Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED ESG Ratings Report
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED ESG Ratings Report
This chart highlights the company's positioning relative to the industry average for each Key Issue that contributed
to its ESG Rating as of September 26, 2023.
Positive
Industr
Industryy ESG Rating history shows five most recent rating actions
Aver
erage
age
ESG Rating distribution
Universe: MSCI ACWI Index constituents, Utilities, n=141
Negative
ns
gy
abl ies in
sio
pm pital
ner
mis
ent
eE
e
it
a
anc
Ren ortun
Dev an C
nE
n
ew
elo
rbo
ver
m
p
Hu
Op
Go
Ca
Key scores
Last ESG Rating action
Weight Scor
Scoree (0-10)
Rating action date: Mar
March
ch 28, 2023 Industry-Adjusted Score 4.1
(Last Updated: Mar
March
ch 28, 2023)
We initiate coverage of SUPER at 'BB'.
◤ Weighted-Average Key Issue Score 5.2
Focus on renewable energy (RE) operations (FY 2021: ~88% of assets) lowers SUPER’s exposure to (Last updated: June 30, 2023)
environmental risks, particularly related to carbon, compared with peers with more substantial fossil fuel-
based assets. However, the company lags industry peers in talent management and global peers on ◤ Environmental Pillar Score 36% 8.4
business ethics. ◤ Social Pillar Score 23% 1.6
Thailand (FY 2021: ~61% of assets, domicile) and Vietnam (~35%) set RE targets of 30% of ◤ Governance Pillar Score 41% 4.4
◥
energy consumption by 2037 and 47% of electricity generation by 2030, respectively. As of March
2023, SUPER has ~460 MW of ongoing RE projects in both countries that may support their Report table of contents
respective targets. Thus, the company appears well positioned to capitalize on opportunities in
the RE space.
ESG Rating tearsheet Data rrepor
eportt
Based on our model, utility companies rely on skilled professionals and are thus exposed to
◥
However, SUPER’s business ethics framework lags that of global peers: we found no evidence of summary
regular audits of ethics programs and mechanisms or of a policy protecting whistleblowers from ESG Rating drill down P05 Glossary P55
retaliation.
Analysts: Joseph Benjamin De la Torre, Nilesh Nagdev What is an ESG Rating? MSCI ESG Ratings aim to measure a
company's resilience to long-term ESG risks. Companies are
scored on an industry-relative AAA-CCC scale across the most
relevant Key Issues based on a company's business model.
Opportunities in Renewable 24% 6.0 8.0 ● 97% of revenues derived from power generation
● Relatively large proportion of renewable energy capacity compared to peers
Energy
Carbon Emissions 12% 7.4 9.3 ● 83% of operations from less carbon-intensive business lines relative to
peers
Human Capital Development 23% 5.5 1.6 ● Disclosed compensation practices are poor relative to peers; in particular
our research found limited to no evidence of stock-based awards
Corporate Governance 6.0 6.3 ▲1.4 ● The company falls into the average scoring range relative to global peers,
reflecting relatively few areas of concern.
SUPER was rated based on a standard version of the Utilities Industry Data feedback in last 12 months? No
ESG Rating Model.
Date of last feedback N/A
MODEL VERSION: 4.1.1 This section only captures inputs provided by companies through our online issuer portal that may have an
impact on the weighted Key Issues for the company
Represents the MSCI ESG Ratings model version used to assess the
company. Please refer to the “ESG Ratings Methodology” document for more
details on the model versions.
Key documents used for updates, as of September 26, 2023
This table shows the last 10 score changes* and rating actions that have occurred in the past 12 months.
Curr
Current
ent W
Weighted-A
eighted-Avver
erage
age K
Keey Issue 5.2
Scor
Scoree
Jun 30, 2023 Data Update: Corporate Governance ▲0.4 Flags Added
Added: Related Party Transactions
Flags Remo
Removved
ed: Audit Committee Industry Expert, CEO Equity
Changes, Entrenched Board
Mar 28, 2023 ESG Rating action 4.8 ▲4.8 We initiate coverage of SUPER at 'BB'.
Mar 28, 2023 Data Update: Exposure Change in exposure score for the following Key Issue(s): Human
Capital Development, Opportunities in Renewable Energy,
Corporate Behavior, Corporate Behavior
Mar 28, 2023 Data Update: Carbon Increase in practices score, performance score, management
score, exposure score
This table outlines the latest changes to specific data points that have occurred, the trigger for change (e.g. issuer feedback, data update or methodology enhancements) and the overall impact
on the company's Weighted Average Key Issue Score.
There are no recent new controversies or updates to ongoing controversies for this company.
53r
53rdd global per
percentile
centile Ownership summar
summaryy
Total summar
summaryy pa
pay*:
y*:
Board diversity
Male Female USD 8,315.29
50% 50%
*CEO pay figures are sourced from listed company annual reports and proxy filings. When a new CEO is named the pay figures for the previous CEO will be displayed until this information has
been updated for the new CEO
Peer benchmarking
Carbon Oppor
Opportunities
tunities in Renewable Human Capital Corpor
Corporate
ate Corpor
Corporate
ate Rating &
Emissions Ener
Energy
gy De
Devvelopment Go
Govvernance Beha
Behaviour
viour Trend
CEZ, a.s. ●●●● ●● ●● ●●●● ●● AA ◄►
Fortis Inc. ●●● ●● ●●● ●●●● ●●●● AA ◄►
Fortum Oyj ●●● ● ●● ●● ●● BBB ◄ ►
CENTERPOINT ENERGY, INC. ●● ● ●● ●●● ●● BBB ◄ ►
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC ●●● ●●●● ● ●● ● BB ◄►
COMPANY LIMITED
Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, ● ●● ● ● ● CCC ◄ ►
Incorporated
As of prior rating action date: As of last rating action date: As of last report update date: Difference
Mar 28, 2023 Sep 26, 2023
Description Score Weight Score Weight Score Weight Score Weight
Envir
Environmental
onmental Pillar Scor
Scoree 8.4 36.0% 8.4 36.0% - -
Carbon Emissions K
Keey Issue Scor
Scoree 9.3 12.0% 9.3 12.0% - -
Exposure Score 1.2 1.2 - -
Business Segment Exposure Score 1.2 1.2 - -
Geographic Exposure Score 4.6 4.6 - -
Management Score 4.3 4.3 - -
Management Score - Excluding 4.3 4.3 - -
Controversies
Practices Score 5.0 5.0 - -
Performance Score 3.0 3.0 - -
Oppor
Opportunities
tunities in Renewable Ener
Energy
gy K
Keey Issue 8.0 24.0% 8.0 24.0% - -
Scor
Scoree
Exposure Score 8.4 8.4 - -
Business Segment Exposure Score 9.7 9.7 - -
Geographic Exposure Score 3.7 3.7 - -
Management Score 8.3 8.3 - -
Management Score - Excluding 8.3 8.3 - -
Controversies
Practices Score 7.5 7.5 - -
Performance Score 10.0 10.0 - -
Controversy Deduction 0.0 0.0 - -
Human Capital De
Devvelopment K
Keey Issue Scor
Scoree 1.6 23.0% 1.6 23.0% - -
Exposure Score 7.3 7.3 - -
Business Segment Exposure Score 7.3 7.3 - -
Company-Specific Exposure Score 0.0 0.0 - -
Management Score 1.9 1.9 - -
Management Score - Excluding 1.9 1.9 - -
Controversies
Practices Score 1.4 1.4 - -
Performance Score 3.0 3.0 - -
Controversy Deduction 0.0 0.0 - -
Go
Govvernance Pillar Scor
Score*
e* 3.3 41.0% 4.4 41.0% 1.1 -
Go
Govvernance Pillar Deductions** -6.7 -5.6 1.1 -
Corpor
Corporate
ate Go
Govvernance Deductions -4.0 -2.9 1.1 -
As of prior rating action date: As of last rating action date: As of last report update date: Difference
Mar 28, 2023 Sep 26, 2023
Description Score Weight Score Weight Score Weight Score Weight
Corpor
Corporate
ate Beha
Behavior
vior Deductions -2.7 -2.7 - -
Business Ethics -2.7 -2.7 - -
Tax Transparency 0.0 0.0 - -
**Beginning November 2020, the Environmental Pillar Score and Social Pillar Score are calculated based on the weighted average of underlying Key Issue Scores, while the
Governance Pillar Score is calculated based on 10 minus the sum of Corporate Governance and Corporate Behavior deductions. In the ESG Rating drill-down, deductions are
scaled to indicate impact on the overall Governance Pillar Score. In subsequent sections of the report, deductions are scaled to show impact on the Corporate Behavior and
Corporate Governance Theme Scores.
Market Cap: 339,424,191 USD Home Market: Thailand Last Data Update: Aug 07, 2023
10
0
Apr 2021 Feb 2023 Mar 2023 Apr 2023 Aug 2023
Key Metric Key Metric Change Date Score Change* Change Notes
Audit Committee Industry Expert Flag Removed Jun 26, 2023 0.10
No Nomination Committee Flag Added Jun 12, 2022 -0.30 Methodology enhancements
BOARD
The policies and practices of the SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC board fall Global Home Market
within the average scoring range relative to global peers. We have flagged this board 0-10 Score Percentile Rank Percentile Rank
for potential concerns regarding the presence of certain related party transactions
and the absence of a pay committee. 61st (Average) 81st (Above
7.6
Average)
BOARD INDEPENDENCE ▼ ▼
Executives on Board -0.20
Related Party Transactions -0.10
PAY OVERSIGHT
No Pay Committee and Execs on Board -0.59
LEADERSHIP
CHAIR
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
The SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC board currently has an independent majority, which enables it to more effectively fulfill its critical function of
overseeing management on behalf of shareholders. The board includes at least one executive director in addition to the CEO, characteristic of 47% of
companies in this market. Multiple inside directors may increase management’s influence within the boardroom. Additionally, the company has split the
roles of CEO and chair and has named a fully independent chairman. An independent chairman is characteristic of 44% of companies in the home market.
Total (of 8) 4 1 2 0 5 8
$ - Financial Expert (3) I - Industry Expert (4) CEO - Chief Executive Officer COB - Chair of the Board
CFO - Chief Financial Officer DC - Deputy Chair
The risk to minority shareholders arising from related party transactions is a function of the nature of the related party, the relative size of the transaction
and the pricing of the transaction. The board, and in particular the independent directors or audit committee, play a key role in the protection of minority
shareholders’ interests, and monitoring and managing potential conflicts of interest of management, board members and shareholders.
Reported Transactions
The Group has transactions with related parties. These parties are related through common
shareholders The significant transactions with related parties as includes Electricity expense and parking fee.
For the two most recently reported fiscal years, these value of these transactions can be summarised as follows :
Dec 31, Other 1,011,000 THB 0.012% of Expenses Recurring purchases from related party
2022
Dec 31, Other 1,228,000 THB 0.020% of Expenses Purchases from related party
2021
Sources : 2022 FS p. 39-41 Note 6, 2021 FS p. 36-39 Note 6
BOARD EFFECTIVENESS
Nomination Committee
The company's 'Below Average' rating for pay may be an indication of a management-friendly board because of the presence of one or more active CEO's
on the board.
AUDIT OVERSIGHT
The SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC board of directors includes a fully independent audit committee and at least one member of that committee
meets our standards for financial expertise.
Independent
Name M/F Age Board Tenure (Years) Boards of Mgmt of Other Committee Status
Interests
Kamthorn Udomritthiruj M 91 17 1 Yes Yes Chair
Independent
Name M/F Age Board Tenure (Years) of Mgmt of Other Committee Status
Interests
I - Industry Expert
PAY OVERSIGHT
Pay Committee
PAY
Executive pay practices at SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC fall into the average Global Home Market
scoring range relative to global peers. Areas of particular concern include poor 0-10 Score Percentile Rank Percentile Rank
disclosure in relation to executive pay.
26th (Below 89th (Above
2.3
Average) Average)
PAY FIGURES
Executive Pay Disclosure -1.18
ANALYSIS
Pay values of the executives only reflect their remuneration as directors of the company.
PAY FIGURES
DISCLOSURE
Disclosure should include, at minimum, pay for each executive member of the Board of Directors (or Management Board for companies with a two-tier
board structure) on an individualized basis or in cases where there are no executive members, the CEO. The individualized disclosure should include
separate information on the amount of each of the following (where such a component is provided): salary, short-term Incentives, long-term Incentives,
pensions, benefits, and any one-off payments (such as recruitment or retention awards).
Executive Title Tenure Total Awarded Pay (USD) Total Realized Pay (USD)
(Years)
Salary Salary
Pension Pension
Perks & Other Pay 288,000 THB Perks & Other Pay 288,000 THB
Total Awarded Pay 288,000 THB Total Realized Pay 288,000 THB
SMALLCAP - EMERGING - INDEPENDENT POWER AND RENEWABLE ELECTRICITY PRODUCERS (33 COMPANIES)
Company Home Market Market Pay 1 Yr Total CEO CEO Name CEO
Cap Year TSR Annual Since
(USD m) Pay (USD)
CONCORD NEW ENERGY GROUP LIMITED China 699 2022 -0.13% 572,666 Gui Aug 2020
MALAKOFF CORPORATION BERHAD Malaysia 651 2022 -0.08% 550,390 Abdul Ajib Dec 2020
TERNA ENERGY S.A. Other EMEA 1,912 2022 0.44% 362,471 Maragoudakis Jan 1997
Emerging
CECEP Wind-Power Corporation China 2,892 2021 0.00% 359,670 Liu Jun 2013
CANVEST ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION GROUP COMPANY China 1,294 2022 0.05% 337,350 Yuan Sep 2014
LIMITED
..........
GLOBAL POWER SYNERGY PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 3,696 2022 -0.19% 102,506 Pitayasiri Dec 2020
SHANGHAI ELECTRIC POWER CO., LTD. China 3,524 2022 -0.28% 102,277 Wei Jun 2020
TPI Polene Power Public Company Limited Thailand 774 2022 -0.16% 51,558 Leopairut Jan 2007
CK Power Public Company Limited Thailand 776 2022 -0.11% 24,542 Trivisvavet Jul 2015
Gunkul Engineering Public Company Limited Thailand 848 2022 -0.07% 24,109 Aueatchasai Mar
2021
Banpu Power Public Company Limited Thailand 1,184 2022 -0.04% 14,898 Limpaphayom Apr 2020
ABSOLUTE CLEAN ENERGY PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 454 2022 -0.25% 10,972 Bunditvorapoom May
2017
RATCH GROUP PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 1,931 2022 0.05% 10,266 Kietkajornkul Oct 2021
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 372 2022 -0.33% 8,315 Lochaya Sep 2004
SPCG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 360 2022 -0.20% 3,898 Khunchornyakong Apr 2011
Juljarern
China Datang Corporation Renewable Power Co., Limited China 1,748 2022 -0.35% 0 Liu Mar
2019
ELECTRICITY GENERATING PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 1,833 2022 -0.02% 0 Theppitak Jul 2020
MEGA FIRST CORPORATION BERHAD Malaysia 692 2022 -0.08% 0 Goh Jul 2011
B.GRIMM POWER PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Thailand 2,280 2022 -0.04% 0 Link Dec 2020
FIRST GEN CORPORATION Philippines 1,228 2022 -0.39% Lopez Feb 2008
..........
PT Cikarang Listrindo Tbk Indonesia 805 2022 0.08% Labbaika Jan 2015
Shamal Az-Zour Al-Oula Power and Water Company KSCP Other EMEA 681 2021 -0.11% Frain Nov
Emerging 2017
Omega Energia S.A. Brazil 1,198 2021 -0.20% de Bastos Filho May
2015
SHINFOX ENERGY CO., LTD. Taiwan 649 2022 0.00% Huisen Dec 2012
AKSA ENERJI URETIM ANONIM SIRKETI Turkey 1,701 2020 0.00% Kazanci Jul 2019
Due to the large size of this peer group, only a subset of companies is displayed in this table.
0.5
0.25
TSR - 1yr
-0.25
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED
-0.5
-100k 0 100k 200k 300k 400k 500k 600k 700k 800k 900k
Total Awarded Pay (USD)
Pay Peers (♦) are used in the calculation of the Key Metric CEO Pay Total Summary and selected as set out in the MSCI Governance Metrics Methodology Document.
7.5
5
TSR - 5yr
2.5
-2.5
-100k 0 100k 200k 300k 400k 500k 600k 700k 800k 900k
Total Realized Pay (USD)
Pay Peers (♦) are used in the calculation of the Key Metric CEO Pay Total Summary and selected as set out in the MSCI Governance Metrics Methodology Document.
Kulchalee Nuntasukkasem I $ 1 0
Warinthip Chaisangha I $ 10 0
The company has failed to incorporate links to sustainability performance in its current incentive pay policies.
NON-EXECUTIVE EQUITY
Kamthorn Udomritthiruj 17 0
Piya Sorntrakul 5 0
Sunsiri Chaijareonpat 5 0
Trithip Sivakriskul I $ 5 0
Director Tenure (Years) Cash Fees Other Comp Total Pay Total Pay (USD)
Wanida Machimanon N/A (Resigned) 720,000 THB 209,000 THB 1,079,000 THB 31,153
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SHAREHOLDER RIGHTS
Say on Pay Policy -0.10
CORPORATE STRUCTURE
Public Company
CAPITAL STRUCTURE
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
OWNERSHIP CATEGORIES
• Principal Shareholder
NOTABLE SHAREHOLDERS
Even in the absence of a controlling shareholder, differential voting rights mean that the economic exposure of certain shareholders is higher than their
voting power.
CONTROL MECHANISMS
TAKEOVER PROVISIONS
Fair Price Provision Mandatory Bid Provision Mandatory Bid Ownership Threshold
75%
GOVERNING DOCUMENTS
MAJORITY REQUIREMENTS
Bylaws Charter
SHAREHOLDER RIGHTS
There may be governance risks for investors in relation to shareholder rights and management-controlled takeover defense mechanisms at SUPER ENERGY
CORPORATION PUBLIC including:
SAY ON PAY
Despite a global trend towards providing shareholders with the ability to review and approve executive pay practices, the company does not operate in a
market which requires regular 'say on pay' votes nor has it extended this right to shareholders.
DIRECTOR ELECTIONS
Not all board members are subject to annual re-election. While considered by some governance experts as a means of ensuring board continuity, a
classified board structure may limit the ability of shareholders to hold directors accountable and serve as a takeover defense. The combined effect of these
mechanisms may reduce board accountability to shareholders.
The company has a majority standard for director elections (with immediate resignation if the director does not receive a majority of the votes cast), which
enables shareholders to hold directors accountable in uncontested elections.
The directors are divided in three parts. And at every AGM one third of directors retire and stand for re-election.
ACCOUNTING
Based on the company's disclosures and other public information, accounting and Global Home Market
financial reporting practices at SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC appear to be 0-10 Score Percentile Rank Percentile Rank
generally appropriate and effective relative to global peers.
9.4 43rd (Average) 74th (Average)
AUDITOR INDEPENDENCE ▼ ▼
Auditor Tenure -0.10
EXTERNAL AUDITORS
00 00 00
0%
2020 2022 2023
■Against ■Abstain/Withhold
AUDITOR FEES
Other Non-
audit
Services
Total Non- 0 0 0
audit Fees
AUDITOR'S REPORT
Emphasis of Matter No No No
10
0
Mar 2023
BUSINESS ETHICS
Global Home
KEY METRICS SCORING 0-10 Score Change Percentile Market
(since rating) Rank Percentile
Rank
Deduction
0.0 8th (Below 4th (Worst
BUSINESS ETHICS POLICIES & PRACTICES -4.90 3.0
Average) In Class)
Bribery and Anti-Corruption Policy -0.70
Regular Audits of Ethical Standards -1.40 METHODOLOGY NOTE
Whistleblower Protection -1.40 Companies are evaluated on their oversight and management of business
Employee Training on Ethical Standards -1.40 ethics issues such as fraud, executive misconduct, corrupt practices,
money laundering, or anti-trust violations.
BUSINESS ETHICS RISK & CONTROVERSIES -2.00 *[ For symbols and terms used in this report, refer to the Glossary
Corruption Risk Exposure & Controversies -2.00 section at the end of the report ]
Note: Business Ethics Policies & Practices deductions as well as Business Ethics Risk & Controversies are capped BUSINESS ETHICS VS.
at a maximum of -7.0. Cumulative deductions are capped at 10.
Oversight for Ethics Issues Board-level committee Board-level committee or C-suite or Executive committee 0.00
Bribery and Anti-Corruption General statements of commitment to address bribery Detailed formal policy on bribery and anti-corruption -0.70
Policy and corruption issues
Regular Audits of Ethical No evidence Audits of all operations at least once every three years -1.40
Standards
Whistleblower Protection No evidence Policy provides whistleblowers with protection from retaliation -1.40
Employee Training on Ethical No evidence Programs covering all employees (including part-time) and -1.40
Standards contractors
Anti-Corruption Policy for NA All suppliers are required to have anti-corruption policies and 0.00
Suppliers programs to verify compliance
*Business Ethics Policies & Practices deductions are capped at a maximum of -7.0.
Exposure to: Regulatory risks or lost market access due to corruption scandals or political and social instability
Business Types : Percentage of operations in business segments perceived most likely to pay or receive bribes
0%
■ Electric power generation, Solar power
generation , Wind power generation,
Biomass power generation, Non-irrigation
water supply Source: Bribe Payers Index (Transparency International); State
■ Integrated systems design (0.11%) Capture Index (Transparency International); Refinitiv; MSCI ESG
100%
■ No exposure to low risk segments Research; company disclosures
Business Locations : Percentage of operations in countries with high/moderate/low level of corruption and political instability, violence or terrorism
■ No operations in markets with high risks Source: Corruption Perceptions Index (Transparency International);
■ Vietnam, other countries, Thailand World Governance Indicators (World Bank); Refinitiv; MSCI ESG
100%
■ No operations in markets with low risks Research; company disclosures
% of operations in medium and high risk % of operations in high risk business >=20% government <20% government No evidence of government
geographies segments ownership ownership ownership
*The Corruption Risk and Controversies Deduction is based on the maximum of deductions from the corruption risk exposure and corruption controversies category listed below
Controversy Cases
Category Assessment Headline Status Last Updated Deduction
Business Ethics & Fraud -- No ongoing controversies. -- -- --
Anticompetitive Practices -- No ongoing controversies. -- -- --
Corruption -- No ongoing controversies. -- -- --
*The maximum deductions from the Anticompetitive Practices and Business Ethics & Fraud categories are summed to arrive at the overall Business Ethics Controversies deduction, which is capped at a maximum
of -7.0.
TAX TRANSPARENCY
Global Home
Change Percentile Market
0-10 score
TAX GAP ASSESSMENT (since rating) Rank Percentile
Rank
Involvement in Controversies NO ▼
▼
TAX CONTROVERSIES
Controversy Cases
Category Assessment Headline Status Last Updated Deduction
Tax Transparency -- No ongoing controversies. -- -- --
Involvement in tax controversies Estimated tax gap Tax gap assessment Deduction
Tax related controversies are not considered for companies in Real Estate Management services or Mortgage REITs industries. Tax gap assessment is effectively low for companies with less than 5% of total
revenue categorized as foreign.
Renewable Energy
8.0 0.0 ●●●● 24.0% Mar 28, 2023
SUPER ENERGY
Strong Risk Management
10 CORPORATION
Top Quartile Second Quartile Third Quartile Bottom Quartile
PUBLIC COMPANY KEY ISSUE SCORE DISTRIBUTION*
9 LIMITED
8 27%
22%
7 16% 15%
6 9%
6%
3% 3%
5 0% 0% 0%
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
4
Key Issue Score
3
*
[ For symbols and terms used in this report, refer to
the Glossary section at the end of the report ]
EXPOSURE
Exposure to: Opportunity to increased revenues from capturing changing consumer demand, enjoying early mover advantage or regulatory incentives
(mandates or subsidies)
Business Locations : Percentage of operations in markets with government subsidies in support of renewable power production
35%
MANAGEMENT
Development
1.6 0.0 ● 23.0% Mar 28, 2023
8 20%
0 5 10 *
[ For symbols and terms used in this report, refer to
the Glossary section at the end of the report ]
Controversy Deduction
Company 0.0
-5.0 -2.5 0
EXPOSURE
Exposure to: Risk of increased turnover and associated costs of rehiring, loss of intellectual and human capital through attrition, reduced ability to attract
talent
Business Types : Percentage of operations in business segments with high/moderate/low levels of employee qualification needs and compensation per
employee
2%
■ Electric power generation, Solar power
generation , Wind power generation,
Biomass power generation, Integrated
systems design Source: Employment Projections, US Bureau of Labor Statistics;
■ Non-irrigation water supply Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, US Bureau of Labor
98%
■ No exposure to low risk segments Statistics; Refinitiv; MSCI ESG Research; company disclosures
MANAGEMENT
Strategy
Extent of grievance reporting or No evidence Formal grievance
- LOW MID TOP
escalation procedures escalation/reporting
(confidential)
Non-salary benefits and work/life Scope not determinable Benefits cover all employees
- LOW MID TOP
balance
Training
Year (YYYY) Percentage of employees receiving training Annual training hours per employee
2021
2020
Year (YYYY) Percentage of employees receiving training Annual training hours per employee
2019
Workforce Diversity
Year Annual employee Profit per employee Percentage of women in executive
(YYYY) turnover (USD '000) management Details
2021 50.00%
2020 36.40%
2019 KMP
CONTROVERSIES
All controversies are assessed as part of the annual review of a company's ESG rating. MSCI ESG Research tracks controversies for all companies on a regular
basis. There is no evidence of the SUPER's current involvement in prominent controversial events or alleged misconduct.
8 28%
7 16%
15%
SUPER ENERGY
11% 11%
6 CORPORATION
4% 4% 5% 4%
PUBLIC COMPANY 1% 2%
5 LIMITED 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
4
Key Issue Score
3
*
[ For symbols and terms used in this report, refer to
the Glossary section at the end of the report ]
EXPOSURE
Exposure to: Risks of having to pay increased compliance costs tied to carbon emissions regulations
Business Types : Percentage of operations in business segments with high/moderate/low carbon intensity
9%
8%
■ Electric power generation
■ Biomass power generation, Non-irrigation
water supply Source: IERS' Comprehensive Environmental Data Archive (CEDA);
83% ■ Solar power generation , Wind power Air Emissions Accounts (Eurostat); Refinitiv; MSCI ESG Research;
generation, Integrated systems design company disclosures
Business Locations : Percentage of operations in countries with strengthening or pending carbon emissions regulation
MANAGEMENT
Mitigation
Strength of Greenhouse Gas Mitigation 10.00
Strategy (0-10 Score, 0=worst, 10=best)
Performance
Carbon Emissions Performance Relative to Peers (0-10 Score, 0=worst, 10=best) 3.00
2021 E.Segmt-Low E.Segmt-Moderately 5,513.0 3,859.0 9,372.0 E.Segmt-Low Mar 2023 Emissions
Low Estimation Update
2020 E.Segmt-Low E.Segmt-Moderately 12,868.0 4,306.0 17,174.0 E.Segmt-Low March 2022
Low Emissions Estimation
Update
2019 E.Segmt-Moderately E.Segmt-Moderately 436.0 2,018.0 2,454.0 E.Segmt-Moderately Mar-2021 Estimation
Low Low Low Update
2018 E.Segmt-Moderately E.Segmt-Low 4.0 903.0 907.0 E.Segmt-Low Jan-2020 Emissions
Low Estimation Update
2017 E.Segmt-Moderately E.Segmt-Moderate 4.0 729.0 733.0 E.Segmt-Moderately April 2019 Estimation
Low Low Update
2016 E.Segmt-Moderately E.Segmt-Moderately 3.0 443.0 446.0 E.Segmt-Moderately Feb-2018 Emission
Low Low Low Estimation Update
2015 E.Segmt-Low E.Segmt-Moderate 1,504.0 83.0 1,587.0 E.Segmt-Low March 2017
Estimation Update
2014 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 1,301.0 30.0 1,331.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
2013 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 770.0 13.0 783.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
2012 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 5,042.0 70.0 5,112.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
2011 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 3,602.0 50.0 3,652.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
2010 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 2,487.0 34.0 2,521.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
2009 E.GICSSI - LOW E.GICSSI - LOW 1,667.0 23.0 1,690.0 E.GICSSI - LOW March 2017
Estimation Update
Year GHG Intensity GHG Intensity Details GHG Intensity - Reported GHG Intensity - Reported Details
2020 79.00
2019 11.80
2018 5.20
2017 4.30
2016 4.40
2015 144.10
2014 213.60
2013 281.70
2012 349.20
2011 349.10
2010 349.20
2009 349.20
APPENDIX
CONTENTS
CONTROVERSIES DETAIL
DIRECTOR VOTES
SHAREHOLDER/MANAGEMENT PROPOSALS
GOVERNANCE STANDARDS
DIRECTOR PROFILES
CONTROVERSIES DETAIL
Here you will find the narratives for all controversies relevant to the ESG Ratings issues covered for the company in addition to those controversies that do not map to the ESG
Ratings issues.
MOST SEVERE 6
CONTROVERSY CONTROVERSY COUNT
Environment
Social
CONTROVERSIES
NUMBER OF CONTROVERSIES BY ASSESSMENT
• Very Severe: Indicates an action by a company that results in a very large
impact on society and/or the environment.
6
• Severe: Indicates an action by a company that results in a large impact on
society and/or the environment.
• Moderate: Indicates an action by a company that results in a moderate
impact on society and/or the environment. 4
• Minor: Indicates an action by a company that results in a low impact on
society and/or the environment.
• None: There is no evidence that a company is involved in any controversy. 2
0 0 0 0
0
Very Severe Severe Moderate Minor
Audit Committee Industry Expert Flag Removed Jun 26, 2023 0.10
Revenue Recognition Score Change Jun 12, 2022 0.20 Methodology enhancements
No Nomination Committee Flag Added Jun 12, 2022 -0.30 Methodology enhancements
Asset-Liability Valuation Score Change Jun 12, 2022 0.29 Methodology enhancements
0.25
TSR - 1yr
-0.25
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED
-0.5
-100k 0 100k 200k 300k 400k 500k 600k 700k 800k 900k
Total Awarded Pay (USD)
Pay Peers (♦) are used in the calculation of the Key Metric CEO Pay Total Summary and selected as set out in the MSCI Governance Metrics Methodology Document.
5
TSR - 5yr
2.5
-2.5
-100k 0 100k 200k 300k 400k 500k 600k 700k 800k 900k
Total Realized Pay (USD)
Pay Peers (♦) are used in the calculation of the Key Metric CEO Pay Total Summary and selected as set out in the MSCI Governance Metrics Methodology Document.
DIRECTOR VOTES
Proxy Year Name Age Tenure Votes For Votes Against, Withheld and / or Abstained
SHAREHOLDER/MANAGEMENT PROPOSALS
MANAGEMENT PROPOSALS
Proxy Proposal Proposal Summary Outcome Votes Votes Abstain/
Year For Against Withheld%
2023 Other 1. The Meeting certified the Minutes of the Annual General Meeting Shareholders for the Year 2022 held on Approved 100% 0% 0%
April 22,2022, with the following voting results:
2023 Other 3. The Meeting approved the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2022, which were Approved 99.9% 0% 0.1%
audited by the auditor, with the following voting results:
2023 Other 4. The Meeting approved the reserve funds as stipulated by the laws in the year 2022 is equal to Approved 99.6% 0.4% 0%
6,651,971.27 baht,and omissions of dividend payments the year 2022. This is because the Company needs to
reserve for workingcapital and to support the economic uncertainty in 2023, with the following […]
2023 Director 6. The Meeting approved the director’s remunerations for the year 2023, the details are as follows: Approved 98% 2% 0%
Compensation
2023 Auditor 7. The Meeting approved to appoint the auditor from Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Chaiyos Audit Co., Ltd. as the Approved 100% 0% 0%
Ratification auditorof the year 2023as follows:
2023 Amend 8. The Meeting approved the amendment of the Company's Articles of Association in 3 items, consisting of Approved 100% 0% 0%
Certificate of Article 21,Article 25, and Article 39, to support the meetingmanagementelectronically. Keeping meetings up-
Incorporation to-date and efficient, including facilitating the shareholders with the following votes.
2022 Other 1. The Meeting certified the Minutes of the Annual General Meeting Shareholders for the Year 2021 was held Approved 100% 0% 0%
on April 30, 2021, with the following voting results:
2022 Other 3. The Meeting approved the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2021, which were Approved 99.9% 0% 0.1%
audited by the auditor, with the following voting results:
2022 Other 4. The Meeting approved the reserve funds as stipulated by the laws in the year 2021 is equal to Approved 100% 0% 0%
16,037,118.25 baht and approve a dividend payment for the year 2021 performance operating profit as cash
dividend in amount of 0.006 Bath per share for existing shareholders. Total dividend payment not […]
2022 Board Size 6. The Meeting approve the increase in the number of directors of the Company by 1 person, from the Approved 92.2% 7.8% 0%
original 7 persons to 8 persons, and deem it appropriate to propose to appoint Mrs. Kulchalee
Nuntasukkasem ,as a new director of the Company, with the following voting results:
2022 Director 7. The Meeting approved the director’s remunerations for the year 2022, the details are as follows: Approved 100% 0% 0%
Compensation
2022 Other 9. The Meeting approved the issuance and offering of debentures with the offering value not exceeding of Approved 99.1% 0.9% 0%
Baht 20,000,000,000 (- twenty billion baht -) or equivalent. , with the following votes;
2022 Auditor 8. The Meeting approved to appoint the auditor from Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Chaiyos Audit Co., Ltd. as the Approved 100% 0% 0%
Ratification auditor
*For Management Proposals at AGM’s held more than three years ago, please refer to the Screener tool on ESG Manager.
THAILAND
The legislative framework for corporate governance in Thailand is based on the Thai Civil and Commercial Code, Public Limited Companies Act (Companies Act), the Securities
and Exchange Act, The Stock Exchange of Thailand Listing Rules (Listing Rules), The Principles of Good Corporate Governance for Listed Companies 2012 (Principles) and the
Corporate Governance Code 2017 (Code), which adopts an “apply or explain” approach.
Companies in Thailand adopt a unitary board structure. The Companies Act establishes that the board should consist of at least five directors and at least half shall be residents
of Thailand. The Code recommends the maximum number of directors be no more than 12.
Listed companies must have at least three independent directors or comprise one-third of the board. The Principles recommends the independent directors constitute 50% of
the board when the roles of the chief executive officer (CEO) and chair are combined, the CEO and chair are immediate family members, the chair is part of the management
team or the chair is not an independent director. The Principles recommends board memberships at listed companies be limited to five.
The Listing Rules stipulate the establishment of an audit committee comprised of at least three members in which all members must be independent. The Principles
recommends the establishment of a nomination and pay committees. The majority of the pay committee shall be comprised of independent directors, including its chair. The
nomination committee shall consist entirely of independent directors.
Under the Principles, directors must inform the board of their conflicts of interest regarding any agenda item before consideration and such conflicts should be recorded.
Interested members must abstain from participating in the discussion.
The Principles state that companies shall disclose the pay for directors and executives. Directors’ pay is disclosed individually while aggregate disclosure for top executives is
required. The pay of directors, including bonuses, is set by the company’s pay committee and requires shareholder approval at its annual general meeting.
Ownership structure in Thailand is mainly concentrated in founding families. The Companies Act states that a notice of shareholders’ meeting must be delivered to
shareholders no less than seven days before the date of the meeting and published in a newspaper no less than three days prior to the meeting. The Principles recommends
the proxy material to be released 28-days before the date of the meeting.
A mandatory takeover bid is triggered upon the acquisition of 25%, 50% or 75% of the total voting rights of a target company. There is no concept of minority squeeze-out
under Thai laws, as of the date of this publication.
The law requires all companies to prepare audited financial statements, although specific rules differ for each type of company. A listed company must disclose information
which may affect market price along with other compulsory disclosures such as quarterly financial statements, yearly financial statements, annual registration information and
annual reports. The board should be confident that all information presented in the financial reports is correct and has been audited by an independent external auditor.
DIRECTOR PROFILES
JORMSUP LOCHAYA
Age: 53 Financial: No
Gender: M Risk: No
Nationality: Not Disclosed Industry: Utilities - Independent Power and Renewable
Electricity Producers
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Executive, Board Member, CEO, Deputy Chairman Source Date: 03/25/2023
Jomsup Lojaya, Position: Chairman of the Board (Date of appointment 29 Sep 2004 By being a director who has authority to sign to bind the company As specified in the
certificate) Educational qualifications: Doctor of Laws (Juris Doctor) Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, California USA Bachelor's Degree in Economics, University of California, Los
Angeles, California, USA. Training courses: Passed the Director Accreditation Program (DAP) Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Family Relation with Executives: -
Experience: Period Position Company / Department Type of Business Public Company Limited 2006-present Chairman of the Board, Super Energy Corporation Plc. Holding
Company 2011-present Acting Managing Director, Super Energy Corporation Plc. Holding Company 2013-present Chairman of the Board, Open Technology IT Business Plc.
2004 - 2006 Director, Managing Director, Super Energy Corporation Plc. Holding Company Company Limited / other organization 2015-Present Director, WXA 4 Solar Power
Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, WXA5 Solar Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, WXA 6 Solar Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, WXA7 Solar Power
Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, Seoul Kid Solar Co., Ltd. Solar Power Plant 2015-Present Director, Northeast Future Energy Company Limited Solar Power Plant
2015-Present Director, SPPC Solar Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, N Serve Technology Co., Ltd. Investment / Development of Renewable Energy Power Plant
2015-Present Director, Srinaka Power Co., Ltd. Solar power plant 2015-Present Director, Amanuf Solar Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, Energy Serve Solar Power
Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, Power Technology International Co., Ltd. Solar power plant 2015-Present Director, Infinite Alternative Co., Ltd. Invest / develop alternative
energy power plants 2015-Present Director, Apollo Solar Co., Ltd. Solar power plant 2015-Present Director, STFE Solar Co., Ltd. Solar Power Plant 2015-Present Director, Tang
Xiang Green Power One Co., Ltd. Solar Power Plant 2015-Present Director, North Solar Power Co., Ltd. Solar power plant 2015-Present Director, Electrica Asia Co., Ltd. Solar
Power Plant 2015-Present Director, Media Mark Co., Ltd. Solar power plant 2015-Present Director, 17 Anyavee Holding Solar Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director
Millennium Act Co., Ltd. invest / develop alternative energy power plants. 2015-Present Director, Energy Surfland Investment / Land Development Co., Ltd. 2015-Present
Director, NPS Starland Investment / Land Development Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, Generalas Land Investment / Land Development Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, World
Exchange Asia Land Investment / Land Development Co., Ltd. 2015-Present Director, Power Technology International Land Investment / Land Development Co., Ltd.
2015-Present Director Super Sky Energy Co., Ltd. Investment / Development of Waste Power Plant 2015-Present Director Super Earth Energy 5 Co., Ltd. Investment /
Development of Waste Power Plant 2015-Present Director Super Earth Energy 4 Co., Ltd. Investment / Development of Waste Power Plant 2015-Present Director Super Earth
Energy 3 Co., Ltd. Investment / Development of Waste Power Plant 2015-Present Director Super Earth Energy 2 Co., Ltd. Investment / development of waste-to-energy power
plants 2015-Present Director Super Earth Energy 1 Co., Ltd. Investment / Development of Waste Power Plant 2015-Present Director Super Earth Energy Co., Ltd. Investment /
Development of Waste Power Plant 2014-Present Director, Green Bi-O Mahasarakham Company Limited Solar Power Plant 2014-Present Director, PT Dire (Thailand) Solar
Power Plant Co., Ltd. 2014-Present Director, Pro Solar One Co., Ltd., Solar Power Plant 2014-Present Director Lemon Gold Farm Co., Ltd. Investment / development of wind
power plants.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC Executive, Board Member, CEO, 18 Sep 29, 2004 No Yes
COMPANY LIMITED Deputy Chairman
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED CEO,Deputy Chair 18 2022 8,315 8,315 8,315 4,888,380,123
KAMTHORN UDOMRITTHIRUJ
Age: 91 Financial: No
Gender: M Risk: No
Nationality: Not Disclosed Industry:
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Board Member, Chairman Source Date: 03/25/2023
Mr. Kamthorn Udomritthiruj, Position: Vice Chairman of the Board (Date of appointment 29 Sep 2004) Chairman of the Audit Committee And independent director (Date of
appointment 26 July 2006) Educational qualifications: Bachelor of Political Science, University of California, Berkeley, USA Training courses: Passed the Director Accreditation
Program (DAP) Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Family Relation with Executives: - Experience: Period Position Company / Department Type of Business Public
Company Limited 2004-present Vice Chairman of the Board, Super Energy Corporation Plc. Holding Company 2006-present Chairman of the Audit Committee, Super Energy
Corporation Plc., Holding Company 2007-present Vice Chairman of the Board, Chairman of the Audit Committee Everland Plc. Real estate business Company Limited / other
organization 2005-Present Director, Superblock South Co., Ltd. Construction contractor and consulting 2006-2008 Chairman of the Commission for the Inspection of the State
Budget The National Legislative Assembly Draft and consider laws 2001-2002 Election Commission Board of Directors Elections, control and conduct of elections.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY Board Member, 17 Jul 26, 2006 Yes Yes
LIMITED Chairman
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
VOTING RESULTS
Company Year For % Against, Withheld and / or Abstained %
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Chair 17 2022 24,253 43,713 0
KULCHALEE NUNTASUKKASEM
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Executive, Board Member, CFO Source Date: 03/25/2023
Kulchalee Nuntasukkasem, Education : - Bachelor of Accounting, Chulalongkorn University - Master of Business Administration National Institute of Development
Administration; Director Training : - Directors Accreditation Program (DAP) Class 315/2022 Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD); - Director Refreshment Program (Lesson
Learnt from Financial Cases: How Board Should React) 2005 – present, Director ADVANCE PLANNER COMPANY LIMITED; 2005 – present, financial advisor EVERLAND PUBLIC
COMPANY LIMITED; 2005 – present, financial advisor SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED. 2000-2005, Assistant Director of Debt Restructuring 2 Thai
Asset Management Corporation (TAMC); 2001-2003, Deputy Director of Investment Banking The Book Club Finance And Securities CO., LTD.; 1998-2001, Assistant Director of
Property Management Organization for the Reform of Financial Institutions.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC Executive, Board 1 Apr 22, 2022 No Yes
COMPANY LIMITED Member, CFO
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED CFO 1 2022 3,032 3,032 3,032 0
PIYA SORNTRAKUL
Age: 67 Financial: No
Gender: M Risk: No
Nationality: Not Disclosed Industry:
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Board Member Source Date: 03/25/2023
Piya Sorntrakul, Director / Chairman of the Risk Management Committee ; Date of serving as director 9 May 2018 ; Education ; Bachelor of Public Administration (Royal
Society), Year 1978 (Nor Sor. 31) Master of Public Administration (Public Administration) NID ; Shareholding Proportion (%) without ; Family Relation with Executives without
Work experience: Public Company Limited ; 2018-Present Director Super Energy Corporation Plc. Work Experience: Company Limited / Other Organization ; 2015-2016,
Assistant Commissioner, National Police ; 2013-2015 Commander, Maintenance Office ; 2007-2013 Police Deputy Commander Phuthon 1 ; 2003-2007 Commander of Police,
Phuthon 1 ; 2001-2003, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Phuthon 1 ; 1996-2001 Deputy Commander of the Technical Division, Region 1 ; 1995-1996 Commander, Public Works
Division 1 Supervisor 2, Command Division Phuthon Police 5 ; 1991-2001 Inspector, Division 3, Investigation Division Phuthon Police Headquarters 1 ; 1991-1995 Deputy
Director of Education Administration Institute of Police Service Development ; 1989-1991, Protective Governing Body. Metropolitan Police Station Chakrawat ; 1986-1989,
Inspector of the Armed Forces, Director of the Metropolitan Police Division Thonburi ; 1986-1989, Inspector of the Armed Forces, Director of the Metropolitan Police Division
Thonburi.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY Board 5 May 09, 2018 Yes Yes
LIMITED Member
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Non-Executive 5 2022 24,253 42,962 0
SUNSIRI CHAIJAREONPAT
Age: 53 Financial: No
Gender: F Risk: No
Nationality: Not Disclosed Industry: Consumer Services - Diversified Consumer
Services
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Board Member Source Date: 03/25/2023
Sansiri Chaicharoenpat, Director, Educational background ; Master of Public Health Epidemiology, University of California, Los Angeles, USA Training course ; Received the
Director Accreditation Program (DAP) ; Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Shareholding Proportion (%) ; without Family Relation with Executives ;without Work
Experience: Public Company Limited ; 2018-Present Director Super Energy Corporation Plc. ; 2011-present Director and Audit Committee Everland Plc. ; 2008-2011 Director and
Vice Chairman of the Board Check Open Technology Plc. Work Experience: Company Limited / Other Organization ; 2005-present Vice President Xinxere Edutainment Company
Limited ; 2003 - 2006 Business Development Coordinator California Finess Centers ; 2000-2003 Director and Project Manager Advance Web Studio ; 2000 Research Executive
Research International.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY Board 5 May 09, 2018 Yes Yes
LIMITED Member
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Non-Executive 5 2022 20,788 33,261 0
TRITHIP SIVAKRISKUL
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SISB PCL - Board Member Source Date: 03/13/2023
TRITHIP SIVAKRISKUL Independent Director / Audit committee Ms. Trithip Sivakriskul is the director serving boards of the Government Pharmaceutical Organization, Express
Authority of Thailand, State Railway Thailand and CFO of Inception Technology Limited. She was formerly worked at Minor International Plc as CFO. She has experience in
investment banking business including advisory services such as corporate restructuring, corporate reorganization, fundraising, and merger and acquisitions. She holds a
Master in Business from SASIN of Chulalongkorn University.
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Board Member Source Date: 03/25/2023
Trithip Sivakritkul, Director, Date of appointment 25 April 2018 Educational background Master of Business Administration Graduate Institute of Business Administration Sasin,
Chulalongkorn University Kellogg Graduate Student Exchange Program Management, Northwestern University, USA Bachelor Degree in Banking Finance, Chulalongkorn
university Training course Apply for Director Accreditation Program (DAP) Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Value of shareholding in the company (%) None Family
Relation with Executives None Work Experience: Public Company Limited 2018-present Director and Vice Chairman Check Super Energy Corporation Plc. Independent Director
and Audit Committee Triton Holding PCL. Singapore International School o King Telecom Plc. Work Experience: Company Limited / Other Organization 2016 - 2017 Chief
Financial Officer Ek-Chai Distribution System Co., Ltd. 2011-2016 Chief Financial Officer Minor International Plc. 2011 - 2011 Executive Vice President, Finance Ratchaburi
Electricity Generating Holding PCL. 2007 - 2011 Executive Vice President, Planning Division And business development IRPC Plc. 2006-2007 Director Open Technology Plc.
Executive Vice President, Accounting and finance IRPC Plc. 2008 - 2008 Cost Management Consultant The Stock Exchange of Thailand 2005-2007 Advisor to the Managing
Director Muang Thai Life Assurance Co., Ltd. 2003-2006 The Faculty of Finance Working Group Plan administrator Industrial Plc. Thai Petrochemicals 2003-2003 Advisor
Institutional System Development Fund finance 2001-2003 Director of Asset Management 2 Thai Asset Management Corporation 1997-2001 Partner Deloitte Touche Tomasu
Corporate Structure Co., Ltd. Jering / accounting and auditing 1994-1997 Director, Investment Banking Department Peregrine Nithi Finance & Securities Co., Ltd.
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY Board 5 Apr 25, 2018 Yes Yes
LIMITED Member
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
VOTING RESULTS
Company Year For % Against, Withheld and / or Abstained %
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Non-Executive 5 2022 20,788 31,413 0
VIRASAK SUTANTHAVIBUL
Age: 65 Financial: No
Gender: M Risk: No
Nationality: Not Disclosed Industry: Banks - Banks
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
Krung Thai Bank Public Company Limited - Board Member Source Date: 03/07/2023
Mr. Virasak Sutanthavibul Class 21/2003, Director Accreditation Program (DAP), Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Class 18/2005, The Joint State - Private Sectors, The
National Defence College Class 10/2010, Top Management Program, Capital Market Academy, The Stock Exchange of Thailand Class 1/2012, Top Executive Program in Energy
Literacy, Thailand Energy Academy Class 17/2012-2013, Top Executive Program in Justice Administration, Judicial Training Institute Class 2/2015, Completion and Graduation
Pin , Institute of Business and Industrial Development (IBID) Class 2/2018, Business Revolution and Innovation Network (BRAIN), The Federation of Thai Industries Advanced
Management Program, Harvard University, U.S.A. Financial Institution for Private Enterprise Development, Harvard University, U.S.A. Other Positions Independent Director,
Member of the Audit Committee and Member of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, Nirvana Daii Pcl. Independent Director, Chairman of the Audit Committee and
Member of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, Thai Plaspac Pcl. Independent Director and Member of the Audit Committee, T.Krungthai Industries Director, TFMJV
Co.,Ltd.
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Board Member Source Date: 03/25/2023
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY Board Apr 25, 2023 Yes Yes
LIMITED Member
Krung Thai Bank Public Company Limited Board Apr 07, 2023 Yes Yes
Member
BOARD COMMITTEES
Company Committee Type Position
VOTING RESULTS
Company Year For % Against, Withheld and / or Abstained %
WARINTHIP CHAISANGHA
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED - Executive, Board Member Source Date: 03/25/2023
Warinthip Chaisangha, Director, Educational background ; Bachelor of Business Administration (Accounting), Ramkhamhaeng University Training course ; Certificate of Director
Accreditation Program (DAP) ; Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) Shareholding Proportion (%) ; without Family Relation with Executives ; without Work Experience:
Public Company Limited ; 2018-Present Director Super Earth Energy 8 Co., Ltd. ; 2013-Present Director Super Energy Corporation Plc. ; 2007-Present Director, Director of
Accounting Department finance Open Technology Plc. Work Experience: Company Limited / Other Organization ; 2015-Present Director o Super Sky Energy Co., Ltd. o North
Solar Power Co., Ltd. o Super Earth Energy Co., Ltd. ; 2014-Present Director o Lemon Gold Farm Co., Ltd. o Green Bi-O Mahasarakham Co., Ltd. o PT DRY (Thailand) Co., Ltd. ;
2013-Present Director Super Energy Group Co., Ltd. ; 2006 Assistant Manager, Finance ABN Amro NL Bank ; 2004-2006 Assistant Managing Director Bangkok Micro Bus Co., Ltd.
; 2001-2004 Accounting and Finance Manager Mechai Thai Legal Counseling Office Co., Ltd. Land ; 1994-2001 Assistant Auditor KPMG Audit (Thailand) Co., Ltd
CORPORATE BOARDS
Company Role Tenure Appointed Resigned Independent of Independent of Other Attendance
Management Interests
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC Executive, Board 10 May 14, 2013 No Yes
COMPANY LIMITED Member
VOTING RESULTS
Company Year For % Against, Withheld and / or Abstained %
SUPER ENERGY CORPORATION PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED Executive 10 2022 4,331 4,331 4,331 0
GLOSSARY
ESG PILLARS
• the Environment Score represents the weighted average of all Key Issues that fall under the Environment Pillar
• the Social Score represents the weighted average of all Key Issues that fall under the Social Pillar
• the Governance Score represents the sum of score deductions derived from Key Metrics included in Corporate Governance (including Board,
Pay, Ownership & Control, and Accounting) and Corporate Behavior (including Business Ethics and Tax Transparency)
• the Environment Weight represents the sum of the weights of all Key Issues that fall under the Environment Pillar
• the Social Weight represents the sum of the weights of all Key Issues that fall under the Social Pillar
• the Governance Weight represents the sum of the weights of Corporate Governance and Corporate Behavior, with a minimum weight set at
33% for all rated issuers
KEY ISSUES
For each industry and Company-Specific Key Issue that contributes to the final rating:
• Weight contribution to the final rating
• Exposure Score (available for companies published since June 2011; excluding Raw Material Sourcing – Environmental)
• Management Score (available for companies published since June 2011; excluding Raw Material Sourcing – Environmental)
• Overall Key Issue Score
ABOUT MSCI
MSCI is a leading provider of critical decision support tools and services for the global investment community. With over 50 years of expertise in research, data and technology, we power better
investment decisions by enabling clients to understand and analyze key drivers of risk and return and confidently build more effective portfolios. We create industry-leading research-enhanced
solutions that clients use to gain insight into and improve transparency across the investment process.