Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Optics & Laser Technology: Jetro Pocorni, John Powell, Eckard Deichsel, Jan Frostevarg, Alexander F.H. Kaplan
Optics & Laser Technology: Jetro Pocorni, John Powell, Eckard Deichsel, Jan Frostevarg, Alexander F.H. Kaplan
Fibre laser cutting stainless steel: Fluid dynamics and cut front
morphology
Jetro Pocorni a,n, John Powell a,c, Eckard Deichsel b, Jan Frostevarg a, Alexander F.H. Kaplan a
a
Department of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics, Luleå University of Technology, 97187 Luleå, Sweden
b
Bystronic Laser AG, Industriestrasse 21, CH-3362 Niederönz, Switzerland
c
Laser Expertise Ltd., Acorn Park Industrial Estate, Harrimans Lane, Nottingham NG7 2TR, U.K
art ic l e i nf o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this paper the morphology of the laser cut front generated by fibre lasers was investigated by ob-
Received 9 March 2016 servation of the ‘frozen’ cut front, additionally high speed imaging (HSI) was employed to study the fluid
Accepted 8 August 2016 dynamics on the cut front while cutting. During laser cutting the morphology and flow properties of the
Available online 16 August 2016
melt film on the cut front affect cut quality parameters such as cut edge roughness and dross (residual
Keywords: melt attached to the bottom of the cut edge). HSI observation of melt flow down a laser cutting front
Laser cutting using standard cutting parameters is experimentally problematic because the cut front is narrow and
Fibre laser surrounded by the kerf walls. To compensate for this, artificial parameters are usually chosen to obtain
Melt flow wide cut fronts which are unrepresentative of the actual industrial process. This paper presents a new
Particle tracking velocimetry
experimental cutting geometry which permits HSI of the laser cut front using standard, commercial
High speed imaging
parameters. These results suggest that the cut front produced when cutting medium section (10 mm
thick) stainless steel with a fibre laser and a nitrogen assist gas is covered in humps which themselves are
covered by a thin layer of liquid. HSI observation and theoretical analysis reveal that under these con-
ditions the humps move down the cut front at an average speed of approximately 0.4 m/s while the
covering liquid flows at an average speed of approximately 1.1 m/s, with an average melt depth at the
bottom of the cut zone of approximately 0.17 mm.
& 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction at the bottom of the kerf and the cut edge surface roughness de-
pend on the melt film condition throughout the kerf. Schulz et al.
Laser cutting is a well-established industrial process and has [6] have also pointed out that dross formation is related to prop-
now become a multibillion euro industry. A wide range of mate- erties of the melt such as its thickness and velocity.
rials can be processed by laser cutting, from polymeric materials The importance of the melt film characteristics on the cut front
(Choudhury et al. [1]) to tool steels (Scintilla et al. [2]) and Nickel is also emphasised by Chen and Yao [7] who conclude that fluc-
super alloys (Hasçalık et al. [3]). In depth research into the details tuations in the absorbed laser power and the velocity of the high
of the process is continuing to optimise cutting speeds and cut speed gas jet can create perturbations in the melt film which in
edge quality. turn could give rise to fluctuating striation patterns on the cut
In laser fusion cutting of metals a volume of melt is created (by edge. Dross and surface roughness are, of course, important be-
absorption of the laser beam) and then blown out of the cut zone cause they are two of the main quality parameters in laser cutting
by an inert assist gas. During the process a thin layer of melt flows (Rajaram et al. [8] and Ghany et al. [9]). An increase in cut edge
down the cut front, as shown in Fig. 1. roughness has been noted by both Himmer et al. [10] and Purto-
The importance of understanding the melt flow on the cut front nen et al. [11] when fibre lasers are used to profile metals of 6 mm
is discussed by Tani [5] who states that both the amount of dross thickness and higher. Petring et al. [12,13] have also studied melt
flow and kerf morphology and have explained that the decrease in
cut edge quality for fibre lasers is primarily due to multiple re-
n
Corresponding author. flections of the laser beam against the kerf walls.
E-mail addresses: Jetro.Pocorni@ltu.se (J. Pocorni),
High speed imaging has been used in the past to investigate the
John.Powell@laserexp.co.uk (J. Powell),
Eckard.Deichsel@bystronic.com (E. Deichsel), Jan.Frostevarg@ltu.se (J. Frostevarg), hydrodynamics of the melt layer (Arata et al. [14,15]) and striation
Alexander.Kaplan@ltu.se (A.F.H. Kaplan). formation (Zefferer [16]). Previous work on HSI of the cut front has
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.optlastec.2016.08.002
0030-3992/& 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
88 J. Pocorni et al. / Optics & Laser Technology 87 (2017) 87–93
Fig. 3. (a) The HSI set-up and (b) a single frame from the HSI film showing bright
spots on the cut front.
Fig. 5. Velocity of a number of droplets in the first 1 mm of their flight out of the
bottom of the kerf.
liquid removal and striation formation. They found that for CO2
laser cutting there exists a well-developed coherent stream of li-
quid, while for fibre laser cutting the melt flow is highly unstable
with multiple melt ejections from the cut front to the side walls.
Kaplan [23] has calculated a melt thickness of 20 mm and melt
velocity of 7 m/s for a 3 mm mild steel plate and CO2 laser cutting
with nitrogen assist gas. He concluded that the melt film thickness
increases with increasing processing speed due to increased
melting rate and the stagnation pressure of the cutting gas.
Thermodynamic and fluid dynamic conditions within the cut
zone vary according to what material is being cut, the cutting
speed, the type of laser being used, and how thick the material is.
At the high speeds associated with thin sections (0.1–2.0 mm) the
temperatures in the cut zone are much higher than when cutting
thicker sections, and evaporation can play a major part in the
material removal process (Petring et al. [13]). At higher sections
the reduced cutting speeds and associated lower cut front tem-
peratures mean that the amount of mass removed by evaporation
is negligible (Powell et al. [24]). However, in the case of fibre laser
cutting evaporation can play a role in propelling the melt down
the cut front.
In this paper HSI is used to investigate the flow conditions
within the cut zone for 10 mm thick stainless steel cut by fibre
laser, also for the first time a new experimental cutting geometry
has been introduced, which enables HSI of the laser cut front
produced using standard cutting parameters and kerf widths ra-
ther than the exaggerated cut widths and unrealistic cutting gas
pressures employed by earlier researchers (Hirano and Fabbro
[17]).
The purpose of this study is to analyse the flow conditions in
Fig. 4. Two different ways of working out the mass flow rate out of the cut zone by the cut zone and the morphology of the laser cut front created by
(a) kerf removal rate, Kr in Eq. (1) and (b) liquid flow rate Lr in Eq. (2).
fibre lasers, and to study their effect on laser cut quality as com-
pared to CO2 laser cutting. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
phase evolution. Both Golubdev [22] and Hirano and Fabbro [17] was used to observe the ‘frozen’ cut front and high speed imaging
describe humps as melt accumulations which rest on top of so was employed to study the movement of the melt on the cut front
called ‘shelves’. These shelves have been shown to slide down the while cutting.
cut front by Hirano and Fabbro [17]. However, Hirano and Fabbro
[17] performed their experiments with parameters which are very
different from the ones used in actual laser cutting. They used a 2. Material and methods
focus spot diameter of 1.7 mm (industry standard 0.2–1.0 mm) and
a cutting gas pressure of 2.5 bar (industry standard 10–16 bar). The observation of melt flow down a laser cutting front using
Ermolaev et al. [18] filmed the cut front from the side via a standard cutting parameters is experimentally rather difficult be-
transparent plate with a high speed camera to study the melt flow, cause the cut front is narrow and surrounded by the recently cut
90 J. Pocorni et al. / Optics & Laser Technology 87 (2017) 87–93
Fig. 6. (a) Three frames from the HSI film showing the movement of a bright spot down the cut front; frame rate 4000 frames per second and 0.25 ms time steps between
frames; (b) velocity measurements of bright spots as they move down the kerf.
walls of the kerf (Arai [25]). For this reason most studies of the cut Frame rate of 4000 frames per second with spatial resolution of
front either use artificial parameters to produce a possibly un- 512 496 pixels.
representative wide cut front (Hirano and Fabbro [17]), or involve 105 mm Micro-Nikkor lens with focal ratio f/4.
cuts started at the edge of the sheet– where the cut front is most Band pass filter which blocks process light and matches the il-
visible. This latter approach can also give misleading results be- lumination wavelength, as described by Frostevarg [26].
cause the cut front is, at this point, in its ‘start up’ phase rather Illumination laser: Cavilux HF diode illumination laser with
than its eventual quasi-steady state. 810 nm wavelength.
To overcome these problems a new experimental technique,
called triangle drop out, has been developed which allows the HSI Analysis of the cut front is based upon the empirical photo-
camera a view of the well-established quasi steady state cut front. graphic evidence collected. Particle tracking velocimetry (PTV)
This involves using the laser to produce a cut path which results in was employed to measure the velocity of bright patches on the
the sudden falling away of a triangular cut part to expose the melt surface as they flow towards the bottom of the kerf. This
cutting front in action. technique has previously been applied by Roth et al. [27] to the
The cutting path used is explained in Fig. 2. First the laser cuts analysis of particle movement in fluid jets in abrasive water jet
along line 1, then returns to the edge of the material and cuts to cutting. PTV determines the velocity of individual particles in
the intersection along line 2 (without stopping at the intersection). flows and is based on the Lagrangian reference frame, which ob-
As the laser reaches the intersection the triangle enclosed by lines serves fluid motion by tracking an individual feature as it moves
1 and 2 and the edge of the material falls away – revealing the through space and time. The algorithm first isolates individual
steady state cut front as it continues to cut line 2. The HSI camera features on the cut front in each frame of the high speed video. In
is focused on the intersection and true images of the fluid flow in order to find valid correspondences between features in different
the cut zone can be obtained. frames the temporal matching problem was solved with cross-
Table 1 shows the cutting parameters and laser beam condi- correlation algorithms, relaxation algorithms or a combination of
tions used in this experiment. The material used was 10 mm both as described in Brevis [28].
stainless steel AISI 304 (EN 1.4301). The laser used was a Bystronic
BySprint Fibre 3015 with a Fibre 6000 resonator and HK35 nozzle. 3. Results and discussion
A Redlake NR4-S2 high speed camera was used with following
setup parameters: Fig. 3 shows a schematic of the set up for high speed imaging
J. Pocorni et al. / Optics & Laser Technology 87 (2017) 87–93 91
π
Lr = ⋅W ⋅t⋅umelt ⋅ρ
2 (2)
where Lr is the liquid flow rate (g/s), t is the average melt depth
(mm) and umelt is the average melt flow velocity (mm/s).
Clearly the kerf removal rate must equal the liquid flow rate:
L r = Kr (3)
Fig. 8. SEM images of cross sections of the cut front obtained with (a) and (b) Fibre laser: humps are present in both the liquid layer and the underlying solid, (c) and (d) CO2
laser: uniform structure of resolidified melt over flatter solid/liquid interface.
laser cut front drive the melt ejection process in an intermittent technique (triangle drop out) which allowed HSI observation
manner and this is in agreement with the findings of Ermolaev of cuts produced under standard cutting conditions.
et al. [18] that CO2 laser cutting involves a coherent flow of liquid (4) The results here indicate that the decrease in cut edge quality,
down the cut front, whereas during fibre laser cutting the melt when processing thicker section steel with fibre lasers, could
flow is highly unstable. The natural consequence of this unstable be a consequence of sporadic hump generation (as opposed to
flow is the reduction in cut edge smoothness which has been smooth flow) in addition to multiple reflections of the laser
shown by both Himmer et al. [10] and Purtonen et al. [11] when beam inside the cut kerf.
fibre lasers are used to profile metals of 6 mm thickness and
higher.
Acknowledgements