHFNLQ:UIHO
JHVFKQLWWHQXQGDXIVLOEHUQHQ5RVWHQJHU|VWHWZHUGHQVROOWH'LH
+RIGDPHQWUDWHQDEZHLOGLH.|QLJLQGLHV*HVFKlIWDXVWUHXHU
$QKlQJOLFKNHLWXQG(KUIXUFKWYRUGHPN|QLJOLFKHQ*HPDKODOOHLQ
XQWHUQHKPHQZROOWH$OOHLQVRZLHGHU6SHFN]XEUDWHQDQILQJOLH‰
VLFKHLQJDQ]IHLQHVZLVSHUQGHV6WLPPFKHQYHUQHKPHQ9RQ
GHP%UlWOHLQJLEPLUDXFK6FKZHVWHU ZLOODXFKVFKPDXVHQELQ
MDDXFK.|QLJLQ JLEPLUYRQGHP%UlWOHLQ  'LH.|QLJLQZX‰WH
ZRKOGD‰HV)UDX0DXVHULQNVZDUGLHDOVRVSUDFK)UDX
0DXVHULQNVZRKQWHVFKRQVHLWYLHOHQ-DKUHQLQGHV.|QLJV3DODVW
6LHEHKDXSWHWHPLWGHUN|QLJOLFKHQ)DPLOLHYHUZDQGWXQGVHOEVW
.|QLJLQLQGHP5HLFKH0DXVROLHQ]XVHLQGHVKDOEKDWWHVLHDXFK
HLQHJUR‰H+RIKDOWXQJXQWHUGHP+HUGH'LH.|QLJLQZDUHLQH
JXWHPLOGWlWLJH)UDXZROOWHVLHGDKHUDXFKVRQVW)UDX0DXVHULQNV
QLFKWJHUDGHDOV.|QLJLQXQGDOVLKUH6FKZHVWHUDQHUNHQQHQVR
J|QQWHVLHLKUGRFKYRQ+HU]HQDQGHPIHVWOLFKHQ7DJHGLH
6FKPDXVHUHLXQGULHI.RPPWQXUKHUYRU)UDX0DXVHULQNV,KU
P|JHWLPPHUKLQYRQPHLQHP6SHFNJHQLH‰HQ 'DNDPDXFK)UDX
0DXVHULQNVVHKUVFKQHOOXQGOXVWLJKHUYRUJHKSIWVSUDQJDXIGHQ
+HUGXQGHUJULIIPLWGHQ]LHUOLFKHQNOHLQHQ3I|WFKHQHLQ
6WFNFKHQ6SHFNQDFKGHPDQGHUQGDVLKUGLH.|QLJLQKLQODQJWH
$EHUQXQNDPHQDOOH*HYDWWHUQXQG0XKPHQGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNV
KHUYRUJHVSUXQJHQXQGDXFKVRJDULKUHVLHEHQ6|KQHUHFKW
XQDUWLJH6FKOLQJHOGLHPDFKWHQVLFKEHUGHQ6SHFNKHUXQG
QLFKWZHKUHQNRQQWHLKQHQGLHHUVFKURFNHQH.|QLJLQ=XP*OFN
NDPGLH2EHUKRIPHLVWHULQGD]XXQGYHUMDJWHGLH]XGULQJOLFKHQ
*lVWHVRGD‰QRFKHWZDV6SHFNEULJEOLHEZHOFKHUQDFK
$QZHLVXQJGHVKHUEHLJHUXIHQHQ+RIPDWKHPDWLNHUVVHKUNQVWOLFK
DXIDOOH:UVWHYHUWHLOWZXUGH3DXNHQXQG7URPSHWHQ
HUVFKDOOWHQDOOHDQZHVHQGHQ3RWHQWDWHQXQG3ULQ]HQ]RJHQLQ
JOlQ]HQGHQ)HLHUNOHLGHUQ]XP7HLODXIZHL‰HQ=HOWHUQ]XP7HLOLQ
NULVWDOOQHQ.XWVFKHQ]XP:XUVWVFKPDXVH'HU.|QLJHPSILQJVLH
PLWKHU]OLFKHU)UHXQGOLFKNHLWXQG+XOGXQGVHW]WHVLFKGDQQDOV
/DQGHVKHUUPLW.URQXQG6]HSWHUDQJHWDQDQGLH6SLW]HGHV
7LVFKHV6FKRQLQGHU6WDWLRQGHU/HEHUZUVWHVDKPDQZLHGHU
.|QLJLPPHUPHKUXQGPHKUHUEOD‰WH ZLHHUGLH$XJHQJHQ
+LPPHOKRE OHLVH6HXI]HUHQWIORKHQVHLQHU%UXVW HLQJHZDOWLJHU
6FKPHU]VFKLHQLQVHLQHP,QQHUQ]XZKOHQ'RFKLQGHU6WDWLRQ
GHU%OXWZUVWHVDQNHUODXWVFKOXFK]HQGXQGlFK]HQGLQGHQ
/HKQVHVVHO]XUFNHUKLHOWEHLGH+lQGHYRUV *HVLFKWHU
MDPPHUWHXQGVW|KQWH $OOHVVSUDQJDXIYRQGHU7DIHOGHU
/HLEDU]WEHPKWHVLFKYHUJHEHQVGHVXQJOFNOLFKHQ.|QLJV3XOV
]XHUIDVVHQHLQWLHIHUQDPHQORVHU-DPPHUVFKLHQLKQ]X
]HUUHL‰HQ(QGOLFKHQGOLFKQDFKYLHOHP=XUHGHQQDFK
$QZHQGXQJ VWDUNHU0LWWHODOVGDVLQGJHEUDQQWH)HGHUSRVHQXQG
GHUJOHLFKHQVFKLHQGHU.|QLJHWZDV]XVLFKVHOEVW]XNRPPHQHU
VWDPPHOWHNDXPK|UEDUGLH:RUWH =XZHQLJ6SHFN 'DZDUI
VLFKGLH.|QLJLQWURVWORVLKP]X)‰HQXQGVFKOXFK]WH 2PHLQ
DUPHUXQJOFNOLFKHUN|QLJOLFKHU*HPDKO 2ZHOFKHQ6FKPHU]
PX‰WHQ6LHGXOGHQ $EHUVHKHQ6LHKLHUGLH6FKXOGLJH]X,KUHQ
)‰HQ VWUDIHQVWUDIHQ6LHVLHKDUW DFK )UDX0DXVHULQNVPLW
LKUHQVLHEHQ6|KQHQ*HYDWWHUQXQG0XKPHQKDWGHQ6SHFN
DXIJHIUHVVHQXQG GDPLWILHOGLH.|QLJLQUFNOLQJVEHULQ
2KQPDFKW$EHUGHU.|QLJVSUDQJYROOHU=RUQDXIXQGULHIODXW
2EHUKRIPHLVWHULQZLHJLQJGDV]X" 'LH2EHUKRIPHLVWHULQ
HU]lKOWHVRYLHOVLHZX‰WHXQGGHU.|QLJEHVFKOR‰5DFKH]X
QHKPHQDQGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQGLKUHU)DPLOLHGLHLKPGHQ
6SHFNDXVGHU:XUVWZHJJHIUHVVHQKDWWHQ'HU*HKHLPH
6WDDWVUDWZXUGHEHUXIHQPDQEHVFKOR‰GHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVGHQ
3UR]H‰]XPDFKHQXQGLKUHVlPWOLFKH*WHUHLQ]X]LHKHQGDDEHU
GHU.|QLJPHLQWHGD‰VLHXQWHUGHVVHQLKPGRFKQRFKLPPHUGHQ
6SHFNZHJIUHVVHQN|QQWHVRZXUGHGLHJDQ]H6DFKHGHP
+RIXKUPDFKHUXQG$UNDQLVWHQEHUWUDJHQ'LHVHU0DQQGHU
HEHQVRKLH‰DOVLFKQlPOLFK&KULVWLDQ(OLDV'UR‰HOPHLHU
YHUVSUDFKGXUFKHLQHJDQ]EHVRQGHUVVWDDWVNOXJH2SHUDWLRQGLH
)UDX0DXVHULQNV PLWLKUHU)DPLOLHDXIHZLJH=HLWHQDXVGHP
3DODVW]XYHUWUHLEHQ(UHUIDQGDXFKZLUNOLFKNOHLQHVHKU
NQVWOLFKH0DVFKLQHQLQGLHDQHLQHP)lGFKHQJHEUDWHQHU6SHFN
JHWDQZXUGHXQGGLH'UR‰HOPHLHUULQJVXPGLH:RKQXQJGHU
)UDX6SHFNIUHVVHULQDXIVWHOOWH)UDX0DXVHULQNVZDUYLHO]XZHLVH
XPQLFKW'UR‰HOPHLHUV/LVWHLQ]XVHKHQDEHUDOOHLKUH:DUQXQJHQ
DOOHLKUH9RUVWHOOXQJHQKDOIHQQLFKWVYRQGHPV‰HQ*HUXFKGHV
JHEUDWHQHQ6SHFNVYHUORFNWJLQJHQDOOHVLHEHQ6|KQHXQGYLHOH
YLHOH*HYDWWHUQXQG0XKPHQGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVLQ
'UR‰HOPHLHUV0DVFKLQHQKLQHLQXQGZXUGHQDOVVLHHEHQGHQ
6SHFNZHJQDVFKHQZROOWHQGXUFKHLQSO|W]OLFKYRUIDOOHQGHV*LWWHU
JHIDQJHQGDQQDEHULQGHU.FKHVHOEVWVFKPDFKYROO
KLQJHULFKWHW)UDX0DXVHULQNVYHUOLH‰PLWLKUHPNOHLQHQ+lXIFKHQ
GHQ2UWGHV6FKUHFNHQV*UDP9HU]ZHLIOXQJ5DFKHHUIOOWHLKUH
%UXVW'HU+RIMXEHOWHVHKUDEHUGLH.|QLJLQZDUEHVRUJWZHLOVLH
GLH*HPWVDUWGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVNDQQWHXQGZRKOZX‰WHGD‰
VLHGHQ7RGLKUHU6|KQHXQG9HUZDQGWHQQLFKWXQJHUlFKW
KLQJHKHQODVVHQZUGH,QGHU7DWHUVFKLHQDXFK)UDX
0DXVHULQNVDOVGLH.|QLJLQHEHQIUGHQN|QLJOLFKHQ*HPDKO
HLQHQ/XQJHQPXVEHUHLWHWHGHQHUVHKUJHUQD‰XQGVSUDFK
0HLQH6|KQH PHLQH*HYDWWHUQXQG0XKPHQVLQGHUVFKODJHQ
JLEZRKODFKW)UDX.|QLJLQGD‰0DXVHN|QLJLQGLUQLFKWGHLQ
3ULQ]H‰FKHQHQW]ZHLEHL‰W JLEZRKODFKW 'DUDXIYHUVFKZDQGVLH
ZLHGHUXQGOLH‰VLFKQLFKWPHKUVHKHQDEHUGLH.|QLJLQZDUVR
HUVFKURFNHQGD‰VLHGHQ/XQJHQPXVLQV)HXHUIDOOHQOLH‰XQG
]XP]ZHLWHQPDOYHUGDUE)UDX0DXVHULQNVGHP.|QLJHHLQH
/LHEOLQJVVSHLVHZRUEHUHUVHKU]RUQLJZDU 1XQLVW VDEHU
JHQXJIUKHXWHDEHQGNQIWLJGDVEULJH

6RVHKUDXFK0DULHGLHEHLGHU*HVFKLFKWHLKUHJDQ]HLJQHQ
*HGDQNHQKDWWHGHQ3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUEDWGRFKQXUMD
ZHLWHU]XHU]lKOHQVROLH‰HUVLFKGRFKQLFKWHUELWWHQVRQGHUQ
VSUDQJDXIVSUHFKHQG=XYLHODXIHLQPDOLVWXQJHVXQGPRUJHQ
GDVEULJH(EHQDOVGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWLP%HJULIIVWDQG]XU
7UKLQDXV]XVFKUHLWHQIUDJWH)ULW]$EHUVDJPDO3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHULVW VGHQQZLUNOLFKZDKUGD‰GXGLH0DXVHIDOOHQ
HUIXQGHQKDVW":LHNDQQPDQQXUVRDOEHUQIUDJHQULHIGLH
0XWWHUDEHUGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWOlFKHOWHVHKUVHOWVDPXQG
VSUDFKOHLVH%LQLFKGHQQQLFKWHLQNQVWOLFKHU8KUPDFKHUXQG
VROOWQLFKWHLQPDO0DXVHIDOOHQHUILQGHQN|QQHQ
)RUWVHW]XQJGHV0lUFKHQVYRQGHUKDUWHQ
1X‰
1XQZL‰WLKUZRKO.LQGHUVRIXKUGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW
'UR‰HOPHLHUDPQlFKVWHQ$EHQGHIRUWQXQZL‰WLKUZRKO.LQGHU
ZDUXPGLH.|QLJLQGDVZXQGHUVFK|QH3ULQ]H‰FKHQ3LUOLSDWVR
VRUJOLFKEHZDFKHQOLH‰0X‰WHVLHQLFKWIUFKWHQGD‰)UDX
0DXVHULQNVLKUH'URKXQJHUIOOHQZLHGHUNRPPHQXQGGDV
3ULQ]H‰FKHQWRWEHL‰HQZUGH"'UR‰HOPHLHUV0DVFKLQHQKDOIHQ
JHJHQGLHNOXJHXQGJHZLW]LJWH)UDX0DXVHULQNVJDQ]XQGJDU
QLFKWVXQGQXUGHU$VWURQRPGHV+RIHVGHU]XJOHLFK*HKHLPHU
2EHU]HLFKHQ XQG6WHUQGHXWHUZDUZROOWHZLVVHQGD‰GLH)DPLOLH
GHV.DWHUV6FKQXUULPVWDQGHVHLQZHUGHGLH)UDX0DXVHULQNVYRQ
GHU:LHJHDE]XKDOWHQGHPQDFKJHVFKDKHVDOVRGD‰MHGHGHU
:lUWHULQQHQHLQHQGHU6|KQHMHQHU)DPLOLHGLHEULJHQVEHL+RIH
DOV*HKHLPH/HJDWLRQVUlWHDQJHVWHOOWZDUHQDXIGHP6FKR‰H
KDOWHQXQGGXUFKVFKLFNOLFKHV.UDXHQLKPGHQEHVFKZHUOLFKHQ
6WDDWVGLHQVW]XYHUV‰HQVXFKHQPX‰WH(VZDUHLQPDOVFKRQ
0LWWHUQDFKWDOVGLHHLQHGHUEHLGHQ*HKHLPHQ2EHUZlUWHULQQHQ
GLHGLFKWDQGHU:LHJHVD‰HQZLHDXVWLHIHP6FKODIHDXIIXKU
$OOHVUXQGXPKHUODJYRP6FKODIHEHIDQJHQ NHLQ6FKQXUUHQ
WLHIH7RWHQVWLOOHLQGHUPDQGDV3LFNHQGHV+RO]ZXUPVYHUQDKP
 GRFKZLHZDUGGHU*HKHLPHQ2EHUZlUWHULQDOV VLHGLFKWYRUVLFK
HLQHJUR‰HVHKUKl‰OLFKH0DXVHUEOLFNWHGLHDXIGHQ+LQWHUI‰HQ
DXIJHULFKWHWVWDQGXQGGHQIDWDOHQ.RSIDXIGDV*HVLFKWGHU
3ULQ]HVVLQJHOHJWKDWWH0LWHLQHP6FKUHLGHV(QWVHW]HQVVSUDQJ
VLHDXIDOOHVHUZDFKWHDEHULQGHP$XJHQEOLFNUDQQWH)UDX
0DXVHULQNV QLHPDQGDQGHUVZDUGLHJUR‰H0DXVDQ3LUOLSDWV
:LHJH VFKQHOOQDFKGHU(FNHGHV=LPPHUV'LH/HJDWLRQVUlWH
VWU]WHQLKUQDFKDEHU]XVSlW GXUFKHLQH5LW]HLQGHP
)X‰ERGHQGHV=LPPHUVZDUVLHYHUVFKZXQGHQ3LUOLSDWFKHQ
HUZDFKWH YRQGHP5XPRUXQGZHLQWHVHKUNOlJOLFK'DQNGHP
+LPPHO ULHIHQGLH:lUWHULQQHQVLHOHEW 'RFKZLHJUR‰ZDULKU
6FKUHFNHQDOVVLHKLQEOLFNWHQQDFK3LUOLSDWFKHQXQG
ZDKPDKPHQZDVDXVGHPVFK|QHQ]DUWHQ.LQGHJHZRUGHQ6WDWW
GHVZHL‰XQGURWHQJROGJHORFNWHQ(QJHOVN|SIFKHQVVD‰HLQ
XQI|UPOLFKHUGLFNHU.RSIDXIHLQHPZLQ]LJNOHLQHQ
]XVDPPHQJHNUPPWHQ/HLEHGLHD]XUEODXHQbXJHOHLQKDWWHQ
VLFKYHUZDQGHOWLQJUQHKHUYRUVWHKHQGHVWDUUEOLFNHQGH$XJHQ
XQGGDV0QGFKHQKDWWHVLFKYHU]RJHQYRQHLQHP2KU]XP
DQGHUQ'LH.|QLJLQZROOWHYHUJHKHQLQ:HKNODJHQXQG-DPPHU
XQGGHV.|QLJV6WXGLHU]LPPHUPX‰WHPLWZDWWLHUWHQ7DSHWHQ
DXVJHVFKODJHQZHUGHQZHLOHUHLQ0DOEHUGDVDQGHUHPLWGHP
.RSIJHJHQGLH:DQGUDQQWHXQGGDEHLPLWVHKUMlPPHUOLFKHU
6WLPPHULHI2LFKXQJOFNVHOLJHU0RQDUFK  (UNRQQWH]ZDU
QXQHLQVHKHQGD‰HVEHVVHUJHZHVHQZlUHGLH:UVWHRKQH
6SHFN]XHVVHQXQGGLH)UDX0DXVHULQNVPLWLKUHU6LSSVFKDIW
XQWHUGHP+HUGHLQ5XKH]XODVVHQGDUDQGDFKWHDEHU3LUOLSDWV
N|QLJOLFKHU9DWHUQLFKWVRQGHUQHUVFKREHLQPDODOOH6FKXOGDXI
GHQ+RIXKUPDFKHUXQG$UNDQLVWHQ&KULVWLDQ(OLDV'UR‰HOPHLHUDXV
1UQEHUJ'HVKDOEHUOLH‰HUGHQZHLVHQ%HIHKO'UR‰HOPHLHUKDEH
ELQQHQYLHU:RFKHQGLH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWLQGHQYRULJHQ=XVWDQG
KHU]XVWHOOHQRGHUZHQLJVWHQVHLQEHVWLPPWHVXQWUJOLFKHV0LWWHO
DQ]XJHEHQZLHGLHV]XEHZHUNVWHOOLJHQVHLZLGULJHQIDOOVHUGHP
VFKPDFKYROOHQ7RGHXQWHUGHP%HLOGHV+HQNHUVYHUIDOOHQVHLQ
VROOH'UR‰HOPHLHUHUVFKUDNQLFKWZHQLJLQGHVVHQYHUWUDXWHHU
EDOGVHLQHU.XQVWXQGVHLQHP*OFNXQGVFKULWWVRJOHLFK]XGHU
HUVWHQ2SHUDWLRQGLHLKPQW]OLFKVFKLHQ(UQDKP3ULQ]H‰FKHQ
3LUOLSDWVHKUJHVFKLFNWDXVHLQDQGHUVFKURELKU+lQGFKHQXQG
)‰FKHQDEXQGEHVDKVRJOHLFKGLHLQQHUH6WUXNWXUDEHUGDIDQG
HUOHLGHUGD‰GLH3ULQ]HVVLQMHJU|‰HUGHVWRXQI|UPOLFKHUZHUGHQ
ZUGHXQGZX‰WHVLFKQLFKW]XUDWHQQLFKW]XKHOIHQ(UVHW]WH
GLH3ULQ]HVVLQEHKXWVDPZLHGHU]XVDPPHQXQGYHUVDQNDQLKUHU
:LHJHGLHHUQLHYHUODVVHQGXUIWHLQ6FKZHUPXW

6FKRQZDUGLHYLHUWH:RFKHDQJHJDQJHQ MDEHUHLWV0LWWZRFKDOV
GHU.|QLJPLW]RUQIXQNHOQGHQ$XJHQKLQHLQEOLFNWHXQGPLWGHP
6]HSWHUGURKHQGULHI&KULVWLDQ(OLDV'UR‰HOPHLHUNXULHUHGLH
3ULQ]HVVLQRGHUGXPX‰WVWHUEHQ 'UR‰HOPHLHUILQJDQELWWHUOLFK
]XZHLQHQDEHU3ULQ]H‰FKHQ3LUOLSDWNQDFNWHYHUJQJW1VVH
=XPHUVWHQPDOILHOGHP$UNDQLVWHQ3LUOLSDWVXQJHZ|KQOLFKHU
$SSHWLWQDFK1VVHQXQGGHU8PVWDQGDXIGD‰VLHPLW=lKQFKHQ
]XU:HOWJHNRPPHQ,QGHU7DWKDWWHVLHJOHLFKQDFKGHU
9HUZDQGOXQJVRODQJHJHVFKULHHQELVLKU]XIlOOLJHLQH1X‰
YRUNDPGLHVLHVRJOHLFKDXINQDFNWHGHQ.HUQD‰XQGGDQQUXKLJ
ZXUGH6HLWGHU=HLWIDQGHQGLH:lUWHULQQHQQLFKWVJHUDWHQDOV
LKU1VVH]XEULQJHQ2KHLOLJHU,QVWLQNWGHU1DWXUHZLJ
XQHUIRUVFKOLFKH6\PSDWKLHDOOHU:HVHQ ULHI-RKDQQ(OLDV
'UR‰HOPHLHUDXVGX]HLJVWPLUGLH3IRUWH]XP*HKHLPQLVLFKZLOO
DQNORSIHQXQGVLHZLUGVLFK|IIQHQ (UEDWVRJOHLFKXPGLH
(UODXEQLVPLWGHP+RIDVWURQRPVSUHFKHQ]XN|QQHQXQGZXUGH
PLWVWDUNHU:DFKHKLQJHIKUW%HLGH+HUUHQXPDUPWHQVLFKXQWHU
YLHOHQ7UlQHQGDVLH]lUWOLFKH)UHXQGHZDUHQ]RJHQVLFKGDQQLQ
HLQJHKHLPHV.DELQHWW]XUFNXQGVFKOXJHQYLHOH%FKHUQDFK
GLHYRQGHP,QVWLQNWYRQGHQ6\PSDWKLHQXQG$QWLSDWKLHQXQG
DQGHUQJHKHLPQLVYROOHQ'LQJHQKDQGHOWHQ'LH1DFKWEUDFK
KHUHLQGHU+RIDVWURQRPVDKQDFKGHQ6WHUQHQXQGVWHOOWHPLW
+OIHGHVDXFKKLHULQVHKUJHVFKLFNWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUVGDV
+RURVNRSGHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDW'DVZDUHLQHJUR‰H0KHGHQQ
GLH/LQLHQYHUZLUUWHQVLFKLPPHUPHKUXQGPHKUHQGOLFKDEHU
ZHOFKH)UHXGHHQGOLFKODJHVNODUYRULKQHQGD‰GLH3ULQ]HVVLQ
3LUOLSDWXPGHQ=DXEHUGHUVLHYHUKl‰OLFKW]XO|VHQXQGXP
ZLHGHUVRVFK|Q]XZHUGHQDOVYRUKHUQLFKWV]XWXQKlWWHDOV
GHQV‰HQ.HUQGHU1X‰.UDNDWXN]XJHQLH‰HQ

'LH1X‰.UDNDWXNKDWWHHLQHVROFKHKDUWH6FKDOHGD‰HLQH
DFKWXQGYLHU]LJSIQGLJH.DQRQHGDUEHUZHJIDKUHQNRQQWHRKQH
VLH]X]HUEUHFKHQ'LHVHKDUWH1X‰PX‰WHDEHUYRQHLQHP0DQQH
GHUQRFKQLHUDVLHUWZRUGHQXQGGHUQLHPDOV6WLHIHOQJHWUDJHQ
YRUGHU3ULQ]HVVLQDXIJHELVVHQXQGLKUYRQLKPPLWJHVFKORVVHQHQ
$XJHQGHU.HUQGDUJHUHLFKWZHUGHQ(UVWQDFKGHPHUVLHEHQ
6FKULWWHUFNZlUWVJHJDQJHQRKQH]XVWROSHUQGXUIWHGHUMXQJH
0DQQZLHGHUGLH$XJHQHUVFKOLH‰HQ'UHL7DJHXQGGUHL1lFKWH
KDWWH'UR‰HOPHLHUPLWGHP$VWURQRPHQXQXQWHUEURFKHQ
JHDUEHLWHWXQGHVVD‰JHUDGHGHV6RQQDEHQGVGHU.|QLJEHLGHP
0LWWDJVWLVFKDOV'UR‰HOPHLHUGHU6RQQWDJLQDOOHU)UKHJHN|SIW
ZHUGHQVROOWHYROOHU)UHXGHXQG-XEHOKLQHLQVWU]WHXQGGDV
JHIXQGHQH0LWWHOGHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGLHYHUORUHQH6FK|QKHLW
ZLHGHU]XJHEHQYHUNQGHWH'HU.|QLJXPDUPWHLKQPLWKHIWLJHP
:RKOZROOHQYHUVSUDFKLKPHLQHQGLDPDQWHQHQ'HJHQYLHU2UGHQ
XQG]ZHLQHXH6RQQWDJVU|FNH*OHLFKQDFK7LVFKH VHW]WHHU
IUHXQGOLFKKLQ]XVROOHVDQV:HUNJHKHQVRUJHQ6LHWHXUHU
$UNDQLVWGD‰GHUMXQJHXQUDVLHUWH0DQQLQ6FKXKHQPLWGHU1X‰
.UDNDWXNJHK|ULJEHLGHU+DQGVHLXQGODVVHQ6LHLKQYRUKHU
NHLQHQ:HLQWULQNHQGDPLWHUQLFKWVWROSHUWZHQQHUVLHEHQ
6FKULWWHUFNZlUWVJHKWZLHHLQ.UHEVQDFKKHUNDQQHU
HUNOHFNOLFKVDXIHQ 'UR‰HOPHLHUZXUGHEHUGLHVH5HGHGHV
.|QLJVVHKUEHVWU]WXQGQLFKWRKQH=LWWHUQXQG=DJHQEUDFKWH
HUHVVWDPPHOQGKHUDXVGD‰GDV0LWWHO]ZDUJHIXQGHQZlUH
EHLGHVGLH1X‰.UDNDWXNXQGGHUMXQJH0DQQ]XP$XIEHL‰HQ
GHUVHOEHQDEHUHUVWJHVXFKWZHUGHQP‰WHQZREHLHVQRFK
REHQHLQ]ZHLIHOKDIWEOLHEHRE1X‰XQG1X‰NQDFNHUMHPDOV
JHIXQGHQZHUGHQGUIWHQ+RFKHU]UQWVFKZDQJGHU.|QLJGHQ
6]HSWHUEHUGDVJHNU|QWH+DXSWXQGVFKULHPLWHLQHU
/|ZHQVWLPPH6REOHLEWHVEHLGHP.|SIHQ (LQ*OFNZDUHVIU
GHQLQ$QJVWXQG1RWYHUVHW]WHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUGD‰GHP.|QLJH
GDV(VVHQJHUDGHGHQ7DJVHKUZRKOJHVFKPHFNWKDWWHHUPLWKLQ
LQGHUJXWHQ/DXQHZDUYHUQQIWLJHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQ*HK|U]X
JHEHQDQGHQHQHVGLHJUR‰PWLJHXQGYRQ'UR‰HOPHLHUV
6FKLFNVDOJHUKUWH.|QLJLQQLFKWPDQJHOQ OLH‰'UR‰HOPHLHUID‰WH
0XWXQGVWHOOWH]XOHW]WYRUGD‰HUGRFKHLJHQWOLFKGLH$XIJDEH
GDV0LWWHOZRGXUFKGLH3ULQ]HVVLQJHKHLOWZHUGHQN|QQH]X
QHQQHQJHO|VWXQGVHLQ/HEHQJHZRQQHQKDEH'HU.|QLJ
QDQQWHGDVGXPPH$XVUHGHQXQGHLQIlOWLJHQ6FKQLFNVFKQDFN
EHVFKOR‰DEHUHQGOLFKQDFKGHPHUHLQ*OlVFKHQ0DJHQZDVVHU]X
VLFKJHQRPPHQGD‰EHLGHGHU8KUPDFKHUXQGGHU$VWURQRP
VLFKDXIGLH%HLQHPDFKHQXQGQLFKWDQGHUVDOVPLWGHU1X‰
.UDNDWXNLQGHU7DVFKHZLHGHUNHKUHQVROOWHQ'HU0DQQ]XP
$XIEHL‰HQGHUVHOEHQVROOWHZLHHVGLH.|QLJLQYHUPLWWHOWHGXUFK
PHKUPDOLJHV(LQUFNHQHLQHU$XIIRUGHUXQJLQHLQKHLPLVFKHXQG
DXVZlUWLJH=HLWXQJHQXQGOQWHOOLJHQ]%OlWWHUKHUEHLJHVFKDIIW
ZHUGHQ 'HU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWEUDFKKLHUZLHGHUDEXQG
YHUVSUDFKGHQDQGHUQ$EHQGGDVEULJH]XHU]lKOHQ
%HVFKOX‰GHV0lUFKHQVYRQGHUKDUWHQ1X‰
$PDQGHUQ$EHQGHVRZLHNDXPGLH/LFKWHUDQJHVWHFNWZRUGHQ
IDQGVLFK3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUZLUNOLFKZLHGHUHLQXQGHU]lKOWHDOVR
ZHLWHU'UR‰HOPHLHUXQGGHU+RIDVWURQRPZDUHQVFKRQIQI]HKQ
-DKUHXQWHUZHJVRKQHGHU1X‰.UDNDWXNDXIGLH6SXUJHNRPPHQ
]XVHLQ:RVLHEHUDOOZDUHQZHOFKHVRQGHUEDUHVHOWVDPH'LQJH
LKQHQZLGHUIXKUHQGDYRQN|QQWLFKHXFKLKU.LQGHUYLHU:RFKHQ
ODQJHU]lKOHQLFKZLOOHVDEHUQLFKWWXQVRQGHUQQXUJOHLFK
VDJHQGD‰'UR‰HOPHLHULQVHLQHUWLHIHQ%HWUEQLV]XOHW]WHLQH
VHKUJUR‰H6HKQVXFKWQDFKVHLQHUOLHEHQ9DWHUVWDGW1UQEHUJ
HPSIDQG*DQ]EHVRQGHUVEHUILHOLKQGLHVH6HKQVXFKWDOVHU
JHUDGHHLQPDOPLWVHLQHP)UHXQGHPLWWHQLQHLQHPJUR‰HQ:DOGH
LQ$VLHQHLQ3IHLIFKHQ.QDVWHUUDXFKWH2VFK|QH VFK|QH
9DWHUVWDGW1UQEHUJ VFK|QH6WDGWZHUGLFKQLFKWJHVHKHQKDW
PDJHUDXFKYLHOJHUHLVWVHLQQDFK/RQGRQ3DULVXQG
3HWHUZDUGHLQLVWLKPGDV+HU]GRFKQLFKWDXIJHJDQJHQPX‰HU
GRFKVWHWVQDFKGLUYHUODQJHQ QDFKGLUR1UQEHUJVFK|QH
6WDGWGLHVFK|QH+lXVHUPLW)HQVWHUQKDW  $OV'UR‰HOPHLHUVR
VHKUZHKPWLJNODJWHZXUGHGHU$VWURQRPYRQWLHIHP0LWOHLGHQ
HUJULIIHQXQGILQJVRMlPPHUOLFK]XKHXOHQDQGD‰PDQHVZHLW
XQGEUHLWLQ$VLHQK|UHQNRQQWH 'RFKID‰WHHUVLFKZLHGHU
ZLVFKWHVLFKGLH7UlQHQDXVGHQ$XJHQXQGIUDJWH$EHU
ZHUWJHVFKlW]WHU.ROOHJHZDUXPVLW]HQZLUKLHUXQGKHXOHQ"
ZDUXPJHKHQZLUQLFKWQDFK1UQEHUJLVW VGHQQQLFKWJlQ]OLFK
HJDOZRXQGZLHZLUGLHIDWDOH1X‰.UDNDWXNVXFKHQ" 'DVLVW
DXFKZDKU HUZLGHUWH'UR‰HOPHLHUJHWU|VWHW%HLGHVWDQGHQ
DOVEDOGDXINORSIWHQGLH3IHLIHQDXVXQGJLQJHQVFKQXUJHUDGHLQ
HLQHP6WULFKIRUWDXVGHP:DOGHPLWWHQLQ$VLHQQDFK1UQEHUJ
.DXPZDUHQVLHGRUWDQJHNRPPHQVROLHI'UR‰HOPHLHUVFKQHOO]X
VHLQHP9HWWHUGHP3XSSHQGUHFKVOHU/DFNLHUHUXQG9HUJROGHU
&KULVWRSK=DFKDULDV'UR‰HOPHLHUGHQHULQYLHOHQYLHOHQ-DKUHQ
QLFKWPHKUJHVHKHQ'HPHU]lKOWHQXQGHU8KUPDFKHUGLHJDQ]H
*HVFKLFKWHYRQGHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQG
GHU1X‰.UDNDWXNVRGD‰GHUHLQ0DOEHUGDVDQGHUHGLH+lQGH
]XVDPPHQVFKOXJXQGYROO(UVWDXQHQDXVULHI(L9HWWHU9HWWHU
ZDVVLQGGDVIUZXQGHUEDUH'LQJH 'UR‰HOPHLHUHU]lKOWHZHLWHU
YRQGHQ$EHQWHXHUQVHLQHUZHLWHQ5HLVHZLHHU]ZHL-DKUHEHL
GHP'DWWHON|QLJ]XJHEUDFKWZLHHUYRP0DQGHOIUVWHQVFKQ|GH
DEJHZLHVHQZLHHUEHLGHUQDWXUIRUVFKHQGHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWLQ
(LFKKRUQVKDXVHQYHUJHEHQVDQJHIUDJWNXU]ZLHHVLKPEHUDOO
PL‰OXQJHQVHLDXFKQXUHLQH6SXUYRQGHU1X‰.UDNDWXN]X
HUKDOWHQ:lKUHQGGLHVHU(U]lKOXQJKDWWH&KULVWRSK=DFKDULDV
RIWPDOVPLWGHQ)LQJHUQJHVFKQLSSW VLFKDXIHLQHP)X‰H
KHUXPJHGUHKW PLWGHU=XQJHJHVFKQDO]W GDQQJHUXIHQ +P
KP , (L 2 GDVZlUHGHU7HXIHO  (QGOLFKZDUIHU0W]HXQG
3HUFNHLQGLH+|KHXPKDOVWHGHQ9HWWHUPLW+HIWLJNHLWXQGULHI
9HWWHU 9HWWHU,KUVHLGJHERUJHQJHERUJHQVHLG,KUVDJLFK
GHQQDOOHVP‰WHPLFKWUJHQRGHULFKEHVLW]HVHOEVWGLH1X‰
.UDNDWXN (UKROWHDOVEDOGHLQH6FKDFKWHOKHUYRUDXVGHUHUHLQH
YHUJROGHWH1X‰YRQPLWWHOPl‰LJHU*U|‰HKHUYRU]RJ6HKW 
VSUDFKHULQGHPHUGLH1X‰GHP9HWWHU]HLJWHVHKWPLWGLHVHU
1X‰KDWHVIROJHQGH%HZDQGWQLV9RUYLHOHQ-DKUHQNDPHLQVW]XU
:HLKQDFKWV]HLWHLQIUHPGHU0DQQPLWHLQHP6DFNYROO1VVHQ
KLHKHUGLHHUIHLOERW*HUDGHYRUPHLQHU3XSSHQEXGHJHULHWHULQ
6WUHLWXQGVHW]WHGHQ6DFNDEXPVLFKEHVVHUJHJHQGHQ
KLHVLJHQ1X‰YHUNlXIHUGHUQLFKWOHLGHQZROOWHGD‰GHU)UHPGH
1VVHYHUNDXIHXQGLKQGHVKDOEDQJULII]XZHKUHQ,QGHP
$XJHQEOLFNIXKUHLQVFKZHUEHODGHQHU/DVWZDJHQEHUGHQ6DFN
DOOH1VVHZXUGHQ]HUEURFKHQELVDXIHLQHGLHPLUGHUIUHPGH
0DQQVHOWVDPOlFKHOQGIUHLQHQEODQNHQ=ZDQ]LJHUYRP-DKUH
IHLOERW0LUVFKLHQGDVZXQGHUEDULFKIDQGJHUDGHHLQHQ
VROFKHQ=ZDQ]LJHULQPHLQHU7DVFKHZLHLKQGHU0DQQKDEHQ
ZROOWHNDXIWHGLH1X‰XQGYHUJROGHWHVLHVHOEVWQLFKWUHFKW
ZLVVHQGZDUXPLFKGLH1X‰VRWHXHUEH]DKOWHXQGGDQQVR
ZHUWKLHOW -HGHU=ZHLIHOGD‰GHV9HWWHUV1X‰ZLUNOLFKGLH
JHVXFKWH1X‰.UDNDWXNZDUZXUGHDXJHQEOLFNOLFKJHKREHQDOV
GHUKHUEHLJHUXIHQH+RIDVWURQRPGDV*ROGVDXEHUDEVFKDEWHXQG
LQGHU5LQGHGHU1X‰GDV:RUW.UDNDWXNPLWFKLQHVLVFKHQ
&KDUDNWHUHQHLQJHJUDEHQIDQG'LH)UHXGHGHU5HLVHQGHQZDU
JUR‰XQGGHU9HWWHUGHUJOFNOLFKVWH0HQVFKXQWHUGHU6RQQHDOV
'UR‰HOPHLHULKPYHUVLFKHUWHGD‰VHLQ*OFNJHPDFKWVHLGDHU
DX‰HUHLQHUDQVHKQOLFKHQ3HQVLRQKLQIURDOOHV*ROG]XP
9HUJROGHQXPVRQVWHUKDOWHQZHUGH%HLGHGHU$UNDQLVWXQGGHU
$VWURQRPKDWWHQVFKRQGLH6FKODIPW]HQDXIJHVHW]WXQGZROOWHQ
]X%HWWHJHKHQDOVOHW]WHUHUQlPOLFKGHU$VWURQRPDOVRDQKRE
%HVWHU+HUU.ROOHJHHLQ*OFNNRPPWQLHDOOHLQ *ODXEHQ6LH
QLFKWQXUGLH1X‰.UDNDWXNVRQGHUQDXFKGHQMXQJHQ0DQQGHU
VLHDXIEHL‰WXQGGHQ6FK|QKHLWVNHUQGHU3ULQ]HVVLQGDUUHLFKW
KDEHQZLUJHIXQGHQ,FKPHLQHQLHPDQGHQDQGHUVDOVGHQ6RKQ
,KUHV+HUUQ9HWWHUV 1HLQQLFKWVFKODIHQZLOOLFK IXKUHU
EHJHLVWHUWIRUWVRQGHUQQRFKLQGLHVHU1DFKWGHV-QJOLQJV
+RURVNRSVWHOOHQ  'DPLWUL‰HUGLH1DFKWPW]HYRP.RSIXQG
ILQJJOHLFKDQ]XREVHUYLHUHQ 'HV9HWWHUV 6RKQZDULQGHU7DW
HLQQHWWHUZRKOJHZDFKVHQHU-XQJHGHUQRFKQLHUDVLHUWZRUGHQ
XQGQLHPDOV6WLHIHOJHWUDJHQ,QIUKHU-XJHQGZDUHU]ZDUHLQ
SDDU:HLKQDFKWHQKLQGXUFKHLQ+DPSHOPDQQJHZHVHQGDV
PHUNWHPDQLKPDEHUQLFKWLPPLQGHVWHQDQVRZDUHUGXUFKGHV
9DWHUV%HPKXQJHQDXVJHELOGHWZRUGHQ$QGHQ
:HLKQDFKWVWDJHQWUXJHUHLQHQVFK|QHQURWHQ5RFNPLW*ROG
HLQHQ'HJHQGHQ+XWXQWHUGHP$UPXQGHLQHYRU]JOLFKH)ULVXU
PLWHLQHP+DDUEHXWHO6RVWDQGHUVHKUJOlQ]HQGLQVHLQHV9DWHUV
%XGHXQGNQDFNWHDXVDQJHERUQHU*DODQWHULHGHQMXQJHQ
0lGFKHQGLH1VVHDXIZHVKDOEVLHLKQDXFKVFK|Q
1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQQDQQWHQ 'HQDQGHUQ0RUJHQILHOGHU$VWURQRP
GHP$UNDQLVWHQHQW]FNWXPGHQ+DOVXQGULHI(ULVWHVZLU
KDEHQLKQHULVWJHIXQGHQQXU]ZHL'LQJHOLHEVWHU.ROOHJH
GUIHQZLUQLFKWDX‰HUDFKWODVVHQ)UVHUVWHPVVHQ6LH,KUHP
YRUWUHIIOLFKHQ1HIIHQHLQHQUREXVWHQK|O]HUQHQ=RSIIOHFKWHQGHU
PLWGHPXQWHUQ.LQQEDFNHQVRLQ9HUELQGXQJVWHKWGD‰GLHVHU
GDGXUFKVWDUNDQJH]RJHQZHUGHQNDQQGDQQPVVHQ ZLUDEHU
NRPPHQZLUQDFKGHU5HVLGHQ]DXFKVRUJIlOWLJYHUVFKZHLJHQ
GD‰ZLUGHQMXQJHQ0DQQGHUGLH1X‰.UDNDWXNDXIEHL‰WJOHLFK
PLWJHEUDFKWKDEHQHUPX‰VLFKYLHOPHKUODQJHQDFKXQV
HLQILQGHQ,FKOHVHLQGHP+RURVNRSGD‰GHU.|QLJ]HUEHL‰HQ
VLFKHUVWHLQLJHGLH=lKQHRKQHZHLWHUQ(UIROJGHPGHUGLH1X‰
DXIEHL‰WXQGGHU3ULQ]HVVLQGLHYHUORUHQH6FK|QKHLWZLHGHUJLEW
3ULQ]HVVLQXQG1DFKIROJHLP5HLFK]XP/RKQYHUVSUHFKHQZLUG 
'HU9HWWHU3XSSHQGUHFKVOHUZDUJDUK|FKOLFKGDPLW]XIULHGHQGD‰
VHLQ6|KQFKHQGLH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWKHLUDWHQXQG3ULQ]XQG.|QLJ
ZHUGHQVROOWHXQGEHUOLH‰LKQGDKHUGHQ*HVDQGWHQJlQ]OLFK
'HU=RSIGHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUGHPMXQJHQKRIIQXQJVYROOHQ1HIIHQ
DQVHW]WHJHULHWEHUDXVZRKOVRGD‰HUPLWGHP$XIEHL‰HQGHU
KlUWHVWHQ 3ILUVLFKNHUQHGLHJOlQ]HQGVWHQ9HUVXFKHDQVWHOOWH

'D'UR‰HOPHLHUXQGGHU$VWURQRPGDV$XIILQGHQGHU1X‰
.UDNDWXNVRJOHLFKQDFKGHU5HVLGHQ]EHULFKWHWVRZDUHQGRUW
DXFKDXIGHU6WHOOHGLHQ|WLJHQ$XIIRUGHUXQJHQHUODVVHQZRUGHQ
XQGDOVGLH5HLVHQGHQPLWGHP6FK|QKHLWVPLWWHODQNDPHQKDWWHQ
VLFKVFKRQYLHOHKEVFKH/HXWHXQWHUGHQHQHVVRJDU3ULQ]HQ
JDEHLQJHIXQGHQGLHLKUHPJHVXQGHQ*HEL‰YHUWUDXHQGGLH
(QW]DXEHUXQJGHU3ULQ]HVVLQYHUVXFKHQZROOWHQ'LH*HVDQGWHQ
HUVFKUDNHQQLFKWZHQLJDOVVLHGLH3ULQ]HVVLQZLHGHUVDKHQ'HU
NOHLQH.|USHUPLWGHQZLQ]LJHQ+lQGFKHQXQG)‰FKHQNRQQWH
NDXPGHQXQI|UPOLFKHQ.RSIWUDJHQ'LH+l‰OLFKNHLWGHV*HVLFKWV
ZXUGHQRFKGXUFKHLQHQZHL‰HQEDXPZROOHQHQ%DUWYHUPHKUWGHU
VLFKXP0XQGXQG.LQQJHOHJWKDWWH(VNDPDOOHVVRZLHHVGHU
+RIDVWURQRPLP+RURVNRSJHOHVHQ(LQ0LOFKEDUWLQ6FKXKHQQDFK
GHPDQGHUQEL‰VLFKDQGHU1X‰.UDNDWXN=lKQHXQG.LQQEDFNHQ
ZXQGRKQHGHU3ULQ]HVVLQLPPLQGHVWHQ]XKHOIHQXQGZHQQHU
GDQQYRQGHQGD]XEHVWHOOWHQ=DKQlU]WHQKDOERKQPlFKWLJ
ZHJJHWUDJHQZXUGHVHXI]WHHU'DVZDUHLQHKDUWH1X‰  $OV
QXQGHU.|QLJLQGHU$QJVWVHLQHV+HU]HQVGHPGHUGLH
(QW]DXEHUXQJYROOHQGHQZHUGH7RFKWHUXQG5HLFKYHUVSURFKHQ
PHOGHWHVLFKGHUDUWLJHVDQIWH-QJOLQJ'UR‰HOPHLHUXQGEDWDXFK
GHQ9HUVXFKEHJLQQHQ]XGUIHQ.HLQHUDOVGHUMXQJH
'UR‰HOPHLHUKDWWHVRVHKUGHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWJHIDOOHQVLH
OHJWHGLHNOHLQHQ+lQGFKHQDXIGDV+HU]XQGVHXI]WHUHFKWLQQLJ
$FKZHQQHVGRFKGHUZlUHGHUGLH1X‰.UDNDWXNZLUNOLFK
DXIEHL‰WXQGPHLQ0DQQZLUG 1DFKGHPGHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHU
GHQ.|QLJXQGGLH.|QLJLQGDQQDEHUGLH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWVHKU
K|IOLFKJHJU‰WHPSILQJHUDXVGHQ+lQGHQGHV
2EHU]HUHPRQLHQPHLVWHUVGLH1X‰.UDNDWXNQDKP6LHRKQH
ZHLWHUHV]ZLVFKHQGLH=lKQH]RJVWDUNGHQ=RSI DQXQG.UDN
.UDN]HUEU|FNHOWHGLH6FKDOHLQYLHOH6WFNH*HVFKLFNWUHLQLJWHHU
GHQ.HUQYRQGHQQRFKGDUDQKlQJHQGHQ)DVHUQXQGEHUUHLFKWH
LKQPLWHLQHPXQWHUWlQLJHQ.UDW]IX‰GHU3ULQ]HVVLQZRUDXIHUGLH
$XJHQYHUVFKOR‰XQGUFNZlUWV]XVFKUHLWHQEHJDQQ'LH
3ULQ]HVVLQYHUVFKOXFNWHDOVEDOGGHQ.HUQXQGR:XQGHU
YHUVFKZXQGHQZDUGLH0L‰JHVWDOWXQGVWDWWLKUHUVWDQGHLQ
HQJHOVFK|QHV)UDXHQELOGGDGDV*HVLFKWZLHYRQOLOLHQZHL‰HQXQG
URVDURWHQ6HLGHQIORFNHQJHZHKWGLH$XJHQZLHJOlQ]HQGH$]XUH
GLH YROOHQ/RFNHQZLHYRQ*ROGIlGHQJHNUlXVHOW7URPSHWHQXQG
3DXNHQPLVFKWHQVLFKLQGHQODXWHQ-XEHOGHV9RONV'HU.|QLJ
VHLQJDQ]HU+RIWDQ]WHZLHEHL3LUOLSDWV*HEXUWDXIHLQHP%HLQH
XQGGLH.|QLJLQPX‰WHPLW(DXGH&RORJQHEHGLHQWZHUGHQZHLO
VLHLQ 2KQPDFKWJHIDOOHQYRU)UHXGHXQG(QW]FNHQ'HUJUR‰H
7XPXOWEUDFKWHGHQMXQJHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUGHUQRFKVHLQHVLHEHQ
6FKULWWH]XYROOHQGHQKDWWHQLFKWZHQLJDXVGHU)DVVXQJGRFK
KLHOWHUVLFKXQGVWUHFNWHHEHQGHQUHFKWHQ)X‰DXV]XP
VLHEHQWHQ6FKULWWGD HUKREVLFKKl‰OLFKSLHSHQGXQGTXLHNHQG
)UDX0DXVHULQNVDXVGHP)X‰ERGHQVRGD‰'UR‰HOPHLHUDOVHU
GHQ)X‰QLHGHUVHW]HQZROOWHDXIVLHWUDWXQGGHUPD‰HQVWROSHUWH
GD‰HUEHLQDKHJHIDOOHQZlUH 20L‰JHVFKLFN XUSO|W]OLFKZDU
GHU-QJOLQJHEHQVRPL‰JHVWDOWHWDOVHVYRUKHU3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDW
JHZHVHQ'HU.|USHUZDU]XVDPPHQJHVFKUXPSIWXQGNRQQWH
NDXPGHQGLFNHQXQJHVWDOWHWHQ.RSIPLWJUR‰HQ
KHUYRUVWHFKHQGHQ$XJHQXQGGHPEUHLWHQHQWVHW]OLFK
DXIJlKQHQGHQ0DXOHWUDJHQ6WDWWGHV=RSIHVKLQJLKPKLQWHQHLQ
VFKPDOHUK|O]HUQHU0DQWHOKHUDEPLWGHPHUGHQXQWHUQ
.LQQEDFNHQUHJLHUWH 8KUPDFKHUXQG$VWURQRPZDUHQDX‰HU
VLFKYRU6FKUHFNXQG(QWVHW]HQVLHVDKHQDEHUZLH)UDX
0DXVHULQNVVLFKEOXWHQGDXIGHP%RGHQZlO]WH,KUH%RVKHLWZDU
QLFKWXQJHUlFKWJHEOLHEHQGHQQGHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUKDWWHVLH
PLWGHPVSLW]HQ$EVDW]VHLQHV6FKXKHVVRGHUELQGHQ+DOV
JHWURIIHQGD‰VLHVWHUEHQPX‰WH$EHULQGHP)UDX0DXVHULQNV
YRQGHU7RGHVQRWHUID‰WZXUGHGDSLHSWHXQGTXLHNWHVLHJDQ]
HUElUPOLFK2.UDNDWXNKDUWH1X‰DQGHULFKQXQVWHUEHQPX‰
KLKL SLSLIHLQ1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQZLUVWDXFKEDOGGHV7RGHVVHLQ
6|KQOHLQPLWGHQVLHEHQ.URQHQZLUG VGHP1X‰NQDFNHUORKQHQ
ZLUGGLH0XWWHUUlFKHQIHLQDQGLUGXNOHLQ1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQ R
/HEHQVRIULVFKXQGURWYRQ GLUVFKHLGLFKR7RGHVQRW 4XLHN 
0LWGLHVHP6FKUHLVWDUE)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQGZXUGHYRQGHP
N|QLJOLFKHQ2IHQKHL]HUIRUWJHEUDFKW 8PGHQMXQJHQ
'UR‰HOPHLHUKDWWHVLFKQLHPDQGEHNPPHUWGLH3ULQ]HVVLQ
HULQQHUWHDEHUGHQ.|QLJDQVHLQ9HUVSUHFKHQXQGVRJOHLFK
EHIDKOHUGD‰PDQGHQMXQJHQ+HOGHQKHUEHLVFKDIIH$OVQXQ
DEHUGHU8QJOFNOLFKHLQVHLQHU0L‰JHVWDOWKHUYRUWUDWGDKLHOWGLH
3ULQ]HVVLQEHLGH+lQGHYRUV*HVLFKWXQGVFKULH)RUWIRUWPLW
GHPDEVFKHXOLFKHQ1X‰NQDFNHU $OVEDOGHUJULIILKQDXFKGHU
+RIPDUVFKDOOEHLGHQNOHLQHQ6FKXOWHUQXQGZDUILKQ]XU7UH
KHUDXV'HU.|QLJZDUYROOHU:XWGD‰PDQLKPKDEHHLQHQ
1X‰NQDFNHUDOV(LGDPDXIGULQJHQZROOHQVFKREDOOHVDXIGDV
8QJHVFKLFNGHV8KUPDFKHUVXQGGHV$VWURQRPHQXQGYHUZLHV
EHLGHDXIHZLJH=HLWHQDXVGHU5HVLGHQ]'DVKDWWHQXQQLFKWLQ
GHP+RURVNRSJHVWDQGHQZHOFKHVGHU$VWURQRPLQ1UQEHUJ
JHVWHOOWHUOLH‰VLFKDEHUQLFKWDEKDOWHQDXIVQHXH]XREVHUYLHUHQ
XQGGDZROOWHHULQGHQ6WHUQHQOHVHQGD‰GHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHU
VLFKLQVHLQHP QHXHQ6WDQGHVRJXWQHKPHQZHUGHGD‰HUWURW]
VHLQHU8QJHVWDOW3ULQ]XQG.|QLJZHUGHQZUGH6HLQH0L‰JHVWDOW
N|QQHDEHUQXUGDQQYHUVFKZLQGHQZHQQGHU6RKQGHU)UDX
0DXVHULQNVGHQVLHQDFKGHP7RGHLKUHUVLHEHQ6|KQHPLW
VLHEHQ.|SIHQJHERUHQXQGZHOFKHU0DXVHN|QLJJHZRUGHQYRQ
VHLQHU+DQGJHIDOOHQVHLHXQGHLQH'DPHLKQWURW]VHLQHU
0L‰JHVWDOWOLHEJHZLQQHQZHUGH0DQVROOGHQQDXFKZLUNOLFKGHQ
MXQJHQ'UR‰HOPHLHULQ1UQEHUJ]XU:HLKQDFKWV]HLWLQVHLQHV
9DWHUV%XGH]ZDUDOV1X‰NQDFNHUDEHUGRFKDOV3ULQ]HQJHVHKHQ
KDEHQ 'DVLVWLKU.LQGHUGDV0lUFKHQYRQGHUKDUWHQ1X‰
XQGLKUZL‰WQXQZDUXPGLH/HXWHVRRIWVDJHQ'DVZDUHLQH
KDUWH1X‰ XQGZLHHVNRPPWGD‰GLH1X‰NQDFNHUVRKl‰OLFK
VLQG

6RVFKOR‰GHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWVHLQH(U]lKOXQJ0DULHPHLQWHGD‰
GLH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGRFKHLJHQWOLFKHLQJDUVWLJHVXQGDQNEDUHV
'LQJVHL)ULW]YHUVLFKHUWHGDJHJHQGD‰ZHQQ1X‰NQDFNHUQXU
VRQVWHLQEUDYHU.HUOVHLQZROOHHUPLWGHP0DXVHN|QLJQLFKWYLHO
)HGHUOHVHQVPDFKHQXQGVHLQHYRULJHKEVFKH*HVWDOWEDOG
ZLHGHUHUODQJHQZHUGH
2QNHOXQG1HIIH
+DWMHPDQGYRQPHLQHQKRFKYHUHKUWHVWHQ/HVHUQRGHU=XK|UHUQ
MHPDOVGHQ=XIDOOHUOHEWVLFKPLW*ODV]XVFKQHLGHQVRZLUGHU
VHOEVWZLVVHQZLHZHKHHVWXWXQGZHOFKVFKOLPPHV'LQJHV
EHUKDXSWLVWGDHVVRODQJVDPKHLOW+DWWHGRFK0DULHEHLQDKH
HLQHJDQ]H:RFKHLP%HWW]XEULQJHQPVVHQZHLOHVLKULPPHU
JDQ]VFKZLQGOLFKW]XPXWHZXUGHVREDOGVLHDXIVWDQG(QGOLFK
DEHUZXUGHVLHJDQ]JHVXQGXQGNRQQWHOXVWLJZLHVRQVWLQGHU
6WXEHXPKHUVSULQJHQ,P*ODVVFKUDQNVDKHVJDQ]KEVFKDXV
GHQQQHXXQGEODQNVWDQGHQGD%lXPHXQG%OXPHQXQG+lXVHU
XQGVFK|QHJOlQ]HQGH3XSSHQ9RUDOOHQ'LQJHQIDQG0DULHLKUHQ
OLHEHQ1X‰NQDFNHUZLHGHUGHULQGHP]ZHLWHQ)DFKHVWHKHQG
PLWJDQ]JHVXQGHQ=lKQFKHQVLHDQOlFKHOWH$OVVLHQXQGHQ
/LHEOLQJVRUHFKWPLW+HU]HQVOXVWDQEOLFNWHGDILHOHVLKUPLW
HLQHPPDOVHKUElQJOLFKDXIV+HU]GD‰DOOHVZDV3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUHU]lKOWKDEHMDQXUGLH*HVFKLFKWHGHV1X‰NQDFNHUV
XQGVHLQHV=ZLVWHVPLWGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQGLKUHP6RKQH
JHZHVHQ1XQZX‰WHVLHGD‰LKU1X‰NQDFNHUNHLQDQGHUHUVHLQ
N|QQHDOVGHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUDXV1UQEHUJGHV3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUVDQJHQHKPHUDEHUOHLGHUYRQGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNV
YHUKH[WHU1HIIH'HQQGD‰GHUNQVWOLFKH8KUPDFKHUDP+RIH
YRQ 3LUOLSDWV9DWHUQLHPDQGDQGHUVJHZHVHQDOVGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDW'UR‰HOPHLHUVHOEVWGDUDQKDWWH0DULHVFKRQEHL
GHU(U]lKOXQJQLFKWHLQHQ$XJHQEOLFNJH]ZHLIHOW$EHUZDUXP
KDOIGLUGHU2QNHOGHQQQLFKWZDUXPKDOIHUGLUQLFKWVRNODJWH
0DULHDOVVLFK HVLPPHUOHEHQGLJHUXQGOHEHQGLJHULQLKU
JHVWDOWHWHGD‰HVLQMHQHU6FKODFKWGLHVLHPLWDQVDK
1X‰NQDFNHUV5HLFKXQG.URQHJDOW:DUHQGHQQQLFKWDOOHEULJHQ
3XSSHQLKPXQWHUWDQXQGZDUHVGHQQQLFKWJHZL‰GD‰GLH
3URSKH]HLXQJGHV+RIDVWURQRPHQHLQJHWURIIHQXQGGHUMXQJH
'UR‰HOPHLHU.|QLJGHV3XSSHQUHLFKVJHZRUGHQ",QGHPGLHNOXJH
0DULHGDVDOOHVVRUHFKWLP6LQQHUZlJWHJODXEWHVLHDXFKGD‰
1X‰NQDFNHUXQGVHLQH9DVDOOHQLQGHP$XJHQEOLFNGD‰VLHLKQHQ
/HEHQXQG%HZHJXQJ]XWUDXWHDXFKZLUNOLFKOHEHQXQGVLFK
EHZHJHQP‰WHQ'HPZDUDEHUQLFKWVRDOOHVLP6FKUDQNHEOLHE
YLHOPHKUVWDUUXQGUHJXQJVORVXQG0DULHZHLWHQWIHUQWLKUH
LQQHUHhEHU]HXJXQJDXI]XJHEHQVFKREGDVQXUDXIGLH
IRUWZLUNHQGH9HUKH[XQJGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQGLKUHV
VLHEHQN|SILJHQ6RKQHV'RFKVSUDFKVLHODXW]XP1X‰NQDFNHU
ZHQQ6LHDXFKQLFKWLPVWDQGHVLQGVLFK]XEHZHJHQRGHUHLQ
:|UWFKHQPLWPLU]XVSUHFKHQOLHEHU+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUVRZHL‰
LFKGRFKGD‰6LHPLFKYHUVWHKHQXQGHVZLVVHQZLHJXWLFKHV
PLW,KQHQPHLQHUHFKQHQ6LHDXIPHLQHQ%HLVWDQGZHQQ6LH
GHVVHQEHGUIHQ :HQLJVWHQVZLOOLFKGHQ2QNHOELWWHQGD‰HU
,KQHQPLWVHLQHU*HVFKLFNOLFKNHLWEHLVSULQJHZRHVQ|WLJLVW
1X‰NQDFNHUEOLHEVWLOOXQGUXKLJDEHU0DULHQZDUHVVRDOVDWPH
HLQOHLVHU6HXI]HU GXUFKGHQ*ODVVFKUDQNZRYRQGLH*ODVVFKHLEHQ
NDXPK|UEDUDEHUZXQGHUOLHEOLFKHUW|QWHQXQGHVZDUDOVVlQJH
HLQNOHLQHV*ORFNHQVWLPPFKHQ0DULDNOHLQ 6FKXW]HQJOHLQPHLQ
 'HLQZHUGLFKVHLQ 0DULDPHLQ0DULHIKOWHLQGHQHLVNDOWHQ
6FKDXHUQGLHVLHEHUOLHIHQGRFKHLQVHOWVDPHV:RKOEHKDJHQ
'LH'lPPHUXQJZDUHLQJHEURFKHQGHU0HGL]LQDOUDWWUDWPLWGHP
3DWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUKLQHLQXQGQLFKWODQJHGDXHUWHHVVRKDWWH
/XLVHGHQ7HHWLVFKJHRUGQHWXQGGLH)DPLOLHVD‰ULQJVXPKHU
DOOHUOHL/XVWLJHVPLWHLQDQGHUVSUHFKHQG0DULHKDWWHJDQ]VWLOOLKU
NOHLQHV/HKQVWKOFKHQKHUEHLJHKROWXQGVLFK]XGHQ)‰HQGHV
3DWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUJHVHW]W$OVQXQJHUDGHHLQPDODOOHVFKZLHJHQ
GDVDK0DULHPLWLKUHQJUR‰HQEODXHQ$XJHQGHP2EHUJHULFKWVUDW
VWDUULQV*HVLFKWXQGVSUDFK,FKZHL‰MHW]WOLHEHU3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUGD‰PHLQ1X‰NQDFNHUGHLQ1HIIHGHUMXQJH
'UR‰HOPHLHUDXV1UQEHUJLVW3ULQ]RGHUYLHOPHKU.|QLJLVWHU
JHZRUGHQGDVLVWULFKWLJHLQJHWURIIHQZLHHVGHLQ%HJOHLWHUGHU
$VWURQRPYRUDXVJHVDJWKDWDEHUGXZHL‰WHVMDGD‰HUPLWGHP
6RKQHGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVPLWGHPKl‰OLFKHQ0DXVHN|QLJLQ
RIIQHP.ULHJHVWHKW:DUXPKLOIVWGXLKPQLFKW"0DULHHU]lKOWH
QXQQRFKPDOVGHQJDQ]HQ9HUODXIGHU6FKODFKWZLHVLHHV
DQJHVHKHQXQGZXUGHRIWGXUFKGDVODXWH*HOlFKWHUGHU0XWWHU
XQG/XLVHQVXQWHUEURFKHQ1XU)ULW]XQG'UR‰HOPHLHUEOLHEHQ
HUQVWKDIW$EHUZRNULHJWGDV0lGFKHQDOOGDVWROOH=HXJLQGHQ
.RSIVDJWHGHU0HGL]LQDOUDW(LQXQHUZLGHUWHGLH0XWWHUKDW
VLHGRFKHLQHOHEKDIWH)DQWDVLH HLJHQWOLFKVLQGHVQXU7UlXPH
GLHGDVKHIWLJH:XQGILHEHUHU]HXJWH(VLVWDOOHVQLFKWZDKU
VSUDFK)ULW]VROFKH3ROWURQVVLQGPHLQHURWHQ+XVDUHQQLFKW
3RW]%DVVD0DQHONDZLHZUGLFKVRQVWGDUXQWHUIDKUHQ6HOWVDP
OlFKHOQGQDKPDEHU3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUGLHNOHLQH0DULHDXIGHQ
6FKR‰XQGVSUDFKVDQIWHUDOVMH(LGLUOLHEH0DULHLVWMDPHKU
JHJHEHQDOVPLUXQGXQVDOOHQGXELVWZLH3LUOLSDWHLQHJHERUQH
3ULQ]HVVLQGHQQGXUHJLHUVWLQHLQHPVFK|QHQEODQNHQ5HLFK
$EHUYLHOKDVWGX]XOHLGHQZHQQGXGLFKGHVDUPHQ
PL‰JHVWDOWHWHQ1X‰NQDFNHUVDQQHKPHQZLOOVWGDLKQGHU
0DXVHN|QLJDXIDOOHQ:HJHQXQG6WHJHQYHUIROJW 'RFKQLFKWLFK
 GXGXDOOHLQNDQQVWLKQUHWWHQVHLVWDQGKDIWXQGWUHX:HGHU
0DULHQRFKLUJHQGMHPDQGZX‰WHZDV'UR‰HOPHLHUPLWGLHVHQ
:RUWHQVDJHQZROOWHYLHOPHKUNDPHVGHP0HGL]LQDOUDWVR
VRQGHUEDUYRUGD‰HUGHP2EHUJHULFKWVUDWDQGHQ3XOVIKOWHXQG
VDJWH6LHKDEHQZHUWHVWHU)UHXQGVWDUNH.RQJHVWLRQHQQDFK
GHP.RSIHLFKZLOO,KQHQHWZDVDXIVFKUHLEHQ1XUGLH
0HGL]LQDOUlWLQVFKWWHOWHEHGlFKWOLFKGHQ.RSIXQGVSUDFKOHLVH
,FKDKQHZRKOZDVGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWPHLQWGRFKPLW
GHXWOLFKHQ:RUWHQVDJHQNDQQLFK VQLFKW
'HU6LHJ
1LFKWODQJHGDXHUWHHVDOV0DULHLQGHUPRQGKHOOHQ1DFKWGXUFK
HLQVHOWVDPHV3ROWHUQJHZHFNWZXUGHGDVDXVHLQHU(FNHGHV
=LPPHUV]XNRPPHQVFKLHQ(VZDUDOVZUGHQNOHLQH6WHLQHKLQ
XQGKHUJHZRUIHQXQGJHUROOWXQGUHFKWZLGULJSILIIXQGTXLHNWH
HVGD]ZLVFKHQ$FKGLH0lXVHGLH0lXVHNRPPHQZLHGHUULHI
0DULHHUVFKURFNHQXQGZROOWHGLH0XWWHUZHFNHQDEHUMHGHU/DXW
VWRFNWHMDVLHYHUPRFKWHNHLQ*OLHG]XUHJHQDOVVLHVDKZLHGHU
0DXVHN|QLJVLFKGXUFKHLQ/RFKGHU0DXHUKHUYRUDUEHLWHWHXQG
HQGOLFKPLWIXQNHOQGHQ$XJHQXQG.URQHQLP=LPPHUKHUXP
GDQQDEHUPLWHLQHPJHZDOWLJHQ6DW]DXIGHQNOHLQHQ7LVFKGHU
GLFKWQHEHQ0DULHQV%HWWHVWDQGKHUDXIVSUDQJ+L KL KL
PX‰WPLUGHLQH=XFNHUHUEVHQ GHLQHQ0DU]LSDQJHKHQNOHLQ
'LQJ VRQVW]HUEHL‰LFKGHLQHQ1X‰NQDFNHU GHLQHQ
1X‰NQDFNHU 6RSILII0DXVHN|QLJNQDSSHUWHXQGNQLUVFKWH
GDEHLVHKUKl‰OLFKPLWGHQ=lKQHQXQGVSUDQJGDQQVFKQHOO
ZLHGHUIRUWGXUFKGDV0DXHUORFK0DULHZDUVRJHlQJVWHWYRQGHU
JUDXOLFKHQ(UVFKHLQXQJGD‰VLHGHQDQGHUQ0RUJHQJDQ]EOD‰
DXVVDKXQGLP,QQHUVWHQDXIJHUHJWNDXPHLQ:RUW]XUHGHQ
YHUPRFKWH+XQGHUWPDOZROOWHVLHGHU0XWWHURGHUGHU/XLVHRGHU
ZHQLJVWHQVGHP)ULW]NODJHQZDVLKUJHVFKHKHQDEHUVLHGDFKWH
*ODXEW VPLUGHQQHLQHUXQGZHUGLFKQLFKWREHQGUHLQWFKWLJ
DXVJHODFKW" 'DVZDULKUGHQQDEHUZRKONODUGD‰VLHXPGHQ
1X‰NQDFNHU]XUHWWHQ=XFNHUHUEVHQXQG0DU]LSDQKHUJHEHQ
PVVH6RYLHOVLHGDYRQEHVD‰OHJWHVLHGDKHUGHQDQGHUQ
$EHQGKLQYRUGHU/HLVWHGHV6FKUDQNV$P0RUJHQVDJWHGLH
0HGL]LQDLUlWLQ,FKZHL‰QLFKWZRKHUGLH0lXVHPLWHLQHPPDOLQ
XQVHU:RKQ]LPPHUNRPPHQVLHKQXUDUPH0DULHVLHKDEHQGLU
DOOGHLQ=XFNHUZHUNDXIJHIUHVVHQ:LUNOLFKZDUHVVR'HQ
JHIOOWHQ0DU]LSDQKDWWHGHUJHIUl‰LJH0DXVHN|QLJQLFKWQDFK
VHLQHP*HVFKPDFNJHIXQGHQDEHUPLWVFKDUIHQ=lKQHQEHQDJW
VRGD‰HUZHJJHZRUIHQZHUGHQPX‰WH0DULHPDFKWHVLFKJDU
QLFKWVPHKUDXVGHP=XFNHUZHUNVRQGHPZDUYLHOPHKULP
,QQHUVWHQHUIUHXWGDVLHLKUHQ1X‰NQDFNHUJHUHWWHWJODXEWH'RFK
ZLHZDUGLKUDOVLQGHUIROJHQGHQ1DFKWHVGLFKWDQLKUHQ2KUHQ
SILIIXQGTXLHNWH$FKGHU0DXVHN|QLJZDUZLHGHUGDXQGQRFK
DEVFKHXOLFKHUZLHLQGHUYRUYRULJHQ1DFKWIXQNHOWHQVHLQH
$XJHQXQGQRFKZLGULJHUSILIIHU]ZLVFKHQGHQ=lKQHQ0X‰W
PLUGHLQH=XFNHUGHLQH'UDJDQWSXSSHQJHEHQNOHLQ'LQJVRQVW
]HUEHL‰LFKGHLQHQ1X‰NQDFNHUGHLQHQ1X‰NQDFNHUXQGGDPLW
VSUDQJGHUJUDXOLFKH0DXVHN|QLJZLHGHUIRUW 0DULHZDUVHKU
EHWUEWVLHJLQJGHQDQGHUQ0RUJHQDQGHQ6FKUDQNXQGVDKPLW
GHQZHKPWLJVWHQ%OLFNHQLKUH=XFNHU XQG'UDJDQWSSSFKHQDQ
$EHULKU6FKPHU]ZDUDXFKJHUHFKWGHQQQLFKWJODXEHQPDJVW
GX VPHLQHDXIPHUNVDPH=XK|UHULQ0DULHZDVIUJDQ]
DOOHUOLHEVWH)LJUFKHQDXV=XFNHURGHU'UDJDQWJHIRUPWGLHNOHLQH
0DULH6WDKOEDXPEHVD‰1lFKVWGHPGD‰HLQVHKUKEVFKHU
6FKlIHUPLWVHLQHU6FKlIHULQHLQHJDQ]H+HUGHPLOFKZHL‰HU
6FKlIOHLQZHLGHWHXQGGDEHLVHLQPXQWUHV+QGFKHQ
KHUXPVSUDQJVRWUDWHQDXFK]ZHL%ULHIWUlJHUPLW%ULHIHQLQGHU
+DQGHLQKHUXQGYLHUVHKUKEVFKH3DDUHVDXEHUJHNOHLGHWH
-QJOLQJHPLWEHUDXVKHUUOLFKJHSXW]WHQ0lGFKHQVFKDXNHOWHQ
VLFKLQHLQHUUXVVLVFKHQ6FKDXNHO+LQWHUHLQLJHQ7lQ]HUQVWDQG
QRFKGHU3DFKWHU)HOGNPPHOPLWGHU-XQJIUDXYRQ2UOHDQVDXV
GHQHQVLFK0DULHQLFKWYLHOPDFKWHDEHUJDQ]LP:LQNHOFKHQ
VWDQGHLQURWElFNLJHV.LQGOHLQ0DULHQV/LHEOLQJGLH7UlQHQ
VWU]WHQGHUNOHLQHQ0DULHDXVGHQ$XJHQ$FKULHIVLHVLFK]X
GHP1X‰NQDFNHUZHQGHQGOLHEHU+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUZDVZLOOLFK
QLFKWDOOHVWXQXP6LH]XUHWWHQDEHUHVLVWGRFKVHKUKDUW
1X‰NQDFNHUVDKLQGHVVHQVRZHLQHUOLFKDXVGD‰0DULHGDHV
EHUGHPLKUZDUDOVVlKHVLH0DXVHN|QLJVVLHEHQ5DFKHQ
JH|IIQHWGHQXQJOFNOLFKHQ-QJOLQJ]XYHUVFKOLQJHQDOOHV
DXI]XRSIHUQEHVFKOR‰$OOH=XFNHUSSSFKHQVHW]WHVLHGDKHU
DEHQGVZLH]XYRUGDV=XFNHUZHUNDQGLH/HLVWHGHV6FKUDQNV
6LHN‰WHGHQ6FKlIHUGLH6FKlIHULQGLH/lPPHUFKHQXQGKROWH
DXFK]XOHW]WLKUHQ/LHEOLQJGDVNOHLQHURWElFNLJH.LQGOHLQYRQ
'UDJDQWDXVGHP:LQNHOZHOFKHVVLHMHGRFKJDQ]KLQWHUZlUWV
VWHOOWH3DFKWHU)HOGNPPHOXQGGLH-XQJIUDXYRQ2UOHDQVPX‰WHQ
LQGLHHUVWH5HLKH1HLQGDVLVW]XDUJULHIGLH0HGL]LQDOUlWLQDP
DQGHUQ0RUJHQ(VPX‰GXUFKDXVHLQHJUR‰HJDUVWLJH0DXVLQ
GHP*ODVVFKUDQNKDXVHQGHQQDOOHVFK|QH=XFNHUSSSFKHQGHU
DUPHQ0DULHVLQG]HUQDJWXQG]HUELVVHQ0DULHNRQQWHVLFK]ZDU
GHU7UlQHQQLFKWHQWKDOWHQVLHOlFKHOWHDEHUGRFKEDOGZLHGHU
GHQQVLHGDFKWH:DVWXW V LVWGRFK1X‰NQDFNHUJHUHWWHW'HU
0HGL]LQDOUDWVDJWHDP$EHQGDOVGLH0XWWHUGHP2EHUJHULFKWVUDW
YRQGHP8QIXJHU]lKOWHGHQHLQH0DXVLP*ODVVFKUDQNGHU
.LQGHUWUHLEH(VLVWGRFKDEHUDEVFKHXOLFKGD‰ZLUGLHIDWDOH
0DXVQLFKWYHUWLOJHQN|QQHQGLHLP*ODVVFKUDQNVRLKU:HVHQ
WUHLEWXQGGHUDUPHQ0DULHDOOHV=XFNHUZHUNZHJIUL‰W(LILHO
)ULW]JDQ]OXVWLJHLQGHU%lFNHUXQWHQKDWHLQHQJDQ]
YRUWUHIIOLFKHQJUDXHQ/HJDWLRQVUDWGHQZLOOLFKKHUDXIKROHQ(U
ZLUGGHP'LQJHEDOGHLQ(QGHPDFKHQXQGGHU0DXVGHQ.RSI
DEEHL‰HQLVWVLHDXFKGLH)UDX0DXVHULQNVVHOEVWRGHULKU6RKQ
GHU0DXVHN|QLJ8QGIXKUGLH0HGL]LQDOUlWLQODFKHQGIRUWDXI
6WKOHXQG7LVFKHKHUXPVSULQJHQXQG*OlVHUXQG7DVVHQ
KHUDEZHUIHQXQGWDXVHQGDQGHUQ6FKDGHQDQULFKWHQ $FKQHLQ
GRFKHUZLGHUWH)ULW]%lFNHUV/HJDWLRQVUDWLVWHLQJHVFKLFNWHU
0DQQLFKP|FKWHQXU]LHUOLFKDXIGHPVSLW]HQ'DFKJHKHQ
N|QQHQZLHHU1XUNHLQHQ.DWHU]X1DFKW]HLWEDW/XLVHGLH
NHLQH.DW]HQOHLGHQNRQQWH(LJHQWOLFKVSUDFKGHU0HGL]LQDOUDW
HLJHQWOLFKKDW)ULW]UHFKWLQGHVVHQN|QQHQZLUMDDXFKHLQH)DOOH
DXIVWHOOHQKDEHQZLUGHQQNHLQH" 'LHNDQQXQV3DWH
'UR‰HOPHLHUDPEHVWHQPDFKHQGHUKDWVLHMDHUIXQGHQULHI
)ULW]$OOHODFKWHQXQGDXIGLH9HUVLFKHUXQJGHU0HGL]LQDOUlWLQ
GD‰NHLQH)DOOHLP+DXVHVHLYHUNQGHWHGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW
GD‰HUPHKUHUHGHUJOHLFKHQEHVLW]HXQGOLH‰ZLUNOLFK]XU6WXQGH
HLQHJDQ]YRUWUHIIOLFKH0DXVIDOOHYRQ+DXVHKHUEHLKROHQ'HP
)ULW]XQGGHU0DULHJLQJQXQGHV3DWHQ0lUFKHQYRQGHUKDUWHQ
1X‰JDQ]OHEHQGLJDXI$OVGLH.|FKLQGHQ6SHFNU|VWHWH]LWWHUWH
XQGEHEWH0DULHXQGVSUDFKJDQ]HUIOOWYRQGHP0lUFKHQXQG
GHQ:XQGHUGLQJHQGDULQ]XUZRKOEHNDQQWHQ'RUH$FK)UDX
.|QLJLQKWHQ6LHVLFKGRFKQXUYRUGHU)UDX0DXVHULQNVXQG
LKUHU)DPLOLH)ULW]KDWWHDEHUVHLQHQ6lEHOJH]RJHQXQGVSUDFK
-DGLHVROOWHQQXUNRPPHQGHQHQZROOWLFKHLQVDXVZLVFKHQ(V
EOLHEDEHUDOOHVXQWHUXQGDXIGHP+HUGHUXKLJ$OVQXQGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWGHQ6SHFNDQHLQIHLQHV)lGFKHQEDQGXQGOHLVH
OHLVHGLH)DOOHDQGHQ*ODVVFKUDQNVHW]WHGDULHI)ULW]1LPP
GLFKLQDFKW3DWH8KUPDFKHUGD‰GLU0DXVHN|QLJNHLQHQ3RVVHQ
VSLHOW $FKZLHJLQJHVGHUDUPHQ0DULHLQGHUIROJHQGHQ1DFKW
(LVNDOWWXSIWHHVDXILKUHP$UPKLQXQGKHUXQGUDXKXQG
HNHOKDIWOHJWH HVVLFKDQLKUH:DQJHXQGSLHSWHXQGTXLHNWHLKU
LQV2KU 'HUDEVFKHXOLFKH0DXVN|QLJVD‰DXILKUHU6FKXOWHUXQG
EOXWURWJHLIHUWHHUDXVGHQVLHEHQJH|IIQHWHQ5DFKHQXQGPLWGHQ
=lKQHQNQDWWHUQGXQGNQLUVFKHQG]LVFKWHHUGHUYRU*UDXHQXQG
6FKUHFNHUVWDUUWHQ0DULHLQV2KU=LVFKDXV ]LVFKDXVJHK
QLFKWLQV+DXV JHKQLFKW]XP6FKPDXV ZHUGQLFKWJHIDQJHQ
]LVFKDXV JLEKHUDXVJLEKHUDXVGHLQH%LOGHUEFKHUDOOGHLQ
.OHLGFKHQGD]XVRQVWKDVWNHLQH5XK PDJVW VQXUZLVVHQ
1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQZLUVWVRQVWPLVVHQGHUZLUG]HUELVVHQ KLKL SL
SL TXLHNTXLHN 1XQZDU0DULHYROO-DPPHUXQG%HWUEQLV
VLHVDKJDQ]EOD‰XQGYHUVW|UWDXVDOVGLH0XWWHUDPDQGHUQ
0RUJHQVDJWH'LHE|VH0DXVKDWVLFKQRFKQLFKWJHIDQJHQVR
GD‰GLH0XWWHULQGHP*ODXEHQGD‰0DULHXPLKU=XFNHUZHUN
WUDXUHXQGVLFKEHUGHPYRUGHU0DXVIUFKWHKLQ]XIJWH$EHU
VHLQXUUXKLJOLHEHV.LQGGLHE|VH0DXVZROOHQZLUVFKRQ
YHUWUHLEHQ+HOIHQGLH)DOOHQQLFKWVVRVROO)ULW]VHLQHQJUDXHQ
/HJDWLRQVUDWKHUEHLEULQJHQ.DXPEHIDQGVLFK0DULHLP
:RKQ]LPPHUDOOHLQDOVVLHYRUGHQ*ODVVFKUDQNWUDWXQG
VFKOXFK]HQGDOVR]XP1X‰NQDFNHUVSUDFK$FKPHLQOLHEHUJXWHU
+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUZDVNDQQLFKDUPHVXQJOFNOLFKHV0lGFKHQIU
6LHWXQ"*lELFKQXQDXFKDOOHPHLQH%LOGHUEFKHUMDVHOEVWPHLQ
VFK|QHVQHXHV.OHLGFKHQGDVPLUGHU+HLOLJH&KULVWHLQEHVFKHUW
KDWGHPDEVFKHXOLFKHQ0DXVHN|QLJ]XP=HUEHL‰HQKHUZLUGHU
GHQQQLFKWGRFKQRFKLPPHUPHKUYHUODQJHQVRGD‰LFK]XOHW]W
QLFKWVPHKUKDEHQZHUGHXQGHUJDUPLFKVHOEVW VWDWW,KUHU
]HUEHL‰HQZROOHQZLUG" 2LFKDUPHV.LQGZDVVROOLFKGHQQQXQ
WXQ ZDVVROOLFKGHQQQXQWXQ" $OVGLHNOHLQH0DULHVR
MDPPHUWHXQGNODJWHEHPHUNWHVLHGD‰GHP1X‰NQDFNHUYRQ
MHQHU1DFKWKHUHLQJUR‰HU%OXWIOHFNDP+DOVHVLW]HQJHEOLHEHQ
ZDU6HLWGHU=HLWGD‰0DULHZX‰WHZLHLKU1X‰NQDFNHUHLJHQWOLFK
GHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUGHV2EHUJHULFKWVUDWV1HIIHVHLWUXJVLH
LKQQLFKWPHKUDXIGHP$UPXQGKHU]WHXQGN‰WHLKQQLFKW
PHKUMDVLHPRFKWHLKQDXVHLQHUJHZLVVHQ6FKHXJDUQLFKW
HLQPDOYLHODQUKUHQMHW]WQDKPVLHLKQDEHUVHKUEHKXWVDPDXV
GHP)DFKHXQGILQJDQGHQ%OXWIOHFNDP+DOVHPLWLKUHP
6FKQXSIWXFKDE]XUHLEHQ$EHUZLHZDUGLKUDOVVLHSO|W]OLFK
IKOWHGD‰1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQLQLKUHU+DQGHUZDUPWHXQGVLFK]X
UHJHQEHJDQQ6FKQHOOVHW]WHVLHLKQZLHGHULQV)DFKGDZDFNHOWH
GDV0QGFKHQKLQXQGKHUXQGPKVDPOLVSHOWH1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQ
$FKZHUWHVWH'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXP YRUWUHIIOLFKH)UHXQGLQ
ZDVYHUGDQNHLFK,KQHQDOOHV 1HLQNHLQ%LOGHUEXFKNHLQ
&KULVWNOHLGFKHQVROOHQ6LHIUPLFKRSIHUQ VFKDIIHQ6LHQXUHLQ
6FKZHUW HLQ6FKZHUWIUGDVEULJHZLOOLFKVRUJHQPDJHU
+LHUJLQJGHP1X‰NQDFNHUGLH6SUDFKHDXVXQGVHLQHHUVW]XP
$XVGUXFNGHULQQLJVWHQ:HKPXWEHVHHOWHQ$XJHQZXUGHQZLHGHU
VWDUUXQGOHEORV0DULHHPSIDQGJDUNHLQ*UDXHQYLHOPHKUKSIWH
VLHYRU)UHXGHQGDVLHQXQHLQ0LWWHOZX‰WHGHQ1X‰NQDFNHU
RKQHZHLWHUHVFKPHU]KDIWH$XIRSIHUXQJHQ]XUHWWHQ$EHUZRQXQ
HLQ6FKZHUWIUGHQ.OHLQHQKHUQHKPHQ" 0DULHEHVFKOR‰)ULW]HQ
]X5DWH]X]LHKHQXQGHU]lKOWHLKPDEHQGVDOVVLHGDGLH(OWHUQ
DXVJHJDQJHQHLQVDPLQGHU:RKQVWXEHDP*ODVVFKUDQNVD‰HQ
DOOHVZDVLKUPLWGHP1X‰NQDFNHUXQGGHP0DXVHN|QLJ
ZLGHUIDKUHQXQGZRUDXIHVQXQDQNRPPHGHQ1X‰NQDFNHU]X
UHWWHQhEHUQLFKWVZXUGH)ULW]QDFKGHQNOLFKHUDOVGDUEHUGD‰
VLFKQDFK0DULHQV%HULFKWVHLQH+XVDUHQLQGHU6FKODFKWVR
VFKOHFKWJHQRPPHQKDEHQVROOWHQ(UIUXJQRFKHLQPDOVHKU
HUQVWREHVVLFKZLUNOLFKVRYHUKDOWHXQGQDFKGHPHV0DULHDXI
LKU:RUWYHUVLFKHUWVRJLQJ)ULW]VFKQHOOQDFKGHP*ODVVFKUDQN
KLHOWVHLQHQ+XVDUHQHLQHSDWKHWLVFKH5HGHXQGVFKQLWWGDQQ]XU
6WUDIHLKUHU6HOEVWVXFKWXQG)HLJKHLWHLQHPQDFKGHPDQGHUQ
GDV)HOG]HLFKHQYRQGHU0W]HXQGXQWHUVDJWHLKQHQDXFK
ELQQHQHLQHP-DKUGHQ*DUGHKXVDUHQPDUVFK]XEODVHQ1DFKGHP
HUVHLQ6WUDIDPWYROOHQGHWZDQGWHHUVLFKZLHGHU]X0DULHQ
VSUHFKHQG:DVGHQ6lEHOEHWULIIWVRNDQQLFKGHP1X‰NQDFNHU
KHOIHQGDLFKHLQHQDOWHQ2EULVWHQYRQGHQ.UDVVLHUVJHVWHUQPLW
3HQVLRQLQ5XKHVWDQGYHUVHW]WKDEHGHUIROJOLFKVHLQHQVFK|QHQ
VFKDUIHQ6lEHOQLFKWPHKUEUDXFKW%HVDJWHU2EULVWHUYHU]HKUWH
GLHLKPYRQ)ULW]HQDQJHZLHVHQH3HQVLRQLQGHUKLQWHUVWHQ(FNH
GHVGULWWHQ)DFKHV'RUWZXUGHHUKHUYRUJHKROWLKPGHULQGHU
7DWVFKPXFNHVLOEHUQH6lEHODEJHQRPPHQXQGGHP1X‰NQDFNHU
XPJHKlQJW

9RUEDQJHP*UDXHQNRQQWH0DULHLQGHUIROJHQGHQ1DFKWQLFKW
HLQVFKODIHQHVZDULKUXP0LWWHUQDFKWVRDOVK|UHVLHLP
:RKQ]LPPHUHLQVHOWVDPHV5XPRUHQ.OLUUHQXQG5DXVFKHQ0LW
HLQHPPDOJLQJHV4XLHN'HU0DXVHN|QLJGHU0DXVHN|QLJ
ULHI0DULHXQGVSUDQJYROO(QWVHW]HQDXVGHP%HWWH$OOHVEOLHE
VWLOODEHUEDOGNORSIWHHVOHLVHOHLVHDQGLH7UHXQGHLQIHLQHV
6WLPPFKHQOLH‰VLFKYHUQHKPHQ$OOHUEHVWH'HPRLVHOOH
6WDKOEDXPPDFKHQ6LHQXUJHWURVWDXI JXWHIU|KOLFKH
%RWVFKDIW0DULHHUNDQQWH GLH6WLPPHGHVMXQJHQ'UR‰HOPHLHU
ZDUILKU5|FNFKHQEHUXQG|IIQHWHIOXJVGLH7UH
1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQVWDQGGUDX‰HQGDVEOXWLJH6FKZHUWLQGHU
UHFKWHQHLQ:DFKVOLFKWFKHQLQGHUOLQNHQ+DQG6RZLHHU0DULHQ
HUEOLFNWHOLH‰HUVLFKDXIHLQ.QLHQLHGHUXQGVSUDFKDOVR,KUR
'DPHVHLGHVDOOHLQGLHPLFKPLW5LWWHUPXWVWlKOWHXQGPHLQHP
$UPH.UDIWJDEGHQhEHUPWLJHQ]XEHNlPSIHQGHUHVZDJWH
(XFK]XK|KQHQ8EHUZXQGHQOLHJWGHUYHUUlWHULVFKH0DXVHN|QLJ
XQGZlO]WVLFKLQVHLQHP%OXWH :ROOHWR'DPHGLH=HLFKHQGHV
6LHJHVDXVGHU+DQG(XUHV(XFKELVLQGHQ7RGHUJHEHQHQ5LWWHUV
DQ]XQHKPHQQLFKWYHUVFKPlKHQ'DPLWVWUHLIWH1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQ
GLHVLHEHQJROGHQHQ.URQHQGHV0DXVHN|QLJVGLHHUDXIGHQ
OLQNHQ$UPKHUDXIJHVWUHLIWKDWWHVHKUJHVFKLFNWKHUXQWHUXQG
EHUUHLFKWHVLH0DULHQZHOFKHVLHYROOHU)UHXGHDQQDKP
1X‰NQDFNHUVWDQGDXIXQGIXKUDOVRIRUW$FKPHLQHDOOHUEHVWH
'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXPZDVN|QQWHLFKLQGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFNHGD
LFKPHLQHQ)HLQGEHUZXQGHQ6LHIUKHUUOLFKH'LQJHVFKDXHQ
ODVVHQZHQQ6LHGLH*HZRJHQKHLWKlWWHQPLUQXQHLQSDDU
6FKULWWFKHQ]XIROJHQ 2WXQ6LHHV WXQ6LHHVEHVWH
'HPRLVHOOH
'DV3XSSHQUHLFK
,FKJODXEHNHLQVYRQHXFKLKU.LQGHUKlWWHDXFKQXUHLQHQ
$XJHQEOLFNDQJHVWDQGHQGHPHKUOLFKHQJXWPWLJHQ1X‰NQDFNHU
GHUQLH%|VHVLP6LQQKDEHQNRQQWH]XIROJHQ0DULHWDWGLHVXP
VRPHKUGDVLHZRKOZX‰WHZLHVHKUVLHDXI1X‰NQDFNHUV
'DQNEDUNHLW$QVSUXFKPDFKHQN|QQHXQGEHU]HXJWZDUGD‰HU
:RUWKDOWHQXQGYLHO+HUUOLFKHVLKU]HLJHQZHUGH6LHVSUDFK
GDKHU,FKJHKHPLW,KQHQ+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUGRFKPX‰HVQLFKW
ZHLWVHLQXQGQLFKWODQJHGDXHUQGDLFKMDQRFKJDUQLFKW
DXVJHVFKODIHQKDEH,FKZlKOHGHVKDOEHUZLGHUWH1X‰NQDFNHU
GHQQlFKVWHQZLHZRKOHWZDVEHVFKZHUOLFKHQ:HJ(UVFKULWW
YRUDQ0DULHLKPQDFKELVHUYRUGHPDOWHQPlFKWLJHQ
.OHLGHUVFKUDQNDXIGHP+DXVIOXUVWHKHQEOLHE0DULHZXUGH]X
LKUHP(UVWDXQHQJHZDKUGD‰GLH7UHQGLHVHVVRQVWZRKO
YHUVFKORVVHQHQ6FKUDQNVRIIHQVWDQGHQVRGD‰VLHGHXWOLFKGHV
9DWHUV5HLVHIXFKVSHO]HUEOLFNWHGHUJDQ]YRUQHKLQJ1X‰NQDFNHU
NOHWWHUWHVHKUJHVFKLFNWDQGHQ/HLVWHQXQG9HU]LHUXQJHQKHUDXI
GD‰HUGLHJUR‰H7URGGHOGLHDQHLQHUGLFNHQ6FKQXUEHIHVWLJW
DXIGHP5FNWHLOHMHQHV3HO]HVKLQJHUIDVVHQNRQQWH6RZLH
1X‰NQDFNHUGLHVH7URGGHOVWDUN DQ]RJOLH‰VLFKVFKQHOOHLQHVHKU
]LHUOLFKH7UHSSHYRQ=HGHUQKRO]GXUFKGHQ3HO]lUPHOKHUDE
6WHLJHQ6LHQXUJHIlOOLJVWDXIZlUWVWHXHUVWH'HPRLVHOOHULHI
1X‰NQDFNHU0DULHWDWHVDEHUNDXPZDUVLHGXUFKGHQbUPHO
JHVWLHJHQNDXPVDKVLH]XP.UDJHQKHUDXVDOVHLQEOHQGHQGHV
/LFKWLKUHQWJHJHQVWUDKOWHXQGVLHPLWHLQHPPDODXIHLQHU
KHUUOLFKGXIWHQGHQ:LHVHVWDQGYRQGHU0LOOLRQHQ)XQNHQZLH
EOLQNHQGH(GHOVWHLQHHPSRUVWUDKOWHQ:LUEHILQGHQXQVDXIGHU
.DQGLVZLHVHVSUDFK1X‰NQDFNHUZROOHQDEHUDOVEDOGMHQHV7RU
SDVVLHUHQ1XQZXUGH0DULHLQGHPVLHDXIEOLFNWHHUVWGDV
VFK|QH7RUJHZDKUZHOFKHVVLFKQXUZHQLJH6FKULWWHYRUZlUWVDXI
GHU:LHVHHUKRE(VVFKLHQJDQ]YRQZHL‰EUDXQXQGURVLQIDUEHQ
JHVSUHQNHOWHP0DUPRUHUEDXW]XVHLQDEHUDOV0DULHQlKHUNDP
VDKVLHZRKOGD‰GLHJDQ]H0DVVHDXV]XVDPPHQJHEDFNHQHQ
=XFNHUPDQGHOQXQG5RVLQHQEHVWDQGZHVKDOEGHQQDXFKZLH
1X‰NQDFNHUYHUVLFKHUWHGDV7RUGXUFKZHOFKHVVLHQXQ
GXUFKJLQJHQGDV0DQGHOQ XQG5RVLQHQWRUKLH‰*HPHLQH/HXWH
KLH‰HQHVVHKUXQ]LHPOLFKGLH6WXGHQWHQIXWWHUSIRUWH$XIHLQHU
KHUDXVJHEDXWHQ*DOHULHGLHVHV7RUHVDXJHQVFKHLQOLFKDXV
*HUVWHQ]XFNHUPDFKWHQVHFKVLQURWH:lPVHUFKHQJHNOHLGHWH
bIIFKHQGLHDOOHUVFK|QVWH-DQLWVFKDUHQPXVLNGLHPDQK|UHQ
NRQQWHVRGD‰0DULHNDXPEHPHUNWHZLHVLHLPPHUZHLWHU
ZHLWHUDXIEXQWHQ0DUPRUZLHVHQGLHDEHUQLFKWVDQGHUVZDUHQ
DOVVFK|QJHDUEHLWHWH0RUVFKHOOHQIRUWVFKULWW%DOGXPZHKWHQVLH
GLHV‰HVWHQ*HUFKHGLHDXVHLQHPZXQGHUEDUHQ:lOGFKHQ
VWU|PWHQGDVVLFKYRQEHLGHQ6HLWHQDXIWDWOQGHPGXQNHOQ
/DXEHJOlQ]WHXQGIXQNHOWHHVVRKHOOKHUYRUGD‰PDQGHXWOLFK
VHKHQNRQQWHZLHJROGHQHXQGVLOEHUQH)UFKWHDQEXQWJHIlUEWHQ
6WHQJHOQKHUDEKLQJHQXQG6WDPPXQGbVWHVLFKPLW%lQGHUQ
XQG%OXPHQVWUlX‰HQJHVFKPFNWKDWWHQJOHLFKIU|KOLFKHQ
%UDXWOHXWHQXQGOXVWLJHQ+RFK]HLWVJlVWHQ8QGZHQQGLH
2UDQJHQGIWHVLFKZLHZDOOHQGH=HSKLUHUKUWHQGDVDXVWHHVLQ
GHQ=ZHLJHQXQG%OlWWHUQXQGGDV5DXVFKJROGNQLWWHUWHXQG
NQDWWHUWHGD‰HVNODQJZLHMXEHOQGH0XVLNQDFKGHUGLH
IXQNHOQGHQ/LFKWHUFKHQKSIHQXQGWDQ]HQP‰WHQ$FKZLH
VFK|QLVWHVKLHUULHI0DULHJDQ]VHOLJXQGHQW]FNW:LUVLQGLP
:HLKQDFKWVZDOGHEHVWH'HPRLVHOOHVSUDFK1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQ
$FKIXKU0DULHIRUWGUIWLFKKLHUQXUHWZDVYHUZHLOHQRHVLVW
MDKLHUJDU]XVFK|Q1X‰NQDFNHUNODWVFKWHLQGLHNOHLQHQ
+lQGFKHQXQGVRJOHLFKNDPHQHLQLJHNOHLQH6FKlIHUXQG
6FKlIHULQQHQ-lJHUXQG-lJHULQQHQKHUEHLGLHVR]DUWXQGZHL‰
ZDUHQGD‰PDQKlWWHJODXEHQVROOHQVLHZlUHQYRQSXUHP
=XFNHUXQGGLH0DULHXQHUDFKWHWVLHLP :DOGHXPKHUVSD]LHUWHQ
QRFKQLFKWEHPHUNWKDWWH6LHEUDFKWHQHLQHQDOOHUOLHEVWHQJDQ]
JROGHQHQ/HKQVHVVHOKHUEHLOHJWHQHLQZHL‰HV.LVVHQYRQ
5HJOLVVHGDUDXIXQGOXGHQ0DULHQVHKUK|IOLFKHLQVLFKGDUDXI
QLHGHU]XODVVHQ.DXPKDWWHVLHHVJHWDQDOV6FKlIHUXQG
6FKlIHULQQHQHLQVHKUDUWLJHV%DOOHWWWDQ]WHQZR]XGLH-lJHUJDQ]
PDQLHUOLFKEOLHVHQGDQQYHUVFKZDQGHQVLHDEHUDOOHLQGHP
*HEVFKH9HU]HLKHQ6LHVSUDFK1X‰NQDFNHUYHU]HLKHQ6LH
ZHUWHVWH'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXPGD‰GHU7DQ]VRPLVHUDEHO
DXVILHODEHUGLH/HXWHZDUHQDOOHYRQXQVHUP'UDKWEDOOHWWGLH
N|QQHQQLFKWVDQGHUVPDFKHQDOVLPPHUXQGHZLJGDVVHOEHXQG
GD‰GLH-lJHUVRVFKOlIULJXQGIODXGD]XEOLHVHQGDVKDWDXFK
VHLQH8UVDFKHQ'HU=XFNHUNRUEKlQJW]ZDUEHULKUHU1DVHLQ
GHQ:HLKQDFKWVElXPHQDEHUHWZDVKRFK 'RFKZROOHQZLUQLFKW
ZDVZHQLJHVZHLWHUVSD]LHUHQ"$FKHVZDUGRFKDOOHVUHFKW
KEVFKXQGPLUKDWHVVHKUZRKOJHIDOOHQVRVSUDFK0DULH
LQGHPVLHDXIVWDQGXQGGHPYRUDQVFKUHLWHQGHQ1X‰NQDFNHU
IROJWH6LHJLQJHQHQWODQJ HLQHVV‰UDXVFKHQGHQIOVWHUQGHQ
%DFKHVDXVGHPQXQHEHQDOOGLHKHUUOLFKHQ:RKOJHUFKH]X
GXIWHQVFKLHQHQGLHGHQJDQ]HQ:DOGHUIOOWHQ(VLVWGHU
2UDQJHQEDFKVSUDFK1X‰NQDFNHUDXI%HIUDJHQGRFKVHLQHQ
VFK|QHQ'XIWDXVJHQRPPHQJOHLFKWHUQLFKW DQ*U|‰HXQG
6FK|QKHLWGHP/LPRQDGHQVWURPGHUVLFKJOHLFKLKPLQGHQ
0DQGHOPLOFKVHHHUJLH‰W,QGHU7DWYHUQDKP0DULHEDOGHLQ
VWlUNHUHV3OlWVFKHUQXQG5DXVFKHQXQGHUEOLFNWHGHQEUHLWHQ
/LPRQDGHQVWURPGHUVLFKLQVWRO]HQLVDEHOOIDUEHQHQ:HOOHQ
]ZLVFKHQJOHLFKJUQJOKHQGHQ.DUIXQNHOQOHXFKWHQGHP
*HVWUlXFKIRUWNUlXVHOWH(LQHDXVQHKPHQGIULVFKH%UXVWXQG+HU]
VWlUNHQGH.KOXQJZRJWHDXVGHPKHUUOLFKHQ:DVVHU1LFKWZHLW
GDYRQVFKOHSSWHVLFKPKVDPHLQGXQNHOJHOEHV:DVVHUIRUWGDV
DEHUXQJHPHLQV‰H'IWHYHUEUHLWHWHXQGDQGHVVHQ8IHUDOOHUOHL
VHKUKEVFKH.LQGHUFKHQVD‰HQZHOFKHNOHLQHGLFNH)LVFKH
DQJHOWHQXQGVLHDOVEDOGYHU]HKUWHQ1lKHUJHNRPPHQEHPHUNWH
0DULHGD‰GLHVH)LVFKHDXVVDKHQZLH/DPSHUWVQVVH,QHLQLJHU
(QWIHUQXQJODJHLQVHKUQHWWHV'|UIFKHQDQGLHVHP6WURPH
+lXVHU.LUFKH3IDUUKDXV6FKHXHUQDOOHVZDUGXQNHOEUDXQ
MHGRFKPLWJROGHQHQ'lFKHUQJHVFKPFNWDXFKZDUHQYLHOH
0DXHUQVREXQWJHPDOWDOVVHLHQ=LWURQDWXQG0DQGHONHUQH
GDUDXIJHNOHEW'DVLVW3IHIIHUNXFKKHLPVDJWH1X‰NQDFNHU
ZHOFKHVDP+RQLJVWURPHOLHJWHVZRKQHQJDQ]KEVFKH/HXWH
GDULQDEHUVLHVLQGPHLVWHQVYHUGULH‰OLFKZHLOVLHVHKUDQ
=DKQVFKPHU]HQOHLGHQZLUZROOHQGDKHUQLFKWHUVWKLQHLQJHKHQ
,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNEHPHUNWH0DULHHLQ6WlGWFKHQGDVDXVODXWHU
EXQWHQGXUFKVLFKWLJHQ+lXVHUQEHVWDQGXQGVHKUKEVFK
DQ]XVHKHQZDU1X‰NQDFNHUJLQJJHUDGH]XGDUDXIORVXQGQXQ
K|UWH0DULHHLQWROOHVOXVWLJHV*HW|VHXQGVDKZLHWDXVHQG
QLHGOLFKHNOHLQH/HXWFKHQYLHOHKRFKEHSDFNWH:DJHQGLHDXIGHP
0DUNWHKLHOWHQXQWHUVXFKWHQXQGDE]XSDFNHQLP%HJULIIVWDQGHQ
:DVVLHDEHUKHUYRUEUDFKWHQZDUDQ]XVHKHQZLHEXQWHV
JHIlUEWHV3DSLHUXQGZLH6FKRNRODGHWDIHOQ:LUVLQGLQ
%RQERQVKDXVHQVDJWH1X‰NQDFNHUHEHQLVWHLQH6HQGXQJDXV
GHP3DSLHUODQGHXQGYRP6FKRNRODGHQN|QLJHDQJHNRPPHQ'LH
DUPHQ%RQERQVKlXVHUZXUGHQQHXOLFKYRQGHU$UPHHGHV
0FNHQDGPLUDOVKDUWEHGURKWGHVKDOEEHU]LHKHQVLHLKUH+lXVHU
PLWGHQ*DEHQGHV3DSLHUODQGHVXQGIKUHQ6FKDQ]HQDXIYRQ
GHQWFKWLJHQ:HUNVWFNHQGLHLKQHQGHU6FKRNRODGHQN|QLJ
VDQGWH$EHUEHVWH'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXPQLFKWDOOHNOHLQHQ
6WlGWHXQG'|UIHUGLHVHV/DQGHVZROOHQZLUEHVXFKHQ ]XU
+DXSWVWDGW ]XU+DXSWVWDGW 5DVFKHLOWH1X‰NQDFNHUYRUZlUWV
XQG0DULHYROOHU1HXJLHUGHLKPQDFK1LFKWODQJHGDXHUWHHVVR
VWLHJHLQKHUUOLFKHU5RVHQGXIWDXIXQGDOOHVZDUZLHYRQHLQHP
VDQIWHQKLQKDXFKHQGHQ5RVHQVFKLPPHUXPIORVVHQ0DULH
EHPHUNWHGD‰GLHVGHU:LGHUVFKHLQHLQHVURVHQURWJOlQ]HQGHQ
:DVVHUVZDUGDVLQNOHLQHQURVDVLOEHUQHQ:HOOHQYRULKQHQKHU
ZLHLQZXQGHUOLHEOLFKHQ7|QHQXQG0HORGLHQSOlWVFKHUWHXQG
UDXVFKWH$XIGLHVHPDQPXWLJHQ*HZlVVHUGDVVLFKLPPHUPHKU
XQGPHKUZLHHLQJUR‰HU6HHDXVEUHLWHWHVFKZDPPHQVHKU
KHUUOLFKHVLOEHUZHL‰H6FKZlQHPLWJROGQHQ+DOVElQGHUQXQG
VDQJHQPLWHLQDQGHUXPGLH:HWWHGLHKEVFKHVWHQ/LHGHUZR]X
GLDPDQWQH)LVFKOHLQDXVGHQ5RVHQIOXWHQDXI XQGQLHGHUWDXFKWHQ
ZLHLPOXVWLJHQ7DQ]H$FKULHI0DULHJDQ]EHJHLVWHUWDXVDFK
GDVLVWGHU6HHZLHLKQ3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUPLUHLQVWPDFKHQ
ZROOWHZLUNOLFKXQGLFKVHOEVWELQGDV0lGFKHQGDV PLWGHQ
OLHEHQ6FKZlQFKHQNRVHQZLUG1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQOlFKHOWHVR
VS|WWLVFKZLHHV0DULHQRFKQLHPDOVDQLKPEHPHUNWKDWWHXQG
VSUDFKGDQQ6RHWZDVNDQQGHQQGRFKZRKOGHU2QNHOQLHPDOV
]XVWDQGHEULQJHQ6LHVHOEVWYLHOHKHUOLHEH'HPRLVHOOH
6WDKOEDXPGRFKODVVHQ6LHXQVGDUEHUQLFKWJUEHOQVRQGHUQ
YLHOPHKUEHUGHQ5RVHQVHHKLQEHUQDFKGHU+DXSWVWDGW
VFKLIIHQ
'LH+DXSWVWDGW
1X‰NQDFNHUOHLQNODWVFKWHDEHUPDOVLQGLHNOHLQHQ+lQGFKHQGD
ILQJGHU5RVHQVHHDQVWlUNHU]XUDXVFKHQGLH:HOOHQSOlWVFKHUWHQ
K|KHUDXIXQG0DULHQDKPZDKUZLHDXVGHU)HUQHHLQDXV
ODXWHUEXQWHQVRQQHQKHOOIXQNHOQGHQ(GHOVWHLQHQJHIRUPWHU
0XVFKHOZDJHQYRQ]ZHLJROGVFKXSSLJHQ'HOSKLQHQJH]RJHQVLFK
QDKWH=Z|OINOHLQHDOOHUOLHEVWH0RKUHQPLW0W]FKHQXQG
6FKU]FKHQDXVJOlQ]HQGHQ.ROLEULIHGHUQJHZHEWVSUDQJHQDQV
8IHUXQGWUXJHQHUVW0DULHQGDQQ1X‰NQDFNHUQVDQIWEHUGLH
:HOOHQJOHLWHQGLQGHQ:DJHQGHUVLFKDOVEDOGGXUFKGHQ6HH
IRUWEHZHJWH(LZLHZDUGDVVRVFK|QDOV0DULHLP
0XVFKHOZDJHQYRQ5RVHQGXIWXPKDXFKWYRQ5RVHQZHOOHQ
XPIORVVHQGDKLQIXKU'LHEHLGHQJROGVFKXSSLJHQ'HOSKLQH
HUKREHQLKUH1VWHUQXQGVSULW]WHQNULVWDOOHQH6WUDKOHQKRFKLQ
GLH+|KHXQGZLHGLHLQIOLPPHUQGHQXQGIXQNHOQGHQ%RJHQ
QLHGHUILHOHQGDZDUHVDOVVlQJHQ]ZHLKROGHIHLQH
6LOEHUVWLPPFKHQ:HUVFKZLPPWDXIURVLJHP6HH" GLH)HH
0FNOHLQELPELP)LVFKOHLQVLPVLP 6FKZlQH6FKZDVFKZD
*ROGYRJHOWUDUDK:HOOHQVWU|PH UKUWHXFKNOLQJHWVLQJHW
ZHKHWVSlKHW )HHOHLQ)HHOHLQNRPPWJH]RJHQ5RVHQZRJHQ
ZKOHWNKOHWVSOHWVSOWKLQDQ KLQDQ $EHUGLH]Z|OI
NOHLQHQ0RKUHQGLHKLQWHQDXIGHQ0XVFKHOZDJHQDXIJHVSUXQJHQ
ZDUHQVFKLHQHQGDV*HVLQJHGHU:DVVHUVWUDKOHQRUGHQWOLFK
EHO]XQHKPHQGHQQVLHVFKWWHOWHQLKUH6RQQHQVFKLUPHVRVHKU
GD‰GLH'DWWHOEOlWWHUDXVGHQHQVLHJHIRUPWZDUHQ
GXUFKHLQDQGHUNQLWWHUWHQXQGNQDWWHUWHQXQGGDEHLVWDPSIWHQVLH
PLWGHQ)‰HQHLQHQJDQ]VHOWVDPHQ7DNWXQGVDQJHQ.ODSS
XQGNOLSSXQGNOLSSXQGNODSSDXIXQGDE 0RKUHQUHLJHQGDUI
QLFKWVFKZHLJHQUKUWHXFK)LVFKH UKUWHXFK6FKZlQHGU|KQH
0XVFKHOZDJHQGU|KQHNODSSXQGNOLSSXQGNOLSSXQGNODSSXQG
DXIXQGDE 0RKUHQVLQGJDUOXVWLJH/HXWHVSUDFK
1X‰NQDFNHUHWZDVEHWUHWHQDEHUVLHZHUGHQPLUGHQJDQ]HQ
6HHUHEHOOLVFKPDFKHQ,QGHU7DWJLQJDXFKEDOGHLQ
VLQQYHUZLUUHQGHV*HW|VHZXQGHUEDUHU6WLPPHQORVGLHLQ6HH
XQG/XIW]XVFKZLPPHQVFKLHQHQGRFK0DULHDFKWHWHGHVVHQ
QLFKWVRQGHUQVDKLQGLHGXIWHQGHQ5RVHQZHOOHQDXVGHUHQMHGHU
LKUHLQKROGHVDQPXWLJHV0lGFKHQDQWOLW]HQWJHJHQOlFKHOWH$FK
ULHIVLHIUHXGLJLQGHPVLHGLHNOHLQHQ+lQGFKHQ]XVDPPHQVFKOXJ
DFKVFKDXHQ6LHQXUOLHEHU+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHU'DXQWHQLVWGLH
3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGLHOlFKHOWPLFKDQVRZXQGHUKROG$FK
VFKDXHQ6LHGRFKQXUOLHEHU+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHU 1X‰NQDFNHU
VHXI]WHDEHUIDVWNOlJOLFKXQGVDJWH2EHVWH'HPRLVHOOH
6WDKOEDXPGDVLVWQLFKWGLH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWGDVVLQG6LHXQG
LPPHUQXU6LHVHOEVWLPPHUQXU,KUHLJQHVKROGHV$QWOLW]GDVVR
OLHEDXVMHGHU5RVHQZHOOHOlFKHOW'DIXKU0DULHVFKQHOOPLWGHP
.RSI]XUFNVFKOR‰GLH$XJHQIHVW]XXQGVFKlPWHVLFKVHKU,Q
GHPVHOEHQ$XJHQEOLFNZXUGHVLHDXFKYRQGHQ]Z|OI0RKUHQDXV
GHP0XVFKHOZDJHQJHKREHQXQGDQGDV/DQGJHWUDJHQ6LH
EHIDQGVLFKLQHLQHPNOHLQHQ*HEVFKGDVEHLQDKHQRFKVFK|QHU
ZDUDOVGHU:HLKQDFKWVZDOGVRJOlQ]WHXQGIXQNHOWHDOOHVGDULQ
YRU]JOLFKZDUHQDEHUGLHVHOWVDPHQ)UFKWH]XEHZXQGHUQGLH
DQDOOHQ%lXPHQKLQJHQXQGQLFKWDOOHLQVHOWVDPJHIlUEWZDUHQ
VRQGHUQDXFKJDQ]ZXQGHUEDUGXIWHWHQ:LUVLQGLP
.RQILWUHQKDLQVSUDFK1X‰NQDFNHUDEHUGRUWLVWGLH
+DXSWVWDGW:DVHUEOLFNWH0DULHQXQ:LHZHUGLFKHVGHQQ
DQIDQJHQHXFKLKU.LQGHUGLH6FK|QKHLWXQG+HUUOLFKNHLWGHU
6WDGW]XEHVFKUHLEHQGLHVLFKMHW]WEUHLWEHUHLQHQUHLFKHQ
%OXPHQDQJHUKLQYRU0DULHQV$XJHQDXIWDW1LFKWDOOHLQGD‰
0DXHUQXQG7UPHLQGHQKHUUOLFKVWHQ)DUEHQSUDQJWHQVRZDU
DXFKZRKOZDVGLH)RUPGHU*HElXGHDQODQJWJDUQLFKWV
bKQOLFKHVDXI(UGHQ]XILQGHQ'HQQVWDWWGHU'lFKHUKDWWHQGLH
+lXVHU]LHUOLFKJHIORFKWHQH.URQHQDXIJHVHW]WXQGGLH7UPH
VLFKPLWGHP]LHUOLFKVWHQEXQWHVWHQ/DXEZHUNJHNUlQ]WGDVPDQ
QXUVHKHQNDQQ$OVVLHGXUFKGDV7RUZHOFKHVVRDXVVDKDOVVHL
HVYRQODXWHU0DNURQHQXQGEHU]XFNHUWHQ)UFKWHQHUEDXW
JLQJHQSUlVHQWLHUWHQVLOEHUQH6ROGDWHQGDV*HZHKUXQGHLQ
0lQQOHLQLQHLQHPEURNDWQHQ6FKODIURFNZDUIVLFKGHP
1X‰NQDFNHUDQGHQ+DOVPLWGHQ:RUWHQ:LOONRPPHQEHVWHU
3ULQ]ZLOONRPPHQLQ.RQIHNWEXUJ0DULHZXQGHUWHVLFKQLFKW
ZHQLJDOVVLHPHUNWHGD‰GHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUYRQHLQHPVHKU
YRUQHKPHQ0DQQDOV3ULQ]DQHUNDQQWZXUGH1XQK|UWHVLHDEHU
VRYLHOIHLQH6WLPPFKHQGXUFKHLQDQGHUWREHQVROFKHLQ*HMXFK]H
XQG*HOlFKWHUVROFKHLQ6SLHOHQXQG6LQJHQGD‰VLHDQQLFKWV
DQGHUVGHQNHQNRQQWHVRQGHUQQXUJOHLFK1X‰NQDFNHUFKHQ
IUDJWHZDVGHQQGDV]XEHGHXWHQKDEH"2KHVWH'HPRLVHOOH
6WDKOEDXPHUZLGHUWH1X‰NQDFNHUGDVLVWQLFKWV%HVRQGHUHV
.RQIHNWEXUJLVWHLQHYRONUHLFKHOXVWLJH6WDGWGDJHKW VDOOH7DJH
VRKHUNRPPHQ6LHDKHUQXUJHIlOOLJVWZHLWHU.DXPZDUHQVLH
HLQLJH6FKULWWHJHJDQJHQDOVVLHDXIGHQJUR‰HQ0DUNWSODW]
NDPHQGHUGHQKHUUOLFKVWHQ$QEOLFNJHZlKUWH$OOH+lXVHU
ULQJVXPKHUZDUHQYRQGXUFKEURFKHQHU=XFNHUDUEHLW*DOHULHEHU
*DOHULHJHWUPWLQGHU0LWWHVWDQGHLQKRKHUKHU]XFNHUWHU
%DXPNXFKHQDOV2EHOLVNXQGXPLKQKHUVSUW]WHQYLHUVHKU
NQVWOLFKH)RQWlQHQ2UVDGH/LPRQDGHXQGDQGHUHKHUUOLFKH
V‰H*HWUlQNHLQGLH/IWHXQGLQGHP%HFNHQVDPPHOWHVLFK
ODXWHU&UHPHGHQPDQJOHLFKKlWWHDXVO|IIHOQP|JHQ$EHU
KEVFKHUDOVDOOHVGDVZDUHQGLHDOOHUOLHEVWHQNOHLQHQ/HXWFKHQ
GLHVLFK]X7DXVHQGHQ.RSIDQ.RSIGXUFKHLQDQGHUGUlQJWHQXQG
MXFK]WHQXQGODFKWHQXQGVFKHU]WHQXQGVDQJHQNXU]MHQHV
OXVWLJH*HW|VHHUKREHQGDV0DULHVFKRQLQGHU)HUQHJHK|UW
KDWWH'DJDEHVVFK|QJHNOHLGHWH+HUUHQXQG'DPHQ$UPHQLHU
XQG*ULHFKHQ-XGHQXQG7LUROHU2IIL]LHUHXQG6ROGDWHQXQG
3UHGLJHUXQG6FKlIHUXQG+DQVZUVWHNXU]DOOHQXUP|JOLFKH
/HXWHZLHVLHLQGHU:HOW]XILQGHQVLQG$QGHUHLQHQ(FNHZXUGH
JU|‰HUGHU7XPXOWGDV9RONVWU|PWHDXVHLQDQGHUGHQQHEHQOLH‰
VLFKGHU*UR‰PRJXODXIHLQHP3DODQNLQYRUEHUWUDJHQEHJOHLWHW
YRQGUHLXQGQHXQ]LJ*UR‰HQGHV5HLFKVXQGVLHEHQKXQGHUW
6NODYHQ(VEHJDEVLFKDEHUGD‰DQGHUDQGHUQ(FNHGLH
)LVFKHU]XQIWDQIQIKXQGHUW.|SIHVWDUNLKUHQ)HVW]XJKLHOWXQG
KHOZDUHVDXFKGD‰GHUWUNLVFKH*UR‰KHUUJHUDGHGHQ(LQIDOO
KDWWH PLWGUHLWDXVHQG-DQLWVFKDUHQEHUGHQ0DUNW
VSD]LHUHQ]XUHLWHQZR]XQRFKGHUJUR‰H=XJDXVGHP
XQWHUEURFKHQHQ2SIHUIHVWHNDPGHUPLWNOLQJHQGHP6SLHOXQG
GHP*HVDQJH$XIGDQNHWGHUPlFKWLJHQ6RQQHJHUDGHDXI
GHQ%DXPNXFKHQ]XZDOOWH'DVZDUHLQ'UlQJHQXQG6WR‰HQXQG
7UHLEHQXQG*HTXLHNH %DOGJDEHVDXFKYLHO-DPPHUJHVFKUHL
GHQQHLQ)LVFKHUKDWWHLP*HGUlQJHHLQHP%UDKPLQGHQ.RSI
DEJHVWR‰HQXQGGHU*UR‰PRJXOZlUHEHLQDKHYRQHLQHP
+DQVZXUVWEHUUDQQWZRUGHQ7ROOHUXQGWROOHUZXUGHGHU/lUP
XQGPDQILQJEHUHLWVDQVLFK]XVWR‰HQXQG]XSUJHOQDOVGHU
0DQQLPEURNDWQHQ6FKODIURFNGHUDP7RUGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUDOV
3ULQ]KHJU‰WKDWWHDXIGHQ%DXPNXFKHQNOHWWHUWHXQGQDFKGHP
HLQHVHKUKHOONOLQJHQGH*ORFNHGUHLPDODQJH]RJHQZRUGHQ
GUHLPDOODXWULHI.RQGLWRU.RQGLWRU.RQGLWRU6RJOHLFKOHJWH
VLFKGHU7XPXOWHLQMHGHUVXFKWHVLFK]XEHKHOIHQZLHHUNRQQWH
XQGQDFKGHPGLHYHUZLFNHOWHQ=JHVLFKHQWZLFNHOWKDWWHQGHU
EHVXGHOWH*UR‰PRJXODEJHEUVWHWXQGGHP%UDKPLQGHU.RSI
ZLHGHUDXIJHVHW]WZRUGHQJLQJGDVYRULJHOXVWLJH*HW|VHDXIV
QHXHORV:DVEHGHXWHWGDVPLWGHP.RQGLWRUJXWHU+HUU
'UR‰HOPHLHUIUDJWH0DULH$FKEHVWH'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOKDXP
HUZLGHUWH1X‰NQDFNHU.RQGLWRUZLUGKLHUHLQHXQEHNDQQWHDEHU
VHKUJUDXOLFKH0DFKWJHQDQQWYRQGHUPDQJODXEWGD‰VLHDXV
GHP0HQVFKHQPDFKHQN|QQHZDVVLHZROOHHVLVWGDV
9HUKlQJQLVZHOFKHVEHUGLHVNOHLQHOXVWLJH9RONUHJLHUWXQGVLH
IUFKWHQGLHVHVVRVHKUGD‰GXUFKGLHEOR‰H1HQQXQJGHV
1DPHQVGHUJU|‰WH7XPXOWJHVWLOOWZHUGHQNDQQZLH HVHEHQGHU
+HUU%UJHUPHLVWHUEHZLHVHQKDW(LQMHGHUGHQNWGDQQQLFKW
PHKUDQ,UGLVFKHVDQ5LSSHQVW|‰HXQG.RSIEHXOHQVRQGHUQ
JHKWLQVLFKXQGVSULFKW:DVLVWGHU0HQVFKXQGZDVNDQQDXV
LKPZHUGHQ"  (LQHVODXWHQ5XIVGHU%HZXQGHUXQJMDGHV
K|FKVWHQ(UVWDXQHQVNRQQWHVLFK0DULHQLFKWHQWKDOWHQDOVVLH
MHW]WPLWHLQHPPDOYRUHLQHPLQURVHQURWHP6FKLPPHUKHOO
OHXFKWHQGHQ6FKORVVHPLWKXQGHUWOXIWLJHQ7UPHQVWDQG1XUKLQ
XQGZLHGHUZDUHQUHLFKH%RXTXHWVYRQ9HLOFKHQ1DU]LVVHQ
7XOSHQ/HYNRMHQDXIGLH0DXHUQJHVWUHXWGHUHQ
GXQNHOEUHQQHQGH)DUEHQQXUGLHEOHQGHQGHLQV5RVDVSLHOHQGH
:HL‰HGHV*UXQGHVHUK|KWHQ'LHJUR‰H.XSSHOGHV
0LWWHOJHElXGHVVRZLHGLHS\UDPLGHQI|UPLJHQ'lFKHUGHU7UPH
ZDUHQPLWWDXVHQGJROGHQXQGVLOEHUQIXQNHOQGHQ6WHUQOHLQ
EHVlHW1XQVLQGZLUYRUGHP0DU]LSDQVFKOR‰VSUDFK
1X‰NQDFNHU0DULHZDUJDQ]YHUORUHQLQGHP$QEOLFNGHV
=DXEHUSDODVWHVGRFKHQWJLQJHVLKUQLFKWGD‰GDV'DFKHLQHV
JUR‰HQ7XUPHVJlQ]OLFKIHKOWHZHOFKHVNOHLQH0lQQHUFKHQGLH
DXIHLQHPYRQ=LPWVWDQJHQHUEDXWHQ*HUVWHVWDQGHQ
ZLHGHUKHUVWHOOHQ]XZROOHQVFKLHQHQ1RFKHKHVLHGHQ
1X‰NQDFNHUGDUXPEHIUDJWHIXKUGLHVHUIRUW9RUNXU]HU=HLW
GURKWHGLHVHPVFK|QHQ6FKOR‰DUJH9HUZVWXQJZRQLFKW
JlQ]OLFKHU8QWHUJDQJ'HU5LHVH/HFNHUPDXONDPGHV:HJHV
JHJDQJHQEL‰VFKQHOOGDV'DFKMHQHV7XUPHVKHUXQWHUXQGQDJWH
VFKRQDQGHUJUR‰HQ.XSSHOGLH.RQIHNWEUJHUEUDFKWHQLKP
DEHUHLQJDQ]HV6WDGWYLHUWHOVRZLHHLQHQDQVHKQOLFKHQ7HLOGHV
.RQILWUHQKDLQVDOV7ULEXWZRPLWHUVLFKDEVSHLVHQOLH‰XQG
ZHLWHUJLQJ,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNOLH‰VLFKHLQHVHKUDQJHQHKPH
VDQIWH0XVLNK|UHQGLH7RUHGHV6FKORVVHV|IIQHWHQVLFKXQGHV
WUDWHQ]Z|OINOHLQH3DJHQKHUDXVPLWDQJH]QGHWHQ
*HZU]QHONVWHQJHOQGLHVLHZLH)DFNHOQLQGHQNOHLQHQ+lQGFKHQ
WUXJHQ,KUH.|SIHEHVWDQGHQDXVHLQHU3HUOHGLH/HLEHUDXV
5XELQHQXQG6PDUDJGHQXQGGD]XJLQJHQVLHDXIVHKUVFK|QDXV
SXUHP*ROGJHDUEHLWHWHQ)‰FKHQHLQKHU,KQHQIROJWHQYLHU
'DPHQEHLQDKHVRJUR‰DOV0DULHQV&OlUFKHQDEHUVREHUGLH
0D‰HQKHUUOLFKXQGJOlQ]HQGJHSXW]WGD‰0DULHQLFKWHLQHQ
$XJHQEOLFNLQLKQHQGLHJHERUQHQ3ULQ]HVVLQQHQYHUNDQQWH6LH
XPDUPWHQGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUDXIGDV]lUWOLFKVWHXQGULHIHQGDEHL
ZHKPWLJIUHXGLJ2PHLQ3ULQ] PHLQEHVWHU3ULQ] RPHLQ
%UXGHU1X‰NQDFNHUVFKLHQVHKUJHUKUWHUZLVFKWHVLFKGLHVHKU
KlXILJHQ7UlQHQDXVGHQ$XJHQHUJULIIGDQQ0DULHQEHLGHU+DQG
XQGVSUDFKSDWKHWLVFK'LHVLVWGLH'HPRLVHOOH0DULH6WDKOEDXP
GLH7RFKWHUHLQHVVHKUDFKWXQJVZHUWHQ0HGL]LQDOUDWHVXQGGLH
5HWWHULQPHLQHV/HEHQV:DUIVLHQLFKWGHQ3DQWRIIHO]XUUHFKWHQ
=HLWYHUVFKDIIWHVLHPLUQLFKWGHQ6lEHOGHVSHQVLRQLHUWHQ
2EULVWHQVROlJLFK]HUELVVHQYRQGHPIOXFKZUGLJHQ
0DXVHN|QLJLP*UDEH 2KGLHVHU'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXP
JOHLFKWLKUZRKO3LUOLSDWREVFKRQVLHHLQHJHERUQH3ULQ]HVVLQLVW
DQ6FK|QKHLW*WHXQG7XJHQG" 1HLQVDJLFKQHLQ$OOH
'DPHQULHIHQ1HLQXQGILHOHQGHU0DULHXPGHQ+DOVXQG
ULHIHQVFKOXFK]HQG26LHHGOH5HWWHULQGHVJHOLHEWHQSULQ]OLFKHQ
%UXGHUV YRUWUHIIOLFKH'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXP 1XQJHOHLWHWHQ
GLH 'DPHQ0DULHQXQGGHQ1X‰NQDFNHULQGDV,QQHUHGHV
6FKORVVHVXQG]ZDULQHLQHQ6DDOGHVVHQ:lQGHDXVODXWHU
IDUELJIXQNHOQGHQ.ULVWDOOHQEHVWDQGHQ:DVDEHUYRUDOOHP
EULJHQGHU0DULHVRZRKOJHILHOZDUHQGLHDOOHUOLHEVWHQNOHLQHQ
6WKOH7LVFKH.RPPRGHQ6HNUHWlUVXVZGLHULQJVKHUXP
VWDQGHQXQGGLHDOOHYRQ=HGHUQ RGHU%UDVLOLHQKRO]PLW
GDUDXIJHVWUHXWHQJROGQHQ%OXPHQYHUIHUWLJWZDUHQ'LH
3ULQ]HVVLQQHQQ|WLJWHQ0DULHQXQGGHQ1X‰NQDFNHU]XP6LW]HQ
XQGVDJWHQGD‰VLHVRJOHLFKVHOEVWHLQ0DKOEHUHLWHQZROOWHQ1XQ
KROWHQVLHHLQH0HQJHNOHLQHU7|SIFKHQXQG6FKVVHOFKHQYRQ
GHPIHLQVWHQMDSDQLVFKHQ3RU]HOODQ/|IIHO0HVVHUXQG*DEHOQ
5HLEHLVHQ.DVVHUROOHQXQGDQGHUH.FKHQEHGUIQLVVHYRQ*ROG
XQG6LOEHUKHUEHL'DQQEUDFKWHQVLHGLHVFK|QVWHQ)UFKWHXQG
=XFNHUZHUNZLHHV0DULHQRFKQLHPDOVJHVHKHQKDWWHXQGILQJHQ
DQDXIGDV]LHUOLFKVWHPLWGHQNOHLQHQVFKQHHZHL‰HQ+lQGFKHQ
GLH)UFKWHDXV]XSUHVVHQGDV*HZU]]XVWR‰HQGLH
=XFNHUPDQGHOQ]XUHLEHQNXU]VR]XZLUWVFKDIWHQGD‰0DULH
ZRKOHLQVHKHQNRQQWHZLHJXWVLFKGLH3ULQ]HVVLQQHQDXIGDV
.FKHQZHVHQYHUVWDQGHQXQGZDVGDVIUHLQN|VWOLFKHV0DKO
JHEHQZUGH,POHEKDIWHQ*HIKOVLFKDXIGHUJOHLFKHQ'LQJH
HEHQIDOOVUHFKWJXW]XYHUVWHKHQZQVFKWHVLHKHLPOLFKEHLGHP
*HVFKlIWGHU3ULQ]HVVLQQHQVHOEVWWlWLJVHLQ]XN|QQHQ'LH
VFK|QVWHYRQ1X‰NQDFNHUV6FKZHVWHUQDOVREVLH0DULHQV
JHKHLPHQ:XQVFKHUUDWHQKlWWHUHLFKWHLKUHLQHQNOHLQHQJROGQHQ
0|UVHUPLWGHQ:RUWHQKLQ2V‰H)UHXQGLQWHXUH5HWWHULQ
PHLQHV%UXGHUVVWR‰HHLQH:HQLJNHLWYRQGLHVHP=XFNHUNDQGHO
$OV0DULHQXQVRZRKOJHPXWLQGHQ0|UVHUVWLH‰GD‰HUJDU
DQPXWLJXQGOLHEOLFKZLHHLQKEVFKHV/LHGOHLQHUW|QWHILQJ
1X‰NQDFNHUDQVHKUZHLWOlXIWLJ]XHU]lKOHQZLHHVEHLGHU
JUDXVHQYROOHQ6FKODFKW]ZLVFKHQVHLQHPXQGGHV0DXVHN|QLJV
+HHUHUJDQJHQZLHHUGHU)HLJKHLWVHLQHU7UXSSHQKDOEHU
JHVFKODJHQZRUGHQZLHGDQQGHUDEVFKHXOLFKH0DXVHN|QLJLKQ
GXUFKDXV]HUEHL‰HQZROOHQXQG0DULHGHVKDOEPHKUHUHVHLQHU
8QWHUWDQHQGLHLQLKUH'LHQVWHJHJDQJHQDXIRSIHUQPVVHQ
XVZ 0DULHQZDUHVEHLGLHVHU(U]lKOXQJDOVNOlQJHQVHLQH
:RUWHMDVHOEVWLKUH0|UVHUVW|‰HLPPHUIHUQHUXQG
XQYHUQHKPOLFKHUEDOGVDKVLHVLOEHUQH)O|UHZLHGQQH
1HEHOZRONHQDXIVWHLJHQLQGHQHQGLH3ULQ]HVVLQQHQGLH3DJHQ
GHU1X‰NQDFNHUMDVLHVHOEVWVFKZDPPHQ HLQVHOWVDPHV6LQJHQ
XQG6FKZLUUHQXQG6XPPHQOLH‰VLFKYHUQHKPHQGDVZLHLQGLH
:HLWHKLQYHUUDXVFKWHQXQKREVLFK0DULHZLHDXIVWHLJHQGHQ
:HOOHQLPPHUK|KHUXQGK|KHU K|KHUXQGK|KHU K|KHUXQG
K|KHU
%HVFKOX‰
3UU 3XIIJLQJHV 0DULHILHOKHUDEDXVXQHUPH‰OLFKHU+|KH
'DVZDUHLQ5XFN $EHUJOHLFKVFKOXJVLHDXFKGLH$XJHQDXIGD
ODJVLHLQLKUHP%HWWFKHQHVZDUKHOOHU7DJXQGGLH0XWWHUVWDQG
YRULKUVSUHFKHQG$EHUZLHNDQQPDQDXFKVRODQJHVFKODIHQ
OlQJVWLVWGDV)UKVWFNGD'XPHUNVWHVZRKOYHUVDPPHOWHV
K|FKVWJHHKUWHV3XEOLNXPGD‰0DULHJDQ]EHWlXEWYRQDOOGHQ
:XQGHUGLQJHQGLHVLHJHVHKHQHQGOLFKLP6DDOGHV
0DU]LSDQVFKORVVHVHLQJHVFKODIHQZDUXQGGD‰GLH0RKUHQRGHU
GLH3DJHQRGHUJDUGLH3ULQ]HVVLQQHQVHOEVWVLH]X+DXVH
JHWUDJHQXQGLQV%HWWJHOHJWKDWWHQ20XWWHUOLHEH0XWWHUZR
KDWPLFKGHUMXQJH+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUGLHVH1DFKWEHUDOO
KLQJHIKUWZDVKDEHLFKDOOHV6FK|QHVJHVHKHQ1XQHU]lKOWH
VLHDOOHVEHLQDKHVRJHQDXZLHLFKHVVRHEHQHU]lKOW KDEHXQG
GLH0XWWHUVDKVLHJDQ]YHUZXQGHUWDQ$OV0DULHJHHQGHWVDJWH
GLH0XWWHU'XKDVWHLQHQODQJHQVHKUVFK|QHQ7UDXPJHKDEW
OLHEH0DULHDEHUVFKODJGLUGDVDOOHVQXUDXVGHP6LQQ0DULH
EHVWDQGKDUWQlFNLJGDUDXIGD‰VLHQLFKWJHWUlXPWVRQGHUQDOOHV
ZLUNOLFKJHVHKHQKDEHGDIKUWHGLH0XWWHUVLHDQGHQ
*ODVVFKUDQNQDKPGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUGHUZLHJHZ|KQOLFKLP
GULWWHQ)DFKHVWDQGKHUDXVXQGVSUDFK:LHNDQQVWGXGX
DOEHUQHV0lGFKHQQXUJODXEHQGD‰GLHVH1UQEHUJHU+RO]SXSSH
/HEHQXQG%HZHJXQJKDEHQNDQQ$EHUOLHEH0XWWHUILHO
0DULHHLQLFKZHL‰HVMDZRKOGD‰GHUNOHLQH1X‰NQDFNHUGHU
MXQJH+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUDXV1UQEHUJ3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUV1HIIH
LVW'DEUDFKHQEHLGHGHU0HGL]LQDOUDWXQGGLH0HGL]LQDOUlWLQLQ
HLQVFKDOOHQGHV*HOlFKWHUDXV$FKIXKU0DULHEHLQDKHZHLQHQG
IRUWQXQODFKVWGXJDUPHLQHQ1X‰NQDFNHUDXVOLHEHU9DWHUXQG
HUKDWGRFKYRQGLUVHKUJXWJHVSURFKHQGHQQDOVZLULP
0DU]LSDQVFKOR‰DQNDPHQXQGHUPLFKVHLQHQ6FKZHVWHUQGHQ
3ULQ]HVVLQQHQYRUVWHOOWHVDJWHHUGXVHLVWHLQVHKU
DFKWXQJVZHUWHU0HGL]LQDOUDW 1RFKVWlUNHUZXUGHGDV
*HOlFKWHULQGDVDXFK/XLVHMDVRJDU)ULW]HLQVWLPPWH'DOLHI
0DULHLQVDQGHUH=LPPHUKROWHVFKQHOODXVLKUHPNOHLQHQ
.lVWFKHQGLHVLHEHQ.URQHQGHV0DXVHN|QLJVKHUEHLXQG
EHUUHLFKWHVLHGHU0XWWHUPLWGHQ:RUWHQ'DVLHKQXUOLHEH
0XWWHUGDVVLQGGLHVLHEHQ.URQHQGHV0DXVHN|QLJVGLHPLULQ
YRULJHU1DFKWGHUMXQJH+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHU]XP=HLFKHQVHLQHV
6LHJHVEHUUHLFKWH9ROO(UVWDXQHQEHWUDFKWHWHGLH0HGL]LQDOUlWLQ
GLHNOHLQHQ.U|QFKHQGLHYRQHLQHPJDQ]XQEHNDQQWHQDEHUVHKU
IXQNHOQGHQ0HWDOOVRVDXEHUJHDUEHLWHWZDUHQDOVKlWWHQ
0HQVFKHQKlQGHGDVXQP|JOLFKYROOEULQJHQN|QQHQ$XFKGHU
0HGL]LQDOUDWNRQQWHVLFKQLFKWVDWWVHKHQDQGHQ.U|QFKHQXQG
EHLGH9DWHUXQG0XWWHUGUDQJHQVHKUHUQVWLQ0DULHQ]X
JHVWHKHQZRVLHGLH.U|QFKHQKHUKDEH"6LHNRQQWHMDDEHUQXU
KHLGHPZDVVLHJHVDJWVWHKHQEOHLEHQXQGDOVVLHQXQGHU9DWHU
KDUWDQOLH‰XQGVLHVRJDUHLQHNOHLQH/JQHULQVFKDOWGDILQJVLH
DQKHIWLJ]XZHLQHQ XQGNODJWH$FKLFKDUPHV.LQGLFKDUPHV
.LQGZDVVROOLFKGHQQQXQVDJHQ,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNJLQJGLH
7UDXI'HU2EHUJHULFKWVUDWWUDWKLQHLQXQGULHI:DVLVWGD
ZDVLVWGD"PHLQ3DWFKHQ0DULHZHLQWXQGVFKOXFK]W" :DVLVWGD
 ZDVLVWGD"'HU 0HGL]LQDOUDWXQWHUULFKWHWHLKQYRQDOOHPZDV
JHVFKHKHQLQGHPHULKPGLH.U|QFKHQ]HLJWH.DXPKDWWHGHU
2KHUJHULFKWVUDWDEHUGLHVHDQJHVHKHQDOVHUODFKWHXQGULHI
7ROOHU6FKQDFNWROOHU6FKQDFNGDVVLQGMDGLH.U|QFKHQGLHLFK
YRU-DKUHQDQPHLQHU8KUNHWWHWUXJXQGGLHLFKGHUNOHLQHQ0DULH
DQLKUHP*HEXUWVWDJHDOVVLH]ZHL-DKUHDOWZRUGHQVFKHQNWH
:L‰WLKU VGHQQQLFKWPHKU":HGHUGHU0HGL]LQDOUDWQRFKGLH
0HGL]LQDOUlWLQNRQQWHQVLFKGHVVHQHULQQHUQDOVDEHU0DULH
ZDKUQDKPGD‰GLH*HVLFKWHUGHU(OWHUQZLHGHUIUHXQGOLFK
JHZRUGHQGDVSUDQJVLHORVDXI3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUXQGULHI$FK
GXZHL‰WMDDOOHV3DWH'UR‰HOPHLHUVDJHVGRFKQXUVHOEVWGD‰
PHLQ1X‰NQDFNHUGHLQ1HIIHGHUMXQJH+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUDXV
1UQEHUJLVWXQGGD‰HUPLUGLH.U|QFKHQJHVFKHQNWKDW 'HU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWPDFKWHDKHUHLQVHKUILQVWHUHV*HVLFKWXQG
PXUPHOWH'XPPHUHLQIlOWLJHU6FKQDFN'DUDXIQDKPGHU
0HGL]LQDOUDWGLHNOHLQH0DULHYRUVLFKXQGVSUDFKVHKUHUQVWKDIW
+|UPDO0DULHOD‰QXQHLQPDOGLH(LQELOGXQJHQXQG3RVVHQXQG
ZHQQGXQRFKHLQPDOVSULFKVWGD‰GHUHLQIlOWLJHPL‰JHVWDOWHWH
1X‰NQDFNHUGHU1HIIHGHV+HUUQ2EHUJHULFKWVUDWVVHLVRZHUILFK
QLFKWDOOHLQGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUVRQGHUQDXFKDOOHGHLQHEULJHQ
3XSSHQ0DPVHOO&OlUFKHQQLFKWDXVJHQRPPHQGXUFKV)HQVWHU
 1XQGXUIWHIUHLOLFKGLHDUPH0DULHJDUQLFKWPHKUGDYRQ
VSUHFKHQZRYRQGHQQGRFKLKUJDQ]HV*HPWHUIOOWZDUGHQQ
LKUP|JHWHVHXFKZRKOGHQNHQGD‰PDQVROFK+HUUOLFKHVXQG
6FK|QHVZLHHV0DULHQZLGHUIDKUHQJDUQLFKWYHUJHVVHQNDQQ
6HOEVW VHKUJHHKUWHU/HVHURGHU=XK|UHU)ULW] VHOEVWGHLQ
.DPHUDG)ULW]6WDKOEDXPGUHKWHGHU6FKZHVWHUVRJOHLFKGHQ
5FNHQZHQQVLHLKPYRQGHP:XQGHUUHLFKHLQGHPVLHVR
JOFNOLFKZDUHU]lKOHQZROOWH(UVROOVRJDUPDQFKPDO]ZLVFKHQ
GHQ=lKQHQJHPXUPHOWKDEHQ(LQIlOWLJH*DQVGRFKGDVNDQQ
LFKVHLQHUVRQVWHUSUREWHQJXWHQ*HPWVDUWKDOEHUQLFKWJODXEHQ
VRYLHOLVWDEHUJHZL‰GD‰GDHUQXQDQQLFKWVPHKUZDVLKP
0DULHHU]lKOWHJODXEWHHUVHLQHQ+XVDUHQEHL|IIHQWOLFKHU3DUDGH
GDVLKQHQJHVFKHKHQH8QUHFKWI|UPOLFKDEEDWLKQHQVWDWWGHU
YHUORUQHQ)HOG]HLFKHQYLHOK|KHUHVFK|QHUH%VFKHYRQ
*lQVHNLHOHQDQKHIWHWHXQGLKQHQDXFKZLHGHUHUODXEWHGHQ
*DUGHKXVDUHQPDUVFK]XEODVHQ1XQ ZLUZLVVHQDPEHVWHQZLH
HVPLWGHP0XWGHU+XVDUHQDXVVDKDOVVLHYRQGHQKl‰OLFKHQ
.XJHOQ)OHFNHDXIGLHURWHQ:lPVHUNULHJWHQ

6SUHFKHQGXUIWHQXQ0DULHQLFKWPHKUYRQLKUHP$EHQWHXHUDEHU
GLH%LOGHUMHQHVZXQGHUEDUHQ)HHQUHLFKVXPJDXNHOWHQVLHLQ
V‰ZRJHQGHP5DXVFKHQXQGLQKROGHQOLHEOLFKHQ.OlQJHQVLHVDK
DOOHVQRFKHLQPDOVRZLHVLHQXULKUHQ6LQQIHVWGDUDXIULFKWHWH
XQGVRNDPHVGD‰VLHVWDWW]XVSLHOHQZLHVRQVWVWDUUXQGVWLOO
WLHILQVLFKJHNHKUWGDVLW]HQNRQQWHZHVKDOEVLHYRQDOOHQHLQH
NOHLQH7UlXPHULQJHVFKROWHQZXUGH(VEHJDEVLFKGD‰ GHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWHLQPDOHLQH8KULQGHP+DXVHGHV0HGL]LQDOUDWV
UHSDULHUWH0DULHVD‰DP*ODVVFKUDQNXQGVFKDXWHLQLKUH
7UlXPHYHUWLHIWGHQ1X‰NQDFNHUDQGDIXKUHVLKUZLH
XQZLOONUOLFKKHUDXV$FKOLHEHU+HUU'UR‰HOPHLHUZHQQ6LH
GRFKQXUZLUNOLFKOHEWHQLFKZUG VQLFKWVRPDFKHQZLH
3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWXQG6LHYHUVFKPlKHQZHLO6LHXP
PHLQHWZLOOHQDXIJHK|UWKDEHQHLQKEVFKHUMXQJHU0DQQ]X
VHLQ7QGHP$XJHQEOLFNVFKULHGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW+HLKHL
WROOHU6FKQDFN$EHULQGHP$XJHQEOLFNJHVFKDKDXFKHLQVROFKHU
.QDOOXQG5XFNGD‰0DULHRKQPlFKWLJYRP6WXKOHVDQN$OVVLH
ZLHGHUHUZDFKWHZDUGLH0XWWHUXPVLHEHVFKlIWLJWXQGVSUDFK
$EHUZLHNDQQVWGXQXUYRP6WXKOHIDOOHQHLQVRJUR‰HV
0lGFKHQ +LHULVWGHU1HIIHGHV+HUUQ2EHUJHULFKWVUDWVDXV
1UQEHUJDQJHNRPPHQ VHLKEVFKDUWLJ 6LHEOLFNWHDXIGHU
2EHUJHULFKWVUDWKDWWHZLHGHUVHLQH*ODVSHUFNHDXIJHVHW]W
VHLQHQJHOEHQ5RFNDQJH]RJHQXQGOlFKHOWHVHKU]XIULHGHQDEHU
DQVHLQHU+DQGKLHOWHUHLQHQ]ZDUNOHLQHQDEHUVHKU
ZRKOJHZDFKVHQHQMXQJHQ0DQQ:LH0LOFKXQG%OXWZDUVHLQ
*HVLFKWFKHQHUWUXJHLQHQKHUUOLFKHQURWHQ5RFNPLW*ROG
ZHL‰VHLGHQH6WUPSIHXQG6FKXKHKDWWHLP-DERWHLQ
DOOHUOLHEVWHV%OXPHQERXTXHWZDUVHKU]LHUOLFKIULVLHUWXQG
JHSXGHUWXQGKLQWHQEHUGHQ5FNHQKLQJLKPHLQJDQ]
YRUWUHIIOLFKHU=RSIKHUDE'HUNOHLQH'HJHQDQVHLQHU6HLWHVFKLHQ
YRQODXWHU-XZHOHQVREOLW]WHHUXQGGDV+WOHLQXQWHUP$UPYRQ
6HLGHQIORFNHQJHZHEW:HOFKHDQJHQHKPH6LWWHQGHUMXQJH0DQQ
EHVD‰EHZLHVHUJOHLFKGDGXUFKGD‰HU0DULHQHLQH0HQJH
KHUUOLFKHU6SLHOVDFKHQYRU]JOLFKDEHUGHQVFK|QVWHQ0DU]LSDQ
XQGGLHVHOEHQ)LJXUHQZHOFKHGHU0DXVHN|QLJ]HUELVVHQGHP
)ULW]DEHUHLQHQZXQGHUVFK|QHQ6lEH,PLWJHEUDFKWKDWWH%HL
7LVFKHNQDFNWHGHU$UWLJHIUGLHJDQ]H*HVHOOVFKDIW1VVHDXI
GLHKlUWHVWHQZLGHUVWDQGHQLKPQLFKWPLWGHUUHFKWHQ+DQG
VWHFNWHHUVLHLQGHQ0XQGPLWGHUOLQNHQ]RJHUGHQ=RSIDQ
.UDN ]HUILHOGLH1X‰LQ6WFNH 0DULHZDUJOXWURWJHZRUGHQDOV
VLHGHQMXQJHQDUWLJHQ0DQQHUEOLFNWHXQGQRFKU|WHUZXUGHVLH
DOVQDFK7LVFKHGHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUVLHHLQOXGPLWLKPLQGDV
:RKQ]LPPHUDQGHQ*ODVVFKUDQN]XJHKHQ6SLHOWQXUKEVFK
PLWHLQDQGHULKU.LQGHULFKKDEHQXQGDDOOHPHLQH8KUHQULFKWLJ
JHKHQQLFKWVGDJHJHQULHIGHU2EHUJHULFKWVUDW.DXPZDUDEHU
GHUMXQJH'UR‰HOPHLHUPLW0DULHQDOOHLQDOVHUVLFKDXIHLQ.QLH
QLHGHUOLH‰XQGDOVRVSUDFK2PHLQHDOOHUYRUWUHIIOLFKVWH
'HPRLVHOOH6WDKOEDXPVHKQ6LHKLHU]X,KUHQ)‰HQGHQ
EHJOFNWHQ'UR‰HOPHLHUGHP6LHDQGLHVHU6WHOOHGDV/HEHQ
UHWWHWHQ6LHVSUDFKHQHVJWLJVWDXVGD‰6LHPLFKQLFKWZLHGLH
JDUVWLJH3ULQ]HVVLQ3LUOLSDWYHUVFKPlKHQZROOWHQZHQQLFK
,KUHWZLOOHQKl‰OLFKJHZRUGHQ VRJOHLFKK|UWHLFKDXIHLQ
VFKQ|GHU1X‰NQDFNHU]XVHLQXQGHUKLHOWPHLQHYRULJHQLFKW
XQDQJHQHKPH*HVWDOWZLHGHU2YRUWUHIIOLFKH'HPRLVHOOH
EHJOFNHQ6LHPLFKPLW,KUHUZHUWHQ+DQGWHLOHQ6LHPLWPLU
5HLFKXQG.URQHKHUUVFKHQ6LHPLWPLUDXI0DU]LSDQVFKOR‰GHQQ
GRUWELQLFKMHW]W.|QLJ 0DULHKREGHQ-QJOLQJDXIXQGVSUDFK
OHLVH/LHEHU+HUU 'UR‰HOPHLHU6LHVLQGHLQVDQIWPWLJHUJXWHU
0HQVFKXQGGD6LHGD]XQRFKHLQDQPXWLJHV/DQGPLWVHKU
KEVFKHQOXVWLJHQ/HXWHQUHJLHUHQVRQHKPHLFK6LH]XP
%UlXWLJDPDQ +LHUDXIZXUGH0DULHVRJOHLFK'UR‰HOPHLHUV
%UDXW1DFK-DKUHVIULVWKDWHUVLHZLHPDQVDJWDXIHLQHP
JROGQHQYRQVLOEHUQHQ3IHUGHQJH]RJHQHQ:DJHQDEJHKROW$XI
GHU+RFK]HLWWDQ]WHQ]ZHLXQG]ZDQ]LJWDXVHQGGHUJOlQ]HQGVWHQ
PLW3HUOHQXQG'LDPDQWHQJHVFKPFNWHQ)LJXUHQXQG0DULHVROO
QRFK]XU6WXQGH.|QLJLQHLQHV/DQGHVVHLQLQGHPPDQEHUDOO
IXQNHOQGH:HLKQDFKWVZlOGHUGXUFKVLFKWLJH0DU]LSDQVFKO|VVHU
NXU]GLHDOOHUKHUUOLFKVWHQZXQGHUEDUVWHQ'LQJHHUEOLFNHQNDQQ
ZHQQPDQQXUGDUQDFK$XJHQKDW

You might also like